I, Robot Notes
I, Robot Notes
THE AUTHOR
The Three Laws of Robotics (proposed by Isaac Asimov) These are built into robots’
positronic brains
3. A robot must protect its own ………………………………… as long as such protection does
not conflict with the First or Second Law.
BACKGROUND
US Robots Company: the company (offices and factories) that produces robots
First robots couldn’t talk. It took a long time for US robots to make them more human.
Solar Stations
Robots’ work:
mining minerals in Mercury
controlling solar stations that send solar energy to Earth. Robots do the work,
and only two humans are needed at each station.
later on, they led the change on Earth from nations to regions. A robot, Stephen
Byerley, became the first World Governor in 1944.
First Expedition to Mercury (2005) failed.
Second Expedition 2015
Challenges, problems: Robots’ positronic brains do not work properly
CHARACTERS
A journalist: the narrator, he interviews Dr Susan Calvin
Dr Susan Calvin (75 at the beginning of the story): to be retired, has been the first
robot psychologist for 50 years
Dr Alfred Lanning: an engineer at US Robots, Managing Director of the company
Dr Michal Donovan (Mike) (sent on the Second Expedition)
Dr Gregory Powell (Greg) (sent on the Second Expedition)
Peter Bogert: a mathematician
Milton Ashe: a mathematician
RUNAROUND
Characters: Donovan and Powell, Robot SPD (“Speedy”), six old robots from the First
Expedition
Place: Mercury Station
Robot’s assignment: to fetch selenium in order to repair the photocells of the Sunside
Station (these photocell banks protect them from Mercury’s terrible sun)
Problem: SP-D might have got lost. He has run around the pool several times and
hasn’t returned to the Station with the selenium.
“The Third Law drives him back from the pool, and then when he gets away from the
pool, the Second Law drives him forward towards the pool again.”
“It was just a routine order. I just told him that we needed some selenium and that he
should go and get it.”
They use the old robots to find and take back SPD.
Outcome: First Powell gives SPD a new order “I must get back to the shadow. It’s life or
death, Speedy. I need you.”, “Speedy, I’m dying! (…)”
Later, Donovan orders SPD to go to another pool and get the selenium urgently. “This
time I explained that it was essential to get the selenium urgently.”
(This activates the First Law)
REASON
Characters: Donovan and Powell, Robot QT-1 (“Cutie”, the “highest type of robot ever
made”, “first robot that has ever been curious about himself and the outside world”)
Place: Solar Station 5
Robot’s assignment: to control Solar Station 5
Problem: QT-1 believes that he was created by the Energy Converter, at the centre of
the Solar Station, which he calls “The Master”, and not by humans: “You can’t possibly
have made me. Obviously no being can create another one of much higher quality
than itself.”
When Donovan gets angry and spits at the Converter, QT-1 takes over the control
room and the engine room of the Station and sends Donovan and Powell to the
officers’ room
They are afraid that he won’t be able to avoid the next coming electron storm (But
they are WRONG) so they decide to reason, argue with QT-1 to convince him that he
was made by humans and eventually get back to the control room. They build a robot
in front of him, but this makes no difference to QT-1: he still thinks the parts were
created by the “Master”: “Your brains are probably too weak to understand the
whole truth.”
Outcome: In the end, QT-1 successfully manages to keep the beam straight, and so
prevents destruction on Earth. “He can control the solar station perfectly. What does
it matter what he believes?”
LIAR
Characters: Alfred Lanning, mathematicians Peter Bogert and Milton Ashe (youngest
director of US Robots), Dr Calvin, Robot RB 34 (“Herbie”), is a better mathematician
than the humans
Place: Earth
Problem: Robot RB 34 can read minds. This is due to a mistake in the production of the
positronic brain. “I want to read your novels, your stories, to find out how your minds
work, and to learn about human feelings.”
Dr Calvin discovers that Herbie knows she is in love with Milton Ashe. He confirms this
and lets her think that Ashe loves her too, but Herbie is lying to her.
Herbie also lies to Bogert by telling him that Alfred Lanning has resigned, and Bogert
will be the next Managing Director.
Finally, Herbie lies when he tells Bogert that he (Herbie) knows very little about
mathematics.
“The three of us have fallen into the same trap.”
“Herbie reads our minds and gives us the answers we want to hear. He can’t tell us the
truth if he knows the truth would hurt us. If he did that he would be breaking the
First Law. A robot can’t do that.“ “He knows everything, including the mistake which
was made in the factory when he was being produced.”
Outcome:
Dr Calvin crates a conflict in the robot’s brain which renders him useless, so they get rid
of him: “You must tell them the truth (about the mistake in the positronic brain), but
if you do, you will hurt them. So you mustn’t tell them, but if you don’t tell them, you
are hurting them. So you must tell them.”
EVIDENCE
Characters: Francis Quinn, a politician; Dr Lanning, Robot Stephen Byerley, a
humanoid robot; John (Stephen’s “old teacher”)
Place: Earth, 2032
Problem: Stephen Byerley and Quinn both want to become the next City Governor.
Quinn is ready to accuse Byerley publicly of being a robot, as there are a lot of people
who are against the development of robots. “Nobody would vote for Byerley, if
evidence was produced that he was a robot.”
Dr Calvin: “I can’t prove that he is a robot, but I can prove that he isn’t a robot.”
In a meeting, Byerley is attacked by someone and he fights him back. Then it becomes
obvious that he isn’t a robot, because of The First Law of Robotics.
Outcome: It turns out that the man in the meeting is a robot that John had created to
make people believe that Byerley is not a robot.