Chapter 1
Chapter 1
First. The esthetic standards for design will have to be broadened to embrace wider impacts. Designers
ought to aim to cause no ugliness. Human or ecological. Somewhere else or at some later time. For
education. This means that the architectural curriculum must include ethics. Ecology and tools having
to do wit11 whole systems anal!-sis. And least-cost. End-use considerations. Further. Educational
standards need to include a more sophisticated and ecologically grounded understanding of place
and culture.
Second. it should he recognized that architecture and design are fundamental! Pedagogical. Churchill
hat1 it right: we are shaped I)!-our buildings aid landscapes in powerful hut subtle ways. The education
of all design professions ought to begin in the recognition that architecture and landscapes are a kind
of crystallized pedagogy. That informs well or bad. but never fails to inform. Design inevitable instructs
us about our relationships to nature and people that makes us allure or less mindful and more or less
ecologically competent. The ultimate object of design is not artifacts. Buildings. or landscapes. but
human minds.
Third. Architecture and design ought to he seen in their largest contest that has to do with health. At
the last obvious level ‘sick buildings’ reflect not simplified design but a truncated concept of design. A
larger design perspective would place architecture and landscape architecture as subfields of the art
and science of health with allure than passing affinity for leaving and the hole
Architecture is commonly taught and practiced as if it were only the art and science of designing
buildings. Which is to say merely as a technical subject at the mere!-of the slims of clients. I would like
to offer a contrast view that architecture ought to be placed into a larger contest as a subfield of
ecological design. The essay that follows might best be considered as a series of notes on the
boundaries of this larger field of design. Earlier fora!-s into this area mies van der R!-11 and Coven
(1996)laid the ground rock for a more expansive view of the design professions. I intend to build 011
that foundation to connect design professions. and the education of designers to the larger issues of
human ecology.
Ecological Concepts
Ecological Architecture
Sustainability
Climate
The weather of a place represents the state of the atmospheric environment over a brief period of time.
Integrated weather condition over several years is generally referred to as climate or more specifically,
as the ‘macro-climate’. An analysis of the climate of a particular region can help in assessing the
seasons or periods during which a person may experience comfortable or uncomfortable conditions. It
further helps in identifying the climatic elements, as well as their severity, that cause discomfort.
The information helps a designer to build a house that filters out adverse climatic effects, while
simultaneously allowing those that are beneficial. Discomfort and the corresponding energy demand
for mechanical systems can be significantly reduced by judicious control of the climatic effects. The
built-form and arrangement of openings of a building can be suitably derived from this analysis. For
example, in a place like Mumbai, one feels hot and sweaty owing to intense solar radiation
accompanied by high humidity. Here, the building design should be such that
(a) It is sufficiently shaded to prevent solar radiation from entering the house and,
(b) It is ventilated to reduce discomfort due to high humidity. On the other hand, in a place like Shimla,
it is necessary to maintain warmth inside the building due to the predominantly cold climate. Climate
thus plays a pivotal role in determining the design and construction of a building.
The design requirements of buildings in different climatic zones are discussed and tabulated.
Illustrative examples provide information on how to analyse the climatic conditions, vernacular
architecture of cold and cloudy climate conditions and design in the representative city of Solan, near
Shimla , Himachal Pradesh.
Both weather and climate are characterised by the certain variables known as climatic
factors . They are as follows:
(A) Solar radiation
(B) Ambient temperature
(C) Air humidity
(D) Precipitation
(E) Wind
(F) Sky condition
Solar radiation is the radiant energy received from the sun. It is the intensity of sunrays
falling per unit time per unit area and is usually expressed in Watts per square metre (W/m2). The
radiation incident on a surface varies from moment to moment depending on its geographic location
(latitude and longitude of the place), orientation, season, time of day and atmospheric conditions (Fig.
2.1). Solar radiation is the most important weather variable that determines whether a place
experiences high temperatures or is predominantly cold. The instruments used for measuring of solar
radiation are the pyranometer and the pyrheliometer. The duration of sunshine is measured using a
sunshine recorder.
Fig. 2.1 Factors affecting solar radiation
(a) effect of orientation, (b) effect of season
(D) Precipitation
Precipitation includes water in all its forms rain, snow, hail or dew. It is usually measured
in millimeters (mm) by using a rain gauge. The effects of precipitation on buildings are illustrated in Fig.
2.4
(E) Wind
Wind is the movement of air due to a difference in atmospheric pressure, caused by differential heating
of land and water mass on the earth’s surface by solar radiation and rotation of earth. Wind speed can
be measured by an anemometer and is usually expressed in metres per second (m/s). It is a major
design consideration for architects because it affects indoor comfort conditions by influencing the
convective heat exchanges of a building envelope, as well as causing air infiltration into the building
(Fig. 2.5).
In addition to these factors, a number of natural elements such as hills, valleys, waterbodies, vegetation,
etc. affect the climate locally. Buildings, cities and other man-made features also have an impact on
the climate. The effects of such features are discussed in the section 2.6 under ‘Microclimate’.
Climate Zones
1.4 CLIMATIC ZONES AND THEIR CHARACTERISTICS
Regions having similar characteristic features of climate are grouped under one climatic zone. Based
on the climatic factors discussed in the previous section, the country can be divided into a number of
climatic zones.
Bansal et al. [1] had carried out detailed studies and reported that India can be divided into six
climatic zones, namely, hot and dry, warm and humid, moderate, cold and cloudy, cold and sunny,
and composite. The criteria of classification are presented in Table 2.1 and shows the climatic zones. A
place is assigned to one of the first five climatic zones only when the defined conditions prevail there for
more than six months. In cases where none of the defined categories can be identified for six months or
longer, the climatic zone is called composite. According to a recent code of Bureau of Indian
Standards , the country may be divided into five major climatic zones. Table 2.1 presents the criteria of
this classification as well;
The characteristic features of each climate are described briefly in the following
subsections.
1.4.3 Moderate
Pune and Bangalore are examples of cities that fall under this climatic zone. Areas having a moderate
climate are generally located on hilly or high-plateau regions with fairly abundant vegetation. The solar
radiation in this region is more or less the same throughout the year. Being located at relatively higher
elevations, these places experience lower temperatures than hot and dry regions. The temperatures
are neither too hot nor too cold. In summers, the temperature reaches 30 – 34 ºC during the day and 17
– 24 ºC at night. In winter, the maximum temperature is between 27 to 33 ºC during the day and 16 to
18 ºC at night. The relative humidity is low in winters and summers, varying from 20 – 55%, and going
upto 55 – 90% during monsoons. The total rainfall usually exceeds 1000 mm per year. Winters are dry in
this zone. Winds are generally high during summer. Their speed and direction depend mainly upon the
topography. The sky is mostly clear with occasional presence of low, dense clouds during summers. The
design criteria in the moderate zone are to reduce heat gain by providing shading, and to promote
heat loss by ventilation.
1.4.4 Composite
The composite zone covers the central part of India. Some cities that experience this type of climate
are New Delhi, Kanpur and Allahabad. A variable landscape and seasonal vegetation characterise this
zone. The intensity of solar radiation is very high in summer with diffuse radiation amounting to a small
fraction of the total. In monsoons, the intensity is low with predominantly diffuse radiation. The maximum
daytime temperature in summers is in the range of 32 – 43 ºC, and night time values are from 27 to 32
ºC. In winter, the values are between 10 to 25 ºC during the day and 4 to 10 ºC at night.
The relative humidity is about 20 – 25 % in dry periods and 55 – 95 % in wet periods. The presence of high
humidity during monsoon months is one of the reasons why places like New Delhi and Nagpur are
grouped under the composite and not hot and dry climate. Precipitation in this zone varies between
500 – 1300 mm per year. This region receives strong winds during monsoons from the south-east and dry
cold winds from the north-east. In summer, the winds are hot and dusty. The sky is overcast and dull in
the monsoon, clear in winter and frequently hazy in summer.
Generally, composite regions experience higher humidity levels during monsoons than hot and dry
zones. Otherwise most of their characteristics are similar to the latter. Thus, the design criteria are more
or less the same as for hot and dry climate except that maximising cross ventilation is desirable in the
monsoon period.
1.4.5 Cold and Cloudy
Generally, the northern part of India experiences this type of climate. Most cold and cloudy regions are
situated at high altitudes. Ootacamund, Shimla, Shillong, Srinagar and Mahabaleshwar are examples of
places belonging to this climatic zone. These are generally highland regions having abundant
vegetation in summer. The intensity of solar radiation is low in winter with a high percentage of diffuse
radiation.Hence, winters are extremely cold. In summer, the maximum ambient temperature is in the
range of 20 – 30 ºC during the day and 17 – 27 ºC at night, making summers quite pleasant. In winter,
the
values range between 4 and 8 ºC during the day and from -3 to 4 ºC at night, making it quite chilly. The
relative humidity is generally high and ranges from 70 – 80 %. Annual total precipitation is about 1000
mm and is distributed evenly throughout the year. This region experiences cold winds in the winter
season. Hence, protection from winds is essential in this type of climate. The sky is overcast for most part
of the year except during the brief summer. Conditions in summer are usually clear and pleasant, but
owing to cold winters, the main criteria for design in the cold and cloudy region aim at resisting heat
loss by insulation and infiltration, and promoting heat gain by directly admitting and trapping solar
radiation within the living space.
1.7 MICROCLIMATE
The conditions for transfer of energy through the building fabric and for determining the
thermal response of people are local and site-specific. These conditions are generally grouped under
the term of ‘microclimate’, which includes wind, radiation, temperature, and humidity experienced
around a building. A building by its very presence will change the microclimate by causing a bluff
obstruction to the wind flow, and by casting shadows on the ground and on other buildings. A designer
has to predict this variation and appropriately account for its effect in the design.
An understanding of these factors greatly helps in the preparation of the site layout plan. For example,
in a hot and dry climate, the building needs to be located close to a waterbody. The waterbody helps
in increasing the humidity and lowering the temperature by evaporative cooling.
(A) Landform
Landform represents the topography of a site. It may be flat, undulating or sloping. Major
landforms affecting a site are mountains, valleys and plains. Depending on the macroclimate and
season, some locations within a particular landform experience a better microclimate than others. In
valleys, the hot air (being lighter) rises while cooler air having higher density, settles into the depressions,
resulting in a lower temperature at the bottom. Upward currents form on sunny slopes in the morning. By
night, the airflow reverses because cold ground surfaces cool the surrounding air, making it heavier and
causing it to flow down the valley. Moreover, the wind flow is higher along the direction of the valley
than across it due to unrestricted movement. On mountain slopes, the air speed increases as it moves
up the windward side, reaching a maximum at the crest and a minimum on the leeward side. The
difference in air speed is caused due to the low
pressure area developed on the leeward side.Temperature also varies with elevation. The cooling rate is
about 0.80C for every 100m of elevation. Air moving down the slope will thus be cooler than the air it
replaces lower down, and vice versa. Further, the orientation of the slope also plays a part in
determining the amount of solar radiation incident on the site. For example a south-facing slope will get
more exposure than a
north-facing one in the northern hemisphere. Studies conducted in Mardin, Turkey showed that building
groups located on a south facing slope in the city needed approximately 50% less heat to maintain the
same indoor temperature as buildings located on the plain land.Careful positioning of a building with
respect to landform can thus help in achieving comfort.
(C) Vegetation
Vegetation plays an important role in changing the climate of a city, as seen in section 2.5. It is also
effective in controlling the microclimate. Plants, shrubs and trees cool the environment when they
absorb radiation for photosynthesis. They are useful in shading a particular part of the structure and
ground for reducing the heat gain and reflected radiation. By releasing moisture, they help raise the
humidity level. Vegetation also creates different air flow patterns by causing minor pressure differences,
and thus can be used to direct or divert the prevailing wind advantage.Based on the requirement of a
climate, an appropriate type of tree can be selected. Planting deciduous trees such as mulberry to
shade east and west walls would prove beneficial in hot and dry zones. In summer, they provide shade
from intense morning and evening sun, reduce glare, as
well as cut off hot breezes. On the other hand, deciduous trees shed their leaves in winter and allow
solar radiation to heat the building. The cooling effect of vegetation in hot and dry climates comes
predominantly from evaporation, while in hot humid climates the shading effect is more significant.Trees
can be used as windbreaks to protect both buildings and outer areas such as lawns and patios from
both hot and cold winds. The velocity reduction behind the windbreak depends on their height,
density, cross-sectional shape, width, and length, the first two being the most important factors. When
the wind does not blow perpendicular to the windbreak, the sheltered area is decreased. The rate of
infiltration in buildings is proportional to the wind pressure. Therefore, it is more important to design
windbreaks for maximum wind speed reduction in extreme climates, than to attempt to maximize the
distance over which the windbreak is effective. In cold climates, windbreaks can reduce the heat loss
in buildings by reducing wind flow over the buildings, thereby reducing convection and infiltration
losses. A single-row of high
density trees in the form of a windbreak can reduce infiltration in a residence by about 60% when
planted about four tree heights from the building. This corresponds to about 15% reduction inenergy
costs .Thus, trees can be effectively used to control the micro climate. The data for various trees found
in India are presented in Tab
THERMAL COMFORT
I. THERMAL COMFORT
II. FACTORS INFUENCING THERMAL COMFORT
RECOMMENDATIONS :
Operational Parameters
The operational parameters such as internal gain, set point and scheduling of air changes can help in
reducing the annual load of the building. The effects are summarised as follows.
Internal gain
In cold climates, internal gains help to keep the building warm and hence are preferable.
Set point
Lowering the operating parameters for comfort cooling and heating can reduce the cooling loads by
11.9%. Thus, a change in the expectation of comfort can lead to significant savings.
Scheduling of air exchanges
The scheduling of air changes does not have a significant effect on the annual load.
Apart from above design elements various passive techniques in different climates
In case of heating requirement, the techniques for cold climates may be used. Techniques such as roof
pond, roof radiation trap, solar chimney, earth berming, etc. which find dual usage can also be
incorporated.