Sylvia Plath
Sylvia Plath
Summary
"Daddy," comprised of sixteen five-line stanzas, is a brutal and
venomous poem commonly understood to be about Plath's deceased
father, Otto Plath.
The speaker begins by saying that he "does not do anymore," and that
she feels like she has been a foot living in a black shoe for thirty
years, too timid to either breathe or sneeze. She insists that she needed
to kill him (she refers to him as "Daddy"), but that he died before she
had time. She describes him as heavy, like a "bag full of God,"
resembling a statue with one big gray toe and its head submerged in
the Atlantic Ocean. She remembers how she at one time prayed for
his return from death, and gives a German utterance of grief (which
translates literally to "Oh, you").
She knows he comes from a Polish town that was overrun by "wars,
wars, wars," but one of her Polack friends has told her that there are
several towns of that name. Therefore, she cannot uncover his
hometown, where he put his "foot" and "root."
She also discusses how she could never find a way to talk to him.
Even before she could speak, she thought every German was him, and
found the German language "obscene." In fact, she felt so distinct
from him that she believed herself a Jew being removed to a
concentration camp. She started to talk like a Jew and to feel like a
Jew in several different ways. She wonders in fact, whether she might
actually be a Jew, because of her similarity to a gypsy. To further
emphasize her fear and distance, she describes him as the Luftwaffe,
with a neat mustache and a bright blue Aryan eye. She calls him a
"Panzer-man," and says he is less like God then like the black
swastika through which nothing can pass. In her mind, "Every woman
adores a Fascist," and the "boot in the face" that comes with such a
man.
When she remembers Daddy, she thinks of him standing at the
blackboard, with a cleft chin instead of a cleft foot. However, this
transposition does not make him a devil. Instead, he is like the black
man who "Bit [her] pretty red heart in two." He died when she was
ten, and she tried to join him in death when she was twenty. When
that attempt failed, she was glued back together. At this point, she
realized her course - she made a model of Daddy and gave him both a
"Meinkampf look" and "a love of the rack and the screw." She
promises him that she is "finally through;" the telephone has been
taken off the hook, and the voices can no longer get through to her.
She considers that if she has killed one man, then she has in fact killed
two. Comparing him to a vampire, she remembers how he drank her
blood for a year, but then realizes the duration was closer to seven
years. She tells him he can lie back now. There is a stake in his heart,
and the villagers who despised him now celebrate his death by
dancing on his corpse. She concludes by announcing, "Daddy, Daddy,
you bastard, I'm through."
Analysis
"Daddy" is perhaps Sylvia Plath's best-known poem. It has elicited a
variety of distinct reactions, from feminist praise of its unadulterated
rage towards male dominance, to wariness at its usage of Holocaust
imagery. It has been reviewed and criticized by hundreds and
hundreds of scholars, and is upheld as one of the best examples of
confessional poetry.
The poem begins with complete immobility in the darkness, while the
rider waits on the horse. There is then a change – the intangible blue
of hills and distances come into being. The rider is "God's lioness;"
she experiences the sensation of becoming one with her horse in a
powerful entangling of knees and heels. The plowed field on which
she rides soon splits and vanishes behind her, remaining elusive like
the brown neck of her steed that she "cannot catch."
She compares herself to Lady Godiva, who rode naked upon her
horse. In the midst of the ride, she can slough off things of no
consequence –"dead hands, dead stringencies." She views herself as
the foam on wheat, as a sparkling of light on the ocean. She discerns a
child's cry through a wall, but ignores it.
The rider is now a potent arrow, as well as dew that "flies suicidal."
She has been subsumed into both the horse and the ride as she propels
herself forward into the rising sun, which is depicted as a powerful
red Eye.
Analysis
"Ariel"'s short length and seeming simplicity – a woman rides her
horse through the countryside at dawn – is belied by the incredible
amount of critical attention and praise that the poem has received
since its publication in 1965. It is considered one of Plath's most
accomplished and enigmatic poems, for it explores far more than a
simple daybreak ride. It must be noted that this poem provides the
title for her collection Ariel, selected after she rejected the title
"Daddy." The poem justifies its centrality through a use of dazzling
imagery, vivid emotional resonance, historical and biblical allusions,
and a breathtaking sense of movement. Critics tend to discuss the
poem as explorations of several different subjects, including: poetic
creativity; sexuality; Judaism; animism; suicide and death; self-
realization and self-transformation; and mysticism.
To begin with, the name Ariel refers to three different things: Sylvia
Plath's own horse, which she loved to ride; the androgynous sprite
from Shakespeare's play The Tempest; and Jerusalem, which was also
called Ariel in the Old Testament. Critics who discuss Shakespeare's
Ariel tend to read Plath's poem as an exploration of poetic creativity
and process. Shakespeare's Ariel embodies this power, and Plath may
be attempting to fashion a metaphor for the process of writing a poem.
The poet begins in darkness, but is then hauled along by the
inspiration of poetic language. The poem begins in passivity, but
moves into one of control and power. The critic Susan van Dyne notes
how the poet's self-transformation is manifest in her use of complete
sentences, which begins midway through the poem. She becomes both
male and female, horse and rider, poet and creative force, arrow and
target. She is not merely a captive of the creative drive, but its agent.
The narrator begins by saying she has "done it again." Every ten
years, she manages to commit this unnamed act. She considers herself
a walking miracle with bright skin, her right foot a "paperweight," and
her face as fine and featureless as a "Jew linen". She address an
unspecified enemy, asking him to peel the napkin from her face, and
inquiring whether he is terrified by the features he sees there. She
assures him that her "sour breath" will vanish in a day.
She is certain that her flesh will soon be restored to her face after
having been sacrificed to the grave, and that she will then be a
smiling, 30 year-old woman. She will ultimately be able to die nine
times, like a cat, and has just completed her third death. She will die
once each decade. After each death, a "peanut-crunching crowd"
shoves in to see her body unwrapped. She addresses the crowd
directly, showing them she remains skin and bone, unchanged from
who she was before.
The first death occurred when she was ten, accidentally. The second
death was intentional - she did not mean to return from it. Instead, she
was as "shut as a seashell" until she was called back by people who
then picked the worms off her corpse. She does not specifically
identify how either death occurred.
She believes that "Dying / Is an art, like everything else," and that she
does it very well. Each time, "it feels real," and is easy for her. What
is difficult is the dramatic comeback, the return to the same place and
body, occurring as it does in broad daylight before a crowd's cry of "A
miracle!" She believes people should pay to view her scars, hear her
heart, or receive a word, touch, blood, hair or clothes from her.
In the final stanzas, she addresses the listener as "Herr Dockter" and
"Herr Enemy," sneering that she is his crowning achievement, a "pure
gold baby." She does not underestimate his concern, but is bothered
by how he picks through her ashes. She insists there is nothing there
but soap, a wedding ring, and a gold filling. She warns "Herr God,
Herr Lucifer" to beware of her because she is going to rise out of the
ash and "eat men like air."
Analysis
"Lady Lazarus" is a complicated, dark, and brutal poem originally
published in the collection Ariel. Plath composed the poem during her
most productive and fecund creative period. It is considered one of
Plath's best poems, and has been subject to a plethora of literary
criticism since its publication. It is commonly interpreted as an
expression of Plath's suicidal attempts and impulses. Its tone veers
between menacing and scathing, and it has drawn attention for its use
of Holocaust imagery, similar to "Daddy." The title is an allusion to
the Biblical character, Lazarus, whom Jesus raised from the dead.
As has often been the case in Plath's poems, the Holocaust imagery
has drawn much attention from critics and readers. It is quite profuse
in this poem. Lady Lazarus addresses a man as "Herr Dokter," "Herr
Enemy," "Herr God," and "Herr Lucifer." She describes her face as a
"Nazi lampshade" and as a"Jew linen." As previously described, one
effect of these allusions is to implicate the reader, make him or her
complicit in passive voyeurism by comparing him or her to the
Germans who ignored the Holocaust. However, they also serve to
establish the horrific atmosphere than be understood as patriarchy, as
a society of consumers, or as simply cruel humans. No matter how
one interprets the crowd in the poem, they complicate the poem's
meaning so that it is a sophisticated exploration of the responsibility
we have for each other's unhappiness, rather than simply a dire,
depressive suicide note.
Death
Death is an ever-present reality in Plath's poetry, and manifests in
several different ways.
One common theme is the void left by her father's death. In "Full
Fathom Five," she speaks of his death and burial, mourning that she is
forever exiled. In "The Colossus," she tries in vain to put him back
together again and make him speak. In "Daddy," she goes further in
claiming that she wants to kill him herself, finally exorcising his
vicious hold over her mind and her work.
Victimization
Plath felt like a victim to the men in her life, including her father, her
husband, and the great male-dominated literary world. Her poetry can
often be understood as response to these feelings of victimization, and
many of the poems with a male figure can be interpreted as referring
to any or all of these male forces in her life.
In regards to her father, she realized she could never escape his
terrible hold over her; she expressed her sense of victimhood in "The
Colossus" and "Daddy," using powerful metaphors and comparisons
to limn a man who figured heavily in her psyche.
Patriarchy
Plath lived and worked in 1950s/1960s England and America,
societies characterized by very strict gender norms. Women were
expected to remain safely ensconced in the house, with motherhood as
their ultimate joy and goal. Women who ventured into the arts found
it difficult to attain much attention for their work, and were often
subject to marginalization and disdain. Plath explored and challenged
this reductionist tendency through her work, offering poems of
intense vitality and stunning language. She depicted the bleakness of
the domestic scene, the disappointment of pregnancy, the despair over
her husband's infidelity, her tortured relationship with her father, and
her attempts to find her own creative voice amidst the crushing weight
of patriarchy. She shied away from using genteel language and
avoided writing only of traditionally "female" topics. Most
impressively, the work remains poetic and artistic - rather than
political - because of her willing to admit ambivalence over all these
expectations, admitting that both perspectives can prove a trap.
Nature
Images and allusions to nature permeate Plath's poetry. She often
evokes the sea and the fields to great effect. The sea is usually
associated with her father; it is powerful, unpredictable, mesmerizing,
and dangerous. In "Full Fathom Five," her father is depicted as a sea
god. An image of the sea is also used in "Contusion," there suggesting
a terrible sense of loss and loneliness.
She also pulled from her personal life, writing of horse-riding on the
English fields, in "Sheep in Fog" and "Ariel." In these cases, she uses
the activity to suggest an otherworldly, mystical arena in which
creative thought or unfettered emotion can be expressed.
Nature is also manifested in the bright red tulips which jolt the listless
Plath from her post-operation stupor, insisting that she return to the
world of the living. Here, nature is a provoker, an instigator - it does
not want her to give up. Nature is a ubiquitous theme in Plath's work;
it is a potent force that is sometimes unpredictable, but usually works
to encourage her creative output.
The self
Plath has often been grouped into the confessional movement of
poetry. One of the reasons for this classification is that she wrote
extensively of her own life, her own thoughts, her own worries. Any
great artist both creates his or her art and is created by it, and Plath
was always endeavoring to know herself better through her writing.
She tried to come to terms with her personal demons, and tried to
work through her problematic relationships. For instance, she tried to
understand her ambivalence about motherhood, and tried to vent her
rage at her failed marriage.
The Body
Many of Plath's poems deal with the body, in terms of motherhood,
wounds, operations, and death.
In "Metaphors," she describes how her body does not feel like it is her
own; she is simply a "means" towards delivering a child. In "Tulips"
and "A Life," the body has undergone an operation. With the surgery
comes an excising of emotion, attachment, connection, and
responsibility. The physical cut has resulted in an emotional severing,
which is a relief to the depressed woman. "Cut" depicts the thrill Plath
feels on almost cutting her own thumb off. It is suggested that she
feels more alive as she contemplates her nearly-decapitated thumb,
and watches the blood pool on the floor. "Contusion" takes things
further - she has received a bruise for some reason, but unlike in
"Cut," where she eventually seems to grow uneasy with the wound,
she seems to welcome the physical pain, since the bruise suggests an
imminent end to her suffering. Suicide, the most profound and
dramatic thing one can do to one's own body, is also central to many
of her poems.
Motherhood
Motherhood is a major theme in Plath's work. She was profoundly
ambivalent about this prescribed role for women, writing in
"Metaphors" about how she felt insignificant as a pregnant woman, a
mere "means" to an end. She lamented how grotesque she looked, and
expressed her resignation over a perceived lack of options. However,
in "Child," she delights in her child's perception of and engagement
with the world. Of course, "Child" ends with the suggestions that she
knows her child will someday see the harsh reality of life. Plath did
not want her children to be contaminated by her own despair. This
fear may also have manifested itself in her last poem, "Edge," in
which some critics have discerned a desire to kill her children and
take them with her far from the terrors of life. Other poems in her
oeuvre express the same tension. Overall, Plath clearly loved her
children, but was not completely content in either pregnancy or
motherhood.