CHAPTER 4 Separation and Processing
CHAPTER 4 Separation and Processing
SEPARATION AND
PROCESSING
4.1 INTRODUCTION
With three-phase operation, two liquid level controls and two liquid
dump valves are required. Three-phase separators are used commonly
for well testing and in instances where free water readily separates from
the oil or condensate.
From an evaluation of the advantages and disadvantages of the
various types of separators, the horizontal single-tube separator has
Gas and Liquid Separation 113
emerged as the one that gives the most efficient operation for initial
investment cost for high-pressure gas-distillate wells with high gas-oil
(4.1)
and
(4.2)
where
v = superficial gas velocity based on total cross-sectional
area of vessel,fps
114 Separation and Processing
(4.3)
Where
q = gas capacity at standard conditions, MMscfd
D = internal diameter, ft
p = operating pressure, psia
T = operating temperature, °F
z = gas deviation factor
Since this equation is empirical, a better determination of separator
gas capacity might be made from actual manufacturers' field test
data. Figures 7.6 to 7.13 are gas capacity charts for various standard
size separators based on operating pressure. These actual
manufacturers' gas capacity charts consider height differences in
vertical separators and length differences in horizontal separators, which
add to the gas capacity of the separators. As can be seen, height and
length differences are not taken into account in the Souders- Brown
equation. But field experience has proved that additional gas capacity
can be obtained by increasing height of vertical separators and length
of horizontal separators.
As seen on the sizing charts for horizontal separators, a correction
Gas and Liquid Separation 115
must be made for the amount of liquid in the bottom of the separator.
This is for single-tube horizontal vessels. One-half full of liquid is more or
less standard for most single-tube horizontal separators. However, the
gas capacity can be increased by lowering liquid level to increase the
available gas space within the vessel. Gas capacities of horizontal
separators with liquid sections one-half full, one-third full, or one-quarter
full can be determined from the gas capacity charts.
Liquid Capacity
The liquid capacity of a separator is primarily dependent on the
retention time of the liquid within the vessel. Good separation requires
sufficient time to obtain an equilibrium condition between the liquid and
gas phase at the temperature and pressure of separation. The liquid
capacity of a separator or the settling volume required based on
retention can be determined from the following equation:
(4.4)
116 Separation and Processing
stage separation requires two separators and a storage tank; and so on.
The tank is always counted as the final stage of vapor-liquid separation
because the final equilibrium flash occurs in the tank.
The purpose of stage separation is to reduce the pressure on the
reservoir liquids a little at a time, in steps or stages, so that a more stable
stock-tank liquid will result. The ideal method of separation, to attain
maximum liquid recovery, would be that of differential liberation of gas
by means of a steady decrease in pressure from that existing in the
reservoir to the stock-tank pressure. However, to carry out this differential
process would require an infinite number of separation stages.
Differential liberation can be closely approached by using three or more
series-connected stages of separation, in each of which flash
vaporization takes place.
120 Separation and Processing
increase the liquid recovery over two stages, the net increase over two-
stage separation will rarely payout the cost of the second or third
separator. Therefore, it has been generally accepted that two stages of
separation plus the stock tank are considered optimum. Actual increase
in liquid recovery for
(4.5)
or
(4.6)
where
R = pressure ratio
n = number of stages - 1
P1 = first-stage or high-pressure separator pressure, psia
p2 = second-stage or low-pressure separator pressure, psia
Ps = stock tank pressure, psia
Fig.4.12 Gas capacities of spherical L. P. Separators ( After Sivalls. )
Fig.4.13 Gas capacities of spherical high -pressure separators ( After Sivalls. )
The magnitude of stock tank liquid recoveries are not considered in the
equation
Figure 4.17 has been prepared to determine the optimum low-
stage separator pressure based on the high-stage separator pressure
with additional parameters of overall stock tank liquid recovery. This
information has been determined from extensive field test data.
Figure 4.18 is a chart illustrating the average percent increase in
liquid recovery for two-stage separation over single-stage separation. By
using this, an operator can rapidly determine the payout of additional
equipment required
Fig.4.17 Optimum low-stage separator pressure. (After Sivalls.)
From Fig. 4.18 it also can be seen that additional recovery can be
obtained by using 15-psig pressure distillate storage tanks rather than
atmospheric storage tanks.
From Fig. 4.7, at 800-psig operating pressure, a 20 in. x 7 ft, 6 in. vertical
separator will handle 5.4 MMscfd. From Table A.5, a 20 in. x 7 ft, 6 in.
separator will handle the following liquid capacity:
From Fig. 4.10, at 800-psig operating pressure and one-half full of liquid,
a 16 in.. x 5 ft horizontal separator will handle 5.1 MMscfd. From Table
A.9, a 16 in. x 5 ft separator will handle
Therefore, the 20 in. x 10 ft separator will not handle the combined liquid
load of 500 + 100 = 600 bbl/day. Five minute retention time is used as a
conservative figure without any additional information.
From Table A.9, a separator with more settling volume is 24 in. x 10 ft. Its
liquid capacity is
Example 4.5. A well test was made using a simple high pressure
separator and an atmospheric stock tank and the following results were
obtained:
Gas flow rate 10.0 MMscfd
Operating pressure 800 psig
Condensate recovery 500 bbl/day
What additional recovery could be expected using two-stage
separation and 15-psig pressure storage tanks?
Solution
From Fig.4.18, using the top curve at 800 psig, a 15.3% increase could
be expected. This would result in, 500(0.153) = 76.5 bbl/day additional
condensate recovery.
Example 4.6. On the test of a high-pressure gas-condensate well the
following data were recorded:
Gas flow rate 10.0 MMscfd
Operating pressure 800 psig ,
Condensate recovery 200 bbl/day
Separator temperature 85°F
What additional recovery could be expected using a low-temperature
separation unit operating at 20°F?
Solution
From Fig. 4.20, following the dotted lines, the recovery would go from 20
bbl/MMcf to 25.7 bbl/MMcf, or an additional 5.7 bbl/MMscf = 57
bbl/day.
equipment. Several of these methods that relate water content and dew
point are summarized below.
1. The correlation of McCarthy, Boyd, and Reid can be used for most
natural gas dehydration applications and will generally result in
reasonably conservative designs. Their chart is presented in Fig.
4.23.
2. The correlation of McKetta and Wehe (Fig. 4.22) is similar to
McCarthy, Boyd, and Reid and includes correlation factors for
produced water salinity and gas specific gravity.
3. At or near atmospheric pressure, Dalton's law of partial pressures is
valid and may be used to estimate the water vapor content of gas.
4. The Natural Gas Processors Suppliers Association has described a
method for predicting the water content of sour natural gas using
the data of Weibe and Gaddy for CO2 and the data of Selleck,
Carmichael, and Sage for H2S.
5. The most rigorous approach uses physical chemistry techniques to
account for the effect of differences in gas composition on water
vapor content. This method was developed by Sharma and
Campbell.
of water from a natural gas under pressure occurs when the temperature
is at or below the dew point at that pressure. Free water obtained under
such conditions is essential to formation of hydrates, which will occur at or
below the hydrate temperature at the same pressure. Hence, the
hydrate temperature would be less than or equal to the dew point
temperature.
During the flow of natural gas, it becomes necessary to define, and
thereby avoid, conditions that promote the formation of hydrates. This is
essential since hydrates may choke the flow string, surface lines, and
other equipment. Hydrate formation in the flow string results in a lower
value for measured wellhead pressures, In a flow rate measuring device,
hydrate formation results in lower flow rates. Excessive hydrate formation
may also completely block flow lines and surface equipment.
The conditions that tend to promote the formation of natural gas
hydrates are:
1. Natural gas at or below its water dew point with liquid water present.
2. Temperatures below the "hydrate formation" temperature for the
pressure and gas composition considered.
3. High operating pressures that increase the "hydrate formation"
temperature.
4. High velocity or agitation through piping or equipment.
5. Presence of a small "seed" crystal of hydrate.
6. Presence of H2S or CO2 is conducive to hydrate formation since
these acid gases are more soluble in water than hydrocarbons.
140 Separation and Processing
Example 4.7.
(a) A certain natural gas has a specific gravity of 0.693. If the gas is at
50°F, what would be the pressure above which hydrates could be
expected to form?
Example 4.8.
(a) How far can a 0.8-gravity gas at 1000 psia and 100°F be expanded
without hydrate formation?
(b) How far can a 0.7-gravity gas at 800 psia and 100°F be expanded
without hydrate formation, assuming presence of free water?
(c) A 0.6-gravity gas is to be expanded from 1000 psi a to 400 psia.
What is the minimum initial temperature that will permit expansion
without danger of hydrate formation?
Solution
(a) The intersection of the 1000 psia initial pressure line with the 100°F
initial temperature curve gives a final pressure of 440 psia (Fig.
4.27). Hence, this gas may be expanded to a final pressure of 440
psia without a possibility of hydrate formation.
(b) The 100°F initial temperature curve does not intersect the 800-psia
Dehydration of Natural Gas 145
initial pressure line (Fig. 4.26). Hence, this gas may be expanded to
atmospheric pressure without hydrate formation.
(c) The intersection of the 1000-psia initial pressure line and the 400-
psia final pressure line gives an initial temperature of 78°F (Fig. 4.25).
Hence, 78°F is the minimum initial temperature to avoid hydrate
formation. Figures 4.24 to 4.29 are strictly applicable to
sweet natural gases. For sour gases, they may be used, keeping in
mind that the presence of H2S and CO2 will increase the hydrate
temperature and reduce the pressure above which hydrates will
form. In other words, the presence of H2S or CO2 increases the
possibility of hydrate formation.
and sour natural gases over the following range of operating conditions:
Dew point depression 40-140°F
Gas pressure 25-2500 psig
Gas temperature 40-160°F
The dew point depression obtained depends on the equilibrium dew
point temperature for a given TEG concentration and contact
temperature. Increased glycol. viscosity may be a problem at the lower
end of the contact temperature range; consequently, heating of the
natural gas may be desirable. Very hot gas streams contain more water,
vaporize more TEG, have lower equilibrium ,dew points, and are
therefore often cooled prior to dehydration.
The wet inlet gas must be free of liquid water and hydrocarbons, wax,
sand, drilling muds, and so on. The presence of any of these substances
can cause severe foaming, flooding, higher glycol losses, poor
efficiency, and increased maintenance in the dehydration tower or
absorber. These impurites should be removed upstream of the absorber
by an efficient scrubber, separator, or even a filter separator for very
contaminated gases.
Methanol, injected at the wellhead as a hydrate inhibitor, can cause
several problems for glycol dehydration plants. First, methanol increases
the heat requirements of the glycol regeneration system, since
methanol is coabsorbed with water vapor by glycol. Second, slugs of
liquid methanol can cause flooding in the absorber. Finally, methanol
vapor vented to the atmosphere with the water vapor from the
regeneration system is hazardous and should be recovered or vented so
that hazardous concentrations do not occur.
Figure 4.32 illustrates the process and flow through a typical glycol
dehydrator. The west inlet gas stream first enters the unit through an inlet
gas scrubber where any liquid accumulations are removed. A two-
phase or distillate-gas scrubber is illustrated in Fig. 4.32. If any liquid water
is in the gas stream, a three-phase scrubber may be used to discharge
the distillate and water from the vessel separately. The mist eliminator
aids in removing any entrained liquid particles from the wet gas stream
leaving the top of the inlet scrubber.
The wet gas then enters the bottom of the glycol-gas contactor and
flows upward through the trays as illustrated countercurrent to the glycol
flowing downward through the column. The gas contacts the glycol on
each tray and the glycol absorbs the water vapor from the gas stream.
The dry gas leaves the
top of the contactor vessel through another mist eliminator which aids in
152 Separation and Processing
removing any entrained glycol droplets from the gas steam. The gas
then flows down through a vertical glycol cooler, usually fabricated in the
form of a concentric pipe heat exchanger, where the outlet dry gas aids
in cooling the hot regenerated glycol before it enters the contactor. The
dry gas then leaves the unit from the bottom of the glycol cooler.
The dry glycol enters the top of the glycol-gas contactor from the
glycol cooler and is injected onto the top tray. The glycol flows across
each tray and down through a downcomer pipe onto the next tray. The
bottom tray downcomer is fitted with a seal pot to hold a liquid sear on
the trays.
The wet glycol, which has now absorbed the water vapor from the
gas stream, leaves the bottom of the glycol-gas contactor column,
passes through a high- pressure glycol filter, which removes any foreign
solid particles that may have been picked up from the gas stream, and
enters the power side of the glycol pump.
In the glycol pump the wet high-pressure glycol from the contactor
column pumps the dry regenerated glycol into the column. The wet
glycol stream flows from the glycol pump to the inlet of the flash
separator. The low-pressure flash separator allows for the release of the
entrained solution gas, which must be used with the wet glycol to pump
the dry glycol into the contactor. The gas separated in the flash
separator leaves the top of the flash separator vessel and may be used
to supplement the fuel gas required for the reboiler. Any excess vent gas
is discharged through a back-pressure valve.
The flash separator is equipped with a liquid level control and
diaphragm motor valve that discharges the wet glycol stream through a
heat exchange coil in the surge tank to preheat the wet glycol stream. If
the wet glycol stream absorbs any liquid hydrocarbons in the contactor,
it may be desirable to use a three-phase flash separator to separate the
glycol from the liquid hydrocarbons before the stream enters the
reboiler. Any liquid hydrocarbons present in the reboiler will cause undue
glycol losses from the stripping still.
The wet glycol stream leaves the heat exchange coil in the surge
tank and enters the stripping still mounted on top of the reboiler at the
feed point in the still. The stripping still is packed with a ceramic intalox
saddle-type packing, and the glycol flows downward through the
column and enters the reboiler. The wet glycol passing downward
through the still is contacted by hot rising glycol and water vapors
passing upward through the column. The water vapors released in the
reboiler and stripped from the glycol in the stripping still pass upward
through the still column through an atmospheric reflux condenser that
provides a partial reflux for the column. The water vapor then leaves the
top of the stripping still column and is released to the atmosphere.
Dehydration of Natural Gas 153
solutions. Also, overheating of solution may produce both low and high
boiling decomposition products. The resultant sludge may collect on
heating surfaces, causing some loss in efficiency, or, in severe cases,
complete flow stoppage. Placing a bypass mechanical filter ahead of
the solution pump usually prevents such troubles. When both oxygen
and hydrogen sulfide are present, corrosion may become a problem
because of the formation of acid material in glycol solution.
Second, liquids (e.g., water, light hydrocarbons, or lubricating oils) in
inlet gas may require installation of an efficient separator ahead of the
absorber. Highly mineralized water entering the system with inlet gas
may, over long periods, crystallize and fill the reboiler with solid salts. Third,
foaming of solution may occur with a resultant carry-over of liquid. The
addition of a small quantity of antifoam compound usually remedies this
trouble.
Fourth, some leakage around the packing glands of pumps may be
permitted since excessive tightening of packing may result in the
scouring of rods. This leakage is collected and periodically returned to
the system. Fifth, highly concentrated glycol solutions tend to become
viscous at low temperatures and, therefore, are hard to pump. Glycol
lines may solidify completely at low temperatures when the plant is not
operating. In cold weather, continuous circulation of part of the solution
through the heater may be advisable. This practice can also prevent
freezing in water coolers.
In starting a plant, all absorber trays must be filled with glycol before
good contact of gas and liquid can be expected. This may also
become a problem at low-circulation rates because weep holes on
trays may drain solution as rapidly as it is introduced. Finally, sudden
surges should be avoided in starting and shutting down a plant.
Otherwise, large carry-over losses of solution may occur.
4.3.4 Glycol Dehydrator Design
Triethylene glycol dehydrators using tray or packed-column contactors
may be sized from standard models by using the following procedures
and associated graphs and tables (Sivalls). Custom-designed glycol
dehydrators for specific applications may also be designed using these
procedures. The following information must be available on the gas
stream to be dehydrated:
1. Gas flow rate, Mmscfd.
2. Specific gravity of gas.
3. Operating pressure, psig.
4. Maximum working pressure of contact, psig.
Dehydration of Natural Gas 155
Fig.4.33 Gas capacity of vertical gas inlet scrubbers based on 0.7 specific
gravity, at 100°F. (After Sivalls.)
Inlet Scrubber
A good inlet scrubber is essential for efficient operation of any glycol
dehydrator unit. The required diameter of a vertical inlet scrubber may
be selected using Fig. 4.33, based on the operating pressure of the unit
and gas capacity required. Two-phase inlet scrubbers are generally
constructed with 7V2-ft shell heights. Additional data on typical standard
vertical inlet scrubbers are contained in Tables A.14 and A.15 in the
Appendix.
Glycol-gas Contactor
Select a contactor diameter based on the operating pressure required
with the approximate required gas capacity from Fig. 4.34 or 4.35.
Figure 4.34 is for glycol contactors using trayed columns, and Fig. 4.35 is
for contactors using packed columns. The gas capacities as
determined for a given diameter contactor from Fig. 4.34 or 4.35 must
be corrected for the operating temperature and gas specific gravity.
Calculate the gas capacity of the gas-glycol contactor selected for the
specific operating conditions:
where
qo = gas capacity of contactor at operating conditions,
Mmscfd
qs = gas capacity of contactorat standard conditions (0.7
specific gravity and 100°F) based on operating pressure,
Mmscfd
Ct = correction factor for operating temperature
Cg = correction factor for gas specific gravity
The temperature and gas specific gravity correction factors for trayed
glycol contactors are contained in Tables 4.1 and 4.2, respectively. The
temperature and specific gravity factors for packed glycol contactors
are contained in Tables 4.3 and 4.4, respectively.
Next, determine the required dew point depression and the water
removed from the glycol dehydration unit from the following:
Dew point depression
Dehydration of Natural Gas 157
(4.8)
Where
Fig. 4.34 Gas capacity for trayed glycol gas contactors based on 0.7 specific
gravity, at 100°F. (After Sivalls.)
158 Separation and Processing
The outlet dew point temperature can be found on the water vapor
content graph using the outlet gas water content required and the
operating pressure. The dew point temperature is the temperature at
which the remaining water vapor in the gas will start to condense. The
inlet gas temperature is also the inlet dew point temperature since the
gas is generally assumed to be water-saturated before it is dehydrated.
The water content of the inlet gas can be determined from the same
water vapor content graph using the inlet gas temperature and the
operating pressure.
If the natural gas stream contains appreciable, amounts of either
carbon dioxide or hydrogen sulfide, the water content of these sour
gases should be taken into account in determining the total water
content of the inlet gas stream. Since both carbon dioxide and
hydrogen sulfide absorb considerably more water vapor than natural
gas, they appreciably increase the total water content and dehydration
requirements of the gas stream.
Fig. 4.35 Gas capacity for packed glycol gas contactors based on 0.7 specific
gravity, at 100°F. (After Sivalls.)
Trayed Contactors
Select the number of actual trays required from Fig. 4.36, using the
required dew point depression and the selected glycol to water
circulation rate. The data contained in Fig 4.36 will give the approximate
number of trays required for rapid sizing of field glycol dehydrators. A
Dehydration of Natural Gas 159
(4.9)
(4.10)
Where
160 Separation and Processing
theoretical and actual test data using a typical natural gas. Select the
next whole number of trays based on the above design procedures after
the tray efficiencies have been considered. However, good operation of
field dehydrators indicates that a minimum of four trays should be used
in any glycol-gas contactor.
Standard field dehydration contactors normally have 24-in. tray
spacing.
Because of the tendency of glycol to foam in the presence of liquid
hydrocarbons,
162 Separation and Processing
Packed Contactors
The same procedures can be used for packed column contactors and
Dehydration of Natural Gas 163
(4.13)
where
L = glycol circulation rate, gas/hr
Lw = glycol to water circulation rate, gal TEG/lb H2O
Wi = water content of inlet gas, lb H2O/MMscf
q = gas flow rate, MMscfd
Reboiler
The required heat load for the reboiler can be estimated from the
following
equation:
H, = 2000L (4.14)
where
H, = Total heat load on reboiler, Btu/h
L = Glycol circulation rate, gph
The above formula for determining the required reboiler heat load is an
approximation, which is accurate enough for most high-pressure glycol
dehydrator sizing. A more detailed determination of the required
reboiler heat load may be made from the following procedure:
164 Separation and Processing
(4.15)
(4.16)
(4.17)
(4.18)
(4.19)
Where
The actual surface of the firebox required for direct-fired reboilers can be
determined from the following equation, which is based on a design
heat flux of 7000 Btuh/sq ft. By determining the diameter and overall
length of the V-tube firebox required to give the total surface area as
calculated, the general overall size of the reboiler can be determined.
TheDehydration of Natural Gas 165
(4.21)
Where
(4.22)
where
V = required settling volume in separator, gal
L = glycol circulation rate, gph
T = retention time = 5.0 min
Liquid hydrocarbon should not be allowed to enter the glycol-gas
contactor.
Should this be a problem, a three-phase glycol flash separator will keep
these liquid hydrocarbons out of the reboiler and stripping still. A liquid
retention time of 20 to 30 min should be used in Eq. 4.22 to size a three-
phase flash separator.
The hydrocarbon gas released from the flash separator can be piped to
the
166 Separation and Processing
Stripping Still
The size of the packed stripping still for use with the glycol reconcentrator
can be determined from Fig. 4.39. The diameter required for the
stripping still is normally based on the required diameter at the base of
the still using the vapor and liquid loading conditions at that point. The
vapor load consists of the water vapor (steam) and stripping gas flowing
up through the still. The liquid load consists of the rich glycol stream and
reflux flowing downward through the still column. The minimum cross-
sectional area or diameter required for the still as read from Fig. 4.39 is
based on the glycol to water circulation rate (gal TEG/lb H2O) and the
glycol circulation rate (gph).
Normally, one theoretical tray is sufficient for most stripping still
requirements for triethylene glycol dehydration units. For conservative
design, the height of packing using 1 ½-in. ceramic lntalox saddles is
held at a minimum of 4 ft. Conservative design and field test data
indicate that this height should be gradually increased with the size of
the glycol reconcentrator to a maximum of approximately 8 ft for a
1,000,000 Btuh unit.
The Dehydration of Natural Gas 167
gas that has been sweetened by treating. Some of the processes for
removing acid gases from natural gas are briefly discussed below.
Iron-sponge Sweetening
The iron-sponge process is a batch process, the sponge being a
sensitive, hydrated iron oxide (Fe2O3) supported on wood shavings. The
reaction between the sponge and H2S in the gas stream is
2 Fe2O3 + 6 H2S ~ 2 Fe2S3 + 6 H2O
The ferric oxide is present in a hydrated form; without the water of
hydration, the reaction will not proceed. Thus, the operating
temperature of the vessel must be kept below approximately 120°F or a
supplemental water spray must be provided.
Regeneration of the bed is sometimes accomplished by the addition of
air
(O2, either continuously or by batch addition. The regeneration reaction
is
2 Fe2S3 + 3 O2 ~ 2 Fe2O3 + 6 S
Because, the sulfur remains in the bed, the number of regeneration steps
is limited, and eventually the bed will have to be replaced.
Alkanolamine Sweetening
Alkanolamine encompasses the family of organic compounds of
monoethanolamine (MEA), diethanolamine (DEA), and triethanolamine
(TEA). The chemicals are used extensively for the removal of hydrogen
sulfide or carbon dioxide from other gases and are particularly adapted
for obtaining the low acid-gas residuals that are usually specified by
pipelines. The alkanolamine process is not selective and must be
designed for total acid-gas removal, even though CO2 removal may not
be required or desired to meet market specifications.
REFERENCES
Campbell, J. M. Gas Conditioning and Processing. Norman, Okla.:
Campbell Petroleum Series, 1976.
Gas Processors Suppliers Assoc. Engineering Data Book. 9th ed. 3rd
revision. 1977.
Guenther, J. D. "Natural Gas Dehydration." Paper presented at Seminar
on Process Equipment and Systems on Treatment Platforms,
Taastrup, Denmark. April 26, 1979.
172 Separation and Processing
PROBLEMS