Job Architecture Competency Framework
Job Architecture Competency Framework
Linda M. Ginac
President and CEO of TalentGuard
20+ years experience leading companies and
individuals through career transformations
https://www.linkedin.com/in/lindaginac/
Discussion Points
2
Copyright © 2020 TalentGuard, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Talent Ecosystem
4
Copyright © 2020 TalentGuard, Inc. All rights reserved. Source: Adapted from Willis Towers Watson: Transform the Present, Redefine the Future. Job Leveling Solutions, 2016.
Global growth, changing business environments,
and digital transformation require companies to
redesign structures, workflow, and talent
strategies around best-practices to achieve an
inclusive talent ecosystem.
Do I have a choice between a How many levels are there in Where else can I navigate in What are the role expectations?
technical career or a the career ladder? this company? What other
management career at some functions exist?
point?
Update Inconsistent
Outdated Job Haphazard
Random Job Title and Localized Legal
Data & Job
Salary Bands Capabilities Infrastructure Defensibility
Structure Governance
and Grades Catalog
• Bolster career growth • Build capability and capacity to • Drive speed-to-value with with HR
opportunities and improved skills deliver on business strategies tech using on a common platform
to improve employee experience
• Provides details on an employee’s scope of • Offers visibility into talent needed to drive
responsibility and organizational impact future success • Creates a common language to describe
• Provides employees with tools and data to • Offers a consistent methodology to help jobs, career paths, job requirements and
manage their career managers explain roles, levels, etc. expectations across the globe
• Enables better career conversations • Helps managers offer advice on career • Foundation to support linkages to
aspirations and more organizational and job family competencies
• Reduced ambiguity on job expectations
and clarifies accountability • Provides clarity about what constitutes a • Evaluate total reward programs for market
“promotion,” including movement to a new competitiveness
• Establishes a foundation for mapping
career paths up, down and across the level, and growth within a level • Ensures internal equity/diversity goals
organization • Supports savings due to consolidation,
grade inflation and inappropriate
promotions
Career
Architecture
10
Copyright © 2020 TalentGuard, Inc. All rights reserved. Source: Adapted Deloitte - Job Architecture. Building a Foundation for Talent Programs, 2017
Where Do You Stand on the Career Architecture Maturity Curve?
A blueprint and adaptive data model upon which to build your talent strategy and experiences
Consulting &
Data
Level 3 Consistent Language of Work IBM
Approach to job documentation developed ∙ Job documentation created ∙ Strategy for job content storage Deloitte
developed ∙ Compliance assessment conducted ∙ Governance process updated ∙ Functional / Technical
competencies developed
11
Copyright © 2020 TalentGuard, Inc. All rights reserved. Source: Deloitte - Job Architecture. Building a Foundation for Talent Programs,
2017
Leveling Awareness
Level 1
Illustrative
Output
Source: Willis Towers Watson: Transform the Present, Redefine the Future. Job Leveling Solutions, 2016.
Jobs organized by function and family ∙ Number of levels identified ∙ Leveling criteria developed ∙ Jobs mapped to
12 levels
Copyright © 2020 TalentGuard, Inc. All rights reserved.
Align jobs and job grades across business units and geographies while ensuring sensitivity to local market conditions
Job and Leveling Identity
Level 2
Illustrative
Output
Finance
Marketing
Informatio
n
Technolog
y
Source: Willis Towers Watson: Transform the Present, Redefine the Future. Job Leveling Solutions, 2016.
Jobs reviewed for consolidation opportunities ∙ Job title nomenclature and consistent classification approach through competency matrix ∙ Jobs organized into career progressions /
path ∙ Governance process identified
Copyright © 2020 TalentGuard, Inc. All rights reserved. Structure to harmonize job title and career bands and across the organization
13
Consistent Language of Work
Job Responsibility 3 Managing the organization's tax filing and governmental reporting activities.
P5 Master VP Finance
Managing the distribution of tasks to junior staff as appropriate to their
Job Responsibility 4
development and to the satisfaction of the needs of the organization.
P4 Specialist Director Finance
Level 3
Illustrative
Output
Getting Org Strategy • Reflects strategy and culture
Started Core & • Defines expectations at each level
Leadership • Enables a leadership pipeline
Job Strategy
Job Responsibility 3 Managing the organization's tax filing and governmental reporting activities.
Managing the distribution of tasks to junior staff as appropriate to their
Job Responsibility 4
development and to the satisfaction of the needs of the organization.
Competency Code Core and Leadership Competencies Proficiency Level
Capability Data I0700 Decision Making & Critical Thinking 3 – Extensive experience
I1010 Business Analytics 2 – Working experience
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Manual Budget Too Too Many Lack of
Process Constraints Difficult Jobs Executive
Support
Source: IBM Corporation: Competencies,
Compensation and Technology Luncheon, 2012
Length of Career Architecture Projects
6-12 months Less than 6 months and mining data for patterns that lead to
25%
new employee and talent discoveries.
7%
Source: Deloitte: Analysis and survey submissions / verifications still in process. Preliminary results
as of May 2017 from Deloitte Consulting’s 2017 Global Job Architecture Practices Survey.
Note: Total does not equal 100% due to rounding.
18%
46%
PowerPoint
Career
Architecture Software
Employee Control
Assessment or Input
Admin Control
definition? Skills
Employees add any skill
Employees add any skill regardless of job role with no
Set target benchmarks at the Set expectations of what good
regardless of job role with expectation of performance
proficiency level to indicate looks like in the role. (Merit badge)
ability to assess
minimum performance and
behavioral expectations.
5 of 15
Disadvantages
• No restriction the type of skills
employees can add
Performance Mana. Sales (Saas)
• More work for employees to
Team Building Pricing
build profiles
• Skill tags does not produce
Coaching Adaptability
meaningful outcomes
• Little credibility and evidence on
more
whether an employee is truly
skilled in the areas tagged
• Typically not merit based so the
focus and quality on the tags or
assessment are very low
Disadvantages
• Requires some setup to match
companies existing titles to industry
job taxonomy
• Ongoing maintenance and governance
Copyright © 2020 TalentGuard, Inc. All rights reserved.
AI-Assisted Intelligent Career Architecture
Frictionless
Experience
Our platform is purpose-built to make HR more effective at their jobs. By providing off-the-shelf models for many common industry use cases and automating many of the
manual processes involved in traditional organizational development tasks, TalentGuard allows HR to focus on the impactful problems that drive real value for employees, 26
managers and organizations.
Copyright © 2020 TalentGuard, Inc. All rights reserved.
27
Copyright © 2020 TalentGuard, Inc. All rights reserved.
Copyright © 2020 TalentGuard, Inc. All rights reserved.
AI-Assisted Talent Transformation Playbook
Intelligent
Talent
Career
Workflow
Architecture
1 2
Integrated
Talent
Technology
Intelligence
Platform
4 3
30
Copyright © 2020 TalentGuard, Inc. All rights reserved.
Source: Adapted from Willis Towers Watson: Transform the Present, Redefine the Future. Job Leveling Solutions, 2016.
How Do I Get Going?
Choose an Initial AI Launch Approach for a Quick Win
HR Data • Company provides Job Title list • Company provides Job Role Data • Users upload resume or Linked-in Profile
Model • AI for Job Title Reconciliation and • AI for Reconciliation and Normalization • AI for Reconciliation of Skills tagged and
Normalization of Job Title, Job Description and Skills collected
• Use Best Fit Job Role in our Framework • SME Set Proficiencies • No progressions to start unless configured,
• Automatic Build of Progressions based on • Automatic Build of Progressions based rely on role match based on similar skills
Skills and more on Skills and more
Timeframe • 1-3 Months • 2-6 Months • 3-12 Months to build a fully rationalized skill
taxonomy
Governance • Automatically adapt it overtime using AI, • Automatically adapt it overtime • Automatically adapt skill taxonomy overtime
tools and feedback loop using AI, tools and feedback loop using AI
• Use AI to infer job role titles based on similar
skills added in assessment or profile and others
Copyright © 2020 TalentGuard, Inc. All rights reserved.
Intelligent Role Rationalizer (SME Rationalization)
Natural Language
Processing
Progression Pruning
• Eliminate paths never travelled
• What is the role of humans in the workflow that shape both the user
Monitor targeted Adjust career levels experience and costs?
development and and compensation
growth
Intelligent Assessment
Intelligent Assessment
Intelligent Assessment
Intelligent Assessment
Generate automatic
recommendations of career
paths based on
And more…
4 Talent Intelligence
4 Talent Intelligence
DIVERSITY
4 Talent Intelligence
DIVERSITY
512.943.6800
talentguard.com