Comparative Models in Policing
Comparative Models in Policing
4. Globalization – a package of transnational flows of people, production, investment, information, ideas, and
authority.
a. Globalization as Internationalization – It describes the growth in international exchange and
interdependence. With growing flows of trade and capital investment there is the possibility of moving beyond
an inter-national economy, (where 'the principle entities are national economies') to a 'stronger' version - the
globalized economy in which, 'distinct national economies are subsumed and rearticulated into the system by
international processes and transactions.
b. Globalization as Liberalization – a process of removing government-imposed restrictions on movements
between countries in order to create an "open", "borderless" world economy.
c. Globalization as Universalization – the process of spreading various objects and experiences to people at
all corners of the earth'. A classic example of this would be the spread of computing, television etc.
d. Globalization as Westernization or Modernization – the social structures of modernity (capitalism,
rationalism, industrialism, bureaucratism, etc.) are spread the world over, normally destroying pre-existent
cultures and local self-determination in the process.
e. Globalization as Deterritorialization (or as the spread of Supraterritoriality) – a reconfiguration of
geography, so that social space is no longer wholly mapped in terms of territorial places, territorial distances
and territorial borders.
= What are the Positive Effects of Globalization?
- It has helped communicate better.
- It has helped in war.
= What are the Effects of Globalization on Law Enforcement?
- The emergence of an "international regime" for state security and protection of human rights, growing
transnational social movement networks, increasing consciousness and information politics have the potential
to address both traditional and emerging forms of law violations.
= What are the Threats of Globalization on Law Enforcement?
- Increasing volume of human rights violations evident by genocide or mass killing.
- The underprivileged gain unfair access to global mechanisms on law enforcement and security.
- Conflict between nations.
- Transnational criminal networks for drug trafficking, money laundering, terrorism, etc.
= What are the Opportunities of Globalization for law enforcement?
- Creation of International tribunals to deal with human rights problems
- Humanitarian interventions that can promote universal norms and link them to the enforcement power of
states
- Transnational professional network and cooperation against transnational crimes
- Global groups for conflict monitoring and coalitions across transnational issues
LESSON II: THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL POLICE ORGANIZATION
The Advisers
These are experts in a purely advisory capacity, who may be appointed by the Executive Committee and
confirmed by the General Assembly.
Some people also talk about a fifth type: Post-modern society, where the emphasis is upon the meaning of
words and the deconstruction of institutions.
B. Legalistic or Political
a. The Rule of Law vs. Community Expectations
= The legalistic (or bureaucratic, quasi-military, professional or reform) approach assumes that justice is a
product of consistent application of laws and departmental policies and procedures.
= Ideally, the laws, policies and procedures are rationally developed and free of any bias that would be
inconsistent with the fundamental principles of the society.
= The political view of the police role rests on one of two assumptions, one is that laws and the police primarily
serves the interest of the most influential persons in the community. Such individual is considered to be above
the law, whereas others are treated more harshly. This view leads to politics of preference and discrimination.
= The second assumption focuses on responsiveness and individualization. It advocates that strict
enforcement of the rules does not consider the uniqueness of the problems and needs of individuals and
neighborhood groups in the community.
b. Three types of Police – Community Relation
1. Political Model – refers to the police-community relation that is plagued by problems of preferential
treatment, discrimination and corruption.
2. Legalistic Model – assumes that political influence has a corrupting influence on policing, therefore, the
police community – relationship must be more structured or bureaucratic.
3. Community Policing Model – based on the desirability of the police being responsive to individuals and
groups without engaging in preferential treatment or discrimination.
PNP MEMORANDUM CIRCULAR 2009-006 “Rules and Procedures on the Selection of the PNP Personnel
for Secondment, Detail to International Organizations, Peacekeeping Missions”
a. UN Special Action Team (UNSAT)
COVERAGE of the UNSAT Pre-Qualifying Exam (conducted by the PNP DPL)
= 1st Stage – Written Examination which covers Reading Comprehension, Listening Comprehension, Report
Writing
= 2nd Stage – Driving Proficiency Test
= 3rd Stage – Firing Proficiency Test.
b. Qualifications
1. Age Requirement
= Applicant must not be less than 25 years old or more than 53 years old upon actual deployment.
= An applicant shall be considered 25 years of age on his/her actual 25th birthday, or more than fifty-three 53
years of age on his/her actual 54th birthday.
2. Rank Requirement
= For Police Commissioned Officers (PCOs): Only those with the rank of Police Senior Inspector, Police Chief
Inspector, or Police Superintendent are allowed to apply.
= For Police Non-commissioned Officers (PNCOs): Only those within the rank bracket of Police Officer 3 to
Senior Police Officer 4 are allowed to apply.
= All applicants must have been appointed in permanent status in their respective present ranks.
3. Service Requirement
= All applicants must have attained a minimum of 5 years of active police service (excluding cadetship, officer
orientation/trainee course, and police basic course)
4. Physical Requirement
= All applicants must have passed the latest Physical Fitness Test (PFT) conducted by the PNP Directorate for
Human Resource and Doctrine Development, as well as medical, dental, and neuropsychiatric examinations.
5. Special Skills Needed
= Computer Literacy Requirement – All applicants must be knowledgeable of basic computer operations,
including Word, Excel, PowerPoint, and use of the Internet.
= Driving Proficiency Requirement – All applicants must have at least one (1) year of recent driving
experience and must possess a valid national or international driver's license issued at least one (1) year to the
application.
6. Unit Recommendation Requirement
= All applicants must be recommended by Unit Commanders (Command Group or Directors of their respective
Directorial Staff, National Support Units, or Police Regional Offices).
7. Other Requirements
= All applicants must hold a Performance Evaluation Rating (PER) with a minimum Very Satisfactory
evaluation for two (2) consecutive rating semesters prior to the UNSAT examinations.
= All applicants must not have been repatriated from any previous UN mission for disciplinary reasons.
= All applicants must not have been convicted of any administrative or criminal offense; have no pending
administrative/criminal cases in any body/tribunal/court.
= No applicant should be a witness to any administrative/criminal case, especially those covered by Republic
Act 9165, or a summary hearing officer with unresolved cases.
8. Term of Deployment
= All PNP personnel who are deployed as part of the UN Peacekeeping Mission shall have one (1) year
tenure, extendable to 6 months.
A. U.S.
1. The U.S. Police Department
= Policing in the United States (U.S.) is divided into four broad categories: federal, state, county and municipal
agencies. Each branch of law enforcement has been created to enforce a specific set of laws within a specific
geographical area. This means that the key to understanding which law enforcement has the authority to
respond to a crime is two-fold. First, one must determine which government unit prohibits the acts. For
example, homicide is an act that is prohibited at the state level. So, as a general rule, only law enforcement
agencies with authority to enforce state laws may investigate the crime of murder. Second, one must look at
the place (venue) where the criminal act occurred. If the murder occurred in Alabama, the Alabama authorities
will be responsible in investigating the crime.
2. Federal Law Enforcement Agencies
Police officers that work for the national government are generally called federal police officers. These
police officers enforce criminal federal laws that are passed by the United States Congress and signed into law
by the president. They have the authority to arrest anyone who commits violation of federal criminal laws within
the specific area they are hired to protect.
Police agencies that hire federal police officers include the White House Police, Capital Police,
Supreme Court Police, and Park Police. Each of these Police agencies has specific responsibilities.
The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) is probably the best known of the federal law enforcement
agencies. The FBI is under the U.S. DOJ. This agency is not a police agency, instead it investigates matters
involving violations of federal law including civil rights violations, espionage, treason, bank robbery of federally
insured institution, serious crimes that crosses state lines, and terrorism. The FBI is estimated to have more
than 12,000 agents employed primarily in the United States.
The United States Marshals Service is the nation’s oldest federal law enforcement agency. Marshals
serve to protect federal judicial officials, maintain security in federal courthouses, and protect the safety of the
witnesses in federal trials who are endangered by testifying. The U.S. Marshals also track down fugitives from
justice from across the world, transport federal prisoners who needs to be moved across jurisdictions, and
maintain detention facilities for unsentenced prisoners.
3. Other Federal Agencies
a. Secret Service
Two primary missions:
= Protecting all living current and former U.S. president and their families
= Controlling counterfeiting
b. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, And Explosives
= Assist in controlling the sale of untaxed liquor and cigarettes, illegal firearms, and explosives.
c. Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA)
= The federal agency that enforces federal drug laws.
= Agents of the DEA primarily carry out their responsibilities by assisting local and state authorities in
investigating illegal drug use and drug trafficking. They also work with foreign governments to reduce the
number of illegal drugs entering the United States, as well as operate independent investigations into drug
crime.
4. State Law Enforcement Agencies
= All 50 states have state police agencies. Generally, there are two models of state police agencies. Some
states like New York, Pennsylvania, and Michigan have a single State Police Department that is responsible
for both traffic and criminal investigative responsibilities. One unit is responsible for patrolling state turnpikes
and highways. The second unit is responsible for investigating criminal offenses.
= The second model of policing used by state agencies has been adopted by state such as California, Florida,
Georgia, and Kansas. These states have two separate state police agencies. One agency is called the
Highway Patrol. The Highway Patrol monitors state turnpikes and highways. The second state level policing
agency is assigned the responsibility for state level criminal investigations. The names of these agencies are
varied and include the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, Georgia Bureau of Investigation, and Kansas
Bureau of Investigation.
= In addition, state law enforcement may be responsible for running state law enforcement training academies,
providing emergency medical services, maintaining a crime lab, and providing other services that are needed
to support local level law enforcement efforts.
5. County Law Enforcement Agencies
= The third level of policing occurs at the county level and typically involves an elected sheriff and appointed
deputies. A few states may forego the title of the sheriff and maintain a county police department.
= The duty of the sheriff’s department varies according to the size and population of the county. Nearly all
sheriffs’ office provides basic law enforcement services to areas outside incorporated municipalities. These
duties include routine patrol, responding to citizen calls for service and investigating crimes. They are
authorities to enforce laws within their county as well as enforcing county level laws including traffic
enforcement and, in many counties, animal control.
= In addition, sheriffs’ departments are usually responsible for county jail or detention facility. Although some
states still maintain separate local detention facilities in every city and town, most have consolidated this
function into a single county are facility utilized by all municipalities within the county. Detention duties may be
rotated among all appointed deputies, or deputies may be hired for the single purpose of staffing and
monitoring the detention facility.
= Finally, the sheriff’s department is typically assigned duties associated with court services. These duties
include serving civil court summons, providing court security, providing courthouse security, and dealing with
criminal warrants.
6. Municipal Law Enforcement Agencies
= Municipal law enforcement agencies are those police departments created to serve an incorporated city,
town, village or borough. The primary reason municipalities establish a police department is to maintain order.
= The American Bar Association (ABA) outlines the function of the municipal police officer to include a broad
range of activities. Municipal police officers are expected to:
1. Identify criminal offenders and criminal activity and where appropriate, apprehend offenders and participate
in subsequent court proceedings.
2. Reduce the opportunities for the commission of some crimes through preventive patrol and other measures.
3. Aid individuals who are in danger of physical harm.
4. Protect constitutional guarantees.
5. Facilitate the movement of people and vehicles.
6. Assist those who cannot care for themselves.
7. Resolve conflict.
8. Identify problems that are potentially serious law enforcement and governmental problems.
9. Create and maintain a feeling of security in the community.
10. Promote and preserve civil order.
11. Provide other services on an emergency basis.
7. Police Activities
Study of police activities indicate that most police work involves activity that is non-criminal in nature. Primary
police activities involve:
1. Handling domestic issues
2. Working traffic accidents
3. Finding missing persons
4. Directing traffic
5. Filling out paper works
However, one of the key tasks assigned the police is to respond to calls regarding criminal conduct.
8. Recruitment and Training
General Requirements
Specific requirements for being accepted to a law enforcement training academy vary from department. The
general requirements are the applicant:
1. Is a U.S. citizen
2. Is at least 21 years of age
3. Has at least 20/20 vision uncorrected; (or 20/20 corrected by glasses)
4. Is able to distinguish colors
5. Is physically and mentally healthy.
6. Applicants who have served in the military must have been honorably discharged.
7. May not have been convicted of driving while intoxicated and must hold a valid license for at least three
years prior to application and have a driving record.
8. Applicants should have no criminal conviction, although some misdemeanor crimes may bar applicants from
a law enforcement position.
9. All applicants are expected to be free from drug use, be of good moral character, and have personal
integrity.
10. No applicant should have any history of criminal or improper conduct, have a poor employment record, or
have an irresponsible financial history.
11. Generally, applicants should at least have a GED equivalency or a high school diploma, however, some
departments, such as that in Dallas, Texas, are requiring 60 or more hours of completed college coursework.
9. Probation Period
= When a candidate receives an appointment to the police department, the candidate must then successfully
complete recruit training, which can last from several months to more than a year, depending on the training
requirements of the police department. Once the recruit has successfully completed the training academy, the
recruit then usually receives field training under the supervision of seasoned officers. Upon the successful
completion of the field training, the officer is considered eligible to be on their own.
= Police recruits are on probation during the entire period of training and usually are on probation for a period
of time after they have completed their training. The length of time that a recruit serves on probation varies
from department to department. It should be noted that officers will not generally be eligible for a promotion
until the probationary period is successfully completed.
= It is important that police officer candidates understand that the goal of probationary period is to evaluate
their ability to perform on the job and to fit into the department. Probies may be dismissed during the
probationary period without cause and no reason needs to be provided. Damaging a police vehicle, a single
incident of excessive use of force, violating the chain of command, or making negative comments about
superior officers may all demonstrate that the probie is not the right fit for a department’s needs.
= Once police recruit successfully completes the probationary period, more workplace protections are
acquired. Generally, following the probationary period, law enforcement officers are given civil status. The
actual rights and protections associated with this status differ from municipality to municipality and from state to
state, but they will always provide at least a few rights that are missing during the probationary period.
10. Opportunities for Promotion
= Opportunities for promotion vary from police department to police department. The size of the Department
plays an important role in opportunities. Larger departments are likely to have greater opportunities for
advancement and a wider variety of areas of specialization available to officers.
11. Opportunities for Women and Minorities
= Since the 1970s the opportunities for women and minorities in policing have increased substantially as law
enforcement agencies have begun to recognize importance of ensuring that police force they hire resembles
the public it polices. Today, police departments do not have a sufficient number of women and minorities
applying for policing to meet that goal. For this reason, many police departments are actively recruiting women
and minorities because they would like the opportunity to hire them.
= In today’s policing environment, both women and racial minorities who meet the criteria and qualifications to
be police officers have unlimited opportunities.
12. Affirmative Action/EEOC
= Affirmative Action is a part of the civil rights laws that has been implemented through the Equal Employment
Opportunity Commission’s attempt to implement programs established by the congress. EEOC is an
independent federal agency that oversees federal civil rights laws. EEOC is the agency that investigates cases
of discrimination and takes action to eliminate discrimination when they locate it. Affirmative Action policies and
federal law make it a crime to discriminate against any person because of race, national origin, religion,
gender, age or sexual orientation. This means that a person cannot be discriminated against in hiring process,
promotional process, or in wage determination.
13. Screening Process
The screening process differs in relation to the needs and size of the specific department being applied to.
However, screening processes tend to be similar between departments of the same size. The following list
provides an overview of the typical screening process.
1. Individuals must apply for a police officer position by completing the required application for the police
department.
2. A written examination is required for all police departments in medium-to-large cities.
3. A Police Candidate Who Successfully Passes the Written Examination is then Required to Take a Physical
Abilities/Agility Test.
4. A Police Candidate Who Successfully Passes the Physical Abilities/Agility Test is Then Given a Date to
Take a Pre-Employment Polygraph Examination.
5. A Candidate Who Successfully Passes the Pre-Employment Polygraph Examination Must Then Undergo a
Background Investigation.
6. A Candidate Who Successfully Passes the Background Examination is then Given an Oral Interview.
7. A candidate who successfully passes the oral examination is then scheduled for a psychological
examination.
8. A candidate who passes the psychological examination is then scheduled to take a medical examination.
9. A candidate who passes all the previous examinations may be asked to participate in a final oral interview
with the police chief, the head of the training academy, or police command staff to determine whether the
candidate should be offered a police position in the department.
14. ASSIGNMENTS FOR THE POLICE OFFICER
1. Foot patrol
2. Traffic officer
3. Bicycle patrol
4. Motorcycle patrol
5. Horse patrol
6. Marine Patrol
7. Aircraft patrol
8. Juvenile officer
9. Canine officer
10. Crime scene investigator
11. Crime prevention officer
12. Community policing officer
13. Hostage negotiation teams
14. Bomb squad officers
15. Warrant officers
16. Airport police
17. Housing police
18. Port authority police
19. Transit police
= The national police force of Canada and one of the most recognized of its kind in the world. It is unique in the
world as a national, federal, provincial and municipal policing body. The RCMP provides federal policing
service to all of Canada and policing services under contract to the three territories, eight of Canada's
provinces. The RCMP was formed in 1920 by the merger of the Royal Northwest Mounted Police (RNWMP,
founded 1873) with the Dominion Police (founded 1868). The former was originally named the North-West
Mounted Police (NWMP), and was given the Royal prefix by King Edward VII in 1904. Much of the present-
day organization's symbolism has been inherited from its days as the NWMP, including the distinctive Red
Serge uniform, paramilitary heritage, and mythos as a frontier force. The RCMP/GRC wording is specifically
protected under the Trade-marks Act.
= As the national police force of Canada, the Royal Canadian Mounted Police is primarily responsible for
enforcing federal laws throughout Canada, while general law and order including the enforcement of the
Criminal Code and applicable provincial legislation is constitutionally the responsibility of the provinces and
territories. This responsibility is sometimes further delegated to municipalities which can form their own
municipal police departments. This is common in the largest cities.
a. ORGANIZATION
1. International
= The RCMP International Operations Branch assists the Liaison Officer (LO) Program to deter international
crime relating to Canadian criminal laws. The IOB is a section of the International Policing, which is part of the
RCMP Federal and International Operations Directorate. Thirty-five Liaison Officers are placed in 25 other
countries and are responsible for organizing Canadian investigations in other countries, developing and
maintaining the exchange of criminal intelligence, especially national security with other countries, to aid in
investigations that directly affect Canada, to coordinate and assist RCMP officers on foreign business and to
represent the RCMP at international meetings.
2. National
= The Royal Canadian Mounted Police is organized under the authority of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police
Act. In accordance with the Act, it is headed by the Commissioner, who, under the direction of the Minister of
Public Safety, has the control and management of the Force and all matters connected therewith.
= The Commissioner is assisted by a Senior Deputy Commissioner who is second in command of the force.
SDC primarily functions to review, consult, or advice agency matters before they are considered by the
Commissioner.
= Under the Commissioner and Senior Deputy Commissioner, operational direction is provided by Deputy
Commissioners in charge of
1. Federal and International Policing
2. Police Support Services
3. Contract and Aboriginal Policing
4. Human Resources
5. East
5.1. Ontario (“O” Division)
5.2. National Capital Region (“A” Division)
5.3. National Headquarters,
5.4. Quebec (“C” Division)
5.5. New Brunswick (“J” Division)
5.6. Nova Scotia (“H” Division)
5.7. Prince Edward Island (“L” Division)
5.8. Newfoundland and Labrador (“B” Division)
6. West
6.1. British Columbia (“E” Division)
6.2. Alberta (“K” Division)
6.3. Saskatchewan (“F” Division)
6.4. Manitoba (“D” Division)
6.5. Yukon (“M” Division)
6.6. Northwest Territories (“G” Division)
6.7. Nunavut (“V” Division)
3. Regional
= In 1996, the RCMP began moving towards a more regional management system under the direction of
deputy commissioners. These are: Pacific, Northwestern, Central and Atlantic. This was done to allow greater
grass-roots involvement in decision-making and also allows the RCMP to invest more resources into frontline
services.
= The RCMP divides the country into divisions for command purposes. In general, each division is coterminous
with a province (for example, C Division is Quebec). The province of Ontario, however, is divided into two
divisions: A Division (Ottawa) and O Division (rest of the province). There is one additional division – Depot
Division, which is the RCMP Academy at Regina, Saskatchewan, and the Police Dog Service Training Centre
at Bowden, Alberta. The RCMP headquarters are located in Ottawa, Ontario.
= The RCMP employs three categories of employees to handle the wide scope of its responsibilities:
Regular Members (Police Officers), Civilian Members and Public Service Employees.
4. Regular Member (Police Officers)
= Regular Members are responsible for preserving the peace, upholding the law and providing quality service
in partnership with our communities. Working in the RCMP offers a variety of dynamic and meaningful
challenges, opportunities to be posted across Canada and a competitive salary and benefits package. A
Career Nowhere Near Ordinary is waiting for you to discover.
5. Civilian Members
= Hired for their specialized scientific, technical or analytical skills, in areas such as human resources,
forensics, computer programming and project management, Civilian Members provide support to front-line
policing operations.
6. Public Service Employees
= Public Service employees in areas such as administration, communications and internet technology provide
the additional support to the business management of the RCMP.
7. Police Ranks in the RCMP
1. Commissioner
2. Senior Deputy Commissioner
3. Deputy Commissioner
4. Assistant Commissioner
5. Chief Superintendent
6. Superintendent
7. Inspector
8. Corps Sergeant Major
9. Sergeants Major
10. Staff Sergeants Major
11. Staff Sergeants
12. Sergeants
13. Corporals
14. Constables