Module13 Grounding Part I
Module13 Grounding Part I
2
Learning Objectives
3
Agenda Overview
1. System grounding
2. Equipment grounding
3. Lightning Protection
4. Static Protection
5. Ground Grid Systems Design
6. Grounding of instrumentation systems
7. Substation grounding
4
History of Grounding
Edison’s Pearl Street Generation Station
6
Edison’s Floating Approach to DC Systems
7
Human Sensitivity to Electricity
8
Human Sensitivity to Electricity
Painful Shock – 62 41 9 6
Muscular Control Loss
Severe Shock – 90 60 23 15
Breathing Difficult
9
Edison's’ Isolated 3 Wire System
10
Shock Current Path
Isolated Ground
System
No Shock Current Exists
11
Shock Current Path
G1 L
Neutral
Fuse
G1 L
Neutral Alternate circuit path
leads to shock hazard
12
The Intentional Grounding of Circuits
13
History of Grounding - Continued
Q Later resolved that grounding the secondary circuit was the only
way of absolutely insuring the safety of the circuit
• The debate continued from 1903 – 1913 when it was passed into law
– Secondaries of all circuits 550V or less must be grounded
– Recommended that all circuits 300V or less be grounded
14
Grounding - Today
Q Mandated in both the CEC and NEC that all two wire DC
power systems 300V or less and all three wire DC power
systems are grounded
Q All AC power systems 150V or less to ground or those
incorporating a neutral conductor be grounded
Q All ungrounded systems must incorporate ground fault
protection
15
References
Canadian Electrical Code - Part 1
CSA C22.1-06
17
Canadian Electrical Code - Part 1
CSA C22.1-06
18
Canadian Electrical Code - Part 1
CSA C22.1-06
19
Canadian Electrical Code - Part 1
CSA C22.1-06
20
Canadian Electrical Code - Part 1
CSA C22.1-06
21
CEC Handbook
22
IEEE Color Book Series
23
IEEE Standard 142
(Green Book)
24
IEEE Standard 1100
(Emerald Book)
25
IEEE Standard 80
Q IEEE Standard 80
• IEEE Guide for Safety in AC
Substation Grounding
– Defines the safe limits for
touch and step potentials
– Provides guidance on the
design of ground systems for
outdoor substations
– Primarily used by utilities for
grounding on high voltage
substations
26
IEEE Standard 81
27
API RP 2003
28
NFPA 780
29
NFPA 77
30
Definitions
Definitions
32
Definitions
33
Definitions
34
Definitions
Metallic
Enclosure
Neutral Ground
Device
Bonding Conductor
Grounding Stray Current
Conductor
Grounding
Electrode Earth
35
Definitions
Systems
PP Ground 4
36
Systems Grounding
Purpose of a Systems Ground
38
System Grounding Classifications
39
Ungrounded
Q Advantages
• Single ground fault does not does not allow current to flow
– Allowed for a controlled shutdown for fault repairs
Q Disadvantages
• On a ground faults, the voltage to ground for the remaining phases is
elevated by 73%
– Higher insulation rating required for system components
• Transient overvoltages can be a problem
– Voltages up to 6X system voltage stresses insulation eventually leading to
a second ground fault and subsequently a phase to phase fault
• Locating a ground fault can be difficult
40
Ground Fault Voltage Shift
A VAG
IA IA IB
N VCG VBG
IC
B C B
IB
C
IC
A
CA CB CC VCN VAN
N
VAG
VCA VAB
G VCG
N G
VBN
VBG
41
Ground Fault Voltage Shift
IG
VAG
A
IB
IA
IA
B
N C G VCG=0 VBG
B
IB VAN
C VBN N
A
IG CA CB
VCN VCA
VAB
VAG
G IA + IB = IG N
VCG=0
C VBC B
G VBG
42
Intermittent Ground Faults
N
B
IB
C Breakdown in insulation
IG CA CB
results in phase to phase
fault IG = ISC
G
43
Ungrounded System
Ground Fault Detection Scheme
10-106 Alternating-current systems (see Appendix B)
(2) Wiring systems supplied by an ungrounded supply shall
be equipped with a suitable ground detection
device to indicate the presence of a ground fault.
Ground
Fault Light Dims
L L L 0V
Or
Extinguishes
45
Solid Ground
Q Advantages
• Partially reduces the problem of transient over-voltages
– Reduced insulation level required
• Ground faults do not shift the system neutral
• Simple ground relay schemes provide for circuit protection
Q Disadvantages
• Damage at the fault may be excessive
• Arc flash hazard due to high ground fault current levels
• Arcing ground faults may not be of sufficient energy to clear the fault resulting in
equipment damage
N
B
O/C fuse may not C
clear arcing ground fault IG VAN
VBN N
VCN
G 46
High Resistance Ground
47
High Resistance Ground Scheme
51G AL
1000 KVA Xfmr
25kV – 600V
Y 2 Amp 5.75% Z
NGR
NGR Pulsing Resistor
2A
13 MCP
Pulsing reading Clamp
on phase indicates On CT 45kVA 75kVA
14
M M M X2
U/H
LP X2 HTP
150HP 75HP 25HP
Cooling Recycle Injection
Ground Fan Lighting 30kW Heat Trace Pump Pump
Panel Unit
Fault Heater
Panel
48
Low Resistance Ground
49
Low Resistance Ground Scheme
Y
2A NGR 600V
M M
50
NGR Sizing Criteria
VLL
RNGR =
√3IG
XCO
RNGR ≤
3
51
IG ≥ 3ICO
NGR
IG WNGR = IG2RNGR
51
Neutral Grounding Transformers
52
NGR Sizing Criteria
Secondary Ground Resistor
RNGR
RSGR =
N2
VLN(Pri)
51 N=
VLN(Sec)
XFMR SGR
ISGR = NIG
54
Charging Current – More Detailed Analysis
System Component Type Typical Charging
Voltage Current
600V Cable 3/C - 250 – 500MCM 0.15A/1000ft
3/C - #1 – 4/0AWG 0.02A/1000ft
Transformers 0.02A/MVA
Motors 0.01A/1000HP
4160V Cable 3/C - 500–1000MCM Shielded 0.58A/1000ft
3/C – 1/0 – 350MCM Shielded 0.23/1000ft
Non Shielded 0.1A/1000ft
Transformers 0.05A/MVA
Surge Suppressor. 1.35A per Set
Motors 0.1A/1000HP
13800V Cable 3/C - 600–1000MCM Shielded 0.65A/1000ft
3/C – 250 – 350MCM Shielded 0.75/1000ft
3/C - #1 – 4/0AWG Shielded 0.65A/1000ft
Transformers 0.05A/MVA
Surge Suppressor 2.25A per Set
Motors 0.15A/1000HP
55
Charging Current Test Procedure
Q Connect an ammeter to
A ground through a
resistance, switch and a
IA
fuse
N
B
Q Increase the resistance to
IB maximum level and close
C the disconnect
IC A Ammeter
CA CB CC 0-10A Q Slowly reduce the
resistance to zero
• Ammeter will indication
charging current (3ICO)
G
Q All three phases should be
measured and the average
used as the system
charging current
56
NGR Ratings
57
NGR Ratings
Class BIL
1.2kV 45
2.5kV 60
5kV 75
8.7kV 95
15kV 100
23kV 150
58
NGR Ratings
Q Ground Return
• Ground fault current is
measured in the neutral to
ground connection Phase A
• Applicable only at a source
transformer or generator Neutral
60
Ground Fault Sensing
51G
61
Ground Fault Sensing
Q Differential
• Phase current and neutral current
values are measured and ground
fault current is calculated as the
difference Phase A
62
Ground Fault Relay Settings
63
CEC Code Requirements
64
CEC Code Requirements
65
NGR with Isolated System Neutral
A
Trip main breaker HT
Ckt
HT
Ckt
HT
Ckt
N
HT HT HT HT
Ckt Ckt Ckt Ckt
51 B
C
NGR
Rule 10-1102 requires the system to
IG be de-energized on detection of
ground current
66
CEC Code Requirements
67
CEC Code Requirements
68
CEC Code Requirements
69
Cable Insulation Ratings on Resistance
Grounded Systems
70
Grounding System Comparison
71
Equipment Bonding
System Grounding
73
Equipment Bonding
74
Bonding – CEC Requirements
75
Bonding Conductors
76
Bonding Conductors
Service Raceways
77
Bonding Conductors
Equipment and Raceways
78
Bonding Considerations
79 Cadweld Connection
Bonding of Conduit Enclosing a Grounding
or Bonding Conductor
Q Magnetic effect of metal conduit can increase the impedance of
the grounding circuit by a factor of 40!
• Not an issue with PVC or aluminium conduits
Q Problem can be mitigated by bonding the grounding conductor to
the metal conduit at both ends
• Allow the metal conduit to carry a portion of the ground current
• New CEC rule 10-806 makes this mandatory
80
Grounding of Portable Equipment
81
GFCI Schematic
82
Ground Fault Circuit Interrupters
Q GFCI Class A
• Primarily used for personnel protection
• Typically trip at 5ma
• Time to trip based on the formula
1.43
20 T in seconds
T= I I fault current between 4mA and 260 mA
83
GFCI – Where Required
Q Outdoor receptacles
Q Wet locations
Q Health care facilities
Q Panels supplying power for buildings or projects under
construction
Q Heat trace systems
84
Summary
Summary
86
Summary
87