Yang 2004
Yang 2004
Shicheng Yang, Yurong Fu, Seong Hoon Jeong and Kinam Park
Abstract
Poly(acrylic acid) superporous hydrogel (SPH) microparticles possessing a unique porous structure
were used as a wicking agent to decrease disintegration time of fast-disintegrating tablets (FDTs).
The compression behaviour of poly(acrylic acid) SPH microparticles was evaluated using the
Kawakita equation. Effects of various SPH microparticle sizes and a 19-run fractional factorial design
were evaluated. The factorial design was based on four factors consisting of ketoprofen, SPH
microparticle, filler, and tableting pressure, and each factor contained three levels on the disinte-
gration time and tensile strength of the prepared FDTs. The poly(acrylic acid) SPH microparticles
existed in an amorphous state and swelled approximately 80-times in distilled water and 50-times in
pH 6.8 0.2 M phosphate buffer. The compressibility of SPH microparticles increased significantly as the
microparticle size increased. The FDTs made of SPH microparticles in the range of 75Å –106 ·m showed
the fastest disintegration time and higher tensile strength. SPH microparticle, tableting pressure and
ketoprofen had significant effects on disintegration time and tensile strength of ketoprofen FDTs.
The FDTs that were prepared with 2.5% w/w SPH microparticles of 75Å –106 ·m at 63 MPa pressure
possessed a tensile strength of 84.4 ± 4.1 N cm¡2 and disintegrated in 15.0 ± 2.0 s. It was concluded
that the poly(acrylic acid) SPH microparticles could serve as a good super-disintegrant decreasing the
disintegration time of FDTs.
Introduction
Drug delivery using fast-disintegrating tablets (FDTs) is rapidly gaining interest in the
pharmaceutical industry since the tablets either disintegrate or dissolve in the mouth
rapidly, without requiring any water to aid in swallowing. This novel dosage form is
suitable for all age groups, particularly for children, the elderly and schizophrenic
patients who have difficulty in swallowing conventional tablets and capsules (Lindgren
& Janzon 1993). To ensure the tablet’s fast-disintegrating property, water must be
Purdue University, Departments quickly absorbed into the tablet matrix causing rapid disintegration of the tablet. The
of Industrial and Physical current approaches of making fast-disintegrating tablets are maximizing the porous
Pharmacy, West Lafayette,
structure of the tablet matrix and incorporating appropriate disintegrating agents and/
Indiana, 47907, USA
or highly water-soluble excipients in the tablet formulation (Chang et al 2000; Habib
Shicheng Yang, Yurong Fu, et al 2000; Sastry et al 2000; Dobetti 2000).
Seong Hoon Jeong, Kinam Park
Direct compression is the easiest way of manufacturing tablets. The biggest advan-
tages are the low manufacturing cost and high mechanical property of the tablets
Correspondence: K. Park, Purdue (Takao et al 1996). Disintegration and solubilization of direct-compression tablets are
University, School of Pharmacy, based on single or combined actions of disintegrants, water-soluble excipients, and
575 Stadium Mall Drive,
Room G22, West Lafayette,
effervescent agents (Shangraw et al 1980). In many cases, the disintegrants play a major
IN 47907-2051, USA. role in the disintegration and dissolution process of FDTs made by direct compression.
E-mail: [email protected] The choice of a suitable type and an optimal amount of disintegrant is critical for
ensuring fast disintegration (Dobetti 2000). The super-disintegrants, such as sodium
Funding: This study was starch glycolate and sodium croscarmellose, have been used as wicking agents in the
supported in part by NSF
Industry/University Center for
FDT formulations (Bi et al 1999; Khankari et al 2001; Mattsson et al 2001).
Pharmaceutical Processing Recently, superporous hydrogel (SPH) blocks with fast swelling and super-
Research and Samyang Corp. absorbent properties have been developed (Park et al 2001b) for developing a gastric
429
430 Shicheng Yang et al
retention device (Chen et al 1999; Chen & Park 2000). SPHs 1.25 £ 10¡1 M (10.5 g) NaHCO3. The whole solution was
are hydrogels with numerous pores connected together to stirred vigorously by magnetic stirring to accelerate foam-
form open channel structures. Water is absorbed into the ing and to evenly distribute the gas bubbles. The gelling
dried SPHs by capillary wetting rather than by diffusion. started within 30 s. Synthesis process was carried out under
The dried SPH hydrogels swell extremely fast with the a nitrogen atmosphere.
swelling ratio easily reaching more than 100-times within Synthesis of the poly(acrylic acid) hydrogel and poly
minutes (Chen et al 1999; Park et al 2001a). (acrylic acid) was similar to the synthesis of poly(acrylic
SPH microparticles, having a unique porous structure acid) SPH, but the foaming agent NaHCO3 was omit-
for fast transport of water through capillary forces, are ted in the synthesis of poly(acrylic acid) hydrogel; and
expected to result in an extremely fast wicking effect into NaHCO3 and crosslinker PEGDA were deleted in the
the tablet core. Tablets prepared by direct compression in synthesis of poly(acrylic acid). The synthesized poly(acrylic
the presence of SPH microparticles are thought to dis- acid), SPH and hydrogel were purified with absolute ethyl
integrate very quickly due to the fast uptake of water into alcohol and dried in an oven at 50 ¯ C. The dried samples
the core of the tablets (Park 2002). To evaluate the effect were milled using IKA A11 BASIC (IKA Works, INC;
of SPH microparticles on the disintegration and tensile Wilmington, NC) and the resultant microparticles were
strength of FDTs prepared by direct compression, FDTs screened using different sieves to get various particle size
containing sugar-based excipients and ketoprofen, a model ranges.
drug, were prepared using SPH microparticles as a dis-
integrant. A SPH based on poly(acrylic acid), sodium salt,
was synthesized and characterized. The fast disintegrating Swelling of SPH microparticles
tablets composed of various amounts of SPH microparti- Samples of SPH microparticles (0.10 g) were placed in a
cles were prepared using a fractional factorial design. The series of graduated cylinders (50 mL). Deionized water or
formulation and process were optimized according to the 0.2 M phosphate buffer (25 mL) was added into the cylin-
disintegration time and tensile strength of resultant tablets. der. The system was mixed and left to stand at 37 ¯ C. After
60 min, the volumes of the swollen samples at equilibrium
were measured and the swelling value calculated using the
Materials and Methods following equation (Edge et al 2002):
in the range of 10±90% relative humidity. The relative Table 1 Factors and levels in the fractional factorial experimental
humidity was held at each 5% relative humidity increment design.
until equilibrium occurred. During the desorption period
the same steps were taken in the reverse order, starting Factor Label Level
from 90% relative humidity. The temperature in the incu-
1 2 3
bator was controlled at 25 ¯ C. Sample mass was repre-
sented as a percentage of the dried mass. A Ketoprofen (% w/w) 0 10 20
B SPH* (% w/w) 0 2.5 5
Tablet preparation C Dextrates:mannitol 1:0 4:1 3:2
D Pressure (MPa) 42 63 84
Tablets of 500 mg were compressed on a single punch
Carver Laboratory Press (Carver Inc. Wabash, IN) at *SPH microparticles of 75±106 ·m.
different compression pressures using plane-face punches
with a diameter of 0.5 inch.
Compression data analysis Hardness Tester (Vankel, 36 Meridan Road, Edison, NJ).
The tablet tensile strength (¼x ) of FDTs was calculated
Poly(acrylic acid) SPH microparticles in the range from the following equation (Fell & Newton 1970):
25±250 ·m were dried at 60 ¯ C for 12 h. The pure SPH
microparticle tablets were compressed at pressure ranging ¼x ˆ 2F/ºDT …4†
from 7 to 615 MPa. Changes in density or porosity of
SPH tablets were obtained by measuring the thickness of
resultant tablets at zero pressure. The densification behav- Disintegration time
iour of SPH microparticles was evaluated by means of
the Kawakita equation (Kawakita & Ludde 1971; Denny The disintegration time of the resultant tablets was meas-
2002) as follows: ured using a Basket-rack assembly according to the
USP24/NF19 method.
P/C ˆ P/a ‡ 1/ab …2†
Table 2 Swelling values of poly(acrylic acid) superporous hydrogel Moisture sorption isotherm curve of poly
microparticles with various sizes. (acrylic acid) SPH microparticles
Size (mm) Swelling value (cm3 g¡1) Absorption and desorption of moisture by poly(acrylic
acid) SPH microparticles were measured with the sorption
Distilled water Phosphate buffer balance at 25 ¯ C as shown in Figure 2. The moisture
absorption increased with the increase of relative humidity.
25±44 77.5 § 2.5 47.5 § 2.5
Absorption of water was as high as 150% of the dry mass
44±106 78.0 § 2.0 48.0 § 2.0
106±150 80.0 § 2.5 50.0 § 2.5 at the relative humidity 90%, which may have been due to
150±250 82.5 § 2.5 52.5 § 2.5 the high hygroscopic property and high porosity of the
SPH. Absorption and desorption behaviour of the SPH
Swelling data represent mean § s.d. (n ˆ 3). microparticles were similar in the range of 35±90% relative
humidity. However, the water content at desorption was
higher than the corresponding values at absorption when
the relative humidity was below 35%. The difference may
the same SPH in blocks. The swelling values of sodium have been due to the fact that desorption of moisture from
starch glycolate were approximately 20-times (Ferrari et al SPH needed a longer time than the predetermined time of
2000; Edge et al 2002) and croscarmellose sodium rapidly 3 h at 25 ¯ C.
swelled to approximately 10-times on contact with distilled
water (Ferrari et al 2000). Compared with these commer-
Compressibility and compactability study of SPH
cially available super-disintegrants, the SPH microparticles
microparticles
showed the highest swelling values for a better disintegrant
efficiency in tablets. The compressibility and compactability has a direct rela-
tionship with the tableting performance of the particulate
Crystallinity of poly(acrylic acid) SPH solids. The compactability of SPH microparticles was mea-
sured by plotting the SPH tablet tensile strength as a func-
microparticles
tion of compaction pressure. The tablet tensile strength
The X-ray diffraction diagrams of microparticles of poly increased in a sigmoid shape following the pressure in-
(acrylic acid) SPH, poly(acrylic acid) hydrogel and poly crease. As the pressure increased higher than 400 MPa, the
(acrylic acid) are shown in Figure 1. There was no sharp tablet tensile strength did not increase any further.
peak in the X-ray diffraction diagrams, indicating that the The compressibility behaviour of poly(acrylic acid) SPH
three polymers existed in an amorphous state. Poly(acrylic microparticles was analysed by measuring the relationship
acid) SPH was different from poly(acrylic acid) hydrogel between compression pressure and the relative volume
and poly(acrylic acid) in the diagrams. This difference decrease of the microparticles using the Kawakita equation
may have been due to the existence of sodium in the (Figure 3). When the pressure was lower than 63 MPa, a
crosslinked amorphous network of poly(acrylic acid) curvature appeared for various ranges of microparticle
SPH, since SPH particles were not washed with water to sizes. Straight lines (r2 > 0.9900) were observed at the pres-
remove the salts. sure higher than 63 MPa for various particle sizes. In the
180
Mass in percent of dry sample (%)
Desorption
140
120
Poly(acrylic acid) 100
80
Poly(acrylic acid) hydrogel 60
40
20
0
5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
2q, degrees Relative humidity (%)
Figure 1 X-ray diffraction diagrams of poly(acrylic acid), poly Figure 2 The absorption and desorption of moisture by poly
(acrylic acid) hydrogel, and poly(acrylic acid) superporous hydrogel (acrylic acid) superporous hydrogel microparticles as measured by a
microparticles. sorption balance at 25 ¯ C. Mean value § s.d. (n ˆ 3).
Superporous hydrogel microparticles for fast-disintegrating tablets 433
1600 350 A
150–250 mm Magnesium stearate
1400 106–150 mm 300
Fumed silica
44–106 mm
1000 200
P/ C
800 150
600
100
400
50
200
0
0 0–25 25–44 44–75 75– 106– 150– 180–
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 106 150 180 250
Pressure (MPa) SPH particle size (mm)
Fast disintegrating tablets the SPH microparticle sizes decreased from 180±250 ·m
to 25±44 ·m. However, when the microparticle size was
The FDTs containing SPH microparticles and water solu- smaller than 25 ·m, the tensile strength of resultant tablets
ble carbohydrates were evaluated using ketoprofen as a increased as the size decreased. According to the results,
model drug. Ketoprofen is a hydrophobic drug and has the optimal microparticle size should be in the range of
poor compaction properties. If ketoprofen could be suc- 75±106 ·m. From Figure 4, the glidants and/or lubricants
cessfully formulated in FDTs containing SPH microparti- had a significant effect on the disintegration time of the
cles, this study could be easily extended to other drugs. To tablets. The disintegration time of ketoprofen FDTs sig-
mask the unpleasant taste of ketoprofen, all the formula- nificantly increased after the addition of hydrophobic
tions contained 1.5% w/w citric acid, 2.0% w/w aspartame. magnesium stearate as compared with the addition of
silicon dioxide. For the tablets containing a swelling dis-
Effect of SPH microparticle size on the disintegration integrant, a negative effect of magnesium stearate on the
time and tensile strength disintegration time was observed (Smallenbroek et al
The ketoprofen FDT formulations containing 2.5% w/w 1981). Different particle sizes of disintegrants might result
SPH microparticles with different sizes were prepared at in different swelling pressure in the process of tablet
63 MPa pressure. Figure 4 shows the effect of microparti- disintegration (List & Mauzzam 1979). The effect of
cle size on the disintegration time and tensile strength of disintegrants on tablet disintegration time and hard-
ketoprofen FDTs. The minimum disintegration time was ness depends on the physicochemical properties of the
observed when the microparticle size was in the range of disintegrants themselves and formulation composition
75±106 ·m. Tensile strength of the tablets decreased as (Asker et al 1975).
434 Shicheng Yang et al
Experimental design of ketoprofen FDTs porosity. Penetration of water into the tablet was hin-
The disintegration time and tensile strength of ketoprofen dered, and thus the disintegration time increased. Fast
FDTs prepared according to the fractional factorial design dispersible ibuprofen tablets with the optimal porosity of
are shown in Table 3. The analysis of variance results of approximately 13% had the shortest disintegration time
disintegration time indicated that the three factors SPH of 36 s (Schiermeier & Schmidt 2002). Ketoprofen is a
(P < 0.01), pressure (P < 0.05) and ketoprofen content hydrophobic drug that can increase the wetting time of
(P < 0.05) had significant effects on the disintegration tablets as the content in the formulation increases, and
time of ketoprofen FDTs. The proportion of dextrates to thus increase the disintegration time of ketoprofen FDTs.
mannitol had little effect on the disintegration time of The analysis of variance results for tensile strength of
ketoprofen FDTs. ketoprofen FDTs showed that the three factors tableting
SPH microparticles, which acted as a super-disintegrant pressure (P < 0.01), SPH microparticles (P < 0.01) and
in the tablets, was a key factor to tablet disintegration time. ketoprofen (P < 0.05) had significant effect on the tensile
With 2.5% w/w of SPH microparticles (75±106 ·m), the strength of ketoprofen FDTs. The filler had little effect on
disintegration time of ketoprofen FDTs decreased with the the tensile strength of resultant tablets. The tensile
increase of SPH content in tablet formulation. However, the strength of the FDTs greatly increased as the pressure
disintegration time did not decrease with the increase of increased. The tensile strength of tablets or compacts is
SPH content when it was higher than 2.5% w/w. The max- governed by the sum of the bonding forces of all indivi-
imum disintegration force developed in a tablet depended dual interparticulate bonds in the failure plane of the
on the quality and quantity of the disintegrating agent and compact, and the sum increases with the compaction
was related to the amount of water absorbed by the tablet. pressure through rearrangement of particles, particle de-
Water penetration rate, rather than the amount of water formation and fragmentation (Eriksson & Alderborn
absorbed, influenced the disintegration time (Colombo et al 1995; Rankell & Higuchi 1968). However, the tensile
1981). The swelling materials make pore walls hydrophilic, strength of tablets decreased as the amount of SPH micro-
providing enough swelling force to produce interparticle particles increased in the formulation, which may have
bond disruption (Caramella et al 1984). The time taken for been due to the high stress of SPH microparticles.
the tablets to disintegrate was generally reduced by the
addition of a super-disintegrant; the effectiveness of the Selection of the optimum setting
super-disintegrant was dependent on the nature of the An ideal FDT should possess both short disintegration time
compound and excipients used (Mattsson et al 2001). and high mechanical strength. The mechanical strength of a
Porosity depended on the pressure at which tablets tablet is of great importance with regard to the subsequent
were compressed as well as on the nature of the materials packaging process and transportation. The optimal keto-
used. A high compression force led to tablets with a lower profen FDT should have a disintegration time of less than
kinetics, high swelling ratio and high mechanical strength. In: Schiermeier, S., Schmidt, P. C. (2002) Fast dispersible ibuprofen
Ottenbrite, R. M., Kim, S. W. (eds) Polymeric drugs & drug tablets. Eur. J. Pharm. Sci. 15: 295±305
delivery systems. Technomic Publishing Co., Lancaster, PA, Shangraw, R., Mitrevej, A., Shah, M. (1980) A new era of tablet
pp 145±156 disintegrants. Pharm. Technol. 4: 49±57
Rankell, A. S., Higuchi, T. (1968) Physics of tablet compression. Smallenbroek, A. J., Bolhuis, G. K., Lerk, C. F. (1981) The effect
XV. Thermodynamic and kinetic aspects of adhesion under of particle size of disintegrants on the disintegration of tablets.
pressure. J. Pharm. Sci. 57: 574±577 Pharm. Weekbl. [Sci]. 3: 172±175
Sastry, S. V., Nyshadham, J. R., Fix, J. A. (2000) Recent tech- Takao, M., Yoshinori, M., Muneo, F. (1996) Intrabuccally dis-
nological advances in oral drug delivery. A review. Pharma. solving compressed moldings and production process thereof.
Sci. .Technol. Today 3: 138±145 US patent 5,576,014