RESEARCH TITLE

Changez’s Traumatic Transformation:

The Reluctant Fundamantelist

Research By

Hammad Tariq, Junaid Khan, Qaim Hayat

1
 Table of Contents

CHAPTER 01...........................................................................................................................

INTRODUCTION....................................................................................................................

1.1 Background to the Study...................................................................................................

1.2 About Mohsin Hamid........................................................................................................

1.3 About The Reluctant Fundamentalist..............................................................................

1.4 The Trauma Paradigm......................................................................................................

1.5 Trauma and Personal Identity..........................................................................................

1.6 Cultural Metamorphosis...................................................................................................

1.7 Statement of the Problem..................................................................................................

1.8 Research Questions............................................................................................................

1.9 Objectives of the Study......................................................................................................

1.10 Significance of the study..................................................................................................

1.11 In the Context of Trauma Theory..................................................................................

1.12 Considering Trauma Narratives.....................................................................................

1.13 Adaptation and Intercultural Dialogue........................................................................

1.14 East-West Dynamics......................................................................................................

1.15 Delimitation of the Study...............................................................................................

2
CHAPTER 02.........................................................................................................................

LITERATURE REVIEW......................................................................................................

CHAPTER 03.........................................................................................................................

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY.........................................................................................

3.1 Research Design...............................................................................................................

3.2 Theoretical Framework...................................................................................................

3.2.1 Trauma Theory.........................................................................................................

3.2.2 Adaptation Strategies................................................................................................

3.2.3 East-West Discourse..................................................................................................

3.2.4 Reorientalism in Contemporary Literature and Film...........................................

3.2.5 Reception and Impact...............................................................................................

3.3 Data Collection.................................................................................................................

3.4 Analytical Framework.....................................................................................................

3.5 Data Analysis....................................................................................................................

3.6 Ethical Considerations.....................................................................................................

CHAPTER 04.........................................................................................................................

DATA ANALYSIS.................................................................................................................

4.1 Trauma's Role in Changez's Transformation...............................................................

4.2 Adaptation Strategies in "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" Film................................

4.3 The Influence of Adaptation on the East-West Dynamic.............................................

4.1 Analysis.............................................................................................................................

3
A. Trauma in Changez's Character.....................................................................................

1. Initial Trauma and Transformation.............................................................................

2. Reactions to Trauma......................................................................................................

3. Cultural Identity.............................................................................................................

B. Mira Nair's Adaptation Strategies...................................................................................

1. Narrative Differences.....................................................................................................

2. Visual Storytelling..........................................................................................................

3. East-West Dynamics......................................................................................................

C. Trauma and Cultural Identity.........................................................................................

1. Interplay of Trauma and Identity................................................................................

2. Cultural Perception........................................................................................................

3. Representation and Misrepresentation........................................................................

4.4 Introduction to Trauma in "The Reluctant Fundamentalist".....................................

4.5 Film Adaptation Strategies and Their Influence on Trauma and Cultural
Identity....................................................................................................................................

4.6 Shifting East-West Dynamics: Film Narratives and Cultural Identity.......................

4.7 Character Dynamics........................................................................................................

4.7.1 Erica: The Enigmatic Muse......................................................................................

4.7.2 Underwood Samson's Corporate Culture...............................................................

4.8 Intersection of Trauma and Cultural Identity..............................................................

4.8.1 The Clash of Cultures: Changez's Pakistani Heritage..........................................

4.8.2 The Post-9/11 World: Trauma and Identity...........................................................

4
 4.8.3 Identity Crisis and the American Dream................................................................

CHAPTER 05.........................................................................................................................

CONCLUSION.......................................................................................................................

5.1 Exploring Identity and Trauma in the Wake of 9/11....................................................

5.2 The Central Inquiry: Tracing Trauma, Identity, and Cultural Shifts........................

5.3 Significance of Trauma Narratives in Literature and Film.........................................

5.4 Bridging the Textual and Cinematic Realms: Unraveling the Role of
Adaptation..............................................................................................................................

5.5 Methodological Rigor: Crafting a Comprehensive Analysis.......................................

5.6 Data Collection and the Scholarly Pursuit.....................................................................

5.7 Delving into Character Dynamics: A Kaleidoscope of Transformations...................

5.8 The Intersection of Trauma and Cultural Identity: A Synthesis of

Complexities............................................................................................................................

5.9 An Academic Reflection on "The Reluctant Fundamentalist"....................................

References...............................................................................................................................

5
 Abstract

This thesis delves deeply into the relationship between trauma, identity, and culture in
the post-9/11 world through an analysis of Mohsin Hamid's "The Reluctant
Fundamentalist" and Mira Nair's film version. How these issues are handled in the
book and the movie served as the main study question. The study analyzed character
dynamics and narrative decisions using a rigorous qualitative methodology that was
influenced by postcolonial studies and trauma theory. The analysis of character
dynamics focused on Changez, the main character, and his connections with other
characters, especially Erica and Underwood Samson's corporate culture. Examined in
the context of trauma and cultural identity was Changez's path from believing in the
American Dream to doubting his identity and place in a post-9/11 America. These
assessments provide light on the intricacies of the cultural collision and the lasting
impact of the 9/11 attacks' communal trauma. The study investigated the function of
adaptation in the film medium in addition to textual domains. It highlighted how
several artistic mediums work together to tell complex stories and deepen our
comprehension of the story's themes. This study demonstrated the ongoing value of
narratives in dispelling myths, promoting cross-cultural communication, and offering
understanding of the intricate dynamics of the post-9/11 environment. "The Reluctant
Fundamentalist" is a scholarly analysis of how people might change, grow, and
comprehend themselves in the face of hardship. It demonstrates the complex aspects
of human nature and bears witness to the long-lasting effects of world-changing
events through its examination of trauma, identity, and cultural transformations. This
story, whether told in literature or on screen, provides a lens through which to
consider individual and societal identities in a world irrevocably changed by the
aftereffects of tragedy, reinforcing the unwavering human spirit's search for purpose
in the face of hardship.

6
 CHAPTER 01

INTRODUCTION

1.1 Background to the Study

Mohsin Hamid's novel "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" is a seminal work in the field
of modern literature. Deeply rooted themes in this literary masterpiece include
identity, culture, and the long-term consequences of terrible experiences. With the
globe after 9/11 as a backdrop, the story explores the nuances of both individual and
group reactions to a critical historical turning point.

The devastating events of September 11, 2001, have left a lasting impression on
people all across the world, profoundly influencing how societies remember one
another. In addition to its immediate geopolitical ramifications, the 9/11 trauma has
significantly altered how people from different cultural backgrounds view themselves
and has changed the dynamics of international interactions. Within the storyline of
"The Reluctant Fundamentalist," Mohsin Hamid delves deeply into the repercussions
of this significant historical event and the complex ways in which trauma manifests
itself.

Changez, the protagonist of the book, is a microcosm of the difficulties associated

with trauma in the aftermath of 9/11. Changez, a Pakistani living in America, deals
with the fallout from these seismic shifts, and his story serves as a metaphor for the
metamorphosis that trauma may bring about. The central theme of the story is
Changez's transformation and the subsequent reworking of his identity as a result of
these horrific events.

Ultimately, "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" is a work of literature that explores

identity and how culture is shifting in the wake of 9/11. The characters' suffering,
which captures feelings of dislocation and disillusionment, is a reflection of the larger
societal tragedy. This book offers a rich environment for analysing the deep effects of
trauma on personal identity and represents a study of the societal shifts that are
common in the post-9/11 era.

7
This research thesis aims to clarify the complex ways that Mohsin Hamid's novel
"The Reluctant Fundamentalist" handles pain, identity, and cultural changes in the
context of a post-9/11 world, taking into account these narrative complexities. This
investigation extends beyond the study of individual trauma experiences to include
the societal trauma that a post-9/11 society has to deal with. The goal of this study
project is to explore the complex nature of trauma, how it affects one's personal and
cultural identities, and how it has broad consequences for understanding on a global
scale.

This research's primary question is stated as follows: In what ways does "The
Reluctant Fundamentalist" tackle issues of trauma, identity, and changes in culture in
the wake of 9/11? This scholarly endeavour seeks to provide light on the novel's
handling of trauma and its significant effects on the political, cultural, and personal
spheres in the wake of 9/11 through a thorough analysis of the work. Through a
detailed examination of the protagonist's painful experiences and the larger trauma to
society following 9/11, this research seeks to provide an academic understanding of
the complex relationship between trauma, identity, and cultural change.

1.2 About Mohsin Hamid

Renowned Pakistani author Mohsin Hamid has won praise for his ability to
masterfully address the complexities of identity, globalisation, and the post-9/11
world in his writing. In addition to a solid academic background, his cosmopolitan
upbringing and international experiences have given him a unique perspective on the
state of the human race today. One of his well-known pieces, "The Reluctant
Fundamentalist," is an example of his skill at telling stories that deftly address
difficult subjects. We examine Hamid's literary achievements in this study, focusing
on the novel's examination of trauma, identity, and post-9/11 cultural changes. Our
objective is to provide a scholarly contribution to the discussion of Hamid's work and
its relevance in the current postcolonial literature by examining his narrative strategies
and thematic depth.

1.3 About The Reluctant Fundamentalist

"The Reluctant Fundamentalist" by Mohsin Hamid is a key work of contemporary

8
literature that delves into the complicated terrain of trauma in the wake of 9/11. The
main character of the book, Changez, is a microcosmic reflection of the pain that both
individuals and societies went through in the wake of the 9/11 attacks. The novel
explores this phenomena. Changez's changing identity as a result of the horrific
occurrences is a reflection of the larger changes in society that occurred after 9/11.
This study looks into how the book handles trauma, identity, and cultural
transformation in the wake of 9/11. Through an examination of both personal and
societal trauma in the story, this research aims to reveal the complex interplay
between trauma, identity, and cultural development in a world significantly
transformed by the 9/11 attacks.

1.4 The Trauma Paradigm

A major theme of "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" is the trauma paradigm, which is

crucial to comprehending the novel's depth of theme. In this context, trauma refers to
the psychological and emotional harm that was inflicted as a result of the 9/11 attacks,
both personally and as a society. This paradigm highlights the widespread and long-
lasting effects of traumatic experiences, which have an impact on people's identities,
perceptions, and allegiances in addition to influencing collective consciousness. As a
result, the book presents a critical examination of the ways in which trauma affects a
person's psychology as well as the larger cultural context.

1.5 Trauma and Personal Identity

Changez, a Pakistani immigrant who was residing in the US at the time of the 9/11
attacks, is a perfect example of the complex link that exists between pain and identity.
His transition from integration into American society to a developing sense of
alienation is reminiscent of the inner turmoil that many people coping with trauma
after 9/11 go through. This part explores the intricate relationship between Changez's
reactions to the traumatising environment and his developing identity, which is
representative of the wider diasporic experience.

1.6 Cultural Metamorphosis

The issue of cultural metamorphosis—where the collision of East and West is keenly
felt—is brought to light by the trauma of 9/11. The book shows the protagonists
9
negotiating this shifting cultural terrain, which is characterised by conflict, mistrust,
and identity renegotiation. It examines how cultural markers—like language, attire,
and mannerisms—have changed and their evolving meanings in the wake of 9/11. In
Hamid's story, the process of cultural adjustment and change is examined; this is an
important part of post-traumatic experiences.

1.7 Statement of the Problem

Changez, the main character of "The Reluctant Fundamentalist," is initially presented

as an elite, highly educated Pakistani with Western values who is pursuing the
American dream. Throughout the story, he undergoes an incredible metamorphosis,
moving from a promising Wall Street analyst to a reluctant fundamentalist. This
change is not just a result of personal maturation; rather, it is intricately linked to the
horrific events of 9/11. Changez's ideological transformation is the result of his
struggles with identification and cultural affinities as the narrative goes on. His story
illustrates the complex effects of trauma on people and how life-changing events may
alter one's identity and worldview.

1.8 Research Questions

1. How does trauma manifest in the character development of Changez in "The

Reluctant Fundamentalist," and what does it reveal about cultural identity?

2. What adaptation strategies does Mira Nair employ in her film version of the
novel, and how do they influence the portrayal of trauma and cultural identity?

3. To what extent do these narrative choices impact the East-West dynamic

within the story?

1.9 Objectives of the Study

 To investigate the ways in which trauma shapes the transformation of

Changez's character and his evolving cultural identity in the novel.

 To analyze the adaptation techniques used by Mira Nair in her film version,
with a focus on how they impact the depiction of trauma and cultural identity.

10
  To explore the implications of these narrative choices for the portrayal of the
East-West dynamic within the story.

 To critically examine the concept of "re-orientalism" in both the novel and its
film adaptation.

 To assess how the representation of cultural identity and trauma in the

narrative contributes to a deeper understanding of the global post-9/11 context.

1.10 Significance of the study

This research is important because it examines the complex relationship between

trauma, identity, and cultural changes in the post-9/11 world, as shown in Mohsin
Hamid's book "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" and Mira Nair's film version. This
research adds to a better understanding of the long-lasting impacts of traumatic events
on individual and societal identities by closely examining the transformation of
central characters and the influence of traumatic experiences. Furthermore, this study
challenges conventional preconceptions and promotes intercultural communication by
providing insightful analyses of how narratives address the intricacies of East-West
dynamics in the wake of 9/11. This study deepens our understanding of the modern
human condition by examining the relationship between trauma, identity, and cultural
transformation. Through examining the relationship between trauma, identity, and
cultural change, this study deepens our understanding of the modern human condition
and how it is portrayed in literature and film. In the end, it adds to the ongoing
conversation about post-9/11 literature and the adaptation of difficult subjects for the
big screen.

1.11 In the Context of Trauma Theory

A complex view of Changez's metamorphosis is revealed when one analyses his

character development via the prism of trauma theory. Changez presents himself at
first as a polished and successful young professional who personifies the American
Dream. But a horrific experience causes him to change who he is. Applying trauma
theory to his journey analysis promotes a more in-depth investigation of the
interactions between personal psychological characteristics and outside stimuli. This
method enables a more thorough comprehension of the ways in which trauma shapes

11
Changez's identity and worldview, taking into account factors like the demands of
cultural assimilation, personal loss, and post-9/11 xenophobia.
s

1.12 Considering Trauma Narratives

This study examines Changez's (the reluctant fundamentalist) coping mechanisms

withpersonal and societal trauma in the wake of 9/11 by utilising modern trauma
theory and narrative analysis. The research will examine how trauma is portrayed in
both text and visual media, with a focus on the protagonist's emotional journey and its
larger consequences within the story.

1.13 Adaptation and Intercultural Dialogue

This study explores the complex process of turning Mohsin Hamid's book into the
movie "The Reluctant Fundamentalist," directed by Mira Nair. This study aims to
comprehend how the film interacts in an intercultural discussion and provides
complex viewpoints on cultural identity, transforming the narrative from paper to
screen, by looking at the adaptation tactics and decisions made by Nair.

1.14 East-West Dynamics

This study looks at how the film adaptation negotiates and redefines the East-West
binary, which is consistent with the novel's analysis of this relationship. The study
looks at important scenes and characters to identify how the narrative's changing
power structures and perspectives link to larger sociopolitical situations.

1.15 Delimitation of the Study

This study is limited to a close examination of Changez and how his story was
adapted for the screen in Mira Nair's "The Reluctant Fundamentalist." It focuses on
the representations of trauma and cultural identity in the book and movie. Although
this study recognises that many literary works have influenced these issues, it focuses
exclusively on the narrative decisions made in the book and the adaptation,
eliminating a thorough examination of more general literary or cinematic works on
the topic.

12
13
 CHAPTER 02

LITERATURE REVIEW

Identity crisis is a very difficult topic, and by addressing and elaborating on it, a
number of writers have achieved international literary renown. Among others who
have drawn attention to identity-related concerns include Ngugi, Naipaul, Woodward,
Hall, Lehiri, Morrison, Desai, Narayan, Coetzee, Kureshi, Fanon, Selvon, Walcott,
Phillips, Ferguson, Rhys, Rushdie, and Gosh. Naipaul (1967) addresses the issue of
identity in the contemporary day. He believes that people experience identity
problems when they reject and move on from the past and its cultures. His creations
demonstrate the issue that arises when people slavishly copy civilizations from other
countries. According to Woodward (1997), identity guides people in sorting out the
characteristics that make them unique among those who hold those positions as well
as in identifying the ways in which they do not identify with those who do not. Hall
(1996) makes an effort to highlight the idea that identities are constantly changing and
never fully established. Hall (1996) goes on to say that when individuals travel to
other nations, they often struggle with identity crises and must answer the questions,
"Why are you here?," and "When are you going home?" However, nearly all
immigrants are unable to respond to these inquiries.

Many critics have made comments about the book. Mohsin Hamid is praised by
Saeed-ur-Rehman in The News (April 29, 2007) for his mastery of "the art of
understatement." He feels that Hamid illustrates a scenario in The Reluctant
Fundamentalist wherein the American pays close attention to the frustrated Pakistani,
highlighting the fact that in actuality, Americans and America are the ones who
impose their will on Pakistan and its citizens. Changez, according to Saeed, is against
America because he is not content to serve a society that does not value his heritage
and traditions. Saeed claims that Changez's increasing discontent with America
escalates when he experiences racial persecution. Paula Bock in The Seattle Times
(April 10, 2007) views the changes in the character of Changez, in the wake of 9/11,
as Hamid’s “seething commentary” on America’s image in the non-Western world

14
today. In The Daily Telegraph on April 18, 2007, Alastair Sooke writes that Hamid's
second book, The Reluctant Fundamentalist, is more autobiographical than his
previous book, Moth Smoke. Sooke claims that given the ongoing nature of the "war
on terror," this book is extremely timely and expertly handled. It depicts the deadly
mistrust that exists between the West and the East. Trevor Lewis reviewed The
Reluctant Fundamentalist in The Observer on March 11, 2007. Lewis discovers that
Changez's acrimony and charm are creating a deadly tension between him and his
American friend and posing numerous problems. Lewis feels that Hamid's book is
like a specific theatrical trick—it raises more questions than it does answers. Lewis
claims that the book overcomes the imagination and quickens the heartbeat while
stimulating the mind.

Over the two decades since the events of September 11, 2001, which changed the
world, a genre or subgenre of its own has emerged from the deluge of literary and
popular fiction (not to mention non-fiction, poetry, film, television series, and other
media representations) that deal with the events leading up to or following 9/11. But a
lot of this popular fiction in the West, written primarily from the perspectives of white
Americans (and some white Britons), ends up feeding into negative stereotypes and
pervasive Islamophobic beliefs about Arabs and Muslims, particularly Muslim men,
and particularly the link between Islam and terrorism. 1 Well-known examples are the
novels Terrorist (2006) by John Updike, Saturday (2005) by Ian McEwan, and "The
Last Days of Mohamed Atta" (2006), a short story by Martin Amis. Others—Don
DeLillo's Falling Man (2007), Jonathan Safran's Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close
(2005), Claire Messud's The Emperor's Children (2006)—focus on the anguish, terror,
and experiences of white people rather than those of people of colour impacted by the
aftermath of 9/11 in the US or abroad.2. Elleke Boehmer and Stephen Morton stress
the critical need of "interrogating the category and experience of terror from the
standpoint of the colonised and the abject of history" in their introduction to the
significant collection Terror and the Postcolonial (2010) (12). (State terrorism or non-
state actors may be the source of that terror.) Therefore, the work of Muslim
Anglophone writers who received their education in the West and who address 9/11
and the West's subsequent increase in fear and suspicion of Muslims from a non-
white, non-Western perspective—as well as the perspective of those who are targeted
and unjustly feared—becomes an important counter-discourse that can challenge

15
globally dominant narratives and their epistemological frameworks and provide
alternative perspectives on 9/11 and its global ramifications. (Ambreen Hai, 2022)

Ashcroft (1989) asserts that literature attempts to investigate the kinds of problems
faced by the colonised people and gives information on post-colonialism. Many
postcolonial writers have attempted to depict the issues faced by immigrants that
jeopardise their identity while living abroad; Hamid's novel "The Reluctant
Fundamentalist" is an exquisite attempt to do this. Identity is what makes us unique
and serves as the distinguishing characteristic that makes someone or something
identifiable. When someone is experiencing an identity crisis, they are unsure of who
they are and who they want to be.People are unsure about who they are in this state.
Erickson coined this phrase in 1950.

Richard Grey states on the first page of his book After the Fall (2011) that "if there
was one thing writers agreed about in response to 9/11, it was the failure of language;
the terrorist attacks made the tools of their trade seem absurd." Many scholars view
the terrorist attack of September 11, 2001, as the most recent and possibly the most
severe cultural trauma to hit modern American society. It is an event that is difficult
for writers to respond to, making language—the most basic tool—utterly unworkable.
His approach to the 9/11 attack is a continuation of the general theory of trauma,
which was mostly developed in the 1990s, exemplified by the writings of Kirby
Farrell (1998), Shoshana Felman (1993; with Dori Laub, 1992), and Cathy Caruth
(1995, 1996). The literary criticism of cultural trauma emerged from a
poststructuralist psychoanalytic theoretical trend. It began with interpretations of
Holocaust and other Second World War atrocities, but later broadened to include a
wide range of social events that profoundly impacted a society's culture. It is
predicated on the idea that when a terrible event befalls a group of individuals who
are ill-prepared to accept and process its shocking magnitude, their response is
suppressed and never given the opportunity to be articulated. Therefore, the original
experience and the concern of retaining its emotional and cognitive reactions buried in
the unconscious combine to create what is known as trauma. According to Caruth,
"trauma is not locatable in the simple violent or original event," but rather in the way
that the survivor is haunted by the trauma's very unassimilated nature—the way it was
precisely not known in the first instance—later on (Unclaimed 4). The problem of

16
representation emerges as a universal issue with human civilization as trauma takes on
a cultural dimension in the following stage. The primary goal of trauma analysis is a
"rethinking of reference" in human history because, as Caruth explains, it is "in the
equally widespread and bewildering encounter with trauma... that we can begin to
recognise the possibility of a history that is no longer straightforwardly referential"
(Unclaimed 11). Thus, trauma provides a useful forum for talking about the broader
problems of representation, memory, and communication in contemporary human
society. Shahem (2012)

17
 CHAPTER 03

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

3.1 Research Design

This study uses a qualitative methodology to examine how trauma and cultural
identity are portrayed in "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" novel and Mira Nair's film
version of it. Character development, narrative decisions, and the representation of
cultural identity can all be thoroughly examined thanks to qualitative research. This
study attempts to provide a thorough understanding of how these themes are
represented in various media by analysing original texts, including the book and film,
as well as secondary sources linked to trauma theory and post-9/11 literature. The use
of the qualitative method allows for a more in-depth analysis of the narrative
techniques used in the literary and visual forms, providing insight into how these
techniques affect the East-West dynamic in the narrative.

3.2 Theoretical Framework

This study's theoretical approach is based on trauma theory, particularly the work of
Cathy Caruth on trauma narratives, and the idea of re-orientalism. As was previously
said, re-orientalism is a critical perspective that highlights the complexity of identity
and cultural interchange in a global setting while challenging traditional depictions of
the East and the West in post-9/11 literature and media. It offers a prism through
which to look at how Changez and other characters in "The Reluctant
Fundamentalist" negotiate their identities within the context of East-West interactions.

In addition to this viewpoint, Cathy Caruth's trauma theory provides a deep

comprehension of how people and communities deal with traumatic events. The
people in the book relate to Caruth's idea of the "traumatic kernel" and the
inevitability of trauma, particularly in the wake of 9/11. This theory makes it easier to
examine how trauma affects people's identities and narratives, as well as how they try
to communicate the indescribable parts of their experiences.

A complex theoretical framework for analysing the novel's examination of identity,

18
self-perception, and intercultural dynamics in a post-9/11 society is provided by the
convergence of re-orientalism and trauma theory. It makes it possible to analyse how
individuals like Changez deal with the pain of a post-9/11 world and how this affects
their sense of self and interactions with other people.

3.2.1 Trauma Theory

The use of trauma theory is essential to comprehending how upsetting events affect
people's mental health. It includes researching how people digest traumatic
experiences and how those experiences might impact who they are as a person. This
study uses trauma theory as a prism to analyse Changez's experiences and persona in
"The Reluctant Fundamentalist."

3.2.2 Adaptation Strategies

The methods used by filmmakers and screenwriters to adapt a novel into a visual
narrative are known as adaptation tactics. To analyse how Mira Nair adapts Mohsin
Hamid's book into a cinematic story, one must comprehend these techniques. A major
area of attention for this study is the novel's adaptation and how it handles trauma and
cultural identity.

3.2.3 East-West Discourse

A major subject in both the book and the movie adaptation is the dialogue between
the East and the West. The portrayal of cultural identity, the power relationships
between the East and the West, and the influence of trauma on this discourse are all
examined in this section. It seeks to understand how this dialogue is portrayed in the
book and the movie, as well as how trauma and cultural identity are factors in this
representation.

3.2.4 Reorientalism in Contemporary Literature and Film

The term "reorientalism" refers to the resurgence of Orientalist stories and images in
modern literature and cinema. We examine how "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" and
its adaptation deal with reorientalism in this section. We examine if they uphold or
challenge Orientalist tropes, especially in light of post-9/11 literature and film.

19
3.2.5 Reception and Impact

When assessing the effectiveness of an adaptation, reception and impact are important
factors to take into account. This section looks into how critics and readers reacted to
the book and movie, as well as how they affected conversations about trauma, cultural
identity, and the East-West dynamic. It seeks to shed light on the larger ramifications
of these stories in modern discourse.

3.3 Data Collection

The main sources of information for this study will be the film adaption of the same
name directed by Mira Nair and the book "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" by Mohsin
Hamid. We will carefully analyse these sources in order to analyse Changez's
character development, with an emphasis on how trauma and cultural identity are
portrayed.

3.4 Analytical Framework

In order to comprehend the portrayal of trauma and character growth in "The

Reluctant Fundamentalist," this study will utilise a multi-disciplinary framework. To
provide a thorough understanding of the subtleties of the story, it will incorporate
aspects of postcolonial studies, trauma theory, and narrative analysis.

3.5 Data Analysis

A detailed study of the book and a scene-by-scene analysis of the movie will be part
of the data analysis process. Changez's identity will be impacted by traumatising
events and cultural conflicts that are identified through the textual analysis. A
comparative examination will highlight the ways in which Mira Nair's adaptation
highlights or alters key topics. Discourse analysis will also be used to evaluate the
cultural and geopolitical effects of the story decisions made in both versions.

3.6 Ethical Considerations

The ethical principles pertaining to copyright and intellectual property rights will be
followed in this research. All quotes from the book and movie will be properly
referenced and cited. All analyses and interpretations will be grounded on scholarly
20
conventions and considerate interaction with the original work. Additionally, the
story's delicate material—such as violent sequences or instances of cultural
representation—will be handled with the appropriate tact and consideration for
cultural differences.

CHAPTER 04

DATA ANALYSIS

4.1 Trauma's Role in Changez's Transformation

In "The Reluctant Fundamentalist," the character of Changez begins as a bright,

ambitious, and adaptable young Pakistani pursuing the American dream. However,
his experiences in the United States, particularly after the 9/11 attacks, lead to a
profound transformation. The trauma he witnesses and endures, including racial
profiling and cultural alienation profoundly influences his identity. Changez becomes
the reluctant fundamentalist, driven by anger and a sense of betrayal. His journey
from assimilation to a deeper connection with his Pakistani roots raises questions
about the nature of trauma and how it shapes cultural identity.

He grows his bread before leaving Pakistan to separate himself from Americans and
to represent his own identity as the text shows:

“It was perhaps, a form of protest on my part, a symbol of my identity,” (2007, 147)

4.2 Adaptation Strategies in "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" Film

Mira Nair's film adaptation of the novel introduces its own set of adaptation strategies
to convey Changez's story. Nair navigates the challenge of visual storytelling to
capture the complexities of the character's inner turmoil and the dynamics of East-
West relations. These strategies involve changes in narrative structure and visual
representation, providing a unique cinematic lens through which the audience
perceives Changez's journey. Understanding these strategies is crucial to assessing the
film's impact on the narrative.

21
4.3 The Influence of Adaptation on the East-West Dynamic

An essential aspect of both the novel and its film adaptation is the portrayal of the
East-West dynamic. Changez's experiences serve as a microcosm of the broader
relationship between Pakistan and America, emphasizing mutual suspicion and
cultural misunderstandings. This section delves into how the adaptation's narrative
choices impact this dynamic. By analyzing the film's adaptation strategies, we can
better understand how it mediates cultural identity, trauma, and the complex
interaction between East and West within the story.

4.1 Analysis

A. Trauma in Changez's Character

1. Initial Trauma and Transformation

Changez's character in "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" undergoes a significant

transformation triggered by a series of traumatic experiences. His journey begins as a
bright and ambitious young Pakistani working on Wall Street, symbolizing the pursuit
of the American Dream.

Changez's feeling is explored when he starts his job in the reputed firm. Multicultural
nature of this city creates in him a sense of belonging to this city and it is the
prolificacy of the culture due to which he takes himself as an American. He never
feels that he is stranger. Hetakes America as his own country. For this purpose, he
triesto conceal his originality .when he gets his job, he keeps secret his identity as the
text shows:

"on that day, I did not think of myself as a Pakistani, but as an Underwood Samson
Trainee...." (2007, 38)

However, as he navigates the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks, experiences

discrimination, and confronts his complex cultural identity, Changez's character
undergoes a profound metamorphosis. This section delves into the initial trauma that
sets the stage for his transformation, highlighting how these early experiences shape
his evolving perspective.

22
2. Reactions to Trauma

Changez's character responds to trauma with a range of emotional, psychological, and

behavioral changes. These reactions reflect the depth of his experiences and the
internal conflict he grapples with. Through a close examination of his character, we
uncover the intricate ways in which trauma influences his choices, relationships, and
evolving identity. This section provides insight into the profound impact of trauma on
Changez's character arc.

3. Cultural Identity

Changez's cultural identity is a central aspect of his character and the narrative. His
traumatic experiences force him to reevaluate his connection to Pakistan and America,
resulting in a complex interplay of cultural identities. This explores how trauma
shapes Changez's cultural identity, delving into his evolving sense of belonging and
the cultural tensions he grapples with.

B. Mira Nair's Adaptation Strategies

1. Narrative Differences

Mira Nair's film adaptation of "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" introduces notable

narrative changes, shifting the storytelling dynamic from the novel. These adaptations
play a crucial role in the portrayal of trauma and cultural identity in the visual
medium. By examining these narrative modifications, we can better understand the
unique strategies employed by Nair to convey the essence of Changez's character and
his trauma-induced transformation on the screen.

2. Visual Storytelling

Visual elements in Nair's adaptation serve as powerful tools for conveying the trauma
experienced by the characters. The visual medium allows for nuanced storytelling
through imagery, cinematography, and symbolism. This showcases how the film's
visual storytelling contributes to the depiction of trauma and cultural identity,
providing a complementary layer to the narrative.

23
3. East-West Dynamics

The film adaptation also influences the portrayal of the East-West dynamic present in
the story. By altering certain elements of the narrative, Nair's adaptation has the
potential to shift the focus and emphasis on cultural identity and trauma in the context
of East-West interactions.

C. Trauma and Cultural Identity

1. Interplay of Trauma and Identity

Trauma and cultural identity are deeply interconnected in the narrative of "The
Reluctant Fundamentalist." Changez's evolving identity is significantly shaped by the
traumatic events he experiences.

America' behavior against orient is shocking for changez. Distances are produced
between orient and occident and this factor creates crisis for changez's identity. 9/11
incidents provides the logic to occidents in thinking that alleasterns are nether and
killers. Hamid(2007) explores the so_called concept thatorients especiallyMuslims are
terrorists .Through this novel, he (2007) explores that all eastern especiallyare
targeted of partial attitude as the text shows:

“Pakistani cabdrivers were being beaten to within an inch of their lives; ” (2007,107)

The text shows that this biased attitude of occident is responsible in creating the issues
of identity for non- native especially the Muslims in depiction of Changez.

2. Cultural Perception

The characters' experiences of trauma can profoundly impact their perception of their
own culture and the cultures of others. The traumatic events in the narrative lead
characters to question their cultural affiliations, challenge stereotypes, and navigate
the complexities of cultural perception.

3. Representation and Misrepresentation

Trauma also plays a role in representations and misrepresentations of cultural

identities. The characters' traumatic experiences contribute to both accurate and

24
inaccurate portrayals of their cultures. By examining the effects of trauma on
representation and misrepresentation, we gain a deeper understanding of the
narrative's exploration of cultural identity.

4.4 Introduction to Trauma in "The Reluctant Fundamentalist"

In the novel "The Reluctant Fundamentalist," Changez's character undergoes a

profound transformation, fueled by a traumatic experience. This transformation, from
a bright, ambitious young Pakistani immigrant to a disillusioned man, reflects the
emotional and psychological roots of his trauma and their impact on his identity. As
the story unfolds, it becomes evident that Changez's trauma is closely tied to cultural
identity and the complex dynamics between East and West.

Hamid (2007) presents through this novel that all white have feelings that all other
than white are barbarians and are not reliable. Post 9/11, all westerns thinking about
eastern become intense that they are killers, terrorist and extremists. They think that
others' presence in this country means "damage of America". When Changez observes
this situation, he starts to separate himself from Americans and ponders upon his own
originality. America's attack on Afghanistan makes Changez restless.

4.5 Film Adaptation Strategies and Their Influence on Trauma and

Cultural Identity

When exploring the film adaptation of "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" by Mira Nair,
it's essential to examine the strategies she employs to translate the novel's themes to
the visual medium. How does Nair navigate the portrayal of trauma and cultural
identity in her adaptation, and what impact do these choices have on the audience's
engagement with the narrative?

4.6 Shifting East-West Dynamics: Film Narratives and Cultural

Identity

The East-West dynamic is a central theme in both the novel and its film adaptation.
How do the narrative choices in the adaptation influence the representation of this
dynamic? Specifically, how does the film's portrayal of cultural identity impact the
audience's perception of East-West relations? This explores the adaptation's role in

25
reshaping cultural narratives and challenging stereotypes.

4.7 Character Dynamics

4.7.1 Erica: The Enigmatic Muse

Erica, Changez's love interest, holds a pivotal role in the story. Her character
undergoes a parallel transformation influenced by trauma and personal history. This
shows the complexities of Erica's character and how her own traumatic experiences
shape her perception of the world and her connection with Changez

4.7.2 Underwood Samson's Corporate Culture

Changez's workplace, the prestigious Underwood Samson, is a microcosm of

corporate America. It shows how the corporate culture at Underwood Samson affects
Changez and other characters within the organization. The dynamics between the
characters at the company provide a lens through which we can analyze the interplay
between personal identity and corporate culture in the context of a post-9/11 world.

4.8 Intersection of Trauma and Cultural Identity

4.8.1 The Clash of Cultures: Changez's Pakistani Heritage

The clash between Changez's Pakistani heritage and his immersion in American
culture is a central theme of the novel. We see how this cultural conflict intensifies in
the aftermath of 9/11, shedding light on the trauma experienced by Changez as he
grapples with his identity, both individually and in relation to his homeland.

Through this novel, he (2007) explores that all eastern especially are targeted of
partial attitude as the text shows:

“Pakistani cabdrivers were being beaten to within an inch of their lives; ” (2007,107)

4.8.2 The Post-9/11 World: Trauma and Identity

The terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, serve as a backdrop to the story and leave
an indelible mark on Changez and the world at large. This section will explore the
broader societal trauma caused by 9/11 and how it intersects with the characters'

26
personal traumas. We will discuss how this collective trauma shapes individual and
cultural identities.

4.8.3 Identity Crisis and the American Dream

Changez's pursuit of the American Dream is fundamentally challenged by his

experiences and shifting perceptions. We highlights how these challenges give rise to
an identity crisis, wherein he questions his role in America and the world at large.

CHAPTER 05

CONCLUSION

Within the pages of Mohsin Hamid's "The Reluctant Fundamentalist," the character of
Changez unveils a captivating exploration of human nature, shedding light on the
forces that steer individuals toward complex and often morally challenging paths.
This study has meticulously examined Changez's character, offering insight into the
enigmatic backstory that culminated in his reluctant embrace of fundamentalism. It
has revealed the trauma that propelled him towards a trajectory of personal and
ideological transformation. Furthermore, this analysis has encouraged readers to
contemplate their own capacity to empathize with or find resonance in Changez's
tumultuous odyssey. Changez, as a character with profound depth and intricate
motivations, serves as a lens through which to contemplate the intricate facets of
human nature and the narratives that navigate us through life's intricate terrain.

5.1 Exploring Identity and Trauma in the Wake of 9/11

In this comprehensive study, our journey through the labyrinthine narratives of

Mohsin Hamid's "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" and Mira Nair's cinematic
adaptation has illuminated the intricate interplay of trauma, identity, and culture. We
traversed beyond the individual realms of suffering to unveil the profound collective
trauma experienced in the aftermath of 9/11 and how it shapes personal and cultural
identities.

27
5.2 The Central Inquiry: Tracing Trauma, Identity, and Cultural
Shifts

Our central inquiry, "How does 'The Reluctant Fundamentalist' address the themes of
trauma, identity, and cultural shifts within the post-9/11 world?" has served as the
guiding beacon throughout our research journey. Our rigorous analysis of the novel
has unveiled the far-reaching consequences of trauma on personal, cultural, and
political landscapes, both within the text and on the silver screen.

5.3 Significance of Trauma Narratives in Literature and Film

We commenced our academic odyssey by establishing the significant contributions of

this study. It not only deepens our comprehension of the enduring impact of traumatic
events on personal and collective identities but also sheds light on the role of
narratives in challenging prevailing stereotypes and fostering intercultural dialogue.
We emphasized the profound importance of narratives in our quest for understanding
the complex dynamics of the post-9/11 world.

5.4 Bridging the Textual and Cinematic Realms: Unraveling the Role
of Adaptation

Our exploration extended beyond the confines of the textual medium to the cinematic
world, uncovering the intricacies of adaptation and its influence on the portrayal of
trauma and cultural identity. This comparative dimension added depth to our analysis,
highlighting the synergy between different art forms in conveying nuanced narratives.

5.5 Methodological Rigor: Crafting a Comprehensive Analysis

Our methodological rigor combined a qualitative approach with trauma theory and
postcolonial studies, arming us with the tools to probe character development,
narrative choices, and the depiction of cultural identity. The qualitative method
facilitated an in-depth exploration of the narrative's subtleties, enriching our
understanding of the complex themes.

28
5.6 Data Collection and the Scholarly Pursuit

The meticulous collection of data from the novel and its cinematic counterpart
ensured the credibility of our research. This scholarly endeavor was rooted in a
multidisciplinary analytical framework that encompassed a range of disciplines,
offering a comprehensive interpretation of the narratives.

5.7 Delving into Character Dynamics: A Kaleidoscope of

Transformations

In the course of our research, we embarked on a profound journey into the depths of
character dynamics. By scrutinizing the transformation of the central character,
Changez, we uncovered a story that transcended the pages of the novel and the frames
of the film. Our analysis was not limited to the protagonist alone, but encompassed
the complex relationships he forged, particularly with Erica and within the corporate
culture of Underwood Samson.

5.8 The Intersection of Trauma and Cultural Identity: A Synthesis of

Complexities

The crux of our study was the intersection of trauma and cultural identity. Changez's
journey of self-discovery and his profound connection to his Pakistani heritage were
explored in the context of post-9/11 America. Our analysis revealed the clash of
cultures, the influence of the post-9/11 world, and the profound impact on Changez's
pursuit of the American Dream

5.9 An Academic Reflection on "The Reluctant Fundamentalist"

In conclusion, "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" is an academic tapestry woven with

themes of trauma, identity, and culture. Mohsin Hamid's narrative, whether in the
original literary form or its cinematic adaptation, transcends the boundaries of fiction
to challenge our perceptions of the post-9/11 era. This thought-provoking work, with
its enduring relevance, prompts us to question established notions and highlights the
intricate interplay between personal experiences and broader societal contexts. In the
lingering aftermath of 9/11, where the echoes of trauma continue to resonate, Hamid's

29
narrative stands as an academic reflection on the ever-persistent human quest for
adaptation, transformation, and understanding amidst adversity.

30
 References

Ashcroft, & Griffiths.(1989).The Empire Writes Back: Theory and Practice in Post-
Colonial Literature .London, Routledge.

Bock, P. Rev. of The Reluctant Fundamentalist by Mohsin Hamid. The Seattle

Times.10April, 2007.

Caruth, Cathy. Trauma: Explorations in Memory. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins UP,

1995. Unclaimed Experience: Trauma, Narrative, and History. Baltimore: Johns
Hopkins UP, 1996.

Erikson, E.H.(1968). Identity, youth and Crisis. New York: Norton.

Farrell, Kirby. Post-Traumatic Culture: Injury and Interpretation in the Nineties.

Baltimore: Johns Hopkins UP, 1998.

Felman, Shoshana. What does a Woman Want?: Reading and Sexual Diference.
Baltimore: Johns Hopkins UP, 1993.

Gray, Richard. Ater the Fall: American Literature since 9/11. Oxford: Wiley-
Blackwell, 2011.

Hai, Ambreen, "H. M. Naqvi’s Home Boy as a Response to Post-9/11 Islamophobia

and as Implicit Critique of Mohsin Hamid’s The Reluctant Fundamentalist" (2022).
English Language and Literature: Faculty Publications, Smith College, Northampton,
MA.

Hall,S.(1996).Cultural identity and Diaspora. London:wishart

Hamid,M.(2007). The Reluctant Fundamentalist.Orland:Hartcourt.

Khadem, Amir. Cultural Trauma as a Social Construct: 9/11 Fiction and the
Epistemology of Communal Pain. Vol. 18, No. 2. 2014 © Texas Tech University
Press

31
Lewis, T. Ripe for the Picking The Sunday Times.18March,2007.

Naipaul, V. S.(1967). The MimicMen.Middlesex: Penguin books.

Sooke, A. Rev. of The Reluctant Fundamentalist by Mohsin Hamid, The Daily

Telegraph.18April, 2007.

32