Chemicalanalysis
Chemicalanalysis
1
(a) Explain why chlorine is added to drinking water.
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
(1)
(b) Describe what you would see when bromine water is added to an unsaturated organic
compound.
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
(1)
(c) Bromine can be extracted from seawater. The dissolved bromide ions are reacted with
chlorine. Bromine and chloride ions are formed.
(i) Complete and balance the equation below, which represents the reaction between
chlorine and bromide ions.
(ii) Describe what you see when chlorine is added to a solution containing bromide ions.
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
(1)
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
(1)
Page 2 of 91
(ii) explain why bromine is less reactive than chlorine.
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
(3)
(e) What is the result of adding acidified silver nitrate solution to a solution containing:
...................................................................................................................
(1)
...................................................................................................................
(1)
(Total 10 marks)
Page 3 of 91
(a) A student tested some Low Sodium Salt to show that it contains carbonate ions and
chloride ions.
(i) Describe and give the result of a test for carbonate ions.
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
(2)
(ii) A student identified chloride ions using acidified silver nitrate solution.
State what you would see when acidified silver nitrate solution is added to a solution
of Low Sodium Salt.
...................................................................................................................
(1)
(iii) Flame tests can be used to identify potassium ions and sodium ions.
Suggest why it is difficult to identify both of these ions in Low Sodium Salt using a
flame test.
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
(1)
(b) Read the following information and then answer the questions.
Page 4 of 91
(i) Suggest why Option 1 was rejected.
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
(1)
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
(3)
(Total 8 marks)
Draw a straight line from each sulfate in List A to its correct test result in List B.
List A List B
Name of sulfate Result of adding
in solution sodium hydroxide solution
(2)
(b) Suggest why clean test tubes were used for each test.
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
(1)
Page 5 of 91
(c) Draw a ring around the correct colour to complete this sentence.
blue
green precipitate.
white
(1)
(Total 4 marks)
The result of a process used to detect and identify the colours in two foods, A and B, is
4 shown.
(i) Describe the differences between the colours used in food A and food B.
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
(2)
(ii) Tick ( ) the name of the process used to detect and identify colours in food.
Process ( )
chromatography
extraction
hardening
(1)
(Total 3 marks)
Page 6 of 91
This question is about chemical tests.
5
(a) Solutions of copper(II) ions and iron(III) ions produce coloured precipitates with sodium
hydroxide solution.
Draw one line from each metal ion to the colour of the precipitate it produces.
(2)
(b) Sodium hydroxide solution was added to a solution containing ions of a metal.
A white precipitate was produced. The white precipitate dissolved in excess sodium
hydroxide solution.
Use the correct answer from the box to complete the sentence.
Page 7 of 91
(c) Low sodium salt contains sodium chloride and potassium chloride.
...............................................................................................................
(1)
...............................................................................................................
(1)
(iii) Why is it not possible to tell from the flame test that both ions are present in low
sodium salt?
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(1)
(Total 6 marks)
Page 8 of 91
Chemical tests can be used to detect and identify elements and compounds.
6
A jar of a chemical from 1870 is shown.
Copperas was a name used for iron(II) sulfate, FeSO4. It does not contain any copper!
barium chloride.
sodium hydroxide.
green
white
liquid.
solid
(3)
Page 9 of 91
(ii) The student tested for sulfate ions, SO42–
barium chloride
The student added dilute hydrochloric acid and silver nitrate solution.
sodium hydroxide
green
white
Sulfuric acid (H2SO4) should not be used instead of hydrochloric acid (HCl) when
testing for sulfate ions. This is because sulfuric acid contains nitrate ions, NO3–
(3)
(b) A flame test can be used to identify the metal ions in a compound.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(1)
(c) The elements in a compound can also be detected and identified using instrumental
methods of analysis.
State one advantage of using instrumental methods compared with chemical tests.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(1)
(Total 8 marks)
Page 10 of 91
7
Alums are salts. They have been used since ancient times in dyeing and medicine and still
have many uses today.
(a) The student did a flame test on these alums. A sample of each alum was held on a wire in
a colourless flame.
In (a)(i) and (a)(ii) use the correct word from the box to complete each sentence.
(iii) Draw a ring around the correct answer to complete the sentence.
density.
The wire used in a flame test should have a high electrical conductivity.
melting point.
(1)
Page 11 of 91
(b) Draw a ring around the correct word to complete the sentences.
(i) The student tested a solution of each salt for sulfate ions (SO42– ).
barium chloride
The student added dilute hydrochloric acid and nitric acid solution and
silver nitrate
gas
solid
(2)
(ii) The student tested a solution of each salt for aluminium ions (Al3+ ).
green
white
was formed. When excess sodium hydroxide solution was added, the
boiled.
precipitate condensed.
dissolved.
(2)
(Total 7 marks)
Page 12 of 91
A student investigated an egg shell.
8
Test Observation
Sodium hydroxide solution was A white precipitate formed that did not
3 added to the colourless solution dissolve in excess sodium hydroxide
from test 1. solution.
(i) The student concluded that the egg shell contains carbonate ions.
Describe how the student could identify the gas produced in test 1.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
Page 13 of 91
(2)
(ii) The student concluded that the egg shell contains aluminium ions.
Is the student’s conclusion correct? Use the student’s results to justify your answer.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(2)
(iii) The student concluded that the egg shell contains chloride ions.
Is the student’s conclusion correct? Use the student’s results to justify your answer.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(2)
(b) Some scientists wanted to investigate the amount of lead found in egg shells.
They used a modern instrumental method which was more sensitive than older methods.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(1)
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(1)
(Total 8 marks)
Page 14 of 91
Read the article.
9
W, X, Y and Z are food colourings that may cause hyperactive behaviour in young children.
A scientist used chromatography to see if these food colourings were used in two sweets, S and
P.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(1)
Page 15 of 91
(b) In chromatography, the Rf value =
Use the scale on the chromatogram to help you to answer this question.
(1)
(c) From the chromatogram, what conclusions can the scientist make about the colourings in
sweets S and P?
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(3)
(Total 5 marks)
Page 16 of 91
Icing on cakes is tested to check that safe colours were used when they were made.
10
Paper chromatography is one method of testing which colours are in cake icing.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(1)
Page 17 of 91
(ii) The start line should be drawn in pencil not in ink.
Suggest why.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(1)
(b) The diagram shows the results of the paper chromatography experiment.
(i) How many different food colours were used in the colouring from the cake icing?
............................................
(1)
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(1)
(i) Give two advantages of gas chromatography compared with paper chromatography.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(2)
Page 18 of 91
(ii) What does gas chromatography do to the mixture of solvents?
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(1)
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(1)
(Total 8 marks)
Four bottles of chemicals made in the 1880s were found recently in a cupboard during a
11 Health and Safety inspection at Lovell Laboratories.
Page 19 of 91
(a) You are provided with the following reagents:
• aluminium powder
• limewater
(i) Describe tests that you could use to show that these chemicals are correctly named.
In each case give the reagent(s) you would use and state the result.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(4)
Page 20 of 91
(ii) Suggest why a flame test would not distinguish between these four chemicals.
...............................................................................................................
(1)
(b) Instrumental methods of analysis linked to computers can be used to identify chemicals.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(2)
(Total 7 marks)
Page 21 of 91
An article began:
12
(a) A student tested a food to find out if it contained quinoline yellow (E104).
The student’s results are shown below.
(i) Draw a ring around the correct answer to complete the sentence.
chromatography.
electrolysis.
(1)
(ii) Using the student’s results, how many different colours are in the food? ......
(1)
(iii) Using the student’s results, how can you tell that the food does not contain quinoline
yellow (E104)?
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(1)
Page 22 of 91
(b) Quinoline yellow (E104) is used in foods such as sweets, drinks and ice cream.
(i) Give one reason why quinoline yellow (E104) is added to foods.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(1)
(ii) Suggest what should be done to decide if quinoline yellow (E104) should be banned.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(1)
(Total 5 marks)
(a) State two reasons that a manufacturer might give to justify the use of these additives.
1 ....................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
2 .....................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
(2)
Page 23 of 91
(b) Some scientists asked 4000 twelve-year-old children to help them investigate if there is a
link between these three coloured additives and hyperactivity.
How would the scientists use these 4000 children to investigate if there is a link between
these three coloured additives and hyperactivity in children?
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(4)
(c) A manufacturer used an independent scientist to show that their orange drink did not
contain these three coloured additives.
(i) Suggest why the manufacturer would use a scientist who was independent instead of
using their own scientist.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(1)
Page 24 of 91
(ii) The scientist had samples of E102, E104 and E110 and the orange drink. The
scientist used paper chromatography for the test.
Describe how the scientist could use the results to show if the orange drink contained
any of these three coloured additives.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(2)
(Total 9 marks)
Use the correct word from the box to complete the sentence.
Page 25 of 91
(b) Chromatography was used to compare three of the colours used to coat the chocolate
sweets.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(3)
(Total 4 marks)
Page 26 of 91
The colours of fireworks are produced by chemicals.
15
© Igor Sokalski/iStock/Thinkstock
Colour produced in
Chemical
firework
(2)
(b) Describe a test to show that barium chloride solution contains chloride ions.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(2)
Page 27 of 91
(c) A student did two tests on a solution of compound X.
Test 1
Sodium hydroxide solution was added.
A blue precipitate was formed.
Test 2
Dilute hydrochloric acid was added.
Barium chloride solution was then added.
A white precipitate was formed.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(3)
(Total 7 marks)
Cola
Ingredients:
Carbonated water
Sugar
Colouring
Phosphoric acid
Flavouring
Caffeine
Name the ingredient on the label that lowers the pH of Cola to 2.9.
...............................................................................................................
(1)
Page 28 of 91
(ii) Which ion causes the pH to be 2.9?
...............................................................................................................
(1)
(b) A student investigated the food colouring in Cola and in a fruit drink using paper
chromatography.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(2)
(ii) Suggest three conclusions you can make from the student’s results.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(3)
Page 29 of 91
(c) Caffeine can be separated from the other compounds in the drink by gas chromatography.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(1)
(i) Only one of the questions in the table can be answered by science alone.
Question Tick ( )
(1)
(ii) Give two reasons why the other questions cannot be answered by science alone.
Reason 1 ..............................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
Reason 2 ..............................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(2)
(Total 11 marks)
Page 30 of 91
(a) The colours of fireworks are produced by chemicals.
17
© Igor Sokalski/iStock/Thinkstock
Three of these chemicals are lithium sulfate, potassium chloride and sodium nitrate.
(i) A student wants to carry out flame tests on these three chemicals.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(2)
(ii) Draw one line from each chemical to the correct flame colour.
(2)
Page 31 of 91
(iii) Dilute nitric acid and silver nitrate solution are added to solutions of the three
chemicals.
...............................................................................................................
(1)
...............................................................................................................
(1)
(ii) The student adds dilute hydrochloric acid to a solution of chemical X and then adds
barium chloride solution.
(1)
(Total 7 marks)
Page 32 of 91
The diagram shows three stages in the treatment of reservoir water.
18
(a) (i) What is separated from the reservoir water during filtration?
Bacteria
Dissolved nitrates
Solids
(1)
Calcium
Chlorine
Magnesium
(1)
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(1)
Page 33 of 91
(b) The diagram shows a water filter used in the home.
Water in
The student could show that the filtered water contains dissolved salts without using a
chemical test.
Describe how.
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
(2)
Page 34 of 91
(c) Seawater is forced through a membrane to make drinking water.
Seawater
Drinking water
Suggest why water molecules can pass through the membrane, but sodium ions and
chloride ions cannot.
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
(1)
(Total 6 marks)
Page 35 of 91
Chromatography can be used to separate components of a mixture.
19
(a) A student used paper chromatography to analyse a black food colouring.
The student placed spots of known food colours, A, B, C, D and E, and the black food
colouring on a sheet of chromatography paper.
Diagram 1
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
(4)
Page 36 of 91
(b) A different student set up the apparatus without making any errors.
Diagram 2
(i) What do the results tell you about the composition of the black food colouring?
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(2)
Table 1
Distance in mm
(2)
(iii) Use your answers in part (b) (ii) to calculate the Rf value for food colour C.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
Rf value = ........................................
(1)
Page 37 of 91
(c) Table 2 gives the results of chromatography experiments that were carried out on some
known food colours, using the same solvent as the students.
Table 2
Ponceau 4R 62 59 0.95
Carmoisine 74 45 0.61
Erythrosine 58 17 0.29
Which of the food colours in Table 2 could be food colour C from the chromatogram?
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
(2)
(d) Two types of chromatography are gas chromatography and paper chromatography.
.........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
(1)
(Total 12 marks)
Page 38 of 91
In this question you will be assessed on using good English, organising information
20 clearly and using specialist terms where appropriate.
A group of students had four different colourless solutions in beakers 1, 2, 3 and 4, shown in the
figure below.
• sodium chloride
• sodium iodide
• sodium carbonate
• potassium carbonate
The teacher asked the class to plan a method that could be used to identify each solution.
Page 39 of 91
The teacher suggested using a flame test to identify the positive ions.
Outline a method the students could use to identify the four solutions.
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................
(Total 6 marks)
Page 40 of 91
This question is about chemical analysis.
21
(a) A student has solutions of three compounds, X, Y and Z.
The student uses tests to identify the ions in the three compounds.
Test
Add
Add sodium Add nitric acid
hydrochloric
Compound Flame test hydroxide and silver nitrate
acid and barium
solution solution
chloride solution
X ........................................................................................................................
Y ........................................................................................................................
Z ........................................................................................................................
(3)
Page 41 of 91
(b) A chemist needs to find the concentration of a solution of barium hydroxide.
Barium hydroxide solution is an alkali.
The chemist could find the concentration of the barium hydroxide solution using two
different methods.
Method 1
• An excess of sodium sulfate solution is added to 25 cm 3 of the barium hydroxide
solution. A precipitate of barium sulfate is formed.
• The concentration of the barium hydroxide solution is calculated from the mass of
barium sulfate produced.
Method 2
• 25 cm 3 of the barium hydroxide solution is titrated with hydrochloric acid of known
concentration.
• The concentration of the barium hydroxide solution is calculated from the result of the
titration.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(5)
(Total 8 marks)
Page 42 of 91
This question is about reactions of ethanoic acid and the analysis of salts.
22
(a) Figure 1 shows the apparatus used to investigate the reaction of ethanoic acid with
calcium carbonate.
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
(4)
(1)
Page 43 of 91
(iii) Ethanoic acid is a carboxylic acid.
Complete the sentence.
........................
called ............................ .
(2)
(b) Figure 2 shows four test tubes containing three different salt solutions and water.
Calcium
Potassium Ammonium
nitrate Water
chloride solution sulfate solution
solution
(2)
Page 44 of 91
(c) Flame tests can be used to identify metal ions.
(ii) Give one reason why a flame test would not show the presence of both potassium
ions and calcium ions in a mixture.
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
(1)
(Total 12 marks)
Air
Carbon dioxide
Graphite
Sodium Chloride
Steel
(2)
Page 45 of 91
(b) Draw one line from each context to the correct meaning.
Context Meaning
Pure substance
A single element or a single compound
in chemistry
(2)
(1)
Page 46 of 91
(d) A student tested a metal chloride solution with sodium hydroxide solution.
Calcium
Copper(II)
Iron(II)
Iron(III)
(1)
(Total 6 marks)
Page 47 of 91
A student investigated food dyes using paper chromatography.
24
This is the method used.
Figure 1
(a) Write down two mistakes the student made in setting up the experiment and explain what
problems one of the mistakes would cause.
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
(2)
Page 48 of 91
(b) Another student set up the apparatus correctly.
Figure 2 shows the student’s results. The result for dye D is not shown.
Figure 2
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
Rf value = ...........................................
(3)
(c) Dye D has an Rf value of 0.80. Calculate the distance that dye D moved on the
chromatography paper.
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
Page 49 of 91
(d) Explain how the different dyes in X are separated by paper chromatography.
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
(4)
(e) Flame emission spectroscopy can be used to analyse metal ions in solution.
Figure 3 gives the flame emission spectra of five metal ions, and of a mixture of two metal
ions.
Figure 3
Use the spectra to identify the two metal ions in the mixture.
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
(2)
Page 50 of 91
(f) Explain why a flame test could not be used to identify the two metal ions in the mixture.
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
(2)
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
(4)
(Total 18 marks)
Page 51 of 91
Water from a lake in the UK is used to produce drinking water.
25
(a) What are the two main steps used to treat water from lakes?
Step 1 ................................................................................................................
Reason .............................................................................................................
Step 2 ...............................................................................................................
Reason .............................................................................................................
(2)
(b) Explain why it is more difficult to produce drinking water from waste water than from water
in lakes.
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
(3)
Complete the figure below to show how you can distil salt solution to produce and collect
pure water.
(3)
Page 52 of 91
(d) How could the water be tested to show it is pure?
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
(2)
.............................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................
(1)
(Total 11 marks)
Page 53 of 91
A student investigated a food colouring using paper chromatography.
26
This is the method used.
Figure 1
(2)
Page 54 of 91
(b) Another student set the experiment up correctly.
Figure 2
1 3 4 6
(1)
(1)
Page 55 of 91
(d) Use Figure 2 to complete the table below.
Distance in mm
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
Rf value = ................................................................
(5)
(Total 9 marks)
Page 56 of 91
Mark schemes
(a) kills bacteria / sterilises (water)
1
allow kills microorganisms / microbes / germs
allow ‘makes (water) safe (to drink)’ or disinfectant
ignore cleans water or removes impurities / bacteria
1
(b) goes colourless / decolourised (from red / red-brown / brown / yellow / orange)
allow colour disappears
ignore ‘goes clear’ or discoloured
do not accept incorrect initial colour
do not accept precipitate
1
Page 57 of 91
(e) (i) white precipitate or white solid
ignore names of chemicals
1
Page 58 of 91
(ii)
mark positively ie no list principle
advantages
disadvantages
• undemocratic
Page 59 of 91
(b) eg some idea of contamination
allow so you can see the colour change clearly / easily
or
(c) white
1
[4]
(ii) chromatography
1
[3]
(b) aluminium
allow correct answer shown in box if answer line blank
1
Page 60 of 91
(c) (i) yellow
allow orange
1
(ii) lilac
allow purple
1
6
(a) (i) sodium hydroxide
1
green
1
solid
1
white
1
Page 61 of 91
(c) any one from:
ignore reference to cost / safer
• accurate
• precise
• sensitive
• reliable
• rapid
7
(a) (i) yellow
1
(ii) lilac
1
solid
1
(ii) white
1
dissolved
1
[7]
Page 62 of 91
(ii) ignore yes or no
or
or
(b) X
1
Page 63 of 91
(c) any three from:
five / 5 colourings
or
(b) (i) 4
1
Page 64 of 91
(ii) no mark for ‘no / don’t know’ ,
ignore numbers
• rapid / quick
• accurate
(ii) separates
1
Page 65 of 91
Na2SO4: BaCl2 → white ppt (1)
barium sulfate (1)
1
each correct test and one result = 1 mark
one other result for any test = 1 mark this mark can only be
awarded once
(ii) all would give a yellow / yellow-orange (flame) / same coloured (flame) / same
results
allow orange (flame) 1
or
• small amounts/sensitive
allow can be left to run/continuous analysis
• accurate
• ease of automation
accept operators do not need chemical skills
• reliable / efficient
2
[7]
(ii) 3 / three
1
(iii) the colour / E104 is not on the same level as any of the colours in the food
accept E104 does not match
1
Page 66 of 91
(ii) further / or different tests (for harmful effects) or obtain more evidence
(that it is harmful)
allow do a survey / study
1
[5]
• maintain the low cost of the drink or natural colours would make the drink cost
more
allow cheaper if qualified
2
(b) have a control group / placebo or test children before any drink given
1
(ii) compare the colours / spots from the orange drink with those of the (three)
additives
accept diagram of chromatogram(s) with spots for E102, 104, 110
and sample from the orange drink
1
(a) additive
14 1
Page 67 of 91
(b) colour 3 is a mixture of colours 1 and 2
(a) lithium
15
allow Li+ / Li
1
yellow
allow orange
1
white precipitate
1
Page 68 of 91
(a) (i) (phosphoric) acid
16
allow phosphoric
1
or
(c) different substances travel at different speeds or have different retention times
accept different attraction to solid
ignore properties of compounds
1
Page 69 of 91
(a) (i) method of introducing sample into flame
17
e.g. wire / splint / spray
1
(ii)
1
1
(ii) sulfate
1
[7]
(ii) Chlorine
1
(b) put a sample of the filtered water in an evaporating basin or leave to evaporate
accept any description of evaporation (using a Bunsen or leaving on
the windowsill)
1
(c) sodium and / or chloride ions are bigger than water (molecules) or ions are charged
or molecules are not charged
do not accept sodium chloride molecules as ions is given in the
question
1
[6]
Page 70 of 91
so it will run / dissolve in the solvent / split up
allow mixes with the spots
1
so they will mix with solvent or wash off paper or colour the solvent or dissolve in the
solvent
1
(ii) 45 or 46
allow any value from 45 to 46
1
18
allow any value from 16 to 20
award 1 mark if numbers correct but in cm
1
(iii) 0.40
allow ecf from (b)(ii)
ignore units
1
• more accurate
• more sensitive
• uses small quantities of samples
• quicker / faster / more rapid
• can link to mass spectrometer (MS)
1
[12]
Page 71 of 91
Marks awarded for this answer will be determined by the Quality of Communication (QC)
20 as well as the standard of the scientific response. Examiners should also apply a ‘best-fit’
approach to the marking.
0 marks
No relevant content
Level 1 (1 – 2 marks)
Any description of a method used and / or a result given
Level 2 (3 – 4 marks)
Description of workable methods used, with results to identify positive or negative ions
Level 3 (5 – 6 marks)
Description of methods used to identify both positive and negative ions, with relevant
results
Result: the sodium compounds result in a yellow / orange / gold flame or the potassium
compound results in a lilac / purple / mauve flame
student could state that potassium carbonate gives a different
colour to the three sodium compounds as long as it is clear that the
flame test colour comes from Na+ or K+
Result: sodium carbonate and potassium carbonate will effervesce or sodium chloride and
sodium iodide will not effervesce
Result: sodium chloride and sodium iodide produce a precipitate or sodium chloride
produces a white precipitate and sodium iodide produces a yellow precipitate
accept sodium carbonate and potassium carbonate do not produce
a precipitate
[6]
(a) X:
21 Fe2+ / iron(II), SO42- / sulfate
allow iron(II) sulfate
or FeSO4
1
Page 72 of 91
Y:
Na+ / sodium, I- / iodide
allow sodium iodide
or NaI
1
Z:
Fe3+ / iron(III), Br- / bromide
allow iron(III) bromide
or FeBr3
correct identification of any two ions = one mark
correct identification of any four ions = two marks
1
method 1
• weighing is accurate
• not all barium sulfate may be precipitated
• precipitate may be lost
• precipitate may not be dry
• takes longer
• requires energy
allow not all the barium hydroxide has reacted
method 2
• accurate
• works for low concentrations
allow reliable / precise
5
[8]
Page 73 of 91
(ii)
allow -OH
do not allow lower case ‘h’
1
(iii) acid
must be in this order
ignore any name of an acid
1
ester(s)
1
no change no change
red
1
must be in this order
(a) Air
23 2
Steel
1
Page 74 of 91
(b)
Allow 1 mark for the correct meanings linked to context but incorrect way around
1
(d) Iron(III)
1
[6]
water level
food colours would dissolve into water
or
start line
the ink would ‘run’ on the paper
1
Page 75 of 91
0.34
allow 0.33 or 0.35
allow ecf from incorrect measurement to final answer for 2 marks if
given to 2 significant figures
accept 0.34 without working shown for 3 marks
1
(c) 6.6 cm
allow values between 6.48 and 6.64 cm
1
sodium ions
allow Na+
1
Page 76 of 91
(Student B was incorrect)
because adding acid to carbonate produces carbon dioxide
1
(a) filtration
25 or
by passing through filter beds to remove solids
1
Page 77 of 91
The water level was above the spots
1
(b) 3
1
(c) A
1
0.37254 …
allow values in range 0.35 − 0.39
1
0.37
1
accept 0.37 with no working shown for 5 marks
[9]
Page 78 of 91
Examiner reports
Parts (a) and (d) were answered quite well, the other parts less so.
1
(a) Most candidates knew why chlorine is added to drinking water. However, candidates need
to say that chlorine kills bacteria rather than just removes bacteria. Weaker candidates
simply stated it was to clean the water or thought it softened the water.
(b) Less than half of the candidates knew that bromine water was decolourised. It does not go
clear and neither does it become discoloured.
(c) (i) Only the best candidates were able to complete and balance the equation. Most
candidates had no idea what the products of the reaction were, and charges were
frequently omitted/added even when the products’ formulae were correct.
(ii) The large majority of the candidates were unable to describe the effect of chlorine on
bromide ions. Many candidates thought that a precipitate formed or that there was an
effervescence.
(d) (i) The majority of candidates knew that these elements have the same number of outer
electrons (7) or need one electron to gain a complete outer shell of electrons.
Chlorine and bromine do not have a similar number of outer electrons.
(ii) An excellent discriminator as usual, and some excellent answers were seen. In a
question such as this, a comparison is required so it is essential to include
comparative terms such as more/most, closer/closest, stronger/strongest or
easier/easiest. Simply saying easy/easily, close or strong/strongly is insufficient.
Candidates needed to mention outer electron or outer energy level or outer shell
somewhere in their answer to receive full credit. Some candidates suggested that a
bromine atom loses an electron less easily. Others wrote about bromine having more
outer shells than chlorine. Some candidates thought that intermolecular, magnetic or
gravitational forces hold the electrons to the nucleus, while others referred to the
strength of the bond between electron and nucleus. The third marking point proved
elusive for many who often concluded their answer with the words therefore bromine
is less reactive rather than therefore bromine gains an electron less easily.
(i) Less than half the candidates knew that a white precipitate/solid was formed when
silver nitrate solution was added to a solution containing chloride ions. Simply saying
that the solution goes white or milky is insufficient.
(ii) Even fewer candidates knew that a pale yellow (or cream) precipitate was formed
with bromide ions. Candidates should be aware that a yellow precipitate is formed
when silver nitrate solution is added to a solution containing iodide ions.
Page 79 of 91
Foundation Tier
2
Part (a) was quite poorly attempted In Part (a)(i) a large number of candidates did not
know the test for carbonates. Many candidates wrote ‘add lime water’ and ‘it will go cloudy’.
Some candidates even wrote ‘flame test’. They seemed to know that carbon dioxide was
somehow involved/evolved and simply gave the test for carbon dioxide.
A large number of candidates in Part (a)(ii) wrote ‘bubbles’ or ‘gas’ while some suggested
‘there will be a colour change’. Very few candidates knew that there would be a precipitate or a
solid formed. Some lost marks by giving an incorrectly coloured precipitate.
Many candidates in Part (a)(iii) lost the mark here. They could not apply their knowledge of
separate flame colours to a mixture. Many candidates wrote ‘they have similar coloured flames’
or ‘they produce same coloured flames’ while others suggested that ‘it is low in sodium’. Some
stated wrong colours for sodium and potassium.
Part (b) was quite well attempted. The majority of the candidates were able to pick out the
relevant points from the passage.
In Part (a)(i) most candidates got the mark for ‘essential mineral’.
The majority of the candidates in Part (a)(ii) gave two advantages for option 2 but many
found it difficult to identify a disadvantage. The most commonly seen correct responses were
‘preservation’, ‘taste’ and ‘flavour’. Some candidates wrote ‘it is an essential mineral’ while others
talked in terms of the difficulty of removing salt from food and how expensive that would be.
Higher Tier
In part (a)(i) a surprising number of candidates did not know the test for carbonates. Many
used silver nitrate, sodium hydroxide or flame tests, and some thought carbon was evolved.
Many candidates knew that carbon dioxide was involved in some way but too many simply added
the limewater to the carbonate. Carbon dioxide forms a white precipitate with limewater.
Many candidates in part (a)(ii) lost marks by describing an incorrectly coloured precipitate
– cream and yellow were common errors.
In part (a)(iii) many candidates had difficulty expressing themselves, and those candidates
who stated the colours frequently gave the wrong colours. Potassium was sometimes suggested
to give a red or a white flame test rather than lilac.
Both parts in (a) were well answered and it was clear that generally candidates understood
the issues and gave very sensible and mature answers.
Part (b)(i) was well answered – most candidates were able to suggest a reason why Option
1 was rejected.
In part (b)(ii) the majority of the candidates could extract the information for the advantages
of Option 2 from the passage. However, identifying the disadvantage was problematic for many
who focused on the difficulty of removing salt from food and quoted economic factors in their
response. Taste, flavour and preservation were the correct responses most often seen.
Page 80 of 91
(a) A lot of candidates did not know the colours given by the two sulfates.
3
(b) This was quite well attempted although some candidates wrote so no bacteria present.
(i) Despite the fact that the Specification includes detection and identification of artificial
4 colours by chromatography, most candidates showed little or no understanding of the test
results. These candidates often expressed their answers in terms of low = safe and high =
unsafe. Candidates who gained one mark usually did so by stating that A has more colours
than B.
(ii) The majority of candidates did recognise that the result shown was produced by
chromatography.
(a) About a third of candidates knew both and a further third knew one. Iron(III) was
5 unsurprisingly often linked to green.
(b) Less than a third of students knew this test result. Magnesium was predictably the more
popular incorrect answer.
(c) (i) Slightly more than half the students scored this mark. Some students seemingly were
just guessing the colour (blue, brown, white) whilst others were clearly mixed up
(crimson, red).
(iii) This was very poorly attempted. Many students were unable to express themselves
well. There were responses like ‘sodium is more reactive and will show its colour’,
‘the flame cannot give two separate colours’, ‘it can only produce one colour’, ‘it’s a
low sodium salt’, ‘they are both the same colour’, and ‘the most reactive element’s
colour is shown’.
Page 81 of 91
6
(a) (i) A few candidates could not recall the test for Fe2+ ions but the vast majority
managed to gain at least one mark here.
(ii) This was better attempted and a large number of candidates managed to gain at least
two marks.
(b) Some candidates found this difficult. There were vague answers like heat the compound
with a Bunsen burner or place it in a beaker and heat it. Others suggested carrying out a
test for either hydrogen or oxygen gas, eg put the compound in a test tube, bring a lighted
splint near the mouth of the test tube and see if there is a pop sound.
(c) Some candidates gave the names of instrumental methods eg mass spectrometry. Others
gave vague answers such as it will be fairer or there will not be much wastage of the
sample while some candidates made references to cost and safety.
7
(a) (i) More than half of the candidates got this wrong. They could not identify the
correct colour of the flame given by the sodium ion.
(ii) Almost half of the candidates were unable to identify the correct colour of the flame
given by the potassium ion.
(iii) A large majority of candidates gained a mark here as they were able to recall the fact
that the wire used in a flame test should have a high melting point.
(b) (i) Many candidates could not recall the test for the sulfate ion.
(ii) While most of the candidates gained some credit, about a third gained both marks.
Page 82 of 91
(a) (i) Most students correctly described the limewater test for carbon dioxide and
8 gave the correct result. A very small number mentioned limewater but omitted the
result. A common error was to fail to notice that the question specifically asked
students how to identify the gas produced from the addition of acid to a carbonate. As
a result, many described tests for other gases such as for hydrogen or ammonia.
(ii) Many students knew that test 3 was for aluminium but there was some confusion over
whether the insolubility of the precipitate in excess sodium hydroxide argued in
favour of or against aluminium ions. Of those who did score the mark relatively few
went on to say that test three indicated magnesium or calcium ions to gain a second
mark. The flame test was often cited, but usually incorrectly. Quite a few said that
aluminium produces a red flame; others that it does not, but only a few gained a mark
by correctly attributing the red flame to calcium (or lithium) or by indicating that
aluminium produces no flame colour (which is not the same as ‘not red’). A few were
incorrectly drawn to the test for nitrates by the mention of aluminium.
(iii) There was some confusion with other tests but most identified test 4 as indicating the
presence of chloride ions. Far fewer realised that the test was rendered invalid by the
prior addition of hydrochloric acid and most of those who did unfortunately omitted to
mention the test so that very few gained both marks.
(b) (i) Just over half of students answered correctly, mass spectrometry proving slightly
more popular than atomic absorption spectroscopy. Wrong answers included
incorrect instrumental methods such as nmr or uv but some gave wet chemistry
answers such as flame tests. A few simply answered ‘spectroscopy’ without further
elucidation. There is still confusion between spectroscopy and spectrometry along
with much misspelling of these terms, but these were not penalised.
(ii) Responses to this question were disappointing, with just under half of students being
awarded a mark. Students frequently mentioned or described accuracy and,
especially, precision. Such references did not gain a mark but, where cited in addition
to a correct response, nor were they penalised.
Page 83 of 91
(a) Surprisingly, only about half of the students gave the correct reason that colourings
9 are added to improve the appearance of the sweets. Many students thought that the
colouring was added to improve the taste of the sweets or to provide an energy boost or
even to preserve the sweets. Several students also thought that it was a good idea to add
colourings because it would make children hyperactive.
(c) There were very few answers that earned all three marks. Most students had difficulty
interpreting the chromatogram. Many students incorrectly thought that W, X, Y and Z were
also sweets. A comparison of the number of colourings and the types of colourings in each
sweet was required. The most common marks awarded were for ‘the sweets may cause
hyperactivity’, ‘both sweets contain W and Y’ and ‘sweet S contains more colourings than
sweet P’. Very few students mentioned the actual number of colourings in each sweet or
mentioned that both sweets did not contain X and Z.
Page 84 of 91
This question involving chromatography was generally not well answered. It appeared that
10 many students had not had practical experience of carrying out paper chromatography.
(a) (i) The vast majority of answers were incorrect. Many responses referred to the function
of the lid as to preventing substances such as gases, oxygen and bacteria getting
into the container. Vague references to contamination and preventing the escape of
toxins/poisons and the colours were prevalent. The idea of preventing the
loss/evaporation of solvent was rarely seen.
(ii) Generally well answered. A lack of knowledge and understanding was evident when
some students discussed the problems of removing the ink compared to rubbing out
a pencil mark if a mistake were made.
(b) (i) A surprising number of students were unable to deduce that four different colours
were present in the cake icing. Seven, three and two were common incorrect
answers.
(ii) Many students thought that the cake icing was safe because they identified the two
safe colours and ignored the others. Answers that detailed that all the cake colours
were safe showed a lack of understanding.
(c) Only the more able students had any knowledge and understanding of gas
chromatography.
(i) This was the best attempted part of the question. Confusion between accuracy and
reliability and precision was evident. Vague references to better results, the cost and
‘easier to do’ were common.
(ii) The idea of separating the mixture was the correct answer. Poor responses referred
to evaporation and the mixing of solvents.
(iii) Very few students scored credit here. Those who did implied that the identity of the
solvents could be realised. Many vague answers such as ‘something to do with
weight/mass’ showed no knowledge of molecular mass.
(a) (i) This question clearly divided the students into those who had learned the tests
11 and those who had not. Approximately one quarter answered well, gaining four or five
marks, but well over half scored one or zero. Most knew that the test for the
carbonate ion involved carbon dioxide but many incorrectly suggested adding sodium
carbonate directly to limewater. Of the remaining three tests, that for sulfate ions was
by far the best known, and that for nitrates the least. A frequent mistake in the latter
was to omit either sodium hydroxide or aluminium powder from the test. Many
students believed that test for ions required the use of those ions in the test; for
example by adding silver nitrate to test for nitrate ions or barium chloride to test for
chloride ions.
Page 85 of 91
(ii) About half of students answered correctly. A major source of confusion was the belief
that only anions, which would have no flame colour, were being tested. Others failed
to recognise that all the compounds contained sodium and therefore wrote of the
difficulty of recognising individual colours within a mixture.
(b) Most students managed to score a mark, with the majority gaining both. The most frequent
answers identified accuracy or precision, speed, or a small sample size.
(a) (i) The majority of students gained credit for knowing that chromatography is the
12 method used to detect and identify colours in food.
(ii) Most students understood that the food contained three different colours.
(iii) Many students had difficulty describing the positions of the colours on the
chromatogram. A comparison of levels is the probably the clearest way. There were
still far too many vague descriptions of what was happening or comparisons of the
number of colours on each columns.
(b) (i) Surprisingly, less than half of the students could give the correct reason that colours,
such as quinoline yellow (E104), are added to improve the appearance of the food.
Many students thoughtthat the colouring was added to improve the taste of the food
or to make food sweeter or to provide an energy boost or even to preserve the food.
Several students also thought that it was a good idea to add E104 because it would
make people hyperactive
(ii) Most of the students managed to get the idea that further or different tests were
needed. There were a few students who incorrectly wanted to use chromatography
again, use a different colouring or simply ban E104.
(a) There were lots of good reasons given as to why a manufacturer might justify the use
13 of additives in orange drinks. However, there was a large minority who felt that the
possibility of the additives causing hyperactivity might be a good selling point as an energy
drink.
(b) There were many good answers as to how scientists could use 4000 children to investigate
if there is a link between three coloured additives and hyperactivity in children. The most
common error was to have just two groups of children: a control group and another group
that were given all three coloured additives.
(c) (i) This was very well answered; most students understood that the company’s own
scientists might be biased.
(ii) Chromatography was less well known. There were few correct descriptions of how to
use paper chromatography for the test. Very few students said how the results could
be used to show if the orange drink contained any of the three coloured additives.
Page 86 of 91
(a) Most students did know that an E-number is used to identify a permitted food additive.
14
(b) There were very few answers that earned all three marks. Most students had difficulty
interpreting the simple chromatogram. Many students incorrectly thought that the height of
the dots represented the level of hyperactivity the colour causes or that the number of dots
represented the number of tests done. Few students mentioned the actual number of
colourings in each colour or mentioned that colour 3 is a mixture of colour 1 and colour 2.
(a) Part a was done well; students seemed reasonably secure in their knowledge of
15 flame colours. Where an error was made it was usually in identifying lithium.
(b) This part was much less well done than part (a), with just over a third gaining both marks.
Few scored a single mark; most who knew the test also knew the correct result. There
were several common errors. Many added hydrochloric acid as a reagent, perhaps
associating it with barium chloride in the test for sulfate ions. Many suggested a flame test,
often giving green as the expected colour, which would be the correct test for barium but
which did not answer the question. A few stated that a green flame colour would be caused
by the presence of chlorine. Finally, a significant number of students gave incorrect or
spurious tests, many of which were claimed to give a white precipitate, although no mark
was awarded for this.
(c) Part b produced a good spread of marks. The best students were able to gain all three
marks with clear and thorough answers. Marks were usually lost by omission; students
should take note of the number of marks achievable on this type of question. Some less
able students confined themselves to reiterating the information in the question without
adding anything significant, for example, ‘Yes, because it produced a white precipitate with
barium chloride’.
Page 87 of 91
(a) (i) The majority of students correctly named the ingredient as phosphoric acid
16 recognising that a pH of 2.9 indicated acidity.
(ii) The correct response was hydrogen ion. Only a few students read the question and
were able to give an ion. Most chose an incorrect answer from the list of ingredients
for Cola. The most popular answers were phosphoric acid, carbonated water and
sugar.
(b) (i) Most students scored a mark for using a pencil. To gain the second mark the idea
was needed that the pencil was insoluble and that ink was soluble with the
appropriate consequences for the chromatogram. Answers scoring no further credit
included the line being straight, being able to erase the line if an error occurred and
vague answers that ink interfered with the results of the separation.
(ii) This question discriminated well with the full range of marks awarded. Many students
were poor at expressing their ideas. The most common answer quoted the cola as
having the most colours with the fruit juice having fewer colours. Good answers
showed students had analysed the chromatogram and referred to the number of
colours in each drink and deduced that one of the colours was the same.
Misconceptions were often in terms of the speed of dots rising up the paper. There
were several incorrect conclusions about the similarity and differences of the dots.
(c) This was poorly answered. Reference to substances travelling at different speeds was rare.
Common incorrect answers involved boiling point or pH. Several answers confused gas
chromatography with mass spectrometry thinking that the speed through the column was
related to the mass of the molecule.
(d) (i) About half of students chose the correct answer, ‘Is there caffeine in a certain brand
of drink?’
(ii) Common correct responses were concerned with opinion or choice or ethical / moral
reasons followed by words to the effect that caffeine has different effects on different
people. Answers involving the inability to do an experiment were less frequent. Lots
of confused responses discussed the labels on the drinks at length.
Page 88 of 91
(a) (i) Many students did not know how to carry out the flame test in any detail,
17 although a majority gained at least one mark. A large number of students did not
mention a colourless flame or cleaning of the wire. A fair number specifically stated
that the safety flame should be used. Some just added the substance to the flame
without being in any way specific about how this should be achieved. Others
suggested adding the chemical to water, perhaps confusing a flame test with the
reactions of alkali metals with water.
(ii) Most students managed to gain both marks although a significant number failed to
gain any marks.
(iii) As in previous years, students do not seem to have learned chemical tests. Only a
small minority correctly identified potassium chloride. Many students did not appear
to realise that their answer should be limited to the three given chemicals, with many
random guesses attempted. Students should be encouraged to see questions as a
whole rather than as a sequence of unrelated parts.
(b) (i) Despite not having a restricted choice of answers as in part (a)(iii), students fared
better in this question, with more than twice as many successfully identifying copper,
perhaps due to a familiarity with the blue colour of copper sulfate.
(ii) Again, with only three answers to choose from, less than a third of students did so
correctly. The most popular answer was chloride. A knowledge of the chemical tests
in the specification is an area that needs attention.
This question produced a wide range of responses; some very clearly expressed, others
20 suggesting that the student had not done any practical chemistry of this sort. Nearly half of the
responses, however, achieved Level 3 with five or six marks.
There were several routes to identifying the ions and substances. The most popular route was to
use the flame test to differentiate the potassium ion (and hence potassium carbonate) from the
three sodium compounds, then to carry out the halide test, using nitric acid and silver nitrate, to
identify sodium chloride and iodide. Students then assumed that the remaining chemical, which
would not produce a precipitate, was sodium carbonate. Some students identified the carbonates
as well, using nitric or hydrochloric acid and passing the gas released through limewater.
Most of the other methods chosen were similar, some students starting with the halide test,
others with identification of the two carbonates.
Some descriptions were very detailed, explaining why nitric acid was used before adding silver
nitrate, while others confused the halide test with that for a sulfate.
The method used for the flame test varied considerably. The most common methods included
spraying the solutions in the flame, soaking spills in the solutions before placing in the flame and
using nichrome wire or glass rods that had been dipped in the solutions. Some students
evaporated the water from the solutions to gain a solid version of the substance. Others just
stated that the flame test should be used but did not give a method, which limited their mark to
four.
Page 89 of 91
(a) A wide spread of responses was seen, as might be expected. In general, the cation
21 tests were better known than the anion tests. Sulfate was the least well known of all. Some
students spoiled their halide ion answers by naming them iodine and bromine. Fewer than
a quarter knew all six ion results.
(b) The responses to this question were generally poor. A large number of students considered
how difficult it would be for them to do the experiments rather than compare the two
methods being done by a competent chemist. Therefore they frequently stated that the
titration would take a long time and the results would be inaccurate due to the difficulty of
recognising the end point in a titration. Students also considered the calculation (instead of
the actual method) and gave the response that a titration calculation would be difficult to do
and was prone to mistakes, whereas the calculation for the precipitation reaction would be
very easy to do. Even students who recognised that some of the precipitate would be lost
then sometimes went on to state that this method is more accurate than the titration. In
general, the greater speed and accuracy of the titration were the two marks most frequently
awarded, with loss of precipitate also mentioned by some students. The other marking
points were seldom seen and in general the award of four marks was uncommon and of
five marks extremely rare. As with question 4(b), students need to be careful that their
responses in respect of each method do not contradict each other.
Foundation
22
(a) (i) Reasonably well answered by the majority, with three marks being the most common
score. Many students described either effervescence or reduction in size of calcium
carbonate in the first test tube and some went on to link this with the evolution of
carbon dioxide. More often, though, credit was given for carbon dioxide when it was
used as an explanation for the formation of cloudy limewater in the second tube. The
least well known feature was that the cloudy observation is caused by a precipitate of
calcium carbonate. Some students thought that the limewater would be drawn back
into the first tube. A significant minority wrote their responses for the two tubes in the
wrong spaces but were given credit if it was clear what was meant.
(ii) Fewer than one in ten of the students could draw the structure of ethanoic acid.
Incorrect responses included completion with hydrogen atoms to show ethane, or
something completely infeasible.
(iii) Most students had no idea what the catalyst was, so chose a substance they knew
was a catalyst from other parts of the specification – usually iron, sometimes nickel.
However, ester was known by more, even if often spelled like the female name.
‘Perfume’ and ‘fragrance’ were commonly seen. No credit was available for ether.
(b) Poorly attempted by many. It is clear that students do not know or understand these anion
tests. Often a random scatter of white, cream and yellow precipitates were seen, and even
flame colour precipitates like lilac and crimson. However, some students at least
recognised that water would do nothing in either test.
(ii) This question stretched the powers of expression of many students to the limit. Many
inadequate statements such as ‘you can’t see two colours at once’ or ‘only one colour
can be seen at a time’ were seen. However, credit was given to those students who
thought the colours would mix or blend.
Page 90 of 91
Higher
(a) (i) Reasonably well answered by the majority, with three marks being the most common
score. Many students described either effervescence or reduction in size of calcium
carbonate in the first test tube and some went on to link this with the evolution of
carbon dioxide. More often, though, credit was given for carbon dioxide when it was
used as an explanation for the formation of cloudy limewater in the second tube. The
least well known feature was that the cloudy observation is caused by a precipitate of
calcium carbonate. Some students thought that the limewater would be drawn back
into the first tube. A significant minority wrote their responses for the two tubes in the
wrong spaces but were given credit if it was clear what was meant.
(ii) Fewer than half of the students could draw the structure of ethanoic acid. A small
minority extended the diagram and drew propanoic acid instead. The weaker
responses involved completion with hydrogen atoms to show ethane.
(iii) Most students had no idea what the catalyst was, so chose a substance they knew
was a catalyst from other parts of the specification – usually iron, sometimes nickel.
However, ester was well known, even if often spelled like the female name. No credit
was available for ether.
(b) Quite poorly attempted by many. It is clear that students do not know or understand these
anion tests. Often a random scatter of white, cream and yellow precipitates were seen, and
even flame colour precipitates like lilac and crimson. However, most students recognised
that water would do nothing in either test.
(ii) This question stretched the powers of expression of many students to the limit. Many
inadequate statements such as ‘you can’t see two colours at once’ or ‘only one colour
can be seen at a time’ were seen. However, credit was given to those candidates
who thought the colours would mix or blend.
Page 91 of 91