International Journal of Academic Research in Accounting, Finance and Management Sciences

Vol. 10, No.2, April 2020, pp. 264–269

E-ISSN: 2225-8329, P-ISSN: 2308-0337
© 2020 HRMARS
www.hrmars.com

To cite this article: Zahri, M. A., Awang, N. Norbahiyah Awang, N. (2020). The Operation of Islamic Trust Funds: A
Case Study of CIMB-Principal Asset Management, International Journal of Academic Research in Accounting,
Finance and Management Sciences 10 (2):264-269.
http://dx.doi.org/10.6007/IJARAFMS/v10-i2/7475 (DOI: 10.6007/IJARAFMS/v10-i2/7475)

The Operation of Islamic Trust Funds: A Case Study of CIMB-Principal

Asset Management
Mohd. ‘Adli Zahri1, Norafzan Awang2, Norbahiyah Awang3
1
Operation Division BUJ Technology Enterprise Sdn. Bhd. Malaysia
2
Faculty of Economic and Management, University College Bestari, Setiu, Terengganu, Malaysia,
2
Email: [email protected]
3
Faculty of Computer Science and Mathematics, UiTM, Malaysia

Abstract
This paper aims to discuss the basic understanding of Islamic Trust Fund (ITF) and to analyze performance by
evaluating the funds that are managed by the Fund Manager, namely CIMB Principal Asset Management.
This paper also to compare the performance of fund returns against market returns. Kuala Lumpur
Composite Index is used as market returns benchmark. The findings showed the ITF returns exceeded market
returns within three years, and in the years later. Therefore, investors have the opportunity to get higher
returns from investing in trust funds, especially in the ITF by using the right investment plan.
Key words
Islamic Trust Fund (ITF), Sharia-Compliant, Performance, Mutual Fund, Fund Manager.

Received: 10 Jul 2020 © The Authors 2020

Revised: 01 Aug 2020 Published by Human Resource Management Academic Research Society (www.hrmars.com)
Accepted: 15 Aug 2020 This article is published under the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY 4.0) license. Anyone may
reproduce, distribute, translate and create derivative works of this article (for both commercial and
Published Online: 22 Aug 2020 non-commercial purposes), subject to full attribution to the original publication and authors. The full
terms of this license may be seen at: http://creativecommons.org/licences/by/4.0/legalcode

1. Introduction
In Malaysia, investment in Islamic Trust Funds (ITF) began on January 12th, 1993, with the launch of
the Trust Fund Ittikal Arab Malaysia, which was managed by Arab-Malaysia Unit Trust Berhad (now known
as Am Investment Services Berhad). From 2006 to 2015, Islamic Trust funds have received encouraging
responses from the public, seeing from the increase in the number of funds and offers generated from the
management of these funds. It was seen clearly from the number of clear values of approved assets which
had multiplied five times from RM 9.10 billion in 2006 to RM 52.12 billion in 2015 (Zahri, 2016).
However, despite the encouraging development of the trust funds in these modern economic times,
there are still matters that are deemed to be incompliant with the rules of Islamic muamalah (Wan Azman
Wan Hassan, 2002). It is important to ensure that these Islamic funds should only be an investment within
the halal and secured portfolios that are rooted in Islamic principle (Mansor & Sulaiman, 2009). Until now,
there are questions that are still lingering among scholars. Is the management of the ITF still based on
Islamic principle? How does the ITF operate in terms of the applied Shariah principle? What are the criteria
for the Shariah factors for the secured investment bodies?
This paper aims to discuss the Shariah principles and the current criteria for Shariah in Islamic funds
and to look into the performance of Islamic trust funds under CIMB Principal Asset Management Berhad.
This paper is categorised into several subtopics, starting with the introduction, the operation of Islamic

264
 International Journal of Academic Research in Accounting, Finance and Management Sciences
Vol. 10 (2), pp. 264–269, © 2020 HRMARS (www.hrmars.com)

Trust Funds, CIMB Principal Asset Management Berhad as a case study, the analysis of funds in CIMB
Principal Asset Management Berhad and conclusion.

2. Literature review
2.1. The Operation of Islamic Trust Funds
a) The Principles of Shariah in Islamic Trust Fund
The application of the Shariah Principle in the management of the stocks under Islamic Funds is the
determining point of the status of a trust fund. Also, the applied Shariah principles are what differentiate
between an Islamic Trust Fund and other conventional trust funds. Among the complied Shariah principle
are:
i) Al-Musyarakah. Generally, the stock under Islamic Trust Fund must apply the principle of al-
musyarakah. This means that every unit holder will share the accumulative value of the funds and everyone
possesses a share in the trust fund. Therefore, once a person bought a unit in the trust find, he or she
shares the possession of the trust funds with other unit holders (Mansor & Sulaiman, 2009).
ii) Al-Wakalah. In general, Al-Wakalah means authorisation. In linguistics terms, it contains two
definitions, ‘representation’ and ‘authorisation’. In terms of fuquha’, al-wakalah means authorising two
forms of power to manage matters under their power and knowledge. Besides, al-wakalah is an aqad, or a
legal binding that authorise the agent to exercise their duties on behalf of the unitholders. Based on the
agreement stipulated in the trust deed, the fund manager is the representative of the unitholders, and he
or she is responsible for managing the trust fund. The unitholders will put their full trust to the company
that manages their funds, and to represent them in making any investment in various portfolios.
iii) Al-Ujr. Al-Ujr means commissions or fee charged. In Islamic Trust Investment, the fund manager is
responsible for managing the funds and investing the funds in various portfolios. In delivering these
responsibilities, the company that manages these funds will receive management fees under the concept of
al-ujr. More precisely, al-ujr refers to fees and commissions that the customers pay for the services
provided.
iv) Musya Properties. Funds investment is regarded as selling properties under the category of Musya
Property. Musya properties refer to property that is shared with others who cannot be dividing, and every
holder can manage their share with waiting for consent from other holders, under the condition that the
portion of the properties has been valued prior. The criteria of investments that are based on the
accumulation of investments from various companies that operates in various activities are what truly
complied with the concept of musya properties in Islamic principles.
v) ‘Uqud Ghayr Musamma. ‘Uqud Ghayr Musamma (denominated contact) refers to the aqad that is
made to be compatible with the current needs of the times and places. Some of the contracts within this
category are bay al-istina’ and bay al-wafa’. This means that the concepts of the current modern
companies that operate their trust investment based on the contract of ‘uqud ghayr musamma’, has been
publicly accepted and it has been the norm (‘urf) to practice. In other words, it is a newly formed contract
that was conceived to fulfil the current needs. In fiqh muamalat, these contracts are called ‘uqud ghayr
musamma’ as there were not mentioned in nas (as in the Quran or Hadith) and they were not formally
termed by past fukaha’ (scholars).
Currently, the ITFs are developing at rapid speed. As a response to the rapid development, various
issues regarding ITFs have been discussed and sanctioned by Shariah Advisory Council (SAC), Securities
Commission Malaysia (SC) in their series of meetings. From the year of 2012 to 2014, there has been an
update to the existing rule underlined in the book ‘The Resolutions of the SC Shariah Advisory Council
(Second Edition).
Among the addition are; (1) Ta’widh. Ta’widh (compensation) is applied in the Islamic trust fund. It
refers to the compensation granted to the creditors (investors) upon agreement between the contracting
party when a debtor (supplier) failed or late in delivering his or her obligation to repay a developed debt.
(2) Ibra’. Ibra’ is referred to as an action of a person to withdraw the rights and claims to another party,
either partially or fully. As a result of Ibra’, (the latter) is free from any obligation or liability to the first
party (the former).
b) The Shariah criteria for the listed Shariah-Compliant Securities

265
International Journal of Academic Research in Accounting, Finance and Management Sciences
Vol. 10 (2), pp. 264 –269, © 2020 HRMARS (www.hrmars.com)

The decision to grant the status of Shariah-compliant to any securities is based on the deliberation
made by the SAC through two approaches, the quantitative approach and the qualitative approach. For the
qualitative approach, the SAC takes into account the qualitative aspect, which involves public perception of
the company’s activities from the Islamic perspective. For the quantitative approach, the SAC adopts a two-
tier system, which applies: (i) business activity benchmarks and (ii) financial ratio benchmarks (Securities
Commission Malaysia, 2019). A benchmark of less than 5% applies to Sharia non- compliant businesses or
activities, such as conventional banking. The 5% benchmark includes conventional banking; conventional
insurance; gambling, alcohol and pork-related activities; non-halal food and beverages; Sharia non-
compliant entertainment; tobacco and related activities; benefit income from conventional accounts and
instruments (including dividends from investments in Sharia non-compliant instruments and interest
income received as a result of a court or arbitrator’s decision); and other activities that are considered
Sharia non-compliant. For those businesses/activities, the contribution from Sharia non- compliant
businesses/activities to the group’s earnings or the group’s pre-tax profit must be less than 5%. Meanwhile,
a benchmark of less than 20% applies to Sharia non-compliant businesses or activities such as stock trading
(Zahri, 2020).

3. Methodology of research
This research is case study research base on descriptive data. Descriptive data are used to present
quantitative descriptions in a manageable form. Descriptive analysis is a fundamental component of this
process because of the role it plays in helping us to observe the world or a phenomenon and, subsequently,
in identifying research questions and generating hypotheses based on what has been observed (Evergreen,
2013). The data obtained will be analyzed according to the requirements of the study conducted. This
method has flexibility and can adapt to changes as the research progresses. The use of such method will
lead to further research.

3.1. CIMB principle asset management as case Study

CIMB-Principal Asset Management Berhad (CIMB-Principal) is one of the prominent asset
management companies that can run regional investment. CIMB-Principal was founded in 1995, and it is
one of the biggest asset management companies in Malaysia, and it also runs its operation in Indonesia,
Singapura and Thailand.
CIMB-Principal aims to be a renowned investment management company in Southeast Asia by
offering a comprehensive range of asset management products. This company runs and distributes a
network of comprehensive trust funds, and also, manages flexible portfolios for institution, corporate,
government and pension fund. Their regional integrated investment team comprises of a professional and
dedicated team, and they are prepared to offer their expertise in equity investment, fixed income, financial
management and Shariah-compliant funds management.
CIMB-Principal is co-owned by CIMB Group, one of the most prominent universal banking in
Southeast Asia and The Principal Financial Group, U.S.A., one of the global financial companies listed under
NYSE, and also, one of the companies listed in the Fortune 500.

3.2. The analysis on the Islamic Trust Fund in CIMB principle asset management
The analysis on the Islamic funds under CIMB-Principal Asset Management Berhad was based on five
important aspects which are: objective, funds, received a benefit, the strategy for investments, the
performance of analyzed funds and the estimation of the fund’s investment of the same company, whether
investing locally or internationally (Mansor & Sulaiman, 2009). All of these five aspects were analyzed to
prove whether the Islamic based funds have outstanding performances and also, whether these funds are
fully compliant with the Shariah principle.
The first aspect that was analyzed is the objective of an introduced trust fund. The objective of the
fund is important as it ensures that the investors made the right decision in choosing the right portfolio to
invest on. For an Islamic trust fund, this objective will indirectly tell whether the fund is indeed Shariah-
compliant or not. When customers were informed on the objectives, they would know whether they would
receive their return in the forms of dividends income fund, bond fund or equity fund. The second aspect is
266
 International Journal of Academic Research in Accounting, Finance and Management Sciences
Vol. 10 (2), pp. 264–269, © 2020 HRMARS (www.hrmars.com)

regarding the specific benefit that the investors would receive if they chose to invest in the fund. Among
the benefits are charge, low transaction cost, cooling period and insurance package and takaful.
Furthermore, the third aspect is regarding the analysis of the investment strategy on a certain fund.
The investment strategy was identified to determine it as a factor of success. It also depends on the
brilliance of the fund management company to manage and to make the correct decision to their funds.
Also, the success of a fund is looked at how it manages to achieve its goal or not. The fourth aspect is seen
from the performance of the analyzed fund. A good performance will make an Islamic trust fund to be
competitive and can yield a great return to its investors. In this sense, a good performance is defined when
the performance of the fund outperformed the market return value. Next, the funds are identified to be
free of any elements that contradict and oppose the Islamic rule of law. According to Elfakhani et al. (2007),
age is an important factor to be considered in measuring the performance of a fund to avoid any
survivorship bias. Therefore, only five funds were analyzed in terms of their types of an equity fund and
balanced fund. The decision to choose these five funds are due to these funds have invested in the stock
market exclusively, and these five funds have their series of records on their returns on investment and the
records of their financial fund data. The five funds are CIMB Islamic DALI Equity (CIDE), CIMB Islamic DALI
Equity Growth fund (CIDEG), Cimb Islamic Equity Theme (CIDET) fund, CIMB Islamic Balanced fund (CIB),
and CIMB Islamic Balanced Growth fund (CIBG).

3.3. The Analysis of the Performances of the Analyzed funds

After the analysis was conducted on these funds, which are CIDE fund, CIDEG fund, CIDET fund, CIB
fund and CIBG fun, it was found that all of these funds were managed well by CIMB Principal Asset
Management Berhad. Looking at the aspect of their investment objectives, the CIDE fund, CIDEG fund,
CIDET fund, CIB fund and CIBG fund aim to gain a strong growth on their modal in medium-term length or
long term. These funds are invested in numerous main investment portfolios in Malaysia, and these
portfolios are Shariah-compliant, and its debt instruments are in line with their investment objectives. In
terms of specific benefits, all of these five funds provide the opportunity to invest in either local or regional
investment especially in blue-chip investment, growth investment, dividend investment, Islamic debt
security and Islamic bond.
Looking at the fund investment strategy, all of these funds have their strategies to ensure that their
funds are invested in Shariah-compliant portfolios. The fund investment for equity is made in numerous
portfolios listed in the Security Bursa. For the equity investment, such as CIDE fund, CIDEG fund, CIDET
fund, CIB fund and CIBG fund, the focus of the investment is prioritized to the portfolios of multiple
companies that invest in indexes, luxurious funds, and companies that are rooted in Shariah-compliant
growth and listed in the Security Bursa and also selected regional investment such as Hong Kong, Indonesia
and South Korea. Companies with good growth records will be chosen to maximize their funds' growth
returns. In identifying these companies, these funds will take the initiative to study these companies in
terms of their financial growth, industry prospect, the quality of the management, and past companies’
records. It was found that the Islamic trust fund under CIMB Principal Asset Management (CPAM) is
excellently managed based on their outstanding performances of these five funds. For example, funds like
CIDE fund, CIDEG fund, CIDET fund, CIB fund, and CIBG fund always yield the average return that surpassed
the KLSI expected return. Referring to Table 1, it was found that for the CIDE fund, the annual average
return of the fund since its inception is 214.39%, which surpasses the KLSI average return of 155.62%.
Table 1.The Performance of the fund return since the funds’ inception as compared to the KLSI return
CIDE CIDEG CIDET CIB CIBG
Inception 214.39% 486.03% 62.88% 159.89% 141.42%
FTSE 155.62% 181.99% 21.27% 98.32% 126.95%
Source: Adapted from Master Prospectus (Shariah-Compliant Funds), CIMB Principal Asset Management, 30 Jun 2016
For the CIDEG fund, since its inception, it has yielded a return that surpasses the KLSI benchmark,
which was recorded at 486.03%, as compared to the KLSI return of 181.99%. The CIDET fund also showed a
return value that surpasses the KLSI return, which is 21.27%. For the CIB fund, the return also surpasses

267
International Journal of Academic Research in Accounting, Finance and Management Sciences
Vol. 10 (2), pp. 264 –269, © 2020 HRMARS (www.hrmars.com)

KLSI by 159.89%, compared to KLSI referral of 98.32%. For the CIBG fund, it was found that the
performance also surpasses KLSI referral of 141.42%, compared to KLSI of 126.95%.
Table 2. The average annual fund returns for CIDE, CIDEG, CIDET, CIB and CIBG funds for the end year of
June 30th 2016
The types of
Applied benchmark Year 1 Year 3 Year 5
funds
70% FTSE Bursa Malaysia
CIDE EMAS Shariah Index + 30% -1.15 13.57 31.85
MSCI AC Asia ex Japan Islamic Index
CIDEG FTSE Bursa Malaysia EMAS Shariah Index -0.21 6.95 35.33
CIDET FTSE Bursa Malaysia EMAS Shariah Index -2.29 6.85 28.25
30% FTSE Bursa Malaysia EMAS Shariah Index + 30%
CIB MCSI AC Asia ex Japan Islamic Index + 40% CIMB 0.27 18.02 28.07
Islamic 1-month General Investment Account-I (GIA)
60% FBM EMAS Shariah Index + 40% CIMB Islamic 1-
CIBG 0.86 9.83 29.58
Month General Investment Account-I (GIA)
Source: Adapted from Master Prospectus (Shariah-Compliant Funds), CIMB Principal Asset Management, 30 Jun 2016
Table 2 refers to the performance of the fund return for all analyzed funds, CIDE, CIDEG, CIDET, CIB
and period end of June 31st 2016. It was found that except for CIB fund, the other funds yielded good
return in one-year period. This was due to the other funds exceed the set benchmark of 0.71%, except for
CIB, which was set at 0.27%. For the three-year period and the five-year period, all funds recorded
increased return. According to Shafee (2018), there is a significant impact between pass performance and
mutual fund and investment decision making.
In terms of the distribution of the funds, all of the distributions are made in both local and
international companies, and all of them were approved by the Shariah advisor and these companies have
the potential to produce a high return. Table 8.3 shows the list of companies for the fund’s distribution for
Islamic trust funds.
Table 3. The list of Companies for the distribution of investment in the Islamic Trust Fund under CIMB
Principal Asset Management
Name of the Companies
Year
Local and International Investment Companies
1. Axiata Group Bhd 13. MISC Bhd
2. Bumitama Agri Ltd 14. Nestle Malaysia Bhd
3. Digi.com Bhd 15. Perbadanan Kemajuan N.Selangor
4. First Resources Ltd 16. Petronas Chemicals Group Bhd
5. Fraser & Neave Hldg Bhd 17. Petronas Gas Bhd
6. Gamuda Bhd 18. Sime Darby Bhd
2015
7. Golden Asset Intl Fin Ltd 19. Telekom Malaysia Bhd
8. IHH Healthcare Bhd 20. Telekomunikasi TBK Bhd
9. IJM Corp Bhd 21. Tenaga Nasional Bhd
10. IOI Corp Bhd 22. Westports Hldgs Bhd
11. Jimah Energy Ventures 23. Tencent Hldg Ltd (Hong Kong)
12. Malakoff Power Bhd 24. Amorepacific Corp (South Korea)
The Islamic Trust Fund is a type of collective fund that is offered and managed by Professional Fund
Management (FIMM, 2005). It is expected to give returns for investors in the long term. A fund is
considered as an Islamic fund when it agreed with the Shariah principle, and the investment was made in
the secured portfolios that have attained the Shariah-compliant status (Wan Azman Wan Hassan, 2012).

4. Conclusions
Based on the analysis of this chapter, it was found that all five analyzed funds, which are CIDE fund,
CIDEG fund, CIDET fund, CIB fund, and, CIBG fund are complying with the principal concept of Islamic

268
 International Journal of Academic Research in Accounting, Finance and Management Sciences
Vol. 10 (2), pp. 264–269, © 2020 HRMARS (www.hrmars.com)

investment. All of these funds are invested in Shariah-compliant trust fund, and they are following the
guidelines that are set by the Shariah Advisory Council (SAC). The applied Shariah principles are al-
musyarakah principle, al wakalah, al-ujr, harta musya, and ‘uqud ghayr musmma also, the applied the
added Shariah principle of ta’widh and ibra’. The existence of a governing body such as SAC in CIMB
Principal Asset Management Berhad has played a crucial role in ensuring that the operations of the Islamic
funds are complying with the Shariah principles. SAC is paramount to determine the legitimacy of these
Islamic funds, even though these funds are managed by conventional companies.
Therefore, the Islamic trust fund is one of the productive instruments that offered a moderate return
to investors with minimal risk. This is seen by the analysis that found that the return of the investment
exceeds the average annual return in the three-year period and above. Also, the features of Islamic fund
are collective investments that offer the investors a chance to invest in numerous Shariah-compliant
portfolios, have moderate risk and managed professionally. It is complying with the Shariah principles. Also,
these funds are managed by a management company with high caliber. In long terms, the Islamic trust fund
is seen as a high potential and stable investment in generating and building a strong and competitive
Islamic economy. This type of investment should be grasped by Islamic investors, especially those who are
involved and active in Islamic trust funds.

References
1. Dana unit amanah di Malaysia- Ringkasan Statistik. (2015). Suruhanjaya sekuriti Malaysia. Access
from http: //www.sc.com.my/data-statistics/ unit-trust-funds-in-malaysia-Summary-of-statistics/
2. Elfakhani, S. M., Hassan, M. K., & Sidani, Y. M. (2007). 16 Islamic mutual funds.Handbook of Islamic
banking, 256.
3. Evergreen, S. D. (2017). Presenting data effectively: Communicating your findings for maximum
impact. Sage Publications.
4. Mansor, F., & Sulaiman, F. (2009). Operasi dana saham amanah secara Islam: kajian kes di Public
Mutual Berhad. Jurnal Syariah, 17(1), 69-88.
5. Federation of Investment Managers Malaysia (FIMM). (2005). Federation of Investment Manager
Malaysia (FIMM). Kuala Lumpur: Urusniaga Niaga Unit Amanah.
6. Majlis Penasihat Shariah Suruhanjaya Sekuriti. (2012). Keputusan Majlis Penasihat Shariah
Suruhanjaya Sekuriti Malaysia, Suruhanjaya Sekuriti Malaysia. Diakses daripada http://www.cimb-
principal.com.my.
7. Norhafiza, B. D. (2006). Perkembangan Saham Amanah Islam Dan Konvensional di Malaysia: Kajian
Terhadap Beberapa Dana Terpilih, Latihan Ilmiah, Akademik Pengajian Islam, Universiti Malaya, Kuala
Lumpur.
8. Shafee, N. B. (2018). Mutual fund investment decision by Malaysian investor. International Journal
of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, 8, 607-12.
9. Zahri, M. A. (2016). Dimensi kepatuhan beragama dalam gelagat pemilihan dana Amanah Islam
(DAI): Satu sorotan awal, Paper presented at Workshop Antarabangsa Pembangunan Islam (WAPI 2016),
Universitas Muhammadiyah Sumatera (UMSU), Medan, Indonesia.
10. Zahri, M. A., Melzatia, S., Sari, M. D., & Yahaya, S. (2020). Awareness and Marketing in Islamic
Unit Trust Fund Investment among Muslim Investors. Talent Development & Excellence, 12(1), 3448-3463.

269