Konz 2016
Konz 2016
www.elsevier.com/locate/ces
PII: S0009-2509(16)30429-8
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ces.2016.08.007
Reference: CES13104
To appear in: Chemical Engineering Science
Received date: 19 January 2016
Revised date: 15 June 2016
Accepted date: 5 August 2016
Cite this article as: Anne K. Konz and Erich Windhab, Experimental and
Computational Study of a High Speed Pin Mixer via PEPT, Visualization and
C F D , Chemical Engineering Science,
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ces.2016.08.007
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for
publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of
the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and
review of the resulting galley proof before it is published in its final citable form.
Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which
could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
Experimental and Computational Study of a High
a
Laboratory of Food Process Engineering, Institute of Food, Nutrition and Health, ETH
b
Laboratory of Food Process Engineering, Institute of Food, Nutrition and Health, ETH Zurich, LFO E18,
Schmelzbergstrasse 9, CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland.
*
Corresponding author. Phone (mobile): +41 77 418 47 17. E-mail address: [email protected]. Present
address: Oleanderstrasse 14, CH-8050 Zurich, Switzerland
Abstract
Continuous high speed pin mixers have been successfully implemented industrially to mix high fractions of
powders into highly viscous non-Newtonian liquids. However, they have not been described in the literature
yet. This work presents a multi-method approach, consisting of conventional torque and throughput
measurements to calculate average residence times and dimensionless Reynolds/power numbers for
suspension mixing, Positron Emission Particle Tracking (PEPT) to gain information on particle trajectories
and velocities in the investigated opaque model system, high speed film visualization and CFD simulations.
By the combination of these methods, valuable information on the influence of variable process parameters,
particularly on the influence of pin configuration, pin shape and inclination of semi-cylindrical pins on
mixing mechanisms and efficiency, could be gathered for a broad range of viscosities and powder fractions in
Newtonian and non-Newtonian fluids. Flow patterns such as a “Split-and-Recombine” convection pattern at
the pins, axial mixing mechanisms and beneficial process conditions to reduce particle sedimentation caused
by centrifugal forces in the mixer were retrieved from the results. The PEPT methodology was successfully
implemented for a high-shear continuous mixing process of suspensions for the first time. As the combined
methodology shows reasonable and reliable results that were also applicable at industrial scale, the work
1
Phone: +41 44 632 53 48, Fax: +41 44 632 11 55, E-mail address:
[email protected].
1
provides sound basis for further research development of measurement techniques for other mixing
Keywords: Pin mixer, PEPT, CFD, methodology, solid-liquid mixing, opaque systems
1 Introduction
Continuous mixing processes have progressively replaced common used batch processes in
continuous processes, such as being compact with short mixing paths at high throughput
rates, saving resources for interim storage, consuming less space and other resources and
allowing to establish continuous process chains (Patel et al., 2012; Portillo et al., 2009;
For both batch and continuous mixers, thorough understanding of their influence on the
operation conditions and further on the process mechanisms that determine product
properties and quality is required to successfully adapt the parameters to each new mixing
Parameters typically relevant in continuous mixing processes are: Mixer geometry, (if
variable) configuration of the rotor, rotation speed, material throughput rate and the
feeding and properties of mixing components. The effects of the parameters mentioned
previously have been studied by several authors (e.g. Florian et al. (2014)). In particular,
the effect of the impeller geometry as a variable suitable for optimization has been
However, information on the influence of parameters is often lacking due to the large
2
systematic design methodologies and control strategies are limited in their development
Kingston and Heindel (2014) however give rise to concern about the complexity in the
design of experiments and the high amount of resources needed to collect, analyze and
interpret data if too many parameters are incorporated and investigated simultaneously.
Previous experience is therefore beneficial to identify the most influential parameters for
computational power allows the flow mechanisms to be accessed via simulations and to
predict results to restrict efforts for large series of experiments. However, they may be
driving shaft, causing convection as a primary source of mixing (Portillo et al., 2008).
Values for convective, shear and deagglomeration forces can be derived from the mixer
geometry and the rotation speed. Power measurements or direct monitoring of the torque
exerted by the rotor during steady-state mixing operation allow to calculate the specific
energy impacting on the processed materials. Their throughput rate and mass hold-up in
the mixer enable calculation of the average residence time and also efficiency evaluations
The Metzner-Otto concept (Metzner and Otto, 1957) provides an approach for the
can be utilized for scale-up and comparison of mixer types. This approach is also suitable
Complex mixing mechanisms or geometrical parameters changing over time cannot always
be included in the model equations. In the centrifugal high speed mixer presented in this
work, the non-constant immersion depth of the pins into the suspension and air-
3
Noninvasive methods provide information on particle or fluid element trajectories, velocity
fields, residence time distributions, flow mechanisms in different regions of the mixer
Optical tracers/tracer fluids can be applied in a transparent assembly and with transparent
fluid systems, such as with PIV. Opaque systems require the use of different tracing
principles such as LDV, ERT and also the PEPT methodology used in this work.
properties of the mixture connected to product quality and to calculate residence time
However, the high rotation speed and low wall-clearance of the mixer characterized in this
work hindered on-line sampling of the materials and was therefore not put into focus.
Previous work on mixers with adjustable rotor extensions mainly relates to powder mixers
with paddles with variable configurations of paddles and their inclination towards the axial
flow direction, and how the several process parameters influence mixing efficiency. One or
more often a set of methods is used to reach this goal, with some of the studies given in the
Yabushita et al. (1989) investigated the influence of pin sections in a barrel screw extruder
for a rubber compound. PEPT was used by Laurent and Bridgwater (2002a) to describe the
influence of different agitator designs in horizontal powder flow and by Barigou et al.
horizontal laminar flow profiles of non-Newtonian suspensions gained by PEPT with CFD
simulations and found a very good agreement - a similar approach was implemented in our
work.
Pitched blade turbines were studied by Pianko-Oprych et al. (2009) who compared results
of PEPT and PIV measurements for suspensions (5 % w/w) and by Liu and Barigou
4
(2013). They modeled the velocity field and phase distribution of dense monodisperse
solid-liquid suspensions and compared them with PEPT experiments, finding a high degree
Pakzad et al. (2013) compared CFD and ERT results for non-Newtonian batch reactor
To our knowledge, only one multi-method approach for a centrifugal mixer using PEPT
has been presented by Portillo and coworkers (2008, 2009; 2010), but in that case
pharmaceutical powder paddle mixers at much lower rotation speeds were operated. They
used PEPT and NIR respectively to investigate particle trajectories at different operation
settings to assess the mixing quality of samples and found appropriate paddle inclinations
The multi-method approach presented here is used to investigate the influence of operating
parameters on mixing, to our knowledge describing a continuous high speed pin mixer for
the first time. Information on the characterization of this mixer type is unavailable in the
literature, although it has been established to mix solids into highly viscous fluids for
industry-relevant production scales and compositions. As well, the PEPT methodology has
not been described yet for its application on continuous solid-liquid mixers, particularly at
the high rotation speeds given (Barigou et al., 2009; Guida et al., 2010,2011; Edwards et
al., 2009; Perez-Mohedano et al., 2015). It was utilized to reveal flow mechanisms in the
opaque mixer-suspension system. High speed filming for visualization and the comparison
of experimental results with CFD calculations were further methods applied in our
approach.
The influence of variations of pin configuration and particularly pin shape (and inclination
for semi-cylindrical pins) on mixing enhancement and on the local flow around each pin
was characterized. Since pin configurations with semi-cylindrical pins were found to
5
improve mixing and reduce particle sedimentation at the mixer wall, a specific solution
approach for problems arising from the centrifugal demixing tendencies is additionally
addressed in an excursus. The applicability and comparability of the used methods for
certain research aspects, particularly opaque, industrial fluids that are not otherwise
amenable to PIV or LDV measurements, was evaluated. This offers important information
6
2 Experiments
2.1.1 General
Fig. 1 a Schematic of the driving shaft with designed pin arrangement, inlet and outlet positions and
designation of axial zones. b The high speed pin mixer during operation: Housing and driving shaft
assembled with an arrangement of 100 % cylindrical pins (configuration 1, Table 2), powder inlet from the
back, fluid inlet from the front (shifted inlet position not used in the experiments), temperature sensors at the
top, view of the Perspex visualization window. c Photograph of the driving shaft with cylindrical pins
Fig. 1 shows the continuous high speed pin mixer used in this study which was designed
mixer utilized for the industrial production of powder-filled polymers. For optical
7
explorations of the flow mechanisms near the mixer wall, the pilot mixer is additionally
equipped with a Perspex window providing view along the whole mixer axis (Fig. 1b). The
mixer housing comprises inner dimensions of 321 mm in length and 90 mm in diameter and
experiments.
The fluid inlet positioned at an axial position (left to right) of 21 mm and entering laterally
from the front is fed by an eccentric screw pump with a volumetric flow rate freely
adjustable up to 1000 L/h. The powder inlet positioned at an axial position of 71 mm and
entering laterally from the opposite back side of the mixer is fed by a single-screw powder
dosage unit. Via a funnel, the mixer outlet can be connected to the fluid pump to enable
On the driving shaft with a diameter of 45 mm, up to 128 pins can be assembled on two
spirals (27.31° inclination) with the second spiral solely covering the posterior 192 mm of
the mixer axis (Fig. 1a, c). The motor drives the shaft and attached pins with a freely
adjustable rotation speed of up to 3000 rpm which (with 1 mm wall clearance at 3000 rpm)
generates a pin tip speed of 13.82 m/s and shear rates of up to 13820 1/s.
2.1.2 Parameters/Configurations
To characterize the flow behavior of solid-liquid systems under the high shear conditions
in the pin mixer, the following parameters were varied: mixer rotation speed (0-3000 rpm),
fluid or suspension volumetric flow rate (0-1000 L/h), powder mass flow rate (affecting the
powder fraction) and the pin configuration. The inlet positions of powder and fluid
Two pin shapes (Fig. 2) were mainly used in the experiments: A pin with cylindrical shape
with a related pin-wall gap width of 1 mm, and a semi-cylindrical pin with a related gap
width of 1 mm. The inclination of the semi-cylindrical pin was adjusted to inclinations of
8
-45° or +45° (Fig. 2 c), influencing the axial flow behavior.
Fig. 2 a Schematic view of the cylindrical pin (top: 2D drawing, bottom: 3D CAD representation).
b Schematic view of the semi-cylindrical pin (top: 2D drawing, bottom: 3D CAD representation).
Furthermore, the pin fraction was varied and set to either 25 %, 50 % or 100 %. A
differentiated pin assembly for the front zone with only one pin spiral and the back zone
with two pin spirals was only investigated for experiments on the reduction of particle
Two types of fluid were used: Pure glucose syrup (DE 60, BC*Sweet 01257, density:
properties of highly viscous polymers mixed with filling powders relevant for industrial
applications of the high speed mixer. The model fluid consisted of 71.4 % (w/w) glucose
syrup and a 2 % (w/w) aqueous solution of Carbopol solved in water (28.1 % (w/w), Zurich
tap water for usage in high amounts); Carbopol© 0.57 % (Ultrez 20; Lubrizol, Brussels,
Luckham and Rossi (1999)) (Wyoming Greendbond 453; Albert Isliker und Co. AG,
Zurich, Switzerland; laser diffraction particle size X90,3 = 53 μm with a large fraction of
agglomerates; bulk density ca. 800 kg/m3) were combined with the MF either separately by
powder dosage or in a raw suspension premix for continuous circulation of the resulting
Table 1 Composition and application of the combinations of several bentonite fractions with the model fluid
10
6 % bentonite CFD simulations (3.4)
“MF+30%-Bent.” 70 % MF dosed PEPT experiments (3.2),
30 % bentonite separately CFD simulations (3.4)
variable MF + stepwise dosed Sedimentation excursus
increased separately (4.2)
bentonite fraction
A powder fraction of 5 % (w/w, density: 1200 kg/m3) was chosen for the mixer’s parameter
studies. The “MF+6%-Bent.” premix represented the composition with the highest
viscosity still allowing continuous circulation through the mixer. The “MF+30%-Bent.”
composition (“IC”) produced with the upscaled version of the high speed pin mixer (Fig.
3b). The addition of a large amount of fine powders (i.e. bentonite) into the model fluid
lead to resistance to the flow, thus increase in apparent viscosity at a given shear rate.
The PEPT experimental conditions using pure GS and the MF+6%-Bent. and MF+30%-
Bent. solid-liquid systems were reproduced by CFD simulations as well. The flow behavior
of the IC was used for CFD simulations relating to the influence of semi-cylindrical pin
inclinations.
11
2.2.3 Rheology
Fig. 3 a Viscosity data of GS, MF, MF+5%-Bent. composition, MF+6%-Bent. composition, and MF+30%-
Bent. composition at 30 °C; Power law fit constants: GS: K=5.426, n=0.97; MF: K=0.289, n=0.557; MF+5%-
Viscosity data of the fluids and compositions investigated in the experiments at 30 °C and
their constants fit to the Power law equation η = Kγn-1 are shown in Fig. 3a. A comparison
The viscosity measurements were performed with a stress-controlled Physica MCR 300
geometry (CC27, Searle type) was used except for the measurements with 30 % powder
12
fraction (PP25 plate-plate geometry). A preshear period of 1 min at 1000 s-1 and then a
shear rate profile was applied (increasing from 0.01 to 1000 s-1, then decreasing from 1000
to 0.01 s-1 and utilizing the resulting viscosity values from the backward measurement as
throughput rate on net torque and average residence time with the MF+5%-Bent.
composition
The mixer was equipped with a torquemeter and connected to a computer running a
LabView program customized to monitor and record the torque directly at the mixer
driving shaft (temporal resolution: 70 ms, continuous averaging over 50 values to reduce
fluctuations).
and the suspension’s mass hold-up in the mixer gathered and determined gravimetrically.
The net torque during circulation of MF+5%-Bent., average residence times and average
wall layer thickness for each configuration, rotation speed and throughput rate were
calculated accordingly. The parameters considered in this study and their respective
Table 2 Configurations used and details for the assembly in the front and back zone (Fig. 1a)
13
2 50 1 C -d
3 25 1 C -d
4 25 1 SC +45
5 25 1 SC -45
a b c
= Configuration Number; : between pin and wall; : C = cylindrical, SC = semi-cylindrical;
d
: - = no inclination (cylindrical pins)
2.3.2 PEPT
Birmingham, UK. In this study, 18F-marked resin particles (Fan et al., 2006) with a
diameter of 100 m (density: 1100 kg/m3) were used and tested to be neutrally buoyant in
all investigated fluids and suspensions (similar density). Table 4 provides the combinations
14
Table 4 Configurations (Table 2), operation modes and measured temperatures for the three model
The rotation speed was set to either 500, 1000, 1750 or 2500 rpm.
The calculation settings for the trajectory calculation algorithm (Parker et al., 1993) were
set to fopt=20 (optimization parameter), Nevent=75 (decay events per generated data
High speed films with a frame rate of 30 000 frames/s were recorded with a Memrecam
fx RX-6 (NAC Image Technology, Simi Valley, USA) through the window on the upper
side of the pilot scale pin mixer. The rig also consisted of an intensive 1000 W lighting
assembly.
2.3.4 Simulations
The following conditions were used for the simulations: The geometry of the pilot pin
mixer was replicated with a mesh size of 0.6-2.6 x 106 hexahedral cells. The gap between
the pin and the wall has a resolution of 9 cells over the height. Density and viscosity data
as previously presented and a reference pressure of 1 bar were used and laminar and non-
buoyant behavior assumed. The simulations were performed in a steady-state mode
(relative frame), with a counter-rotating outer wall. All rotor walls and the pins have a no-
slip condition. Using a step function at the inlet, the gas/liquid fraction was imposed
depending on the radius and according to the operating point mass flow. In the outer part
of the inlet, Bentonite/MF was introduced, in the center air.
15
The governing equations used in Ansys CFX are the Free Surface Model for the interphase
transfer (VOF-Model) and the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations for solving the flow
conditions. The Shear Stress Transport Model (SST) was used to describe the turbulence.
The computation grids are show in the Fig. 4.
3 Results
16
3.1 Parameter studies
3.1.1 Net torque with 5 % (w/w) bentonite suspension and calculated average
residence times
Fig. 5 a Net torque for configurations 1-5, combinations of three rotation speeds with two mass throughput
rates (MF+5%-Bent. suspension). b Average residence time, calculated from the mass hold-up gathered from
the mixer. Configurations: 1: 100 % cylindrical pins, 2: 50 % cylindrical pins, 3: 25 % cylindrical pins,
4: 25 % semi-cylindrical pins with +45° inclination, 5: 25 % semi-cylindrical pins with -45° inclination; all
with 1 mm pin-wall gap width
Fig. 5a shows the net torque values during circulation of the non-Newtonian MF-5%-Bent.
premix. A definite dependence of the net torque values on the rotation speed was not
found. Despite the low pin fraction of 25 %, the net torque values of configuration 5 mostly
exceed those of configuration 1-4. The difference in the pins’ shape in configurations 3, 4
and 5 shows a decreasing effect on the net torque values for semi-cylindrical pins with
+45° inclination relative to the axial flow direction (configuration 4) and an increasing
17
effect for semi-cylindrical pins with -45° inclination (configuration 5). A pin inclination of
thereby leading to a higher drag on the pins and a higher net torque, with the opposite
The average residence times as calculated from the respective mass hold-up gathered from
the mixer are depicted in Fig. 5b. (An exceedingly high torque and emergency stop averted
the measurement at the combination of 3000 rpm and 100 kg/h for configuration 5.)
The suspension mass retained in the mixer (values proportional to the average residence
times) strongly depends upon the mass throughput rate. This is also reflected by the
observed suspension consistency, showing a higher viscosity and mixing grade for the
lower mass throughput rate whereas the higher mass throughput rate resulted in a very
fluid consistency with lumps of powder poorly mixed into fluid. The retained mass values
range from 75 to 1250 g. The average suspension layer thickness at the mixer wall as
calculated from the mass retention values ranges from about 1 to 11 mm, suggesting that a
sufficient immersion depth of the pin tips into the suspension mass is provided at a pin-
The obtained average residence time values range from 1 to 45 s, suggesting a low overall
mixing intensity for a mass throughput rate of 250 kg/h and a close correlation of lower pin
The strong effect of the pin shape on the time available for mixing is confirmed, especially
high net torque working on the suspension combined with a high average residence time as
given in configuration 5 indicates best prerequisites for intensive mixing forces exerted on
the suspension, particularly at low mass throughput rates such as 100 kg/h.
18
3.1.2 Reynolds and Power numbers
During the preparations for the parameter studies with the MF+5%-Bent. suspension,
torque measurements were recorded to develop a description of the mixer following the
rate and a mixer constant, using glucose syrup as a Newtonian fluid. Several deviations
from the included general assumptions hindered this full description, mainly local
temperature deviations by friction between pin and wall and air entrained which influenced
the overall fluid density. Both factors lead to changes in viscosity that could not be
accounted for in the rheological viscosity measurements. Additionally, the wavy fluid
surface caused the pin-dipping length and thereby the effective rotor diameter to vary
constantly.
19
Fig. 6 a Reynolds-Power number plot for configurations 1-5 (Table 2), combinations of three rotation speeds
at 100 kg/h throughput rate (MF+5%-Bent. suspension). b Reynolds-Power number plot for configurations
1-5 (Table 2), combinations of three rotation speeds at 250 kg/h throughput rate (MF+5%-Bent. suspension)
However, the torque data for the MF+5%-Bent. suspension (section 3.1.1, viscosity
function in Fig. 3a) were used to calculate Reynolds and Power numbers for all
investigated parameter combinations, shown in Fig. 6a for 100 kg/h throughput rate and in
The estimated Reynolds numbers indicate there was mixing in a turbulent regime. The
Power numbers are in a very low range of 10-2 to 10-5. Their span is narrower for a rotation
speed of 1000 rpm for both throughput rates. For rotation speeds of 2000 rpm and
particularly 3000 rpm, the relatively low values for configuration 4 with an assembly of
25 % +45°-inclined pins are assumed to be caused by the low filling degree and low
residence time in the mixer due to increased downstream velocity. The Power number
20
values for configuration 5 with an assembly of 25 % -45°-inclined pins, which effectuates
a high filling degree and residence time by a higher recirculation, are similar to
configuration 1 with 100 % cylindrical pins. This indicates a similar or even higher energy
3.2 PEPT
Fig. 7 3D trajectory of the tracer particle transported in GS. The color scale indicates the residence time with
the tracer particle entering the mixer from the pump at the right lower end at 9.1 x 105 ms and leaving the
mixer at 9.8 x 105 ms, resulting in a residence time of 7 s; conditions: configuration 1, rotation speed:
Velocity data, residence times, occupancy data and 2D as well as 3D trajectories were
derived from the PEPT data and were further evaluated. Fig. 7 shows a 3D trajectory of the
tracer particle transported in GS. It is evident that a spiral movement near the mixer wall is
continuous powder mixer equipped with blades for low rotation speeds. The latter
obviously had the same effect of a relatively low tracer particle velocity like GS as
21
All data were evaluated respective to their median values to avoid a strong influence of
outliers, caused by the tracer particle being stuck during its movement through the mixer.
For the mixing of 30 % (w/w) bentonite fraction into MF, as the particle had to be
recollected and added manually, only 10 trajectories could be received that only allowed
Fig. 8 Axial velocity distributions for the tracer particle movement a in GS for pin configuration 1,
combinations of three rotation speeds with three fluid throughput rates; b in MF+6%-Bent. suspension for pin
configuration 1, for combinations of two rotation speeds with three suspension throughput rates. Both
quantified as given by the fraction of data points from cumulative trajectory information
22
Figs. 8 a and b give axial velocity distributions for the Newtonian GS fluid and the non-
rates and rotation speeds. Most plausibly caused by the pins’ action to split the mass in
front of the pins, a high share of axial backward movement is measured and the velocity
values are low. As expected, the higher the throughput rate and/or the rotation speed, the
higher the velocities. The axial velocity frequency distribution for the Newtonian GS is
narrower and suggests that the tracer particle moved slowly and steadily very close to the
wall.
3.2.2 Total (x-y-z components combined) velocities and their radial distribution
The radial distribution of total velocities between mixer wall and driving shaft, collected
from all recorded trajectories, is shown in Fig. 9a for GS and in Fig. 8b for the MF+6%-
Bent. composition. The median velocity depending on the radial position indicates lower
values of median velocity (ca. 0.13 m/s) for the Newtonian GS (viscosity: 4.1 Pa s)
particularly near the mixer wall, whereas the values for the non-Newtonian MF+6%-Bent.
composition (viscosity: 5 x 10-3 Pa s) are twice as high as for GS. The faster and more
discontinuous axial and total transport found for the bentonite suspension with its lower
viscosity is reflected in the more uniform and higher velocities also near the mixer wall.
23
Fig. 9 Total velocity of the tracer particle movement vs. its distance from the mixer wall for pin
configuration 1, rotation speed 2500 rpm, fluid throughput rate 1000 L/h a in GS; b in MF+6%-Bent.
suspension
Selected results of median residence times from the PEPT experiments are included in
Table 4 (section 3.5) and compared to results from the parameter studies and simulation
calculations. They range about 10-fold higher than the simulation values for the MF+6%-
Bent. and MF+30%-Bent suspensions and even about 100-fold higher for GS which is
mainly attributed to the comparatively large tracer particle size of 100 μm. This reason for
the deviation of values and other possible causes are discussed in section 3.5.
24
3.3 High speed film visualization
Fig. 10 a “Split-and-Recombine” flow pattern visualization captured from a high speed video sequence
(20 000 frames/s, GS at 30 °C, rotation speed: 2000 rpm). b Schematic showing two subsequent pins, the
velocity vectors and the fluid flow (from right to left side), split behind the first pin, partly recombining
flow (a) and a schematic, delineating the flow mechanism in (b): The mass is split into two
portions in front of each pin (moving from the left to the right side of the frame) and
recombines behind the pin. This phenomenon is particularly obvious at lower viscosities
and is likely attributed to repeated convective mixing. For processing GS, the Reynolds
numbers for the local flow around a cylindrical pin have been calculated according to
Schlichting and Gersten (2006). They lie in the range between 7.7 for a rotation speed of
25
1000 rpm (pin tip speed 4.61 m/s) and 23.2 for a rotation speed of 3000 rpm (pin tip speed
13.82 m/s). For Reynolds numbers between about 3 and 30, a laminar flow around a
cylindrical pin is postulated (Schlichting and Gersten, 2006) with small eddies forming
Fig. 13 (section 3.4) also shows visualizations from photographs in comparison with
Fig. 11 Suspension surface radius contours (orange contours close to the wall, green and blue contours at
inner radius) for the MF+30%-Bent. composition at a rotation speed of 2500 rpm and a mass throughput rate
of 300 kg/h at 60 °C
The simulation visualization shown in Fig. 11 also reveals an impression of the “Split-and-
Recombine” mechanism as well as the spiral bulge forming at higher mass throughput
rates and viscosities of the mixture. Similar “cross-sectional spiraling motion” as a result of
the combination of axial transport and blade (or in our case pin) rotations has been
observed by Portillo et al. (2010) in their work with continuous powder-only mixers.
26
Fig. 12 Volume fraction of the IC at a rotation speed of 1750 rpm and a mass throughput rate of 1000 kg/h at
60 °C for three pin inclination angles: a -45°-inclined semi-cylindrical pins, b cylindrical pins,
Fig. 12 shows the dependence of the mixer’s filling degree on the pin shape and
inclination, implying correlated residence times. The suspension volume occupies a major
portion of the mixer volume for the semi-cylindrical pin assembly with an inclination angle
of -45° and only a minor portion with an inclination angle of +45°, with the filling degree
The simulation showed no clear trend for the turbulence in the mixed mass volume,
particularly below the pins, but additional simulations (not shown) revealed a stronger
27
Fig. 13 Photographs through the mixer window (left side) and simulation visualizations (right side) for GS at
30 °C, both for a fluid throughput rate of 100 L/h and a rotation speed of 1000 rpm (top) and 2500 rpm
(bottom), respectively
The simulation visualization for GS at 2500 rpm shown in Fig. 13 reflects the experimental
findings reliably concerning aspects such as the appearance of the fluid surface and the
thinner fluid layer where pin traces remain recognizable. Since no additional tracer particle
is involved, this indicates that the values calculated by the CFD simulations predict the
3.5 Exemplary comparison of results for the residence time, measured in PEPT
Table 5 Comparison (congeneric compositions and throughput rates) of residence time values from PEPT
measurements, CFD calculations and one parameter study, all for a rotation speed of 2500 rpm
28
MF+5%-Bent. 1.25 sc
throughput rate 400 L/h 400 L/h 250 kg/h ≈ 350 L/
h
MF+30%-Bent. 2 7.04 sb 0.5982 sc
throughput rate 120 kg/h 1350 kg/h
a b c
= Configuration, = median value, = average value
Table 5 gives an overview over selected residence time values as measured by PEPT,
calculated in simulations and one value calculated from the parameter studies. For the
reasons given above, median values were calculated for the PEPT experiments while the
values from the parameter study and the simulation calculations are average values. Apart
from that, the simulations were calculated using the same conditions as in the PEPT
experiments, however based on a configuration with two pin spirals over the full mixer
length in contrast to the experimental pin configuration (Fig. 1a) with only one spiral in the
front zone.
The value from the parameter studies for the MF+5%-Bent. composition corresponds well
The average residence time values calculated from simulations all cover the same range of
The values received from the PEPT experiments range 10-fold higher. In the case of the
differing throughput rate. But for the other compositions as well, particularly for GS, the
PEPT experimental results reveal a very high median residence time which is attributed to
the tracer particle’s almost exclusive movement near the mixer wall (also due to its
comparatively large size) that is not reflected by simulation (1). This behavior has also
Furthermore, simulations were based on a premixed suspension, not taking the behavior of
experimental results to those of simulation calculations. Due to the high rotation speed
required to enable mixing of high powder fractions into the very viscous liquid, a
significant amount of air was entrained into the suspension, also influencing the
could not take air entrainment into account as they were calculated with the viscosity
values taken from rheological measurements where no air was entrained. This difference in
the preconditions is assumed to induce a part of the differences found in the comparison
above (3).
We expect these three arguments to be the main reasons why experimental and simulation
results were not closely comparable and that this difference reflects the chances in and
Nevertheless, most of the result ranges for both the chosen Newtonian as well as the non-
Newtonian fluid are in good accordance to a rough estimation of the residence time that
takes throughput rate and wall layer thickness into account where a range of 2-10 s is
received.
4 Discussion
4.1 Flow mechanisms and their detection by PEPT, high speed film visualization
The exemplary high speed film visualization in Fig. 9 and the simulation results in Fig. 10
and Fig. 11 show the flow mechanism around the pin to be initiated by a splitting of the
mass in front of the pin for both Newtonian as well as non-Newtonian fluids. Depending
on process conditions and at lower viscosities in particular, a part of the mass flows
30
together behind the pin and is split again by the following pin. We describe this flow
elements. These findings were also validated for the Newtonian fluid GS by the PEPT
experiments: The measured axial velocities show the degree of axially backwards oriented
movement to be only slightly lower than the one of forwards oriented movement, which
In numerical results, Chen et al. (2011) found that pins disrupt and partially disorganize
particle trajectories in mixing sections, split material flow and change particle moving
directions. They stated that pin mixing sections increase the material residence time and
thereby also in mixing performance and efficiency. The same effect of pins dividing a
temporary channel in two different channels, thereby separating flows, was observed by
Yabushita et al. (1989) in their investigation of barrel extruders equipped with additional
pins.
For suspensions with higher viscosities, simulations display the major portion of the fluid
mass to be transported in a spiral bulge. This additional mechanism accounts for the higher
axial velocities in these compositions and was also reflected by the PEPT results
(section 3.3.1) and the lower residence times in the parameter studies.
Regarding the detection of flow mechanisms in continuous pin mixers, the visualization
methods through the mixer window and PEPT only reflect the situation near the mixer wall
as explained in section 3.6. However, for other types of mixers PEPT can provide reliable
results also in the inner parts of a mixer, but the tracer particle size still needs to be chosen
carefully. A major advantage of PEPT is its access to opaque systems while not
influencing the mixing process and allowing for elaborate evaluations beyond the scope
presented here.
Our simulations gave reasonable predictions of flow mechanisms, velocities and residence
31
4.2 Influence of pin shape and inclination angle on the residence time and mixing
As reported in the results of the parameter studies and of the conducted simulations, the pin
shape and the inclination angle of the semi-cylindrical pins have a greater influence on all
This finding is consistent with the observations of Chen et al. (2011) who extracted from
their simulations that the mixing performance is not necessarily enhanced by an increased
number of pins.
Opposing effects of +45° and -45° inclination angle of semi-cylindrical pins were found:
+45°-inclined pins were substantiated to cause enhanced axial flow, lower residence times
with an associated lower filling degree of the mixer and due to the combination of these
impacts a lower mechanical input on the suspension. -45°-inclined pins promote backflow
with associated higher residence times. In addition to the positive impact of prolonged and
turbulence around the pins and in the pin-wall gap. Additionally, the turbulence around the
pin tip could be particularly significant although the responsible micro-scale mechanisms
The effect of inclined blades in continuous powder mixers, leading the flow partially
backward, on mixing performance was also investigated by Gao et al. (2011a) and in
several works of Portillo and coworkers (2008, 2009; 2010). Gao et al. (2011a) observed
more effective mixing for alternate blade patterns with some of the blades pushing the
powder backwards and ascribed this to convective recirculation, enhancing the mixing rate.
Gao et al. (2011a) and Gao et al. (2011b) found an increase in fill level to increase the
mean residence time and lower fill levels to shorten residence time and slow down axial
mixing. Lee et al. (2012) reported that decreased screw speed and kneading blocks
32
arranged in an increased angle in mixing zones increased residence time in granulation
processes.
Portillo et al. (2010) described increased impeller rotation speeds to result in longer total
path length. However, they found that an increase in flow rate at lower rotation speed
increased the residence time and decreased the axial dispersion while an increased flow
rate at higher rotation speed still decreased the residence time, but had a complex effect on
axial dispersion.
Laurent and Bridgwater (2002b) reported effects of fill level and increased blade angle to
promote axial dispersion forces in a horizontal mixer that they investigated using PEPT.
convection-blades, the residence time distribution and connected mixing homogeneity was
directly affected by the parameters discussed in literature: blade rotation rate, blade design,
blade configuration, flow rate, and material properties. These parameters were also the
ones that could affect mixing performance in the continuous high speed pin mixer
sedimentation at the mixer wall and confirmed impact of flow behavior around the
pins
Optimizing conditions for initial powder wetting by the highly viscous liquid is decisive to
prevent demixing by centrifugal forces in the high speed pin mixer. Fig. 14 gives an
impression of the deposition forms of a separated powder particle layer at the mixer wall at
high powder fractions and its streaky appearance as effectuated by the pins grooving
33
Fig. 14 Deposition of powder as a soaked particle layer adhering to the mixer wall. a Mixer window with
deposits along the full axis with marker lines indicating the pin tip diameter. b Stripes of deposits forming as
“lines” in pin tip diameter width and dotted “lines” in half the width. c Close-up of the deposit pattern.
d Demonstration of the layer’s spatial structure and thickness with an incidental imprint of a pin on a
different pin fractions in the front and back mixing zone and cylindrical and semi-
cylindrical pin shapes were tested regarding their potential to prevent particle
sedimentation at the mixer wall. Increasing powder fractions were dosed to the MF flow at
and 100 % cylindrical pins in the back main mixing zone was found to allow the highest
mixer wall as evaluated through the mixer window. The superiority of this configuration is
supposed to result from a high degree of backwards-oriented flow in the front zone where
powder and fluid get into contact and correlated higher residence time in this zone. The
implementation of this configuration in the industrial-scale version of the high speed pin
mixer using the IC evinced the transferability of the configuration’s advantages. The
connoted reduction in agglomerates impairing product quality and the reduced mixer
34
downtimes required for cleaning are supporting the usefulness of the multi-method
4.3 Implications for the selection of process conditions for optimal mixing results at
different viscosities
For the continuous high speed pin mixer in this work and the non-Newtonian solid-liquid
compositions to be mixed, the major parameter influencing both the process and the
resulting product was the pin configuration. The application of specific pin shapes and
inclinations for the different requirements of each mixing zone is especially influential. A
strong mechanical impact on the respective composition and minimized particle deposits at
5 Conclusion
provides a valuable toolbox for the engineering and optimization of continuous high speed
mixers with complex configuration and parameter options, particularly for the mixing of
opaque compounds. The respective advantages and limitations of each method have been
explored and underlined, but the demonstrated combination of approaches gives access to
the investigation of selected aspects that are important for a successful implementation of
the materials and apparatus used. Nevertheless, markers to determine the quality of mixing
still need to be selected separately corresponding to the materials and the desired
requirements.
35
Acknowledgements
The financial support of the Swiss “Kommission für Technologie und Innovation” KTI with integrated
financial support from an industrial partner is gratefully acknowledged. The authors would like to thank
Prof. E. Casartelli, N. Ledergerber and P. Stern from the Fluid Dynamics Group of the Lucerne University of
Applied Science and Arts for providing high performance CFD simulations and visualizations in this project,
based on the KTI collaboration. The authors further want to thank Dr. T. Leadbeater and Dr. J. Gargiuli for
their support during the PEPT experiments at the Positron Imaging Centre at the University of Birmingham
that was substantial for the successful application of the PEPT methodology under new technical conditions,
and Dr. Steven Wang for his support during the submission process.
References
Barigou, M., Fairhurst, P., Fryer, P., Pain, J.-P., 2003. Concentric flow regime of solid–liquid food
suspensions: theory and experiment. Chemical Engineering Science 58, 1671-1686.
Barigou, M., Chiti, F., Pianko-Oprych, P., Guida, A., Adams, L., Fan, X., Parker, D.J. & Nienow, A.W.,
2009, Using positron emission particle tracking (PEPT) to study mixing in stirred vessels: validation and
tackling unsolved problems in opaque systems, Journal of Chemical Engineering of Japan, 42(11), 839-84
Chen, J., Dai, P., Yao, H., Chan, T., 2011. Numerical analysis of mixing performance of mixing section in
pin-barrel single-screw extruder. Journal of Polymer Engineering 31, 53-62.
Eesa, M., Barigou, M., 2008. Horizontal laminar flow of coarse nearly-neutrally buoyant particles in non-
Newtonian conveying fluids: CFD and PEPT experiments compared. International Journal of Multiphase
Flow 34, 997-1007.
Edwards, I., Axon, S.A., Barigou, M., Stitt, E.H., 2009, Combined use of PEPT and ERT in the study of
aluminium hydroxide precipitation, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 48(2), 1019–1028.
Fan, X., Parker, D., Smith, M., 2006. Enhancing 18 F uptake in a single particle for positron emission particle
tracking through modification of solid surface chemistry. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics
Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment 558, 542-546.
Florian, M., Velázquez, C., Méndez, R., 2014. New continuous tumble mixer characterization. Powder
Technology 256, 188-195.
Gao, Y., Ierapetritou, M., Muzzio, F., 2011a. Investigation on the effect of blade patterns on continuous solid
mixing performance. The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering 89, 969-984.
Gao, Y., Vanarase, A., Muzzio, F., Ierapetritou, M., 2011b. Characterizing continuous powder mixing using
residence time distribution. Chemical Engineering Science 66, 417-425.
Guida, A., Nienow, A.W., Barigou, M., 2010, PEPT measurements of solid-liquid flow field and spatial
phase distribution in concentrated monodisperse stirred suspensions, Chemical Engineering Science, 65(6),
1905-1914.
Guida, A., Nienow, A.W., Barigou, M., 2011, Mixing of dense binary suspensions: multi-component
hydrodynamics and spatial phase distribution by PEPT, AIChE J, 57(9), 2302-2315.
Kingston, T.A., Heindel, T.J., 2014. Optical visualization and composition analysis to quantify continuous
granular mixing processes. Powder Technology 262, 257-264.
Laurent, B., Bridgwater, J., 2002a. Influence of agitator design on powder flow. Chemical Engineering
Science 57, 3781-3793.
Laurent, B., Bridgwater, J., 2002b. Performance of single and six-bladed powder mixers. Chemical
Engineering Science 57, 1695-1709.
Lee, K.T., Ingram, A., Rowson, N.A., 2012. Twin screw wet granulation: The study of a continuous twin
screw granulator using Positron Emission Particle Tracking (PEPT) technique. European Journal of
Pharmaceutics and Biopharmaceutics 81, 666-673.
Liu, L., Barigou, M., 2013. Numerical modelling of velocity field and phase distribution in dense
monodisperse solid–liquid suspensions under different regimes of agitation: CFD and PEPT experiments.
Chemical Engineering Science 101, 837-850.
36
Luckham, P.F., Rossi, S., 1999. The colloidal and rheological properties of bentonite suspensions. Advances
in colloid and interface science 82, 43-92.
Metzner, A., Otto, R., 1957. Agitation of non‐ Newtonian fluids. AIChE Journal 3, 3-10.
Pakzad, L., Ein-Mozaffari, F., Upreti, S.R., Lohi, A., 2013. Evaluation of the mixing of non-Newtonian
biopolymer solutions in the reactors equipped with the coaxial mixers through tomography and CFD.
Chemical Engineering Journal 215, 279-296.
Parker, D., Broadbent, C., Fowles, P., Hawkesworth, M., McNeil, P., 1993. Positron emission particle
tracking-a technique for studying flow within engineering equipment. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in
Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment 326, 592-
607.
Patel, D., Ein‐ Mozaffari, F., Mehrvar, M., 2012. Effect of impeller type on continuous‐ flow mixing of
non‐ Newtonian fluids in stirred vessels through dynamic tests. The Canadian Journal of Chemical
Engineering 90, 290-298.
Perez-Mohedano, R., Letzelter, N., Amador, C., VanderRoest, C.T., Bakalis, S., 2015. Positron Emission
Particle Tracking (PEPT) for the analysis of motion in a domestic dishwasher, Chemical Engineering Journal,
259(1), 724-736.
Pianko-Oprych, P., Nienow, A., Barigou, M., 2009. Positron emission particle tracking (PEPT) compared to
particle image velocimetry (PIV) for studying the flow generated by a pitched-blade turbine in single phase
and multi-phase systems. Chemical Engineering Science 64, 4955-4968.
Portillo, P.M., Ierapetritou, M.G., Muzzio, F.J., 2008. Characterization of continuous convective powder
mixing processes. Powder Technology 182, 368-378.
Portillo, P.M., Ierapetritou, M.G., Muzzio, F.J., 2009. Effects of rotation rate, mixing angle, and cohesion in
two continuous powder mixers—a statistical approach. Powder Technology 194, 217-227.
Portillo, P.M., Vanarase, A.U., Ingram, A., Seville, J.K., Ierapetritou, M.G., Muzzio, F.J., 2010. Investigation
of the effect of impeller rotation rate, powder flow rate, and cohesion on powder flow behavior in a
continuous blender using PEPT. Chemical Engineering Science 65, 5658-5668.
Schlichting, H., Gersten, K., 2006. Grenzschicht-Theorie. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg.
Weinekötter, R., Gericke, H., 2000. Mixing of Solids, Mixing of Solids. Kluwer Academic Publishers,
Dordrecht, Boston, London, p. 109.
Yabushita, Y., Brzoskowski, R., White, J., Najakima, N., 1989. Flow of Rubber Compound in a Pin Barrel
Screw Extruder. International Polymer Processing 4, 219-224.
Highlights
A novel fast-rotating pin mixer for handling of viscous dense suspensions is described
and characterized.
in opaque flows.
CFD and experimental results confirm the specific flow mechanisms of Newtonian and
37