Classroom Design for Living and Learning with Autism

by Clare L. Vogel, for publication in the May/June 2008 issue of Autism Asperger’s Digest

Created by Clare |. Vogel

University of Wisconsin-Madison
Design Studies Masters Thesis

“identifying Performance Standards:

Designing Classroom Environments for
Populations with Autism”

Under the direction af:

Michael Hunt, PhD
Doug Marschalek, PhD
Roberto Rengel, Associate Professor

Imagine taking an exam with someone turning the overhead lights on and off rapidly, construction workers
drilling cement just outside the window, and acrobats tossing bowling pins around you in dizzying circles.
Forget about the exam, right? A silent room with no distractions would seem like just the ticket. That is, until
your own thoughts begin swimming around in your head, that gentle humming light bulb sounds like an
army of howler monkeys, your skin suddenly itches, and the temperature seems hot. Uh - what exam?

Everyone experiences an uncomfortable classroom at some time or another. Thinking back to grade school,
you can probably still remember a particular teacher’s noxious perfume, or the headache-inducing glare of
shiny waxed floors on the first day back to school. These sensory assaults may be magnified beyond normal
comprehension for someone living and learning with autism. While proactive schools nationwide are
revamping their special education curricula to support increasing numbers of children diagnosed with autism
spectrum disorders (ASD), one area not being as successfully revamped is the facility design to house these
new programs.

If you talk to an architect or contractor you will discover they know little about this distinctive population and
its needs. Contractors follow codes such as the Americans with Disabilities Act, but do not realize these codes
only skim the surface of needs for many students. With limited design standards, is it even possible to build
a classroom environment that fits the needs of such a diverse population as children with autism? A growing
group of professionals say yes.

To follow are eight design standards and solutions gathered from interviews with people most directly
affected by autism - parents, teachers, and therapists, as well as college students and adults with autism.
While they are primarily intended for educational facilities, these strategies can be applied to bedrooms,
family rooms and play spaces. By no means are these performance standards intended to limit a designer’s
creativity; on the contrary, they open doors to more creative solutions than ever before.

1. Flexible & Adaptable

 Offering Meniite covrormmeet © ome of the most Enportant coer
porerm of Geeyring tor apace! paguristion wth divers north
Comeathor Nowe heneaPuregn hanenell and patil ani ereperrenrt> Cae
pe mravepatatert net covly ty itaft bur sho by te Ucn When
teri handing: aed oper emtted materat aw ined tat tere! to
erage © 8 terge of actheties tut fonter het deetingenent and
leerversg "hey can becuse rere corngertent an threw piryen al ated
Tes 2 Gevetop se Confidence and wdeperdionce Thery deveion
APOC bh wh seme ard sbertrenys arct repent hur others
ound then

Peery Rnd Meme

Nee Nake were Merentand Pee wees mh 6
Ph MT a ary are a pes hem emt
eet alee al
A me bere retains benwrees 4 tae
Pry 8 treating art hey ate wraire © bow

Flexibility, which can also be thought of as adjustability or adaptability, is the first and most widely agreed
upon standard. It seems simple enough. However, defining flexibility in terms of design is more complex
than one might imagine, especially since it means different things for different users. In the case of designs
for children with autism, flexibility will not mean constant change, but rather being able to transform an
environment on a moment’s notice.

Furnishings, spatial arrangements and lighting solutions are good places to start since they can contribute to
a design that aids in adapting programs to changes in children’s needs. Students should have the option to
rearrange and subdivide spaces. When offered flexible furnishings and open-ended materials, children
engage in a range of activities that foster their development and learning, become more competent in their
physical abilities, and develop self-confidence and independence (Curtis & Cramer, 2003). Rolling shelving
units and furniture pieces that are easy to move and can serve multiple purposes are helpful. Look for
shelving units that can act as storage spaces, blackboards, and screen partitions. Teachers and students can
both benefit from the flexibility and spatial variety that portable screens or dividers offer, instantly creating
smaller spaces within larger ones for group or individual work. Try risers or movable platforms that also allow
children to create new arrangements.

2. Non-Threatening

Niched + oa vureers Design Solutions

mere
fos, meee and wracety in archer w lean « chad mast euphore, whech = oty
omithe when be ot sive feeb sale and secure. For 4 chdd with auatury thes De ee
es A eee wi
rw, effec trvly
aoeBackery any ermrcrerertal
hee and voxela ism. Envrorenarts
hese ah
f Se
Chey pare onet wanter
ch File. uscd, aie ool tlie 4, Ad

(at hurther soothe the sernes Parhars mart Wnportant when oming & De tae eee
Y
esteadh sc Ae then olfan mating amen
mgagng oh pace. haeTey Shand
pernacien Pn ue gee
be able to use veverad appealing actvty seas fom the vareage peait, 10
Trieste RoR aes 0)
they can be maured that good things hacen here, Comatemcy in al area
wil bead to amore secoesthed wan and ferwh carwoen experiences, ee Rr |
Dee sy
De Ee weal ee ake
ce ee et a

ee Se eat eal
The layout of Ce eee ek
the phyvical eR a eres oa)
same
‘s
welcoming Pe ek
et we a dees
and foctars
eT
encounter,

ond Deas Re beets)

fetebanihips eR ee thy

For a physical space to be non-threatening the layout should feel welcoming and foster encounters,
communication, and relationships. Settings should provide restful, restorative places and offer a sense of
security.

Provide high perching spots (child balconies) and low, enclosed spaces (child caves) above and at floor level,
shallow enough so a teacher can monitor children. Consider providing larger spaces for older children so
groups can gather. However, those spaces should be flexible and temporarily divisible in case large-group
work simply becomes overwhelming (Moore, G. et al, 1979). Use elements that are soft and can provide
sensory input, such as beanbag chairs, stuffed couches, carpeting, swings, clay, and water. For children who
tend to orbit as a way of maintaining control of their bodies, it is wise to avoid large open spaces, which can
easily turn into dead space.

3. Non-Distracting

ee el
Due te hypersenutive smaremens in pencory procesuing many children
wr suton 2) well as sttertice debcit disorder hwve difficulty von- . rely mettertets and ootere
Centraning when they feel sssetted by one on more senmes & chrbts | Wis li-s Milan eM tee iss)
plrypnical beadth and comfort are anpartant reed to cossider wher , - Pa ee ee ae
planning 6 Classroorns design Fickering lights nor andy distract, they a itib ey
can alo came wetneren heewtee too much sural tactile and offs SARE DIAS) LES
imidator Can Caune sore Cvliren to hove balance and self at ;
The clamroam arrangement should onnarioute to a chit) concept of > ‘ 4
Ae wr - ae Tait Ai e
order and specm Mien spaces to wut the newds of chekdren who are |
both sensory-defenive
ond those who are nersory-secbing. Spltthe = | — ’ rectactiiettiaiact iain
fous ints two clear qoace: thet accommodsts everyors thragh the a
use of pcomerrs, Nall mala, shetees ard coher Arrreiiegs
Hepiace fickenng fuores«
with) new ones f
Lee Natreer
et

ee Ll ee de Be

recot and teep ¢ a? wef

ee) i)

ee ee ee eee
a carpel and overstuffed
ee ke

Avo! classroam adjecery

et eR |

Make sue tengs ae wf

ey ee
Scie ee es| Beek to

A non-distracting room will be free of clutter, relatively odor-free, and visually and aurally restorative. In
other words, the room will decrease sensory overload. The classroom arrangement should contribute to the
child’s grasp of order and space. A clean and distinct environment helps the child with autism focus his
attention on learning instead of irrelevant stimuli. A woman with Asperger’s Syndrome commented, “Bodies
can be drowned out by so much stuff.”

Eliminate nonessential visual materials such as posters and disorderly signage, and block out temporary
distractions with screens and window shades. Inadequate storage space, a major gripe from most teachers,
also makes a room look chaotic and cluttered. Develop storage space outside and inside that doubles as
some other architectural feature or furniture element (Curtis & Carter, 2003). To avoid the flickering and
humming from fluorescent lights, try reducing the intensity of lights by switching to fewer bulbs, natural
light, and homier lamps for task lighting. Finally, block out mechanical noises from old heaters or fans with
sound-absorbing carpeting, fabrics, and furnishings. One man with autism who has strong sensitivities to
fluorescents and loud noises admitted his needs vary from day to day. “It boils down to how much I can
tolerate on any given day.”

4. Predictable
 Design Soluti

The arrangement of structure, obyect: and actiewe sbould encour | a) : Aisiet & Ofiere ation and
age choices, problem solving and discoveries Wy the process of levery Fe eae na
ing Theee main thould be takes nto commdersion -legbtbty, ww A . bert me
Sonaitanne Ses botan boner ais 4 domatcated pattwayi
conbgut ston The emdruneent trust sls be men orate and de- ax} ¥
pearangyr ener a) ae enor ey a mmm af Encourage the use of mr
node: - the arem which defrw apace and show for octal gather gs a : UAT i sant
Lynch, 19601 Analy a dassroom a tranunen space should provide colors, pictues, wittten
ugh TIONS, sONgI, Gances and
- ” ‘ — a 2)

yy ao
a o¢ Hi MLL Ale Bet
Al ul
& 1» » |
~~ a . ar Tatepermert every ther 64
\ ’ Spatial orertation can te
i < J ta @ greet deal of inforreatic

“erry > ody

J werk were, Ue eee ue A

fat wn trom 2 safe, pr
r _~ | A oe me ai a
. -S Cea Se a
| c f° cr Sek tea]
| \-] cz

* ha l +t) | Ou a el
he

- z A with auth Ca waplore

ee a Be Le
ee Re

Everyone prefers a building that is easy to navigate. Predictability is key, particularly for populations who
need consistency and visual cueing. Because children with ASD tend to be visual learners, a frequent solution
is pinning up bright schedules, picture boards and labels around the classroom. Teachers unintentionally run
the risk of reversing their efforts to make a room less distracting. Instead, they should consider what makes
classrooms truly imageable (Lynch, 1964) and legible (Weisman, 1981).

When urban planners decide how to arrange a city, various elements are thought to increase both
recognition and legibility. These elements also apply to micro-environments like schools. Create evident
paths (colored tape or painted footprints), activity pockets (pods of work spaces with various tasks),
neighborhood-like districts (named hallways or color-coded zones), bold and memorable edges (murals, half
walls or fences) and landmarks (a sculpture, indoor garden or aquarium). Use signs, numbering systems and
clear views to build a sense of predictability. Provide users with environmental information through smell,
sight, sound and touch, while being cognizant of strong distastes for certain things. Individuals with autism
often have trouble multi-tasking. If they are listening intently to something, they might not be able to see,
as if only one sense is turned on at once (Grandin, 2007). By offering multiple sensory cues, designers can
come closer to insuring all users understand their design.

5. Controllable
 el
Space can aed often deer But the suet of ceeice ter chicteen and
teachers Urdertucetd, these groupe thet ere heghty wrpuscted try thet ee Be a ee
ervronrrent are Tre thet Mere the leat amount of convo! relative eee 8 ek eee he |
thee days>day functiameng in it There shack! te a range of clase
Settings wth variathy cortroded aiid ated srry trdevent vied drcadd eel nn0 a ree
be controllable There ane other means of prowkding ther sence of comol tw NT SIN
ower the errtronment, Aethti chibdhes s self comtrol con be altered by the cont ; } : J
oppormartty 0» be alone, experiaty aden they tee! ted wemarted o Seouieiee Te att
overntebned frowrding adjustethe Asrense i amotvet ray 02 make the » we
chat oorn seem acer centered in addition, es hermsenseds to bemore owed . eN ee
SCR
conrthertable cmanve contysstie ord ntractie. ‘= a, Various acttetty wrterert cor

’ \ Purtelly »opeetact, partie

, ft | et ee eee at
A] | places wth 2 tag’ lowe of
~~ -<«
Wo Se a Al ee
- . rouge (14.146 chéeinan) et
yo” : - . Pt tks sb hs wee
iy
, a ~ - eet test der ta
) Ai . TP et he nel ast
(- « fei tt ee Ml tal muah|

ate ot tor ctéciren wen ?

= <: a es
emer al
aie! i” ee Ron eae
a Se ke tee 8)
al

Predictability is one step towards controllability (Sherrod & Cohen, 1978). When a child can understand his or
her environment, emotional security rises and the child feels an increased sense of control.

Because children on the autism spectrum have specific social challenges, personal space may be more of a
priority than for a typically developing child. Classrooms supporting these children must allow for varied
social interactions and provide opportunities for choice-making. All people feel more comfortable and in
control when they have a transition zone between private and public spaces. Just as a porch separates the
house from the street, a transition space in the form of an alcove or differentiated hallway separates the
classroom from the main corridor, providing important environment information from a safe, defensive
position. Many adults with ASD reported that having a tight, contained space nearby (such as a closet, or
even two vertical mattresses to wedge one’s body between) gave them a sense of control and release.

6. Sensory-Motor Attuned
 ere rs

(Ore rea a ied wit) acter otter diss fet teat wath bes phy eud eretorerert 7aa Forent weraory-dadeniive
aT os ch
nea]
cannet ameply put « chdd in s room and eqpect hen w lesow whut to do nent - he - f Ault” op rene cebetegr ycteantn
Femets teeters, othe chikdren, aad a haghty coerwrerecrive chewnnen aranperreant _ ( Db , ad ? 7 chegir > rdisbmecammitan
With tee proper eentrorrrert, the child mill be able eo iterate sarmatcre he hue \< : ce” vital Gevtract
fave brow abte to me grime Dedore Ayres 2005) For thene dubihen, wasous heights =i
9 7 ’ ey ee eee Baa
thee 48 Oorpetert andl pomwwr fd That ality Wo beet) & ord wersied Bee aevame Prat Oe Re
thesesermcry qpaces oraet offer wacting acovities be x8 dviteen nck cin chalienges
aed oppertareee bor rummy 0 that tee chet eth eaters rebated
ete ee eRe Se

ee pwongirg anul bars

en

Pe Ra
peepee Mie el Ms
basket: eith metucel fiber
Pe et ee ale

el Be eee Bit ee
toe) Oetauwee

Tprowe vous

ee ed

ee ge i

Children tend to have puzzling sensory integration needs and challenges, often ignoring their visual
environment. They may need help in directing their attention to sensory information that will allow them to
interact more effectively (Ayres, 2005). Sensory-motor needs can fluctuate with age, from person to person,
and from day to day in the same child, making it important to plan and fine-tune an environment that is
most suitable.

Sensory gyms are wonderful for learning and playing, but schools must not stop here. Every environment a
child enters at school should provide sensory opportunities for exploration. This also provides sensory
experiences for neurotypical children, which as an autism consultant who also has Asperger’s stresses, is
“extremely important for classroom inclusion.” An elementary school teacher in Madison, Wisconsin,
described a school where she worked previously that did not have a sensory room. “You had to go outside to
do swinging or to run. There’s not always that luxury (to go outside)...we used a wheelchair ramp that was in
the school and we would move up and down the wheelchair ramp doing relay races. It’s much better to have
a space designed for that because kids get more used to it.” A special education teacher in Hustisford,
Wisconsin, built a calm room “where kids knew they could have their meltdowns.” Numerous sensory
experiences exist that can be created and tailored with a variety of textures and flooring materials, sensory
tables filled with interesting objects, scratchy surfaces or music.

7. Safe
 Desagn Solutic
Creating «tate eovironement for Ohfaben oa Challenge Since UNAIEN ie Deesitgn for foc useet dharus
with euter often daupey Remevion © wifmyary terms thet may —
eve he poternal to be dergerout ©) enportert 1b take peecevtions
They atin cand im Rave wonger mecsons tp dirt gem and tom Man ot keae AA
mewral type al Chechen thecetore tendavas ti etoter ewrmert to Lee : WD ae ts
arte ecoowt A serve of safety and cecurty Can Be enforced ty deogeeg {3
ushoos that act at comenurty wetonga rather than erphmuirg whee L eee ee i
Hon from homme, parenet €1C Smal Rounded 1peces enhance feeting: of Carpet Can reduce the pot
Seenest errimer, anc tatety Wel defined ermam a> preverc omgoetG ira)
play fram berg deructed by intruder, wah 45 tudeet ™
ee
put 2 dead bof en the cle
Pe eee i ee

eet Ld A eee ed
fromm chenheng

ees te he) ee
ie Rs ty ee al
Cor ieee

Sqrecial ata ntion must be

Areahen srtct furnnibarrgs
LAA et tReet AA) a)

Drywall 0 preferateie te mom

Construction for certain w

For children with autism, creating a safe environment can be a challenge. Designers and teachers need to
pay attention to both physical hazards (wiring, open stairways, unscreened windows, loose flooring, toxic
paints, etc.) and emotional safety and security. Children with ASD are often prone to seizures and behaviors
like tantrums or “stimming,” where injury to self and others can occur.

A Madison-based speech language pathologist thinks of safety “not in the sense of being sterile, but in being
challenging but safe, eliminating, or at least reducing, the need for a lot of rules.” Transparency in windows
and doorways is another method of easing transitions and making a child feel safe. For youngsters, this
provides a place to wave goodbye to parents; for older students, transparency provides a sense of protection
when they know others can see them. Soft surfaces can reduce the potential for injury; though beware of
chemicals, odors and off-gassing in surfaces such as foam or carpeting. Lastly, small, enclosed spaces tend
to enhance feelings of closeness, intimacy, and safety. An occupational therapist in Madison says “Some kids
start off a lot better in smaller spaces like a tent, with as little in the space as possible, just a few choice
items.” Individual and small-group workstations should provide a certain amount of privacy.

8. Non-Institutional
 Os ele nit
For a edd wt) auton, guteg Par hornet to dhecl Gan heel like stapgerparte ar
evatunion With appomprete wertentaby<aied ceagr te arudety amnocutet
woth the Pardton wil be kewaved darneticaly A cary hornets tee! brings eR Be
Af Gang Conmectors emerge the people dhatng en eretrorerent oa wel me eet tart Ri abies
eo ares of beng at Tey to evesd stance crtabegue hermbies tt
aed cornered equaprrene so that Seating: of saeriny cn be attber Aro, be ;
pancidety aware of rarnemere ric Gemcoce a wed m thom mute de |. , Create « sense of softne
vom. hat all porate Oye halkwoys cntrnces at) Caesruoes oud saree seecoon o comor, fury
akan mon voting or evens neghbarhosd part, Siri tka alto)

eR ee eRe ls
Cee

Oe ee ee a oe

er ee
a ee

Jee neutral cotore rather

es Bee as
ers ti bs ay 3] Oofrevorcrert af

et Te ke Al

MA thee tO RA |
ees eeer eS oe kk a
fee es Bi is
et

Feeling truly at home in their surroundings will allow children to relax and retain more information.
Classrooms designed with catalog furniture are often sterile or the opposite - overstimulating. Such
environments can also remind students all too much of the clinical settings at doctors’ offices.

Adding softer lighting and home furnishings, even for storage cabinets and other functional equipment, can
offset this feeling. Colors suited for homes (warmer hues, skin tones and pastels), soft furnishings,
interesting textures, thoughtfully placed works of art, and plants and objects from the natural world can turn
a conventional classroom into a cozy, community gathering place. If a time-out center is needed, think of
alternative environments such as a small tent or fort rather than a sterile office setting. Essentially, a non-
institutional school embraces all seven of the other design performance standards previously listed.

There is no perfect design treatment for autism, just as there is no perfect set of dietary restrictions,
medications or therapies. However, professional designers, school administrators, classroom teachers and
parents can learn much from user experts in identifying attributes of a supportive, “least restrictive”
environment. It is indeed both practical and hopeful to believe that good design for students with special
needs is good design for all.

References

e = Ayres, A.J. (2005). (reprint) Sensory integration and the child: Understanding hidden sensory
challenges. Los Angeles, CA: Western Psychological Services.
® §6Curtis, D., Carter, M. (2003). Designs for living and learning: Transforming early childhood
environments. St. Paul, MN: Redleaf Press.
@ Grandin, T. (2007). Lecture PowerPoint Handouts, Milwaukee, WI.
@ Lynch, K. (1960). The image of the city. Cambridge: M.I.T. Press.
@ Merritt, E., Beaudin, J., Cassidy, C., Myler, P. (2005). Magnet and specialized schools of the future:
A focus on change. Chapter 6. Lanham, Maryland: Fletcher-Thompson, Inc. and Scarecrow
Education.
@ Moore, Cohen, Oertel, van Ryzin. (1979). Designing environments for handicapped children. (pp.
15-51). NY: Publishing Center for Cultural Resources.
@ Moore, G., Lane, C., Hill, A., Cohen, U., McGinty, T. (1979). Recommendations for child care
centers. Children’s Environment Project, Center for Architecture and Urban Planning Research.
University of WI - Milwaukee.
@ Sherrod & Cohen. (1978). When density matters: Environmental control as a determinant of
crowding effects in laboratory and residential settings. Population & Environment. (pp. 189-202)
Vol. 1, Number 3/September 1978.
@ Weisman, G. (1981). Evaluating architectural legibility - way finding in the built environment.
Environment and Behavior.

Dergnring » Clatseoom space for a child with autism spectrum disorder can be a
daunting tas’, as (he spectrum is too far maching to tay ey One prescription or ar
other would be adeal © is known, however, that a supportive environment is one
that supports users’ physiclogecal, sformabonal and social needs. Using the follow:
ing performance standands, schoo! officials, teachers and parents of children with
aution wil be able to self-assess their children’s environments, in the school at
home and in the community This design quiche is intended a1 2 general guide fram
“When you bull a thing you canned merety build that thing in maleton,
wish any number of specific archwecteal prograrns can be derived
but must afso sepow the world around 4 and within #, so chat the
larger world of that one place becomes mare coherent, and more whale,
ond the thing which you moke takes its place in the wed of nature,
as you mathe it”

Cheutoptner Alexander, A Pattern Language