The Effect of Physical Activity and Exercise
The Effect of Physical Activity and Exercise
By Meghan M. Bellarin
May 2016
Goucher College
Table of Contents
List of Tables i
Abstract ii
I. Introduction 1
Overview 1
Hypothesis 2
Operational Definitions 2
Summary 10
III. Methods 11
Design 11
Participants 11
Instruments 12
Procedure 12
IV. Results 13
V. Discussion 15
Implementations 15
Threats to Validity 15
Relationships to Literature 16
Implications for Future Research 17
Summary 18
References 19
List of Tables
2. Analysis of Variance 14
i
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of physical activity in elementary school
students on academic achievement. This study took place over the course of five weeks and used
a pre-test and post-test design. Students in the study participated in a physical activity session
during “Morning Meeting” each day for a total of twenty minutes each day. The students were
rated each day on their participation level and attendance during the sessions. The tools used to
measure academic achievement were the math benchmarks 2 and 3. Results did not show
positive effects of the physical activity interventions on the math benchmark scores. Future
studies are recommended involving more accurate activity level measurements and requirements
ii
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
Overview
A current trend amongst young children is a sedentary lifestyle that leads to a lack of
motivation, focus, and behavioral issues in school. Physical activity is often lacking in the
school day, and studies have shown that increasing the amount of activity can improve many
aspects of a person’s well-being. The curriculum and schedules in schools are often full of
academics, and there is little time for activity, but it is important that teachers understand the
variety of ways it can be integrated for academic success. Desai, Kurpad, Chomitz, and Thomas
(2015) state that aerobic exercise and activity positively support mental health, influence health
school has the potential to be enhanced through the integration of physical activity and exercise
into the school day, with or without adding in programs. There are several ways that educators
can get the students moving with mathematics problems, taking brain breaks, providing after
The researcher is interested in the many positive effects that physical activity and
exercise have on students and their academic success. As a physical educator, the researcher can
see first-hand accounts of students who are exercising regularly and displaying success in
different aspects of their school day, including focus and attention, scores on assessments and
benchmarks, and positive behaviors. Teachers are capable of providing students with many life
lessons as well as academic lessons, and being physically fit is one lesson where students will be
able to see success. There have been numerous studies to determine the effects of exercise on
1
children and their academic success, and with more positive results, students can become more
academically fit as well as physically fit, which will lead to more success.
The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of physical activity in elementary
Hypothesis
Physical activity and exercise for twenty minutes in the morning for fifth grade students
Operational Definitions
The independent variable for this study was the number of minutes each day the students
spent engaged in physical activity. The type of physical activity that the students participated in
each day varied. The types of physical activity included exercise videos from the website “Go
Noodle,” coordination and balance activities, and sets of fitness skills that the students would
perform. The fitness skills included jumping jacks, push-ups, curl ups, windmills, jogging in
The dependent variable in this study was the student scores for the math benchmark 2 and
3. The two benchmarks were state-wide and required for all fifth grade students. A second
dependent variable in the study was each student’s participation level during the physical
activity. The students were observed by the researcher and the classroom teacher during the
physical activity time each morning and were scored on a scale of 0-3. The zero represents
students who chose not to participate in the activity, a one for those who participated minimally,
a two for those students who participated in most but not all, and a three for those who had full
2
participation. If the students were absent or not in the room at the time, they were not scored for
3
CHAPTER II
This literature review examines the effects of physical activity and exercise on
elementary school students and their academic achievement. The first section will discuss the
importance of physical activity and exercise on the brain and body functions with more specific
scientific references. The second section examines the benefits of physical activity and exercise
on academic success specifically. The third section provides strategies to incorporate movement
and physical activity into the school day for elementary level classes.
There are several proven indicators that have shown physical activity benefits the human
brain, its basic functions, and abilities. One of the most critical brain functions that can predict
academic success is memory. So (2012) found that physical activity may increase memory
functions and in turn create academic success for students who engage in moderate to vigorous
physical activity multiple times a week. According to Chaddock-Heyman et al. (2015), students
who are at higher fitness levels have superior performance on tasks that challenge working
memory and standardized tests of mathematics and reading relative to less fit students.
On a scientific level, there are several effects that occur within the brain as a result of
exercise. In specific brain growth and development, Chaddock-Heyman et al. (2015) found that
differences in aerobic fitness levels in children play a role in cortical gray matter structure, which
is important for academic success. Children who have a higher level of aerobic fitness are
shown to have cognitive and brain plasticity, which can correlate with success in academic areas,
especially mathematics. Also higher levels of aerobic fitness have been associated with larger
brain volumes in two regions of the brain that are critical for memory and learning: the
4
hippocampus and dorsal striatum (Chaddock-Heyman et al., 2015). Conyers and Wilson (2015)
agree, stating that the hippocampus is essential for creating new memories and for learning.
Neurogenesis is the creation of new brain cells within areas of the brain associated with
recall, and Conyers and Wilson (2015) believe that exercise enhances this process, while also
forming connections between neurons in response to learning and sensory input, known as
order cognitive functions in the brain, which is essential for monitoring, maintaining, and
strategizing higher-level cognitive abilities that enhance academic performance. There are many
processes in the brain that occur when the body is engaged in physical activity, and the more
students are exposed to these activities, the more these functions will continue to increase. There
is also evidence that the prefrontal cortex may function at a more efficient level after engaging in
There are also several health benefits from engaging in physical activity, including
increased strength and decreased chance of injuries. Those who are more active experience a
& Sanders, 2001). Exercise also increases serotonin levels, endorphins, and melatonin, which
increase positive emotions (Conyers & Wilson, 2015). These neurochemicals help to make
individuals increase their attention and focus as well as boosting moods, which can enhance
mastery of skills. The physical and scientific effects of exercise on the brain and body go beyond
academic success and are beneficial for a person’s well-being. As the health improves, this can
Due to the many benefits of physical activity on the brain, this in turn results in a higher
5
correlation of academic success with students as well as an increase in positive behavior. Field
et al. (2001) found that among the health benefits of physical activity, exercise has been noted to
increase performance on cognitive tasks as well as raise serotonin levels. In students who
perform higher rates of exercise, it has been shown that those same students will have higher
grade point averages. The number of hours a week a child is physically active can impact their
engagement in sports, social settings, and energy levels, causing them to take the initiative to put
in the extra efforts in academics. The amount of time spent in physical activities, specifically
twenty minutes or more daily, improves performance on perceptual and decisional tasks
(Trudeau & Shephard, 2008). Also Trudeau and Shephard noted that when students are involved
in physical activities such as music, it has the potential to increase reading skills. Physical
activity in general, not specific to physical fitness levels or sports involvement, has positive
effects on academic scores through increased focus, decision making skills, and increasing
interest levels.
Students who are more physically active in aerobic exercise show higher levels of
success in the area of math more so than other academic areas. Aerobic fitness activities have
been linked to cognitive functions, response speed, working memory and attention (Desai et al.,
2015). When students are able to concentrate and have a healthier mental state after exercising,
academic areas such as mathematics, which revolves around memory and concentration, can be
more successful. Moses (2011) found that many studies have noted high levels of physical
exertion had positive influences on mathematical performance and that increasing the amount of
physical activity time did not have a negative effect on academic performance.
Trudeau and Shephard (2008) explored the concept of physical activity having a positive
effect on classroom behavior and reduced disruptions in students. Positive classroom behavior
6
leads to more optimistic attitudes during class in general, which leads to more success with
academic lessons. A student’s behavior can also determine his or her feeling of school
connectedness and school satisfaction, which prevents students from disregarding classwork and
The level of physical activity has shown an effect on the academic success rate when
comparing vigorous exercises, moderate exercises, and strengthening exercises to one another.
According to So (2012), vigorous activities may include soccer, basketball, aerobics, and
swimming; moderate activities include badminton, table tennis, carrying light loads and cycling
at a regular pace, and strengthening exercises can include push-ups, weight lifting, sit-up, and
weight training. Vigorous exercises will raise heart rate higher than strengthening exercise. So
demonstrated that higher levels of physical activity result in a higher correlation of academic
success than lower levels of physical activity. Vigorous activities increase brain and memory
functions and can have a positive influence on boys and girls. Strengthening exercises have not
shown a high correlation with academic achievement when compared to more vigorous activities
performed less than four times a week, especially in boys. As elementary schools push for
higher academic success through higher standards, the positive effects on academic achievement
from movement and physical activity within the school day should be considered. Higher levels
of activity have shown to give greater success with concentration, memory functions, behavior,
and decision-making skills for students, all of which can enhance a student’s academic abilities
and achievement and could then transfer over to higher levels of academic success.
Most elementary schools around the world have physical activity built into the school
week through physical education classes. The amount of time varies between schools, districts,
7
states, and countries, but most have a set schedule of minutes per week a student is guaranteed to
be physically active. Elementary schools also generally have time built into their schedules for
recess each day. These are two opportunities that for the most part are scheduled, but can be lost
or taken out of schedules for various reasons including testing, instrumental classes, and
Brain breaks are a popular strategy and are designed for students to perform in a small
space near desks or in the classroom in their own chairs (Caldwell & Ratliffe, 2014). Examples
of appropriate breaks would be performing fitness skills such as jumping jacks, jogging in place,
or pushups; using exercise videos from DVD’s or the internet; or playing games in class that
involve physical activity. Videos, short clips, and movement sessions should be quick and to the
point and are intended to give the student an opportunity to refocus and reboot their energy. A
few goals of brain break videos are to increase students’ heart rate, assist teachers with providing
physical activity within the day, and release some of the students’ energy after sitting during a
lesson. Movement breaks are essential to refocusing attention on academics and can be taken
Integration of physical activity and academic subjects is bridging or merging the content
from multiple academic areas to allow students to see the connections and relationship of
knowledge (Koch, 2013). Within the classroom setting, there are several ways to integrate
physical activity, including stories, historical characters, creating shapes, and using locomotor
movements to perform tasks. Koch gives several suggestions, including Math Bo, which is using
math equations and functions and “combat” style skills in the air to complete the equations.
Integrating the compass and directions within the classroom and using fitness skills for direction
8
on the map can also allow students in social studies to move more. Within science classes,
teachers can use physical experiments and allow students to move throughout the room, as well
as acting out content material, like physically acting out the states of water. It is important for
classroom teachers to understand basic locomotor movement skills and terminology, and for this
to occur, the physical education teacher and classroom teachers would need to collaborate.
Another integration strategy that has proven to be very useful is the use of yoga skills and
techniques. Yoga practice improves individuals’ physical fitness levels, focus and relaxation, as
well as several aspects of cognition and executive functions (Telles, Singh, Kumar, Kumar, &
Balkrishna, 2013). It is suggested that yoga should be practiced several times a week and for
multiple weeks in a row in order to gain the physical and cognitive benefits. Suggested yoga
skills include breathing techniques, loosening exercises, and physical postures. Specific yoga
skills can be performed within classroom settings, at recess, or within appropriate places at the
school, and consist of different postures such as the butterfly pose, cobra posture, raised leg
posture, and tree posture. According to Telles et al., the strategy of incorporating yoga into the
school day for elementary students is one that teachers are capable of doing without technical
training, can be varied each day to keep enthusiasm and interest, and has shown significant
Afterschool clubs are a great approach to incorporating physical activity into a school day
without taking time from the normal daily schedule. Käll, Nilsson, and Linden (2014) found that
enjoyable, non-competitive activities resulted in many benefits for the school, students, and
teachers, including fellowship, reduced boredom, and joy. The activities held after or before
school should be positive, motivational, and enjoyable for all to participate in and held at least
9
two times a week. The programs can cater to all types of students and can include the use of
A more specific afterschool strategy is a running club to offer students assistance with
improving their running and walking abilities, as well as developing a sense of community.
Some of the options include basic running clubs, like Girls on the Run, H.E.R.O. Boys’ Running
Club, and Running and Writing clubs. Vanzandt (2011) found that after integrating a writing
and running program, there were significant benefits to the students who participated. Many of
these groups meet twice a week for about sixty to ninety minutes and work on running technique
and endurance, building up to a culminating race such as a 5K. Within the program, Vanzandt
also found that many students made more growth after implementing running buddies, which
increase accountability, goal setting, and motivation. The program coincides with a writing
program to help promote journal writing skills. The use of a running program after school has
Summary
Physical activity and exercise are a critical part of everyone’s life, whether the purpose be
to maintain current health, become more successful in academic areas, increase aerobic fitness
viewpoint as well as an academic perspective for students in elementary school so that teachers
are able to integrate necessary activities into daily routines to benefit the students. From brain
breaks to curriculum driven running programs, there is evidence that shows that exercise in
school is critical to the success of students in academics, focus, physical health, and social
relationships.
10
CHAPTER III
METHODS
Design
The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of physical activity in elementary
group of the same students that were not randomly selected. The study uses a pre and post
assessment based on math benchmark scores. The independent variable is the number of
minutes students spent participating in physical activity each morning during “Morning
Meeting.” The dependent variable was the students’ scores of math benchmark 2 and math
benchmark 3. Another dependent variable was the level of participation that the students
performed during the physical activity. The students were observed and scored based on a scale
of 0-3, with 0 given to the students who chose not to participate and 3 given to the students who
participated at a high level for the full time period. A comparison of the ranking of students on
their math benchmark 2 and their ranking for math benchmark 3 was made to determine if the
Participants
The students in this study were fifth graders in a medium sized elementary school. There
were ten girls and thirteen boys, and all were physically able to participate. The school was a
Title 1 school in Anne Arundel County in Maryland and had an enrollment of 475 students.
Within the class of participants, there were several student subgroups represented, including
African American, Asian, Caucasian and Hispanic. Approximately 75% of the participants
qualified and received free and reduced meals. There were no participants that had an IEP and
three participants are Limited English Proficiency. This class was selected because the observer
11
participates in a school-wide initiative called “Morning Meeting” with the homeroom class and
had the ability to integrate movement into the scheduled meetings each day. The observer had
already established a positive rapport with the classroom teacher and the students and the change
in routine did not affect student learning or behaviors. The observer was able to obtain the pre-
assessment and post-assessment benchmark scores from the data program Performance Matters.
Instruments
This study used four measures, including attendance, physical activity participation, and
math benchmark ranking scores as pre and post assessments. Attendance was taken based on the
student being present or absent (ABS) for the activity period. The physical activity was
measured on a scale of 0-3 based on the amount of time and effort the students participated. The
observer would facilitate the physical activity and record the students’ participation level at the
end of the time period. The pre-assessment was the participants’ ranking of scores with their
classmates on the math benchmark 2 that the participants took in January of 2016. The post-
assessment was the participants’ ranking of scores with their classmates on the math benchmark
Procedure
Each day for a period of six weeks, amounting to twenty seven total school days, physical
activities were built into a 20-minute block from 8:55 a.m. to 9:15 a.m. The activities included
exercise videos from www.gonoodle.com, fitness based workouts, sessions of yoga or stretching,
and walking in the halls. The “GoNoodle” website included activity categories of guided
dancing, free movement, stretching, sport and exercise, kinesthetic learning, coordination, and
calming. The activities were selected because of participant interest, variation of styles of
12
CHAPTER IV
RESULTS
This study examines the effects of physical activity in elementary school students on
academic achievement. The dependent variable was the fifth grade math benchmark 3. Multiple
regression was the statistical technique of choice since there were multiple measures that could
physical activity sessions, and average participation in the activity sessions. The fifth grade math
benchmark 2 was the baseline score. Students attended or did not attend physical activity
sessions and thus a ratio or percentage of sessions attended was constructed from the total
attended divided by the total possible sessions offered. Additionally, the researcher kept track of
how attendees participated on a scale of 0 to 3, with 3 being the highest participation and 0 being
non-participation. These variables were entered into a dependent t-test, which found that there
construction of a simple gain score by subtracting benchmark 2 from benchmark 3. The results
Table 1
Test Value = 0
95% Confidence Interval of the
Difference
t df Sig. (2-tailed) Mean Difference Lower Upper
gain 5.759 21 .000 14.59091 9.3223 19.8595
13
The null hypothesis, that no gain from one Benchmark to the other, could be rejected.
This is depicted in Table 2 and simply repeats the independent t-test finding through Analysis of
Table 2
Analysis of Variance
ANOVAa
When the coefficients of the co-variables that were thought to impact the performance on
Benchmark 3 were examined, these co-variables all had negative coefficients in the regression
equation. Thus, multiple regression is statistically saying that these variables actually are
negatively related to performance or detracted from the performance. The attendance ratio was
not statistically significant, but the average participation showed a negative relationship. The
14
CHAPTER V
DISCUSSION
The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of physical activity in elementary
school students on academic achievement. The null hypothesis that no gain on the students’
Implications
The implications of the results of this study show that physical activity and exercise did
not have a direct impact on the academic achievement of fifth grade students. The students were
able to choose their participation level during each physical activity session, therefore they did
not all take advantage of the movement each day. The increase in scores from the two
Benchmarks was a positive outcome, but there was no positive correlation with the benchmark
scores as a result of the activity. The researcher can conclude that although the physical activity
can be positive for the students’ physical well-being, in this study it was not a positive influence
Threats to Validity
There are many threats to validity within the study including internal and external
validity. External validity refers to the extent to which the results of the study can be
generalized. The study group consisted of one of the three fifth grade classes and the results
cannot be generalized for all fifth grade students at the school. The students live in suburban
neighborhoods and attend a Title 1 school so the results cannot be generalized for all students of
a similar demographics. The study was also comprised of only fifth grade students, which
indicates the results cannot be comprehensive for all elementary aged students. This intervention
15
took place in the morning prior to academic lessons, which were later in the school day and may
Internal validity refers to the extent to which a causal relationship can be made based on
the physical activity sessions and the academic achievement of the study group. The data that
was used was the scores on the fifth grade math benchmarks. The physical activity sessions
were conducted in the morning of each school day during the scheduled “Morning Meeting,” and
the students’ attendance for the physical activity sessions may have varied due to students
coming late to school, being absent, or being out of the room for various reasons. Another threat
to validity was the level of participation of the students during each of the sessions. The
student’s motivation, attitudes and external factors within their lives each day could have
affected their level of participation. The researcher also could have miss-estimated the
participation degree of the students. The notion that the students were familiar with the
benchmarks and may have performed better on benchmark 3 due to having already taken
Relationships to Literature
Several other researchers have studied the effects of physical activity and exercise on
academics using many different interventions, fitness measurements, and with varying results.
Desai et al. (2015) agrees that when studying the effects of exercise and academics,
considerations should be made for the adequacy of opportunities of fitness in schools, not just
physical activity, in general. There are several health-related fitness components that make up
physical activity and aerobic fitness has shown to have a more significant relationship with
academic achievement.
16
There is continued research that suggests that students involved in extracurricular
physical activities can have similar academic levels to those not involved in activities, which has
led to improved interactions with peers, a stronger sense of belonging, and higher satisfaction
(Trudeau & Shephard, 2008). Field et al. (2001) has found that higher levels of exercise have
also led students to better relationships with their families and a lower level of depression, which
can increase performances on cognitive tasks. Käll et al. (2014) conducted a study that took
place over a longer period of time, was directed at the entire school, and the physical activity
intervention was scheduled and obligatory, which led to a stronger study and more significant
improvements in academic achievements. With the interventions being more strategic and
important to the students and staff, there are more opportunities for success.
Although this particular study did not make significant improvements for academic
achievement, Conyers and Wilson (2015) believe that it is essential to note that there are no
negative consequences for physical activity as a part of the school day, and it should be an
integral part of the schedule. If students become more physically active and develop higher
levels of fitness, it has been shown to activate important regions in the brain essential for higher-
The results from this study have shown several implications for future research. One
implication is to have a higher degree of control on the participation level of the students and
more accurate measures of the participation levels such as heart rate. A future researcher could
also consider a two group study to compare the score increases from one class who receives the
physical activity intervention and a class who does not. The timing of the intervention in relation
to the academic lessons could also be an implication that a future researcher should consider.
17
Considering that this study was conducted for one grade level in one school, researchers could
study several grade groups or the same grade levels across different demographical schools.
Finally, a random sample of students being selected instead of a specific class may benefit future
Summary
The results of this study show there was no positive relationship between physical
activity and academic achievement for fifth grade students after interventions. Although there
were gains in student performance, the study had limitations which may have had an impact on
the results. Previous research suggests there are positive correlations between exercise and
academic success and a lengthier and controlled study may prove differing results. It is proposed
that more research is conducted on the effects of physical activity and academic achievement in
all students. There are many proven benefits of physical activity and exercise including overall
well-being, brain functions, and relationships. The research suggests that implementing exercise
into the school day will have positive effects for all students.
18
REFERENCES
Caldwell, T., & Ratliffe, T. (2014). Investigation of intensity levels during video classroom
Chaddock-Heyman, L., Erickson, K. I., Kienzler, C., King, M., Pontifex, M. B., Raine, L. B., &
Kramer, A. F. (2015). The role of aerobic fitness in cortical thickness and mathematics
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0134115
Conyers, M., & Wilson, D. (2015). Smart moves: Powering up the brain with physical
Desai, I. K., Kurpad, A.V., Chomitz, V.R., & Thomas, T. (2015). Aerobic fitness, micronutrient
status, and academic achievement in Indian school-aged children. PLoS ONE 10(3):
e0122487. Doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0122487
Field, T., Diego, M., & Sanders, C. E. (2001). Exercise is Positively Related to Adolescents’
Käll, L. B., Nilsson, M., & Lindén, T. (2014). The impact of a physical activity intervention
Moses, T. (2011). Does physical activity impact the academic achievement of fifth grade
students in two Arizona schools? (Order No. 349042). Available from ProQuest
19
So, W. (2012). Association between physical activity and academic performance in
2458-12-258.
Telles, S., Singh, N., Kumar, A., Kumar, A., & Balkrishna, A. (2013). Effect of yoga or physical
controlled trial. Child & Adolescent Psychiatry & Mental Health, 7(1), 1-28.
Doi:10.1186/1753-2000-7-37
Trudeau, F. & Shephard, R. (2008). Physical education, school physical activity, school sports
Vanzandt, C. (2011). Running to achieve: engaging students in literacy and physical activity
Journals. (903795189).
20