CDI 3 Notes
CDI 3 Notes
Criminal investigations are conducted in accordance with the There is one paramount result at which the investigator is constantly
dictates of the law. The conduct of an investigation is governed by striving and that is positive identification of victim, perpetrator and
information obtained from people, records, and physical evidence. witness. Identification, absolute and complete, is often the crowning
Victims or witnesses still provide the bulk of facts as to when, achievement of his work.
where, how, why, and by whom the crime was committed.
Common sense reasoning is in reality the scientific mode. From the
Police science utilizes the methods of natural and related sciences facts in a case you arrive at a judgment, and your future action will
as aid in criminal investigation. It may be said to have three phases be based on that judgment or judgments. It is necessary for you to
that embraces... know how the mind arrives at a judgment, and for you to be careful
the identification of living and dead persons; not to confuse the two methods of reasoning from which your
the field work carried out by specially trained crime scene judgments flow in each case.
investigators; and
the laboratory methods used to examine and analyze physical Judgments are obtained by deductive and inductive reasoning. The
evidences by the criminalists. difference is as follows:
- A deductive judgment is one you decide is the answer of the
case, and which you then attempt to prove with a collection
Phases of Criminal Investigation of facts. To put it in another way, you "jump at a conclusion"
and then undertake to show that your guess was right.
It is very clear that without facts, the courts, which apply the
- Inductive reasoning collects all the facts available first and principles of law, have nothing upon which to decide a case. A court
allows them to determine the judgment. After you carefully has no discretion but must render judgment according to the facts
examine all the details of a case you will be compelled to and the law. Judges are bound, it is true, to act with good judgment,
come to some conclusion regarding them. judiciously, but exercising a sound judgment is by no means
synonymous with rendering judgment, and acting judiciously is not
- The latter, or inductive method of arriving at the truth is the always acting judicially.
scientific method. This does not mean, however, that the
deductive mode of reasoning has no place in investigation Hence, the investigator should crystallize within his mind these
work. Far from it. After all the facts in a case have been three basic definitions:
uncovered and arranged, the solution of the case may still be Law: law is a principle;
far away and two or more alternative decisions may be Fact: a fact is a circumstance, event or occurrence as it
possible. For example: you trace a suspect right to the point actually exists or existed;
where you are convinced of his identity, but you do not have Evidence: evidence is the means by which facts are proved.
knowledge of his whereabouts. You know nothing certain as
to his movements from the time of the perpetration of the
crime. He may be around the corner, or he may be out of
town. Here, where you have no facts to go on, you must begin
EXAMINATION OF THE CRIME SCENE
to deduce a judgment from the probable possibilities.
Are the doors open or closed? Any signs of forced entry? Crime Scene Notes
What is the condition of the windows?
Are the room lights on or off? Notes at the crime scene should be made in the order of the various
Are the blinds open or closed? phases of the examination. By placing the documented notes in a
Are there any distinct odors? chronological order will systemize the investigation, and will avoid
Are there any victims, injured or dead? possible error. Make the notes clear, legible, complete, and to the
Are there any witnesses? point. Always recheck the notes to see that nothing is forgotten.
Is there a need for medical aid?
What is the weather condition? Ambiguous expressions, such as near, or to the left of, should not be
used. The narrative sequence should describe the scene from the
Nothing at the crime scene may be moved unless absolutely outside inward. In other words, upon arrival, note the conditions
necessary. Do not walk around the scene to satisfy curiosity by outside the building; then describe movements in entering the
touching things. Do not use the toilet, turn on the water, smoke, building; eventually the arrival at the exact location of the crime.
or use towels at the scene. Therefore, begin by describing the exterior first, followed by the
central scene and the detailed descriptions of that area. Sketches
- As soon as possible after arriving at the scene, take steps to and photographs should be referred to where necessary. Notes made
protect the scene from curiosity seekers and family at the crime scene should never be discarded, but placed in a case
members. A general rule to follow is that if the scene is file after the final report has been written.
indoors, cordon the area to protect it. This should include: the
central scene, and, if possible, places where the criminal
made entry and exit. Crime Scene Photographs
- If the crime scene is outdoors, ample area should be roped off
to include the path taken in and out of the scene. Use ropes, As the saying goes, a picture is worth a thousand words. In crime
chairs, barricades, etc., to exclude unauthorized people. scene investigation, photography is invaluable. There cannot be
Remain at the scene whenever possible, and send others to instant replay of the crime, but the crime scene can be preserved
call headquarters. Keep other police officers and firemen with photographs.
away from the scene, unless they have been authorized to
enter. Before an investigator begins a preliminary investigation of a crime
- If someone is injured at the scene, first aid should be scene, he must be sure the scene is recorded in detail. The recording
rendered immediately, even though valuable clues may be process is accomplished in several ways through sketches, video
disturbed. All other considerations must yield when a human tape, and photography.
life can be saved. There are some steps to take to reduce the The main function of a crime scene photograph is to provide
amount of evidence that may be destroyed during medical aid information which will assist in the investigation and prosecution of the
to the victim. First, mark the victim's position with a piece of case. Photographs are valuable in three areas:
yellow marking crayon. Make general observations, detailed - They provide the police and prosecutor with an accurate
as necessary, whenever possible. If it can be done, collect pictorial of the appearance of objects in position at the crime
the victim's clothing at the scene, otherwise be sure to get scene.
them at the hospital. - They aid in the questioning of suspects and witnesses.
- Though, at first, it may not be known whether a person has - The will enable the judge to gain a better understanding of
committed suicide or was the victim of a homicide, it is the crime scene and evidence so that he, in turn, can
evaluate testimony of the witness in an intelligent manner.
The important thing to remember in taking photographs is that Crime Scene Sketches
pictures are a means of communication. The aim should be to record
a maximum of useful information in a series of photographs which The word sketch means to draw to scale, with important dimensions
will enable the viewer to understand what has happened. The at the scene being shown to a good degree of accuracy. Legally, for
number and type of photographs will be determined by the a sketch or diagram to be admissible in court, it must:
circumstances of the crime. - be part of some qualified person's testimony;
- relate the observed situation (the person must have seen the
The first step in the photo-recording process is to record the crime area;
scene as completely and accurately as possible. The key aspects of - express it (the crime scene) correctly.
the scene must be photographed before any physical evidence is
disturbed or moved. The scene should be photographed from several A sketch is made for several important reasons:
angles. Remember, film is the least costly part of the investigation. It - to refresh the memory of the investigator;
is better to have too many photos than too few. - to reflect the precise location of objects and their
relationship to other objects and surroundings;
Crime scene photographs should show the relationship of various - to assist the prosecutor and the judge in understanding
objects of evidence to one another. The objects should also be conditions at the crime scene; to supplement photographs; to
shown in their relationship to the background. Usually, a large assist in questioning of witnesses and suspects.
number of photographs must be taken to insure complete coverage.
The type of photographs usually include: A sketch need not be artistically perfect. A simple line drawing with
Overall photographs showing a general view of the scene and accurate measurements is sufficient. It must relate to the case only.
its surroundings. Sketching the crime scene should be systematically planned. When
The attack scene and its surroundings. to make a sketch and what to include in it will depend largely upon
Photographs of evidence in places before anyone moves the seriousness of the offense and the circumstances surrounding
anything. the case. It must be done in a logical and methodical manner.
Photographs of fingerprints, tire marks, tool marks, shoe
tracks, etc.
Rules for Field Sketching
Due to the fact that many courts object to markings or marking
devices appearing in a photograph, it should be taken in two ways: The following rules for field sketching can serve as a guide in
recording the observable material facts:
-First, with no marking in the photograph. - Essential Details. Before starting to draw the sketch, the
- Second, with the marker in the photograph. investigator must decide what and how much to include in
the sketch. Observable facts which are relevant to the case
A complete record of each photograph taken should be made in the should be included. This must be done before the scene is
investigator's notebook. The record should include the following: disturbed or changed in any way.
Identify the photograph with the offense. - Keep it Simple. To be effective the sketch should be kept as
The name of the photographer. simple as possible.
The camera position. - Be Complete. The drawing should not cluttered with
Date and time taken. irrelevant items, but it should be made complete enough to
Weather and light conditions. permit construction of a detailed drawing later.
Exposure data. - Directional Points. The investigator should orient all sketches
by indicating the direction with an arrow on the sketch
The type of equipment used.
pointing north. Exterior sketches are usually made with north
at the top of the paper. Interior sketches, such as of a
rectangular room, are usually drawn to conform to the
rectangular shape of the paper, so the compass heading must Sketch of Grounds. The sketch of grounds pictures the scene
be included. of the crime with its nearest physical surroundings, such as a
house with garden, the plan of one or more floors in a house,
- Include Measurements. The exact position of all important etc., as in Fig. 2.2.
objects should be located by making accurate Sketch of Details. The sketch of details describes the
measurements. Careful measurement eliminate the immediate scene only. Like the room in which the crime was
guesswork in locating items during the investigation. They committed and the details of items in the room, as in Fig. 2.3.
enable the investigator to testify with confidence and
precision about his observation regarding the location of Cross Projection. The cross projection method is sometimes
observable facts at the scene. used for this type of sketch. In this method, walls and
ceilings are pictured as if on the same plane as the floor, as
- Stationary Objects. The position of objects should be in Fig. 2.4.
recorded relative to stationary objects, such as: walls,
windows, doors, trees or curbs. Avoid using "stationary" Rough sketches must not be altered in any way after the investigator
objects which may be subject to become "movable," such as leaves the crime scene. At headquarters, he makes a finished sketch
street signs or utility poles, since these are subject to be from his rough sketch. The only differences between the rough
moved by the departments in charge of them or to be sketch and the finished sketch is that the latter is done in ink and is
displaced by motorists whose cars contact them with more carefully drawn and labeled.
sufficient force.
A straightedge will be used to make straight lines straight, object
- Measuring Tape. Use a steel tape to measure accurately the labels will be printed neatly and, as much as possible, all face one
position of things observed. For short distances, a pocket rule direction for ease of reading. All measurements must be written with
may be used. The cloth tapes have a tendency to stretch, and care on the final sketch to maintain accuracy in transferring them
therefore, should not be used for accurate measurements. from the rough sketch.
Types of Sketches
The investigating officer should look the scene over from several
angles, to grasp the whole scene, and then formulate a plan for
searching the scene. A proper approach prevents fouling any
evidence that trooping through the area haphazardly may trample.
Soil
Paint Soil sometimes has a great deal of evidential value. It is very
Paint traces are often found in clothing and as transfers on tools and sensitive to sampling techniques. The usual sources are clothing,
automobiles. An analysis of paint consists of an examination of its shoes and tools.
color, surface texture and sequence of layers. The samples are - Collect one ounce from areas the suspect's shoe may have
subjected to infrared analysis and spectrographic analysis. All of contacted and collect numerous samples from various
these tests are worthless unless samples of paint to be used as a locations where the suspect may have traveled.
comparative standard are collected at the crime scene to compare - If an impression is dug, such as a grave, collect samples at
with those found in the possession of the suspect. various depths.
When collecting paint fragments, avoid crumbling the - If a large hole, collect samples at different locations at
fragment. various depths.
The shape of the fragment may be able to be marched to a - When collecting, do not mix samples from different areas.
missing paint area on an item involved in the case. - Package and seal in tight containers such as glass vials.
In cases where paint has been transferred from one item to - When collecting samples from vehicles, collect blobs which
another, collect a sample of the foreign paint and a sample of may have come from the same location and place in separate
the uncontaminated paint which belongs on the particular containers.
surface. - Do not scrape all the dirt together into one container.
Package these in separate containers.
When collecting the uncontaminated paint, collect close to
the damaged area. Incendiary Material
Collect samples by cutting or chipping and place them in Incendiary materials must be found to establish the corpus delicti in
clean vials. arson cases.
Label each sample as to the exact location in which it was - Airtight jars or cans are the only safe containers for this type
found. of evidence.
Do not mix samples from various locations. - Use a separate jar for each location.
Take two samples for every distinctly different surface area. - Collect samples from areas of possible origin or which give
response to a Hydro-carbon sniffer (a device used to measure
fumes of volatile substances).
Wood - Collect any uncharred material near area of origin.
Wood may be important evidence in robbery case where forced entry - Samples are needed for comparison and must be collected
is done through wooden material, and automobile hit-and-run from such sources as service stations or hardware stores in
property damage cases. The usual sources of wood evidence are the area where incendiary material may have been
clothing and tools and automobiles. purchased, and from containers owned by the suspect.
Wood itself, because of its common use, does not have a high
evidential value as proof unless some relatively rare type of wood is Tools and Tool Marks
It is possible to determine whether a particular tool made a tool Bullets
mark in question. Never try working a tool against a tool mark as this A bullet can provide information about the type and make of
will damage the mark and destroy the evidential value of any paint ammunition, the type and make of weapon from which the bullet was
on the tool. fired, and whether or not it was fired from a specific weapon,
Handle tools with care and protect the tips so that any paint provided the weapon is available for test purposes.
chips or other traces which might be on them will not be lost. - Handle the bullet so as not to dislodge any extraneous
If possible, remove the portion of the item which contains the materials or damage the markings.
tool mark and submit it to the laboratory along with any - If a bullet is lodged in wood or similar material, cut out the
suspect tools. section and bring to the laboratory.
Mark the item with tool mark and all tools and identify them - At autopsies, request the use of hands or rubber-tipped
as to where and when they were obtained. forceps to minimize the possibility of damage to the bullet.
- Wrap each bullet separately in tissue or cotton to prevent
damage and place in a container.
Firearms Mark initials on the base or side of the bullet.
Firearms, bullets, shotgun shells, shotgun pellets and wads, - If the bullet is too small to be easily marked or there is a
explosive residues and powder patterns can all provide vital possibility of dislodging evidence from the nose, seal the date
evidence and specific answers to possible questions in the case. and information as to where and when the bullet was found
- Firearms must be handled very carefully, not only as a safety onto the container. If there is more than one bullet, mark the
factor, but to avoid disturbing any evidence they may provide. order in which they were found and the exact location.
They must be properly marked for later identification.
- Never insert anything in the barrel as this may damage the
identifying characteristics and dislodge material which may Cartridge Cases
be inside the barrel. Cartridge cases can provide vital information as to the type of
- Pick up the weapon by the trigger guard or checkered grip so weapon used, the type of ammunition, and whether or not the case
as not to disturb any fingerprints. was fired in a specific weapon (if the weapon is available for test
- Unload but do not wipe or clean the weapon. firing).
- When unloading, carefully record the location of fired, unfired Handle cartridge cases so as not to add any scratches or
and misfired cartridges. marks.
- Record the serial number description of the weapon. Wrap each one separately to prevent damage.
- Firearms with no serial number should be marked with initials Be sure to note specific locations in which each was found.
on the receiver or the underside of the barrel. Mark by scratching initials on the inside of the case or on the
- Never use "X" or other non-individual type of marking. outside near the bullet end of
- Do not mark the weapon on any easily removable part such the case.
as the stock or grips. If inscribing initials might damage the markings, seal the
- Use discretion so as not to disfigure the weapon. cartridge case in a container and mark initials on the
container and indicate where and when the case was found.
Even if the identifying marks (make, model, serial number, etc.) have See Fig. 3.1
been removed, the make and caliber can be determined, and possibly
the serial number of the weapon. Whether the weapon is in working
order and, if so, whether it has any defects which might have an
effect on the investigation, and whether it has been used to fire a
particular bullet or cartridge are other questions which can be
answered by expert examination
- Do not mark the items, but seal them in containers and mark
the containers with initial, and where and when the items
were obtained.
Shot and powder patterns may indicate the distance (with limits)
from which the shot was fired. Occasionally they may make it
possible to determine the barrel length or number of lands and
grooves for the weapon.
- Necessary to have the same weapon and type of ammunition
used in the incident to make valid comparison patterns.
- Seize available pertinent ammunition as most likely to be the
type of ammunition used.
Accurately measure patterns on bodies and photograph with
a scale included.
Count the number of holes in patterns if possible.
The figure may give information as to the size of the shot
load.
- Initial all items submitted and give pertinent information as to
where and when found.
Shotgun Shells
Shotgun shells can indicate the type of ammunition used and
whether or not it was fired in a specific weapon (provided the Serial Number Restoration
weapon is available for test firing). Occasionally the type of shotgun Serial number restoration is possible in most cases if the removal
may be determined from the type and location of marks. has not gone too deep or if the number has not been obscured by
- Handle shotgun shells in the same manner as in cartridge overlapping. Only stamped numbers can be restored.
cases. - Do not attempt to raise the number, yourself, but bring the
- If shells are waxed, scrape off the wax and mark initials with item to the laboratory, if practical.
a pen. - If not practicable, contact the laboratory for instructions.
- If plastic, scratch initials into the plastic with a sharp tool. - Obtain any information as to the type of metal in the item, as
- Never mark on the brass portion. different types of metals require different chemicals for
developing the numbers.