Ch3-Question Appendix
Ch3-Question Appendix
3.4 SUMMARY
To make OOM and study estimates, an engineer has to:
• Be able to adjust costs to different time periods. Use Equation 2.7 and
one of the construction cost indices, preferably the CEPI for chemical
processes, to adjust costs.
• Be able to ratio costs for different capacities. Use Equation 3.1 and a size
exponent list to ratio costs. When one does not know the size exponent,
use 0.67 for plants and 0.60 for equipment.
• Be able to estimate equipment purchase costs using budget quotes, com-
pany and personal data, purchased data/software, or published data.
• Be able to convert equipment purchase costs into capital costs using the
Lang method (Equation 3.2) or the Hand factor method (Equation 3.3).
3.5 PROBLEMS/EXERCISES
1. Using the equipment cost graphs in Appendix IV, find the purchase cost
(at a CEPI of 460) of the following:
a. A U-tube HEX with 304 SS shell and tubes, a pressure rating of 600
psig, and 16 ft tubes. The HEX is a three-shell unit with 200 ft2 in
each shell.
b. A centrifugal air compressor having a capacity of 900 scfm and a
discharge pressure of 150 psig.
c. A system comprised of a tank, agitators, and a pump. The tank is made
of CS and has a capacity of 70K gal. The tank will have three side-
mounted, CS 20 HP propeller agitators with stuffing boxes. The pump
is a cast iron rotary positive displacement unit rated at 200 gpm and
100 ft discharge pressure.
d. A 304 SS, 4000 gal vertical pressure vessel having a design rating of
150 psig.
Estimating Investments 63
64
H 2 Vent
150 psig A1
Steam
250°F
350°F T2
Oil Feed:
120°F HE 1 TC 1 A2
250K lb/hr P1 N2
Catalyst: HE 2
120°F F1
R1
P2 200°F P4 85°F
T3 Cooling
350°F T1 Water
85°F
Cooling
40 psig Water 120°F Oil
8212_C003.fm Page 64 Friday, September 29, 2006 12:35 PM
C1 HE 3
H 2: P5
P3
10 psig
Catalyst to
Catalyst System
Estimating Investments 65
TABLE 3.8
Problem 4, Hydrogenation Equipment List
Equipment Number/Description Comments
P 1: Oil feed pump; ANSI centrifugal, cast steel, 270 This is an existing pump. The cost to replace
gpm @ 350 ft of head it (CEPI = 400) is $9.8K.
HE 1: Reactor heater: 2800 ft2 U-tube, CS/CS
(shell/tubes), 150 psig MAP
P 2: Catalyst pump: diaphragm, CS, 1 gpm @ 150 A similar pump, but rated at 1.5 gpm @ 150
psig psig, was purchased in 2000 for $5300.
C 1: Hydrogen compressor: reciprocating, 260 scfm,
40 psig discharge pressure, 50 HP
R 1:Reactor: 12K gal, CS, 150 psig MAP A similar reactor, but 10K gal, SS, and 50 psig
pressure rating, was purchased in 1999 for
$58.5K.
A 1: Reactor agitator, Two-bladed turbine, CS, 150
rpm, 40 HP with mechanical seal
TC 1: Reactor heating and cooling coil: 250 ft2, CS Use a price of $14/ft2 @ CEPI of 500
T 2: Filter feed tank: 12K gal, CS, 150 psig PV
A 2: Filter feed tank agitator: Side-entering propeller
with mechanical seal, CS, 5 HP
P 4: Filter feed pump: ANSI centrifugal, cast steel,
270 gpm @ 350 ft of head
F 1: Filter, 40 ft2, candle, CS In 2002, a similar candle filter, but having 60
ft2, was bought for the Memphis plant for
$12.2K.
T 3: Filtrate tank: 2000 gal, CS, atmospheric
P 5: Filtrate pump: ANSI centrifugal, cast steel,70
gpm @ 350 ft of head
HE 3: Oil cooler: 660 ft2 U-tube, CS/CS, 150 psig
T 1: Water surge tank: 100 gal, CS, 150 psig PV This is an existing tank. Its replacement cost
(CEPI = 400) is $1800.
P 3: Recirculating water pump: ANSI centrifugal,
cast steel, 70 gpm @ 350 ft of head
HE 2: Water cooler: 50 ft2 U-tube, CS/CS 150 psig
8212_A004.fm Page 313 Tuesday, September 26, 2006 12:09 PM
Appendix IV
Equipment Pricing Data
This appendix provides up-to-date equipment purchase cost data for 15 different
types of process equipment. Included in the data are purchase prices, price versus
capacity equations, size exponents, factors for different materials of construction,
factors for different design pressures, and factors for different types of equipment
(for example: floating head versus U-tube heat exchangers). The data can be used
for a variety of purposes:
All the data in the following pages are based upon a CEPI of 460, which roughly
corresponds to a date of March 2005.
The data is based upon actual purchase cost data, budget quotes, and previously
published data. Each of the cost charts blends data from several sources. The sources
used are:
313
8212_A004.fm Page 314 Tuesday, September 26, 2006 12:09 PM
AGITATORS
Side-entering propeller: 316 SS wetted parts, Single propeller,
Stuffing box, Motor
Top-entering turbine: SS wetted parts, Single blade, Stuffing box,
Gear reducer, Motor. Shaft speed: 30–45 rpm
1000
Turbine
100
Purchase cost, $K
CEPI = 460
10
Propeller
1
1 10 100 1000
Agitator HP
BLOWERS
Cast iron with motor
1000
30 psig
10 psig
100 3 psig
Purchase cost, $K
CEPI = 460
1 psig
10
1
100 1000 10000 100000
Blower capacity, cfm
Equations
1 psig $K = 0.066 cfm0.63
3 psig, < 5000 cfm $K = 0.516 cfm0.46
3 psig, > 5000 cfm $K = 0.023 cfm0.82
10 psig $K = 0.174 cfm0.70
30 psig $K = 4.09 cfm0.49
Size Exponents
1 psig 0.63
3 psig, < 5000 cfm 0.46
3 psig, > 5000 cfm 0.82
10 psig 0.70
30 psig 0.49
8212_A004.fm Page 317 Tuesday, September 26, 2006 12:09 PM
BOILERS
Oil and gas fired, No superheat
Small package boilers, 10–1000 HP, 150 psig
Large package boilers, 10K–300K lb/hr, 250 psig
Field-erected boilers, 100K–1000K lb/hr, 400 psig
100000
1000
Purchase cost, $K
CEPI = 460
100
Small package, HP
10
1
10 100 1000
Boiler capacity, HP or K lb/hr
8212_A004.fm Page 318 Tuesday, September 26, 2006 12:09 PM
Field-Erected
400 psig 1.00
500 1.04
600 1.08
700 1.14
1000 1.32
8212_A004.fm Page 319 Tuesday, September 26, 2006 12:09 PM
CENTRIFUGES
Filtering centrifuges: Solid-bowl, Screen-bowl, and Pusher,
316 Stainless steel, including motor
Sedimenting centrifuges: Disc and sedimenting-scroll,
316 Stainless steel, including motor
1000
Filtering--TPH of
Purchase Cost, $K
10
1 10 100
Capacity, TPH of Dry Solids Feed or Bowl Diameter, in
COLUMNS
Distillation, Stripping, Absorption — Tray or Packed
To estimate the cost of a column, first find the price of the vessel using the Pressure
Vessel page. Next, adjust that cost using the appropriate factor from the graph below.
If the metallurgy is other than carbon steel or the design pressure is different from
150 psig, adjust the pressure vessel cost using factors on the pressure vessel page.
Estimate the cost of column internals, trays, and packing using the graph on the
next page.
10
L/D = 50
L/D = 30
CColumn Cost / Pressure Vessel Cost
L/D =20
L/D =10
L/D = 5
1
1 10
Column Diamter, ft
Equations
L/D = 5 F = 5.02 * (Diameter, ft)–0.47
L/D = 10 F = 5.42 * (Diameter, ft)–0.47
L/D = 20 F = 6.51 * (Diameter, ft)–0.47
L/D = 30 F = 8.51 * (Diameter, ft)–0.47
L/D = 50 F = 11.3 * (Diameter, ft)–0.47
8212_A004.fm Page 321 Tuesday, September 26, 2006 12:09 PM
COLUMN INTERNALS
Trays: Carbon steel Bubble cap, Sieve, and Valve
Column packing: Pall rings and Intalox saddles
10
Purchase cost, $K/tray
0.1
1 10 100
Column Diameter, ft
5/8 — 120 — —
1 146 34 29 35
2 98 18 19 23
3 81 13 16 13
3 1/2 — 11 — —
8212_A004.fm Page 323 Tuesday, September 26, 2006 12:09 PM
COMPRESSORS
Air compressors: Reciprocating, Centrifugal, or Lubricated screw,
Carbon steel, 150 psig. Price includes: Motor and auxiliaries
(coolers, separators, tank, and so on)
10000
Reciprocating, BHP
1000
Centrifugal, BHP
Purchase Cost, $K
CEPI = 460
100
10
100 1000 10000
Compressor capacity, cfm or HP
COOLING TOWERS
10–20˚F range (water temperature change)
10000
1000
Purchase cost, $ K
CEPI = 460
100
10
1
100 1000 10000 100000
GPM
DUST COLLECTORS
Bag filters: Carbon steel bodyCyclones:
Carbon steel Electrostatic precipitators: Carbon steel,
Dry operation, Low-efficiency Venturi scrubbers: Carbon steel
1000
Electrostatic
Precipitators
100
Purchase cost, $K
CEPI = 460
Bag Filters
& Venturi
Scrubbers
Cyclones
10
1
1 10 100
cfm/1000
FANS
Carbon steel with Motor
10
p
1
1 10 100
0.59
⎛ cfm ⎞
Equation $K = 1.88 ⎜ ⎟
⎝ 1000 ⎠
Size Exponent 0.59
8212_A004.fm Page 327 Tuesday, September 26, 2006 12:09 PM
HEAT EXCHANGERS
Shell and Tube: U-tube, Carbon steel shell and tubes, 150 psig
Plate and Frame: Stainless steel plates, Nitrile (NBR) gaskets, 150 psig
Spiral: Stainless steel, 150 psig
1000
Spiral
100
Purchase cost, $K
CEPI = 460
Plate
U-tube
10
1
100 1000 10000
Heat transfer area, ft2
8212_A004.fm Page 328 Tuesday, September 26, 2006 12:09 PM
PIPING
Installed cost of schedule 40 carbon steel pipe
100
Installed Cost, $K/100 ft
15 Fittings/100 ft
CEPI = 460
10 Fittings/100 ft
10 5 Fittings/100 ft
1 Fitting/100 ft
1
1 10
Pipe Diameter, in
PRESSURE VESSELS
Carbon steel, 150 psig design pressure
1000
100
Purchase Cost, $K
CEPI = 460
10
1
1 10 100 1000
Vessel Size, Gal/1000
Pressure Factors
150 psig 1.0
Other pressures
F = 0.0023P + 0.66
Full vacuum 1.1
8212_A004.fm Page 331 Tuesday, September 26, 2006 12:09 PM
PUMPS
Centrifugal: ANSI and process types: With motor, cast iron, 150 psig rating
Rotary positive displacement: With motor, Cast iron, 150 psig rating
Reciprocating positive displacement: With motor, Cast iron, 150 psig rating
100
Reciprocating Positive
Displacement
Rotary Positive
Displacement
Purchase cost, $K
Centrifugal
CEPI = 460
10
1
1 10 100 1000
Flow * Pump Head: gpm * ft/1000
8212_A004.fm Page 332 Tuesday, September 26, 2006 12:09 PM
TANKS, STORAGE
Custom built and Off-the-shelf: Carbon steel, Atmospheric
1000
Custom Built
Purchase cost, $K
100
CEPI = 460
10
Off-the-Shelf
1
1 10 100 1000
Tank Capacity, Gallons/1000
Size Exponents
Custom built 0.5
Off-the-shelf 0.83