Admixtures in Concrete - Notes
Admixtures in Concrete - Notes
Difficulties:
o Decreases strength
o Effect can be reduced in moderate strength concrete by lowering water cement
ratio and increasing cement factor
Superplasticizers:
Superplasticizers are ―high-range‖ water reducers. Superplasticizers are
used when placing:
Note: When super plasticizers are used, the fresh concrete stays workable for only
a short period of time (30 min to 60 min), which is why they are usually added
at the site
Retarding concrete admixture:
Used to delay the initial set of concrete. Why do we use them?
Calcium Chloride is the most widely used accelerator. Initial and final set times reduced
CaCl2 by weight Initial Set Time in Hrs.
0% 6
1% 3
2% 2
The PCA (Portland Cement Association) recommends against using calcium chloride
when:
1. Concrete is prestressed
2. Concrete contains embedded aluminum such as conduits
3. Concrete is subjected to alkali-aggregate reaction
4. Concrete is in contact with water or soils containing sulfates
5. Concrete is placed during hot weather
6. Mass application of concrete
Alternatives to CaCl2
1. High early strength cement (type III)
2. Increase cement content
3. cure at higher temperature (if feasible)
4. Triethanolamine, sodium thiocyanate, calcium formate, calcium nitrite or calcium
nitrate
1. Cementitious
o Have hydraulic cementing properties Example: blast furnace slag, natural cement
and hydraulic hydrated lime
2. Pozzolanic
o Siliceous and aluminous material
o Little or no cementitious value
o In presence of moisture, will react with calcium hydroxide to form compounds with
cementitious properties 15% of PC weight is hydrated lime. Addition of pozzolan
could make the hydrated lime into a cementitious material
Fly ash reduces heat of hydration. Silica fume may not affect, but superplasticizers
Hydration
used with silica fume can increase heat.
Fly ash, natural pozzolans, and blast furnace slag increase set time; Can
Set Time
compensate by using accelerator.
Fly ash increases the ultimate strength but reduces rate of strength gain. Silica
Strength
fume has less effect on rate of strength gain than pozzolans.
Drying shrinkage and Low concentrations usually have single effect. High concentrations of ground
creep slag or fly ash may increase shrinkage. Silica fume may reduce shrinkage.
Based on their functions, admixtures can be classified into the following five
major categories:
o Retarding admixtures
o Accelerating admixtures
o Super plasticizers
o Water reducing admixtures
o Air-entraining admixtures
Among other important admixtures that do not fit into these categories are
admixtures whose functions include bonding, shrinkage reduction, damp
proofing and coloring. The following paragraphs provides details on the
above-mentioned categories of concrete admixtures.
Retarding Admixtures
Retarding admixtures slow down the hydration of cement, lengthening set
time. Retarders are beneficially used in hot weather conditions in order to
overcome accelerating effects of higher temperatures and large masses of
concrete on concrete setting time. Because most retarders also act as water
reducers, they are frequently called water-reducing retarders. As per
chemical admixture classification by ASTM-ASTM C 494, type B is simply a
retarding admixture, while type D is both retarding and water reducing,
resulting in concrete with greater compressive strength because of the lower
water-cement ratio.
Accelerating admixtures
Accelerators shorten the set time of concrete, allowing a cold-weather pour,
early removal of forms, early surface finishing, and in some cases, early load
application. Proper care must be taken while choosing the type and
proportion of accelerators, as under most conditions, commonly used
accelerators cause an increase in the drying shrinkage of concrete.
Super plasticizers
Super plasticizers, also known as plasticizers, include water-reducing
admixtures. Compared to what is commonly referred to as a ―water reducer‖
or ―mid-range water reducer‖, super plasticizers are ―high-range water
reducers‖. High range water reducers are admixtures that allow large water
reduction or greater flowability (as defined by the manufacturers, concrete
suppliers and industry standards) without substantially slowing set time or
increasing air entrainment.
Each type of super plasticizer has defined ranges for the required quantities
of concrete mix ingredients, along with the corresponding effects. They can
maintain a specific consistency and workability at a greatly reduced amount
of water. Dosages needed vary by the particular concrete mix and type of
super plasticizer used. They can also produce a high strength concrete. As
with most types of admixtures, super plasticizers can affect other concrete
properties as well. The specific effects, however, should be found from the
manufacturer or concrete supplier.
Air-entraining admixtures
Air-entraining agents entrain small air bubbles in the concrete. The major
benefit of this is enhanced durability in freeze-thaw cycles, especially
relevant in cold climates. While some strength loss typically accompanies
increased air in concrete, it generally can be overcome by reducing the
water-cement ratio via improved workability (due to the air-entraining agent
itself) or through the use of other appropriate admixtures. As always,
admixtures should only be combined in a concrete mix by a competent
professional because some of them can interact in undesirable ways.
Bonding admixtures
Bonding admixtures including addition of compounds and materials such as
polyvinyl chlorides and acetates, acrylics and butadiene-styrene co-
polymers, can be used to assist in bonding new / fresh concrete with old /
set concrete.
Coloring agents have become more commonly used, especially for patios
and walkways. Most are surface applied and often have the additional effect
of surface hardening. Such surface applied coloring admixtures generally
should not be used on air-entrained concrete. Integrally colored concrete is
also available.
The dosage is between 0.01 and 0.10% solid by mass of cement. Examples
of Class B are Styrene copolymers with carboxyl groups, synthetic
polyelectrolytes, and natural gums.
Fly ash, hydrated lime, kaolin, diatomaceous earth, other raw or calcined
pozzolanic materials, and various rock dusts are examples of Class E
Antiwashout admixture.
The high range water reducing admixture increases the setting time that is
why types and dosages of high range water reducing admixtures need to be
considered.
Capacity of the pump is another consideration that needs to be dealt with
because on one hand, high dispersion resistance blockage is possible to
occur in pump lines if issues are came across within the pressure
transmission tube during pumping pressure period.
The resistance of the fresh concrete against the freeze and thaw cycle is
given by the durability factor which is also lowered by 40 to 60%. There is
70% decrease in the bond between the reinforcement and the concrete that
is normally cured.
1. Provision of normal ambient temperatures for the concrete. This can be done
through the heating of the concrete ingredients or by providing heating enclosures.
2. The addition of chemical admixtures.
They are:
1. First Group:
This includes chemicals, weak electrolytes, sodium nitrite, sodium chloride
and non-electrolytic organic compounds which lower the freezing point of the
water used in the concrete. But these group acts as weak accelerators to
promote the setting and hardening.
2. Second Group
These include binary as well as ternary admixtures which contains potash
and additives based on calcium chloride, sodium nitrite, calcium chloride
with sodium nitrite, calcium nitrite -nitrate-urea and other chemicals.
One such example is the use of 8% of sodium nitrite to keep the liquid at a
temperature of -15-degree Celsius.
These admixtures function by lowering the liquid phase freezing point and by
accelerating the cement hydration at the freezing temperatures.
Based on the dosage in the mixture, the non-chloride admixture enables the
mix (concrete or the mortar) to be placed at sub-freezing temperatures. This
hence reduces the need of protective measures required during the cold
weathering works.
The method improves the quality of the concrete and as it facilitates early
setting, early stripping of formworks can also be carried out. This helps in the
reuse of the form within a small duration and hence speed up the
construction.
The table-1 shows the significant difference is strength gain at 3, 7 and 28
days for plain concrete and antifreeze admixture used concrete.
The water reduction will reduce the freezable free water content in the mix.
This freezable water content is the one that serves as the heat sink for the
heat liberated by the initial hydration reactions. This will hence reduce the
number of antifreeze admixtures.
Selection of Antifreeze admixtures
The factors based on which the selection of antifreeze admixtures is carried
out are:
A laboratory test must be carried out with the operating materials and the
dosage of antifreeze admixtures that are intended to be used in the field.
This material is obtained by the heating of iron ore, limestone and coke at a
temperature about 1500 degree Celsius. The process is carried out in a blast
furnace.
This slag is later granulated by cooling it. For this, it is allowed to pass
through a high-pressure water get. This result in quenching of the particles
which results in granules of size lesser than 5mm in diameter.
The main constituents of blast furnace slag are CaO, SiO2, Al2O3 and MgO.
These are the minerals that are found in most of the cementitious
substances.
The particles are further dried and ground in a rotating ball mill to form a
fine powder, known as ground granulated blast furnace slag cement. Now
different methods can be employed to perform the main process called as
the quenching.
MgO 1-18% 5%
From the above two differences in composition compared with the Portland
cement, would show changes in the hydration reaction as well as the
hydration products that are given GGBFS.
Physical Properties of Ground Granulated Blast Furnace
Slag (GGBFS)
Ground granulated blast furnace slag have a color nearly white in
appearance. The figure below shows GGBFS and ordinary Portland cement,
to clearly show the color difference between them.
Hence the use of GGBFS in concrete manufacture would give a light and
brighter color to concrete unlike the dark grey color of ordinary cement
concrete structures. This is an added advantage of GGBFS in terms of
aesthetics.
The typical properties of GGBS are given in Table-2.
Table 2. Physical properties of GGBFS (As per Tasong et.al)
Property Value
o GGBFS in concrete increases the strength and durability of the concrete structure.
o It reduces voids in concrete hence reducing permeability
o GGBFS gives a workable mix.
o It possesses good pumpable and compaction characteristics
o The structure made of GGBFS constituents help in increasing sulphate attack
resistance.
o The penetration of chloride can be decreased.
o The heat of hydration is less compared to conventional mix hydration.
o The alkali-silica reaction is resisted highly.
o These make the concrete more chemically stable
o Gives good surface finish and improves aesthetics
o The color is more even and light.
o Lower chances of efflorescence
o The maintenance and repair cost of structures are reduced thus increasing the life
cycle of concrete structures.
o Unlike cement, GGBFS does not produce carbon dioxide, sulphur dioxide or nitrogen
oxides.
They also have fewer chances to get segregated during handling as well as
pumping of the material. Pumping is facilitated by the lower relative density
and flowing ability of the mix, that is owned by GGBFS.
More the GGBFS amount, more will be the time taken for its setting. But the
strength is gained with time. This slow setting would help in the formation of
cold joints. But the situations where faster setting time is required, cannot
go for this replacement.
The GGBS composition stays plastic for a longer period that would help in
making a smoother finish for the contractor.
But some of the Portland cement do no behave well with the use of
superplasticizers. This problem is understood only by the detailed study on
the mode of action of superplasticizers.
When the intention is to create a large slump value with a lower water/
cement ratio the mentioned problem is met.
o the rate at which different Portland cement mineral phases react with the
water molecules
o the rate at which molecules of superplasticizers are trapped by compounds
that are formed newly by the contact of water and the Portland cement
Most studies have observed that the by the addition of superplasticizers on the
Portland cement, their molecules are adsorbed over the di and tricalcium
silicates. This is to control their hydration efficiently or to retard substantially
at required situations.
The cement’s rheological reactivity can be called as the rate at which the water
molecules are consumed by the cement during the first moment of mixing.
It is seen that that during hydration process certain number of
superplasticizers are also consumed. The first moment consumption of
Superplasticizer molecules after the mixing is qualified as
the cement/Superplasticizer compatibility.
It is very difficult to make high-performance concrete with a very low water-
cement ratio, that it will still have a slump value of 50mm 30 minutes with
an initial slump value of 200mm.
It is observed that the concrete surfaces become shiny as the time progress.
And it is not found appropriate to add more superplasticizer with an intention
to increase the slump value, as the mix lacks water.
Such situations can ask for a small amount of water to recover the slump
instantaneously, but the gained slump value will be lost once the reaction
has been carried out within it.
A great variety of cement that varies in the content of tri calcium aluminate,
tetra calcium alumino ferrite, limestone filler, di and tri calcium silicates and
cement with different fineness works compatible with the test. The whole
arrangement is called the rheopump.
The dosage is based on the type of cement that is used in the preparation of
the grout. This is dosed for a time of four minutes.
As shown in the figure-1, the flow time taken for 1L of the prepared grout
through the Marsh Cone is measured. This marsh cone is used to check the
fluidity of bentonite in the petroleum industry.
Once the measurement of initial time is completed, the grout is placed in
another plastic container and subjected to continuous agitation until the next
measurement. The next set of measurement will be taken 40 minutes later.
Hence the initial reactivity and the compatibility of the chosen cement with
the specified superplasticizer is understood within an hour by employing a
single bag of cement. The rheopump have never failed even used with
concrete for slump loss measurement.
1. Problems with the physical Nature: Because of a limited number of bins and
service to the regular customer, the facilities allow a little latitude in this
area.
2. Problems due to an Economical Nature: Based on the geographic location,
resources that are locally and economically available are demanded first
then selecting others.
3. Problems with the Social Nature: Limit the Superplasticizer selection due to the
tie up with known cement or quarry companies. The concrete producers may
have a personal dealing with any of the cement companies that limit the
variety of selection.
Selection of Superplasticizer for High-Performance
Concrete
Certain general rules that each concrete producer must strictly follow to
bring the desired result are mentioned below:
Type of Superplasticizer
By only focusing on the solid content it is recommended to use naphthalene
superplasticizers when compared with the melamine. The naphthalene
superplasticizers are marketed with a solid content from 40 to 42 percent.
Other factors that influence the choice of superplasticizer is the technical and
the commercial problems. This include factors like quality service that is
offered by the admixture company, the consistency of quality of
superplasticizer, the regularity of superplasticizer delivery and the
confidence laid on the admixture company.
Brand of Superplasticizer
The number of superplasticizer manufacturers whether it be naphthalene or
melamine, is very limited. This will lead to rise of several commercial
superplasticizers that have the same reactor and showing similar properties.
The Portland cement can be classified into different types. But each type
shows different characteristics which is influenced by various factors.
Superplasticizers with variation in types do show variability it character, but
it is less compared with Portland cement.
When the ambient temperature is below 5-degree Celsius their viscosity will
decrease. This change in property will affect the efficiency that is guaranteed
by the superplasticizer. In case of frozen superplasticizers, they must be
kept at a maximum temperature of 35-degree Celsius for a time period of 24
hours.
This retarder use is mainly done when rheologically active types of cement
are used. The retarding agent can be added in an amount equal to 5 to 10
percent of the weight of superplasticizer that is added to the whole mix. The
problem of slump loss is solved without retarding the setting of the concrete.
Retarding agent based on sodium gluconate will work best when compared
with lignosulphonate retarding agents. This is because the sodium gluconate
helps in fewer entrapping of air bubbles when compared with a
lignosulphonate retarding agent.
The use of superplasticizer and the retarding agent is a tricky method. The
climatic factors also must be considered while optimizing their amount,
because the cement reactivity is greatly affected by the temperature of the
concrete.
American Concrete Institute (ACI) Committee 212 offers guidance on use of this
admixture in its ACI 212.3 Rev10 titled ―Report on Chemical Admixtures for
Concrete ―. Details about permeability reducing admixtures are covered in
Chapter – 15 of the report.
Materials in Permeability Reducing Admixtures:
The ACI 212.3 Rev.10 in its report states that following types of materials to
be used in waterproofing admixtures:
The report does not limit the use of materials only to as mentioned above.
Any material can be used as water-resisting admixture which can block the
water penetration. These materials can be used as single or combination of
two or more.
The other mechanism can be the use of pore-blocking admixtures that are very
fine reactive or unreactive fillers or insoluble polymer emulsions. These have
particle sizes of around 0.1 microns and can easily get into the capillaries of
concrete during the early stages of hydration process and physically block
them.
The hydrophobic admixtures are designed as a soluble admixture in concrete
but it reacts with the calcium of the fresh cement and forms an insoluble
material which are adsorbed onto the surfaces of the capillaries. When the
hydration process is complete and moisture dries out, the hydrophobic layer
on surface of pores prevents water from entering the capillary by suction.
But the resistance of hydrophobic admixture is limited and depends
hydraulic head, the quality of the concrete and the effectiveness of the
admixture.
Concrete admixtures are used to enhance the properties of concrete for applications
in concrete works with special requirements.
So, it is of much importance for a civil site engineer to know about the
properties of admixtures for better selection and application in concrete
works.
Definition of Concrete Admixtures
As per BIS (IS – 9103: 1999) Page No.1, Concrete Admixture is defined as a
material other than water, aggregates and hydraulic cement and additives
like Pozzolana or slag and fiber reinforcement, used as on ingredient of
concrete or mortar and added to the batch immediately before or during its
mixing to modify one or more of the properties of concrete in the plastic or
hardened state.
Some of the important purposes for which admixtures are used are:
a) Accelerating admixtures
b) Retarding admixtures
c) Water-reducing admixtures
d) Air-entraining admixtures
a) Air-entraining admixtures
b) Accelerating admixtures
e) Miscellaneous admixtures
In other words, anionic surface active agents produce bubbles that are
negatively charged, cationic charged cause bubbles to be positively charged,
surface active agents of all classes can cause air entrainment in concrete,
but their efficiency and characteristics of air-void system vary widely.
Air entraining Admixtures have following properties:
o These are foaming agents, gas producing chemicals. It introduces millions of tiny,
stable bubbles of uniform size that are uniformly distributed throughout the mix
(usually about 5% of the volume).
o Improves properties of fresh concrete such as workability, cohesion and reduces
segregation and bleeding.
o Improves properties of hardened concrete – For every 1% of air there is a 4% loss
in strength which is minimized by the reduction in water content. It improves
durability of hardened concrete.
Mode of Action
The principal role on mechanism of water reductions and set retardation of
admixtures are usually composed of long-chain organic molecules and that
are hydrophobic (not wetting) at one end and hydrophilic (readily wet) at
the other.
Such molecules tend to become concentrated and form a film at the
interface between two immiscible phases such as cement and water, and
alter the physio-chemical forces acting at this interface.
(iii) protection sheath of water dipoles around each particle i.e. mobility of
fresh mix becomes greater, partly because of reduction in inter-particle
forces and partly because of water freed from the restraining influence of the
highly flocculated system which is now available to lubricate the mixture.
Hence less water is required to achieve given consistency.
c) While maintaining the same w/c ratio and workability concrete can be
made to a given strength as in the reference concrete at lower cement
content.
Effect on durability
The straight addition of admixtures of this type does not came any increase
in permeability and indeed where the admixture is used to reduce the w/c,
then permeability is considerably reduced.
Effect on shrinkage
Admixture of this type when used as workability aids on water reducers do
not adversely effect the shrinkage.
Effect on creep
Materials of this type of admixture have no deleterious effect on the creep of
concrete.
Detrimental effect
a) While using water reducing agent. Care must be taken in controlling the
air content in the mix. Most water-reducing agent entrain air due to their
surfactant properties.
d) Soluble zinc
Mode of action
It is thought that retarding admixtures are absorbed on to the C3A phase in
cement forming a film around the cement grains and presenting or reducing
the reaction with water. After a while thus film breaks down and normal
hydration proceeds. This a simple mixture and there is a reason to believe
that retards also interact with C3S since retardation can be extended to a
period of many days.
Why Retarding Concrete Admixtures are used?
To delay in the setting time of concrete without adversely effecting the
subsequent strength development.
Advantage of Retarding Concrete Admixture
a) The hydroxyl carboxylic acid type admixture normally produces concrete
having a slightly lower aim content them that of a control mix.
c) Durability increases.
Detrimental effect
a) When lignosulphonate based material used, then the air content might be
0.2 to 0.3% higher unless materials of the tributyle phosphate type are
added.
iii) iii) Modified ligno-sulphonates and other sulphonic esters, acids etc.,
Chemical type
a) formaldehyde derivatives such as melamine formaldehyde and napthalene
sulphonate formaldehyde.
c) It does not significantly affect the setting of concrete except that when
used the cements having a very low C3A content.
d) They do not influence shrinkage, creep modulus of elasticity or resistance
to freeing to thawing.
Disadvantage
The only real disadvantage of superplasticizer is their relatively high cost.
b) Industrial by products
b) Calcium silicon
c) Ferrochromium Silicon
d) Silicomanganese
a) SF originates from the condensed SiO vapors and generally has a high
content of silica of 35 to 98%
b) SF is an amorphous material
The beneficial action of SF has also been attributed to the reduction of the
porosity of the transition zone between the cement paste and aggregate
which increases the strength and impermeability of the concrete. In or
conventional concrete, the transition zone can have large and oriented
Portlandite crystals which form weak zones in the concrete.
After selecting the admixtures product, one should carefully choose the
supplier with quality product, timely service and at competitive price. The
admixture supplier should be with good history and should possess the staff
with efficient and professional experience to guide on effective
application/use of admixture in right way.
The various factors which affect the performance of concrete admixtures are:
1. Type of super-plasticizer:
The admixture will be more effective if molecular weight of the super-
plasticizer is high.
2. Dosage:
The quantity of admixture should be optimum. Excess of admixture may
cause segregation or bleeding. It may also cause excessive retardation. The
optimum does should be estimated by trials.
4. Mix Design:
All constituents of mix affect the performance of the super-plasticizer as
given below:
o Water: more water in the mix improves the physical interaction and
dispersion of admixtures.
o Coarse aggregate: proportioning and grading of coarse aggregates influence
the performance of concrete admixture.
o Fine aggregate: proportioning, grading and silt content also influence the
performance of concrete admixture.
o Cement: its fineness, C3A content influence the performance of admixture.
Higher C3A reduces efficiency of admixture.
o Other admixture: presence of other admixtures also influences the
performance of concrete admixtures.
Therefore, proper trials before actual use are very vital for effectiveness of
admixture.
In reinforced concrete, the chloride ion of any admixture used should not
exceed 2% by weight of the admixture as determined in accordance
with IS:6925 and the total chloride ion in all admixtures used in concrete mi
shall not exceed 0.83% by weight of cement. The addition of calcium
chloride to concrete containing embedded metal will not be permitted under
any circumstance.
Accelerating concrete Admixtures conforming to IS:9103 & 2645 should be used. It
is in liquid state with a specific gravity of 1.3 and complying with ASTM C-
494 type E. It accelerates the setting and hardening of the concrete mix
thereby achieving high early ago strength. Accelerating concrete admixture
should be compatible with all types of cement.
Retarding concrete Admixtures conforming to IS:9103. It is in liquid state with a
specific gravity of 1.22 and complying with ASTM C-494 type B&D, CRD-C87
type B & D, BS:5075 part 1. It should be added to the concrete mix during the
mixing process along with water and aggregates. No extension of normal
mixing time is necessary. It will delay the initial and final setting time and
helps to spread the heat of hydration over a longer period of time. It gives a
highly workable concrete with a low W/C ratio. It must be compatible with all
types of cement depending on requirement.
Air-entraining Admixtures conforming to IS:9103.
Water-reducing admixtures conforming to IS:9103.
Integral waterproofing admixtures conforming to IS:2645. It is used as an
excellent cement admixture in all types of concrete/ plaster mortars,
pointing mortars, masonry works, guniting works and pressure grouting
works. It improves resistance of the surface to weathering and chemical
attacks. It should not be toxic so as to use for waterproofing in water tanks,
reservoirs, tanks, etc.