Unit 4
Unit 4
Structure
Objectives
Introduction
Concept of Human Rights
U.N. Declaration of Human Rights
Human Rights Scenario World Over
Human Rights and the Indian Context
The Role of the Mass Media
4.6.1 The Electronic Media
4.6.2 The Print Media
4.6.3 The Film Medium
Let Us Sum Up
Check Your Progress: Model Answers
4.0 OBJECTIVES
The equation between the mass media and human rights is essentially symbiotic. By
their very existence, human rights ensure the freedom of speech and espression of the
I media. In turn, it is the responsibility of the media to ensure that everyone in society
enjoys the privilege of human rights. After reading this unit, you should be able to:
define the concept of human rights
briefly describe the origins of this concept
enlist the current liuman rights issues in our country
outline the general role of the newspapers, radio, television, cinema, video news
magazines and documentaries in projecting hwnan rights issues.
4.1 INTRODUCTION
In the praious unit, we read about the media and approach to co~~w~merism. We
defined co~isumeris~n and studied consumer laws and oolislinier rights. We discussed
the active involvenient of the media in guiding consumers to the right purchases. We
even studied how the media attempts to resolve consumer problenls.
In this. unit, we shall discuss the role of the media in reporting liuman rights issues.
We shall also see how the media can make people aware about various schemes and
programmes to improve their general living conditions.
The concern over human rights has taken on new dimensions in recent times. People
are more aware of their freedoms and rights now than ever before. Tliere is a general
will to implement these rights and make them meaningful in daily life.
Human rights have been legally granted to citizens of countries all over the world.
They pertain to tlie right to a decent life, protection from ill-health, and
unemployment and many other rights.
When addressing tlie human rights situation of a country, the ~iiediacan throw light
upon the actions and inactions of the administration. In all likelihood, such exposure
will alert everyone involved. This will result in creating a favourable human rights
scenario in the country.
We have come to the last unit of this block. In the next block we sliall take up the
issue of "Internatio~lal Communication".
Mass Mcdln and ,
Contemporary Soclnl Issues ~ c t i v i t y1
'
A student of Indian ~iationalityis refused a seat in a medical college in
Karnataka. The reasoli cited is that she has not been a resident of that state for
the stipulated number of years. However, the co~istitutionof India grants an
Indian citizen the right to reside in any part of the country.
Now, select three huiiian riglils of your choice. Then, give an instance each of
similar violation of an individual's rights.
1)
................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................
2)
................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................
3)
.................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................
The United Nations, U~liversalDeclaration of Hunian Rights was adopted 011 10th
December, 1948. It is the only ~ f i ~ id&ument
i~l of its kind, world wide, till date. It
proclaims economic, social and cultural rights in addition to political and civil rights
and freedoms for the people of tlic world. These rights are considered the foundation
of freedom, justice and peace in tlie world.
Media and
Tlie pre:~iiibleto the Declaration quite rightly points out lliat co~llc~llpl
for human Human Rights
rights has resulted in barbarous acts. These have outraged the cotlscicnce of mankind.
It further proclainls lllat the freedom of speech and belief and frwdom from fear and
want are llie highest aspirations of tlie conlmon people.
The Unitcd Natiolrs reaffirmed their faith in the worth of hunlan bcillgs and in tlie
equal rigllts for nieli and women, through this declaration. They cspressed a
deter~nillaliolito prolnote social progress and better star~dardsof livi~lg.for llie large
majority of llle people.
The Declaration statcs that all are equal before tlie law and are erlritlcd lo equal
protection fro111 it. The right to work, to free choice of employ~ncnt.lo just and
favourable conditiolis of work and to protection against unemplo);rncnt are personal
rights granted by tliis declaration. Tlie riglit of ernployces to form a~idjoin trade
unions for the protcction of their interests is a freedom they posscss ;IS a group. There
is spacial eluphasis 011 the basic provision of the right lo a stand:lrd of living
adequate for tlie lieall11 and well being of individuals a ~ their
~ d f:irnilies. It includes
access lo food, clotlling, housing, medical care and ncccssary sociiil scrvice.
It is important to note tliat tliese rights are universally accepted. Ho\\.cver, a successfi~l
lnechallisln to enforce them is yet to bc developed. This is tlie rcaso~lfor tllc large-
scale inequalities alllong peoples of the world. Even williin a coulrl~y,inequalities on
the basis of caste, class; wealth, creed and gender exist. This is quik apparent in 1;dia
where the structure of the society is based on a rigid cask syslcm.
The United Nations has also adopted two International Cove~lallts(agrcements),
effective from 1976. These are the International Cove~lariton Ecor~orllic,Social and
Cultural h g h t s and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
1) 'Health for all by 2000 A.D.' 'Complete literacy by 2000 A.D.' ;Ire oft repeated
slogans. Do they reflcct any concern for human rights ?
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
................................................ .........................................................................
2) "Dignity of labour'' implies that there is a certain rcspect i n pel-for~ningcven a
nieiiial task. Work of any kind is neither great nor small. W11;it does tlie right to
equality in dignity iniply ?
v
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
3) A prisoner is repeatedly torturcd by prison officials to extract sollle inforrna-
tion. Do you consider this as any violation of humaa righls ? G i ~ reasons
e for
your answer.
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
4) Several citizells of a particular community are arrcsted and kepi tinder deten-
tion. Tlie reasons given by tlie authorities is tliat ~heseindivitluals were
i~ldulgingin :inti llational activities. This statement, liowevcr. is not supported
by any proof. In wllat way are the citizens rigllts being curta~lcd?
..........................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................
5) We have the freedom to follow any religion of our choice. Is this human right
classified under cultural rights or civil rights ?
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
Human Rights \ n
For that nlatter, the same sectio~~of people continue to livc in po\,crl and starvation
for generations together. This is possible only because the media I~;r\~e implicity
nuintailled the status quo. They have not posed any u~ico~ilfonable questions to tlie
gover~ullent,at least at a sustai~~edlevel. You do not often hear o l . t l ~media in India
campaigni~~g for the rights of people belonging to the sclleduled ci~slcsand tribes. But
you do hear of the media taking a stand on the issue of reservation of jobs for the
scheduled castes and tribes. This stand, more often tlian not, is in frr\!onr of the elite
castes and classes.
Activity 2
At tlie time of elections, among the first things that political p;lnles proniise
their voters are better living co~iditionsand more job opportu~r~t~cs. In effect,
they ;Ire pro~iiisi~igus our l~unianrights. Collect the election III;IIII~CSIOSof four
major political parties, as released in the last elections. Make ;I IISI of all those
pro~iiiscs\vhiclr !.ou think pertain to ensuri~igof liunlan rigllis of the citizens.
..........................................................................................................................
Activity 3
There are millio~isof people 'in our country who suflcr froni liial~iutritionand
starvation. Although there are government schemes to providc better living
conditions to tlie poor, women, unemployed youth and others, such funds
silnply do not reach them. Scan the newspapers of a week for information of
such schenies and plans. Then, make list (at least 10) of these in the table
below. Tlie first one is filled in to help you along.
................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................ 1
................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................
In order to perforni their role effectively, the media personnel necd to be fully
conversant with tlie various aspects of human rights issi~es.They should arm
themselves with the necessary information and then present the facts and analyses
before tlie public. All this will have to be done at a sustained level. It is never
possible to bring about favourable changes with just one stroke of tlie pen, or an
infrequent programnie or two. The poor would continue to live io conditions of
insuff~cientfood, clothing and shelter and the rich would maintain a luxurious life
style, even after tliis information were conveyed to them. Instead, what could be
hoped for, is to ni'ake every citizen aware and conscious of their riglits and to enable
them to recognize a violation of human rights, when they come across such events in
daily life. The news media can then bring about and maintain a healthy Human
Rights Movement.
Traditional folk media like Tamasha and Burakatha, which co~iiniunicstewith their
audiences at a more personal level. can inform and i~ffluericetlieni. For this, the
communicators the~nselvesmust be knowledgeable about human riglits issues. They
can narrate instances of violation of human rights and relate them to the daily lives
of the masses.
Activity 4
,
h e s t y International (AI) is a wvodd wide organization that monitors the
human rights situation in differen1 countries. A delegation representing A1
visited the troubled state of Janmiu and Kashmir, not so long ago. Their 'version
of events differs much from Ule official stand on the subject of gross violation
of human rights by Indian troops deployed there. Now, select three articles on
the Kashrnir problem from ally three different newspapers or magenes. Read
them and then tabulate your observations in the table below.
Quite naturally, the print media have literate audiences. Big industrial houses have a
monopoly over o\vnership of the press. This fact detemincs the nature of relations
between the press and the government. Newspapers openly take sidcs for or against
the policies of tlle government. For instance, the 'Indian Express' has 21 penchant for
writing against the government in power.
The nexus between the print media and the government is strel~gtllenedby a sort of
'give and take' policy. The press receives government patronage in terms of supply of
P
newsprint and advertisements in return for favourable write-ups aboul the government.
In such a situation, violations of human rights by the state are unlikely to surface.
The sanle is the case if the rights of workers in the press Indust~yitsclf were to be
violated.
C
Personal rapport with the government is limited to senior jour~mlists.It does not
extend to junior journ:rlists at the grassroots level. In OIIC such case, Gulam Rasool, a
fjeld reporter, was gunned down in a false encounter with the Aadl~r;~ Pradesh police.
While investigating t l ~ cissue of corrupt land-dealings. He w;rs app;rrcntly posing
u~lcomfofl:rblequcstions to those involved. This was reason enougll Ibr the authorities
to "liquidate" him.
Tlle regional la~lguagcpress obtains scarce attention in co~npetitio~l \\.it11 major
national dailies. Few individuals attenlpt to start a newsllnper or magazine at a local
level, because of the large amounts of investment and t l ~ ctcch~iology involved.
Consequently, the first casualties are the freedom of the ~lrcssaod tllc standard of
journali~m.
To its credit, investigative journalism has probed human rights issues like the working
conditions providcd to child labourers, the torture behind prison bars and illegal
"encounter * * deaths.
Socially relevant and purposefbl issues enrich the cinematic valuc of any film.
Themes like the caste system, subjugatioll of women, rural poverty and the feudal
system, all of which are concerned with the area of llulni~~l
rights, havc been dealt
with time and again. Let us trace some la~ldnlarksin 1ndi;rn C i ~ l c ~ which
~ l a have
sought to solve the problems prevailing in society.
"Chandidas" ( 1932 ) by Debaki Bose under the banner of the Ncw Theaters and
"Acchyut Kanya" ( 1936 ) by the Bombay Talkies carricd a crusade against
untouchability. The film "Sawakari Pash" (The Indian Shylock or tllc trappings of a
money-lender ) made in 1925 by Baburao Painter of the Maharashtra~Film Company.
was a shocking exposure of the exploitation of the poor peasants by unscrupulous
money lenders. 'Jiban Maran' (1939 ) also from the New Theatres, dwelt on the social
rel~abilitationof the patients of tuberculosis, considered aa infectious and deadly
disease in the thirties. The Prabhat Film Company madc a nunlbcr of socially
purposefill films like "Duniya Na Mane" (1937 ) which voiced a strong protest against
the marriage of young girls to old men. The film "Padosi" (1938) by V. Shantaram
idealised Hindu Muslim brotherhood even in the days of ~l~ou~lting communal
tension. "Dharti Ke Lal" (K.A. Abbas ) and "Neecha Nagar" (Chetan Anand) in the
late Forties struck a note of idealistic social conscious~~ess.In h c ~ "Neecha
, Nagar"
earned international acclaim and is probably the first fill11 to bring to focus the
problenls of environ~l~ental pollution. The Fifties marked the origin of socially
relevant filnls in rural setting like "Do Bigha Zameen" (Bi~nalRoy) and "Mother
India" ( Mehboob Khan ). The Fifties also saw the enlergc~~ce or Satyajit Ray, Ritwik
Ghatak and Mriltll Sen. With the making of "Pather Panchali (1055). the Indian filln
scene undenvent a qualitative change.
But it was only after "Bhuban Shonle" (1969) by Mrinal Sen th;it a New Wave or
Parallel Cinema Movement, gathered momentum. Sucli reillistic filn~sas Basu
Chatterjee's "Sara Akaash" (1979), Moni Kaul's "Uski Roti" (1969), Ku~narSahani's
"Maya Darpan" (1972), Avtar Kaul's "27 Down" (1973), Girish Kanlad's "Kadu" (the
.-
hlaS.9 M t d h .and
Conten~porury Social Issues forest, 1973) and M.S Sathyu's gar an^ Hawa" (1973), were made on shoe-string
budgets. A more traditional path was followed by Sl~yamBenegal whose films
(Ankur, 1974, Nishant, 1975, M ~ I I I ~ ~1976
I ~ I I )I ,have been relatively realistic in form
and deeply committed to socio-poli~ical themes.
By the Eighties, a new generati011of filnl makers was setting a new trend. They began
to use the medium to focus a t t e ~ ~ on~ i grave
o ~ ~ socio-economic issues and raised
questions against social injusticc ;1nc1atrocities, with passion and compassion. They
have been described as "filn~aclivilics", who treat cinema as a pulpit. Tlle trend
started yith Anand Palwardhan, l'apan Bose and Sullashini Mulay (of Bhuban Shome
fame). Patwardhan's "Hamara S ~ I ~ I ~a Stelling
." social commentary on the life in the
slums of Bombay, orered a refrcslling contrast to Inany con~mercialfilnls dealing
with the same theme. At great risk lo his life and equipment, Tapan Bose made a
shocking esposure about tlle Bhagalpur~scandal-the blinding of prisoners by the
police authorities. Bose also procluccd ill1 outstanding film, "Beyond genocide", on
tlle Bhopal gas tragedy and its alicr~l~alh. The "Voice of Baliapal" by Vasudha Joslli
and Ranjan Palit articulated the n~uteespression and protests of evicted villagers in
an Orissa village.
Tlle filnl ~nediu~n has the potenli;rl to portray the ills which all society, frequently in
the narrative format. This is ho\\ lil~nssenle the cause of human rights and ensure
their just inlplenle~ltationin socicly,
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
3) List three ways in which the lncdia can improve our human rights situation.
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
J
In this unit, we have sludicd tllc concept of lluman rights and seen their importance
in the daily lives of the masses.
There are several agc~lciesand groul~s.like the "Civil Liberties Group", which work in
the area of human rights. They act as watchdogs of the govenlnlent in its eflorts to
implement human rights and to impro~ethc quality of life of the people. They seek
to keep in check any kind of viola~ionof hil~llanrights.
M e d l r and
The electronic media are not particularly incl~nedto investigate 1nm.n rights liun~mRights
problems. This lnay be attributed to their being owned by the got/ern~nent.
Many films have been made on the theme of violation of human rights. They have
portrayed sensitive issues in a symbolic, narrative or other fornlal
The media help to fi~lfilthe need for nurturing an infonncd public opinion. They are
indispensable for the correct implementation of human riglits.