Missile Guidance Propulsion and Control
Missile Guidance Propulsion and Control
Compiled By:
Belete Bantealem
[email protected]
1
Table of Contents
1. Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 1
2. MISSILE GUIDANCE....................................................................................................................... 1
2.1 Command to LOS Guidance ............................................................................................... 3
2.2 Beam Rider Guidance .......................................................................................................... 4
2.3 Inertial Navigation System ................................................................................................ 6
2.4 Homing Guidance (HG) ....................................................................................................... 7
2.4.1 PURSUIT GUIDANCE................................................................................................. 11
2.4.2 PREDICTIVE GUIDANCE ......................................................................................... 12
2.4.3 CONSTANT BEARING GUIDANCE........................................................................ 12
2.4.4 PROPORTIONAL NAVIGATION GUIDANCE ..................................................... 13
2.5 OPTIMAL GUIDANCE ........................................................................................................ 15
3. MISSILE CONTROL ..................................................................................................................... 16
3.1 BASIC MOTIONS OF MISSILE ......................................................................................... 17
3.2 Elements of Control System ........................................................................................... 18
3.2.1 Autopilot ....................................................................................................................... 18
3.2.2 Actuation ....................................................................................................................... 18
3.3 Control Technologies of missile.................................................................................... 19
3.3.1 Aerodynamic Control ............................................................................................... 19
3.3.2 Thrust Vector Control (TVC) ................................................................................. 21
3.4 Missile Control surfaces ................................................................................................... 21
Configuration of missile control surfaces .......................................................................... 23
4. MISSILE PROPULSION............................................................................................................... 24
4.1 Types of missile propulsion ........................................................................................... 24
i
1. Introduction
The incorporation of energy source in a missile to provide the required force for its
movement (propulsion), intelligence to go in the correct direction (guidance) and
effective maneuvering (control) are mainly the technologies of guided missiles. They
help in making a missile specific to a target, that is, they determine the size, range
and state of motion of a missile [1].
In other words "Guidance” is the strategy of steering a missile toward a possible
intercept with a target, while “control” is the tactics of using the missile control
actuators to implement the strategy dictated by the guidance unit [2] [3].
2. MISSILE GUIDANCE
As it is stated in above, guidance is the aspect of a missile system which helps it to
decide the direction in which the missile should move. Generally this decision has to
be taken at very short intervals of time ⁄5 during the flight of
the missile [1].
Guidance has normally been divided into [1] [2].
Target related guidance: where target tracking data are provided in real
time from a sensor, which can be on-board or off-board.
Non-target related guidance: where the missile navigates to some
predetermined point, which can be the target or the point where target
related guidance can begin.
The most fundamental, and also most commonly used, guidance laws are [1][2] [3]
[5][6]:
Command to LOS guidance
Beam rider guidance
Inertial guidance
Homing or seeker guidance
Optimal guidance
All of these guidance laws date back to the very first guided missiles developed in
the 1940's and 1950's. The reasons that they have been so successful are mainly
that they are simple to implement and that they give robust performance [2].
Page 1
Some missiles need more than one system of guidance. The requirement depends on
the phase of guidance. In many missiles, the guidance phase is divided into three
phases: Boost/ launch phase, the mid-course phase and the terminal phase [1][3].
i. Launch or boost phase
In this phase the guidance system is usually disabled to allow the missile to
safely travel away from the launch platform. It covers the flight of the missile
from the firing instant to the end of the thrust [3].
ii. Mid-course phase
The majority of the flight is flown using midcourse guidance, during which
the missile makes slight adjustments to its trajectory allowing it to reach the
vicinity of the target. The midcourse phase begins after the boost phase and
remains till the detection of the intended target by the seeker. Actually, the
duration of the midcourse phase is dependent on the instant of the target
detection. In midcourse guidance, it is intended to guide the missile to the
vicinity of the target as soon as possible. While the midcourse guidance is
usually utilized in strategic or long range missiles, it is not employed in short
range tactical missiles most of the times [3].
iii. Terminal phase
It is a final phase of the guidance. Once the target is detected by the seeker,
the terminal guidance phase is initiated. In this phase, using the target state
information acquired by the seeker, the missile is directed to the target by
means of the considered highly accurate guidance law and tracking system
and then the missile tries to follow the target in order to achieve the planned
interception [3].
Page 4
Fig 3. Beam rider guidance
In a beam rider guidance system, equipment in the missile measures the
displacement of the missile from the center of the radar beam then appropriate
action by the control system steers the missile back into the center of the beam. If
the missile is flying in the center of the beam, no signals are sent to the control
system, indicating that no corrective action is necessary [1] [3] [10].
The guidance beam that guides the missiles is formed by the radar antenna, which
sends out electromagnetic energy in the form of lobes, as shown in figure 3. The
antenna is rotated in such a manner that the tips of the lobes describe a circle,
resulting in a cone of radiation in space with its origin at the radar antenna. The
missile is guided along the axis of this cone.
A few launching considerations are to be taken care of in this system. The missile
must be launched in such a manner that it flies as nearly parallel to the beam axis as
possible when it first enters the cone of radiation. Otherwise, it might fly right
through the beam without being captured by its guidance signals. At this time the
missile might not be up to full operational velocity, and its aerodynamic control
system would not be as effective in controlling the missile as it would at the
operating speed for which it is designed. Launching the missile as closely as possible
to the beam axis eliminates sharp turns and sudden maneuvers.
Page 5
This type of guidance system is relatively simple, less complex with increased
reliability and lower cost. The limitation is that the trajectory requires high lateral
acceleration during the terminal phase.
Page 7
fulfills its duty on its own. These kinds of missiles are called fire and forget, or launch
and leave type missiles [1] [3] [13].
The advantage of HG over the other guidance methods is that the measurement
accuracy of the relative motion of the target with respect to the missile increases in
HG but decreases in the others as the missile approaches the target [3].
The main types of homing guidance methods are listed as given below [3] [13].
Active homing guidance
semi-active homing guidance
passive homing guidance
Map Matching homing guidance
Page 8
Fig 5. Active homing guidance
b) SEMI - ACTIVE HOMING GUIDANCE
A semi-active system is similar to command guidance since the missile relies on an
external source to illuminate the target. The homing radiation is already transmitted
from the launcher and the missile is equipped only with a receiver to pick up the
radiation reflected from the target [3].
With the guidance system, the high power radar illuminator or the laser designator
extends the range. The rest of the process is identical to active type. This type helps
to have a simple onboard system and can be used for longer ranges (up to 50 to 60
km) [1] [10].
Page 9
The difference between command guidance and semi-active homing is that the
missile has an onboard computer in this case. The computer uses the energy
collected by its radar receiver to determine the target's relative trajectory and send
correcting commands to control surfaces so that the missile will intercept the target.
Page 10
The widely-used conventional HG strategies can be listed as follows [16] [17] [18]
Pursuit Guidance
Constant Bearing Guidance
Proportional Navigation Guidance
Predictive Guidance
2.4.1 PURSUIT GUIDANCE
In Pursuit Guidance, it is intended to nullify the relative LOS angle between the
missile and the target. However, the Pursuit Guidance laws have limited capability
to engage maneuvering targets follows [3] [8] [16] [14] [17].
The Pursuit Guidance has two basic variants:
Body Pursuit or Attitude Pursuit Guidance
Velocity Pursuit Guidance
In the Body Pursuit approach, the longitudinal axis, or the centerline, of the missile
is directed at the target.
Page 12
of this approach is strongly dependent on the correct prediction of this angle. Here,
it should be noted that the VPG strategy in which the bearing angle is tried to be
kept at zero is a special case of the constant bearing strategy.
In figure 9, as A and B denote the missile and the target, and show the velocity
vectors of the missile and the target.
Page 14
In spite of the fact that the optimality of PNG against no maneuvering targets was
proven many years later from its derivation, the PNG law is not very effective in the
presence of target maneuvers and often leads to unacceptable miss distances
especially when the guidance system time constant is too large or the flight time is
very short. Then, increasing the effective navigation ratio and decreasing the
guidance system time constant work in the direction of reducing the terminal miss
distance due to target maneuver. As the navigation ratio is increased, the initial
values of the acceleration commands become larger, but the commands get smaller
near the end of the flight.
Against non-constant target maneuvers, larger effective navigation ratios result in
smaller miss distances. On the contrary, increasing the effective navigation ratio also
causes the miss distance due to noise and parasitic effects to grow. Here, another
significant property of the noise and parasitic effects is that they place a practical
lower limit on the minimum attainable guidance system time constant.
3. MISSILE CONTROL
In missiles the control function is to ensure stability of the missile and implement
the guidance signals received from external sources or generated onboard. The
control, after processing the guidance signals, actuates the aerodynamic surfaces on
thrust vector to generate turn of the missile speed and direction as required [1].
The guidance system is to detect whether the missile is flying above or below, to the
left or right, of the required path. It obtains these deviations or errors and sends
signals to the control system to reduce these errors to zero. The task of the control
system therefore is to maneuver the missile quickly and efficiently making use of
these signals [1].
Page 16
3.1 BASIC MOTIONS OF MISSILE
In order to appreciate controls we shall briefly describe the motion of the missile as
a free body. Like any moving body, a guided missile executes two basic types of
motion: - rotation and translation. In pure rotation, all parts of the missile pivot
around the center of gravity. In movements of translation or linear motions, the
center of gravity moves along a line [1] [12].
The missile has a total of six degrees or dimensions of freedom (movement). To
describe these motions, we use a reference system of lines or axes. These axes
intersect at the missile's center of gravity.
Out of the six degree of movement of missile, three degrees are translational or
linear about the three axes viz., x, y and z; while the other degrees are rotational
movement about three axes termed as pitch, yaw and roll.
Page 17
from its desired trajectory. This displacement could happen without causing any
significant rotary or angular movements. Any linear movement can be resolved into
three components-lateral, vertical and along the direction of thrust [12].
The missile must sense and correct for each degree of movement to maintain an
accurate and stable flight path. This stable flight path is often called "attitude" and
refers to the position of the missile relative to a known (horizontal or vertical)
plane. The control system contains various components used to maintain a proper
flight attitude [1] [12].
3.2.2 Actuation
The means of deflecting the aerodynamic surfaces or thrust vector is called
actuation and the force to do this can be from many sources like pneumatic (high
pressure air power), hydraulic (high pressure oil power), electrical or turbo-
mechanical.
Page 18
All the four methods are prevalent and used depending upon the size or availability
of expertise. Most of the anti-tank missiles and smaller surface to air missiles have
electrical actuation, while somewhat bigger missiles have electrical or pneumatic
system. While pneumatic actuation depends upon high pressure air pre-stored
onboard, electric type will draw its power from an onboard battery. For the
hydraulic type, the power source is electrical and is used in most of the large tactical
and all ballistic missiles. For some of the very big missiles and space booster’s
actuation is realized through turbine mechanical power.
Page 19
a) Canard Control:
In the canard-controlled missiles, the control fins, or canards, are mounted on the
nose part of the missile as shown in Figure 13. They are light in weight and can be
simply packaged. The drag acting on their bodies is smaller because of their smaller
sizes [3] [10].
They are also quite commonly used, especially on short-range air-to-air missiles.
The primary advantage of canard control is better maneuverability at low angles of
attack, but canards tend to become ineffective at high angles of attack because of
flow separation that causes the surfaces to stall. Since canards are ahead of the
center of gravity, they cause a destabilizing effect and require large fixed tails to
keep the missile stable. These two sets of fins usually provide sufficient lift to make
wings unnecessary.
A further subset of canard control missiles is the split canard. Split canards are a
relatively new development that has found application on the latest generation of
short-range air-to-air missiles. The term split canard refers to the fact that the
missile has two sets of canards in close proximity, usually one immediately behind
the other. The first canard is fixed while the second set is movable. The advantage of
this arrangement is that the first set of canards generates strong, energetic vortices
that increase the speed of the airflow over the second set of canards making them
more effective. In addition, the vortices delay flow separation and allow the canards
to reach higher angles of attack before stalling. This high angle of attack
performance gives the missile much greater maneuverability compared to a missile
with single canard control.
b) Wing Control
In the wing-controlled missiles, the control fins are mounted near the mass center of
the missile. They are the earliest forms of missile control developed, but it is
becoming less commonly used on today's designs. Most missiles using wing control
are longer-range missiles like. The primary advantage of wing control is that the
deflections of the wings produce a very fast response with little motion of the body
lateral acceleration. This feature results in small seeker tracking error and allows
the missile to remain locked on target even during large maneuvers. The major
Page 20
disadvantage is that the wings must usually be quite large in order to generate both
sufficient lift and control effectiveness, which makes the missiles rather large
overall. In addition, the wings generate strong vortices that may adversely interact
with the tails causing the missile to roll. This behavior is known as induced roll, and
if the effect is strong enough, the control system may not be able to compensate [3]
[10] [12]
c) Tail Control
As the name implies, these control surfaces are placed at the tail section of the
missile as shown in Figure 13. They are probably the most commonly used form of
missile control, particularly for longer range air-to-air missiles and surface-to-air
missiles. The primary reason for this application is because tail control provides
excellent maneuverability at the high angles of attack often needed to intercept a
highly maneuverable aircraft. Missiles using tail control are also often fitted with a
non-movable wing to provide additional lift and improve range. Some good
examples of such missiles are air-to-ground weapons as well as surface-to-surface
missiles [3] [10] [12].
Page 23
4. MISSILE PROPULSION
Propulsion is the means of providing power to accelerate the missile body and
sustain, if necessary, to reach the required target. The basis for the working of
missile propulsion systems are the well-known Newton's laws of motion [1].
First Law (law of inertia): - A body continues in its state of rest or in uniform
motion in a straight line unless acted upon by an unbalanced force.
Second Law: - The rate of change of momentum is proportional to the impressed
force and takes place in the direction of the force.
Third Law: - Action and reaction are equal and opposite. That is, if a body exerts a
force on another body, the other body too exerts a force on the first body of the
same magnitude but in the opposite direction.
The propulsion of a missile is achieved with the help of a rocket engine. It produces
thrust by ejecting very hot gaseous matter, called propellant. The hot gases are
produced in the combustion chamber of the rocket engine by chemical reactions.
The propellant is exhausted through a nozzle at a high speed. This exhaust causes
the rocket to move in the opposite direction (Newton's third law) [1].
As per the second law, also called the law of momentum, the rate of' change of
momentum causes a force to be developed. The change in momentum of the missile
body including the rocket motor casing, the nozzle and other systems due to the
ejected matter creates a force leading to the propulsive action on the missile body.
The missile, propelled into air, would continue to move if there were no other forces
acting on it. However, resistance to its forward movement due to air (commonly
called the aerodynamic drag) and the force of gravity acting downwards towards
the center of the earth are to be taken into account. By using Newton's first law
compensative forces are imparted to the missile to overcome these negative forces.
4.1 Types of missile propulsion
Missile propulsion will be mainly of the following two types [1] [9]
Non-air breathing, and
Air breathing
The air breathing rocket engines use the surrounding medium of air for the support
of their oxidizer. Thus, they can be used only within the Earth's atmosphere. In this
Page 24
case the advantage is taken of the atmospheric oxygen for burning the fuel thereby
reducing the quantity of propellants to be carried by a missile. This lowers the
weight of the rocket greatly as 75 per cent of the total propellant's weight is due to
the oxidizer. This can be used either by using small turbojet engines to power the
missile or ramjets [9].
In Non-air breathing engines the rocket engine itself carries its fuel and oxidizer on
board and hence can be used in space above the Earth's atmosphere also and is thus
independent of the air medium.
Depending on the physical state of matter of the propellant used, the non-air rocket
propulsion system is designated as [1] [9]
Solid propulsion,
Liquid propulsion, and
Hybrid propulsion.
Page 26
Strategies”, Middle East Technical University, Graduate School of Natural and Applied
Sciences.
[16] Berglund, E. , March 2000, “Guidance and Control Technology”, RTO SCI Lecture Series
on Technologies for Future Precision Strike Missile Systems, Atlanta, USA, pp. 1-10
[17] Daniel Perh, December 2 , “A Study into Advanced Guidance Laws using
Computational Methods”, B.S.M.E, National University of Singapore, 2007, Naval
Postgraduate School, Monterey, California.
[18] John CS, March 2 , “Missile Terminal Guidance and Control Against Evasive Targets”,
Monterey, California, Naval Postgraduate School.
[19] Yang, C. D., Hsiao, F.B. and Yeh, F. B. , March 1989, “Generalized Guidance Law for
Homing Missiles”, IEEE Transactions on Aerospace and Electronic Systems, Vol. AES-25,
No. 2, pp. 197-212
[20] Yang, C. D., Hsiao, F.B. and Yeh, F. B. , March 1989, “Generalized Guidance Law for
Homing Missiles”, IEEE Transactions on Aerospace and Electronic Systems, Vol. AES-25,
No. 2, pp. 197-212
[21] Doyle D. Knight, August 2 3, “Missile Aerodynamics and Air-to-Air Missile Codes”,
Rutgers - The State University of New Jersey, New Brunswick, New Jersey USA 08903,
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering.
[22] Zarchan, P. , 1994, Tactical and Strategic Missile Guidance, Vol. 157, Progress in
Aeronautics and Astronautics, AIAA, Washington DC
[23] Patrick Costello, March 995, “Simulink Simulation of Proportional Navigation and
Command to Line of Sight Missile Guidance”, Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey
California.
[24] Pastrick, H. L., Seltzer, S. M. and Warren, M. E. , March- April 1981, “Guidance Laws for
Short- Range Tactical Missiles”, Journal of Guidance and Control, Vol. 4, No. 2
[25] Daniel Perh, December 2 , “A Study into Advanced Guidance Laws using
Computational Methods”, B.S.M.E, National University of Singapore, 2007, Naval
Postgraduate School, Monterey, California.
Page 27