Application of Tensegrit To TensileTextie Constructi Ns Formfindingand Structural Analysis
Application of Tensegrit To TensileTextie Constructi Ns Formfindingand Structural Analysis
net/publication/273060144
CITATION READS
1 701
1 author:
Diana Peña
Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya
24 PUBLICATIONS 29 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
New solar control tensed devices for workshops about sustainable school architecture View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Diana Peña on 03 March 2015.
Technical Papers
Application of Tensegrity to Tensile-Textile Constructions: Formfinding and 67
Structural Analysis
D.M. Peña, I. Llorens, R. Sastre, D. Crespo and J. Martínez
COVER: Figure from paper by Peña, Llorens, Sastre, Crespo and Martínez
Diana Maritza PEÑA1*, Ignasi LLORENS2, Ramón SASTRE3, Daniel CRESPO4, Joshua MARTÍNEZ5
1*
Doctorate Student. Department of Architectural Technology I. Technical University of Catalunya.
C/Perea 1-3 11º 2ª CP. 08035, Barcelona-Spain, [email protected],
2
Prof. UPC [email protected], 3Prof. UPC [email protected], 4Prof. UPC [email protected], 5Prof. UPC
[email protected]
Editor’s Note: Manuscript submitted 19 October 2009; revisions received 30 July 2010 and 4 January 2011;
accepted 27 February. This paper is open for written discussion, which should be submitted to the IASS Secretariat no
later than December 2011.
ABSTRACT
This paper applies tensegrity to create an architectural structure such as those that could be used for sports
arenas or other buildings requiring large, open spaces. This proposal generates an external tensegrity ring with
a central dome, free of any interior support, by formfinding a diamond-shaped membrane with discontinuous
struts in a double layer structure that finds its equilibrium through the pretension of the membrane. The tendons
that are used in traditional tensegrity structures are replaced by membranes and this proposal is the main
contribution of this work. Structural equilibrium was analyzed using the WinTess software and wind-tunnel
testing was used to determine the Cp-pressure coefficient.
Keywords: Tensegrity unit, tensegrity ring, formfinding, continuous membrane pattern, diamond-shaped
membrane pattern, pretension, wind tunnel, pressure coefficient.
67
Vol. 52 (2011) No. 2 June n. 168
Figure 1. A comparison of the work of Anthony Pugh and that proposed by the author.
2. FORMFINDING
• The concept of a basic module or tensegrity In the below pictures (Fig. 2 and Fig.3) we can
unit built from polygons and polyhedrons observe different scale model examples in
(prisms and anti-prisms) as well as Platonic tensegrity with cables and membranes constructed
and Archimedean solids. [4] from a variety of materials, that use these
• The substitution of geometric components principles of geometry.
(such as edges and vertices) with bars, cables,
joints, and membrane faces. After they were assembled, we chose some of the
• Forming more complex systems from groups models to define a classification and to do the
and variations of the basic module (tensegrity structural analysis:
unit).
68
JOURNAL OF THE INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR SHELL AND SPATIAL STRUCTURES: J. IASS
Figure 2. Examples of sixty scale models in tensegrity. Models developed using an intuitive and experimental method based
on the geometry.
Figure 3. Examples of scale models in different materials. A spandex membrane was chosen as the material to construct the
scale models (1:100).
69
Vol. 52 (2011) No. 2 June n. 168
3. CLASSIFICATION
A A
B B
Figure 4. A tensegrity unit with a diamond-shaped pattern (an anti-prism of 4 struts) – scale model 1:100
The process is generated by cutting textile 4. The bars are tied to the adjacent pattern piece
membranes into rhombus or diamond shaped on one of its vertexes, and so on. The tied up units
patterns (rhombus= major axis 17 cm, minor axis can be closed by joining the first bar and the last
12 cm) for the basic anti-prism unit of four bars membrane pattern. The final anti-prism form has
(L=22 cm), which are then arranged in an oblique four parabolic surfaces constructed from a flat
direction or diagonal position. The bars are joined rhombus. The initial position of the bars in this
to the end points of the membrane as shown in Fig case is a single layer.
b. Continuous-membrane pattern piece with struts in a single layer
A A
B B
Figure 5. A tensegrity unit formed from a continuous membrane (an anti-prism with 4 struts) – scale model 1:100
One can depart from the previously described of the membrane. The initial location of the bars
process and use a continuous, single-piece, was determined by an orthogonal single mesh (3.5
rectangular-shaped membrane (15 cm x 3.75 cm) cm x 3.5 cm). The equilibrium of this unit
to find the form. The bars (L=10 cm) arranged in tensegrity anti-prism with four bars and single-
a single layer and joined to the end points of the piece membrane is achieved through the tension
membrane as shown in Fig 5. The system is then of the membrane. The final form is a continuum
closed by joining the first bar and the last corner of four paraboloids.
70
JOURNAL OF THE INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR SHELL AND SPATIAL STRUCTURES: J. IASS
A A
B B
C C
Figure 6. A tensegrity ring with a continuous membrane and 20 struts - scale model 1:100
In this tensegrity ring, formfinding is generated by joining the first bars and the last corners of the
means of a single-piece membrane (7.00 cm x membrane. The initial location of the bars was
36.75 cm), which has an initial rectangular shape. determined by an orthogonal double mesh (3.5 cm
For this model of twenty bars (L=10 cm) in a x 3.5 cm), whose distance was defined by the
double layer, the bars are arranged in an oblique elasticity of the membrane relative to the length of
direction or diagonal position, in an alternating the diagonal bar. The final form is a continuum of
pattern and are joined to the end points of the ten upper paraboloids and ten lower paraboloids
membrane like shown in Fig. 6, and resemble the below.
veins of a leaf. The system is then closed by
d. Diamond-membrane pattern pieces with mesh and twenty struts in a double layer
A A
B B
C C
Figure 7. Photos showing the components and final structure as well as a diagram of the tensegrity-ring construction
method – scale model 1:100
71
Vol. 52 (2011) No. 2 June n. 168
The ring structure is made up of a continuum when the last two bars are put into place.
of ten upper-level paraboloids and ten lower-
level paraboloids with a diameter of 40 cm. A dome is created by combining the above ring
Formfinding for the ring structure is generated structure with a “roof” consisting of one
by means of a diamond-shaped membrane central mast (L=9 cm) and ten minor masts
pattern pieces (rhombus = major axis 11.5 cm, (L=6.5 cm) placed in a circular form held in
minor axis 4 cm) formed by two layers of place by the tension of the membrane itself.
twenty bars (L=20 cm), which are arranged The membrane balances the system and joins
either in an oblique or a diagonal position. The the dome with the tensegrity ring. The final
bars are connected to the end points of the structure is a dome free of any internal
membrane as shown in Fig 1 and then to the supports.
adjacent membrane piece at the corresponding
end point. If one compares the model in Fig. 7 with the
continuous membrane in Fig. 6 it can be
This procedure is repeated for all adjacent observed that, though they have the same
membrane pieces, while at the same time, the number of bars, the diameter of model in Fig. 7
upper section is interlaced with the lower is larger (approximately double) and this is
section creating one continuous ring structure why the diamond-pattern model was ultimately
selected for structural analysis.
Figure 8. Technical and geometric drawings of the structure. The tensegrity ring and central dome are shown with
the membrane and external support cables.
The final structure can be scaled as needed. To larger. A larger prototype was assembled using
make a larger diameter, there are two options. 20 struts (L=50 cm) in a double layer resulting
First, the quantity of bars would have to be in an overall diameter of 100 cm (Fig. 9). The
increased proportionally to the elasticity of the ratio of length of the bars to the overall
membrane used. Second, if the length of the diameter is 1:2.
bars is increased, the ring diameter will be
72
JOURNAL OF THE INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR SHELL AND SPATIAL STRUCTURES: J. IASS
4. STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
Tensegrity structures are characterized by: [5] • That the maximum reaction in the
• Discontinuous elements that work under foundation nodes is 24 tons.
compression • That, during external snow loads of 50
• Pre-stressed structural membrane kg/m, a maximum (vertical) displacement
• Auto-balanced structure of 60 cm is found in the minor dome masts
(the minor masts are shown in black in the
The proposed structure was first tested via drawings in Fig. 8) and the maximum
WinTess software [6]. Testing demonstrated reaction in the foundation nodes is 22 tons.
the following: • That the large displacements must be
countered by the use of external tubes and
• It allowed the structural elements cables if the structure is to be built in the
(membrane, tubes, and cables) to be real world.
analyzed and optimized for dimensional • The exterior tubes are placed surrounding
stability. the ring so that they continue in the
• That the structure is closed, in equilibrium direction of the forces coming from the top
(all the compression and tension forces are membrane dome. The pretensioned cables
perfectly distributed via a 650 kg/m increase the stiffness of the structure and
pretension of the membrane), and able to contribute to support and balancing of the
support its own weight. system.
• That, during extreme external wind • In some analyses, distortions and/or
conditions of 170 km/h, the maximum irregularities were used to see if the
inward (horizontal) displacement of the bar structure remained balanced. In our case,
free nodes is 95 cm, which was decreased we tested the irregularities and they had no
to 17 cm after being reinforced. (The bar impact on the structural balance. In
free nodes are located on the side of the addition, the structure is not symmetrical
structure between the upper and lower to wind; the tensegrity of the position of
levels of the tensegrity ring. They are not the bars has a twisting motion like a
directly connected to the upper dome or to windmill, and therefore, the reactions are
the foundation nodes. The bars of the different.
tensegrity ring are shown in blue and red
in Fig 8).
73
Vol. 52 (2011) No. 2 June n. 168
Figure 10. Structural analysis using WinTess software. Note that the computer model is shown with both the
membrane and cables, which prevent the structure from moving in the real world. The structure remains balanced
when wind of up-to 170 km/h is applied. (diameter 40 m - scale model 1:1)
74
JOURNAL OF THE INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR SHELL AND SPATIAL STRUCTURES: J. IASS
5. WIND-TUNNEL TESTING
The proposed structure was then tested in a wind model; thus the flow profile is laminar. However,
tunnel. Due to the nature of tensile-textile the model size is 0.17 m (scale 1:250), and free
construction (lightweight structures), the ability of stream speed ranged between 5 and 20 m/s, that is
the structure to withstand external loads relative to Reynolds numbers from 5x10^4 and 2x10^5,
weight of the structure itself is much greater that which is a fully turbulent regime, which
of conventional construction [8]. It is important to corresponds to the a real-world-sized building.
note, though, that small changes in wind pressure
or snow loads can have a major impact on the size The model is made from a rigid plastic material,
and shape of the structural elements and the while the real-world structure would have a
deformations that occur. For this reason, it is flexible cover. The forces measured with the
important to understand the pressure and suction model have been scaled to the real-world-sized
coefficients that impact the structure: vertical structure assuming that it acts as a rigid body, due
force (lift coefficient) and horizontal force (drag to the beams that support the building in tension.
coefficient). The wind tunnel tests were used to determine the
lift and drag coefficients. Drag coefficient was
Description: The wind tunnel is open, and works used in WinTess to calculate the structure to wind
by aspiration (Eiffel style); that is, undisturbed air up-to 170 km/h.
is accelerated through a nozzle and sent to the
75
Vol. 52 (2011) No. 2 June n. 168
2.5
2.4
2.3
2.2
2.1
2.0
1.9
1.8
1.7
1.6
1.5
1.4
1.3
1.2
1.1
1.0
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
76
JOURNAL OF THE INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR SHELL AND SPATIAL STRUCTURES: J. IASS
The amount of suction or pressure depends on the velocity of the wind and the angle of incidence.
= wind
Figure 13. Surface normal angle in the model (p=pressure and s=suction).
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Figure 14. Drag-coefficient diagram. Pressure coefficients relative to the lateral wall of the building.
The entire wall was found to have negative- The model has a very aerodynamic structure
pressure coefficients, which shows that the effect relative to wind coming from the side due to the
of wind on the wall is that of suction. Negative suction created as a result of negative coefficients
values closer to zero (in red) indicate less suction of pressure. The convex forms allow wind to
and are mostly found for angles closer to zero freely pass by.
relative to the direction the wind. Negative values
farther from zero (in blue) indicate greater suction Drag coefficient: The global drag coefficient
and are mostly found for angles lower than -90 obtained experimentally was Cd ~0.30. Local
degrees and greater than 90 degrees relative to the pressure coefficients show a significant
direction of the wind. dispersion, as shown in Fig 14.
2 Fdrag
Cd (2)
·S e · ·v 2
Where Se is the elevation surface (model 0,008718
Figure 15. Drag-coefficient diagram. m2)
77
Vol. 52 (2011) No. 2 June n. 168
After wind-tunnel testing, we found that there is • Dome central mast: L=9 m - 200-5_S235
an overload of forces on the model and we had to - Section 30,631 cm2 - Elasticity modulus
re-optimize the structural elements. The elements 2.100 t/cm2 = 210 kN/mm2 - Density 7,85
that changed were: t/m3 = 78,5 kN/m3
78
JOURNAL OF THE INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR SHELL AND SPATIAL STRUCTURES: J. IASS
Table 4. A comparison of the results between structure with only cables, structure with only membrane and structure
with both membrane and cables.
79
Vol. 52 (2011) No. 2 June n. 168
6. APPLICATION
There exists a need for roof structures that can patterns with twenty struts in a double layer, to
cover large surfaces and spaces and that are free cover a 40 m diameter sports arena, which has a
of any interior supports. After doing the pertinent surface of 1.200 m2 and can be occupied by
calculations, a tensegrity ring is proposed with a approximately 626 people.
central dome, using diamond-shaped membranes
80
JOURNAL OF THE INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR SHELL AND SPATIAL STRUCTURES: J. IASS
81