1

HOMICIDE by Shooting

KENNIE POCHE y GONBO

(VICTIM)
 2

CONTENTS

A- Request Letter for Forensic Examination

B- Firearm Examination Report
C- Comparison Chart
D- Judicial Affidavit
E- Firearm Examiner’s Profile

Enclosed:

Specimen #1(spent shell marked “AT-1”) with

evidence tag and “chain of custody” receipt.
Specimen #2 (spent shell marked “AT-2”) with
evidence tag and “chain of custody” receipt.
 3

Republic of the Philippines

NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
BATANGAS PROVINCIAL CRIME LABORATORY OFFICE
President Jose P. Laurel Highway, Camp Malvar, Batangas
043-980-0400

MEMORANDUM

FOR : ERWIN D. SMITH

Batangas Provincial Crime Laboratory Office
(Attn: Chief, Fingerprint Identification Section)

FROM : LEVI D. ACKERMAN

Chief of Police

SUBJECT : REQUEST FOR FINGERPRINT EXAMINATION

DATE : November 6, 2023

1. Request to conduct ballistic examination on the specimens described below to

determine whether they were discharged from the same firearm.

a. NATURE OF THE CASE: Shooting Incident

b. VICTIM : Kennie Poche y Gonbo (Deceased)

c.

d. SUSPECT : Unknown

e. DATE AND TIME : On or about 3:00 pm in the afternoon on

November 6, 2023
f. Place of occurrence : Along Gonbo’s residence Barangay Alanginan
Batanagas City
2. Further request to furnish a copy of the result of the examination for our
reference and appropriate action.

a. Two (2) Fired cartridge marked “AT-1” and “AT-2”

3. Further request to furnish a copy the result of the examination for our
reference and appropriate action

Signed by:

PCMS JUNNIE B. OY
Investigator-on-Case
 4

Republic of the Philippines

Department of interior and local government
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
BATANGAS PROVINCIAL CRIME LABORATORY OFFICE
President Jose P. Laurel Highway, Camp Malvar, Batangas

FIREARMS IDENTIFICATION REPORT NO PRO-COR-006-2023

CASE: Alleged Homicide by Shooting

SUSPECT: EREN YEAGER y TITAN
VICTIM: KENNIE POCHE y GONBO

TIME & DATE RECEIVED: 9:15 AM: 07 NOVEMBER 2023

REQUESTING PARTY/UNI: PCMS JUNNIE B. OY
Investigator-on-Case, BPPO

SPECIMENS SUBMITTED:
1 One (1) cartridge case marked "AT-1'’ recovered at the crime scene.
2. One (1) cartridge case marked 'AT-2" was recovered at the crime
scene.

PURPOSES OF LABORATORY EXAMINATION:

 Determine whether the two specimens marked "AT-1” and “AT-2"
respectively were discharged from the same firearm.

FINDINGS:
1. Preliminary examination and microscopic examination revealed that
specimens marked "AT-1" and "AT-2" bear with the same firing pin marks
(See comparison chart attached with this report).

CONCLUSION:
The three specimens, cartridge cases marked "AT-1" and "AT-2" respectively,
were ejected by two different firearms.

REMARKS:
1. Time and date completed-10:00 AM, 08 November 2023.
2. The two specimens were released to PCMS JUNNIE B. OY for
safekeeping 2023 on 08 November.
3. A search for suspected two fired bullets, most probably of caliber .45
must be done to have a basis for determining the firearms where these
specimens were ejected.

EXAMINED BY:

PEMS ALDWIN EBENEZER M. HERJAS

Fingerprint Examiner

APPROVED:

PMAJ LEVI D. ACKERMAN

Chief Fingerprint Examiner

NOTED:

PLTCOL ERWIN D. SMITH

 5

Chief BCPT Republic of the Philippines

REGIONAL TRIAL COURT
BRANCH 1,
BATANGAS CITY

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES CRIM CASES NO. A26- 15 - 2023

Plaintiff,
- versus - FOR: Robbery with Homicide

EREN T. YAEGER
Accused.
x---------------------------------------------------x

JUDICIAL AFFIDAVIT

This Judicial Affidavit of Aldwin Ebenezer M. Herjas, legal age, married, and
with address at , BATANGAS City; is executed to serve as his direct testimony in the
instant case. This Judicial Affidavit is offered to prove:

(1) all of the claims about the case of robbery with homicide.
(2) Including all of the ANNEXES that are attached to it, which he humbly
asks to be appropriately labeled as EXHIBITS in this instance; and
(3) everything pertinent thereto, with the option to submit further exhibits
as the current case is being heard.

QUESTIONS were propounded by Prosecutor, Atty. Girardu Magtaloao

in English, which the affiant fully speaks and understands.

“Q1”: What is your current profession?

“A”: I am a Questioned Document examiner of the Police Crime Laboratory
Batangas City Sir!

Q2: Where did you go for academic attainment and further criminalistics training?
A: I finished my criminology course in Batangas State University – The National
Engineering University in Nasugbuand have undergone training in Question
Document examination in NATIONAL FORENSIC SCIENCE TRAINING
INSTITUTE, at CALAMBA, LAGUNA and I also have undergone related training
abroad in Questioned Documents examination sir.

Q3: How long have you been practicing your profession?

A: I had 11 years of practicing my profession sir.

Q4: What are the principal functions and duties of your position?
A: My principal function and duty to examine Questioned Documents assigned to
me in the Crime Laboratory sir!

Q5: Have you examined several Questioned Documents

evidencebefore?
A: Yes sir.

Q6: Have you been qualified to testify as expert witnessin the past?
A: Yes sir.

Q7: Where were you assigned on April 07, 2023?

A: I was assigned at the QD- Division of the BATANGAS PROVINCIAL POLICE
CRIME LABORATORY sir.

Q8: What position did you hold then?

A: Questioned Documents examiner sir
 6

Q9: I have here technical Report dated November 7, 2023 from the the
BATANGAS PROVINCIAL POLICE CRIME LABORATORY was this one of
those Technical Reports you have prepared?
A: Yes sir.

Q10: If I show you such a document, will you be able to identify it?
A: Yes sir.

Q11:I am showing to you the document entitled Technica

l Questioned Documents Report No. AID – 003 –
2 0 2 3 i s t h i s familiar to you?
A: Yes sir.

Q12:At the bottom right hand side of the document, there appears a
signature above the typewritten name, ALDWIN EBENEZER M.
HERJAS, whose signature is it?
A: My signature sir.

Q13: Below your typewritten name and signature, appears the

signature above the typewritten name, LEVI D. ACKERMAN whose name
and signature, is it?
A : T h e s i g n a t u r e o f LEVI D. ACKERMAN. S i r .

Q14: How did you know it was the signature of LEVI D. ACKERMAN?
A: It was signed in my presence sir, and I personally witnessed him sign the
document.

Q15: What is your relation to him?

A: he is my Chief in the FINGERPRINT EXAMINATION division sir,

Q16: What is the purpose of the document you prepared?

A: It serves as a technical report containing my findings and conclusion on the
examination and comparison that I have conducted on the specimen submitted in
our office sir.

Q17: May you please explain to the court your findings as it

a p p e a r s i n t h a t report?
A: Physical examination and comparison of the specimen QUESTIONED
DOCUMENT and STANDARD SPECIMEN marked “A “revealed that it is the
same DOCUMENT with the same characteristics executedby one and the same
person or individual sir.

Q18: What are your bases for these findings, briefly explain the
principles and procedures arriving at such findings?
A:.The findings was based on the results of the examination and comparison that was
conducted in the crime laboratory. To arrive at those findings, preliminary examination and
microscopic examination revealed that specimens marked "AT-1" and "AT-2"
bear different firing pin marks (See comparison chart attached with this
report).Such verified Documents were compared and submitted for another comparison in
the microscope comparator to determine accuracy hence the basis of my findings sir.

Q19: Based on the examination result, what is now your conclusion in

relation to the instant case?

A: The FIREARMS IDENTIFICATION REPORT submitted was examined and

was found to be the same with the standard specimen submitted and I conclude
that both documents were executed by one and the same person and in this
case the suspect sir.

Q 2 0 : H o w s u r e are you in your conclusions?

A: Very sure sir.
 7

In witness thereof, I have hereunto set my hand this 07th day of November
2023 in the City of CEBU, Philippines.

ALDWIN EBENEZER M. HERJAS

Affiant

LEVI D. ACKERMAN
Ph.D.CRIM
PNP CRIME
LABORATORY
REGIONAL OFFICE -7
CEBU CITY PHILIPINES

SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me this 08th day of November

2023 in Batangas City with the Affiant exhibiting to me her Identification Card No.
15192600 issued on November 10, 2023 by the Philippine Regulation
Commission.

ATTY. JUAN ALBERTO G. GAMEZ

NOTARY PUBLIC
Doc. No. 12
Page No. 34
Book No. 135
Series of 2023

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES

PHILIPPINE CRIMINALISTICS SOCIETY, INC.
High Country Inn Building Naguilian Road, Baquio City

REPORT NO. : 01

CASE NO. :Robbery with Homicide

SUSPECTS ; Eren T. Yaeger

VICTIMS ; Kennie G. Poche

DATE AND TIME RECEIVED ; 0100hrs

REQUESTING PARTY : Relative of the victim

SPECIMEN SUBMITTED

 Driver’s license
 Promissory note
 8

PURPOSE OF LABORATORY EXAMINATION;

TO determine the identity of a person who was one the prime suspects of the
crime of ROBBERY with HOMICIDE took place at the said time and date.

Findings;
The signature found at the driver’s license of the suspect was examined as
verified to be the same signatures obtained from the promissory note being
treated as Standard Specimen gathered by the investigator were later on found
to be the same signature of the accused.

Conclusion;
It was concluded that the suspect MR EfrenPuloyapoy was the one who shot the
victim dead prior to his escape. Concluded further, that upon thorough
investigation and examination conducted the above mentionedcase hereby
considered solved and closed.

REMARKS:
Recommended for filling.
TIME AND DATE COMLETED;
0300HRS/ 04-08-14
Approved by;
examined by;

Noted by;
 9

Republic of the Philippines

Department of Interior and Local Government
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
BATANGAS PROVINCIAL CRIME LABORATORY OFFICE
President Jose P. Laurel Highway, Camp Malvar, Batangas

FIREARMS EXAMINER’S PROFILE

A. NAME:
HERJAS ALDWIN EBENEZER M.
(LASTNAME) (FIRST NAME) (MIDDLE NAME)

B. RANK: POLICE EXECUTIVE MASTER SERGEANT SERIAL NUMBER:

261519

C. BIRTH DATE AND PLACE: _ 19 JULY 1989/CALATAGAN, BATANGAS

D. PERSONAL INFORMATION:
Nickname(s): Aleb
Civil Status: MARRIED Citizenship: Filipino
Religion: Catholic Blood Type: O+
Height (cms): 172 cm Weight (kgs): 69 Kgs
Head Size (cms): 50 cm Foot Size (cms):25 cm
Waist Size (cms): 79 cm Body Build: Masculine
Hair Color: Black Skin Color: Fair Complexion
Eye Color: Black Distinct Feature: N/A
Home Address: Sitio Carbonan, Balitoc, Permanent Address: Sitio
Calatagan, Batangas Carbonan, Balitoc, Calatagan,
Batangas
E-mail Address: Contact Number(s): 0938-350-8591
[email protected]
PAG-IBIG Number: 1822-112-334 Phil Health Number: 0994-3556-
5567
Tax Identification Number (TIN): 123- Driver’s License Number: A05-67-
820- 034566
Dependents: Entry will include (1) Name; (2) Relationship; (3) Birth date
(1) (2) (3)
HERJAS ALDWIN WIFE 15 JULY 1989
EBENEZER M

E. EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
1. Civilian: Entry shall be from Present to Past
a. Academic:
COURSE NAME OF PERIOD STANDING /
SCHOOL/INSTITUTION AND (From – To) HONORS /
LOCATION REMARKS
Post Graduate De La Salle University- 2019-2022 Graduated
Doctor of Philosophy in Dasmarinas
Criminology
Post Graduate Universidad De Manila , Manila 2016-2018 Graduated
Master of Science in City
Criminology
Tertiary Education Cavite State University, Brgy. 2006-2010 Graduated
BS-CRIMINOLOGY Bancod, Indang, Cavite
Secondary Education Isabela National High School, 2002-2006 Graduated
Ilagan Isabela
Primary Education Upi Elementary School, Upi 1996-2002 Graduated
Gamu Isabela
c. Others Trainings (Seminars/Workshops):
 10

COURSE NAME OF PERIOD OF STANDING /

SCHOOL/INSTITUTION AND ATTENDAN HONORS /
LOCATION CE REMARKS
(From – To)
Army Reserved Cavite State University, Indang, 2006-2007 Completed
Officer Course Cavite

2. Service Related: Entry shall be from Present to Past.

a. Philippine National Police

COURSE Authority NAME OF PERIOD OF STANDING /
(Order) SCHOOL/INSTITUTI ATTENDANC HONORS /
ON AND E REMARKS
LOCATION (From – To)
PNP Basic SO Nr 034 dtd NATIONAL 09 December 26 out of 39
Officer 08 December FORENSIC 2014-08 students
Course 2015 SCIENCE December
CL 16-2012 TRAINING 2015
INSTITUTE, at
CALAMBA,
LAGUNA

a.1. Others: Courses/Seminars: (Local)

COURSE/ NAME OF PERIOD OF STANDING /
SEMINARS SCHOOL/INSTITUTION AND ATTENDANCE HONORS /
LOCATION (From – To) REMARKS
Firearms Examiners Philippine Criminalistics May 01-09, 2023 5 out of 50
Training Course Society, Incorporated, Baguio students
City, Philippines

Investigation Officer School for Investigation and 01 October 2021-01 20 out of 56

Basic Course Detective Development March 2023 students
(IOBC) DIDM Anne, PNPTS, Camp
BGen Rafael T Crame
Quezon,City
Annual General HCGIAS, CGBF, Muelle de la 16-18 January 2020 Attended
Inspection (AGI) Industria, Farola Compound
Seminar/Workshop Binondo, Manila
Procedure on AG New World Manila Bay 10 August 2019 Attended
Warrantless Arrest, Hotel 1588 Pedro Gil Corner
Booking and M.H. Del Pilar, Manila 1004
Commitment of
Arrested
Persons/Suspects
Seminar
Strategic Gender PPA-Multi Purpose Hall, 19-20 June 2019 Attended
and Development Bonifacio Drive, Port Area,
(GAD) Planning and Manila
Budget Seminar
and Orientation on
Gender Sensitivity
Training
Symposium on RA PNPETC, Farola Compound 11 December 2018 Attended
9262, RA 8353 and Binondo, Manila
RA 7877
PNP-Junior Great Seas Mariners Training 31 July 2017 to Attended
Management Level & Assessment Center, Inc., August 18 2018
Officers Course Sampaloc Manila,City
Petty Cash Fund H2o Hotel , Luneta , Manila 08 – 09 March 2017 Attended
Gender HPCG Function Hall 05-06 December Attended
Mainstreaming 2016
 11

GSIS Basic Non-life GSIS Financial Center, Pasay 30 September 2016 Attended
Insurance Seminar City
for the PNP
Orientation on PPA ,GAD Center, Bonifacio 27 July 2016 Attended
Accessibility and Drive, Port Area, Manila
Sensitivity

a.2. Others: Courses/Seminars: (Foreign)

NAME OF PERIOD OF STANDING /
COURSE/SEMINARS SCHOOL/INSTITUTION ATTENDANCE HONORS /
AND LOCATION (From – To) REMARKS
Service Police Defence Force School of 02 September-20 Completed
Investigator Course Policing, New South October 2018
Wales, Australia

F. APPOINTMENTS, PROMOTIONS AND REDUCTIONS: Entry shall be

from Present to Past
DESCRIPTION EFFECTIVE DATE AUTHORITY
PEMS 18 March 2019 Ptp GO #406 NHQ-PCG dtd 15 Oct 2019
PSSGT 18 March 2017 Ptp SO # 72 HPCG dtd 19 Apr 2017
PCPL 08 December 2015 Ptp 11 SO #224 HPCG dtd 16 Dec 2015
PATROLMAN 19 December 2012 Ptp 3 SO #122 HPCG dtd 04 Dec 2012

G. AWARDS AND RECOGNITIONS:

1. Philippine National Police
a. Awards and Decorations: Entry shall be in order of merit of the
Awards from Highest down to Lowest
Type of Award(s) Authority
Philippine National Police Commendation HCGIG-IAS GO# 06 dated 04 March 2021
Medal and Ribbon
Philippine National Police Outstanding NHQ-PCG GO#13 dated 10 June 2020
Achievement Medal and Ribbon
Philippine National Police Merit Medal and HCGIAS GO# 21 dated 06 November 2019
Ribbon
Philippine National Police Merit Medal and HCGIAS GO# 08 dated 06 December 2018
Ribbon
Philippine National Police Civic Action Medal HPCG GO# 05 dated 24 July 2017
and Ribbon
Philippine National Police Commendation CGIAS/Admin GO# 07 dated 02 May 2016
Medal and Ribbon

H. CIVIL SERVICE ELIGIBILITY/LICENSURE: Registered Criminologist

2010, License Professional
Teacher 2022

I HEREBY CERTIFY that the aforementioned entries / information are true

and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief:

PEMS HERJAS ALDWIN EBENEZER M.

Fingerprint Identification Examine
 12

Republic of the Philippines

Department of interior and local government
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
BATANGAS PROVINCIAL CRIME LABORATORY OFFICE
President Jose P. Laurel Highway, Camp Malvar, Batangas

CHAIN OF CUSTODY FORM

DELIVERED BY RECEIVED BY DATE TIME ITEM REMARKS

MM/
DD/YY

PCPL CONG T. PCMS JUNNIE B. TWO (2) For

IBEY OY 10/06/23 9:00PM CARTRIDGE Examination
Evidence Collector IOC-Duty Officer CASES
PCMS JUNNIE B. PEMS ALDWIN
OY EBENEZER M. TWO (2)
IOC-Duty Officer HERJAS 10/07/23 9:15AM CARTRIDGE For
Fingerprint Examiner CASES Examination
PEMS ALDWIN TWO (2)
EBENEZER M. NUP Reiner T. 10/08/23 11:00AM CARTRIDGE For
HERJAS Braun CASES Safekeeping
Fingerprint Evidence Custodian
Examiner
NUP Reiner T. PEMS ALDWIN TWO (2)
Braun EBENEZER M. CARTRIDGE For Court
Evidence Cudtodian HERJAS 10/12/23 10:00 AM CASES Presentation
Fingerprint Examiner
NUP Reiner T. PEMS ALDWIN TWO (2)
Braun EBENEZER M. 10/12/23 2:00PM CARTRIDGE For
Evidence Custodian HERJAS CASES Safekeeping
Fingerprint Examiner
 13

Republic of the Philippines

Department of interior and local government
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
BATANGAS PROVINCIAL CRIME LABORATORY OFFICE
President Jose P. Laurel Highway, Camp Malvar, Batangas

MEMORANDUM

FOR : PCOL. KEVIN M GARCIA

Provincial Director
Batangas Police Provincial Office
President Jose P. Laurel St. Batangas City

FROM : PLTCOL ERWIN D. SMITH

Chief of Police
Batangas City Police Station

SUBJECT : Spot Report Re-Shooting Incident

DATE : September 14, 2021

1. On November 6, 2023, at about 8:30 p.m. BCPS received a phone call

regarding a shooting incident that transpired at Gonbo’s residence’ in
Barangay Alanginan, Batangas City, wherein victim Kennie G. Poche, 29
years old, married, businessman, and a resident of Brgy. Alanginan,
Batangas City, was seen lifeless inside the living room by his house helper
Mathilda G. Galdoc, 24 years old, single, and a resident of Brgy.
Alangilan, Batangas City.

2. The victim sustained (2) gunshot wounds in the hand and a blanket
wrapped around his head. The victim was pronounced dead on the spot.
According to Mathilda, Mr. Kennie was having a meeting over the phone
and seemed worried around 4:00 p.m. on November 6, 2023. Ms.
Mathilda left at the victim’s residence at 5:00 p.m. after her work duties.

3. The victim is now in the Barangas Medical Center, Batangas City for an
autopsy. Two (2) caliber .45 specimen of Fired Cartridge was recovered at
the crime scene and are now under the custody of this station for further
investigation.

4. The motive of the incident is undetermined, and the case is still under
investigation.

5. Progress report will follow.

Signed By:

PLTCOL ERWIN D. SMITH

Chief of Police
 14

BALISTIC COMPARISON CHART

FIREARMS ID REPORT NO. PRO-COR-006-2023

SPECIMEN 1 SPECIMEN 2

Comparison image of 2 cartridge cases (marked

AT-1 and AT-2) when examined through the comparison microscope using
8X magnification showing different firing pin marks at the primer cup.

EXAMINED BY:

PEMS ALDWIN EBENEZER M. HERJAS

Fingerprint Examiner

APPROVED:

PMAJ LEVI D. ACKERMAN

Chief Fingerprint Examiner

NOTED:

PLTCOL ERWIN D. SMITH

Chief BCPT Republic of the Philippines