Creditcollection Chap2
Creditcollection Chap2
Joseph M. Jackson, CCE, Director - Corporate The cost of credit term must be given proper
Credit and Collection, Acme metals Inc. consideration. Among these are:
Riverdale, Illinois USA, 1994 Bureau of Business • Administrative cost in running the
Practice, USA. department;
• The cost of financing the accounts
Discounts are generally used to have an edge over
receivable;
competitors, to encourage customers to buy more.
• The credit losses due to delinquent or bad It's assumed that there is no change in the credit term
accounts; and also in the total sales. Bad debt losses are not
considered. Sales and competition are the motivation
Generally, the costs of offering credit are: for a contemplated change.
• Credit evaluation costs; which consists of A company sells on a term of 2/10; n/30. Under these
credit investigation and data processing terms, it's expected that 25% of the customers who
• Discounts in payment - Early payment obtained credit will pay on or before the 10th day, the
made by customers net of prompt payment rest will pay on the average, 50 days after the sale.
rebates lowers price without a corresponding The total amount of sales will not be affected by an
increase in volume. The discount or rebate increase or decrease in the sales volume.
availed of reduces the sales volume.
• Investment in Receivables - Alternative The present value of a day's sales under present
credit limits and credit terms will lead to policy thus:
varying receivable levels. Reduction in these
levels, may tree up capital.
• Collection Expenses - Includes cost of
following up accounts that do not pay on
time, as well as;
• Bad debt Expense - The timing and amount
of the bad debt write-off aggravates the cost
affecting credit policy.
The present value under the proposed policy is
PRESENT VALUE ANALYSIS OF smaller by P366 a day or P122,640 a year. The
CUSTOMER'S CREDIT present policy must be maintained.
A change in the credit line or term extended to Relation to Cost - Particularly with respect to
customers will affect cash flow. To arrive at a discount, terms are influenced by the same economic
decision, it is important to determine the present factors as prices. Whereas the seller should include
values to have cost-benefit comparison. the cash discount as a cost factor in his price
To begin with the direct and indirect cash flows calculations, buyers are constantly bargaining for
associated with any line and/or term policy both lower prices and higher discounts to reduce their
alternatives which are estimated and scheduled on a net costs. This pressure is clearly evident with regard
time line method. to prices, but is more subtly used by larger buyers to
establish discount terms or to increase the amount of
An opportunity cost is determined for discounting existing discounts in order to gain their objective. To
the difference, in the timing of cash flow. Said cost support their argument, such buyers often take the
should be based on the alternative use of the fund position that they must obtain the same discount
which generally is either short term investment rate terms from their suppliers as they are accustomed to
or the borrowing rate. offer their own customers. However, the buyer
should consider the fact that the discount he allows
The present value is computed for the net cash flow
of each of the alternatives under consideration. customers is based on the selling price, larger than
the discount he earns on purchases, which is based
The alternative with the biggest net present value is on cost price.
the one that may be chosen from a financial
viewpoint. The cash discount is to some extent a subterfuge, in
that it must in some way be recovered in the selling
For example: price. Consequently, prices in industries which use
discount terms are inflated by the amount of the
discount, since in computing prices it is generally
assumed that most customers will take advantage of legal tender qualities of the currency as well
the discount. Therefore, the advantage of lower cost as the acceptable prevailing exchange rate
usually referred to by the buyer is not as real as it between the foreign currency as against the
might seem. In fact, it can be assumed that net terms Philippine peso. The exchange rate to use
would result in lower prices, a system of pricing must always be the prevailing buying rate of
without discount allowances is more favorable to the the banks as of the date of conversion.
buyer because: (1) it permits a quick, accurate cost 2. CHECK - Checks owned by the debtor
calculation and comparison of prices from various and/or the co-debtor; or, for that matter by
suppliers; (2) it does not penalize him if he is unable other person offered in payment for the
to pay within the discount period; (3) it may reduce account of the debtor that does not affect or
his capital requirements, since net terms are likely to prejudice your money claim may be accepted
coincide more closely with his own average in payment for the debt. As much as possible
collection period and (4) it results in clerical and only current dated check for an obligation by
accounting conveniences. Despite these arguments, the debtor must be accepted. However, there
the larger, financially strong buyers are inclined to are instances where post dated checks may be
favor discounts terms, because they gain a accepted. In these cases, be certain to know
competitive advantage over those in their line who whose signature(s) are on the said check for
cannot earn discounts or who would find it difficult future reference in case of any legal action to
to do so. undertake against the drawer and signatories
thereon, if the check is dishonored.
Bank Financing - Bank financing permits a buyer to
3. PAYMENT IN KIND OR SERVICE - In
take advantage of discounts which he may otherwise
collecting payment for delinquent or bad
be unable to earn. Naturally it is to the advantage of
accounts receivable the probability of being
any company to maintain good banking relations, but
offered payment in kind or service is great if
this is particularly important when purchases are on
you consider that these accounts are
discount terms. The establishment of bank credit will
generally illiquid. In cases of payment of this
insure financial assistance when needed, so that
nature it is a business decision based on
income represented by earned discounts is not lost.
pragmatism whether or not to accept such
When transactions are on net terms, the buyer is less kind of payment. The matters to take into
likely to require bank financing a greater portion of consideration are the following:
the marketing period. In this case, the supplier rather a. Is the debtor really so distressed that
than the customer may need bank assistance. cash payment is not really possible?
b. Pricing of the thing or service;
ACCEPTABLE PAYMENTS c. Saleability or need of the thing or
Generally all credit or debts must be paid for within service;
the credit term generally in cash. There are occasions d. Tax consideration;
however that cash is not offered as payment but some e. Possibility of an expeditious turn
other form of settlement or payment is offered or around from the payment to liquid
made. In which case, it is important to be aware and cash.
appreciate some other kind and form of payment 4. PAYMENT FROM SURETY OR
specially for delinquent or bad accounts. Among GUARANTY PAYMENT BOND - Claim
these payments are; for performance or payment from surety or
guaranty payment bond must always be
1. CASH - Philippine currency or foreign preceded by a formal notice of claim against
currencies maybe accepted from the debtor or the surety or bonding company within the
from a third person in favor of the debtor. If period explicitly provided in the bond. Be
it's a foreign currency, it is imperative to certain that there is no reason or alibi that
determine the authenticity, genuineness and may have been done or used by the surety or
bonding company to delay, if not on totally Jointly and severally literally means that a person
avoid paying on their joint and several who agrees to be bound under such a mode, answers
obligation under the surety or guaranty personally and directly for the obligations created
payment bond. Extension of time to pay, under the contract.
adding additional condition or material
It also means "in solidium" or "one and the same" in
change in the nature of the obligation will
the obligation created.
generally affect collecting against a surety or
guaranty payment bond due to novation. This partakes of requiring a generally acceptable and
5. JOINT AND SEVERAL OBLIGOR creditworthy third party to be bound in joint-solidary
(DEBTOR) - An experienced creditor will status with the principal debtor, who will
always include the joint and several debtor(s) automatically be bound to pay the obligation whether
in all the notices, demand for payment as well or not he benefited from the credit or loan
as in any material alteration of the credit granted/proceeds thereof. A creditor will not want to
obligation to avoid and prevent unwitting have a third party -joint and several obligor from
novation of the main credit obligation. whom they cannot collect.
COLLATERAL POLICY A demand for payment or performance from the
principal obligor - debtor also necessitates a demand
Credit extension must never be motivated by the
against the co-obligor.
collateral offered by the credit applicant. Because, if
that be the rationale then the going concern paradigm 2. REAL ESTATE MORTGAGE
of business operation losses its meaning and purpose.
It must be borne in mind that credit is an instrument This refers to the conveyance of a real property as a
for economic development and the development of security for the payment of money or the
creditworthiness of the credit availor. performance of some other act, condition to become
null and void upon payment or performance of the
The economy to have dynamism must not be obligation created.
burdened by the "pawnshop mentally" that have
plagued the banking industry which now stymies the The property to be conveyed must be owned, and
availability of credit brought about by their acquired have a free disposal of the same by the party
assets or ROPOAs emanating from inordinate mortgaging the same or is duly authorized to do so.
negligence of granting and enforcing credit. THINGS TO CHECK ON REAL ESTATE
WAYS TO FORTIFY OR SECURE CREDIT MORTGAGE
There are many ways to secure or fortify a credit a. Verification of the authenticity and
granted. It is important for the creditor to realize that, genuineness of the torrens certificate of title
historically, the Philippine financial system has in the name of the owner- mortgagor, with the
always been in dire need of loanable funds. It is for Register of Deeds and Land Registration
this reason that our financial market has been Authority. This must include the positive
dubbed, rightly or wrongly, a "pawnshop, verification of liens and encumbrances
banking/financial market." thereon.
b. Appraisal, location and all the ancillary tasks
Any and all agreements to secure or collateralize a to determine the value, use and worthiness of
loan or credit is an accessory contract. the property.
c. Check the real property declaration and tax
Among the popular methods used to secure credit are
liabilities of the land with the local assessor's
the following:
and treasurer's office.
1. "JOINT AND SEVERAL," (SOLIDARY) d. Verify the inherent limitations of the
OBLIGATION alienability of the land, particularly those
granted to private individual from the public
domain (such as those granted under free, This is a new method of securing large amounts of
sales, lease patents with the DENR, DAR, credit and is resorted to in special cases, particularly
including those granted through the National in housing loan. syndication/consortium for big
Housing Act and similar agencies). infrastructure projects.
e. The contract of real estate mortgage must
The requirements of registration are substantially the
provide an attorney-in-fact provision with
same except in registration with the different
right of substitution in favor of the mortgagee
governmental agencies.
as a practical step in case of extra-judicial
foreclosure. The mortgage contract must 4. CHATTEL MORTGAGE
expeditiously be registered timely with the
Register of Deeds of the place where the A conditional sale of personal property as security for
property is located. the payment of a debt or the performance of some
f. The mortgaged property must be owned by other obligation specified; the condition being that
the person mortgaging. A third party's real the sale shall become null and void upon the
property may, however, be mortgaged by the seller/mortgagor paying to the purchase/mortgagee a
mortgagor, provided that, he has a valid, sum of money or doing some other act named.
genuine and effective special power of Any and all personal or movable property can be the
attorney authorizing him to do so. subject of a chattel mortgage. Due care and prudence
In this regard, due care and prudence must be must be exercised to ascertain and determine the
exercised to determine that the person who owns the legal and lawful ownership of the property
real property in fact gave and executed the special mortgaged because only property factually owned by
power of attorney in favor of the one mortgaging the the mortgagor can be mortgaged; except, when there
same; and that, he knows that it will be mortgaged to is a special power of attorney granted the mortgagor
secure a credit/loan for the benefit of the principal to mortgage a personal property of another. All
obligor/debtor. As much as possible, determine the chattel mortgage contracts must have an affidavit of
genuineness and authenticity of the signatures with good faith and express provision on the address of
the principal maker of the power; or the attorney the chattel mortgaged.
and/or the notary public who notarized the 5. PLEDGE
document. Request the notary to authenticate the
signatures on the power of attorney. Authentication A contract whereby a personal property is delivered
may be made by signing anew on the document to the creditor or a third person as a security for the
notarized beside their signatures. performance of an obligation.
g. After registration of the mortgage contract, it It is an accessory, real and unilateral contract upon
is wise and prudent to officially furnish the the fulfillment or payment of the debt, the property
parties to the contract with a copy of the with its fruits and accessories shall be returned to the
mortgage to inform them of the transaction debtor.
involving the property and to discuss any last Its requisites are:
minute reaction of the property owner.
a. It is constituted to secure the fulfillment of a
3. PARI-PASSU ARRANGEMENT principal obligation.
b. The pledgor must be the absolute owner of
It literally means; by the same priority. This is used the thing pledged.
by creditors who, marshalling assets are entitled to c. That the person or owner of the thing pledged
receive out of the same fund or asset without any has the free disposal of his property and in the
precedence of each other except as to the direct absence thereof, that he be legally authorized
proportion of their financial exposures in the credit to do so.
granted.
d. The thing pledged must be placed in the Being a real contract of purchase and sale, an
possession of the creditor or of a third person assignment of credit, or right, transfers the ownership
by common agreement. of the same to the assignee from the moment the
document evidencing such credit or right is delivered
The sale of the thing or property pledged for non-
to the assignee. Assignment may either be with or
performance or non-payment of the obligation erases
without recourse.
further liability to the principal debtor and/or pledgor
even if the proceeds of the sale of the pledged 9. ESCROW ARRANGEMENT
property is less than the debt claim. Collection of
An agreement whereby a deed or a contract, which
deficiency is not allowed.
may be coupled with monetary consideration, is
6. SURETY delivered to a mutually acceptable stranger or third
party with an obligation for the latter to deliver unto
A contract or an agreement whereby a party called
the party in whose favor the deed or agreement is
the surety guarantees the performance by another
made, upon the occurrence or performance of certain
party called the principal or obligor of an obligation
condition or obligation.
or undertaking in favor of a third party called the
obligee. It includes official recognizance, It is the performance of the obligation imposed
stipulations, bonds or undertakings issued. therein or the happening of a condition imposed, that
makes the contract valid in favor of the grantee.
The surety undertakes to pay if the principal does not
pay. A surety is the insurer of the debt. He is 10. LETTER OF CREDIT
conclusively deemed an original promissor without a
A written instrument from a bank directed to another
need of exhaustion of collection efforts against the
bank requiring that the latter bank allow the bearer of
principal. Hence, he is equally liable.
the letter of credit (LC) to buy commodities or
7. GUARANTY service or to want money (either to procure the same
or to pass his promise, bill or other engagement for
A contract whereby a person, called the guarantor,
it). The writer of the LC undertakes to give the
binds himself to the creditor to fulfill the obligations
money for the goods or service or to pay the bank to
of the principal debtor in case the latter fails to do so.
which the LC is addressed by exchange or to give
He is only liable if the principal cannot pay. The
such satisfaction as required.
guarantor's liability is secondary. The guarantor
cannot be held liable until and after exhaustion of all A letter of credit (LC) is basically a request directing
efforts to collect from the debtor is undertaken. someone to pay or give credit to, a third party and
promising to repay or guarantee the same. It is an
8. ASSIGNMENT
absolute undertaking to money advanced or the
An assignment of credit or right is fundamentally a amount for which credit is given upon the faith on
contract of sale. It has for its subject matter the credit the instrument.
or a right assigned; for consideration, the price paid
A person has sold goods to the one in whose favor
for the right; and for the consent, the agreement
the letter of credit was drawn taking his note
between the parties regarding the credit or right to be
therefore. The undertaking of the writer of the letter
assigned and the price to be paid thereof. It is
of credit is collateral to the promise of the vendee, as
perfected in the same manner as in a contract of sale.
security and is not liable to any contingencies except
An assignment of credit is, in a real sense, a contract that of gross negligence in securing the debt by
of purchase and sale. In an assignment of credit or a which the loss may be thrown upon the vendor.
right, there is a definite third person who is obliged,
11. TRUST RECEIPT FACILITY
whereas in sales, it is the whole world which is
obliged to respect the title of the buyer. An arrangement by virtue of which a banker or a
creditor advances money to a person for the purchase
of goods; the former taking full title of the goods at distinguished from an administrator who is given the
the very beginning and continuing to do so until he incidental power of disposal.
is paid; or, if the good has been sold, until the
proceeds ne bof the sale are turned over to him by the
buyer or his successors-in-interest.
It may also mean a security transaction to aid
importers, wholesalers and retailers of goods who do
not have sufficient funds or resources to finance the
importation of merchandise and, who may not be
able to acquire credit except through utilization as
collateral of the merchandise or goods imported.
12. HOLD-OUT AGREEMENT
A recent credit development that disallows any
withdrawal from the debtor's deposit with the
creditor, banking or financing institution during the
duration of the credit granted. It allows the creditor a
charge or debit to the account for any unpaid balance
of not the obligation.
13. SURETY BOND
It is substantially the same as a suretyship, except
that bonds are issued by non-life insurance and
bonding companies. It must be borne in mind that not
all insurance and bonding companies are capable of
fulfilling their obligations under the bonds. It is,
therefore, imperative that only those companies who
are duly authorized by the office of the Insurance
Commission and/or gent Supreme Court have
acceptable financial capacity to underwrite and pay
shall be used.
It must be remembered that a bonding company's
liability is co-terminus with the fulfillment or
payment of the obligation by the principal, and if
there be any changes, extension and the like in the
obligation, its consent and conformity be secured
prior to such amendment, changes and the like.
Claims on bonds are generally filed within 15 to 30
days from expiry thereof, otherwise, it cannot be held
liable.
14. TRUSTEESHIP ARRANGEMENT
A trustee is a person to whom confidence is reposed
as regards property for the benefit of another person.
The trustee is given the possession or custody of the
property without power to dispose the property as