18.

01 Calculus Jason Starr

Fall 2005

Lecture 19. October 28, 2005

Homework. Problem Set 5 Part I: (d) and (e); Part II: Problems 2 and 3.
Practice Problems. Course Reader: 4A­1, 4A­3, 4B­1, 4B­3, 4B­6.
1. Differentials revisited. In a typical applied integration problem, the main difficulty is finding
the integrand and the limits of integration. An unknown quantity, for instance area A, depends
on some other quantity, for instance the x­coordinate. The method is to allow the independent
variable x vary “infinitesimally” from x to x + dx and then use geometry or science to deduce the
corresponding variation dA of the unknown quantity. The deduction is usually intuitive rather
than rigorous. What is important is whether the deduction leads to the correct solution. If so, the
method of Riemann sums usually gives a rigorous proof of the intuitive answer. But if the solution
is incorrect, no argument will prove it correct.
2. Areas between curves. Given an interval a ≤ x ≤ b and two functions f (x) ≥ g(x) defined

on the interval, what is the area of the region bounded by the lines x = a, x = b and the curves
18.01 Calculus Jason Starr
Fall 2005

y = f (x), y = g(x)? This problem can be solved directly: the area is the difference of the area
between y = f (x) and the x­axis and the area between y = g(x) and the x­axis. Each of these is a
Riemann integral.
The differential method asks, what is the infinitesimal change in the area A as x varies from x
to x + dx? The infinitesimal region is a rectangle of base dx and height f (x) − g(x). Thus the
infinitesimal change in A is,

dA = height × base = (f (x) − g(x))dx.

Integrating gives, � � x=b

A= dA = f (x) − g(x)dx.
x=a
Of course this is the same answer as in the last paragraph. But for other applied integral problems,
the differential method may be the only method that works.
Example. Find the area bounded by the curve y = x(x2 − 3) and a horizontal tangent line.
The horizontal tangent lines are the tangent lines to the curve at critical points. Setting the
derivative equal to 0 gives,
dy
= 3x2 − 3 = 3(x − 1)(x + 1).
dx
Thus the critical points are x = ±1. The function is odd, so symmetry suggests the area is the same
regardless of the choice of critical point. Thus, choose the critical point x = −1. The corresponding
value of the function is,
y = (−1)((−1)2 − 3) = (−1)(−2) = 2.
This is the equation of the horizontal tangent line. Each intersection point (b, f (b)) of the tangent
line with y = x(x2 − 3) occurs at a solution x = b of,

x(x2 − 3) = 2.

By hypothesis, x = −1 is a solution. Thus the polynomial factors as,

x3 − 3x − 2 = (x + 1)(x2 − x − 2) = (x + 1)2 (x − 2).

The remaining intersection point is (2, 2). So the area bounded by the curve y = x(x2 − 3) and the
tangent line y = 2 is,
� x=2 � 2
2
2 − (x(x − 3))dx = −x3 + 3x + 2dx.
x=−1 −1

Using the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus, this equals,

� 4 �2
−x 3x2 �
+ + 2x�� = 27/4.
4 2 −1
18.01 Calculus Jason Starr
Fall 2005

3. Volumes of solids of revolutions: the disk method. If the region in the xy­plane bounded
by x = a, x = b, y = f (x) and the x­axis is revolved through xyz­space about the x­axis, what is
the volume of the resulting solid? The solid is called a solid of revolution. The disk method applies
the method of differentials to solve this problem. As x increases from x to x + dx, the corresponding
infinitesimal region of the solid is essentially a disk. The width of the disk is dx. The area of the
disk is π[f (x)]2 . Thus the infinitesimal volume of the disk is,
dV = Area × width = π[f (x)]2 dx.
Thus the volume is, � � x=b
V = dV = π[f (x)]2 dx.
x=a

Example. Find the volume of a right circular cone whose base has radius R and whose vertex has
height H above the base.
The cone is the solid of revolution for the plane region bounded by x = 0, the x­axis, and the line
containing (0, R) and (H, 0). The equation of this line is,
(H − x)R
y= .
H
Thus the area of an infinitesimal disk is,
(H − x)2 R2
dV = Area × width = π dx,
H2
and the volume is,
x=H
(H − x)2 R2
� �
V = dV = π dx.
x=0 H2
Making the substitution u = H − x, du = −dx gives,
� u=0 � 3 �0
R2 2 R2 u �
V = π 2 u (−du) = π 2 − �� .
u=H H H 3 H
Evaluating gives the volume,
V = πR2 H/3.
In particular, the antiderivative of u2 is responsible for the denominator 3 in the formula for the
volume.
Example. Find the volume of a sphere of radius R.
The sphere of radius R is√the solid of revolution for the plane region bounded by the x­axis and
the upper semicircle y = R2 − x2 . Thus the volume is,
� x=R √ � R �R
x3 ��
�
2 2 2 2 2 2
V = π[ R − x ] dx = π(R − x )dx = π R x − � .
x=−R −R 3 −R
18.01 Calculus Jason Starr
Fall 2005

Evaluating gives the volume,

V = 4πR3 /3.

4. The slice method. A generalization of the disk method is the slice method. The problem
is to find the volume of a region bounded by the planes x = a and x = b given the knowledge
of the area A(x) of the slice of the solid by the plane containing (x, 0, 0) parallel to the yz­plane.
As x increases from x to x + dx, the corresponding infinitesimal region of the solid is essentially
a cylinder. The width of the cylinder is dx. And the area is the area A(x) of the slice. Thus the
infinitesimal volume of the cylinder is,

dV = Area × width = A(x)dx.

Thus the volume is, � � x=b

V = dV = A(x)dx.
x=a

Example. Find the volume of the “corner” region bounded by the xy­plane, the xz­plane, the
yz­plane, and the plane containing (L, 0, 0), (0, L, 0) and (0, 0, L).
This region is bounded by the planes x = 0 and x = L. The x­slice of the region is a right isosceles
triangle. The base and altitude of the triangle both equal f (x), where y = f (x) is the equation of
the line passing through (0, L) and (L, 0). This equation is,

f (x) = L − x.

Thus the slice area is

1 1
A(x) = base × altitude = (L − x)2 .
2 2
Thus the infinitesimal volume is,
1
dV = A(x)dx = (L − x)2 dx,
2
giving the total volume, � � x=L
1
V = dV = (L − x)2 dx.
x=0 2
Make the substitution u = L − x, du = −dx to get,
u=0
�L
u3 ��
� �
1 2 1
V = u (−du) = − � .
u=L 2 2 3 0

Evaluating gives,
V = L3 /6.
Thus the “corner” takes up one sixth of the corresponding cube of edge length L.
18.01 Calculus Jason Starr
Fall 2005

5. Volumes of solids of revolution: the washer method. A variation on the disk method
is the washer method. A washer is the solid obtained by removing from a larger disk a concentric
smaller disk of the same width. If the outer radius of the washer is ro and the inner radius is ri ,
then the net area of the washer is,

A = πro2 − πri2 = π(ro2 − ri2 ).

Thus the volume of the washer is,

dV = Area × width = π(ro2 − ri2 )dx,

giving a total volume, � � x=b

V = dV = π(ro2 − ri2 )dx.
x=a

Example. The main part of a dog dish is a solid of revolution whose radial cross­section is a
triangle of height H whose base has inner radius Ri and outer radius Ro . Find the volume of
material used to make the dog dish.
Note. This integral was only set­up in lecture. The derivation will be completed in recitation.
Here is the complete derivation. Denote by x the height along the altitude of the triangle. Thus x
varies from x = 0 to x = H. When x = H, the inner radius and outer radius are each equal to the
average (Ri + Ro )/2 of the two radii. Both radii depend linearly on x.
The equation for the inner radius increases linearly from ri = Ri at x = 0 to ri = (Ri + Ro )/2 at
x = H. Thus,
H − x Ri + Ro x
ri (x) = Ri + .
H 2 H
Similarly, the equation for the outer radius decreases linearly from ro = Ro at x = 0 to ri =
(Ri + Ro )/2 at x = H. Thus,
H − x Ri + Ro x
ro (x) = Ro + .
H 2 H

Since ro2 − ri2 is a difference of squares, it equals,

ro2 − ri2 = (ro + ri )(ro − ri ).

This is interesting in its own right. Using this factorization, the net area of the region between the
2 circles, called an annulus, equals
� �
2 2 ro + ri
π(ro − ri ) = 2π (ro − ri ).
2
Note the first factor is the circumference of the center of the annulus. And the second factor is the
radial width of the annulus. Thus the area of an annulus is the circumference of the center times
the radial width.
18.01 Calculus Jason Starr
Fall 2005

Back to the problem, the center of each washer is the same,

ri + ro Ri + Ro
= .
2 2
And the radial width of each washer is,
H −x
ro − ri = (Ro − Ri ) .
H
Both of these make sense: The centers are constant because the radial cross­section is an isosceles
triangle. And the width decreases linearly from Ro − Ri at x = 0 to 0 at x = H. Thus the
cross­section area at height x is,
Ri + Ro H −x
A(x) = 2π (Ro − Ri ) .
2 H
Thus the infinitesimal volume is,
H −x
dV = Area × width = π(Ro2 − Ri2 ) dx,
H
giving a total area,
x=H
H −x
� �
V = dV = π(Ro2 − Ri2 ) dx.
x=0 H
Substituting u = H − x, du = −dx gives,
� u=H
u π(Ro2 − Ri2 ) � 2 ��H
V = π(Ro2 − Ri2 ) dx = u 0 .
u=0 H 2H
Thus the total volume of material to produce the dog dish is,

V = π(Ro2 − Ri2 )H/2.

One reality check is that this is the same volume as a cylinder with the same center (Ri + Ro )/2
and height H as the dish, and whose (constant) radial width equals the average radial width of the
dish, (Ro − Ri )/2.