Spectrum Summary 4
Spectrum Summary 4
The Revolt of 1857 - The Major The East India Company’s greedy
policy of
Causes aggrandizement accompanied by
➢ Economic Causes broken pledges and promises
resulted in contempt for the
The colonial policies of the East India Company and loss of political
Company destroyed the traditional prestige, besides causing suspicion
economic fabric of Indian society. in the minds of almost all the ruling
British rule also meant misery to the princes in India, through policies as
artisans and handicrafts people. of 'Effective Control’, 'Subsidiary
The annexation of Indian states by the Alliance' and 'Doctrine of Lapse'.
Company cut off their major source of The collapse of rulers—the erstwhile
patronage. aristocracy—also adversely affected
The Indian trade and mercantile class those sections of the Indian society.
was deliberately crippled by the British
who imposed high tariff duties on ➢ Administrative Causes
Indian-made goods.
At the same time, the import of British Rampant corruption in the Company’s
goods into India attracted low tariffs, administration, especially among the
thus encouraging their entry into India. police, petty officials, and lower law
Free Trade and refusal to impose courts, was a major cause of
protective duties against the machine- discontent.
made goods from Britain, simply killed
Indian manufacture. ➢ Socio-Religious Causes
Zamindars, the traditional landed
aristocracy, often saw their land rights Racial overtones and a superiority
forfeited with frequent use of a quo complex characterised the British
warranto by the administration. administrative attitude towards the
native Indian population.
Example- In Awadh, the storm centre The government’s decision to tax
of the revolt, 21,000 taluqdars had mosque and temple lands and
their estates confiscated and suddenly making laws such as the Religious
found themselves without a source of Disabilities Act, 1856.
income, "unable to work, ashamed to
beg, condemned to penury". ➢ Influence of Outside Events
The revolt of 1857 coincided with bitten off before loading and the
certain outside events in which the grease was reportedly made
British suffered serious losses— of beef and pig fat.
the First Afghan War (1838-
42), Punjab Wars (1845-49), and ➢ Starts at Meerut
the Crimean Wars (1854-56).
The revolt began at Meerut, 58 km
➢ Discontent Among Sepoys from Delhi, on May 10, 1857, and
then, gathering force rapidly, soon
The conditions of service in the embraced a vast area from Punjab in
Company's Army and cantonments the north and the Narmada in the
increasingly came into conflict with south to Bihar in the east and
the religious beliefs and prejudices Rajputana in the west.
of the sepoys. Sepoy of the 34th Native Infantry,
In 1856, Lord Canning's government Mangal Pande, went a step further
passed the General Service and fired at the sergeant major of his
Enlistment Act which decreed that unit at Barrackpore.
all future recruits to the Bengal On April 24, ninety men of the 3rd
Army would have to give an Native Cavalry refused to accept the
undertaking to serve anywhere their greased cartridges.
services might be required by the On May 9, eighty-five of them were
government. This caused resentment. dismissed, sentenced to 10 years
The immediate cause of the sepoys' imprisonment, and put in fetters.
dissatisfaction was the order that On May 10, they released their
they would not be given the foreign imprisoned comrades, killed their
service allowance (bhatta) when officers, and unfurled the banner of
serving in Sindh or in Punjab. revolt.
History of revolts in the British
Indian Army— ➢ Choice of Bahadur Shah as
in Bengal (1764), Vellore (1806), B
arrackpore (1825 ) and during Symbolic Head
the Afghan Wars (1838-42).
This spontaneous raising of the last
Beginning and Spread of the Revolt Mughal king to the leadership of the
➢ The Spark country was a recognition of the fact
that the long reign of
The reports about the mixing of the Mughal dynasty had become the
bone dust in atta (flour) and the traditional symbol of India’s political
introduction of the Enfield rifle unity.
enhanced the sepoy's growing The broad outlook of the rebels was
disaffection with the government. not influenced by religious identity
The greased wrapping paper of the but by the perception of the British
cartridge of the new rifle had to be as the common enemy.
The entire Bengal Army soon rose in Rohilkhand, not enthusiastic about
revolt which spread the pension being granted by the
quickly. Awadh, Rohilkhand, British, organized an army of 40,000
the Doab, Bundelkhand, central In soldiers and offered stiff resistance
dia, large parts of Bihar and East to the British.
Punjab shook off British authority. In Bihar, the revolt was led by
Kunwar Singh, the zamindar of
➢ Civilians Join Jagdishpur. He unhesitatingly joined
the sepoys when they
The revolt of the sepoys was reached Arrah from Dinapore (Dan
accompanied by a rebellion of the apur).
civil population, particularly in the Maulvi Ahmadullah
north-western provinces and Awadh. of Faizabad fought a stiff battle
The peasants and petty zamindars against the British troops. He
took advantage of the revolt to emerged as one of the revolt’s
destroy the moneylender's account acknowledged leaders once it broke
books and debt records. out in Awadh in May 1857.
Rani Laxmibai, who assumed the
➢ Storm Centres and Leaders of the leadership of the sepoys at Jhansi.
Revolt The Rani of Jhansi
and Tantia Tope marched towards
At Delhi the real command lay with Gwalior. Gwalior was recaptured by
a court of soldiers headed by the English in June 1858.
General Bakht Khan Sir Hugh Whe Shah Mal, a local villager in
eler, commanding the station, Pargana Baraut (Baghpat, Uttar
surrendered on June 27, 1857 and Pradesh) organised the headmen and
was killed on the same day. peasants of 84 villages (referred as
Nana Saheb expelled the English chaurasi desh), marching at night
from Kanpur, proclaimed himself the from village to village, urging people
Peshwa, acknowledged Bahadur to rebel against the British
Shah as the Emperor of India, and hegemony. Shah Mal's body was cut
declared himself to be his governor. into pieces and his head displayed on
Begum Hazrat Mahal took over the
reigns at Lucknow where the July 21, 1857.
rebellion broke out on June 4, 1857
and popular sympathy was Suppression of the Revolt
overwhelmingly in favour of the
deposed nawab. In March 1858, the The revolt was finally suppressed.
city was finally recovered by the The British captured Delhi on
September 20, 1857, thus the great
British. House of Mughals was finally and
At Bareilly, Khan Bahadur, a completely extinguished.
descendant of the former ruler of
Sir Colin Campbell occupied traditional conservative forces to
modernity.
Kanpur on December 6, 1857. Rulers who did not participate
included the Sindhia of Gwalior,
Sir Colin Campbell the Holkar of Indore, the rulers of
Patiala, Sindh and other Sikh
Tantia Tope was captured while chieftains, and the Maharaja of
asleep in April 1859 and put to Kashmir.
death. The Rani of Jhansi had died
on the battlefield earlier in June ➢ Poor Arms and Equipment
1858. Jhansi was recaptured
by Sir Hugh Rose. The Indian soldiers were poorly
equipped materially, fighting generally
➢ The British Resistance with swords and spears and very few
guns and muskets.
Delhi - Lieutenant Willoughby, John
Nicholson, Lieutenant Hudson ➢ Uncoordinated and Poorly
Kanpur - Sir Hugh Wheeler, Sir Organised
Colin Campbell
Lucknow - Henry Lawrence, The revolt was poorly organised with
Brigadier Inglis, Henry Havelock, no coordination or central
James Outram, Sir Colin Campbell leadership.
Jhansi - Sir Hugh Rose The principal rebel leaders—Nana
Benaras - Colonel James Neill Saheb, Tantia Tope, Kunwar Singh,
Laxmibai.
The mutineers lacked a clear
Why the Revolt Failed? understanding of the colonial rule,
nor did they have a forward looking
All-India participation was absent.
programme, a coherent ideology, a
The limited territorial spread was one
political perspective or a societal
factor, there was no all - India veneer
alternative.
about the revolt.
Hindu-Muslim Unity Factor
➢ All classes did not join
According to Maulana Azad, “Two
Big zamindars acted as "break- facts stand out clearly in the midst of
waters to storm", even Awadh the tangled story of the Rising of 1857.
taluqdars backed off once promises The first is the remarkable sense of
of land restitution were spelt out. unity among the Hindus and the
Educated Indians viewed this revolt Muslims of India in this period. The
as backward-looking, supportive of other is the deep loyalty which the
the feudal order and as a reaction of people felt for the Mughal Crown.”
Thus, the events of 1857 demonstrated democratic combine against foreign as
that the people and politics of India well as feudal bondage".
were not basically communal or Jawaharlal Nehru considered the
sectarian before 1858. Revolt of 1857 as essentially
a feudal uprising though there were
Nature of the Revolt some nationalistic elements in it
(Discovery of India).
It was a mere 'Sepoy Mutiny’ to some M.N. Roy felt the Revolt was a last-
British historians—"a wholly ditch stand of feudalism
unpatriotic and selfish Sepoy Mutiny
with no native leadership and no against commercial capitalism.
popular support”, said Sir John R.P. Dutt also saw the significance of
Seeley. the Revolt of the peasantry against
Dr. K. Datta considers the revolt of foreign domination It had seeds of
1857 to have been “in the main a nationalism and anti-imperialism but
military outbreak, which was taken the concept of common nationality and
advantage of by certain discontented nationhood was not inherent to the
princes and landlords, whose interests revolt of 1857.
had been affected by the new political S.B. Chaudhuri observes, the revolt
order”. It was "never all-Indian in was "the first combined attempt of
character, but was localised, restricted many classes of people to challenge a
and poorly organised". Further, says foreign power. This is a real if remote,
Datta, the movement was marked by approach to the freedom movement of
absence of cohesion and unity of India of a later age".
purpose among the various sections of
the rebels.
A "planned war of national Consequences
independence", by V.D. Savarkar in
his book, The Indian War of The revolt of 1857 marks a turning
Independence, 1857. Savarkar called point in the history of India. It led to
the revolt the first war of Indian far-reaching changes in the system of
independence. administration and the policies of the
Dr. S.N. Sen in his Eighteen Fifty- British government.
Seven considers the revolt as having The British Parliament, on August 2,
begun as a fight for religion but ending 1858, passed an Act for the Better
as a war of independence. Government of India. The Act
Dr. R.C. Majumdar, however, declared Queen Victoria as the
considers it as neither the first, nor sovereign of British India and provided
national, nor a war of independence as for the appointment of a Secretary of
large parts of the country remained State for India
unaffected According to some Marxist The assumption of the Government of
historians, the 1857 revolt was "the India by the sovereign of Great Britain
struggle of the soldier-peasant was announced by Lord Canning at a
durbar at Allahabad in the 'Queen’s For the British, the Revolt of 1857
Proclamation’ issued on November 1, proved useful in that it showed up the
glaring shortcomings in the Company’s
1858. administration and its army, which
The proclamation also promised equal they rectified promptly. These defects
and impartial protection under law to would never have been revealed to the
all Indians, besides equal opportunities world if the Revolt had not happened.
in government services irrespective of For the Indians, the 1857 Revolt had a
race or creed. It was also promised that major influence on the course of the
old Indian rights, customs, and struggle for freedom. It brought out in
practices would be given due regard the open grievances of people and the
while framing and administering the sepoys, which were seen to be genuine.
law. However, it was also obvious that the
The Army Amalgamation Scheme, primitive arms which the Indians
1861 moved the Company’s possessed were no match for the
European troops to the services of advanced weapons of the British.
the Crown. Furthermore, the senseless atrocities
'Conservative brand of liberalism’, as committed by both sides shocked the
it was called by Thomas Metcalf—had Indian intellectuals who were
the solid support of the conservative increasingly convinced that violence
and aristocratic classes of England who was to be eschewed in any struggle for
espoused the complete non- freedom.
interference in the traditional structure The educated middle class, which was
of Indian society. The Indian economy a growing section, did not believe in
was fully exploited without fear. violence and preferred an orderly
In accordance with the Queen’s approach. But the Revolt of 1857
Proclamation of 1858, the Indian Civil did establish local traditions of
Service Act of 1861 was passed, which resistance to British rule which were
was to give an impression that under to be of help in the course of
the Queen all were equal, irrespective the national struggle for freedom.
of race or creed.
Racial hatred and suspicion between General Features of Socio-Religious
the Indians and English was probably Reform Movements
the worst legacy of the revolt.
The complete structure of the Indian ➢ Factors Giving Rise to Desire for
government was remodeled and based Reform
on the notion of a master race
justifying the philosophy of the The dawn of the nineteenth
‘Whiteman’s burden’. century witnessed the birth of a new
vision—a modern vision among
Significance of the Revolt some enlightened sections of Indian
society.
Which have become as much a part the intrusion of colonial culture and
of daily existence in the whole of the ideology, an attempt to reinvigorate
Indian subcontinent as having the traditional institutions and to realize
fruits of these reform movements. the potential of traditional culture
developed during the nineteenth
➢ Impact of British Rule century.
At All India Khilafat Conference held February 1920 In early 1920, a joint
in Delhi in November 1919, a call was Hindu-Muslim deputation was sent
made for the boycott of British goods. to the viceroy to seek redress of
Gandhi, who was the president of the grievances on the issue of Khilafat.
All India Khilafat Committee, saw in In February 1920, Gandhi announced
the issue a platform from which mass that the issues of the Punjab wrongs
and united non-cooperation could be and constitutional advance had been
declared against the Government. overshadowed by the Khilafat
question.
➢ Congress Stand on Khilafat May 1920 Treaty of Sevres with
Question Turkey, signed in May 1920,
completely dismembered Turkey.
June 1920 An all-party conference itself to an extraconstitutional mass
at Allahabad approved a programme struggle.
of boycott. Some important organisational
August 31, 1920, The Khilafat changes were made: A congress
Committee started a campaign of working committee (CWC) of 15
non-cooperation and the movement members was set up to lead
was formally launched. the Congress from now onwards,
September 1920 At a special session provincial congress committees on
in Calcutta, the Congress approved a linguistic basis were organised, ward
non-cooperation programme till the committees were organised, and the
Punjab and Khilafat wrongs were entry fee was reduced to four annas.
removed and swaraj was established. Gandhi declared that if the non-
cooperation programme was
➢ The programme was to include: implemented completely, swaraj
would be ushered in within a year.
Boycott of government schools and Surendranath Banerjea founded
colleges. the Indian National Liberal
Boycott of law courts and Federation and played a minor role
dispensation of justice through in national politics henceforward.
panchayats instead.
Boycott of legislative councils. ➢ The Spread of the Movement
Boycott of foreign cloth and use of
khadi instead, also practice of hand- Gandhi accompanied by the Ali
spinning to be done. brothers undertook a nationwide
Renunciation of government honours tour. Educational institutions were
and titles, the second phase could organised under the leadership
include mass civil disobedience of Acharya Narendra Dev, C.R.
including resignation from Das, Lala Lajpat Rai, Zakir
government service, and non- Hussain, Subhash Bose (who
payment of taxes. became the principal of National
College at Calcutta) and included
➢ December 1920 At the Nagpur Jamia Millia at Aligarh, Kashi
session of the Indian National Vidyapeeth, Gujarat Vidyapeeth and
Congress Bihar Vidyapeeth.
A no-tax movement against union
An important change was made in board taxes in Midnapore (Bengal)
the Congress creed: Now, instead of and in Guntur (Andhra) was going
having the attainment of self- on.
government through constitutional In Assam, strikes in tea plantations,
means as its goal, the Congress steamer services and Assam-Bengal
decided to have the attainment of Railways had been organised. J.M.
swaraj through peaceful and Sengupta was a prominent leader in
legitimate means, thus committing these strikes.
In November 1921, the visit of the leaders and refused to fall into the
Prince of Wales to India invited trap.
strikes and demonstrations. The
spirit of defiance and unrest gave ➢ The Last Phase of the Movement
rise to many local struggles such as
Awadh Kisan Movement (UP), Eka Gandhi was now under increasing
Movement (UP), Mappila Revolt pressure from the Congress rank and
(Malabar) and the Sikh agitation for file to start the civil disobedience
the removal of mahants in Punjab. programme. The Ahmedabad session
in 1921 appointed Gandhi the sole
➢ People’s Response authority on the issue.
On February 1, 1922, Gandhi
Middle Class - People from the threatened to launch civil
middle classes led the movement at disobedience from Bardoli (Gujarat)
the beginning but later they showed if :
a lot of reservations about Gandhi's (i) Political prisoners were not
programme. released.
Business Class - The economic (ii) Press controls were not removed.
boycott received support from the Chauri Chaura Incident - Chauri-
Indian business group because they Chaura (Gorakhpur district in United
had benefited from the nationalists' Provinces) has found a place in
emphasis on the use of swadeshi. history books due to an incident of
Peasants - Peasants’ participation violence on February 5, 1922,
was massive. which was to prompt Gandhi to
Students - Students became active
volunteers of the movement. withdraw the movement.
Women - Women gave up purdah Congress Working Committee met at
and offered their ornaments for Bardoli in February 1922 and
the Tilak Fund. resolved to stop all activity that led
Hindu- Muslim Unity - The to the breaking of the law and to get
massive participation of Muslims down to constructive work.
and the maintenance of communal In March 1922, Gandhi was arrested
unity, despite the events like and sentenced to six years in jail. He
Moppila Uprisings, were great made the occasion memorable by a
achievements. magnificent court speech: “I am
here, therefore, to invite and submit
➢ Government Response cheerfully to the highest penalty that
can be inflicted upon me for what in
Talks between Gandhi and Reading, law is a deliberate crime, and what
the viceroy, broke down in May appears to me to be the highest duty
1921 Gandhi realised that the of a citizen.”
government was trying to drive a
wedge between him and the Khilafat
Why Gandhi Withdrew the Movement They wanted to 'end or mend'
these councils, which meant that
The movement was also showing if the government did not respond
signs of fatigue. In November 1922, to the nationalists' demands, they
the people of Turkey rose under would obstruct the councils' work.
Mustafa Kamal Pasha and deprived Their only intention was to use
the sultan of political power. the councils as a forum for
In 1924, the caliphate was abolished. political struggle; they had no
intention of using the councils to
gradually transform colonial rule.
Evaluation of Khilafat Non- The Swarajists were those who
Cooperation Movement advocated for inclusion in
legislative councils.
The movement brought the urban
Muslims into the national No Changers
movement, but at the same time, it
communalized national politics, to The 'No-changers' were those who
an extent. opposed council entry.
With the Non-Cooperation They advocated for a focus on
Movement, nationalist sentiments constructive work while
reached every nook and corner of the maintaining the boycott and
country and politicized noncooperation.
every stratum of the population. They also advocated for the quiet
resumption of the suspended civil
……………………………………… disobedience programme.
……… The 'No-changers' were a school
of thought led by Vallabhbhai
Emergence of Swarajists, Socialist Patel, Rajendra Prasad, C.
Ideas, Revolutionary Activities & New Rajagopalachari, and M.A.
Forces Ansari.
Swarajists and No-Changers
Genesis of Congress-Khilafat
Swarajists Swarajya Party
Repression was used to quell the Civil The Congress manifesto reaffirmed the
Disobedience Movement, and reforms total rejection of the 1935 Act.
were used to revive the political Congress’ Performance, Congress won
standing of constitutionalist liberals 716 out of the 1,161 seats it contested.
and moderates. It got a majority in all provinces,
The strategy was to create dissensions except in Bengal, Assam, Punjab,
within the Congress party in order to Sindh, and the NWFP.
placate the right wing with The Congress Party had a very
constitutional concessions and crush successful showing in the provincial
the left wing with police measures. elections of 1937.
Provincial autonomy would create They won a majority in all but five of
powerful provincial leaders who the provinces in which elections were
would gradually become autonomous held.
centers of political power. The party's platform for rejecting the
1935 Act was reaffirmed in their
Nationalists’ Response election manifesto.
The 1935 Act was condemned by nearly
all sections and unanimously rejected by …………………………………………
Congress. ………..
Divided Opinion
Congress Rules in Provinces
The left-wing of the Indian National Congress ministries were formed
Congress, led by Jawaharlal Nehru, in Bombay, Madras, Central
Subhash Bose, and the Congress Provinces, Orissa, United Provinces,
socialists and communists, were Bihar, and later in the NWFP and
opposed to accepting offices under the
1935 Government of India Act. Assam also.
They argued that this would negate the Gandhi’s Advice
nationalists' rejection of the Act. Gandhi advised Congressmen to hold
As a counter-strategy, the leftists these offices lightly and not tightly. The
proposed entering the councils with offices were to be seen as "crowns of
the aim of creating deadlocks, thus thorns'
Work under Congress Ministries
➢ Civil Liberties War clouds had started
hovering around 1938.
Laws giving emergency powers The reactionary second chamber
were repealed. (Legislative Council) dominated by
Ban on illegal organizations, and on landlords, moneylenders, and
certain books and journals was lifted. capitalists in United
Press restrictions were lifted. Provinces, Bihar, Bombay, Madras,
Newspapers were taken out of and Assam had to be conciliated as
blacklists. its support was necessary for
Confiscated arms and arms licenses legislation.
were restored. The agrarian structure was
Police powers were curbed and too complex.
the CID stopped shadowing
politicians. Attitude Towards Labour
Political prisoners and The basic approach was to advance
revolutionaries were released, and workers’ interests while promoting
deportation and internment orders industrial peace. The ministries took
were revoked. recourse to Section 144 and arrested the
In Bombay lands confiscated by the leaders.
government during the Civil ➢ Social Welfare Reforms
Disobedience Movement were
restored. The prohibition imposed in certain
Pensions of officials associated with areas.
the Civil Disobedience Movement Measures for the welfare
were restored. of Harijans taken.
Attention is given to primary,
➢ Agrarian Reforms technical, and higher education and
to public health and sanitation.
The ministries did not The encouragement is given to
have adequate powers. khadi through subsidies and other
There were inadequate financial measures.
resources as a lion’s share was Prison reforms were undertaken.
appropriated by the Government of The encouragement is given to
India. indigenous enterprises.
The strategy of class adjustments Efforts taken to develop planning
was another hurdle since zamindars, through National Planning
etc., had to be conciliated and Committee set up under Congress
neutralized. president Subhash Bose in 1938.
There was the constraint of time
since the logic of Congress politics ➢ Extra-Parliamentary Mass
was a confrontation and not Activity of Congress
cooperation with colonialism.
launching of mass literacy Summary of Nationalist Response in
campaigns, the wake of World War II
setting up of Congress police
stations and panchayats, ➢ Congress Crisis on Method of
Congress Grievance Committees Struggle
presenting mass petitions to
There were issues of bogus
government and states peoples’
membership and unethical means
movements.
employed in trying to getting into the
congressional committees and
➢ Evaluation
controlling them.
Gandhi firmly believed that
The 28-month Congress rule was also
Congress should first put its house in
significant for the following reasons.
The contention that Indian self- order before the movement could
again be launched; besides, he also
government was necessary for radical
felt the masses were not in the mood
social transformation got confirmed.
for a struggle. There were others
Congressmen demonstrated that a
who felt that the struggle should
movement could use state power to
further its ends without being co-opted. continue.
The ministries were able to control
communal riots. ➢ Haripura and Tripuri Sessions:
The morale of the bureaucracy came
Subhash Bose’s Views
down.
Council work helped neutralize many Subhash Chandra Bose was
erstwhile hostile elements (landlords, president of the Bengal Provincial
etc). Congress Committee. His main area
People were able to perceive the shape of work lay in the organization of the
of things to come if independence was youth and promoting the trade union
won. movement. Subhash Bose did not
Administrative work by Indians further agree with Gandhi and other leaders
weakened the myth that Indians were of the Congress on many aspects of
not fit to rule. the struggle for freedom.
The Congress ministries resigned He along with Jawaharlal
in October 1939 after the outbreak of Nehru opposed the Motilal Nehru
the Second World War. Report which spoke for dominion
The Congress victory resulted in what status for India. Bose was all for full
appeared to be an anti-labor shift in independence; he also announced the
Congress attitudes that led to formation of the Independence
the Bombay Traders Disputes Act in League. When the Lahore Congress
1938. session under Jawaharlal
Nehru’s presidency adopted a
………………………………………… resolution that the Congress goal
………
would be Toorna Swaraj’, Bose fully but nominated by the president; the
endorsed the decision. election of the president is thus a
constitutional opportunity through
➢ Haripura which the members expressed the
nature of the leadership of the
At the Congress meeting in Haripura, Congress.
Gujarat, in February 1938, Bose A resolution was moved by Govind
was unanimously elected president Ballabh Pant, reaffirming faith in
of the session. He was firm in his Gandhian policies and asking Bose
belief that the Congress ministries in to nominate the working committee
the provinces had immense Lin in accordance with the wishes of
revolutionary potential, as he said in Gandhiji i”, and it was passed
his presidential address. without opposition from the
Bose also talked of the economic socialists or the communists.
development of the country through Gandhi was not willing to lead a
planning and was instrumental in Congress struggle based on the
setting up a National Planning radical lines preferred by Bose, even
Committee later. as Bose was not willing to
The session adopted a resolution compromise on his ideas. They
that Congress would give moral preferred a united Congress led by
support to those who were agitating Gandhi, as the national struggle was
against the governance in the of utmost importance
princely states. Bose resigned from the president’s
post in April 1939.
➢ 1939: Subhash Wins but Congress
Faces Internal Strife ➢ Gandhi and Bose: Ideological
It got 91 per cent of non-Muslim votes. The success of nationalist forces in the
It captured 57 out of 102 seats in the struggle for hegemony was fairly
Central Assembly. evident by the end of the War.
In the provincial elections, it got a Nationalism had penetrated into
majority in most provinces except in hitherto untouched sections and areas.
Bengal, Sindh and Punjab. There was a demonstration in favour of
The Congress majority provinces nationalism among the bureaucracy
included the NWFP and Assam which and the loyalist sections; because the
were being claimed for Pakistan. paucity of European ICS recruits and a
policy of Indianisation had ended the
➢ Muslim League’s Performance British domination of the ICS and
by 1939, there existed a British-Indian
It got 86.6 per cent of the Muslim parity.
votes. British strategy of conciliation and
It captured the 30 reserved seats in the repression had its limitations and
Central Assembly. contradictions
In the provincial elections, it got a After the Cripps’ Offer, there was little
majority in Bengal and Sindh. left to offer for conciliation except for
Unlike in 1937, now the League full freedom.
clearly established itself as the When non-violent resistance was
dominant party among Muslims. repressed with force, the naked force
In Punjab A Unionist-Congress-Akali behind the government stood exposed,
coalition under Khizr Hayat Khan while if the government did not clamp
assumed power. down on sedition' or made offers for a
truce, it was seen to be unable to wield
➢ Significant Features of Elections- authority, and its prestige suffered.
Efforts to woo the Congress dismayed ➢ Cabinet Mission Arrives
the loyalists. This policy of an unclear
mix presented a dilemma for the The Cabinet Mission reached Delhi
services, who nevertheless had to on March 24, 1946. It had prolonged
implement it. The prospect of Congress discussions with Indian leaders of all
ministries coming to power in the parties and groups on the issues of (i)
provinces further compounded this interim government; and (ii) principles
dilemma. and procedures for framing a new
Constitutionalism or Congress constitution giving freedom to India.
Raj had proved to be a big morale-
booster and helped in deeper ➢ Cabinet Mission Plan—Main
penetration of patriotic sentiments
among the masses. Points
Demands of leniency for INA prisoners
Rejection of the demand for a full-
from within the Army and the revolt of
the RIN ratings had raised fears that fledged Pakistan,
the armed forces may not be as reliable (i) Grouping of existing provincial
if the Congress started a 1942-type assemblies into three sections: Section-
mass movement, this time aided by the A: Madras, Bombay, Central
provincial ministries. Provinces, United Provinces, Bihar and
The Only alternative to all-out Orissa; Hindu-majority provinces)
repression of a mass movement was an Section-B: Punjab, North
entirely official rule which seemed (ii) West Frontier Province and Sindh
impossible now because the necessary (Muslim-majority provinces) Section-
numbers and efficient officials were C: Bengal and Assam (Muslim-
not available. majority provinces).
Three-tier executive and legislature at
The government realised that a
settlement was necessary for burying provincial, section and union levels.
A constituent assembly was to be
the ghost of a mass movement and for
good future Indo-British relations elected by provincial assemblies by
proportional representation. This
➢ On the Eve of Cabinet Mission constituent assembly would be a 389-
Plan- member body.
In the constituent assembly, members
The Congress demanded that power from groups A, B and C were to sit
be transferred to one centre and that separately to decide the constitution for
minorities' demands be worked out in a provinces and if possible, for the
framework ranging from autonomy to groups also. Then, the whole
Muslim- majority provinces to self- constituent assembly would sit together
determination or secession from the to formulate the union constitution.
Indian Union—but, only after the A common centre would control
British left. defence, communication and external
affairs. A federal structure was option of not joining a group in the
envisaged for India. first place.
Communal questions in the central Compulsory grouping contradicts the
legislature were to be decided by a oft-repeated insistence on provincial
simple majority of both communities autonomy.
present and voting. Absence of provision for elected
Provinces were to have full autonomy members from the princely states in the
and residual powers. constituent assembly was not
Princely states were no longer to be acceptable.
under the paramountcy of the British
government. They would be free to ➢ League
enter into an arrangement with
successor governments or the British Grouping should be compulsory with
government. sections B and C developing into solid
After the first general elections, a entities with a view to future secession
province was to be free to come out of into Pakistan.
a group and after 10 years, a province
was to be free to call for a ➢ Acceptance and Rejection
reconsideration of the group or the
union constitution. Muslim League on June 6 and the
Meanwhile, an interim government was Congress on June 24, 1946, accepted
to be formed from the constituent the long-term plan put forward by the
assembly. Cabinet Mission.
July 1946 Elections were held in
➢ Different Interpretations of the provincial assemblies for the
Grouping Clause Constituent Assembly.
July 10, 1946, Nehru stated, "We are
Congress: To the Congress, the not bound by a single thing except that
Cabinet Mission Plan was against the we have decided to go into the
creation of Pakistan since grouping Constituent Assembly. The big
was optional; one constituent assembly probability is that there would be no
was envisaged, and the League no grouping as NWFP and Assam would
longer had a veto. have objections to joining sections B
Muslim League: The Muslim League and C.”
believed Pakistan to be implied in a July 29, 1946, The League withdrew
compulsory grouping. its acceptance of the long-term plan in
response to Nehru’s statement and
Main Objections gave a call for "direct action" from
➢ Congress August 16 to achieve Pakistan.
Provinces should not have to wait till ➢ Communal Holocaust and the
the first general elections to come out Interim Government
of a group. They should have the
From August 16, 1946, the Indian viceroy demanding the resignation of
scene was rapidly transformed. There League members and threatening the
were communal riots on an withdrawal of their own nominees.
unprecedented scale, which left around
several thousand dead. The worst-hit Characteristic Features of Indian
areas were Calcutta, Bombay, Communalism
Noakhali, Bihar and Garhmukteshwar Communalism (more accurately
(United Provinces). ‘sectarianism') is basically an ideology,
Changed Government Priorities- which gives more importance to one’s
Wavell was now eager to somehow get own ethnic/religious group rather than to
the Congress into the Interim the wider society as a whole, evolved
Government, even if the League stayed through three broad stages in India.
out ➢ Communal Nationalism
Interim Government-Fearing mass
action by the Congress, a Congress- The notion that since a group or a
dominated Interim Government headed section of people belong to a particular
by Nehru was sworn in on September religious community, their secular
2, 1946, Wavell quietly brought the interests are the same, i.e., even those
Muslim League into the Interim matters which have got nothing to do
Government on October 26, 1946. The with religion affect all of them equally.
League was allowed to join
(i) without giving up the ‘direct ➢ Liberal Communalism
action’;
(ii) despite its rejection of the Cabinet The notion that since two religious
Mission’s long term and short-term communities have different religious
plans; and interests, they have different interests
(iii) despite the insistence on in the secular sphere also (i.e., in
compulsory grouping with decisions economic, political and cultural
being taken by a majority vote by a spheres).
section as a whole
➢ Extreme Communalism
➢ Obstructionist Approach and
Ulterior Motives of League- The notion that not only do different
religious communities have different
The League did not attend the interests but also that these interests
Constituent Assembly which had its are incompatible, i.e., two communities
first meeting on December 9, 1946. cannot co-exist because the interests of
Consequently, the Assembly had to one community come into conflict with
confine itself to passing a general those of the other.
'Objectives Resolution' drafted by
Jawaharlal Nehru. ➢ Reasons for Growth of
In February 1947, nine Congress Communalism
members of the cabinet wrote to the
Socio-economic Reasons 1916: The Congress accepted the
British Policy of Divide and Rule Muslim League demand of separate
Communalism in History Writing electorates and the Congress and the
Side-effects of socio-religious Reform League presented joint demands to the
Movements-Reform movements such government.
as the Wahabi Movement among 1920-22: Muslims participated in the
Muslims and Shuddhi among Hindus Rowlatt and Khilafat Non-Cooperation
with their militant overtones made the agitations but there was a communal
role of religion more vulnerable to element in the political outlook of the
communalism. Muslims.
Side-effects of Militant Nationalism The 1920s: The shadow of communal
Communal Reaction by Majority riots loomed large over the country.
Community-The Rashtriya 1928: The Nehru Report on
Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) was constitutional reforms as suggested by
established in 1925 the Congress was opposed by Muslim
hardliners and the Sikh League.
➢ Evolution of the Two-Nation
Theory- The development of the two- ➢ By negotiating with the Muslim
nation theory over the years is as League, Congress made a number of
follows: mistakes:
1887: Syed Ahmed Khan appealed to It gave legitimacy to the politics of the
the educated Muslims to stay away League, thus giving recognition to the
from the Congress, although some division of society into separate
Muslims did join the Congress. communities with separate interests.
1906: Agha Khan led a Muslim It undermined the role of secular,
delegation (called the Shimla nationalist Muslims.
delegation) to the viceroy, Lord Minto, Concessions to one community
to demand separate electorates for prompted other communities to
Muslims at all levels demand similar concessions.
1909: Separate electorates were Launching an all-out attack on
awarded under Morley-Minto Reforms. communalism became difficult.
Punjab Hindu Sabha was founded by 1930-34: Some Muslim groups, such
U.N. Mukherji and Lai Chand. as the Jamaat- ulema-i-Hind, State of
1915: The first session of All India Kashmir and Khudai Khidmatgar
Hindu Mahasabha was held under the participated in the Civil Disobedience
aegis of the Maharaja of Kasim Bazar. Movement but overall the participation
1912-24: During this period, the of Muslims was nowhere attended all
Muslim League was dominated by three of them.
younger Muslim nationalists, but their 1932: The Communal Award accepted
nationalism was inspired by a all Muslim communal demands
communal view of political questions. contained in the 14 points.
After 1937: After the Muslim League
performed badly in the 1937 provincial the Indian subcontinent. Clement
elections, it decided to resort to Attlee
extreme communalism. There were ➢ Main Points of Attlee’s Statement
several reasons for the advent of
extreme communalism. The deadline of June 30, 1948, was
With increasing radicalisation, the fixed for transfer of power even if
reactionary elements searched for a the Indian politicians had not agreed
social base through channels of by that time on the constitution.
communalism. British would relinquish power
The colonial administration had either to some form of central
exhausted all other means to divide government or in some areas to the
nationalists. existing provincial governments if
Earlier failures to challenge communal the constituent assembly was not
tendencies had emboldened the fully representative, i.e., if the
communal forces. Muslim majority provinces did not
1937-39: Jinnah blocked all avenues join.
for conciliation by forwarding the British powers and obligations vis-
impossible demand that the Congress a-vis the princely states would lapse
should declare itself a Hindu with the transfer of power, but these
organisation and recognise the Muslim would not be transferred to any
League as the sole representative of successor government in British
the Indian Muslims. India.
March 24, 1940: The 'Pakistan Mountbatten would replace Wavell
Resolution' was passed at the Lahore as the viceroy. The statement
session of the Muslim League contained clear hints of partition and
During Second World War The British even Balkanisation of the country
India Government gave a virtual veto into numerous states and was, in
to the League on a political settlement. essence, a reversion of the Cripps
Offer.
…………………………………………
………. ➢ Why a Date Fixed by Government
for Withdrawal
Independence with Partition
The government hoped that a fixed
Attlee’s Statement of February 20,
1947 date would shock the parties into an
Clement Attlee, the British prime agreement on the main question.
The government was keen to avert
minister, sensing the trouble all around,
made an announcement on February 20, the developing constitutional crisis.
The government hoped to convince
1947. The British House of Commons
declared the British intention of leaving the Indians of British sincerity.
Truth in WavelTs assessment could
no longer be denied.
➢ Congress Stand Sindh would take its own decision.
Referendums in NWFP and the
Provision of transfer of power to Sylhet district of Bengal would
more than one center was acceptable decide the fate of these areas.
to Congress because it meant that the Since the Congress had conceded a
existing assembly could go ahead unified India, all their other points
and frame a constitution for the areas would be met, namely,
represented by it, and it offered a (i) Independence for princely states
way out of the existing deadlock. ruled out—they would join either
India or Pakistan;
➢ Independence and Partition (ii) Independence for Bengal ruled
out;
On March 10, 1947, Nehru stated the accession of Hyderabad to
that the Cabinet Mission was the best Pakistan ruled out;
solution if carried out; the only real (iii) freedom to come on August 15,
alternative was the partition of 1947; and
Punjab and Bengal. In April 1947, (iv) A boundary commission to be
the Congress president, Kripalani, set up if the partition was to be
communicated to the viceroy effected.
Mountbatten as the
Viceroy, Mountbatten proved more ➢ Why Congress Accepted Dominion
firm and quick in taking decisions Status
than his predecessors because he was
informally given more powers to It would ensure a peaceful and quick
decide things on the spot. His task transfer of power;
was to explore the options of unity It was more important for Congress
and division till October 1947 and to assume the authority to check the
then advise the British government explosive situation; and
Would allow for some much-needed
on the form of transfer of power. continuity in the bureaucracy and the
Louis Mountbatten army.
➢ Mountbatten Plan, June 3,1947 ➢ The rationale for an Early Date
(August 15, 1947)
Punjab and Bengal Legislative
Assemblies would meet in two The plan was put into effect without
groups, Hindus and Muslims, to vote the slightest delay. The legislative
for partition. If a simple majority of assemblies of Bengal and Punjab
either group voted for partition, then decided in favor of the partition of
these provinces would be partitioned. these two provinces.
In the case of partition, two Thus, East Bengal and West Punjab
dominions and two constituent joined Pakistan; West Bengal and
assemblies would be created.
East Punjab remained with the There was a delay in announcing the
Indian Union. Boundary Commission Award
(under Radcliffe); though the award
was ready by August 12, 1947,
➢ Indian Independence Act Mountbatten decided to make it
public after August 15 so that the
On July 5, 1947, the British British could escape all
Parliament passed the Indian responsibility of disturbances.
Independence Act which was based
on the Mountbatten Plan, and the Act ➢ Integration of States
got royal assent on June 18, 1947.
The act was implemented on August In July 1947, Vallabhbhai Patel took
15, 1947. charge of the new States Department.
Act provided for the creation of two Under Patel, the incorporation of
independent dominions of India and Indian states took place in two
Pakistan with effect from August 15, phases with a skillful combination of
1947. baits and threats of mass pressure in
As per the provisions of the Indian both.
Independence Act, 1947, Pakistan Phase I By August 15, 1947, all
became independent on August 14 states except Kashmir, Hyderabad,
while India got its freedom and Junagarh had signed an
on August 15, 1947. instrument of accession with the
Jinnah became the first Governor- Indian government
General of Pakistan. Phase II the second phase involved a
India, however, decided to request much more difficult process of
Lord Mountbatten to continue as "integration' of states with
the Governor-General of India. neighboring provinces or into new
units
➢ Problems of Early withdrawal
Inevitability of Partition
The breakneck speed of events under ➢ Why Congress Accepted Partition
Mountbatten caused anomalies in
arranging the details of partition and Congress was only accepting the
totally failed to prevent the Punjab inevitable due to the long-term
massacre, because failure to draw the Muslim masses
there were no transitional into the national movement.
institutional structures within which Congress had a two-fold task—(i)
partition problems could be tackled; structuring diverse classes,
Mountbatten had hoped to be the communities, groups, and regions
common Governor-General of India into a nation, and (ii) securing
and Pakistan, thus providing the independence for this nation.
necessary link, but Jinnah wanted the Only an immediate transfer of power
position for himself in Pakistan; could forestall the spread of direct
action" and communal violence. The Contrary to their pre-1857 intentions of
virtual collapse of the Interim trying to modernize India on progressive
Government also made the notion of lines, now the administration adopted
Pakistan appear unavoidable. blatantly reactionary policies on the
The partition plan ruled out pretext that Indians were not fit for self-
independence for the princely states governance and needed British presence
which could have been a greater in their lives.
danger to Indian unity as it would ➢ Divide and Rule
have meant Balkanisation of the
country. Determined to avoid a united mass
Acceptance of partition was only a action challenging their authority,
final act of the process of step-by- the British rulers in India decided to
step concessions to the League's practice a naked policy of divide and
championing of a separate Muslim rule.
state.
When the CWC resolution stated that ➢ Hostility Towards Educated
Punjab (and by implication, Bengal) Indians:
must be partitioned if the country
was divided and With the 3rd June At a time when the nationalist
Plan, Congress accepted partition. movement was born (Indian National
While loudly asserting the Congress was founded in 1885), the
sovereignty of the Constituent British interpreted the moves as a
Assembly, the Congress quietly challenge to their authority and
accepted compulsory grouping and adopted a hostile attitude to such
accepted the partition most of all leadership.
because it could not stop the
communal riots. ➢ Attitude Towards the Zamindars:
➢ Eka Movement
High rents—50 percent higher than ➢ The All India Kisan
the recorded rates; oppression of Congress/Sabha
thikadars in charge of revenue
collection; and practice of share- This sabha was founded in Lucknow
rents. in April 1936 with Swami Sahjanand
Meetings of the Eka or the Unity Saraswati as the president and N.G.
Movement involved a symbolic Ranga as the general secretary.
religious ritual in which the
assembled peasants vowed that they ➢ Under Congress Ministries
would
pay only the recorded rent but would The period 1937-39 was the high
pay it on time; not leave when watermark of the peasant movements
evicted; refuse to do forced labor; and activity under the Congress
Give no help to criminals; abide by provincial rule.
panchayat decisions.
➢ Peasant Activity in Provinces
➢ Mappila Revolt
Kerala: One significant campaign
Mappilas were the Muslim tenants by the peasants was in 1938 for the
inhabiting the Malabar region. The amendment of the Malabar
communication of the rebellion Tenancy Act, 1929.
completed the isolation of the Andhra: This region had already
Mappilas from the Khilafat-Non- witnessed a decline in the prestige of
Cooperation Movement. zamindars after their defeat by
By December 1921, all resistance Congressmen in elections. Anti-
had come to a stop. zamindar movements were going on
in some.
➢ Bardoli Satyagraha Bihar: Provincial Kisan Sabha
developed a rift with the Congress
Bardoli taluka in Surat district had over the 'bakashl land' issue because
witnessed intense politicization after of an unfavorable government
the coming of Gandhi on the national resolution which was not acceptable
political scene. to the sabha. The movement died out
The movement sparked off by August 1939.
in January 1926 when the Punjab: A new direction to the
authorities decided to increase the movement was given by the Punjab
land revenue by 30 percent. Kisan Committee in 1937. The main
Women of Bardoli gave Vallabhbhai targets of the movement were the
Patel the title of “Sardar” landlords of western Punjab who
In February 1926, Vallabhbhai dominated the unionist ministry.
Patel was called to lead the Peasant activity was also organized
movement. in Bengal (Burdwan and 24
Parganas), Assam (Surma Valley),
Orissa, Central Provinces, and These movements created an
NWFP. atmosphere for post-independence
During the War: Because of a pro- agrarian reforms, for instance, the
War line adopted by the communists, abolition of zamindari.
the AIKS was split on communist They eroded the power of the landed
and non-communist lines class, thus adding to the
transformation of the agrarian
Post-War Phase structure.
➢ Tebhaga Movement These movements were based on the
ideology of nationalism.
The storm center of the movement The nature of these movements was
was north Bengal, principally among similar in diverse areas.
Rajbanshis - a low caste of tribal
origin. Muslims also participated in …………………………………………
large numbers. ……….