PR 2 Group
PR 2 Group
In
Practical Research 2
Submitted by:
Calunia, Jeremie
Cañete, Emmanuelle John
Capus, Johnlaire
Mercado, Raymond Joseph
Perez, Gerrico
Demapeles, Ariza Alliana
Garma, Alexandra
Montallana, Monique Aizzel
December 2020
Submitted to:
Mrs. Salve D. Samoya
Table of Contents
Chapter 1: Introduction
F. Theoretical Framework……………………………………………………………..7
G. Conceptual Framework…………………………………………………………..…9
H. Hypothesis…………………………………………………………………………10
I. Definition of Terms………………………………………………………………..11
A. Foreign Literature………………………………………………………………….12
B. Local Literature……………………………………………………………………13
C. Foreign Study……………………………………………………………………...13
D. Local Study………………………………………………………………………..14
Page | 2
Chapter 3: Methodology
A. Research Design…………...………………………………………………………15
B. Sampling…………………………………………………………………………...20
C. Research Instrument……………………………………………………………….20
A. Summary of Results………………………………………………………………28
B. Conclusion…………………………………………………………………………29
C. Recommendation…………………………………………………………………..31
Bibliography……………………………………………………………………………….32
Page | 3
Chapter I
INTRODUCTION
Papers are one of the most prominent inventions of humans that are now widely
used around the world. It is used for all sorts and types of printed materials, writing, art,
and many more. According to uibk.ac.at, the paper is made of a network of plant fibers laid
down as a flat sheet. It is composed of numerous interlocking fibers obtained from the
suspension of plant tissues in water, known as pulp. The main examples of the source to
get pulp are from wood and other plant sources, such as cotton, sugar canes, and bamboo.
105. It is made from slurry of paper mulberry fibers in water. Using different plants vary
the characteristics of the paper produced. As the years go by, people innovated many ways
on how to make paper. They used different materials and different methods to produce a
In addition to the scarcity of materials for making quality paper, the cost of these is
high depending on the market price set on it. All these set aside, the question on
everyone’s mind is: “What can be a good alternative for making paper with low-cost prices
Patola (Luffa cylindrica) is a common plant that can be grown both by farmers or
garden lovers. According to DOA (Department Of Agriculture), when it matures, the dried
Page | 4
fruit is observed to consist of a stiff, dense network of cellulose fibers. Those fibers are
commonly used as shower accessories that are used for cleaning and exfoliating the skin.
Along with other ingredients like cornstarch, okra, and baking soda, will patola be feasible
Generally, this study ascertains the possibility of the utilization of patola fibers as a
raw material for producing writing paper. Specifically, this study aims to answer the
following questions:
of the paper made out of patola fiber considering having different treatments?
The general objective of this study is to discover new raw material for
paper, which is the patola fiber, and determine its appropriateness as a writing paper
product.
Page | 5
The specific objectives are the following:
The study will focus on the utilization of patola fiber as a material for producing
writing paper. Moreover, the result of this study will benefit the following:
Environment. The experiment will help the environment since producing paper is
massively made by trees. The result of this study can be a way to lessen or stop the cutting
down of trees.
Future Researchers. The future researchers can use this study as reference or be a
Patola Farm. The patola farm will benefit on this study as to they will be the main
Page | 6
Scope and Limitations
The researchers will use patola as a primary variable that will be involved
in this study. They will also only examine the quality of patola fiber paper as a new writing
paper product. The time frame of the experiment will take starting November 19 to
December 6.
Theoretical Framework
Paper is made up of connected fibers. The fibers can come from several sources
including cloth rags, cellulose fibers from plants, and, most notably, trees.
relative newcomer. For the following 1700 years paper was made exclusively from
non-wood fibers, such as cotton, hemp, flax, and grass. Also as affirmed by Mudit
Chandra (1998), over the last few years, a technological breakthrough in almost all
the fields of papermaking has made non-wood more competitive with wood as a raw
Page | 7
Most modern paper is made from trees, but that hasn't always been the case.
Paper can be made from any form of cellulose that can be broken down into fibers.
Because cellulose is what gives all plants their structure, most plants can be used to
make paper. Since the Chinese produced the first true paper around the year 100
A.D., people have made paper with rags, old fishing nets, grass, tree bark, and a
variety of other plants. The reason cellulose molecules in paper stick together after
they're wet is that they are made of long strings of glucose molecules one of the
components of common table sugar. When cellulose is beaten into a watery pulp,
some of the glucose molecules dissolve in the water. Then, when the pulp is spread
in a sheet to dry, the glucose re-bonds with the cellulose molecules to hold the paper
white, alpha-cellulose is insoluble and can be filtered from the solution and washed
before use in the production of paper. The most important characteristic of fiber that makes
it suitable for papermaking is that cellulose fiber develops physical and chemical bonding
Page | 8
Conceptual Framework
This framework shows all the overall outline of the study. It can be
Input (I) comprises of gathering of the materials needed for the experiment
to be used by the researchers; forming and making different processes for the experiment
as the researchers wanted to try for different trials and; creating questions that to be
Page | 9
Process (P) indicates the methodology used to meet the objectives of the
experimental study through doing the actual experiment that has 5 different trials,
Output (O) pertains to the outcome of the experiment which is the writing
paper made out of Patola fiber and the analysis about the quality of the paper product.
Hypothesis
The more fiber we use, the better the quality of paper it can produce.
Even if we use more fiber, it won’t make any difference in paper’s quality that can
be produced.
Page | 10
The product is not capable as a writing paper.
The paper made out of patola fiber can be used as a beautification instead of
writing sheet.
Definition of Terms
processing cellulose fibers from wood, rags, grasses or other vegetable sources.
Patola (Luffa cylindrica). Also goes with the scientific name Luffa aegyptiaca, a
Pulp. A soft wet mass of fibers derived from rags, grasses or woods which are used
Page | 11
Chapter II
This chapter presents and discusses foreign and local literature and studies
that are closely related to the present research. The information in this chapter was sought
to support this study and lead the researchers in discovering the utilization of Patola (Luffa
Foreign Literature
It is said by Rojas (2008) that paper is one of the most important inventions
in the history of civilization which it is an essential commodity to all the people around the
world. Paper was invented around 100 CE during the Han dynasty in China; this is when
The first paper was made from rags, and then later, plants were used such
as bark, hemp, and bamboo. As civil-service officials needed lots of paper to do their work,
paper was then mass-produced which is slowly spread across the world, reaching Europe
in the 1100s.
Page | 12
Local Literature
Ridged gourd (Luffa acutangula) and smooth gourd (Luffa cylindrica) are
Patola, which is commonly called by the Tagalogs and kabatiti among Ilocanos and
when it is not mature, it can be used as a pesticide which is commonly done in China. As
The fruit is known for a lot of benefits. According to a website’s article that
was released in November 2019, Patola is rich in a vast array of essential components like
dietary fibers, water content, vitamin A, vitamin C, iron, magnesium and vitamin B6. This
kind of fruit is naturally low in calorie content, unhealthy saturated fats and cholesterol.
Thus, they abound in potent antioxidants and alkaloid compounds that regulate metabolism
Foreign Study
practiced for over 2000 years in all over the world with utilizing different techniques. The
main raw materials of pulp and papermaking industry in general can be classified into three
Page | 13
In these recent years, the total pulp consumption of the world is 63% for
wood pulp, 34% for wastepaper pulp, and 3% for non-wood pulp.
Local Study
A research study that were conducted by Odilon et. Al (2014) wherein they
made writing papers from repulped waste paper and fresh fallen leaves. They show three
types of leaves (which are Mahogany, Talisay, and Acacia) and done with different ratios.
They prepared paper mold, blender, and a larger basin; they also include the waste paper
and leaves.
For their data gathering procedure, they made a Likert scale questionnaire
for the respondents as the respondents will try out the products.
Page | 14
Chapter III
METHODOLOGY
This chapter deals with the methodology of the study. It covers the research
design, sampling, research instrument, data gathering procedure and data gathering
method.
Research Design
For this study, the researchers will focus more on the utilization of patola
fiber as raw material for producing writing paper. The researchers will use the quantitative
There will be two independent variables with five different trials, which the
A. Gathering of Materials
1. Trial 1
Blender
Paper mold
Page | 15
Basin that as bigger than the paper mold
3 used papers
2. Trial 2
Blender
Paper mold
Basin
3. Trial 3
Paper mold
Basin
Soda Ash
Chopping Board
Hammer
4. Trial 4
Page | 16
Dried Patola fiber
Paper mold
Basin
Cornstarch
Soda Ash
Chopping board
Hammer
5. Trial 5
Okra
Soda Ash
Fresh Patola
Old Cloth
Blender
Plastic Cover
Stone
B. Experimental Procedures
1. Trial 1
Page | 17
In this trial, the researchers peeled the skin of the dried patolas and boiled
the fiber in a pressure cooker for 45 minutes and cool it for atleast 5 minutes. While
waiting for the patola to boil, prepare the used papers by cutting them into smaller
pieces and soak them to get the pulp. When the patola is ready and cut into smaller
pieces, blend it with the paper and water. For making the actual paper, prepare the
basin and the paper mold. Place the paper mold on top of the basin and pour the
mixture, the blended paper and patola fiber, on top of the paper mold. After shaping
2. Trial 2
In this trial, the boiled patola was soaked on the water for 2 days. When the
patola is ready and cut into smaller pieces, blend it with the all purpose flour,
cornstarch and water. For making the actual paper, strain the patola fiber slightly
and place it on the flat surface, using the rolling pin, flatten the paper and dry it.
When the paper is a bit dry, iron it to even the flat shape of the paper and dry it
3. Trial 3
In this trial, the researchers boiled patola fiber with soda ash in 45 minutes
and cool it for atleast 5 minutes. When the patola is ready and cut into smaller
pieces, smash it with using hammer and chopping board to get the fiber smaller and
get the pulp. For making the actual paper, prepare the basin and the paper mold.
Page | 18
Fill the basin with water. Place the paper mold in the basin and put the patola fiber
on top of the paper mold. After shaping the paper, lift the mold and dry it to flat
4. Trial 4
In this trial, the researchers boiled patola fiber with soda ash in 45 minutes
and cool it for atleast 5 minutes. When the patola is ready and cut into smaller
pieces, smash it with using hammer and chopping board to get the fiber smaller and
get the pulp. For making the actual paper, prepare the basin and the paper mold.
Fill the basin with water mixed with cornstarch. Place the paper mold in the basin
and put the patola fiber on top of the paper mold. After shaping the paper, lift the
5. Trial 5
For this trial, the researchers boiled the fresh patola fiber with soda ash for
40 minutes, while boiling boil the okra to serve as the paper’s thickener. When the
patola is ready, smash it with using stone to get the fiber smaller and get the pulp.
After smashing, blend the patola with the thickener (the water used to boil okra).
After that, place the blended pulp on the old cloth, put a plastic cover on top of
Page | 19
Sampling
since the sample is formed by the researcher selects samples based on the subjective
judgment of the researcher rather than random selection. For convenience sampling, the
samples are only chosen just because they are easy to recruit. However in this study, the
respondents are also the researchers. Since it was hard to get the half numbers of grade 12
STEM-1 students of SJCDC, as this was the original plan, to examine the final outcome of
patola fibers as writing paper since there are still risk and precautions present because of
covid-19.
Research Instrument
for the researchers that undergo the experiment of making paper from patola fiber to gather
the data needed for the research. The questions are about observations of the researchers on
the results of different experimental trials made by selected members of the group. In the
preparation of the instrument, the researchers considered the requirements for a good data
collection instrument. For instance, the questions were considered in terms of the trials,
materials, and results obtained by the researchers, such as the quality of the product, the
usefulness and the appearance. The questions are sent directly through chat, same with the
Page | 20
response. The researchers did five (5) different trials with different modifications on each
of them. In the 1 st to 4th trials, the researchers used dried patola, and for the 5 th trial, fresh
After doing the experiment, the researchers rate the study individually to
find out the quality of the product, the paper. The researchers can't ask for other
respondents as today we are experiencing a pandemic. The survey was created using
suitable questions modified from related research and individual questions formed by the
researchers. The survey was comprised of 5 questions which are related to determine the
quality of the experimented products. In the questionnaire, Likert scale was used to
determine if the respondents are satisfied or not using the paper made out from patola fiber.
Page | 21
Chapter IV
This chapter presents the data gathered together with the analysis and its
interpretation.
1.1. Trial 1
Question 2
Question 3
Question 4
Question 5
0 1 2 3 4 5
Page | 22
The first graph shows the quality and appropriateness of the product which is made
out of patola with used paper. In the first question, researcher stated that the paper’s texture
is not very smooth to be a writing paper. For second and third question, the researcher
rated as 2 indicating that it doesn’t have the enough thickness to write on and the paper
cannot withstand the pen pressure. For the question number 4, it is rated as 1 again telling
that the writing texture is not really clear. Lastly, the researcher rated the fifth question as 5
indicating that the pen writing cannot be seen through the back of the paper.
1.2. Trial 2
Question 2
Question 3
Question 4
Question 5
0 1 2 3 4 5
Page | 23
The second graph shows the quality and appropriateness of the product which is
made out of patola with cornstarch and all purpose flour. In the first question, researcher
stated that the paper’s texture is not smooth to be a writing paper. For second and third
question, the researcher rated as 5 and 3 respectively indicating that the paper has enough
thickness to write on it and the paper can slightly withstand the pen pressure. For the
question number 4, it is rated as 2 telling that the writing texture is not clear. Lastly, the
researcher rated the fifth question as 5 indicating that the pen writing cannot be seen
1.3. Trial 3
Question 2
Question 3
Question 4
Question 5
0 1 2 3 4 5
Page | 24
Graph 3. Trial 3’s Appropriateness and Quality
The third graph shows the quality and appropriateness of the product which is made
out of patola fiber alone. In the first question, researcher stated that the paper’s texture is
not very smooth to be a writing paper. For second and third question, the researcher rated
as 4 and 3 respectively indicating that the paper has quite enough thickness to write on and
the paper can slightly withstand the pen pressure. For the question number 4, it is rated as 3
telling that the writing texture is quite clear. Lastly, the researcher rated the fifth question
as 5 indicating that the pen writing cannot be seen through the back of the paper.
1.4. Trial 4
Question 2
Question 3
Question 4
Question 5
0 1 2 3 4 5
Page | 25
Graph 4. Trial 4’s Appropriateness and Quality
The fourth graph shows the quality and appropriateness of the product which is made
out of patola fiber with cornstarch. In the first question, researcher stated that the paper’s
texture is smooth to be a writing paper. For second and third question, the researcher rated
as 4 and 3 respectively indicating that the paper has quite enough thickness to write on and
the paper can slightly withstand the pen pressure. For the question number 4, it is rated as 4
telling that the writing texture is clear. Lastly, the researcher rated the fifth question as 5
indicating that the pen writing cannot be seen through the back of the paper.
1.5. Trial 5
Question 2
Question 3
Question 4
Question 5
0 1 2 3 4 5
Page | 26
Graph 5. Trial 5’s Appropriateness and Quality
The fifth graph shows the quality and appropriateness of the product which is made out
of fresh patola with okra. In the first question, researcher stated that the paper’s texture is
smooth to be a writing paper. For second and third question, the researcher rated as 4 and 5
respectively indicating that the paper has quite enough thickness to write on and the paper
can withstand the pen pressure. For the question number 4, it is rated as 4 telling that the
writing texture is clear. Lastly, the researcher rated the fifth question as 4 indicating that
the pen writing slightly cannot be seen through the back of the paper.
Page | 27
Chapter V
This chapter presents the summary of the findings, the conclusions made and the
recommendations offered.
Summary
The purpose of the study was to find a new way to utilize patola (Luffa cylindrica)
to produce writing paper. Paper is one of the most important inventions in human history.
It can be used in different ways like writing and printing. The history of the paper was first
recorded in China in year 105 AD; they are using old rags and clothes turned into
individual fibers to make their papers. Plant fibers are the most important material for
producing paper. The paper’s texture and characteristics depends on the fibers of the plants
being used. The researchers are able to produce writing paper by using alternative
The researchers decided to use patola as the main material for the study because the
researchers wants to produce paper by using materials that can be found easily and very
cheap in price. The time period of the experiment will take starting November 19 to
December 6. The study focuses on the use of patola fiber as the raw material for writing
paper processing.
Page | 28
There will be two independent variables. The researchers conducted 5 trials using
The research use convenience sampling. In this type of study, the researchers are
also the respondents since the danger and precautions due to COVID 19 are still present.
Researcher-made questionnaire were used for the study. The questions were
considered in terms of the researchers’ experiments, materials, and outcomes such as the
For the data gathering, the researchers created survey questionnaire, the survey
consisted of 5 questions related to evaluating the consistency of the product being tested.
The Likert Scale was used in the questionnaire to determine if the respondents were
pleased with the paper product made of patola fiber or not. As we are facing a pandemic
today, the researchers can’t ask for other respondents instead the researchers rate the study
individually after doing the experiment to find out the quality of the paper made of patola
fiber.
Conclusions
Our research study is about making paper out of patola fiber. On our experiment,
we made five different trials for making the paper and rated by the researchers for
convenience to gather the data about the quality of the actual products.
Page | 29
On the first trial, we blended Patola fiber with used paper. The product’s quality is
so far not good. The thickness is perfect for a writing paper although the paper is not that
smooth because of the threads being visible. The paper also can’t handle the pen's ink and
its pressure.
On our 2nd trial, we used a patola fiber and made a solution which is composed of
all purpose flour, cornstarch, and water as they were combined together in a blender. The
paper’s texture is not that smooth as you can feel the threads on it. As for the paper’s
thickness, it is quite okay but it can’t handle the pen pressure. The writing texture is also
not clear but the pen writing or the ink cannot be seen on the back of the paper.
So then we proceed in our 3rd trial, it's too different to other trials; we only used
pure patola and smashed it to smaller pieces. The researchers can consider this as a fail as
In our 4th trial, same procedure, same materials but we reduce its thickness. We
smashed the fiber more so that we can get the pulp mold it with the cornstarch plus water
solution. We can write on the paper with a pen but the writing texture is bad.
For our 5th and last trial we used ripe patola. After boiling, the researchers smashed
the patola and blended. For molding, the water is mixed with boiled okra as thickener of
the paper. Among the trials, this trial is the most successful that the researchers made.
Page | 30
Recommendations
1. Future researchers must try same process and materials for the experiment but with
2. Future researchers must do the experiment earlier or at least one month in order to
3. Future researchers should find a larger number of respondents for more accurate
data.
Page | 31
BIBLIOGRAPHY
5 Excellent Health Benefits Of Adding Ridge Gourd To Your Daily Diet. (2019, November
health-benefits-of-adding-ridge-gourd-to-your-daily-diet
B.D. (2020, January 28). Patola (Luffa Gourd) Production Guide. Business Diary PH.
https://businessdiary.com.ph/3472/patola-luffa-gourd-production-guide/
Chandra, M. (1998, August). Use of Nonwood Plant Fibers for Pulp and Paper Industry in
https://vtechworks.lib.vt.edu/bitstream/handle/10919/37176/Report.pdf
Chinese Paper-Making. (n.d.). DK Find Out! Retrieved December 12, 2020, from
https://www.dkfindout.com/us/history/ancient-china/chinese-paper-making/
Flores, E. C., Bacang, J. J., & Gualberto, O. (n.d.). Investigatory Project 2014-2015.
Academia.
https://www.academia.edu/22547543/INVESTIGATORY_PROJECT_2014_2015_
1_
Hubbe, M. (2009, November). Handmade paper: A review of its history, craft, and
Page | 32
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/38106934_Handmade_paper_A_review_
of_its_history_craft_and_science
Liu, Z., Wang, H., & Hui, L. (2018, November 5). Pulping and Papermaking of Non-Wood
processing/pulping-and-papermaking-of-non-wood-fibers
Page | 33