Philosophical Perspectives of The Self: Gadfly
Philosophical Perspectives of The Self: Gadfly
Impact of culture to self- concept Egocentric- a concept of the self where the self is seen as an autonomous and
● Erdman (2006) using American and Chinese students, early childhood distinct individual.
memories were a big part of self-concept. Socio-centric- according to this view, there is no intrinsic self that can possess
Findings enduring qualities.
● different cultural memories brought about by early childhood years and
persist into adulthood. Three-Phased Rite of Passage by Arnold Van Gennep
● differences formed both in the extended cultural contexts which defines
the meaning of the self and the immediate family environment. Separation Phase- people detach from their former identity to another
Culture Liminality Phase- a person transitions from one identity to another
● is the set of unwritten norms of conduct that guide the behavior of a Incorporation Phase- the change in one's status is officially incorporated
group?
Anthony Wallace and Raymond Fogelson- coined the term "identity struggles"
Identity Struggles- characterize interaction in which there is a discrepancy define their characteristics (self-knowledge)
between the identity a person claims to possess, and the identity attributed to that how people use task and social feedback to monitor their goal progress
person by other. (self-regulation)
Self-identification- individuals must overcome many obstacles the influence of personal standards, expectations, and values on
Katherine Ewing- formulated the "Illusion of Wholeness" perception of others (self in social judgment)
Illusion of Wholeness- implies that the cohesiveness and continuity of self are , and how people maintain desired self-images.
only illusory The self has been studied as an individual difference variable (primarily
Cultural Differences- exists when groups of people assign different meanings to by personality theorists), as a determinant of social perception,
different life events and things attribution, and judgment, and as an essential element in social relations.
Key Terms
Social Identities- people construct their self-identity from the similarities and
The self as a cognitive construction:
differences in characteristics among individuals.
Family Membership- the most significant feature to determine a person's social
William James (1842–1910)
identity.
was one of the first to postulate a theory of the self in The Principles of
Example: A person’s social identity can be determined based on the
Psychology.
influence of his/her family background (history, status, traits, or even resources)
Language- viewed as an essential for the maintenance of group identity. two aspects of the self that he termed the “I Self”and “Me Self.”
Example: As people become members of a social group and learn to
share that group's identity, they need to adapt to the group’s language.
I Self
Religious Affiliation- an important marker for group identity in each society. reflects what people see or perceive themselves doing in the
Example: In a predominantly Catholic country, most Filipinos qualify physical world (e.g., recognizing that one is walking, eating,
themselves as members of the Roman Catholic Church. writing).
Name- an important device to individualize a person and legitimize him or her as Me Self
a member of a social group. is a more subjective and psychological phenomenon, referring to
Example: When you were born, you were given a name documented individuals’ reflections about themselves (e.g. Characterizing
through a birth certificate to legalize your birth. oneself as athletic, smart, and cooperative).
self-view,self-image, self-schema, and self-concept
PSYCHOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES OF THE SELF
3 COMPONENTS OF ME SELF
(1) The material self (e.g., tangible objects or possessions we collect for
prior conceptions of the self as knower tended to posit a
ourselves)
“transcendental” capacity for the ego
(2) The social self (e.g., how we interact and portray ourselves within different
James’s distinction perseveres in the interest that self-theorists accord to
groups, situations, or persons)
how people acquire self-knowledge and how this knowledge is
(3) The spiritual self (e.g., internal dispositions).
manifested in behavior.
Sigmund Freud preconscious memory. Similar example could be what is your mom's birthday,
when did it last rain, and how long does it take to drive to the mall.
human personality is complex and has more than a single component.
psychoanalytic theory of personality, personality is composed of three The Unconscious: The unconscious contains thoughts, memories, and desires that
elements, id, the ego, and the superego—work together to create complex are buried deep in ourselves, well below our conscious awareness. Even though
human behaviors. we are not aware of their existence, they exert great influence on our behavior.
Example: Things in your unconscious would be forgotten negative
THREE ELEMENTS OF PERSONALITY experiences in your past, extreme dislike for a parent, or a terrible event that you
pushed out of your preconscious.
ID is driven by the pleasure principle, which strives for immediate
gratification of all desires, wants, and needs. I. True self
EGO operates based on the reality principle, which strives to satisfy the id's sense of integrity, of connected wholeness that harks to the early stage.
desires n realistic and socially appropriate ways. II. False self
SUPEREGO is the aspect of personality that holds all our internalized moral When the person must comply with external rules, such as being polite
standards and ideals that we acquire from both parents and society—our sense of or otherwise following social codes, then a false self is used. The false
right and wrong. self constantly seeks to anticipate demands of others to maintain the
relationship.
Two Kinds of False Self
The 3 Levels of Awareness
Healthy false self
The conscious: The conscious consists of what someone is aware of at any point
false self is functional both for the person and for society.
in time. It includes what you are thinking about right now, whether it is in the
front of you mind or the back. If you are aware of it then it is in the conscious The healthy false self feels that that it is still being true to the true self.
mind. It can be compliant but without feeling that it has betrayed its true self.
Example: Right now, as you are reading about Freud you could be thinking When the situation becomes difficult, the true self can still override the
about what is being said in the text and that your eyes are tired from staring at this true self and so acts as an effective conscience or super-ego.
screen. In the back of your mind, however, you might be thinking "wow this
website is really cool, if I was a psychology teacher, I would give whoever made Unhealthy false self
it an A". Both thoughts occur in the conscious mind.
A self that fits in but through a feeling of forced compliance rather than
loving adaptation
The Preconscious: The preconscious contains information that is just below the
surface of awareness. It can be retrieved with relative ease and usually can be false self-wins debates against the true self, the person finds that they are
thought of as memory or recollection. unable to be guided by their true self and so must adapt to the social
Example: Right now think of your middle name. That is an example of situation rather than assert itself.
Discussion contains different modes of the self, “appear, one after another and side-
by-side in the consciousness.”
An unhealthy and pathological false self never gains independence
from the mother, and so never gets to transition to independence. V. Agentic Self and Proactive Self
These principles help explain how people seem at ease or are constantly in tension The agentic self is defined as the aspect of human personality that is determined
and so act in dysfunctional ways. by future assessments of one's goals, objectives, and actions. Its functions are
adversely affected by degenerating planning, selecting, and implementing the
III. Ideal Self -concept capabilities of an individual.
person who we would like to be. It consists of our goals and ambitions in
life, and is dynamic – i.e., forever changing. The proactive self-make things happen, instead of waiting for them to happen to
The ideal self in childhood is not the ideal self in our teens or late you. Active means "doing something."
twenties etc. The prefix pro- means "before."
So if you are proactive, you are ready before something happens.
Proactive Attitude (PA) is a personality characteristic which has
implications for motivation and action. It is a belief in the rich potential
Real Self Concept of changes that can be made to improve oneself and one's environment.
REAL SELF can be seen by others, but because we have no way of truly This includes various facets such as resourcefulness, responsibility,
knowing how others view us, the real self is our self-image. values, and vision.
The Western culture in general, for example, is one that tends to hyper-
Random Facts focus on dieting and body appearance. Digitally retouched photos are the
The human body contains nearly 100 trillion cells. norm in which our society is saturated in, and this mentality can
There are at least 10 times as many bacteria in the human body as cells. negatively influence an individual’s body image.
The average adult takes over 20,000 breaths a day. Other cultures that celebrate and uphold a person’s body and whose
Each day, the kidneys process about 200 quarts (50 gallons) of blood traditions uphold what a person can do rather than their appearance may
to filter out about 2 quarts of waste and water more effectively support the building of a positive body image.
Adults excrete about a quarter and a half (1.42 liters) of urine each
day. Culture Is Just One Factor
The human brain contains about 100 billion nerve cells
Water makes up more than 50 percent of the average adult's body While culture alone is not responsible for a poor or negative body image,
weight the influence and potential in which it can impact how a person feels
You use your eyes to see, your ears to hear and your muscles to do the about themselves and their body are substantial. Being aware of your
heavy lifting. In fact, most body parts are far more complicated than that, surroundings and understanding how culture and traditions may affect
while some seem to have no business being inside there at all. and impact how you think and feel about your body can be
The Impact of Culture on Body Image and Self Esteem helpful, especially in a conscious effort to build a positive body image
Our body image, includes our perception of ourselves and our own body and increase self-esteem.
and the way we feel about our body, is influenced by a variety of factors. Understanding each of the components that contribute to your body
Many aspects contribute to body image, including the environment in image is an important step towards making a difference in how you see
which we are immersed in as well as our biological makeup and genetic and feel about yourself.
predisposition. Understanding how each of these areas impact how we
feel about our body is important to understanding how we can create and Beauty is in the Mind of the Beholder
build a positive body image. You are better off being good-looking. At all ages and in all walks of life,
attractive people are judged more favorably, treated better, and cut
Cultural Traditions Can Help or Hurt slacker. Mothers give more affection to attractive babies. Teachers
The culture in which we are surrounded by has a significant impact on favor more attractive students and judge them as smarter. Attractive
how we feel about ourselves and the way we think about our body. Many adults get paid more for their work and have better success in dating
cultural traditions also contribute to body image and can influence either and mating. And juries are less likely to find attractive people guilty and
negative or positive body image and self-esteem. Depending on the recommend lighter punishments when they do.
culture and overall emphasis of traditions involved, a person may find
FACTORS IN PERSONAL ATTRACTIVENESS ‘Your Symmetry Lights Up the Room’
the way you dress, the way you act, the way you carry yourself, even
things that are hard or impossible to change, like social status and wealth, No two faces are alike, and no two halves of a face are alike. Countless small
race, and body size and shape. variables make faces somewhat asymmetrical – a slightly wider jaw on one side,
But the first thing we notice when we meet someone is their face. one eye a fraction of an inch lower than the other, a cheekbone that sticks out just
Brain is beauty detector a wee bit more, a dimple on one cheek, etc. Some asymmetries (called directional
When participants in a recent study were presented with attractive and asymmetries) are common across the population – for example, the left side of
unattractive faces for only 13 milliseconds, they were able to judge the most people’s faces is slightly larger than the right. But many asymmetries, called
faces’ attractiveness accurately (that is, in accordance with fluctuating asymmetries, arise when one’s unfolding genetic program is perturbed
experimenters’ ratings), even though they were not consciously aware of during development, for instance by parasites or other environmental challenges.
the stimuli and felt like they were just guessing (Olson & Marshuetz, The slings and arrows of life’s fortunes can literally knock our faces off of kilter,
2005). just like a punch to the nose. A symmetrical face, like a particularly masculine or
feminine one, is a sign of having stood up better to life’s figurative schoolyard
Truth in Beauty beatings.
stereotype that “beautiful is good” does hold. Numerous studies have found that when men and women are asked to compare
faces really are windows onto certain fundamental and important versions of faces that are more versus less symmetrical, the symmetrical ones
characteristics indicative of a person’s quality as a romantic partner and garner significantly higher ratings of attractiveness, dominance, sexiness, and
as a mate — qualities of health and genes, and even character. health, and are perceived to be more desirable as potential mates (Rhodes, Proffitt,
Grady, & Sumich, 1998; Shackelford & Larsen, 1997). So as with
Our faces are sculpted by our hormones. These sex-typical facial
masculine/feminine features, the appeal of symmetry makes perfect sense to
features of adult men and women reflect the ratio of testosterone to
evolutionary psychologists. In a beautiful face, we are really seeing the artistry of
estrogen or estrogen to testosterone, respectively, acting on the
good genes. People prefer symmetrical faces even when they can’t actually
individual during development. We are programmed to be drawn to
perceive the symmetry – that is, when only face halves are presented. It may be
strong indicators of maleness (for women) and femaleness (for men)
that symmetry covaries with other desirable characteristics that reflect the same
partly because they reflect an individual’s health (Fink & Penton-Voak,
genetic endowment and overall health (Penton-Voak et al., 2001).
2002). The reason hormones equate to health is somewhat
counterintuitive. High levels of sex hormones during puberty
suppress the immune system, raising vulnerability to disease and It may not be all that surprising that we’d rather mate with a symmetrical Greek
infection. It sounds like a bad thing. But when a person with a god or goddess than with someone who stepped out of a Picasso painting. Less
particularly “male” or “female” face makes it to adulthood with all his or obvious is that a pretty or handsome face is also generally one that is,
her health intact, it means that the person has withstood the potentially well, average. When presented with individual faces and a composite of those
debilitating influence of those high hormones. In other words, it signifies individual faces, participants will judge the composite as more attractive than the
a more robust constitution. individual, more distinctive faces. And the more faces that contribute to the
composite, the more attractive it becomes (Langlois & Roggman, 1990). The most
attractive faces appear to be those whose features are closest to the average in the A group of University of Mexico psychologists have studied women’s shifting
population—that is, more prototypical. preferences for symmetrical men. They have found that this preference (which
women can not only see, but even smell in tee-shirts slept in by symmetrical men)
Averageness, like symmetry, reflects a favorable genetic endowment. Those with increases dramatically around the time of ovulation, when a woman is most fertile
average features are less likely to be carrying harmful mutations. Additionally, and the chance of conception is highest (Gangestad, Thornhill, & Garver-Apgar,
averageness reflects greater heterozygosity — having both a dominant and a 2005). So does a woman’s preference for more masculine-looking men. But this
recessive allele for given traits, rather than two dominant or two recessive alleles preference wanes during other times of the month. Again, evolutionary
(an advantage that symmetry also reflects). Heterozygosity confers relatively psychology provides a ready explanation.
greater resistance to pathogens, in many cases, and thus, along with all the other
indicators of resilience, we may be programmed to seek it out through its subtle Humans, like many other species, are socially monogamous but not necessarily
but telltale signs. sexually monogamous. When sex might result in getting pregnant, it’s health and
fertility that are particularly desirable in a mate. But good genes in the sense of
However, it has also been argued that there may be some much simpler cognitive physical health is not the same as good genes in the sense of character, and what
reasons for the preference for averages. Besides faces, people show a preference makes a good sperm donor may not make the best long-term, nurturing, helpful
for average-looking dogs, average-looking birds, and average-looking watches life partner. The flip side of high testosterone is an increased tendency toward
(Halberstadt & Rhodes, 2000). Prototypes are more familiar-looking than less aggression and antisocial behavior, a tendency to compete rather than help. Thus a
typical examples of a given class of objects, be it the face of a potential mate or male with less testosterone, indicated by less masculine features, may invest more
the face of a timepiece, and they are easier to process. Easy on the eyes = easy on in caring for offspring (whether or not he’s the biological father) and so may be
the brain. better to have around for the long term.
Men and women both show the above preferences when it comes to faces, but in beautiful women are disruptive of men’s reason, even causing them to go to war.
general men’s preferences tend to be more pronounced (Rhodes et al., 1998). We now know that there’s truth to the idea that men make worse decisions when
Males may place greater importance on physical beauty when it comes to mate exposed to female beauty, and we even are beginning to understand the neural
choice, while females also attend to characteristics like power and status. But a basis. A pair of McMaster University researchers found that looking at
number of factors contribute to how much — and when — male face photographs of attractive women (but not unattractive women) caused a
characteristics matter to women. significant increase in delay discounting in men — that is, choosing a smaller
immediate reward over a larger delayed one (Wilson & Daly, 2004). It’s the same
One factor is a woman’s own attractiveness: Preference for masculine and tendency found to a high degree in addicts and others with impaired self-control.
symmetrical features has been shown to be higher for women who regard Interestingly, viewing attractive men did not influence women’s decisions.
themselves as more attractive (Little, Burt, Penton-Voak, & Perrett, 2001).
Another is time of the month: The degree of women’s preferences for different The reason-unseating effect of a beautiful face partly involves the amygdala.
attractive qualities fluctuates strikingly across the ovulatory cycle. Activation of the amygdala, which detects the value of social stimuli, has been
associated with greater discounting of all kinds of future rewards, and sure
enough, this brain area shows much stronger activation to attractive faces than to And then there are the emotions we project through our faces. Not surprising,
more ho-hum ones. (It is actually a U-shaped relationship; the amygdala is also positive emotions increase attractiveness. We are drawn to those who smile, for
highly activated by unattractive faces; Winston, O’Doherty, Kilner, Perrett, & example. As when they wore makeup, women who smiled at men on entering a
Dolan, 2007.) bar were more likely to be approached and were judged more favorably (Gueguen,
2008a). Even a smile perceived only in the periphery of one’s vision will be seen
In both men and women, attractive faces cause greater activation in several other as more attractive than a face with a neutral expression (Bohrn, Carbon, &
brain areas involved in processing of rewards. These include the nucleus Hutzler, 2010). And attractive faces that smile produce even more activity in the
accumbens, which also activates in response to rewarding stimuli like money; the orbitofrontal cortex than do attractive faces wearing neutral expressions
medial prefrontal cortex; and the anterior cingulate cortex, which may be involved (O’Doherty et al., 2003).
in shaping future behavior from learning reward outcomes. In men (but not in
women), the orbitofrontal cortex, an area that evaluates the reward value of So here’s the timeless message of psychological science: Be beautiful—or, as
current behaviors, also activates in response to attractive female faces (Cloutier, beautiful as you can. Smile and sleep and do whatever else you can do to make
Heatherton, Whalen, & Kelley, 2008). your face a reward. Among its other social benefits, attractiveness actually invites
people to learn what you are made of, in other respects than just genetic fitness.
Beautify Yourself According to a new study at the University of British Columbia (Lorenzo,
Biesanz, & Human, 2010), attractive people are actually judged more accurately
Beauty is unfair. Not everyone can be born with great genes. Not everyone can —at least, closer to a subject’s own self-assessments—than are the less attractive,
be born symmetrical. Not everyone can be born enticingly, well, average. But because it draws others to go beyond the initial impression. “People do judge a
obviously there are many factors contributing to attractiveness that are potentially book by its cover,” the researchers write, “but a beautiful cover prompts a closer
under our control. reading.” œ
For women, makeup does have a strong effect. In one study, women wearing
makeup were approached more, and approached faster, by men at a bar than they
were on nights without makeup (Gueguen, 2008b). Effect sizes on beauty
judgments for makeup have been found to be as high as those for the facial
structural features mentioned earlier (Osborn, 2006).