The document discusses decision trees as a planning tool that allows managers to logically layout decision problems. It provides examples of decision trees for real estate property sale options, an company expanding into new locations, and a bicycle manufacturer considering growth options. The document also lists advantages of decision trees such as considering risks and enabling more objective decisions, and disadvantages like relying on estimates and not accounting for qualitative factors.
The document discusses decision trees as a planning tool that allows managers to logically layout decision problems. It provides examples of decision trees for real estate property sale options, an company expanding into new locations, and a bicycle manufacturer considering growth options. The document also lists advantages of decision trees such as considering risks and enabling more objective decisions, and disadvantages like relying on estimates and not accounting for qualitative factors.
Minne Li Outline ØThefollowing planning tool in a given situations (AO2, AO4) • Decision tree
ØThevalue to an organization of these planning tools
(AO3) Decision trees • Option 1: sell the property at the current market price of $600,000 this year. This option would incur costs of $10,000 for estate agency and solicitor’s fees. • Option 2: sell the property next year - 65% chance of receiving a higher price $638,000 after associated costs - 25% chance of house price remaining stable; costs remain the same - 10% chance of the price declining; the estimated price is $530,000 after associated costs Decision trees Decision tree • The diagram is constructed from left to right. • Decision nodes are shown as squares. • Chance nodes are shown as circles. • For each chance node, there will be two or more routes (outcomes) – show the probability of the different outcomes for each chance node. The probability of each chance node must add up to 1. • The actual values of each outcome are stated at the end of each branch. • Each unwanted branch of the decision tree is cut-off, indicated by two parallel lines. • Keys to indicate all symbols • Identify the best option Decision tree • TCL is considering expanding into one of three locations. The expected costs and revenues are shown in Table 1. TCL only has the resources to pursue one of these options. Construct a decision tree diagram for TCL (show all your working)
Location Cost ($m) Probability (%) Revenue ($m)
choice High sales Low sales High sales Low sales Shanghai 95 60 40 220 85 Beijing 85 50 50 200 75 Guangzhou 100 65 35 190 90 Decision tree • CMB manufactures bicycles in a large factory. Government data suggest that there is a 45% chance of the economy improving during the next three years, with a 35% chance of it remaining unchanged and only a 20% chance of the economy worsening. Hence, CMB is considering three growth option: • Option 1: launch a new line of foldable bikes, costing an estimated $2.5m • Option 2: build a new factory to increase the productive capacity of its existing bikes, costing an estimated $4.5m. • Option 3: diversify by building skateboards to add to its current product portfolio, costing an estimated $1.5m • Construct a decision tree diagram for CMB. State of Option 1 Option 2 Option 3 economy ($m) ($m) ($m) Improves 5 8 3 Unchanged 3 5 2 Worsens 2 3 -1 Decision tree Decision trees Advantages Disadvantages They allows managers to set out The probabilities given in a decision problems in a clear and logical manner. tree are only estimates and subject to All potential options can be seen at the forecasting errors. same time, thereby speeding up decision-making. They consider the risks involved in Delays in the planning process can decision-making, such as possible void the data by the time a decision is negative outcomes. actually made, yet time lags are often They enable more scientific and inevitable in the real business world. objective decisions to be made as all likely costs of decisions are considered. They are based on quantitative data only, so qualitative issues are ignored.