0% found this document useful (0 votes)

22 views

Arm Designs and Issues Part 1

The document summarizes a panel discussion on tubular steel arm designs and issues. The panel discussed the need for improved arm designs, validating arm connection designs, and understanding issues related to wind-induced vibration effects on tubular steel arms. Specific topics included arm design methodology, materials, manufacturing/welding processes, assembly practices, and mitigating challenges through robust engineering designs validated by full-scale testing.

Uploaded by

Oscar Chirinos

We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.

Available Formats

Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

0% found this document useful (0 votes)

22 views

Arm Designs and Issues Part 1

Uploaded by

Oscar Chirinos

We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.

Available Formats

Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

You are on page 1/ 15

Transmission Workshop

Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues
" Need for Improvement in Arm Design?
Ajay Mallik, P.E., SANPEC, Inc.

" Has Your Arm Connection Design Been Validated?

Ric Slocum, S.E., P.E., David Nahlen, P.E., Thomas & Betts Corp.

" Wind Induced Vibration Effects on Tubular Steel Arms:

Do We Really Understand the Current Issues?
Wesley J. Oliphant, P.E., ReliaPOLE Inspection Services Company
Transmission Workshop
Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues

Need for Improvement in Arm Design:

Consideration for new design approach?

Ajay Mallik, P.E.

President, SANPEC, Inc.
Ph: 832-392-4230
Email: [email protected]

Date: Sept 12, 2013

Transmission Workshop
Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues

Why Arms are Failing?

Several Factors Involved:

" Design Methodology (Discussion)

" Materials (Steel, Welding Electrode)

" Manufacturing/Welding process

" Assembly & Erection Practices

" Wind Induced Vibration

Transmission Workshop
Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues

ASCE/SEI 48-11:

" No Standard Design Method available

" Provides some basic details and layout
" Fabricators responsibility
" Empirical Formula

" FEM Method

" R&D (Full Scale Testing)

Transmission Workshop
Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues

Today’s Challenge:

" Arms are Failing at Job Site

" Projects are Getting Delayed
" Costing Millions of Dollars in Downtime
" Pointing Fingers for the Responsibility:
" Pole Manufacturers

" Utility Customers

" Location of Poles

(Terrain and Gusting Wind)

Transmission Workshop
Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues

How to Mitigate the Challenges:

" Develop a robust engineering design

" Validate the design with Full Scale Testing
" Consideration of Dynamic/Cyclic Loading
" Follow the best manufacturing process
" Develop Proven Solutions to increase the fatigue
life of arms at the weld joints
" Follow the best practices during construction
and assembly of steel pole structures
Transmission Workshop
Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues

Design Methodology:

" Arm Configuration : Six (6) Sided or Eight (8)

Sided or Hex-Elliptical
" Bracket Type: Cold Bend, Hot Bend or Three
Piece Brackets
" Factor of Safety (FOS)
" Welding: Full penetration or Partial Penetration
" Design consideration for Fatigue Stress
Transmission Workshop
Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues

Arm Design:

" Avoid high Stress concentration

at points by changing arm
configuration
" Eight sided (8) arm performs
better under fatigue stress
" Hex-Elliptical arm with high
aspect ratio gives high stress
concentration at points
Transmission Workshop
Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues

Arm Design (cont.):

" Try to limit the ratio of Arm

(F/F) dia and Bracket Ht (H/D)
to the range 1.5 - 2 (Max.)
" Limit the % usage at arm base
to 70%- 75% (Max.)
" For Galvanized arm, limit the
drainage hole size to very
minimum
Transmission Workshop
Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues

Bracket Design:

" Check Bending Stress

" Vertical plane (1-1)

" Horizontal Plane (2-2)

" Slant Plane (3-3)

" Use the Max. Bending Stress

" Limit the ratio of Yield strength
of member and Actual Bending
Stress to 1.50 (Min.)
Transmission Workshop
Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues

Bracket Design (Cont.):

" Types of Bracket (U-Shape):

" Cold Bending Bracket

" More Leg Spacing due

large inside bend radius
" High Bending Stress

" Hot Bending Bracket

" Less Leg Spacing due

small inside bend radius
" Less Bending Stress

" Mostly Preferred

Transmission Workshop
Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues

Bracket Design (Cont.):

Face Plate
" Three (3) Piece Bracket
" Ideal Preference for
bigger arm size
" Option to increase the
thick. of face plate
Transmission Workshop
Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues

Welding Preference

" Partial Penetration Weld:

" Meets the static loading
on arms
" Pole Vendors preference

" Complete Penetration Weld:

" Meets the static loading
on arms
" Increase the life for
fatigue resistance
" Challenge for small dia
arms
Transmission Workshop
Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues

Fatigue Stress:

" Cyclic Stresses at arm base

" Conductor Aeolian vibration can produce
both vertical and horizontal or combination
movements of the tip of the arm
" Static stresses adjacent to weld at base is
generally 2 to 3 times higher than predicted
by ultimate strength design methods
" Fatigue cracks generally originate from
typical weld discontinuities and high stress
concentration at corners of arm
Transmission Workshop
Panel Discussion:
Tubular Steel Arm Designs & Issues