Special Process
Special Process
*Corresponding author: Garima Rawat, MD Scholar, P.G Department of Rasa Shastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana, Uttarakhand
Ayurved University, Rishikul Campus Haridwar, India, Tel: 9634985613; Email: [email protected]
Abstract
Introduction: Kharpara is an ore of (Yashada) Zinc. In Ayurveda, a description of Kharpara (ore) and Yashada (extracted
metal from Kharpara) is also mentioned. Kharpara is a highly-negligible Rasa Dravya (Drug) in Ayurveda these days.
Aim & Objective: To find the description and importance of Karpara in Metallurgy and Ayurveda. Also, determine the
beginning era of extraction of Yashada from Karpara in ancient India.
Data Source: classical text of Rasa Shastra & allied branches and various online and offline research journals on Ayurveda &
Metallurgy.
Review Method: Word “Karpara” and “Rasaka” are used to search all aspects, such as types of categorizations among Rasa
Dravya, classification, pharmacological property, the process of Shodhana (Purification), Marana (Incineration), Satvapattana
(Extraction) and Grahyaagrahyatva (Acceptable-non acceptable qualities) of Kharpara is mentioned in Rasa Shastra texts and
Ancient Literature.
Result and Conclusion: Discovery of Pittala (Brass) brings a revolution in the metal industry because it diminished the use of
Kansya (Bronze). Pittala is an alloy of Copper and Zinc. But it is very difficult to answer which one is the real source of Zinc in
Brass, either Kharpara or Zinc Metal. Kharpara is an indirect source of three Bhasmas i.e., Yashada, Pittala and Varta (Bronze)
Thus, in this review study, every aspect of Kharpara is summarized such as the historic review, types, pharmacodynamic
properties, pharmaceutical processing of Karpara Bhasma procedures, dose and formulations of Kharpara from different
sources. The age of the beginning of Karpara used by Indians is not traceable.
Rawat G, et al. Kharpara, a Forgotten Mineral Drug of Ayurveda: A Review. Nat Ayurvedic Med 2022, Copyright© Rawat G, et al.
6(3): 000358.
3
Journal of Natural & Ayurvedic Medicine
production of zinc. Findings of radiocarbon dating conform in north Rajasthan, a copper spearhead was found containing
activity belongs to a period of the 12th and 18th century. only 3.4% of zinc [19] The archaeological record indicates
that in the 2nd BC the percentage of zinc started increasing
Comparison of Findings of Study and Rasa and intentional use of brass appears on the scene. In Taxila
Shastra Procedure (Now, in Rawalpindi of Pakistan), a large variety of metal
objects including those copper, bronze, brass and iron [20].
• Seven distillation furnaces square-shaped having a size Several brass objects datable from the 4th century BC to
of 66x69 cm was discovered. Two-chambered furnaces, 1st century AD have been discovered. Evidence of real brass
separated by a thick perforated plate of clay into upper was discovered recently at Senuwar in the Ganga Valley. Since
and lower. The firing temperature was also recorded zinc could change the colour of copper and impart it a golden
based on the degree of verification and it was recorded glitter, it was preferred for making Hindu, Buddhist and Jain
at 1200-1250 “C [15]. This high heating arrangement or icons throughout the historical period.
device was used for Satvapatan (metallurgical) propose
and it is mentioned as ‘Paatala Kosthi’ in Rasa Ratana This process is aimed at separating the metallic compound
Sammuchaya [16]. from the undesirable gangue and non-metallic inclusions in
• Brinjal-shaped earthen retorts, filled with charge, were the ore manual separation of non-metallic inclusions from
fixed on the perforated plate in an inverted position in the matrix. By doing this, sphalerite [(Zn, Fe) S] components
the upper chamber. Dimension of retorts, ranging from were separated which was easy to identify based on the
20 to 35 cm in length and 8 to 12cm in diameter. About colour. Roasting sphalerite to zinc oxide is represented in
36 retorts were arranged in each furnace for smelting this equation: 2ZnS + 3O2 = 2ZnO + 2SO2. Roasting was done
and they were heated for 3-4 hours. A retort was made on traditional fuels such as wood and charcoal fire until the
in two parts and luted together after filling the charge. odour of Gandhaka (sulphur) disappeared. The crushed ore
The retort is mentioned as ‘Vrintak Musa’ in Rasa Ratana was mixed with fresh cow dung and other substances, and
Sammuchaya [17]. after that shaped into balls. Finally, this ball-shaped chunk,
• The charge was prepared by crushing and grinding of which is basically the charge, was dried under a shade. After
ore and then mixed with some organic material and drying, the charge was finally ready for the smelting process.
cow dung. The mixture was rolled into tiny balls and
left under the sun for drying. These dried balls are then The temperature inside the retort was allowed to go up
kept in retorts after drying. The opening of the snout was to around 1100 “C for the reaction to be ZnO + CO: Zn + CO2
obstructed by a wooden match. A thin wooden stick was [21].
inserted in the narrow opening of retort, which perhaps
prevented the escape of charge before heating when Description of Kharpara in Rasa Shastra
they are initially inverted in the furnace and might also
facilitate the escape of zinc vapour formed after melting. Description of Kharpara like its categorization, type,
In Rasa Ratana Sammuchaya the three fundamental Shodhana (Purification of drug) [22], Marana (incineration
methods of zinc extraction from ore are described and of mineral or metal) [23] Stavapatan [24], doses, indication
a charge is a mixture of some herbs i.e Laksha, Guda, in diseases and, formulations are mentioned in Ayurvedic
Haritaki, Haridra etc, and borax. In the last method text viz, Rasarnava, Rasendra Chudamani, Rasa Prakash
some modification is described which is quite similar Sudhakara, Ananda Kanda, Ayurveda Prakasha, Rasa Ratna
to the aforesaid procedure explained by the team of Samucchaya, Brihad Rasa Raja Sundara, Rasa Jala Nidhi, Rasa
archaeologists. Tarangini, etc.
• This procedure is called ‘distillation of Zinc’ in
metallurgical science and Iatrochemistry the process It is stated in the classical book of Rasa Shastra, a well-
is known as ‘Karphara Satvapatan’. The appearance of versed person in the different procedures of Rasa Shastra is
extract has features similar to tin [18]. capable of making the Rasa (Mercury) and Kharpara (Ore
of Zinc) thermostable that can acquire the Siddhi (magical
The Analytical Finding of Ancient Artefact and power) to make that Dehavada & Lohavada like a slave [25].
Mining Debris
Categorization of Kharpara: Different authors have
Bronzes found in Harappan only have a few small given their opinion on the classification of Kharpara under
percentages of zinc. From Kalibangan, another Harappan site Maharasa and Uprasa, Swarnadi Varga, Rasa Varga.
Rawat G, et al. Kharpara, a Forgotten Mineral Drug of Ayurveda: A Review. Nat Ayurvedic Med 2022, Copyright© Rawat G, et al.
6(3): 000358.
4
Journal of Natural & Ayurvedic Medicine
Synonyms: Gobhadra, Kharpara, kshitikita, Rasodbhava, are found in Texts. In general, the classification of Kharpara
Kharpara, Netrarogari, Reetikrita, Kharpariyak, is based on the Grahya Lakshan (Acceptable features). One
yashadkarana, Tamraranjaka [3]; Chakshhushya, classification is based on external morphology and quality
Amritotpanna, Kharpari, Darvika, Tuttha, Kharparituttha, (i) Mritikabha, yellow in colour & soil like in consistency
Kharparitutthaka,Yashadopdhatu [37]; Kharpari, Tuttha and considered as best in quality. (ii) Gudabha, colour and
kharpari, Amritsambhava [33]; Tutthaka, Rasa tutthaka [35]; consistency are similar to Guda (jaggery) and are considered
Tutthakharparika [36]; Ritikrita and tamraranjaka [29]. as a medium in quality. (iii) Pashanabha, consistency is
similar to stone and considered as inferior in quality.
Vernacular names [41]: Hindi- Khapariya, Kharpar, Rasaka; Another classification is based on the appearance or sensory
English- Blackjack; Sanskrit- Kharpar; Bangoli- Kharpar; feeling on touch and its use. (i) Dardura is scaly in nature &
Marathi- Kalkhapari, Kalkhaparo; Panjabi-Khapariya; it is best for Satvapatana. (ii) Kaarvellaka is without Patra
Gujrati- Khapriyunkalu, Khapariyo. (scale) & it is good for medicinal use. A summarized view of
categorisation adopted in different texts is present in Table 2.
Bheda (Types) of Kharpara: Different types of classification
Type of Kharpara
Rasa Shastra Text
Numbers Name
1. Mritikabha Rasarnava [3],
3 2. Gudabha Rasendra sara sangraha [29],
3. Pashanabha and Rasamritam [42]
Ayurveda prakasha [30], Rasendra Chudamani [43],
1. Dardur Rasa-prakasha Sudhakar [2], Rasa-ratna Samuchchaya [1],
2
Rasa Taringini [38], Rasamritam [42],
2. Kaarvellaka Anandakanda [33], Rasendra Sambhava [40], Rasa Mitra [29]
1. Kharpara
3 Brihat rasa raja sundar [44]
2. Kalambuk
1. Pita
4 2. Krishna Brihat rasa raja sundar [44]
3. Rakta
Table 2: Types of Kharpara mentioned in the various text.
In the above table classification of Rasaka is based on as best in quality. (ii) Gudabha, colour and consistency are
the Grahya Lakshan (Acceptable features). One classification similar to Guda (jaggery) and are considered as a medium in
is based on external morphology and quality (i) Mritikabha, quality. (iii) Pashanabha, consistency is similar to stone and
yellow in colour & soil like in consistency and considered considered inferior in quality. Another classification is based
Rawat G, et al. Kharpara, a Forgotten Mineral Drug of Ayurveda: A Review. Nat Ayurvedic Med 2022, Copyright© Rawat G, et al.
6(3): 000358.
5
Journal of Natural & Ayurvedic Medicine
on the appearance or sensory feeling of touch and its use. is done according to some of the properties of the three
• Dardura is scaly & it is best for Satvapatana (Extraction) varieties of Rasaka [45].
• (ii) Kaarvellaka is without a scale (lamilaes) & it is good
for medicinal use. Mrittikabh- Zinc Carbonate-Smithsonite- (ZnCO3)
Gudabh- Zinc sulphide (ZnS)
Nowadays, it is quite difficult to procure Rasaka as per Pashanabh- Zinc oxide- Calamine- (ZnO).
the specifications stated in Rasashastra texts. So, to combat
this problem, the ores of zinc that are available in the present Rasa Panchank and Ayurvedic pharmacology of Kharpara is
era are taken as the types of Rasaka. This nomenclature mentioned in Table 3.
Rawat G, et al. Kharpara, a Forgotten Mineral Drug of Ayurveda: A Review. Nat Ayurvedic Med 2022, Copyright© Rawat G, et al.
6(3): 000358.
6
Journal of Natural & Ayurvedic Medicine
Vipaka of Kharpara is not mentioned in any text of Rasa mostly Rasa Dravya (Mineral, metal and herbal poisonous
Shastra. ingredient drugs of the formulation) need Shodhana. This
• Necessity of Purification: Administration of impure process removes the poisonous and deleterious effects
Kharpara leads to Vamana (nausea and vomiting) and present in them. In Rasa Shastra Different methods have
Bhranti (vertigo) [44]. been adopted for Shodhan of Kharpara by Acharyas and
• Shodhana of Kharpara (Method of purification): In summarized in Table 4.
general practice of Ayurvedic Pharmaceutical science
Duration
Principle followed Drugs used /Process Reference
repetition
Sharangdhar Samhita.[39] Brihat
Gomutra (Cow’s Urine) / Naramutra (Men’s Urine) 7 Days Rasa Raja Sundar [44] Yogratnakar
[47]
Nara mutra/ Gomutra/ Saindhava lavana yukta amla
3/7 Days Ayurveda prakash [30]
jala
Swedan in Dola
Yantra Nara mutra/ Khara mutra 7 Days Rasa manjari [32]
Gomutra 3 hr Rasa Pradeep [48]
Mutra Varga 7 Days Arka Prakash [49]
Rasa Tantra & Sara Sidhaprayog
Gomutra 7Days
Sangrah [50]
Rawat G, et al. Kharpara, a Forgotten Mineral Drug of Ayurveda: A Review. Nat Ayurvedic Med 2022, Copyright© Rawat G, et al.
6(3): 000358.
7
Journal of Natural & Ayurvedic Medicine
Bhavana
Respectively Kshar varg, Tail Varg & Amla Varga Rasa Hridaya Tantra [28]
(Levigation)
Dipping Gomutra 7 times Siddha Yoga Sangrah [53]
Dipping Gomutra/Naramutra 7 Days Rasa Pradeep [48]
Table 4: Different summarized textual methods of Kharpara Shodhana.
• Special function of Kharpara: Rasendra Chudamani Parada, Shudha Tamra, Shudha Rajata into golden yellow
has mentioned in his book, that when Kharpara is kept [43].
in Nara Mutra (Men’s Urine) for one month it acquires • Kharpara Marana (Incineration of Kharpara):
a special property that converts the colour of Shudha Methods of Kharpara Marana is categorized in Table 5.
Rawat G, et al. Kharpara, a Forgotten Mineral Drug of Ayurveda: A Review. Nat Ayurvedic Med 2022, Copyright© Rawat G, et al.
6(3): 000358.
8
Journal of Natural & Ayurvedic Medicine
Steps- 1. Laksha, Guda, Rayi, Harad, Haridra, Raal, & Tankana triturated with an equal amount of
Kharpara
Ayurveda prakash 2. boil with cow’s milk & made into a ball
[30]
3. Confined in Brintaka musha
• Resemblance of Satva- Vanga Sadrusha
I Steps- 1. An equal amount of Kharpara, Laksha, Guda (Jaggery), Haritaki, Haridra, Alsi (Linum
usitatissium), Rala & Tankana grind together.
2. Put it in Andha musha & subjected to heat.
• Resemblance of Satva- Yashada Sadrisha
Rasa Tarangini [38] II Steps- 1. Take Laksha, Haritaki, Haridra, Alsi, Guda (Jaggery), Rala & Tankana & mix it properly with
Kharpara.
2. Heated it with cow’s milk & Ghee & made it into a ball
3. Put it in Brintaka musha & subjected to heat
4. Resemblance of satva- Yashad sadrisha.
I Steps- 1. Kharpara & ¼ part of Haridra, Triphala, Rala, Grihadhuma, Tankana,
Rasa Ratna Bhallataka(Semecarpus Anacardium) triturated with Amla rasa & made into a paste
Smuchchaya [1]
2. Coating the paste in the inner surface of Brintaka Musha.
3. When dried, the Musha is to be covered & placed on the mouth of another Musha, subjected to heat
until Kharpara gets smelted.
• Resemblance of Satva- Vanga sadrisha.
II Steps- 1. Kharpara discharges its essence if mixed with Haritaki, Laksha, Earthworm, Haridra,
Grihadhuma, Tankana & heated by means of Muka Musha or Andh Musha.
Rasajala nidhi [52]
III Steps- 1. Laksha, Guda, Rayi (Mustered), Harad, Haridra, Rala & Tankana are powdered by mixing
them with Kharpara,
2. Boil it with cow’s milk & ghee & make a ball.
3. then put that ball in Brintaka Musha & subjected to heat.
4. Strike the Musha on a stone.
• Resemblance of satva- Vang sadrisha
Steps- 1. Kharpara Swedana in kulatha kwatha for 3 hours.
2. Mardana with-
Rasa Chinta mani i. ¼ part Paan patra kalka & Vata praroh swarasa
[54] ii. ¼ part Guda & Tankana+ Triphala kwatha
1 Make a ball & put it in the Musha for subjected to heat.
• Resemblance of Satva- Naga sadirsha.
Steps- 1. Kharpara & ¼ part Shudha Manhshila, Haridra churna, Triphala churna, Grihadhuma,
Saindhava, Bhallataka, Tankana, all Kshara, & Amla.
Rasa Prakash 2. made a ball & put it in Brintaka Musha
Sudhakar [2] 3. This musha is kept on another musha, & subjected to heat
4. Casting a musha on a stone.
• Resemblance of satva- Seesopamam.
Rawat G, et al. Kharpara, a Forgotten Mineral Drug of Ayurveda: A Review. Nat Ayurvedic Med 2022, Copyright© Rawat G, et al.
6(3): 000358.
9
Journal of Natural & Ayurvedic Medicine
Steps- 1. Take 1part Kharpara & ¼ part Jayanti (Sesbania sesban) Patra churna, Triphala churna,
Haridra churna, Guda, Tankana.
2. Take 2 musha.
Anandakanda [33]
3. Do the Rsakadipishti lepa in 1 musha & keep the 2nd musha empty, with holes
4. Do the Sandhi Bandhan & Paka by Patalyantra methods
5. Satva of Kharpara is collected in the musha placed below
Rasendra Steps- 1. Mix Haritaki, Laksha, Bhunaga, Haridra, Grihadhuma, Tankana & Kharpara altogether.
Sambhava [40] 2. Put the above mixture in Muka Musha & subjected to heat.
Steps- 1- Kharpara triturated with Kshara, Sneha & Amla dravya
Rasendra Mangal 2. Mix it with wool, Laksha, Haritaki, Grhadhuma & Tankana
[55] 3. put the mixture in muka musha & subjected to heat.
4. Resemblance of Satva- Kutila Sadrisha
Table 6: Different summarized textual methods of Kharpara Satvapatana (Metallurgy).
• Kharpara Satva Marana: Put the Kharpara & Hartala add a little amount of fine powder of Hartala in it & stir with
in equal amounts in the pan, keep it on the fire & keep a ladle [38].
stirring it with laohadanda. In this way, Kharpara satva
Bhasma is formed [1,2]. • Kharpara amayika prayoga: Amayika prayoga means
Took 1 pala (48gm) Kharpara satva in the pan & subjected dose and indication of drug. The Dose, adjuvant, and
to heat. When the Sattva melts, stirring it with a ladle, while indication of Kharpara Bhasma is illustrated in Table 7.
Matra of Kharpara Bhasma [38]: 1/2- 2 Ratti (appearance of Tin). Satva merely indicates the color and
Kharpara Viakara Shanti Upaya [44] - Gomutra for 7 days. appearance of Zinc. Pittala or Brass, an alloy of Zinc is used
Kharpara Yoga [56] (Formulation of Kharpara Bhasma)- since the 2nd century while the description of Kharpara
is obtained from the 10th century, and its extract of it is
Mahajwarankusha rasa called “Karpara Satva”. In Rasa Ratana Sammucaya, a 13th-
Basant Malti Rasa century book, the word Ritikrita (constituents of Brass),
LaghuBasant Malti Rasa Tamraranjaka (impart colour to copper), both words self-
Lakshmi Vilasha Rasas explored that Karpara is used in the preparation of Brass
[57]. The word Yashada is first time found in the 15th-century
Discussion book, Madanpal nighantu. But the Elemental analysis of
material shows that Brass made by Indian metallurgists has
Yashada or Zinc is obtained by the Satvapattan of 18 to 34 percent of zinc. Such a high quantity of Zinc is only
Kharpara (extract). Satava of Kharpara has Vangakriti
Rawat G, et al. Kharpara, a Forgotten Mineral Drug of Ayurveda: A Review. Nat Ayurvedic Med 2022, Copyright© Rawat G, et al.
6(3): 000358.
10
Journal of Natural & Ayurvedic Medicine
infused when pure zinc is used instead of Zinc ore. Therefore, Kasahya; Guna is Laghu, Sheeta & Ruksha; Sheeta in Virya and
it is a quite surprising fact that Satava or extract of Kharpara Kapha-pitta samaka in nature. Its Bhasma is made by Both
ie. Yashada is known in the community of iatrochemistry but Kuppipakwa (heating in an open pot) and putta (heating
Kharpara is not. in a closed pot) Methods. The practice of Kharpara Bhasma
preparation has been declined due to many reasons but it is
Zinc is used in Brass for the purpose of value addition mentioned in various diseases in Classical texts.
in copper. Brass is superior in metallic property and
appearance. Zinc improves the colour, tensile strength, References
ductility, malleability and glitters and reduces the corrosion
of ferrous metals. Additionally, it is easy to cast, recast and 1. Shastri KSA (2015) The Suratnojjvala Hindi Commentary
mold [58]. Thus, this might be the possible reason that on Rasaratna Samuchchaya of Sri Vagbhatacharya.
earlier metallurgists replace the Tin by Zinc in making a Chapter 2, Verse 1-161, Chaukhamba Amarabharati
much better alloy of copper. The Classification of Pittala in Prakashan, pp: 39-61.
Rasa Shastra is based on colour-changing property of Pittala
after quenching in Kanjika (Sour gruel). 2. Mishra SN (2013) Siddhiprada Hindi Commentaries on
Rasaprakash Sudhakar by Acharya Yashodhar. Chapter
Among all Dravyas of Maharasa, Uprasa & Sadharana 5, Verse 2-120, Chaukhambha Orientalia, Varanasi, pp:
Rasa, Bhasma of Kharpara [Incinerated formulation, Calyx] 90-110.
is only made by Kupipakwa (Baking of drug in a glass bottle
3. Tripathi I (2001) Rasachandrika Hindi Commentary on
by indirect heat) and Puta (Baking of drug in an earthen
Rasarnavam, Saptam Patal. Verse 2-38, Chawkhamba
pot) method. In one of the Kupipakwa methods, Kharpara
Sanskrit Series office, Varanasi pp: 86-92.
is mixed with Parada (Mercury). Parada Bhasma & other
preparation of Parada are made by Kupipakwa method by 4. Jha ChB (2006) Ayurvediya Rasa Shastra. Chapter 7,
using Kajjali [Black Sulphide of Mercury], a mixture of Parada Chaukhambha Subharati Prakashan, Varanasi, pp: 298.
and Gandhaka (Sulfur).
5. Mishra GS (1987) Arthavidyotini & Arthaprakasini
Kharpara comes under the group of Maharas Varga Sanskrit & Hindi commentaries on Ayurveda Prakash by
which is described by most of the texts of Rasashastra Acharya Sri Madhava. Chapter 3, Chaukhambha Bharati
while Some Acharyas had described it under Uparasa, Academy Varanasi, India.
Dhatu-Updhatu. Swarnadi Varga etc. It has a wide range of
therapeutic applications including in diseases like Prameh, 6. Raghunandan RK, Dhruva Rao BK and Singhal ML (1981)
Stree Roga, Pandu, Netra Roga, Yoniroga, Kasa, Shwasa, Jwara Exploration for copper, lead and Zinc ore in India. Bulletin
etc [5]. of the Geological Survey of India, Series – E economic
Geology, no 47, Calcutta.
Nirvapa is the commonest amongst the many Samanya 7. Jha ChB, (2018) Ayurvediya Rasashastra. Chapter 6,
Shodhana procedures of Kharpara. In this process hardness Chowkhambha subharati prakashan, Varanasi, pp: 240.
of the metal gets reduced and it becomes more brittle due to
repeated heating and quenching. 8. Charak Samhita Chikitsa sthana Kushtha Chikitsa.
Chapter 7, pp: 108-110,
Conclusion
9. Tripathi I (2010) Dravyagunaprakashika Hindi
Karpara is known to Indian metallurgists since Bronze Commentary on Rajanighantu of Pandit Narhari,
Age, but it is impossible to find the date of its conversion into Suvarnadi Varga. Verse 103, Chowkhamba Krishnadas
Zinc due to the absence of rigid poof. In the medieval age, the Academy, Varanasi, pp: 449.
production of zinc in India is stated in the Udaipur District of
Rajasthan State. Here so many remnants of retorts, furnaces, 10. Jha ChB (2006) Ayurvediya Rasa Shastra. Chapter 6,
Mining and smelting equipment are present on the bank Tiri Chaukhambha Subharati Prakashan, Varanasi, pp: 230.
River. Indian Metallurgist begins the high percentage of Pittala
11. Mishra SN (2015) Ayurvediya Rasa Shastra.
(Brass) production before the 13th century. Thus, it is very
Chaukhambha Orientalia, Varanasi, pp: 345.
mysterious to know the exact time of Karparasatvapattan. In
Rasa Shartra it is an equally important drug as mercury. Various 12. Kangle RP (1972) The Kautilya Arthasastra. Vol II, Motilal
pharmaceutical procedures are mentioned in many classical Banarasidas, Delhi, India.
books. Kharpara is kept in so many classes e.g., Maharasa,
Uprasa, Dhattu and Updhattu etc. Its Rasa (Taste) is Kattu- 13. Kharakwal JS, Gurjar LK (2006) Zinc and Brass in
Rawat G, et al. Kharpara, a Forgotten Mineral Drug of Ayurveda: A Review. Nat Ayurvedic Med 2022, Copyright© Rawat G, et al.
6(3): 000358.
11
Journal of Natural & Ayurvedic Medicine
Archaeological Perspective. Ancient Asia 1: 139-159. 26. Mishra SN (2015) Siddhiprada Hindi Commentary on
Bhaisajya Ratnavali of Kaviraja Govind das Sen. Verse 15,
14. Craddock PT, Freestone IC, LK Gurjar A. Middleton, Chaukhamba Surbharati Prakasan, Varanasi, pp: 29.
Willies L (1989) The Production of Lead, Silver and
Zinc in Early India, In: Hauptmann A (Eds.), Old world 27. Sharma SK, Rasabindu, Chapter 6. Mukesh printing
Archaeometallurgy. Selbstverlag des Deutschen press, Rohatak, pp: 91.
Bergbau- Museums, Bochum, pp: 51-69.
28. Rasasastri DR (2014) Mugdhava Bodhini Commentary
15. Tite MS, Freestone LC, Meeks ND, Craddock PT (1985) on Rasahrdaya Tantram of Caturbhuja Misra. Avabodh
The Examination of Refractory Ceramics from Metal- 9, Verse 4, Chaukhambha Publishers, Varanasi, pp: 127.
Production and Metalworking Sites. Archaeologist and
the Laboratory, Council of British Archaeology, London: 29. Sharma TN (2001) RasaMitra. Chowkhamba Sanskrit
Research Report 58, pp: 50-55. Series Office, Varanasi, pp: 58-83.
16. Shastri KSA (2015) The Suratnojjvala Hindi Commentary 30. Mishra GS (1987) Arthavidyotini & Arthaprakasini
on Rasaratna Samuchchaya of Sri Vagbhatacharya. Sanskrit & Hindi commentaries on Ayurveda Prakash
Chapter 10, verse 39-42, Chaukhamba Amarabharati by Acharya Sri Madhava. Chapter 2, Verse 1-293,
Prakashan, pp: 179. Chaukhambha Bharati Academy Varanasi , India, pp:
251-330.
17. Shastri KSA (2015) The Suratnojjvala Hindi Commentary
on Rasaratna Samuchchaya of Sri Vagbhatacharya. 31. Mishra SN (2003) Savimarsa Rasavidyotini Hindi
Chapter 10, Verse 23-24, Chaukhamba Amarabharati Commentary on Rasendra Sara Sangrah by Dr Indradeva
Prakashan, pp: 177. Tripathi. Chapter 1,Verse 118, Chaukhambha Orientalia,
Varanasi.
18. Shastri KSA (2015) The Suratnojjvala Hindi Commentary
on Rasaratna Samuchchaya of Sri Vagbhatacharya. 32. Mishra SN (2003) Siddhiprada Hindi Translation on
Chapter 2, Verse 155-156, Chaukhamba Amarabharati Rasa Manjari by Acharya Shalinath. Chapter 3, Verse 1
Prakashan, pp: 61. and 76, Chaukhambha Orientalia, pp: 23-39.
19. Lal BB, Joshi JP, Thapar BK, Madhubala (2003) 33. Mishra SN (2018) Siddhiprada Hindi Translation on
Excavations at Kalibangan the Early Harappans. Anandakanda, Pratham Ullas. Verse 5-249, Chaukhambha
Archaeological Survey of India, Delhi. Orientalia, Varanasi, pp: 641-672.
20. Marshall, Sir John (1951) Taxila an Illustrate Account of 34. Sharma PV (2005) Dhanvantari Nighantu, Mishrakadi
Archaeological Excavations. Vol. II, Minor Antiquities, Gana. Verse 88, Chaukhambha Orientalia, Varanasi, pp:
University Press, Cambridge, USA, pp: 564-571. 276.
21. Kanungo AK, Raviteja K, Roy O, Kharakwa JS (2020) 35. Chunekar KC (2020) Svimarsha Hindi commentary on
Understanding Ancient Zinc Technology: An Bhavprakasha Nighantu of Bhavamishra, Dhatvadi varga.
Experimental Study. Man and Environment 45(2): 87-94. Verse 68-151, Chaukhamba Bharatia academy, Vranasi,
pp: 598-602
22. Sharma S, Shastri K (1979) Rasa Tanrangini. 11th(Edn.),
Chapter 2, Verse 52, Motilal Banarasidas, New Delhi, pp: 36. Tripathi I (2010) Dravyagunaprakashika Hindi
22. Commentary on Rajanighantu of Pandit Narhari,
Suvarnadi Varga. Verse 103-104, Chowkhamba
23. Meena PM (2020) Ayurvediya Rasa shastra. Chapter 2, Krishnadas Academy, Varanasi, pp: 449.
Jagadeesh Sanskrita Pustakalaya, Jaipur, pp: 61.
37. Daas KK (1981) Shaligram Nighantu, Dhatu-updhatu
24. Shastri KSA (2015) The Suratnojjvala Hindi Commentary varga. Shri vainkateshwar steam press, Mumbai, pp:
on Rasaratna Samuchchaya of Sri Vagbhatacharya. 551- 552.
Chapter 5, Verse 36, Chaukhamba Amarabharati
Prakashan, pp: 152. 38. Sharma KN (2009) Rasatarangini. Chapter 21, Verse
181-214, Motilal Banarasidas, New Delhi, pp: 553-560.
25. Shastri KSA (2015) The Suratnojjvala Hindi Commentary
on Rasaratna Samuchchaya of Sri Vagbhatacharya. 39. Shrivastava S (2017) Jiwanprada Hindi Commentary on
Chapter 2nd, Verse 143-145, Chaukhamba Amarabharati Sharangdhar Samhita of Acharya Sharangdhar. Chapter
Prakashan, pp: 59. 11, Madhyam Khanda, Verse 53-76, Chaukhambha
Rawat G, et al. Kharpara, a Forgotten Mineral Drug of Ayurveda: A Review. Nat Ayurvedic Med 2022, Copyright© Rawat G, et al.
6(3): 000358.
12
Journal of Natural & Ayurvedic Medicine
40. Dwivedi VN (1997) Rasendra Sambhava. Verse 421-490, 49. Tripathi I (2015) Hindi Teeka on Arka prakasa of
Krishnadas Academy, Varanasi, pp 163-174. Lankapati Ravana, Dasham Shatakam, Dasham. Verse 87,
Chowkhamba Krishnadas Academy, Varanasi pp: 170.
41. Daas KK (1981) Shaligram Nighantu, Dhatu-updhatu
varga. Shri vainkateshwar steam press, Mumbai pp: 552. 50. Singh TN (2000) Rasa tantra Sara & Siddhaprayog
Sangrah, Pratham Khand. Krishna Gopal Ayurveda
42. Joshi D (2003) English translation of Rasamritam Bhavan, Ajmera, pp: 34-85.
of Vaidhya Jadavji Trikamji Acharya. Chaukhambha
Sanskrit Sansthan, Varanasi pp: 86-89. 51. Mishra SN (2006) Rasendra Chintamani by Acharya
Dunduk Nath. Chapter 7, Verse 98, Chaukhambha
43. Mishra SN (2017) Siddhiprada Hindi Translation on Orientalia, Varanasi, pp: 103.
Rasendra Chudamani by Acharya Somdeva. Chapter 10,
Chaukhambha Orientalia, Varanasi, pp: 160-163. 52. Mookerjee B (1984) Rasa-Jala-Nidhi. Chapter 1, Volume
2, Srigokul Mudranalaya, Varanasi, pp: 118-126.
44. Chaubay DR (1998) Brihat Rasa Rasa Sundar (Apurva
Rasagrantha). Moti Lal Banarasidas Publishers, Delhi, 53. Tikramji Y (2006) Siddha Yoga Sangrah. Shri Vaidhnaath
pp: 118-122. Ayurveda Bhavan Ltd, Calcutta, India, pp: 163.
45. Jha ChB (2018) Ayurvediya Rasashastra. Chapter 6, 54. Mishra SN (1990) Siddhiprada- Hindi commentary on
Chowkhambha subharati prakashan, Varanasi, pp: 239. Rasachintamani by Acharya- Anantadev Soori, Verse
124-127, Chaukhambha Orientalia, Varanasi, India, pp:
46. Acharya VT (1988) Rasakamdhenu compiled by 78-79.
Vaidhyavara Sri Cudamani, Dvitiya Dhatusangrahpaade
Tritiya Adhikaar. Chaukhambha Orientalia, Varanasi, pp: 55. Sharma PV (2003) Rasendra Mangala. Chapter 2, Verse
264-268. 32-33, Chaukhambha Orientalia, Varanasi, India, pp: 38.
47. Shastri SLP (2005) Vidhyotini Hindi Tika on Yoga 56. Mishra SN (2005) Rasapaddhati. Verse 225-227,
Ratnakara. Verse 1-2, Chaukhambha Prakashan, Chaukhambha orientaliya, Varanasi, India, pp: 180.
Varanasi, pp: 148.
57. Jha ChB (2018) Ayurvediya Rasashastra. Chapter 6,
48. Mishra SN (2013) Rasa Pradeep, Dhatwadi Bhasma Chowkhambha subharati prakashan, Varanasi, pp: 239.
Nirman Vidhi. Verse 254, Chaukhambha Orientalia,
58. Brass
Rawat G, et al. Kharpara, a Forgotten Mineral Drug of Ayurveda: A Review. Nat Ayurvedic Med 2022, Copyright© Rawat G, et al.
6(3): 000358.