Volume 4
Volume 4
VOLUME 4
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
July 2013
LIST OF CONTENTS
GEOTECHNICAL INVESTIGATION
PEPORT
PART B: BRIDGES
PART A
Survey Report
Contents Page
1. Introduction 1
4. Materials Investigation 3
8. Appendix 13
Borrow Pits 19
8.7 Figure.7 Summary of Laboratory Test Results of
Quarries 20
The geology of the project area and its immediate environments are
shown in Figure 1.
Cambodia is geologically composed of three different structures; they are
mostly Triassic, Jurassic-Cretaceous and Quaternary. The Triassic period
covers a large area in the east, Jurassic-Cretaceous Era forming important
highlands in the west and, between them, the Quaternary basin occupy
the whole central plain of the country.
1
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Figure1. Geology Map of Cambodia
South-Eest Project
Cross-Border Facilities
2
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
3. Objective and Scope
4. Materials Investigation
3
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
5. Field Investigation Methodology
1. Pit Dig
In order to identify the different type of soil encountered along the road
alignment of the project, Pit Tests were conducted on existing road
sections with intervals of 2.50 Km by a maximum depth of 0.70 m with an
area of 1.00m x 1.00m. The texture and type of soil were described and
made the pit log at every changed stratum. Soil samples along the road
were brought to routine laboratory to identify characteristics of soil along
road alignment of the construction project. The results of test pits provide
information on road alignment, existing pavement condition, soil profile as
recorded in the field. Each retrieved samples was conducted in laboratory
in according with the AASHTO standard methods and its results are shown
in the appendix.
2. DCP Test
DCP tests were performed at the every dug pit of 2.50 Km intervals to get
information of CBR in-situ along project. It is carried out by using free
dropping hammer at constant height. The test shall be used 8 Kg drive
weight at free fall height of 760 mm to drive the hammer at every 5 blows
or 10 blows. The interpreted CBRs conducted on road site are shown in
the DCP appendix attached.
Soil samples extracted to present the different strata from pits tests along
the road alignment were subjected to standard laboratory soil testing for
evaluation and analysis in accordance with AASHTO standard methods
and specification to classify them for their engineering values. The
4
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
quantity and type of tests performed were also in accordance with the
TOR and contract agreement for the project.
Bulk samples taken from test pits on the existing sub-grade were subject
to Procter Test under AASHTO-T80 testing procedure. Method B or D was
adopted depending on the gradation of the soil or aggregate material. A
(4.54Kg) hammer was used. Five trials were performed for each
compaction test.
5
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
6 Finding (Test results):
A five (5) test pits, five (5) CBRs test and ten (10) DCPs to a depth of
1.00 m respectively were undertaken for road PR314D on a road
alignments for soil profile investigation. Corresponding soil samples taken
were submitted to the routine laboratory for subsequent testing.
Five (5) soil samples from test pits representing the strata along the
stretch of the road section were submitted for routine soil classification
determination. From beginning station to the end of road section PR314D,
soil behavior is good to be embankment and/or possibly sub-graded layer,
the CBR tests is varying between 8.00% and 9.00% of the existing road
condition. And DCP test results show between 7.08% and 66.35% for
provincial road 314D road section.
Potential borrow site from section along the construction project road
were investigated including materials from nearby the road. Materials are
suitable for embankment materials depending on its classification,
gradation, liquid limit, and plasticity index of natural soil. The soil
classifications are classified as A-6 and A-2-6 based on test results.
Five (5) were taken from these mentioned sites and subjected to routine
laboratory tests. Result of the laboratory test indicated a soil classification;
CBR test results, gradation, liquid limit, and plastic index are within the
construction standard. Detail results of laboratory test are shown in
appendix and summary of Laboratory Test Results, Materials Sources.
6
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
2. Sub-base materials and soil-cement stabilization
Potential borrow site from section along the construction project road
were investigated including materials from nearby the road. Materials may
not be suitable for sub-base depending on its laboratory test results, and
may need stabilizing soil-cement to reduce plasticity index of soil and to
strengthen soil bearing capacity of CBRs.
Samples were taken from these mentioned sites and subjected to routine
laboratory tests. This investigation was undertaken to confirm previous
report information obtained and to locate new materials sources regarding
technical specification of soil-cement stabilization. It should be a well
graded soil aggregate with not more than 40% passing 0.075 mm sieve.
The fraction of material passing the 0.425 mm sieve should have a liquid
limit not greater than 40% and a plasticity index not greater than 20, then
the minimum soaked CBR value after stabilization shall be equal or greater
than 30% as determined by AASHTO-T193.
7
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Km RHS of NR7. The representative physical and mechanical properties of
the quarry stone crushed aggregates sampled and tested by routine
laboratory and supervised by consultant’s team are presented in appendix.
All the test results tabulated above appears that the crushed rock
aggregates are appropriate for use in the construction of Base Course,
Concrete and Double Bituminous Surface Treatment (DBST). Required
particle size to comply specific grading of crushed aggregates to be
adjusted by placing order with the crushing plant owner as and when
needed.
4. Aggregate Materials
8
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
BP14 Pk. 23+600 RHS Offset 300m from PR314D 100,000.00 CBF BP for Emb
Sub Base SB1 Pk. 11+800 RHS Offset 7000m from PR13 N=1275654, E=578904 10,000.00
PR.314D
Borrow Pit
SB2 Pk. 20+100 RHS Offset 4700m from PR13 N=1267547, E=583708 360,000.00
BS, Q1 Pk. 71+050 LHS Offset 4.000 Km from NR1 N=1242418, E=540459 As required Chheukach
Base Course BS, Q2 Pk. 158+500 LHS Offset 3.300 Km from NR7 N=1312831, E=583968 As required Bratheat
PR.314D
Quarries
BS, Q3 Pk. 132+100 RHS Offset 1.300 km from NR7 N=1319525, E=559007 As required Sre Siem
BS, Q4 Pk. 103+900 RHS Offset 0.100 Km from NR7 N=1332446, E=536230 As required Troeung
9
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Figure.2 Location Map of Borrow Area and Quarries
10
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
6 Conclusion and Recommendation
The site investigation along the existing roadbed was undertaken by two
kind of test methodology to compare and accurately check in order to
ensure the test results are confidence and believable. All two testing
conduct on site is DCP test and CBR test at laboratory. The result test of
DCP test results on site showed the CBR values ranging from 7.08 % to
66.35 % for the depth of top surface down to 1.00 m depth regarding
TRL.
The test results of CBR value ranging from 8.00% to 9.00%. According to
the above test results, it is concluded that the existing sub-grade layer
could be a layer of new sub-grade layer of 10% CBR for the new
construction road. The embankment layer may be omitted for more
workability because during site investigation along the construction road
because the CBR test results show the good results of embankment
material for all along road section or there is only for the section of
widening.
Potential borrow site along the project road were investigated. Materials
suitable for sub-grade and sub-base were not founded for any CBR values
ranging within the technical specification shown in the appendix. These
materials can be used as both sub-grade and sub-base materials to meet
technical specification standard by stabilizing with cement. Materials
suitable for sub-base were founded for the CBR values of stabilizing soil-
cement ranging between 50% and over 100%. Therefore the soil-cement
stabilized is recommended to use as sub-grade or sub-base for this
particular road construction project.
CBR test results of base course materials indicated that the classification is
in the specification standard required at a long road section is at Pratheat
Quarry PK.158+500 offset 1.30 Km LHS, Sre Siem Quarry PK.132+100,
0.100 Km LHS, Treung Quarry PK.103+900 RHS, Phnom Chheu Kach
PK.71+050, 4.00 Km LHS, but CBR and plastic index analysis can be
corrected when construction period.
11
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
subjected to quality tests. The results of the test showed that aggregate
materials satisfy the AASHTO standard specification requirement except
for plastic index at Sre Siem Quarry. Test analysis and some
recommendation of materials can be corrected to meet specification
standards by choosing good rock from deeper layer when blasting.
Materials classification and materials specification are all within technical
specification standard. It is recommended that all materials be crushed
and processed to meet standard requirements.
12
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
7 Appendix
13
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Figure.3 Pitting Test Logs
KINGDOM OF CAMBODIA
MINISTRY OF PUBLIC WORKS AND TRANSPROT
EXISTING ROAD TEST PIT LOGS
10cm Macadam
20cm Sand and Macadam
5cm Asphaltic
30cm Laterite
60cm Clayey
30cm Clayey
10cm Macadam
60cm Clayey
Pit No. 05
14
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Figure No.4 Summary of DCP Tests
Figure.4 SUMMARY OF AVERAGE CBR VALUES OBTAIN BY DCP TEST RESULTS ( TRRL )
15
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PR314D 27/01/13 2+500 2.0m 1 0m-0.7m A-2-6 1.948 12.80 8.90 32.50 18.04 72.87 64.72
PR314D 27/01/13 7+500 2.0m 2 0m-0.7m A-2-6 2.098 6.80 9.00 32.5 20.64 56.05 39.13
PR314D 30/01/13 12+500 3.0m 16 0m-0.7m A-2-6 2.205 6.00 9.00 32.50 16.28 47.62 34.88
PR314D 30/01/13 17+500 3.0m 17 0m-0.7m A-2-6 2.202 6.20 9.00 32.50 18.74 59.83 45.3
PR314D 30/01/13 22+500 3.0m 16 0m-0.7m A-2-6 2.093 6.70 8.00 32.50 14.32 73.78 56.47
16
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Test Results
Sampling Sample Location
Road No. Offset Pit No. Depth (m) Soil L.A Remarks
Date (Km) MDD(g/cc) OMC(%) CBR(%) LL(%) PI(%) # 0.425mm # 0.075mm
Classification (%)
13 26/02/13 Pk. 11+800 RHS 7000 001 1 to 2m A-2-6 2.228 9.10 Cement2%= 73 24.60 9.27 31.28 21.85 29.93
002 1 to 2m A-2-6 Cement4%= 162
003 1 to 2m A-2-6 Cement6%= 225
13 26/02/13 Pk. 20+100 RHS 4700m 004 1 to 2m A-2-6 2.23 7.90 Cement2%= 69 25.80 12.11 27.85 21.18 30.42
005 1 to 2m A-2-6 Cement4%= 166
006 1 to 2m A-2-6 Cement6%= 215
17
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
18
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Figure No.8 DCP Tests at Pits along Road Section
Comments:
Test No.1
1.00 m
Formula used to calculate CBR is TRL Overseas Road Note 31 (60oCone), Log10(CBR) = 2.48-1.057* Log10(mm/blow ).
19
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
-100
CBR2 = 11.70 325
-200
-400
Depth, mm
CBRm = 16.74
-500
-600
-700
-800
-900
-1000
20
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Comments:
Test No.2
1.00 m
Formula used to calculate CBR is TRL Overseas Road Note 31 (60oCone), Log10(CBR) = 2.48-1.057* Log10(mm/blow ).
21
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
-100
CBR2 = 19.98 718
-200
-400
Depth, mm
CBRm = 22.22
-500
-600
-700
-800
-900
-1000
22
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Dynamic Cone Penetration Test (DCP), TRL
Comments:
Test No.3
1.00 m
Formula used to calculate CBR is TRL Overseas Road Note 31 (60oCone), Log10(CBR) = 2.48-1.057* Log10(mm/blow ).
23
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR2 =
-200
CBRm = 58.24
-600
-800
-1000
-1200
24
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Dynamic Cone Penetration Test (DCP), TRL
Comments:
Test No.4
1.00 m
Formula used to calculate CBR is TRL Overseas Road Note 31 (60oCone), Log10(CBR) = 2.48-1.057* Log10(mm/blow ).
25
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Dynamic ConeImprovement
Penetration Test (DCP), TRL
of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Sheet No.4
-100
CBR2 = 36.28 297
-200
-400
Depth, mm
CBRm = 23.65
-500
-600
-700
-800
-900
-1000
26
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Comments:
Test No.5
1.00 m
Formula used to calculate CBR is TRL Overseas Road Note 31 (60oCone), Log10(CBR) = 2.48-1.057* Log10(mm/blow ).
27
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
-100
CBR2 = 11.63 305
-200
-400
Depth, mm
CBRm = 9.34
-500
-600
-700
-800
-900
-1000
28
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Dynamic Cone Penetration Test (DCP), TRL
Comments:
Test No.6
1.00 m
Formula used to calculate CBR is TRL Overseas Road Note 31 (60oCone), Log10(CBR) = 2.48-1.057* Log10(mm/blow ).
29
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
-100
CBR2 = 81.27 502
-200
-400
Depth, mm
CBRm = 51.88
-500
-600
-700
-800
-900
-1000
30
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Dynamic Cone Penetration Test (DCP), TRL
Comments:
Test No.7
1.00 m
Formula used to calculate CBR is TRL Overseas Road Note 31 (60oCone), Log10(CBR) = 2.48-1.057* Log10(mm/blow ).
31
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
-100
CBR2 = 33.53 160
-200
-400
Depth, mm
CBRm = 16.07
-500
-600
-700
-800
-900
-1000
32
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Dynamic Cone Penetration Test (DCP), TRL
Comments:
Test No.8
1.00 m
Formula used to calculate CBR is TRL Overseas Road Note 31 (60oCone), Log10(CBR) = 2.48-1.057* Log10(mm/blow ).
33
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBRm = 13.40
-600
-800
-1000
-1200
34
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Dynamic Cone Penetration Test (DCP), TRL
Comments:
Test No.9
1.00 m
Formula used to calculate CBR is TRL Overseas Road Note 31 (60oCone), Log10(CBR) = 2.48-1.057* Log10(mm/blow ).
35
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
-100
CBR2 = 16.23 715
-200
-400
Depth, mm
CBRm = 20.08
-500
-600
-700
-800
-900
-1000
36
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Dynamic Cone Penetration Test (DCP), TRL
Comments:
Test No.10
1.00 m
Formula used to calculate CBR is TRL Overseas Road Note 31 (60oCone), Log10(CBR) = 2.48-1.057* Log10(mm/blow ).
37
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR3 =
-400
Depth, mm
CBRm = 7.08
-600
-800
-1000
-1200
38
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Figure No.9 Soil Pitting Tests at Laboratory
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
8.9 90 12.80
95
98
100
Remarks:
39
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
1.950
1.930
Dry Density, g/cc
1.910
1.870
1.850
9.40 10.40 11.40 12.40 13.40 14.40 15.40
Moisture content %
40
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soil Testing and Georesearch Inc.
# 35 A, 464 Street, Tuol Tumpung I, Chamkar Mon, Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Tel : 088 818 5555, 097 730 0760, Tel/Fax: 855-23 996 804, Email : [email protected], P.O.Box : 2470 Phnom Penh 3.
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 13 22 32 40
Unit Tin No. 94 78 187 4 140 130
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 72.55 72.41 72.30 72.18 43.76 43.86
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 63.62 64.03 64.33 64.42 40.12 40.02
W3 Weight of can g 14.89 15.02 15.00 14.89 14.21 14.21
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 8.93 8.38 7.97 7.76 3.64 3.84
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 48.73 49.01 49.33 49.53 25.91 25.81
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 18.33 17.10 16.16 15.67 14.05 14.88
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 16.70 14.46
PI Plastic Limit % 2.24
Atterburg Limit
30
18.5
29
18.0
28
Moisture content %
17.5
27
26
17.0
25
16.5
24
23
16.0
22
15.5
21
20
15.0
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
41
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-823 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 26/01/13
Sample Description: Existing on the Road Date Test Start : 21/02/13
Sample Location: 2+500 RHS Offset 2.5m Pit: 1
42
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-823 Sample 01 Date Sampled 27/01/13 Date Test Start : 22/02/13
Sample Description: Existing on the road Pit: 1
Sample Location: PK: 2+500 RS Offset 2.0m Depth: 0.0m - 0.7m
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. A205 A201 A218 A229 A217 A77
43
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soil Testing and Georesearch Inc.
# 35 A, 464 Street, Tuol Tumpung I, Chamkar Mon, Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Tel : 088 818 5555, 097 730 0760, Tel/Fax: 855-23 996 804, Email : [email protected], P.O.Box : 2470 Phnom Penh 3.
9 25 40
8 35
20
Stress in kg/cm2
7 30
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
6 25
15
5
20
4
10 15
3
2 10
5
1 5
0 0 0
0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10 20
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
44
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.717 1.851 2.037
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 5.94 16.07 30.27
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.753 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.851 g/cc
Plotting value for 98% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.909 g/cc
30
25
Soaked CBR (%)
20
15
CBR = 8.9%
of MDD 90%
10
5
1.700 1.750 1.800 1.850 1.900 1.950 2.000 2.050 2.100
Dry Density g/cc
45
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
9 90 6.80
95
98
100
Remarks:
46
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-824 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 27/01/13 Date Test Start : 21/02/13
Sample Description: Existing on the road Pit: 2
Sample Location: PK: 7+500 RS Offset 2.0m Depth: 0.0m - 0.7m
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7369.2 7593.2 7754.9 7696.8
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3043.8 3043.8 3043.8 3043.8
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4325.4 4549.4 4711.1 4653.0
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 2.056 2.162 2.239 2.212
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 2.002 2.061 2.096 2.036
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. A20 A29 T22 A24
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 361.10 444.60 376.10 407.50
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 352.60 425.70 354.10 378.10
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 8.50 18.90 22.00 29.40
m3 Weight of can g 37.40 40.70 32.20 37.10
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 315.20 385.00 321.90 341.00
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 2.70 4.91 6.83 8.62
2.100
2.080
Dry Density, g/cc
2.060
2.020
2.000
2.40 3.40 4.40 5.40 6.40 7.40 8.40
Moisture content %
47
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soil Testing and Georesearch Inc.
# 35 A, 464 Street, Tuol Tumpung I, Chamkar Mon, Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Tel : 088 818 5555, 097 730 0760, Tel/Fax: 855-23 996 804, Email : [email protected], P.O.Box : 2470 Phnom Penh 3.
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 12 22 32 40
Unit Tin No. 129 15 54 33 148 150
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 70.64 70.56 70.47 70.36 43.70 42.89
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 61.53 61.93 62.19 62.27 40.24 40.17
W3 Weight of can g 14.15 14.16 14.17 14.18 14.10 14.20
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 9.11 8.63 8.28 8.09 3.46 2.72
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 47.38 47.77 48.02 48.09 26.14 25.97
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 19.23 18.07 17.24 16.82 13.24 10.47
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 17.80 11.86
PI Plastic Limit % 5.94
Atterburg Limit
30
19.5
29
19.0
28
Moisture content %
18.5
27
26
18.0
25
17.5
24
23
17.0
22
16.5
21
20
16.0
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
48
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-824 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 26/01/13
Sample Description: Existing on the Road Date Test Start : 11/03/13
Sample Location: PK: 7+500 RS Offset 2.0m Pit: 2
49
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-824 Sample 01 Date Sampled 27/01/13 Date Test Start : 28/02/13
Sample Description: Existing on the road Pit: 2
Sample Location: PK: 7+500 RS Offset 2.0m Depth: 0.0m - 0.7m
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. B22 A18 A410 A11 A48 A201
50
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soil Testing and Georesearch Inc.
# 35 A, 464 Street, Tuol Tumpung I, Chamkar Mon, Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Tel : 088 818 5555, 097 730 0760, Tel/Fax: 855-23 996 804, Email : [email protected], P.O.Box : 2470 Phnom Penh 3.
9 25 45
8 40
20
Stress in kg/cm2
7 35
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
6 30
15
5 25
4 20
10
3 15
2 5 10
1 5
0 0 0
0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10 20
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
51
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
CBR Caculations from corrected CBR = 5.91 % CBR = 19.11 % CBR = 38.217 %
load / stress of Form No. 9A graphs Stress at 5.08mm= 5.502 Stress at 5.08mm= 16.627 Stress at 5.08mm= 31.788
kg/cm2 kg/cm2 kg/cm2
CBR = 5.24 % CBR = 15.84 % CBR = 30.27 %
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.854 1.958 2.106
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 5.24 15.84 30.27
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.888 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.993 g/cc
Plotting value for 98% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.056 g/cc
30
25
Soaked CBR (%)
20
15
CBR =
of MDD 90%
10
5
1.850 1.900 1.950 2.000 2.050 2.100
Dry Density g/cc
52
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
9 90 6.00
95
98
100
Remarks:
53
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-825 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 30/01/13 Date Test Start : 28/02/13
Sample Description: Existing on the road Pit: 3
Sample Location: PK: 12+500 RS Offset 3.0m Depth: 0.0m - 0.7m
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7591.7 7941.9 7949.8 7891.6
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3043.8 3043.8 3043.8 3043.8
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4547.9 4898.1 4906.0 4847.8
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 2.162 2.328 2.332 2.304
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 2.092 2.203 2.164 2.106
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. I30 I28 I10 I4
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 341.30 289.70 291.80 297.30
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 331.30 275.70 273.00 274.20
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 10.00 14.00 18.80 23.10
m3 Weight of can g 29.80 29.80 30.49 28.68
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 301.50 245.90 242.51 245.52
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 3.32 5.69 7.75 9.41
2.220
2.200
2.180
Dry Density, g/cc
2.160
2.100
2.080
3.20 4.20 5.20 6.20 7.20 8.20 9.20
Moisture content %
54
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soil Testing and Georesearch Inc.
# 35 A, 464 Street, Tuol Tumpung I, Chamkar Mon, Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Tel : 088 818 5555, 097 730 0760, Tel/Fax: 855-23 996 804, Email : [email protected], P.O.Box : 2470 Phnom Penh 3.
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 15 25 33 42
Unit Tin No. 76 77 86 199 181 180
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 68.80 68.62 68.51 68.40 45.78 45.68
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 55.59 56.25 56.45 56.64 41.39 41.29
W3 Weight of can g 13.34 14.35 14.32 14.30 14.29 14.25
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 13.21 12.37 12.06 11.76 4.39 4.39
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 42.25 41.90 42.13 42.34 27.10 27.04
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 31.27 29.52 28.63 27.78 16.20 16.24
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 29.50 16.22
PI Plastic Limit % 13.28
Atterburg Limit
30
32.0
29
31.5
28
31.0
Moisture content %
27
30.5
26
30.0
25
29.5
24
29.0
23
28.5
22
28.0
21
27.5
20
27.0
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
55
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-825 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 26/01/13
Sample Description: Existing on the Road Date Test Start : 06/03/13
Sample Location: PK: 12+500 RS Offset 3.0m Pit: 3
Test Method : AASHTO T27/T88 Soil Classification: A-2-6 Depth: 0.0m - 0.7m
56
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-825 Sample 01 Date Sampled 30/01/13 Date Test Start : 01/03/13
Sample Description: Existing on the road Pit: 3
Sample Location: PK: 12+500 RS Offset 3.0m Depth: 0.0m - 0.7m
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. C05 C34 C85 C101 C17 C61
57
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soil Testing and Georesearch Inc.
# 35 A, 464 Street, Tuol Tumpung I, Chamkar Mon, Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Tel : 088 818 5555, 097 730 0760, Tel/Fax: 855-23 996 804, Email : [email protected], P.O.Box : 2470 Phnom Penh 3.
9 25 45
8 40
20
Stress in kg/cm2
7 35
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
6 30
15
5 25
4 20
10
3 15
2 5 10
1 5
0 0 0
0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10 20
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
58
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
CBR Caculations from corrected CBR = 6.43 % CBR = 20.67 % CBR = 38.912 %
load / stress of Form No. 9A graphs Stress at 5.08mm= 5.746 Stress at 5.08mm= 17.116 Stress at 5.08mm= 35.455
2
kg/cm kg/cm2 kg/cm2
CBR = 5.47 % CBR = 16.30 % CBR = 33.77 %
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.953 2.053 2.219
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 5.47 16.30 33.77
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.985 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.095 g/cc
Plotting value for 98% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.161 g/cc
35
30
25
Soaked CBR (%)
20
15 CBR = 9.0%
of MDD 90%
10
5
1.950 2.000 2.050 2.100 2.150 2.200
Dry Density g/cc
59
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
9 90 6.20
95
98
100
Remarks:
60
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-826 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 30/01/13 Date Test Start : 28/02/13
Sample Description: Existing on the road Pit: 4
Sample Location: PK: 17+500 LS Offset 3.0m Depth: 0.0m - 0.7m
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7552.0 7893.1 7985.3 7855.0
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3043.8 3043.8 3043.8 3043.8
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4508.2 4849.3 4941.5 4811.2
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 2.143 2.305 2.349 2.287
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 2.068 2.188 2.188 2.084
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. I10 I30 I4 I28
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 341.00 297.70 290.00 290.30
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 330.20 284.10 272.10 267.20
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 10.80 13.60 17.90 23.10
m3 Weight of can g 30.49 29.75 28.68 29.80
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 299.71 254.35 243.42 237.40
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 3.60 5.35 7.35 9.73
2.220
2.210
2.200
2.190
2.180
2.170
2.160
Dry Density, g/cc
2.150
2.140
2.130
MDD = 2.203 g/cc
2.120
2.110
2.100 OMC = 6.20 %
2.090
2.080
2.070
2.060
2.050
3.40 4.40 5.40 6.40 7.40 8.40 9.40
Moisture content %
61
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soil Testing and Georesearch Inc.
# 35 A, 464 Street, Tuol Tumpung I, Chamkar Mon, Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Tel : 088 818 5555, 097 730 0760, Tel/Fax: 855-23 996 804, Email : [email protected], P.O.Box : 2470 Phnom Penh 3.
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 12 23 32 42
Unit Tin No. 41 23 46 70 160 158
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 77.65 77.57 77.42 77.36 43.80 43.75
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 66.47 67.00 67.19 67.40 40.22 40.17
W3 Weight of can g 14.00 14.00 14.04 14.06 14.20 14.16
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 11.18 10.57 10.23 9.96 3.58 3.58
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 52.47 53.00 53.15 53.34 26.02 26.01
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 21.31 19.94 19.25 18.67 13.76 13.76
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 19.80 13.76
PI Plastic Limit % 6.04
Atterburg Limit
30
21.5
29
21.0
28
Moisture content %
20.5
27
26
20.0
25
19.5
24
23
19.0
22
18.5
21
20
18.0
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
62
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-826 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 30/01/13
Sample Description: Existing on the Road Date Test Start : 05/03/13
Sample Location: PK: 17+500 LS Offset 3.0m Pit: 4
63
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-826 Sample 01 Date Sampled 30/01/13 Date Test Start : 01/03/13
Sample Description: Existing on the road Pit: 4
Sample Location: PK: 17+500 LS Offset 3.0m Depth: 0.0m - 0.7m
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. B11 A24 A38 A74 A13 A28
64
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soil Testing and Georesearch Inc.
# 35 A, 464 Street, Tuol Tumpung I, Chamkar Mon, Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Tel : 088 818 5555, 097 730 0760, Tel/Fax: 855-23 996 804, Email : [email protected], P.O.Box : 2470 Phnom Penh 3.
10 25 45
9 40
8 20
Stress in kg/cm2
35
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
7 30
6 15
25
5
20
4 10
15
3
2 5 10
1 5
0 0 0
0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10 20
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
65
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
6
CBR Calculation : 10 Blows 30 Blows 65 Blows 7
Stress at 2.54mm= 4.401 Stress at 2.54mm= 14.0599 Stress at 2.54 mm= 27.631 1
2 2
kg/cm2 kg/cm kg/cm 1
CBR = 6.25 % CBR = 19.98 % CBR = 39.259 %
CBR Caculations from corrected
load / stress of Form No. 9A graphs Stress at 5.08mm= 5.746 Stress at 5.08mm= 16.872 Stress at 5.08mm= 34.966
1
kg/cm2 kg/cm2 kg/cm2
CBR = 5.47 % CBR = 16.07 % CBR = 33.30 %
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.949 2.055 2.218
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 5.47 16.07 33.30
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.983 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.093 g/cc
Plotting value for 98% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.159 g/cc
35
30
Soaked CBR (%)
25
20
CBR = 9.0%
15
10 of MDD 90%
5
1.940 1.990 2.040 2.090 2.140 2.190
Dry Density g/cc
66
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
8 90 6.70
95
98
100
Remarks:
67
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-827 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 30/01/13 Date Test Start : 21/02/13
Sample Description: Existing on the road Pit: 5
Sample Location: PK: 22+500 LS Offset 3.0m Depth: 0.0m - 0.7m
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7368.1 7594.1 7750.5 7664.5
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3043.8 3043.8 3043.8 3043.8
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4324.3 4550.3 4706.7 4620.7
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 2.055 2.163 2.237 2.196
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 2.002 2.063 2.092 2.025
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. A20 A29 T22 A24
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 360.90 448.60 370.10 400.50
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 352.50 429.70 348.10 372.10
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 8.40 18.90 22.00 28.40
m3 Weight of can g 37.40 40.70 32.20 37.10
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 315.10 389.00 315.90 335.00
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 2.67 4.86 6.96 8.48
2.100
2.080
Dry Density, g/cc
2.060
OMC = 6.70 %
2.020
2.000
2.50 3.50 4.50 5.50 6.50 7.50 8.50
Moisture content %
68
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soil Testing and Georesearch Inc.
# 35 A, 464 Street, Tuol Tumpung I, Chamkar Mon, Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Tel : 088 818 5555, 097 730 0760, Tel/Fax: 855-23 996 804, Email : [email protected], P.O.Box : 2470 Phnom Penh 3.
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 13 23 33 42
Unit Tin No. 63 86 15 168 169 175
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 72.51 72.42 72.39 72.18 41.75 41.73
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 61.48 61.99 62.41 62.54 37.48 37.51
W3 Weight of can g 15.00 14.77 14.80 14.79 14.10 14.18
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 11.03 10.43 9.98 9.64 4.27 4.22
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 46.48 47.22 47.61 47.75 23.38 23.33
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 23.73 22.09 20.96 20.19 18.26 18.09
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 21.70 18.18
PI Plastic Limit % 3.52
Atterburg Limit
30
24.0
29
23.5
28
23.0
Moisture content %
27
22.5
26
22.0
25
21.5
24
21.0
23
20.5
22
20.0
21
20
19.5
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
69
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-827 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 26/01/13
Sample Description: Existing on the Road Date Test Start : 05/03/13
Sample Location: PK: 22+500 LS Offset 3.0m Pit: 5
70
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-827 Sample 01 Date Sampled 30/01/13 Date Test Start : 22/02/13
Sample Description: Existing on the road Pit: 5
Sample Location: PK: 22+500 LS Offset 3.0m Depth: 0.0m - 0.7m
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. B22 A18 A410 A11 A48 A201
71
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soil Testing and Georesearch Inc.
# 35 A, 464 Street, Tuol Tumpung I, Chamkar Mon, Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Tel : 088 818 5555, 097 730 0760, Tel/Fax: 855-23 996 804, Email : [email protected], P.O.Box : 2470 Phnom Penh 3.
9 25 40
8 35
20
Stress in kg/cm2
7 30
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
6 25
15
5
20
4
10 15
3
2 10
5
1 5
0 0 0
0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10 20
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
72
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.867 1.947 2.112
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 5.71 15.84 30.04
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.884 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.988 g/cc
Plotting value for 98% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.051 g/cc
30
25
Soaked CBR (%)
20
15
10 CBR = 8.0%
of MDD 90%
5
1.850 1.900 1.950 2.000 2.050 2.100
Dry Density g/cc
73
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Figure No.10 Laboratory Test Results of Materials for Embankment,
Sub-base, and Base Aggregate:
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
5 90 6.40
95
98
100
Remarks:
74
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road:PR:314D
Lab No: LB-835 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 08/03/13 Date Test Start : 25/03/13
Sample Description: Borrow Pit Embankment Pit:3
Sample Location: PK1+000 LHS Offset 100m Depth:0.2m→2m
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7262.6 7417.6 7578.3 7537.7
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3043.6 3043.6 3043.6 3043.6
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4219.0 4374.0 4534.7 4494.1
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 2.005 2.079 2.156 2.136
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 1.957 1.987 2.023 1.968
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. A37 A37 T22 T55
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 473.50 473.50 456.70 400.10
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 462.80 454.00 430.70 371.60
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 10.70 19.50 26.00 28.50
m3 Weight of can g 31.10 31.10 32.20 38.60
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 431.70 422.90 398.50 333.00
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 2.48 4.61 6.52 8.56
2.030
2.020
2.010
2.000
Dry Density, g/cc
1.990
1.970
OMC = 6.40 %
1.960
1.950
1.940
2.20 3.20 4.20 5.20 6.20 7.20 8.20
Moisture content %
75
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Plasticity Index Test AASHTO T-89 and T-90
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road:PR:314D
Lab No: LB-835 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 08/03/13 Date Test Start : 25/03/13
Sample Description: Borrow Pit Embankment Pit:3
Sample Location: PK1+000 LHS Offset 100m Depth:0.2m→2m
Test Method : AASHTO T89 and T90
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 15 25 35 45
Unit Tin No. 21 145 234 32 12 19
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 65.76 65.68 65.58 65.40 40.86 40.74
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 56.50 57.30 57.86 58.14 36.65 36.45
W3 Weight of can g 14.12 14.17 14.20 14.22 13.96 13.90
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 9.26 8.38 7.72 7.26 4.21 4.29
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 42.38 43.13 43.66 43.92 22.69 22.55
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 21.85 19.43 17.68 16.53 18.55 19.02
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 19.40 18.79
PI Plastic Index % 0.61
Atterburg Limit
30
22.0
21.5
29
21.0
28
20.5
Moisture content %
20.0
27
19.5
26
19.0
25
18.5
18.0
24
17.5
23
17.0
16.5
22
16.0
21
15.5
20
15.0
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
76
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-835 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 08/03/13
Sample Description: Borrow Pit Embankment Date Test Start : 25/03/13
Sample Location: PK1+000 LHS Offset 100m Pit: 1
77
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-835 Sample 01 Date Sampled 08/03/13 Date Test Start : 26/03/13
Sample Description: Borrow Pit Embankment Pit:3
Sample Location: PK1+000 LHS Offset 100m Depth:0.2m→2m
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. B22 A111 A39 A0 A32 A78
Wet of Can+Wet Materials g 397.70 400.3 415.50 333.10 375.90 376.6
Wt of can +Dry Materials g 381.60 373.8 398.20 309.60 358.50 351.2
Wt of Moisture g 16.10 26.5 17.30 23.5 17.40 25.4
Wt of can g 37.60 38.7 32.80 30.7 36.80 34.9
Wt of dry materials g 344.00 335.1 365.40 278.9 321.70 316.3
Moisture content % 4.68 7.91 4.73 8.43 5.41 8.03
Average Moisture Content % 6.29 6.58 6.72
78
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soil Testing and Georesearch Inc.
# 35 A, 464 Street, Tuol Tumpung I, Chamkar Mon, Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Tel : 088 818 5555, 097 730 0760, Tel/Fax: 855-23 996 804, Email : [email protected], P.O.Box : 2470 Phnom Penh 3.
4 18 30
3 16
25
Stress in kg/cm2
14
Stress in kg/cm2
3
Stress in kg/cm2
12 20
2 10
15
2 8
6 10
1
4
1 5
2
0 0 0
0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10 20
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
79
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.805 1.909 2.091
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 2.21 10.71 16.88
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.822 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.923 g/cc
Plotting value for 98% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.984 g/cc
18
17
16
15
14
13
Soaked CBR (%)
12
11
10 CBR = 5.00%
9
8
7
6
5
4 of MDD 90%
3
2
1.790 1.840 1.890 1.940 1.990 2.040 2.090
Dry Density g/cc
80
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
0.95 90 10.20
95
98
100
Remarks:
81
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR 314D
Lab No: LB-833 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 17/03/13
Sample Description: Embankment Borrow Pit
Sample Location: Pk. 5+600 RHS Offset 100m from PR314D Depth :
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7069.8 7269.5 7466.4 7451.5
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3043.8 3043.8 3043.8 3043.8
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4026.0 4225.7 4422.6 4407.7
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.7 2103.7 2103.7 2103.7
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 1.914 2.009 2.102 2.095
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 1.802 1.859 1.907 1.855
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. A74 A410 A74 A11
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 406.70 441.20 425.20 406.30
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 384.90 410.80 389.00 364.20
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 21.80 30.40 36.20 42.10
m3 Weight of can g 34.99 32.40 35.20 38.70
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 349.91 378.40 353.80 325.50
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 6.23 8.03 10.23 12.93
1.910
1.890
Dry Density, g/cc
1.870
1.810
1.790
6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 11.00 12.00 13.00
Moisture content %
82
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Plasticity Index Test AASHTO T-89 and T-90
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR 314D
Lab No: LB-833 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 17/03/13
Sample Description: Embankment Borrow Pit
Sample Location: Pk. 5+600 RHS Offset 100m from PR314D
Test Method : AASHTO T89 and T90 Depth : 0
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 15 25 35 42
Unit Tin No. 68 156 2 204 109 104
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 72.83 72.66 72.54 72.41 42.90 42.60
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 56.83 57.51 58.01 58.22 38.49 38.39
W3 Weight of can g 14.29 14.24 14.38 14.28 14.10 14.01
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 16.00 15.15 14.53 14.19 4.41 4.21
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 42.54 43.27 43.63 43.94 24.39 24.38
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 37.61 35.01 33.30 32.29 18.08 17.27
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 34.80 17.67
PI Plastic Index % 17.13
Atterburg Limit
30
38.5
38.0
29
37.5
28
37.0
36.5
Moisture content %
27
36.0
26
35.5
35.0
25
34.5
24
34.0
33.5
23
33.0
22
32.5
32.0
21
31.5
20
31.0
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
83
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR 314D
Lab No: LB-833 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 26/02/13
Sample Description: Embankment Borrow Pit Date Test Start : 17/03/13
Sample Location: Pk. 5+600 RHS Offset 100m from PR314D
84
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd 0
Lab No: LB-833 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 18/03/13
Sample Description: Embankment Borrow Pit Depth : 0
Sample Location: Pk. 5+600 RHS Offset 100m from PR314D
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. I7 I28 I24 I17 I38 V1
85
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
2
Stress in kg/cm2
4
Stress in kg/cm2
1
1 2 3
1
1 2
0
0 1 1
0
0 5 10 15 0 0
0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
86
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.702 1.796 2.015
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 0.82 1.63 3.14
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.717 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.813 g/cc
2.5
Soaked CBR (%)
CBR = 0.95%
1.5
of MDD 90%
0.5
1.680 1.730 1.780 1.830 1.880 1.930 1.980 2.030
Dry Density g/cc
87
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
3.3 90 8.70
95
98
100
Remarks:
88
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No:314D
Lab No: LB-836 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 08/03/13 Date Test Start : 25/03/13
Sample Description: Borrow Pit Embankment Pit:
Sample Location: PK10+300 RHS Offset 500m Depth:0m→1.8m
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7271.6 7571.6 7767.2 7621.7
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3043.6 3043.6 3043.6 3043.6
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4228.0 4528.0 4723.6 4578.1
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 2.010 2.152 2.245 2.176
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 1.925 2.012 2.063 1.968
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. I34 I38 V1 C7
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 440.50 450.50 377.90 322.30
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 423.70 423.70 350.30 294.30
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 16.80 26.80 27.60 28.00
m3 Weight of can g 39.80 39.80 38.10 29.20
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 383.90 383.90 312.20 265.10
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 4.38 6.98 8.84 10.56
2.080
2.060
2.040
2.020
Dry Density, g/cc
2.000
1.960
OMC = 8.70 %
1.940
1.920
1.900
4.20 5.20 6.20 7.20 8.20 9.20 10.20
Moisture content %
89
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Plasticity Index Test AASHTO T-89 and T-90
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No:314D
Lab No: LB-836 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 08/03/13 Date Test Start : 25/03/13
Sample Description: Borrow Pit Embankment Pit:
Sample Location: PK10+300 RHS Offset 500m Depth:0m→1.8m
Test Method : AASHTO T89 and T90
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 15 25 35 43
Unit Tin No. 21 18 99 72 133 132
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 70.76 70.61 70.50 70.36 40.80 40.73
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 60.73 61.50 62.03 62.28 36.49 36.40
W3 Weight of can g 13.98 13.90 13.96 14.00 14.80 14.72
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 10.03 9.11 8.47 8.08 4.31 4.33
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 46.75 47.60 48.07 48.28 21.69 21.68
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 21.45 19.14 17.62 16.74 19.87 19.97
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 19.30 19.92
PI Plastic Index % -0.62
Atterburg Limit
22.0
30
21.5
29
21.0
20.5
28
20.0
Moisture content %
27
19.5
26
19.0
18.5
25
18.0
24
17.5
17.0
23
16.5
22
16.0
21
15.5
15.0
20
1 1 1010 100
100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
90
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-836 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 08/03/13
Sample Description: Borrow Pit Embankment Date Test Start : 25/03/13
Sample Location: PK10+300 RHS Offset 500m Pit:
91
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No:314D
Lab No: LB-836 Sample 01 Date Sampled 08/03/13 Date Test Start : 25/03/13
Sample Description: Borrow Pit Embankment Pit:
Sample Location: PK10+300 RHS Offset 500m Depth:0m→1.8m
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. P90 A47 A78 A32 A42 A0
Wet of Can+Wet Materials g 306.60 302.9 308.80 317.00 304.20 300.3
Wt of can +Dry Materials g 285.00 283.1 287.80 295.80 282.10 280.1
Wt of Moisture g 21.60 19.8 21.00 21.2 22.10 20.2
Wt of can g 39.90 30.9 34.90 36.8 29.90 30.7
Wt of dry materials g 245.10 252.2 252.90 259 252.20 249.4
Moisture content % 8.81 7.85 8.30 8.19 8.76 8.10
Average Moisture Content % 8.33 8.24 8.43
92
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soil Testing and Georesearch Inc.
# 35 A, 464 Street, Tuol Tumpung I, Chamkar Mon, Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Tel : 088 818 5555, 097 730 0760, Tel/Fax: 855-23 996 804, Email : [email protected], P.O.Box : 2470 Phnom Penh 3.
4 9 12
4 8
10
Stress in kg/cm2
3 7
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
6 8
3
5
2 6
4
2 4
3
1 2
2
1 1
0 0 0
0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10 20
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
93
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.835 1.935 2.098
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 2.68 4.31 4.89
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.859 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.962 g/cc
Plotting value for 98% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.024 g/cc
5.5
5.0
4.5
Soaked CBR (%)
4.0
3.5
CBR = 3.3%
3.0
of MDD 90%
2.5
2.0
1.820 1.870 1.920 1.970 2.020 2.070 2.120
Dry Density g/cc
94
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
6.7 90 12.00
95
98
100
Remarks:
95
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-834 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 18/03/13
Sample Description: Embankment Borrow Pit Borrow Pit:
Sample Location: Pk. 16+800 RHS Offset 100m from PR314 Depth :
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7204.9 7328.6 7466.9 7410.6
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3043.8 3043.8 3043.8 3043.8
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4161.1 4284.8 4423.1 4366.8
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.7 2103.7 2103.7 2103.7
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 1.978 2.037 2.103 2.076
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 1.830 1.849 1.874 1.808
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. A47 A32 A23 T22
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 451.90 387.50 375.60 436.50
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 420.30 355.20 338.90 384.40
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 31.60 32.30 36.70 52.10
m3 Weight of can g 30.90 36.80 38.50 32.20
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 389.40 318.40 300.40 352.20
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 8.12 10.14 12.22 14.79
1.880
1.860
Dry Density, g/cc
OMC = 12.00 %
1.820
1.800
8.00 9.00 10.00 11.00 12.00 13.00 14.00 15.00
Moisture content %
96
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Plasticity Index Test AASHTO T-89 and T-90
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-834 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 18/03/13
Sample Description: Embankment Borrow Pit
Sample Location: Pk. 16+800 RHS Offset 100m from PR314
Test Method : AASHTO T89 and T90 Depth :
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 15 22 31 43
Unit Tin No. 150 47 39 117 124 128
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 68.40 65.30 64.23 65.22 40.27 40.31
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 57.84 56.10 56.00 57.44 36.80 36.72
W3 Weight of can g 14.15 14.22 14.35 14.12 14.15 14.19
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 10.56 9.20 8.23 7.78 3.47 3.59
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 43.69 41.88 41.65 43.32 22.65 22.53
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 24.17 21.97 19.76 17.96 15.32 15.93
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 21.00 15.63
PI Plastic Index % 5.37
Atterburg Limit
30
25.0
24.5
29
24.0
23.5
28
23.0
Moisture content %
27
22.5
22.0
26
21.5
25
21.0
20.5
24
20.0
19.5
23
19.0
22
18.5
18.0
21
17.5
20
17.0
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
97
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-834 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 26/02/13
Sample Description: Embankment Borrow Pit Date Test Start : 18/03/13
Sample Location: Pk. 16+800 RHS Offset 100m from PR314
98
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-834 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 19/03/13
Sample Description: Embankment Borrow Pit Depth :
Sample Location: Pk. 16+800 RHS Offset 100m from PR314
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. A410 A74 B22 A211 A20 A111
99
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
5 20 50
Stress in kg/cm2
4
Stress in kg/cm2
40
Stress in kg/cm2
15
3 30
10
2
20
1 5
10
0
0 5 10 15 0 0
0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
100
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.637 1.743 1.890
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 2.91 13.16 26.78
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.688 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.781 g/cc
16.0
14.0
12.0
10.0
CBR = 6.7%
8.0
6.0
of MDD 90%
4.0
2.0
0.0
1.600 1.650 1.700 1.750 1.800 1.850 1.900
Dry Density g/cc
101
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soil Testing and Georesearch Inc.
# 35 A, 464 Street, Tuol Tumpung I, Chamkar Mon, Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Tel : 088 818 5555, 097 730 0760, Tel/Fax: 855-23 996 804, Email : [email protected], P.O.Box : 2470 Phnom Pe
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
3.4 90 7.70
95
98
100
Remarks:
102
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road:314D
Lab No: LB-836 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 08/03/13 Date Test Start : 25/03/13
Sample Description: Embankment Pit:
Sample Location: PK17+700 LHS Offset 300m Depth:
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7277.1 7417.1 7631.7 7541.6
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3043.6 3043.6 3043.6 3043.6
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4233.5 4373.5 4588.1 4498.0
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 2.012 2.079 2.181 2.138
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 1.941 1.968 2.025 1.958
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. A32 A34 A20 A410
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 502.20 505.70 434.00 538.30
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 485.80 480.70 405.70 495.70
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 16.40 25.00 28.30 42.60
m3 Weight of can g 37.50 37.50 37.40 32.40
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 448.30 443.20 368.30 463.30
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 3.66 5.64 7.68 9.19
2.040
2.020
2.000
Dry Density, g/cc
1.980
MDD = 2.025 g/cc
1.960
OMC = 7.70 %
1.940
1.920
3.50 4.50 5.50 6.50 7.50 8.50
Moisture content %
103
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Plasticity Index Test AASHTO T-89 and T-90
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road:314D
Lab No: LB-836 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 08/03/13 Date Test Start : 25/03/13
Sample Description: Borrow Pit Embankment Pit:
Sample Location: PK17+700 LHS Offset 300m Depth:
Test Method : AASHTO T89 and T90
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 15 25 35 43
Unit Tin No. 23 123 34 56 112 125
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 70.71 70.91 70.47 70.32 40.84 40.64
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 60.91 61.79 61.94 62.13 36.39 36.30
W3 Weight of can g 13.95 13.91 13.95 14.10 14.80 14.85
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 9.80 9.12 8.53 8.19 4.45 4.34
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 46.96 47.88 47.99 48.03 21.59 21.45
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 20.87 19.05 17.77 17.05 20.61 20.23
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 19.00 20.42
PI Plastic Index % -1.42
Atterburg Limit
30
20.6
29
20.1
28
19.6
Moisture content %
27
19.1
26
18.6
25
18.1
24
17.6
23
17.1
22
16.6
21
16.1
20
15.6
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
104
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. PR314D
Lab No: LB-836 Sample 01 Date Sampled : 08/03/13
Sample Description: Borrow Pit Embankment Date Test Start : 25/03/13
Sample Location: PK17+700 LHS Offset 300m Pit:
105
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road:314D
Lab No: LB-836 Sample 01 Date Sampled 08/03/13 Date Test Start : 26/03/13
Sample Description: Borrow Pit Embankment Pit:
Sample Location: PK17+700 LHS Offset 300m Depth :
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. A15 A7 A48 A38 A18 A33
Wet of Can+Wet Materials g 505.70 528.6 527.50 529.60 606.70 566.3
Wt of can +Dry Materials g 475.10 493.2 492.30 496.40 569.10 530.3
Wt of Moisture g 30.60 35.4 35.20 33.2 37.60 36
Wt of can g 36.10 35.6 31.50 31.4 36.50 41.8
Wt of dry materials g 439.00 457.6 460.80 465 532.60 488.5
Moisture content % 6.97 7.74 7.64 7.14 7.06 7.37
Average Moisture Content % 7.35 7.39 7.21
106
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soil Testing and Georesearch Inc.
# 35 A, 464 Street, Tuol Tumpung I, Chamkar Mon, Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Tel : 088 818 5555, 097 730 0760, Tel/Fax: 855-23 996 804, Email : [email protected], P.O.Box : 2470 Phnom Penh 3.
5 16 25
4 14
20
Stress in kg/cm2
4 12
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
3
10 15
3
8
2
6 10
2
1 4
5
1 2
0 0 0
0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10 20
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
107
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.795 1.903 2.067
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 1.75 7.34 12.46
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.823 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.924 g/cc
Plotting value for 98% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.985 g/cc
12
11
10
9
Soaked CBR (%)
8
7 CBR = 3.40%
6
5
4
3
of MDD 90%
2
1
1.780 1.830 1.880 1.930 1.980 2.030 2.080
Dry Density g/cc
108
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
9 90 14.60
95
98
100
Remarks:
109
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 314D
Lab No: LB-835 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 18/03/13
Sample Description: Embankment Borrow Pit (CBF) Borrow Pit: 08
Sample Location: Pk. 23+600 RHS Offset 300m from PR314D Depth : 0 to 1m
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7095.6 7318.6 7363.9 7291.9
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3043.8 3043.8 3043.8 3043.8
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4051.8 4274.8 4320.1 4248.1
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.7 2103.7 2103.7 2103.7
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 1.926 2.032 2.054 2.019
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 1.719 1.780 1.764 1.703
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. B22 A70 A211 A201
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 416.70 406.80 376.20 415.50
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 376.00 360.90 328.50 356.40
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 40.70 45.90 47.70 59.10
m3 Weight of can g 37.60 36.10 38.40 38.70
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 338.40 324.80 290.10 317.70
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 12.03 14.13 16.44 18.60
1.800
1.780
1.760
Dry Density, g/cc
1.740
MDD = 1.783 g/cc
1.720
OMC = 14.60 %
1.700
1.680
11.80 12.80 13.80 14.80 15.80 16.80 17.80 18.80
Moisture content %
110
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Plasticity Index Test AASHTO T-89 and T-90
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 314D
Lab No: LB-835 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 18/03/13
Sample Description: Embankment Borrow Pit (CBF)
Sample Location: Pk. 23+600 RHS Offset 300m from PR314D
Test Method : AASHTO T89 and T90 Depth : 0 to 1m
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 14 25 35 42
Unit Tin No. 74 25 27 122 114 154
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 72.08 74.28 75.86 76.13 45.15 45.25
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 54.72 57.43 59.33 59.96 40.24 40.34
W3 Weight of can g 14.18 14.15 14.22 14.17 14.15 14.35
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 17.36 16.85 16.53 16.17 4.91 4.91
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 40.54 43.28 45.11 45.79 26.09 25.99
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 42.82 38.93 36.64 35.31 18.82 18.89
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 38.75 18.86
PI Plastic Index % 19.89
Atterburg Limit
30
44.0
43.5
29
43.0
42.5
28
42.0
41.5
Moisture content %
27
41.0
40.5
26
40.0
39.5
25
39.0
38.5
24
38.0
37.5
23
37.0
36.5
22
36.0
35.5
21
35.0
34.5
20
34.0
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
111
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 314D
Lab No: LB-835 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 26/02/13
Sample Description: Embankment Borrow Pit (CBF) Date Test Start : 18/03/13
Sample Location: Pk. 23+600 RHS Offset 300m from PR314D
112
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 314D
Lab No: LB-835 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 19/03/13
Sample Description: Embankment Borrow Pit (CBF) Depth : 0 to 1m
Sample Location: Pk. 23+600 RHS Offset 300m from PR314D
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. P90 T55 A111 A4 A23 A20
113
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Stress in kg/cm2
4 12 30
10 25
3
8 20
2 6 15
1 4 10
2 5
0
0 5 10 15 0 0
0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
114
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.514 1.629 1.760
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 3.84 10.83 27.36
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.605 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.694 g/cc
27.0
25.0
23.0
21.0
19.0
Soaked CBR (%)
17.0
15.0
13.0
CBR = 9.00%
11.0
of MDD 90%
9.0
7.0
5.0
3.0
1.510 1.560 1.610 1.660 1.710 1.760
Dry Density g/cc
115
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
90
73 95 9.17
98
100
Remarks:
116
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 13
Lab No: LB-840 Sample No.: S09 Date Sampled : 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 14/03/13
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 98% and Cement 2%) Borrow Pit:
Sample Location: Pk. 11+800 RHS Offset 7000m from PR13 Depth : 1 to 2.0m
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7812.6 7966.5 8155.6 7863.4
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3043.6 3043.6 3043.6 3043.6
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4769.0 4922.9 5112.0 4819.8
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 2.267 2.340 2.430 2.291
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 2.156 2.182 2.221 2.060
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. A34 A75 A0 A12
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 454.90 379.10 389.20 352.10
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 434.50 355.70 358.40 319.90
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 20.40 23.40 30.80 32.20
m3 Weight of can g 37.50 31.70 30.70 32.85
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 397.00 324.00 327.70 287.05
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 5.14 7.22 9.40 11.22
2.260
2.240 y
2.220
y
2.200
2.180
Dry Density, g/cc
2.160
2.140
2.120
MDD = 2.228 g/cc
2.100
OMC = 9.10 %
2.080
2.060
2.040
2.020
5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 11.00 12.00
Moisture content %
117
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Plasticity Index Test AASHTO T-89 and T-90
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 13
Lab No: LB-840 Sample No.: S09 Date Sampled : 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 14/03/13
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 98% and Cement 2%)
Sample Location: Pk. 11+800 RHS Offset 7000m from PR13
Test Method : AASHTO T89 and T90 Depth : 1 to 2.0m
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 15 23 35 45
Unit Tin No. 90 53 42 30 140 52
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 66.86 66.62 66.42 66.30 42.80 43.62
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 55.69 56.10 56.50 56.92 38.96 39.72
W3 Weight of can g 14.14 14.20 14.15 14.18 13.96 14.24
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 11.17 10.52 9.92 9.38 3.84 3.90
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 41.55 41.90 42.35 42.74 25.00 25.48
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 26.88 25.11 23.42 21.95 15.36 15.31
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 24.60 15.33
PI Plastic Index % 9.27
Atterburg Limit
30
27.5
27.0
29
26.5
28
26.0
Moisture content %
27
25.5
25.0
26
24.5
25
24.0
24
23.5
23.0
23
22.5
22
22.0
21
21.5
20
21.0
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
118
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 13
Lab No: LB-840 Sample No.: S09 Date Sampled : 26/02/13
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 98% and Cement 2%) Date Test Start : 14/03/13
Sample Location: Pk. 11+800 RHS Offset 7000m from PR13
119
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 13
Lab No: LB-840 Sample No.: S09 Date Sampled 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 15/03/13
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 98% and Cement 2%) Depth : 1 to 2.0m
Sample Location: Pk. 11+800 RHS Offset 7000m from PR13
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. A12 A22 A20 A74 A211 A410
120
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Stress in kg/cm2
50 100
80
40 80
30 60
60
20 40
40
10 20
20
0
0 5 10 15 0 0
0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
121
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.968 2.088 2.236
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 29.11 67.07 86.51
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.005 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.117 g/cc
85.0
CBR = 73.00%
75.0
Soaked CBR (%)
65.0
95% of MDD=
55.0
45.0
35.0
25.0
1.960 2.010 2.060 2.110 2.160 2.210
Dry Density g/cc
122
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 13
Sample No.01, Date: 26/02/2013, Lab No. 840, Test Date: 16/03/2013 Pit: 1
Test Method: AASHTO T96. Depth : 0
Grading used:__D__, No. of steel ball used: ___8____Nos. Trials No.
Unit
Cycles: 500 1 2 3
A Initial Weight of sample g 5000.50
Remarks:
123
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
90
162 95 9.13
98
100
Remarks:
124
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 13
Lab No: LB-840 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 15/03/13
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 96% and Cement 4%) Depth : 1 to 2.0m
Sample Location: Pk. 11+800 RHS Offset 7000m from PR13
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. C12 A4 A41 T55 A15 A4
Wet of Can+Wet Materials g 284.50 366.40 325.60 374.50 371.50 382.40
Wt of can +Dry Materials g 263.20 338.40 301.00 346.40 343.50 353.50
Wt of Moisture g 21.30 28.00 24.60 28.10 28.00 28.90
Wt of can g 29.62 32.70 31.80 38.60 36.10 36.90
Wt of dry materials g 233.58 305.70 269.20 307.80 307.40 316.60
Moisture content % 9.12 9.16 9.14 9.13 9.11 9.13
Average Moisture Content % 9.14 9.13 9.12
125
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
200
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
100
200
80 150
60 150
100
40 100
20 50
50
0
0 5 10 15 0 0
0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
126
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.946 2.075 2.239
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 72.19 144.97 195.62
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.005 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.117 g/cc
150.0
95% of MDD=
140.0
130.0
120.0
110.0
100.0
90.0
80.0
70.0
1.940 1.990 2.040 2.090 2.140 2.190 2.240
Dry Density g/cc
127
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
90
225 95 9.16
98
100
Remarks:
128
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 13
Lab No: LB-840 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 15/03/13
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 94% and Cement 6%) Depth : 1 to 2.0m
Sample Location: Pk. 11+800 RHS Offset 7000m from PR13
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. C33 A13 B22 A47 A11 A23
Wet of Can+Wet Materials g 299.60 314.80 384.50 380.50 378.60 364.20
Wt of can +Dry Materials g 277.50 291.20 355.30 351.20 350.20 336.90
Wt of Moisture g 22.10 23.60 29.20 29.30 28.40 27.30
Wt of can g 36.45 33.70 37.60 30.90 38.70 38.50
Wt of dry materials g 241.05 257.50 317.70 320.30 311.50 298.40
Moisture content % 9.17 9.17 9.19 9.15 9.12 9.15
Average Moisture Content % 9.17 9.17 9.13
129
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
300
Stress in kg/cm2
120
200 250
100
80 150 200
60 150
100
40 100
20 50
50
0
0 5 10 15 0 0
0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
130
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.966 2.083 2.234
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 99.55 204.93 257.33
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.005 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.117 g/cc
190.0
180.0 95% of MDD=
170.0
160.0
150.0
140.0
130.0
120.0
110.0
100.0
90.0
1.960 2.010 2.060 2.110 2.160 2.210
Dry Density g/cc
131
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
90
69 95 7.94
98
100
Remarks:
132
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 13
Lab No: LB-841 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 14/03/13
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 98% and Cement 2%) Borrow Pit:
Sample Location: Pk. 20+100 RHS Offset 4700m from PR13 Depth : 1 to 2.0m
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7752.6 8002.0 8106.7 7822.9
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3043.6 3043.6 3043.6 3043.6
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4709.0 4958.4 5063.1 4779.3
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 2.238 2.357 2.407 2.272
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 2.141 2.203 2.223 2.051
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. A03 A23 A79 A47
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 355.80 394.60 391.60 383.30
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 341.70 371.40 364.40 349.10
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 14.10 23.20 27.20 34.20
m3 Weight of can g 32.80 38.50 35.80 30.90
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 308.90 332.90 328.60 318.20
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 4.56 6.97 8.28 10.75
2.260
2.240
2.220
2.200
Dry Density, g/cc
2.180
2.160
2.140 MDD = 2.230 g/cc
2.120
OMC = 7.90 %
2.100
2.080
2.060
2.040
4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 11.00
Moisture content %
133
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Plasticity Index Test AASHTO T-89 and T-90
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 13
Lab No: LB-841 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 14/03/13
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 98% and Cement 2%)
Sample Location: Pk. 20+100 RHS Offset 4700m from PR13
Test Method : AASHTO T89 and T90 Depth : 1 to 2.0m
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 15 23 33 45
Unit Tin No. 82 125 194 157 126 28
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 76.86 76.60 76.44 76.32 44.80 43.87
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 63.34 63.75 64.10 64.48 41.16 40.24
W3 Weight of can g 14.58 14.46 14.66 14.60 14.00 14.28
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 13.52 12.85 12.34 11.84 3.64 3.63
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 48.76 49.29 49.44 49.88 27.16 25.96
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 27.73 26.07 24.96 23.74 13.40 13.98
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 25.80 13.69
PI Plastic Index % 12.11
Atterburg Limit
30
28.5
28.0
29
27.5
28
27.0
Moisture content %
27
26.5
26
26.0
25
25.5
24
25.0
23
24.5
22
24.0
21
23.5
20
23.0
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
134
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 13
Lab No: LB-841 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 26/02/13
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 98% and Cement 2%) Date Test Start : 14/03/13
Sample Location: Pk. 20+100 RHS Offset 4700m from PR13
135
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 13
Lab No: LB-841 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 15/03/13
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 98% and Cement 2%) Depth : 1 to 2.0m
Sample Location: Pk. 20+100 RHS Offset 4700m from PR13
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. A21 A24 T55 A41 P90 A15
136
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
140
50 100
120
Stress in kg/cm2
40 80
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
100
30 60 80
20 40 60
40
10
20
20
0
0 5 10 15 0 0
0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
137
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.944 2.062 2.247
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 25.62 57.05 84.18
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.007 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.119 g/cc
80.0
CBR = 69.00%
70.0
Soaked CBR (%)
50.0
40.0
30.0
20.0
1.940 1.990 2.040 2.090 2.140 2.190 2.240
Dry Density g/cc
138
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 13
Sample No.01, Date: 26/02/2013, Lab No. 841, Test Date: 16/03/2013 Pit: 1
Test Method: AASHTO T96. Depth : 0
Grading used:__D__, No. of steel ball used: ___8____Nos. Trials No.
Unit
Cycles: 500 1 2 3
A Initial Weight of sample g 5001.80
Remarks:
139
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
90
166 95 7.94
98
100
Remarks:
140
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 13
Lab No: LB-841 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 15/03/13
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 96% and Cement 4%) Depth : 1 to 2.0m
Sample Location: Pk. 20+100 RHS Offset 4700m from PR13
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. A72 A05 A78 A7 A79 A4
Wet of Can+Wet Materials g 362.50 320.80 448.60 363.20 304.50 307.20
Wt of can +Dry Materials g 338.20 299.70 418.10 339.10 284.80 287.40
Wt of Moisture g 24.30 21.10 30.50 24.10 19.70 19.80
Wt of can g 33.80 34.78 34.90 35.60 35.80 36.90
Wt of dry materials g 304.40 264.92 383.20 303.50 249.00 250.50
Moisture content % 7.98 7.96 7.96 7.94 7.91 7.90
Average Moisture Content % 7.97 7.95 7.91
141
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
100 250
Stress in kg/cm2
200
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
80 200
150
60
150
40 100
100
20 50
50
0
0 5 10 15 0 0
0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
142
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.963 2.081 2.233
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 71.03 149.62 189.21
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.007 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.119 g/cc
180.0
CBR = 166.00%
170.0
160.0
150.0
Soaked CBR (%)
130.0
120.0
110.0
100.0
90.0
80.0
70.0
1.960 2.010 2.060 2.110 2.160 2.210
Dry Density g/cc
143
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
90
215 95 7.91
98
100
Remarks:
144
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No. 13
Lab No: LB-841 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled 26/02/13 Date Test Start : 15/03/13
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 94% and Cement 6%) Depth : 1 to 2.0m
Sample Location: Pk. 20+100 RHS Offset 4700m from PR13
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. A14 A05 A11 A37 A48 A33
145
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
120
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
250 250
100
200 200
80
60 150 150
40 100 100
20 50 50
0
0 5 10 15 0 0
0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
146
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.955 2.091 2.247
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 105.96 203.18 248.01
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.007 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.119 g/cc
200.0
of MDD 95%
190.0
180.0
170.0
160.0
150.0
140.0
130.0
120.0
110.0
100.0
1.950 2.000 2.050 2.100 2.150 2.200 2.250
Dry Density g/cc
147
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
90
95
96 98 6.54
100
Remarks:
148
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Lab No: Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013 Date Test Start : 26/2/2013
Sample Description: Base Course (Bratheat)
Sample Location: NR 7 Pk. 158+500 Turn Left to NR 73 Pk. 3+300 RHS Offset 100m (N=1312831, E=583968)
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7764.8 7981.3 8162.8 8178.5
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3082.0 3082.0 3082.0 3082.0
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4682.8 4899.3 5080.8 5096.5
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 2.226 2.329 2.415 2.423
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 2.173 2.231 2.267 2.227
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. A03 A18 A47 A11
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 311.20 468.00 444.60 595.10
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 304.60 449.90 419.20 549.80
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 6.60 18.10 25.40 45.30
m3 Weight of can g 35.10 36.00 30.90 34.99
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 269.50 413.90 388.30 514.81
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 2.45 4.37 6.54 8.80
2.280
2.260
2.240
Dry Density, g/cc
2.180
2.160
2.30 3.30 4.30 5.30 6.30 7.30 8.30
Moisture content %
149
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Plasticity Index Test AASHTO T-89 and T-90
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Lab No: Date Sampled : 24/2/2013 Date Test Start : 26/2/2013
Sample Description: Base Course (Bratheat)
Sample Location: NR 7 Pk. 158+500 Turn Left to NR 73 Pk. 3+300 RHS Offset 100m (N=1312831, E=583968)
Test Method : AASHTO T89 and T90
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 15 20 25 31
Unit Tin No. R1 T3 D4 D6 I37 C5
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 39.64 40.26 40.83 40.70 61.97 51.92
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 36.35 36.42 36.89 36.91 58.90 48.93
W3 Weight of can g 23.92 21.26 20.75 20.82 40.40 29.83
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 3.29 3.84 3.94 3.79 3.07 2.99
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 12.43 15.16 16.14 16.09 18.50 19.10
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 26.47 25.33 24.41 23.56 16.59 15.65
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 24.40 16.12
PI Plastic Index % 8.28
Atterburg Limit
30
27.0
29
26.5
28
26.0
Moisture content %
27
25.5
26
25
25.0
24
24.5
23
24.0
22
23.5
21
20
23.0
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
150
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
151
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. C13 C9 C2 C3 C07 D3
Wet of Can+Wet Materials g 316.00 340.80 364.20 405.40 408.50 311.40
Wt of can +Dry Materials g 298.30 321.60 343.70 382.50 385.00 293.70
Wt of Moisture g 17.70 19.20 20.50 22.90 23.50 17.70
Wt of can g 28.90 28.35 28.48 29.70 28.85 21.84
Wt of dry materials g 269.40 293.25 315.22 352.80 356.15 271.86
Moisture content % 6.57 6.55 6.50 6.49 6.60 6.51
Average Moisture Content % 6.56 6.50 6.55
152
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
35
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
100
30 200
25 80
150
20 60
15 100
40
10 50
20
5
0 0
0
0 5 10 15 0 5 10 15
0 5 10 15
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
153
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 2.015 2.139 2.285
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 18.47 83.84 133.90
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.041 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.155 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.223 g/cc
130
120
110
90
80 of MDD 98%
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
2.010 2.060 2.110 2.160 2.210 2.260
Dry Density g/cc
154
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Resistance to Degradation of Small Size Aggregate by Abrasion and Impact in the Los Angeles
Machine ( AASHTO T 96)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Remarks:
155
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
Soundness of Aggregate by use of Sodium Sulphate (T 104)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Sample Descriptions: Base Course (Bratheat)
Sample No.01, Date: 24/02/2013, Lab No.807, Test Date: 05/03/2013
25 mm------------19.0 mm 500 ± 30
156
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
Determination of Sprcific Gravity and Absorption of Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Data Sheet
Pycnometer No. Determination No.
Average
1 2 3
0
T Temperature of Water during testing C 26 26 26 26
GT Specific Gravity of Water at T 0C - 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968
A1 Weigth of Oven Dry sampel+Container g 3416.20 2975.10 3315.20 3235.50
A2 Weight of Container g 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00
A Weigth of oven dry sample in air =(A1-A2) g 3316.20 2875.10 3215.20 3135.50
B Weight of SSD Specimen in air g 3327.20 2890.60 3226.80 3148.20
C Weight of SSD Specimen in water g 2033.40 1767.60 1970.50 1923.83
Specific Gravity:
Bulk Sp. Gravity (Oven Dry Basis)
- 2.561 2.558 2.557 2.559
=A/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Bulk Sp. Gravity (SSD Basis)
- 2.570 2.572 2.566 2.569
=B/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Apparent Sp. Gravity=A/(A-C)*(GT/G23) - 2.583 2.594 2.581 2.586
157
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
90
80 95 5.92
98
100
Remarks:
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
158
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7659.9 7959.1 8024.9 7910.0
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3082.0 3082.0 3082.0 3082.0
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4577.9 4877.1 4942.9 4828.0
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 2.176 2.318 2.350 2.295
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 2.107 2.202 2.184 2.099
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. I31 I37 I38 I40
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 266.40 453.00 470.40 497.40
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 259.10 432.30 439.90 458.00
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 7.30 20.70 30.50 39.40
m3 Weight of can g 35.60 40.40 37.60 35.80
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 223.50 391.90 402.30 422.20
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 3.27 5.28 7.58 9.33
2.240
2.220
2.200
Dry Density, g/cc
2.180
2.100
2.080
3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00
Moisture content %
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
159
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows 15 20 25 30
Unit Tin No. I8 I25 I29 I26 I16 I4
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g 47.07 47.36 46.74 48.35 48.47 49.21
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g 43.65 43.94 43.50 45.01 45.95 46.35
W3 Weight of can g 29.58 29.26 29.10 29.71 30.76 28.68
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g 3.42 3.42 3.24 3.34 2.52 2.86
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g 14.07 14.68 14.40 15.30 15.19 17.67
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) % 24.31 23.30 22.50 21.83 16.59 16.19
LL Liquit limit (from graph) % 22.50 16.39
PI Plastic Index % 6.11
Atterburg Limit
30
25.0
29
24.5
28
24.0
Moisture content %
27
23.5
26
25
23.0
24
22.5
23
22.0
22
21.5
21
20
21.0
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
160
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
161
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. A29 A11 A2 A20 A10 A23
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
162
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
50 140 160
45 140
120
40
Stress in kg/cm2
120
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
35 100
30 100
80
25 80
60
20 60
15 40 40
10
20 20
5
0 0 0
0 20 0 20 0 20
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
163
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.977 2.104 2.215
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 23.09 81.27 97.11
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.987 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.098 g/cc
100
90 % CBR = 80.00
80
Soaked CBR (%)
70
60 of MDD 95%
50
40
30
20
1.950 2.000 2.050 2.100 2.150 2.200
Dry Density g/cc
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
164
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Resistance to Degradation of Small Size Aggregate by Abrasion and Impact in the Los Angeles
Machine ( AASHTO T 96)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Sub-Consultant: Sakor Co.,Ltd Road No.
Sample Descriptions: Base Course from NR 7 Pk. 132+100 RHS Offset 1.3Km (N=1319525, E=559007)
Remarks:
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
165
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Soundness of Aggregate by use of Sodium Sulphate (T 104)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Sample Descriptions: Base Course from NR 7 Pk. 132+100 RHS Offset 1.3Km (N=1319525, E=559007)
25 mm------------19.0 mm 500 ± 30
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
166
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Determination of Sprcific Gravity and Absorption of Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Sample Descriptions: Base Course from NR 7 Pk. 132+100 RHS Offset 1.3Km (N=1319525, E=559007)
Sample No.01, Date: 24/2/2013, Lab No., Test Date: 26/2/2013
Test Method:AASHTO T85,
Data Sheet
Pycnometer No. Determination No.
Average
1 2 3
0
T Temperature of Water during testing C 26 26 26 26
GT Specific Gravity of Water at T 0C - 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968
A1 Weigth of Oven Dry sampel+Container g 3369.40 3564.70 3105.80 3346.63
A2 Weight of Container g 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00
A Weigth of oven dry sample in air =(A1-A2) g 3269.40 3464.70 3005.80 3246.63
B Weight of SSD Specimen in air g 3281.80 3478.90 3018.60 3259.77
C Weight of SSD Specimen in water g 2003.60 2126.50 1842.60 1990.90
Specific Gravity:
Bulk Sp. Gravity (Oven Dry Basis)
- 2.556 2.560 2.554 2.557
=A/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Bulk Sp. Gravity (SSD Basis)
- 2.565 2.570 2.565 2.567
=B/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Apparent Sp. Gravity=A/(A-C)*(GT/G23) - 2.581 2.587 2.582 2.583
167
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Roads Improvement Project (PRIP).
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
90
95
94 98 6.63
100
Remarks:
168
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Roads Improvement Project (PRIP).
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Lab No: Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013 Date Test Start : 26/2/2013
Sample Description: Base Course Depth :
Sample Location: NR.1, Pk. 71+050 LHS Offset 4.0Km (E=540459,N=1242418)
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7288.1 7528.9 7581.0 7392.5
W2 Wt.of Mould g 2599.0 2599.0 2599.0 2599.0
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4689.1 4929.9 4982.0 4793.5
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2118.0 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 2.214 2.343 2.368 2.279
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 2.129 2.211 2.208 2.073
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. A37 A18 A38 A10
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 469.40 550.70 623.50 548.10
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 452.60 521.70 583.50 501.90
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 16.80 29.00 40.00 46.20
m3 Weight of can g 31.10 36.50 30.50 35.50
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 421.50 485.20 553.00 466.40
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 3.99 5.98 7.23 9.91
2.270
2.250
2.230
2.210
Dry Density, g/cc
2.190
2.170
2.090
2.070
2.050
3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00
Moisture content %
169
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Roads Improvement Project (PRIP).
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Lab No: Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled 24/2/2013 Date Test Start : 27/02/13
Sample Description: Base Course Depth :
Sample Location: NR.1, Pk. 71+050 LHS Offset 4.0Km (E=540459,N=1242418)
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. A70 A77 A29 A11 A78 A4
170
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Roads Improvement Project (PRIP).
120
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
70 140
60 100 120
50 80 100
40 60 80
30 60
40
20 40
10 20
20
0 0 0
0 10 20 0 10 20 0 10 20
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
171
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.916 2.028 2.231
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 49.84 72.19 100.14
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 1.998 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.109 g/cc
Plotting value for 98% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.176 g/cc
100.0
80.0
of MDD 98%
70.0
60.0
50.0
40.0
1.910 1.960 2.010 2.060 2.110 2.160 2.210
Dry Density g/cc
172
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Roads Improvement Project (PRIP).
Plasticity Index Test AASHTO T-89 and T-90
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Lab No: Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013 Date Test Start : 26/2/2013
Sample Description: Base Course
Sample Location: NR.1, Pk. 71+050 LHS Offset 4.0Km (E=540459,N=1242418)
Test Method : AASHTO T89 and T90 Depth : 0
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows
Unit Tin No.
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g
W3 Weight of can g
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) %
LL Liquit limit (from graph) %
PI Plastic Index %
Atterburg Limit
30
58.0
29
57.0
28
Moisture content %
56.0
27
26
55.0
25
54.0
24
23
53.0
22
52.0
21
20
51.0
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberof
ofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
173
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Roads Improvement Project (PRIP).
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Lab No: 808 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013
Sample Description: Base Course Date Test Start : 26/2/2013
Sample Location: NR.1, Pk. 71+050 LHS Offset 4.0Km (E=540459,N=1242418)
174
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Roads Improvement Project (PRIP).
Resistance to Degradation of Small Size Aggregate by Abrasion and Impact in the Los Angeles
Machine ( AASHTO T 96)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.:
Lab No: Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013 Date Test Start : 26/2/2013
Data Sheet
Grading used:__A__, No. of steel ball used: ___12____Nos. Trials No.
Unit
Cycles: 500 1 2 3
A Initial Weight of sample g 5003.80
Remarks:
175
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Roads Improvement Project (PRIP).
Soundness of Aggregate by use of Sodium Sulphate (T 104)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Lab No: Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013 Date Test Start : 26/2/2013
25 mm------------19.0 mm 500 ± 30
176
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Roads Improvement Project (PRIP).
Determination of Sprcific Gravity and Absorption of Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.:
Lab No: Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013
Sample Description: Base Course Date Test Start : 26/2/2013
Sample Location: NR.1, Pk. 71+050 LHS Offset 4.0Km (E=540459,N=1242418)
Data Sheet
Pycnometer No. Determination No.
Average
1 2 3
0
T Temperature of Water during testing C 26 26 26 26
0
GT Specific Gravity of Water at T C - 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968
A1 Weigth of Oven Dry sampel+Container g 3369.40 3564.70 3105.80 3346.63
A2 Weight of Container g 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00
A Weigth of oven dry sample in air =(A1-A2) g 3269.40 3464.70 3005.80 3246.63
B Weight of SSD Specimen in air g 3281.80 3478.90 3018.60 3259.77
C Weight of SSD Specimen in water g 2003.60 2126.50 1842.60 1990.90
Specific Gravity:
Bulk Sp. Gravity (Oven Dry Basis)
- 2.556 2.560 2.554 2.557
=A/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Bulk Sp. Gravity (SSD Basis)
- 2.565 2.570 2.565 2.567
=B/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Apparent Sp. Gravity=A/(A-C)*(GT/G23) - 2.581 2.587 2.582 2.583
177
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
CBR Reporting:
At % of Specified Dry
CBR (%) Moisture Content (MC) at Moulding (%)
Density(AASHTO T-193)
90
96 95 7.71
98
100
Remarks:
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
178
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship(AASHTO T-180) for CBR Test
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Lab No: Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013 Date Test Start : 26/2/2013
Sample Description: Base Course (Treung)
Sample Location: NR 7 Pk. 103+900 RHS Offset 100m (N=1332446, E=536230)
Weight of Rammer: 4.54 kg ,Free fall height = 457 mm with a flat circular face of dia: 50.8 mm
Determination of Density
Trial No. I II III IV V
W1 Wt.of wet compacted material+mould g 7816.2 7920.2 8118.8 8150.0
W2 Wt.of Mould g 3082.0 3082.0 3082.0 3082.0
W3 Wt.of wet compacted materials(W1-W2) g 4734.2 4838.2 5036.8 5068.0
Vm Volume of Mould(by filling water) cc 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8 2103.8
γwd Wet Density = W3 / Vm g/cc 2.250 2.300 2.394 2.409
γdd Dry Density = γwd / (1 + mc / 100) g/cc 2.172 2.179 2.227 2.197
Determination of Moisture Content :
Can Nos. A05 A18 C9 I39
m Wt.of weight matrial+ Can g 288.70 488.70 437.10 527.00
m1 Wt.of dry material + Can g 279.90 465.00 408.50 484.20
m2 Weight of water (m-m 1) g 8.80 23.70 28.60 42.80
m3 Weight of can g 34.80 35.56 28.35 40.60
md Weight of dry material(m 1-m 3) g 245.10 429.44 380.15 443.60
mc Moisture Content (m 2 /m d) x100 % 3.59 5.52 7.52 9.65
2.240
2.220
Dry Density, g/cc
2.200
MDD = 2.228 g/cc
2.180
OMC = 7.70 %
2.160
2.140
3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00
Moisture content %
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
179
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Plasticity Index Test AASHTO T-89 and T-90
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Lab No: Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013 Date Test Start : 26/2/2013
Sample Description: Base Course (Treung)
Sample Location: NR 7 Pk. 103+900 RHS Offset 100m (N=1332446, E=536230)
Test Method : AASHTO T89 and T90
Data Sheet
Liquit Limit (LL)
Plstic Limit (PI)
Number of blows
Unit Tin No.
W1 Weight of can + Wet soil g
W2 Weight of can + Dry soil g
W3 Weight of can g
W4 Weight of water = (W1-W2) g
W5 Weight of dry soil = (W2-W3) g
W6 Moisture content =(W4/W5*100) %
LL Liquit limit (from graph) %
PI Plastic Index %
Atterburg Limit
30
27.0
29
26.5
28
26.0
Moisture content %
27
25.5
26
25
25.0
24
24.5
23
24.0
22
23.5
21
20
23.0
11 10
10 100
Number
Numberofofblows
blows(in
(inLL
LLDevice)
Device)
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
180
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Lab No: Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013
Sample Description: Base Course (Treung) Date Test Start : 26/2/2013
Sample Location: NR 7 Pk. 103+900 RHS Offset 100m (N=1332446, E=536230)
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
181
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Moisture-Density Relationship for Different Blows in CBR Test(T-193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Lab No: Sample No.: S01Date Sampled : 24/2/2013Date Test Start : 26/2/2013
Sample Description: Base Course (Treung)
Sample Location: NR 7 Pk. 103+900 RHS Offset 100m (N=1332446, E=536230)
DETERMINATION OF DENSITY
MOISTURE DETERMINATION
No. of blows per layer 10 30 65
Moisture Can No. I32 A36 A23 A7 A18 A5
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
182
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Determination of California Bearing Ratio(CBR) ( AASHTO T 193)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Lab No: Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013 Date Test Start : 26/2/2013
Sample Description: Base Course (Treung)
Sample Location: NR 7 Pk. 103+900 RHS Offset 100m (N=1332446, E=536230)
Soaking started on: 27/2/2013CBR Testing Date: 3/3/2013 MDD(g/cc): 2.228 OMC(%): 7.7
CBR Test (T193): Swell and Pennetration Data
SWELL DATA Surcharge Weights: 4.581 kg
Mld. No.1 Ht(mm) = 116.43 Mld. No.2 Ht(mm) = 116.43 Mld. No.3 Ht(mm) = 116.43
Date Time Remarks
Reading in mm Swell % Reading in mm Swell % Reading in mm Swell %
27/2/13 Start 4.85 0 6.00 0 1.58 0
28/2/13 4.91 0.05 6.01 0.01 1.59 0.01
1/3/2013 4.92 0.06 6.02 0.02 1.59 0.01
2/3/2013 4.94 0.08 6.02 0.02 1.60 0.02
3/3/2013 Ended 4.95 0.09 6.03 0.03 1.61 0.03
.
Proving Ring Reading and Stress
Penetration
Mould No. (10 Blows) Mould No. (30 Blows) Mould No. (65 Blows)
Dial Stress in Dial Stress in Dial Stress in
inch mm Load in kN Load in kN Load in kN
Reading kg/cm2 Reading kg/cm2 Reading kg/cm2
0.000 0.00 0 0.0000 0.000 0 0.0000 0.000 0 0.0000 0.000
0.025 0.64 28 1.2880 6.788 220 5.1040 26.897 305 7.0760 37.289
0.050 1.27 43 1.9780 10.424 359 8.3288 43.891 495 11.4840 60.519
0.075 1.91 61 2.8060 14.787 479 11.1128 58.562 620 14.3840 75.801
0.100 2.54 95 4.370 23.029 570 13.2240 69.688 755 17.5160 92.306
0.150 3.81 124 5.7040 30.059 657 15.2424 80.325 887 20.5784 108.444
0.200 5.08 164 7.5440 39.756 785 18.2120 95.974 1020 23.6640 124.705
0.250 6.35 189 8.6940 45.816 876 20.3232 107.100 1185 27.4920 144.878
0.300 7.62 210 9.6600 50.906 975 22.6200 119.203 1354 31.4128 165.540
0.350 8.89 235 10.8100 56.967 1054 24.4528 128.862 1486 34.4752 181.678
0.400 10.16 259 11.9140 62.785 1125 26.1000 137.542 1600 37.1200 195.616
60 140
200
120
Stress in kg/cm2
50
Stress in kg/cm2
Stress in kg/cm2
100 150
40
80
30 100
60
20 40
50
10 20
0 0
0 0 5 10 15
0 5 10 15
0 5 10 15
Penetration mm Penetration in mm Penetration in mm
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
183
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
CBR Test (AASHTO T193)
6
CBR Calculation : 10 Blows 30 Blows 65 Blows 7
Stress at 2.54mm= 23.029 Stress at 2.54mm= 69.6881 Stress at 2.54 mm= 92.306
kg/cm2 kg/cm 2 kg/cm 2
CBR Caculations from CBR = 32.72 % CBR = 99.02 % CBR = 131.154 %
corrected load / stress of Form
Stress at 5.08mm= 39.756 Stress at 5.08mm= 95.974 Stress at 5.08mm= 124.705
No. 9A graphs
kg/cm2 kg/cm2 kg/cm2
CBR = 37.86 % CBR = 91.40 % CBR = 118.77 %
No.of blows 10 30 65
Moisture-Density Data from sheet " CBR MD"
Dry-Density , g / cc 1.953 2.097 2.230
Corresponding CBR from 2.54mm penetration level Corrected CBR ( %) 37.86 91.40 118.77
Plotting value for 90% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.005 g/cc
Plotting value for 95% of Maximum Dry Density (MDD) 2.117 g/cc
120
110
% CBR = 96.00
100
90
Soaked CBR (%)
80
of MDD 95%
70
60
50
40
30
1.950 2.000 2.050 2.100 2.150 2.200
Dry Density g/cc
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
184
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Resistance to Degradation of Small Size Aggregate by Abrasion and Impact in the Los Angeles
Machine ( AASHTO T 96)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Sample Descriptions: Base Course from NR 7 Pk. 103+900 RHS Offset 100m (N=1332446, E=536230)
Remarks:
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
185
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
Soundness of Aggregate by use of Sodium Sulphate (T 104)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.
Sample Descriptions: Base Course from NR 7 Pk. 103+900 RHS Offset 100m (N=1332446, E=536230)
25 mm------------19.0 mm 500 ± 30
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
186
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Figure No.11 Laboratory Test Results of Aggregate 12.5mm & 19mm
Data Sheet
Pycnometer No. Determination No.
Average
1 2 3
0
T Temperature of Water during testing C 26 26 26 26
GT Specific Gravity of Water at T 0C - 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968
A1 Weigth of Oven Dry sampel+Container g 2546.80 2845.60 2633.50 2675.30
A2 Weight of Container g 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00
A Weigth of oven dry sample in air =(A1-A2) g 2446.80 2745.60 2533.50 2575.30
B Weight of SSD Specimen in air g 2467.50 2768.60 2556.90 2597.67
C Weight of SSD Specimen in water g 1549.80 1737.30 1604.40 1630.50
Specific Gravity:
Bulk Sp. Gravity (Oven Dry Basis)
- 2.664 2.660 2.658 2.661
=A/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Bulk Sp. Gravity (SSD Basis)
- 2.687 2.682 2.682 2.684
=B/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Apparent Sp. Gravity=A/(A-C)*(GT/G23) - 2.726 2.721 2.725 2.724
187
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Resistance to Degradation of Small Size Aggregate by Abrasion and Impact in the Los Angeles
Machine ( AASHTO T 96)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd
Remarks:
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
188
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Sample Descriptions: Aggregate 12.5 mm Location: Pk. 132+100 RHS Offset 1.0Km
Sampling Date: 24/02/2013 Test Date: 5/3/2013
Fraction Size Sieve Sizes (mm) Test Weight Wt.Passing Flaky Test Weight Wt.Passing Elongation
50-37.5
28-20
20-14
Minimum
14-10 1000.0 504.4 50.44% 1000.0 46.1 4.61%
>5<15%100pieces
10-6.3 500.5 178.6 35.68% 500.5 164.6 32.89%
Minimum
NOTE:
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
189
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
g j ( )
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd
Lab No: LB-807 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013
Sample Description: Aggregate 12.5 mm Date Test Start : 05/03/13
Sample Location: Pk. 132+100 RHS Offset 1.0Km (Sre Siem Quarry)
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
190
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soundness of Aggregate by use of Sodium Sulphate (T 104)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd
Sample Descriptions: Aggregate 12.5mm
Sample No.01, Date: 24/02/2013, Lab No.807, Test Date: 05/03/2013
25 mm------------19.0 mm 500 ± 30
191
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Data Sheet
192
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Data Sheet
Pycnometer No. Determination No.
Average
1 2 3
0
T Temperature of Water during testing C 26 26 26 26
GT Specific Gravity of Water at T 0C - 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968
A1 Weigth of Oven Dry sampel+Container g 2457.50 2633.50 2415.60 2502.20
A2 Weight of Container g 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00
A Weigth of oven dry sample in air =(A1-A2) g 2357.50 2533.50 2315.60 2402.20
B Weight of SSD Specimen in air g 2375.60 2548.90 2326.30 2416.93
C Weight of SSD Specimen in water g 1489.80 1598.30 1454.40 1514.17
Specific Gravity:
Bulk Sp. Gravity (Oven Dry Basis)
- 2.659 2.663 2.654 2.659
=A/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Bulk Sp. Gravity (SSD Basis)
- 2.680 2.679 2.666 2.675
=B/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Apparent Sp. Gravity=A/(A-C)*(GT/G23) - 2.715 2.707 2.687 2.703
193
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Resistance to Degradation of Small Size Aggregate by Abrasion and Impact in the Los Angeles
Machine ( AASHTO T 96)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd
Remarks:
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
194
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Fraction Size Sieve Sizes (mm) Test Weight Wt.Passing Flaky Test Weight Wt.Passing Elongation
(g) (g) (%) (g) (g) (%)
50-37.5
NOTE:
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
195
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Soundness of Aggregate by use of Sodium Sulphate (T 104)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd
Sample Descriptions: Aggregate 19mm
Totals =
25 mm------------19.0 mm 500 ± 30
196
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Data Sheet
197
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
g j ( )
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd
Lab No: LB-807 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013
Sample Description: Aggregate19 mm Date Test Start : 05/03/13
Sample Location: Pk. 132+100 RHS Offset 1.0Km (Sre Siem Quarry)
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
198
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Data Sheet
Pycnometer No. Determination No.
Average
1 2 3
0
T Temperature of Water during testing C 26 26 26 26
GT Specific Gravity of Water at T 0C - 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968
A1 Weigth of Oven Dry sampel+Container g 2715.40 2633.70 2126.80 2491.97
A2 Weight of Container g 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00
A Weigth of oven dry sample in air =(A1-A2) g 2615.40 2533.70 2026.80 2391.97
B Weight of SSD Specimen in air g 2626.10 2542.50 2033.20 2400.60
C Weight of SSD Specimen in water g 1603.30 1554.10 1240.80 1466.07
Specific Gravity:
Bulk Sp. Gravity (Oven Dry Basis)
- 2.555 2.561 2.556 2.557
=A/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Bulk Sp. Gravity (SSD Basis)
- 2.566 2.570 2.564 2.567
=B/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Apparent Sp. Gravity=A/(A-C)*(GT/G23) - 2.582 2.584 2.577 2.581
199
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Remarks:
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
200
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Fraction Size Sieve Sizes (mm) Test Weight Wt.Passing Flaky Test Weight Wt.Passing Elongation
50-37.5
28-20
20-14
Minimum
14-10 1000.0 523 52.30% 1000.0 43.2 4.32%
>5<15%100pieces
10-6.3 500.5 167 33.37% 500.5 159.7 31.91%
Minimum
NOTE:
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
201
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
g j ( )
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd
Lab No: LB-807 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013
Sample Description: Aggregate 12.5 mm Date Test Start : 05/03/13
Sample Location: Base Course (Bratheat)
202
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Data Sheet
203
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
25 mm------------19.0 mm 500 ± 30
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
204
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
g j ( )
Sieve Analysis of Fine and Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd
Lab No: LB-807 Sample No.: S01 Date Sampled : 24/2/2013
Sample Description: Aggregate19 mm Date Test Start : 05/03/13
Sample Location: Base Course (Bratheat)
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
205
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Data Sheet
Pycnometer No. Determination No.
Average
1 2 3
0
T Temperature of Water during testing C 26 26 26 26
GT Specific Gravity of Water at T 0C - 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968
A1 Weigth of Oven Dry sampel+Container g 2457.50 2633.50 2415.60 2502.20
A2 Weight of Container g 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00
A Weigth of oven dry sample in air =(A1-A2) g 2357.50 2533.50 2315.60 2402.20
B Weight of SSD Specimen in air g 2375.60 2548.90 2326.30 2416.93
C Weight of SSD Specimen in water g 1489.80 1598.30 1454.40 1514.17
Specific Gravity:
Bulk Sp. Gravity (Oven Dry Basis)
- 2.659 2.663 2.654 2.659
=A/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Bulk Sp. Gravity (SSD Basis)
- 2.680 2.679 2.666 2.675
=B/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Apparent Sp. Gravity=A/(A-C)*(GT/G23) - 2.715 2.707 2.687 2.703
206
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Resistance to Degradation of Small Size Aggregate by Abrasion and Impact in the Los Angeles
Machine ( AASHTO T 96)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd
Remarks:
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
207
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
NOTE:
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
208
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Totals =
25 mm------------19.0 mm 500 ± 30
209
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Test Method:AASHTO T 19
Data Sheet
210
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Roads Improvement Project (PRIP)
Resistance to Degradation of Small Size Aggregate by Abrasion and Impact in the Los Angeles
Machine ( AASHTO T 96)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor : Sakor Co.,Ltd Road No.: 7
Sample Descriptions: Aggregate 12.5mm from NR 7 Pk. 103+900 RHS Offset 100m (N=1332446, E=536230)
Remarks:
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
211
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Roads Improvement Project (PRIP)
Soundness of Aggregate by use of Sodium Sulphate (T 104)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor : Sakor Co.,Ltd Road No.: 7
Sample Descriptions: Aggregate 12.5mm from NR 7 Pk. 103+900 RHS Offset 100m (N=1332446, E=536230)
25 mm------------19.0 mm 500 ± 30
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
212
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Roads Improvement Project (PRIP)
Determination of Sprcific Gravity and Absorption of Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor : Sakor Co.,Ltd Road No.: 7
Sample Descriptions: Aggregate 12.5mm from NR 7 Pk. 103+900 RHS Offset 100m (N=1332446, E=536230)
Data Sheet
Pycnometer No. Determination No.
Average
1 2 3
0
T Temperature of Water during testing C 26 26 26 26
0
GT Specific Gravity of Water at T C - 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968
A1 Weigth of Oven Dry sampel+Container g 2715.40 2633.70 2126.80 2491.97
A2 Weight of Container g 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00
A Weigth of oven dry sample in air =(A1-A2) g 2615.40 2533.70 2026.80 2391.97
B Weight of SSD Specimen in air g 2626.10 2542.50 2033.20 2400.60
C Weight of SSD Specimen in water g 1603.30 1554.10 1240.80 1466.07
Specific Gravity:
Bulk Sp. Gravity (Oven Dry Basis)
- 2.555 2.561 2.556 2.557
=A/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Bulk Sp. Gravity (SSD Basis)
- 2.566 2.570 2.564 2.567
=B/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Apparent Sp. Gravity=A/(A-C)*(GT/G23) - 2.582 2.584 2.577 2.581
213
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Road Improvement Project (PRIP)
ADB Loan No. 2670-CAM (SF)
Resistance to Degradation of Small Size Aggregate by Abrasion and Impact in the Los Angeles
Machine ( AASHTO T 96)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor : Sakor Co.,Ltd Road No.: 7
Sample Descriptions: Aggregate 19mm from NR 7 Pk. 103+900 RHS Offset 100m (N=1332446, E=536230)
Remarks:
Tested by:………….....….…..…………….…………...Date:………….…...………,Signature:………………..
Checked by:………….....….…..……….……………...Date:……….…..…….……,Signature:………………..
214
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Road Improvement Project (PRIP)
Soundness of Aggregate by use of Sodium Sulphate (T 104)
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor : Sakor Co.,Ltd Road No.: 7
Sample Descriptions: Aggregate 19mm from NR 7 Pk. 103+900 RHS Offset 100m (N=1332446, E=536230)
Totals = 0 0
25 mm------------19.0 mm 500 ± 30
Tested by:………….....….…..….……......…….Date:…………….………,Signature:…………..……
Checked by:……...………..……..…..…….…...Date:…………...…….…,Signature:…………………
215
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Provincial Road Improvement Project (PRIP)
Determination of Sprcific Gravity and Absorption of Coarse Aggregate
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor : Sakor Co.,Ltd Road No.: 7
Sample Descriptions: Aggregate 19mm from NR 7 Pk. 103+900 RHS Offset 100m (N=1332446, E=536230)
Sample No.01, Date: 26/02/2013, Lab No., Test Date: 03/03/2013
Test Method:AASHTO T85,
Data Sheet
Pycnometer No. Determination No.
Average
1 2 3
0
T Temperature of Water during testing C 26 26 26 26
0
GT Specific Gravity of Water at T C - 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968 0.9968
A1 Weigth of Oven Dry sampel+Container g 2218.40 2634.70 2489.70 2447.60
A2 Weight of Container g 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00
A Weigth of oven dry sample in air =(A1-A2) g 2118.40 2534.70 2389.70 2347.60
B Weight of SSD Specimen in air g 2126.50 2548.20 2398.10 2357.60
C Weight of SSD Specimen in water g 1299.30 1555.80 1465.80 1440.30
Specific Gravity:
Bulk Sp. Gravity (Oven Dry Basis)
- 2.559 2.552 2.561 2.557
=A/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Bulk Sp. Gravity (SSD Basis)
- 2.569 2.566 2.570 2.568
=B/(B-C)*(GT/G23)
Apparent Sp. Gravity=A/(A-C)*(GT/G23) - 2.584 2.587 2.584 2.585
216
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Figure No.12 Laboratory Test Results of Unconfined Com. Strength
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
UNCONFINED COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.: 13
Lab No. Date Moulded: 3/15/2013 RFT No.
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 98% and Cement 2%)
Sample Location: Pk. 20+100 RHS Offset 4700m from PR13 (X:583708, Y:1267547)
Curing Lab/Field : Laboratory of SARKOR Test Method: AASHTO T-22
Average = 0.000
Witnessed by ……………...….………….Date:………………………………….Signatute:
1 Mpa = 10.1971 Kg/cm2 = 10.2 kgf/cm2 (Say)
217
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
UNCONFINED COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.: 13
Lab No. Date Moulded: 3/6/2013 RFT No.
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 96% and Cement 4%)
Sample Location: Pk. 20+100 RHS Offset 4700m from PR13 (X:583708, Y:1267547)
Curing Lab/Field : Laboratory of SARKOR Test Method: AASHTO T-22
Average = 0.000
Witnessed by ……………...….………….Date:………………………………….Signatute:
1 Mpa = 10.1971 Kg/cm2 = 10.2 kgf/cm2 (Say)
218
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
UNCONFINED COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.: 13
Lab No. Date Moulded: 3/15/2013 RFT No.
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 94% and Cement 6%)
Sample Location: Pk. 20+100 RHS Offset 4700m from PR13 (X:583708, Y:1267547)
Curing Lab/Field : Laboratory of SARKOR Test Method: AASHTO T-22
Dimensions in cm Strength
Compre.
Cylinder Testing Age in Area Load for Cube
Strength Type of Failure
I.D No. date days (cm2) KN (150mm)
L D1 D2 Av.D (MPa)
Mpa
1 22/03/13 7 11.50 10.50 10.50 10.50 86.59 3.4 0.39 0.41 Shear
Average = 0.000
Witnessed by ……………...….………….Date:………………………………….Signatute:
1 Mpa = 10.1971 Kg/cm2 = 10.2 kgf/cm2 (Say)
219
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
UNCONFINED COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.: 13
Lab No. Date Moulded: 3/15/2013 RFT No.
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 98% and Cement 2%)
Sample Location: Pk. 11+800 RHS Offset 7000m from PR13 (X:578904, Y:1275654)
Curing Lab/Field : Laboratory of SARKOR Test Method: AASHTO T-22
Average = 0.762
Witnessed by ……………...….………….Date:………………………………….Signatute:
1 Mpa = 10.1971 Kg/cm2 = 10.2 kgf/cm2 (Say)
220
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
UNCONFINED COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.: 13
Lab No. Date Moulded: 3/6/2013 RFT No.
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 96% and Cement 4%)
Sample Location: Pk. 11+800 RHS Offset 7000m from PR13 (X:578904, Y:1275654)
Curing Lab/Field : Laboratory of SARKOR Test Method: AASHTO T-22
Average = 0.773
Witnessed by ……………...….………….Date:………………………………….Signatute:
1 Mpa = 10.1971 Kg/cm2 = 10.2 kgf/cm2 (Say)
221
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
PROVINCIAL ROADS IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
UNCONFINED COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH
ADB LOAN NO. 2839-CAM (SF) Contractor: Sarkor., Co.,Ltd Road No.: 13
Lab No. Date Moulded: 3/15/2013 RFT No.
Sample Description: Sub Base (Laterite 94% and Cement 6%)
Sample Location: Pk. 11+800 RHS Offset 7000m from PR13 (X:578904, Y:1275654)
Curing Lab/Field : Laboratory of SARKOR Test Method: AASHTO T-22
Dimensions in cm Strength
Compre.
Cylinder Testing Age in Area Load for Cube
Strength Type of Failure
I.D No. date days (cm2) KN (150mm)
L D1 D2 Av.D (MPa)
Mpa
1 22/03/13 7 11.50 10.50 10.50 10.50 86.59 35.7 4.12 4.29 Shear
Average = 0.763
Witnessed by ……………...….………….Date:………………………………….Signatute:
1 Mpa = 10.1971 Kg/cm2 = 10.2 kgf/cm2 (Say)
222
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Figure13. Field investigation activities:
223
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
224
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Figure14. Sampling of Sub-base Materials:
225
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Figure15. Crushing Plant:
Crushing Plant:
226
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Crushing Plant:
227
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Crushing Plant:
228
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part A Roads
Figure16. Laboratory activities:
229
PART B
BRIDGES
CONTENTS Page
I. General 1
1. Introduction 1
2. Geology and Landform 1
III. Findings 5
1. Subsoil Condition 5
2. Underground Water Condition 6
V. Appendices 9
I. General
1. Introduction
The Consultants undertook subsurface soil investigation for this particular project
of Provincial Roads Improvement Project on January 7, 2013 for the
determination of subsurface soil condition, its relative soil characteristics and its
texture, consistency, classification and characteristics of soil types, especially
geologic and subsurface soil condition of the soil beneath the Project Site for the
construction of bridge structures. These provide economical cost and safety of
construction structures.
The geology of the project area and its immediate environments are shown in
Figure1. Cambodia is geologically composed of three different structures; they
are mostly Triassic, Jurassic-Cretaceous and Quaternary. The Triassic period
covers a large area in the east, Jurassic-Cretaceous Era forming important
highlands in the west and, between them, the Quaternary basin occupy the
whole central plain of the country.
The area of the site is situated within a belt of recent lacustrine sediments. The
project site is covering by diluvia of the high land or mountain area of Paleozoic
sedimentary units, mainly Carboniferous-Permian. In the flat area of the site,
they are reported to comprise brown, gray, light gray and reddish silts, sands,
clay and organic soils layer. The geological map also shows the alluvial
sediments of the project area, where it come from vicinity high land and
mountain area to fulfill swamp and flood plain.
Therefore the project area occurred historically from year after years, era after
era by deposited layer by layers the sediment covering carboniferous rock at the
depth some 50.00m depth. Moreover, the top ground layer in boreholes is firm
or medium dense gray, yellow, brown, black sticky sand and clay from the
ground surface down to the rock layer. The project site is close to the mountain,
therefore the depth of the strength layer is not so depth and the soil stratum
from borehole to borehole is dramatically inclined.
1
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
South-Eest Project
Cross-Border Facilities
2
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
Soil Testing and Geo-research Inc. namely Sarkor Cambodia was commissioned
to undertake geotechnical investigation for this particular project on January 7,
2013 for the determination of subsurface soil condition, its consistency,
resistance, classification and characteristics of soil types, especially geologic and
geotechnical condition of the soil beneath the project site for the construction
design bridges of Provincial Roads Improvement Project. The investigation site is
located at the Svay Rieng Province located at road PR314D and led by Mr. SEA
Sochivoan, professional engineer in geotechnical engineering.
2. Site Methodology
3
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
The main activities of the whole field investigations consisted of the following
tasks:
Soil boring
Boring Machines used in the project area is Toho (Japan), 200 meters depth
capacity and the diameter of 100 mm, equip with SPT testing operation. A rotary
flight auger was employed in this operation. The process is continued boring
every 1.50 meters depth, and then take out the flight auger to operate the thin-
walled sampler and conducted SPT test. The field soil classification and
observation such as soil name, consistency, color, soil strata, percent of soil grain
size estimation, ground water table, seal and label, protection from sun shine,
making note and putting in core boxes are undertaken. All disturbed and
undisturbed samples were transported to routine laboratory in Phnom Penh.
After the borehole has advanced to required depth, the rotary flight auger was
withdrawn and replaced with thin-wall sampler (59mm) first to push slowly into
the natural soil in order to get undisturbed sample and than put split barrel
sampler into soil layer to conducted SPT test. The correct depth after boring out
the soil is also checked.
The Standard Penetration Test (SPT) used 65.00 kg drive weight at free fall
height of 760 mm to drive standard split barrel and the number of blows for
every 150 mm penetration was noted. The first 150mm was the setting blow and
the total number of blows for the last 300mm was the N-value. The samples
extracted by the split spoon sampler (ASTM D-1586) during the penetration test
would be tested for their engineering properties. Procedure was repeated on
4
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
each succeeding depth down to the bottom of the borehole. The water level in
the borehole was measured 24 hours after completion of boring works.
The soil samples extracted to represent the different strata from machine auger
borings and SPT test were subjected to soil testing laboratory for evaluation and
analysis in accordance with ASTM Standard methods and specifications to
classify them for their engineering values. The quantities and the types of tests
performed were in accordance with the TOR and Contract Agreement for the
construction project.
III. Findings
Underlying the site are uniform layers of both cohesive and non-cohesive soil
mostly alluvial in characters. The soil layers stretched beneath the project site
are mostly comprised of low plasticity lean clay, high plasticity fat clay, poorly
graded sand, and clayey sand. In accordance to its USCS classifications are CL,
CH, SP, and SC. There was not similar defined pattern to the progression of the
layers from clay or clayey sand and the thickness of layers was also found not to
be similar.
The topsoil layer is stiff to very stiff yellow, brown, reddish fat clay with sand
from the depth of ground surface down to the depth of 4.00 m, with SPT N-value
ranging ranging 13 to 15 blows. The soil layer is stiff yellow, brown, reddish
sandy fat clay from the depth of 4.00m down to 5.50m depth, with SPT-N value
of 11 blows. The next layer is medium dense yellow, brown, reddish clayey sand
5
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
from the depth of 5.50m down to 7.00m depths, with SPT-N value of 14 blows.
Under the above layer is very stiff yellow, brown, reddish fat clay from the depth
of 7.00m down to 8.50m depths, with SPT-N value of 22 blows. Underlying the
above layer is stiff to very stiff yellow, brown, reddish lean clay with sand from
the depth of 8.50m down to 10.00m, with SPT-N value of 15 blows. Beneath the
above layer is stiff to very stiff yellow, brown, reddish lean clay from the depth of
10.00m down to 13.00m, with SPT-N value ranging from 14 to 19 blows. The
underneath layer is hard yellow, brown, reddish lean clay with sand from the
depth of 13.00m down to 16.00m, with SPT-N value ranging from 32 to 41
blows.
Underlying the above layer is hard yellow, brown, reddish lean clay from the
depth of 16.00m down to 17.50m, with SPT-N value of 31 blows. Below the
above layer is hard yellow, brown, reddish lean clay with sand from the depth of
17.50m down to 19.00m, with SPT-N value of 33 blows. The bottom layer is
dense yellow, brown, reddish clayey sand from the depth of 19.00m down to
20.00m, with SPT-N value of 36 blows.
The topsoil layer is soft to firm black, brown, gray sandy fat clay from the depth
of ground surface down to the depth of 4.00 m, with SPT N-value ranging from 4
to 6 blows. The soil layer is medium dense gray, brown, white clayey sand from
the depth of 4.00m down to 10.00m depth, with SPT-N value ranging from 10 to
19 blows. The next layer is very stiff gray, brown, white sandy lean clay from the
depth of 10.00m down to 16.00m depths, with SPT-N value ranging from 21 to
31 blows.
Under the above layer is very stiff to hard gray, brown, white lean clay with sand
from the depth of 16.00m down to 17.50m depths, with SPT-N value of 30
blows. Underlying the above layer is hard gray, brown, white sandy lean clay
from the depth of 17.50m down to 19.00m, with SPT-N value of 31 blows. The
bottom layer is very stiff to hard gray, brown, white lean clay with sand from the
depth of 19.00m down to 20.00m, with SPT-N value of 30 blows.
The ground water met during operation of boring is one of the important factors
for soil investigation because the variation of ground water level, the
characteristic of soil mechanic also can be changed. The underground water level
is met 3.00m and 3.70 meter depth-measuring 24 hours after finished boring.
The underground water will be increased in the rainy season because of the
project area is located in the flat area. The underground water is considerably
not wastewater affecting structure foundation.
6
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
Table No.1
Laboratory tested results and field operation showed that the stratigraphy of
subsoil layers beneath project area is varied; it is mostly not similar layer, it is
7
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
changed within low plasticity lean clay, high plasticity fat clay, poorly graded
sand, and clayey sand characters. In according to the geology formation the area
occurred in Quaternary Sedimentary (during Holocene period), so the soil texture
is performed by recent sedimentation of clay and sand strata in the soil layer.
There is not seismic record in the project area as well as in the whole country,
therefore the seismic factor and potential liquefaction under seismic effects is not
considered for our construction project or it depends on decision of engineer.
The soil formation consists of very soft to hard clay layer and very loose to dense
sand soil layer. The physical and mechanical properties of subsurface ground
condition are good for supporting bridge structure by pile foundation. The soil
consistency or relative density is very soft to hard clay layer and very loose to
dense sand layer according to N (SPT) blows results and laboratory test. The all
soil characters are summarizing in the appendices.
According to laboratory and field test, the soil layer and its characters are mostly
not uniform. The bearing capacity of soil calculated for deep foundation attached
in the next sheet by using SPT blow-count and laboratory test results for all
boreholes of testing. The bearing capacity of soil can be chosen of any types and
depth of foundation depending upon the decision of engineer. Safety factor to be
taken is 3 for deep foundation.
The field load test should be conducted during the construction period in order to
confirm the bearing capacity of soil computed from soil investigation. If the
calculated bearing capacity of soil was found inappropriate, the modification shall
be promptly brought into. The site and design engineers shall be informed
immediately of such a variation.
The suggestion and recommendation stated herein being base on data obtained
from limited soils, the homogeneity of soil formation assumption, and these
theoretical equations for calculation, such prediction or recommendation should
be verified by full-scale investigation during the construction period to obtain
more precise reliable data. Should any variation were founded, construction
method will be modified accordingly to best suit the actual condition at site.
8
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
V. Appendix
9
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
BH1-A1
BH2-A2
27.00 m
27.00 m
10
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
Chart.1 Soil Classification Chart
PLASTICITY CHART
80
A Line
70
60
Plastricity Index - %
50 CH
40 MH, OH
30
CL
20
CL
10 ML, OL
CL - ML
0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120
Liquid Limit - %
11
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
WATER
STRATUM
DEPTH
SAMPLE
12
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
WATER
STRATUM
DEPTH
SAMPLE
o
B.D D.D M & C SAND GRAVEL Cu Ø qu qu/2 N-VALUE
No No No (M) N W% L.L% P.L% I.P I.L Gs ASTM
3
KN/m KN/m 3
% % % KN/m Deg.
2
Kpa Kpa 300MM
D1 0.00-1.50 Soft to firm black, brown, gray sandy fat 31.31 59.68 23.87 35.81 0.21 18.46 14.06 67.23 32.57 0.20 - - 40 20 2.69 CH 6
1
D2 1.50-3.00 clay. 26.60 56.20 21.64 34.56 0.14 18.33 14.48 67.90 32.10 0.00 - - 27 14 2.69 CH 4
D3 3.00-4.50 36.10 45.51 16.12 29.39 0.68 18.85 13.85 43.70 56.22 0.08 - - 67 34 2.67 SC 10
D4 4.50-6.00 Medium dense gray, brown, white clayey 26.13 42.62 17.24 25.38 0.35 19.55 15.50 35.13 52.89 11.98 - - 110 55 2.66 SC 16
2
D5 6.00-7.50 sand. 21.11 35.62 16.22 19.40 0.25 19.55 16.14 25.60 74.40 0.00 - - 110 55 2.65 SC 16
D6 7.50-9.00 20.93 39.52 18.52 21.00 0.11 19.93 16.48 26.38 73.62 0.00 - - 127 64 2.65 SC 19
BH12 D7 9.00-10.50 21.53 36.33 19.78 16.55 0.11 20.00 16.46 64.51 35.49 0.00 - - 140 70 2.69 CL 21
, A2
D8 10.50-12.00 Very stiff gray, brown, white sandy lean 24.09 31.52 21.42 10.10 0.26 20.01 16.13 69.92 30.08 0.00 - - 160 80 2.70 CL 24
3
D9 12.00-13.50 clay. 21.68 37.62 19.24 18.38 0.13 20.03 16.46 69.62 30.38 0.00 - - 200 100 2.70 CL 30
D10 13.50-15.00 22.87 30.84 21.44 9.40 0.15 20.04 16.31 63.25 36.75 0.00 - - 210 105 2.69 CL 31
Very stiff to hard gray, brown, white lean
4 D11 15.00-16.50 19.55 30.58 19.98 10.60 -0.04 20.03 16.75 69.43 29.81 0.76 - - 200 100 2.70 CL 30
clay with sand.
5 D12 16.50-18.00 Hard gray, brown, white sandy lean clay. 22.63 31.80 22.57 9.23 0.01 20.04 16.34 65.36 34.36 0.28 - - - - 2.69 CL 31
6 D13 18.00-19.50 Very stiff to hard gray, brown, white lean clay22.76 31.92 21.87 10.05 0.09 20.03 16.32 70.54 22.32 7.14 - - - - 2.70 CL 30
13
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
Figure.3 Grain Size Analysis and Distribution
Project : Provincial Roads Improvement Project. Client: Korean Consultants International (KCI).
Location : PR314D, PK23+790, Oyadav Bridge (314D), Abutment A1
Tested : Loeung Dararoth Date: 05-03-13 Checked : Ou Saody Date: 05-03-13
No. 37.50 19.00 9.50 4.75 2.00 0.425 0.075 0.010 0.005 0.002 0.001 (mm) (mm) (mm)
D10xD60
Sand Gravel
Clay Silt
Fine Medium Coarse Fine Coarse
100.00
90.00
80.00
70.00
Percent Passing %
60.00
50.00
40.00
30.00 D1
D2
20.00 D3
D4
10.00 D5
0.00
0.00 0.01 0.10 1.00 10.00 100.00
Particle Size, mm
14
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
Grain size analysis and distribution curve (ASTM-D 422)
Project : Provincial Roads Improvement Project. Client: Korean Consultants International (KCI).
Location : PR314D, PK23+790, Oyadav Bridge (314D), Abutment A1
Tested : Loeung Dararoth Date: 05-03-13 Checked : Ou Saody Date: 05-03-13
Sand Gravel
Clay Silt
Fine Medium Coarse Fine Coarse
100.00
90.00
80.00
70.00
Percent Passing %
60.00
50.00
40.00
30.00
D6
D7
20.00 D8
D9
10.00 D10
0.00
0.00 0.01 0.10 1.00 10.00 100.00
Particle Size, mm
15
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
Project : Provincial Roads Improvement Project. Client: Korean Consultants International (KCI).
Location : PR314D, PK23+790, Oyadav Bridge (314D), Abutment A1
Tested : Loeung Dararoth Date: 05-03-13 Checked : Ou Saody Date: 05-03-13
Sand Gravel
Clay Silt
Fine Medium Coarse Fine Coarse
100.00
90.00
80.00
70.00
Percent Passing %
60.00
50.00
40.00
30.00
D11
D12
20.00 D13
D14
10.00 D15
0.00
0.00 0.01 0.10 1.00 10.00 100.00
Particle Size, mm
16
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
Grain size analysis and distribution curve (ASTM-D 422)
Project : Provincial Roads Improvement Project. Client: Korean Consultants International (KCI).
Location : PR314D, PK23+810, Oyadav Bridge (314D), Abutment A1
Tested : Loeung Dararoth Date: 05-03-13 Checked : Ou Saody Date: 05-03-13
No. 37.50 19.00 9.50 4.75 2.00 0.425 0.075 0.010 0.005 0.002 0.001 (mm) (mm) (mm)
D10xD60
Sand Gravel
Clay Silt
Fine Medium Coarse Fine Coarse
100.00
90.00
80.00
70.00
Percent Passing %
60.00
50.00
40.00
30.00 D1
D2
20.00 D3
D4
10.00 D5
0.00
0.00 0.01 0.10 1.00 10.00 100.00
Particle Size, mm
17
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
Grain size analysis and distribution curve (ASTM-D 422)
Project : Provincial Roads Improvement Project. Client: Korean Consultants International (KCI).
Location : PR314D, PK23+810, Oyadav Bridge (314D), Abutment A1
Tested : Loeung Dararoth Date: 05-03-13 Checked : Ou Saody Date: 05-03-13
Sand Gravel
Clay Silt
Fine Medium Coarse Fine Coarse
100.00
90.00
80.00
70.00
Percent Passing %
60.00
50.00
40.00
30.00
D6
D7
20.00 D8
D9
10.00 D10
0.00
0.00 0.01 0.10 1.00 10.00 100.00
Particle Size, mm
18
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
Grain size analysis and distribution curve (ASTM-D 422)
Project : Provincial Roads Improvement Project. Client: Korean Consultants International (KCI).
Location : PR314D, PK23+810, Oyadav Bridge (314D), Abutment A1
Tested : Loeung Dararoth Date: 05-03-13 Checked : Ou Saody Date: 05-03-13
Sand Gravel
Clay Silt
Fine Medium Coarse Fine Coarse
100.00
90.00
80.00
70.00
Percent Passing %
60.00
50.00
40.00
30.00
D11
D12
20.00 D13
D14
10.00 D15
0.00
0.00 0.01 0.10 1.00 10.00 100.00
Particle Size, mm
19
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
Figure.4 Borehole Logs
20
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
21
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
22
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
23
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
3
Borelog: BH-11. A1 Density in KN/m
Surface elevation 0.00 m Stress Increment in Kpa Project : Provincial Roads Improvement Project.
Observed WL 3.70 m Vertical Stress in Kpa
Depth to Water -3.70 m Cohesion of Clay in KN/m2 Location: PR314D, PK23+790, Oyadav Bridge (314D), Abutment A
2
Pile Size: 0.30 Adhesion, CA in KN/m
Pile Area: 0.09 Friction Increment inKN Data Base : SPT Blows Test
Pile Perimeter: 1.20 Friction in KN
Pile Spacing: 1.50 End Bearing in KN Calculated by : SEA Sochivoan Date: 28.03.13
Ratio of Horiz to Vertical Stress: 1.25 Ultimate Capacity in KN
Limit of Increase in Vertical Effective Stress: 7.5 Safety Factor is 3 for allowable bearing Capacity Position : P.E, Geotechnical/Materials Engineer
Depth of Soft Soil: 1.50 m
From To Distance Strata SPT N Friction Delta Tan Nq Density Sub Stress Vertical Clay Clay Friction Friction End Ultimate
m m m Angle Delta Density Increm Stress C CA Increm Bearing Capacity
0.0 -1.5 1.5
-1.5 -3.0 1.5 clay 15 19.48 9.48 14.22 14.22 125 35 63.0 63.0 87.8 150.8
-3.0 -4.5 1.5 clay 11 18.89 8.89 13.34 27.56 100 30 54.0 117.0 70.2 187.2
-4.5 -6.0 1.5 sand 14 32 24.00 0.4453 29 19.35 9.35 14.03 41.58 27.8 144.8 108.5 253.3
-6.0 -7.5 1.5 clay 22 20.01 10.01 15.02 56.60 150 40 72.0 216.8 105.3 322.1
-7.5 -9.0 1.5 clay 15 19.50 9.50 14.25 70.85 125 35 63.0 279.8 87.8 367.5
-9.0 -10.5 1.5 clay 14 19.38 9.38 14.07 84.92 100 30 54.0 333.8 70.2 404.0
-10.5 -12.0 1.5 clay 19 19.97 9.97 14.96 99.87 150 40 72.0 405.8 105.3 511.1
-12.0 -13.5 1.5 clay 41 20.07 10.07 15.11 114.98 400 65 117.0 522.8 280.8 803.6
-13.5 -15.0 1.5 clay 32 20.03 10.03 15.05 130.02 200 55 99.0 621.8 140.4 762.2
-15.0 -16.5 1.5 clay 31 20.02 10.02 15.03 145.05 200 55 99.0 720.8 140.4 861.2
-16.5 -18.0 1.5 clay 33 20.04 10.04 15.06 160.11 200 55 99.0 819.8 140.4 960.2
-18.0 -19.5 1.5 sand 36 38 28.50 0.5430 86 20.05 10.05 15.08 175.19 142.7 962.5 1355.9 2318.4
24
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
From To Distance Strata SPT N Friction Delta Tan Nq Density Sub Stress Vertical Clay Clay Friction Friction End Ultimate
m m m Angle Delta Density Increm Stress C CA Increm Bearing Capacity
0.0 -1.5 1.5
-1.5 -3.0 1.5 clay 4 18.33 8.33 12.50 12.50 37.5 13 23.4 23.4 26.3 49.7
-3.0 -4.5 1.5 sand 10 30 22.50 0.4143 21 18.85 8.85 13.28 25.77 16.0 39.4 48.7 88.1
-4.5 -6.0 1.5 sand 16 32 24.00 0.4453 29 19.55 9.55 14.33 40.10 26.8 66.2 104.6 170.8
-6.0 -7.5 1.5 sand 16 32 24.00 0.4453 29 19.55 9.55 14.33 54.42 36.3 102.5 142.0 244.6
-7.5 -9.0 1.5 sand 19 32 24.00 0.4453 29 19.93 9.93 14.90 69.32 46.3 148.8 180.9 329.8
-9.0 -10.5 1.5 clay 21 20.00 10.00 15.00 84.32 150 40 72.0 220.8 105.3 326.1
-10.5 -12.0 1.5 clay 24 20.01 10.01 15.02 99.33 150 40 72.0 292.8 105.3 398.1
-12.0 -13.5 1.5 clay 30 20.03 10.03 15.05 114.38 175 47.5 85.5 378.3 122.9 501.2
-13.5 -15.0 1.5 clay 31 20.04 10.04 15.06 129.44 200 55 99.0 477.3 140.4 617.7
-15.0 -16.5 1.5 clay 30 20.03 10.03 15.05 144.48 175 47.5 85.5 562.8 122.9 685.7
-16.5 -18.0 1.5 clay 31 20.04 10.04 15.06 159.54 200 55 99.0 661.8 140.4 802.2
-18.0 -19.5 1.5 clay 30 20.03 10.03 15.05 174.59 175 47.5 85.5 747.3 122.9 870.2
25
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
Figure5. Boring Operations
26
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
Laboratory Activities
27
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
Figure6. Legends
28
Provincial Roads Improvement Project
Improvement of PR314D
Geotechnical Investigation Report : Part B Bridges
29
PART II
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMEN PLAN
Environmental Management Plan 1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
A Mitigation 1-17
B Monitoring 17-20
1. This EMP gives mitigation and management measures to be taken during Project implementation to
avoid, reduce, and mitigate adverse environmental impacts in compliance with ADB SPS 2009.
A. Mitigation
2. Table 1 presents the environmental impacts and corresponding mitigation measures. The table
also shows responsibilities for implementation of mitigation measures and monitoring. MPWT shall ensure
that the EMP is included in the tender and contract documents for civil works.
3. This EMP is part of the tender documents. The responsibilities given in this EMP are contractually
binding on the contractor. Failure by the contractor to comply with the EMP may result in penalties being
imposed.
4. Within 1 month of contract signing the contractor must prepare a CEMP (Contractors
Environmental Management Plan) and submit to the DDIS consultants for approval. The EMP is of
necessity general. The CEMP must be site specific and give details of contractors operations and their
locations.
5. The conformity of contractors with environmental contract procedures and specifications shall be
regularly monitored by the Project Management Unit (PMU3) through the Social and Environmental
O f f i c e (SEO) within M P W T during Project implementation. PMU3/SEO shall be assisted by the
detailed design and implementation supervision consultant (DDIS) to undertake EMP monitoring and to
prepare corresponding semi-annual reports for submission to ADB.
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 3
Project design Climate change and Incorporate in the project design the All project roads Part of DDIS MPWT/PMU3
hydrological impacts measures that have been developed project cost
under the Climate Change Adaptation
Component of the Project (e.g.,
ecosystem-based adaptation
measures).
Provide for appropriate design of All project roads Part of DDIS MPWT/PMU3
roadside and cross drainage systems, project cost
where necessary, to avoid flooding on
project roads as well as in areas
surrounding the project roads, especially
at sections where road embankments
will be raised to prevent flooding of
roadways.
The road embankment, bridges and All project roads Part of DDIS MPWT/PMU3
drainage facilities shall be designed project cost
based on the historical flood data and
flood forecasting.
Erosion control and slope stabilization All project roads Part of DDIS MPWT/PMU3
measures shall be included in the project cost
design, as appropriate, such as side
ditches and berms, rock lining and slope
walls along the road, shrub buffer strips
sites in areas of high erosion risk, cross
drainage to accommodate
floodwater/run-off in case road sections
are on elevated fills that will obstruct
natural drainage.
Site preparation Disruption to community Prior to commencement of site works, All project roads Part of Contractor DDIS, MPWT/PMU3
utilities relocate or re-provision water supply contractor’s
pipelines, irrigation canals and other bid cost
facilities that may be affected by
construction works This will be done in
agreement with the local community and
the utility company.
Construction
Project Activity Potential Proposed Mitigation Measures Location Estimated Responsibility
Environmental Cost Implementation Monitoring
Impacts/Concerns
Operation of Encroachment/damage Within conservation areas and vicinity; All project roads No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO,
construction to historically/culturally project activities, e.g., operation of cost MCFA
equipment, significant areas. jackhammers, piling, blasting, etc. that
excavation may cause damage to nearby
works, spoils and archaeological relics shall be prohibited.
waste disposal, Spoils and other construction wastes All project roads No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO,
transport of shall be disposed sites approved by cost MCFA
construction concerned authorities.
materials The contractor shall ensure that all All project roads No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO,
project-related trucks and vehicles (i.e., cost MCFA
those owned by the contractor, sub-
contractor, suppliers, etc.) are not
overloaded to avoid damage to access
roads. This measure shall be
implemented for the entire Project.
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 4
The following ‘chance-find’ principles will All project roads No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO,
be implemented by the contractor for all cost MCFA
Project roads to account for any
undiscovered items identified during
construction:
a. In coordination with MCFA,
workers will be provided orientation
in the location of cultural/heritage
zones within the construction area
and in the identification of potential
items of cultural/heritage
significance.
b. Upon discovery of any objects of
possible archaeological significance that
may be uncovered during construction,
the site supervisor shall immediately
suspend construction activities affecting
the area and shall alert MCFA or its
provincial or district offices to inspect the
site.
c. Work will remain suspended until a site
assessment has been made by the
concerned authority (MCFA, etc.), an
agreement has been reached as to any
required mitigation measures (which may
include excavation and recovery of the
item), and the contractor has been given
permission by the concerned authority to
proceed with the construction activities.
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 5
Impose speed limits on construction All project roads No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
vehicles to minimize dust emission and access roads cost
along areas where sensitive receptors
are located (houses, schools, hospitals,
temples, etc.).
Position any stationary emission All project roads No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
sources (e.g., portable diesel cost
generators, compressors, etc.) as far as
is practical from sensitive receptors.
Burning of wastes generated at the All project roads No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
construction sites, work camps and and other project- cost
other project-related activities shall be related areas
strictly prohibited. (workers camps,
etc.)
Provide temporary covers (e.g., Throughout Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
tarpaulins, grass, etc.) on long term project sites contractor’s
materials and spoils stockpiles. bid cost
Clean road surfaces of debris/spills from All project roads Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
construction equipment and vehicles and access roads contractor’s
bid cost
Install temporary fencing or barriers Throughout Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
around particularly dusty activities in project sites contractor’s
vicinity of sensitive receivers. bid cost
Locations for stockpiling spoils, fill and Throughout No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
other materials with high dust content project sites cost
shall be at least 300 m from the nearest
residential areas and other sensitive
receivers.
Earthworks, Elevated noise and No noisy construction-related activities Throughout No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
transport of vibration levels that (e.g., transport of materials along project sites cost
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 6
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 7
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 8
Quarry and borrow sites must be ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
selected amongst those offering the cost
highest ratio between extractive capacity
(both in terms of quality) and loss of
natural state.
Quarry and borrow sites lying close to ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
the alignment, with a high level of cost
accessibility and with a low hill gradient,
are preferred.
Upon completion of extraction activities, ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
re-contour borrow/quarry pit wall or fill- contractor’s
up when there are available and suitable bid cost
materials such as excavation spoils,
replace topsoil, and re-vegetate with
native species such as grasses and fast-
growing shrubs and trees.
Upon completion of extraction activities, ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
borrow pits shall be dewatered and contractor’s
fences shall be installed, as appropriate, bid cost
to minimize health and safety risks.
In quarries in mountainous or hilly areas, ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
or wherever slopes are important, contractor’s
terraces shall be cut after extraction, bid cost
drainage system and vegetation cover
shall be provided for rehabilitation to
enhance slope stability
Implement compensatory planting (at ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
least one is to one ratio) if trees will contractor’s
have to be removed at quarry and bid cost
borrow sites.
Project Activity Potential Proposed Mitigation Measures Location Estimated Responsibility
Environmental Cost Implementation Monitoring
Impacts/Concerns
Borrow pits will be left in a tidy state with ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
stable side slopes and proper drainage contractor’s
in order to minimize soil erosion, bid cost
siltation of nearby bodies of water and to
avoid creation of water bodies favorable
for mosquito breeding.
To avoid drowning when pits become ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
water-filled, measures such as fencing, contractor’s
providing flotation devices such as a bid cost
buoy tied to a rope, etc. shall be
implemented.
It is possible that villagers may request ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
borrow pits to be left excavated so that cost
they may be used as water reservoirs or
fishponds. If this were to be agreed
between the contractors and the
villagers, all the full safety measures
detailed above must be observed. Such
agreements would be formalized in
writing between the contractors and the
villagers after full discussion with all
concerned parties.
Use of Pollution and safety Store fuel and hazardous substances Throughout Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
hazardous risks due to use of and wastes in paved areas with roof and project sites contractor’s
substances hazardous materials embankment. If spills or leaks do occur, bid cost
such as fuel, and disposal of undertake immediate clean up.
oil, bitumen, hazardous wastes Train relevant construction personnel in All project roads Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
etc. handling of fuels and other hazardous contractor’s
substances as well as spill control bid cost
procedures.
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 9
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 10
Bitumen storage and mixing areas as Throughout Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
well as storage areas for other project sites contractor’s
petroleum products used in the bid cost
preparation of the bitumen mixture shall
be protected against spills and all
contaminated soil must be properly
handled according to national and local
regulations. As a minimum, these areas
must be provided with concrete flooring
and surrounded by an embankment to
readily contain and clean-up spills.
Adequate precaution will be taken to Throughout No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
prevent oil/lubricant/ hydrocarbon project sites cost
contamination of channel beds. Spillage
if any will be immediately cleared with
utmost caution to leave no traces.
All areas intended for storage of Designated Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
hazardous materials will be quarantined storage sites contractor’s
and provided with adequate facilities bid cost
(e.g., fire fighting equipment, sorbent
pads, etc.) to combat emergency
situations complying with all the
applicable statutory stipulation.
Blasting Safety risks to workers Blasting will be carried out only with All areas where No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
and the public permission of the concerned authority, blasting will be cost
using a pre-established schedule. undertaken
All the statutory laws, regulation, rules Throughout Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
etc., pertaining to acquisition, transport, project sites contractor’s
Project Activity Potential Proposed Mitigation Measures Location Estimated Responsibility
Environmental Cost Implementation Monitoring
Impacts/Concerns
storage, handling and use of explosives bid cost
will be strictly followed.
The timing will be made available to the All areas where No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
local people within 500 m of the blasting blasting will be cost
site in all directions, depending on the undertaken
total charge used.
Blasting will be held only during day time ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
and shall be carried out not using high cost
powered explosives. Under no
circumstance will blasting be undertaken
at night.
Where possible blasting mats will be ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
used to reduce noise levels when contractor’s
blasting is carried out to reduce flying bid cost
rock.
No blasting will take place without ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
condition survey of the buildings within cost
500 m and permission and monitoring
by the DDIS
People living near blasting sites will be ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
informed of blasting times prior to the cost
blasting.
Warning sirens will be sounded before ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
blasting. cost
Pre-splitting shall be undertaken. ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
contractor’s
bid cost
Where the vibration from blasting is ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
exceeding the maximum permissible cost
level, or damage occurs to local property
information from the blasting shall be
used to modify blasting patterns and
calculate a reduced charge for future
blasts
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 11
Blasting shall be under careful and strict ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
management/supervision of properly cost
trained and licensed personnel. Workers
at blasting sites will be trained prior to
blast operations and provided with
safety equipment and earplugs.
Observe proper warning and ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
precautionary measures to ensure cost
safety of residents, pedestrians,
motorists and structures during blasting.
All expenses/costs to address injuries, ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
damage to properties, accidents, etc. contractor’s
due to blasting shall be shouldered by bid cost
the contractor.
Earthworks/exca Improper spoils Provide grass cover and other suitable Throughout Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
vation disposal could cause slope stabilization measures on road project sites contractor’s
deterioration of water embankment slopes and on long term bid cost
quality, damage to stockpile of spoils.
productive land and
flow obstruction of Spoil disposal shall not cause ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
water courses. sedimentation and obstruction of flow of cost
watercourses, damage to agricultural
land and densely vegetated areas.
The spoils disposal site shall be located ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
Project Activity Potential Proposed Mitigation Measures Location Estimated Responsibility
Environmental Cost Implementation Monitoring
Impacts/Concerns
at least 50 m from surface water contractor’s
courses and shall be protected from bid cost
erosion by avoiding formation of steep
slopes, provisions of adequate drainage
and grassing.
Spoils shall only be disposed to areas ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
approved by local authority. contractor’s
bid cost
Water courses (rivers, canals, etc.) shall ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
be kept free of excavation spoil and cost
construction debris, floating and
submerged.
Spoil and construction materials ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
stockpile area shall be located away cost
from waterbodies and under no
circumstances will these materials be
dumped into watercourses.
Dredged and excavated materials shall ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
be reused or provided to local residents cost
as soon as possible, if they require such
materials, for land reclamation. The
remaining spoils can be disposed into
low elevation sites for road construction.
Bridge works Bridge repair and Rocks, stones, soil and other materials All bridge repair No additional Contractor DDIS,
replacement could shall not be dumped onto rivers and and replacement cost PMU3/SEO/DPWT
cause obstruction of streams. sites
river flow and
deterioration of water
quality due to siltation
Ensure bridge works shall not cause ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
obstruction of river flow and flooding of cost
adjacent area.
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 12
At bridge repair and demolition sites, the ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
bridge structure will not be dropped into contractor’s
the river but alternative means will be bid cost
used to avoid "dropping the bridge" into
rivers/streams. This shall be done by
"sawing" appropriate sections of the
bridge and using cranes to lift these
sections away or alternatively by
construction of a platform onto which the
bridge could be lowered.
Cofferdams, silt fences, sediment ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
barriers or other devices will be used as contractor’s
appropriate based on the design to bid cost
prevent migration of silt during
excavation and boring operations within
streams. If cofferdams are used, these
will be dewatered and cleaned to
prevent siltation by pumping from
cofferdams to a settling basin or a
containment unit.
Exposed surfaces shall be provided with ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
native grasses and creepers to reduce contractor’s
runoff as early as possible in bid cost
construction.
Transport of Damage to community The contractor shall not allow Throughout No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
materials and utilities such as water overloading of trucks used for all project- project sites cost
spoils, supply pipes, irrigation related activities.
Project Activity Potential Proposed Mitigation Measures Location Estimated Responsibility
Environmental Cost Implementation Monitoring
Impacts/Concerns
of construction canals, drainage, etc.
equipment may occur during The contractor shall immediately repair ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
and various construction activities. any damage caused by the Project to contractor’s
construction community facilities such as water bid cost
activities supply, power supply, irrigation canals,
drainage and the like. Adequate
compensation shall be paid to affected
parties, as necessary.
Access roads damaged during transport ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
of construction materials and other contractor’s
project-related activities shall be bid cost
reinstated upon completion of
construction works.
Bridge works, Deterioration of surface Firmly consolidate river banks using Throughout Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
stockpiling of water quality, flooding stones, concrete and other suitable project sites contractor’s
construction and flow obstruction of retaining measures at each bridge bid cost
materials watercourses construction site and ensure that water
and spoils, courses (rivers, canals, etc.) shall be
use of kept free of excavation spoil and
hazardous construction debris, floating and
materials submerged.
and Spoils, construction wastes and Throughout No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
earthworks construction materials stockpile area project sites cost
shall be located away from water bodies
and under no circumstances will these
materials be dumped into watercourses.
Do not fill up canals and creeks at the Throughout No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
construction site. In case filling of local project sites cost
drainage system is necessary,
consultation with local
authorities shall be undertaken and their
permission obtained beforehand. An
alternative drainage shall be established
before the existing canal is filled-up.
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 13
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 14
If necessary, traffic will be diverted for ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
safe and smooth movement of vehicles cost
to ensure smooth traffic flow and
minimize accidents, traffic hold ups and
congestion.
The diversion signs would be bold and ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
clearly visible particularly at night. contractor’s
bid cost
Temporary bypasses will be constructed ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
and maintained (including dust control) contractor’s
during the construction period bid cost
particularly at bridge crossings. Location
of temporary bypasses shall be agreed
with local authorities and such sites shall
reinstated upon completion of works.
Earthworks, Soil erosion On hill slopes and other potentially Throughout Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
stockpiling erodible places along the roadside, project sites contractor’s
and appropriate native vegetation that bid cost
roadworks retards erosion will be planted.
As much as possible, construction ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
activities in hilly areas are to be cost
Project Activity Potential Proposed Mitigation Measures Location Estimated Responsibility
Environmental Cost Implementation Monitoring
Impacts/Concerns
undertaken during dry season only.
Road embankments and slopes shall be ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
monitored during construction for signs contractor’s
of erosion, vegetative cover shall be bid cost
provided on slopes by planting native
grass and creepers on erosion prone
sections.
Long-term material stockpiles will be ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
covered with native species of grass or contractor’s
other suitable materials to prevent wind bid cost
erosion.
Operation of Impacts to flora and Spoils and all types of wastes shall not Throughout No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
construction fauna be dumped into forested areas, project sites cost
equipment agricultural land, densely vegetated
and vehicles, areas, and water courses.
site works, Workers shall be prohibited from ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
spoils collecting firewood and construction cost
disposal and materials from surrounding forests, and
presence of from hunting wild animals.
workers Ensure that construction works are ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
carried out without unnecessary cost
clearing of roadside vegetation.
The contractor shall prohibit cutting of ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
trees for firewood and for use in for cost
construction-related activities
Construction vehicles will operate within ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
the corridor of impact, i.e., cost
approximately within ROW, to avoid
damaging soil and vegetation. It will be
most important to avoid soil compaction
around trees. Generally the rule will be
to avoid driving heavy equipment or
trucks anywhere into the 'drip-line' of a
tree (defined as imaginary line around a
tree where rainwater falls freely to
ground unimpeded by the tree's foliage)
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 15
The contractor will not use or permit the ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
use of wood as a fuel for the execution cost
of any part of the Works, including but
not limited to the heating of bitumen and
bitumen mixtures, and to the extent
practicable shall ensure that fuels other
than wood are used for cooking, and
water heating in all his camps and living
accommodations.
Contractor shall not buy or use wood ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
from the illegal sources (that come from cost
the illegal logging)
Construction camps, asphalt mixing ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
plants, material storage sites and other cost
project facilities shall not be located in
the forest areas and other densely
vegetated sites.
Contractor will take all precautions ditto Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
necessary to ensure that damage to contractor’s
vegetation is avoided due to fires bid cost
resulting from execution of the works.
Project Activity Potential Proposed Mitigation Measures Location Estimated Responsibility
Environmental Cost Implementation Monitoring
Impacts/Concerns
The Contractor will immediately
suppress the fire, if it occurs, and shall
undertake replanting to replace
damaged vegetation.
As much as possible, bridge works will ditto No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
be scheduled in dry season to minimize cost
adverse impacts to fishery, river water
quality and other aquatic resources.
Construction Health and safety risks Conduct orientation for construction Throughout Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
works, to workers and the workers regarding emergency response project sites contractor’s
operation of public procedures and equipment in case of bid cost
workers camps accidents (e.g., burns from hot bitumen,
spills of hazardous substances, etc.),
fire, etc.; health and safety measures,
such as on the use of hot bitumen
products for paving of Project roads,
etc.; prevention of HIV/AIDS, malaria,
diarrhea, and other related diseases.
Provide drainage at construction sites Throughout Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
and workers camps to prevent water project sites contractor’s
logging/ accumulation of stagnant water bid cost
and formation of breeding sites for
mosquitoes.
Provide fire fighting equipment and Throughout Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
appropriate emergency response project sites contractor’s
equipment (based on on-going bid cost
construction activities) at the work areas
and at construction and workers camps.
Provide first aid facilities that are readily Throughout Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
accessible by workers. project sites contractor’s
bid cost
At the workers camps, provide adequate Workers camps Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
housing for all workers at the contractor’s
construction camps, provide reliable bid cost
supply of potable water, install separate
hygienic sanitation facilities/toilets and
bathing areas with sufficient water
supply for male and female workers and
establish clean eating areas and
kitchen.
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 16
Provide workers with appropriate safety Throughout Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
equipment/devices (such as dust mask, project sites contractor’s
hard hats, safety shoes, goggles, ear bid cost
plugs, etc.) and strictly require them to
use these as necessary.
Install sign boards, lighting system at the Throughout Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
construction sites, borrow pits, or places project sites, contractor’s
which may cause accidents for people where appropriate bid cost
and workers
Strictly impose speed limits on Throughout No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
construction vehicles along residential project sites, cost
areas and where other sensitive where appropriate
receptors such as schools, hospitals,
and other populated areas are located.
Educate drivers on safe driving practices Throughout No additional Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
to minimize accidents and to prevent project sites cost
spill of hazardous substances and other
construction materials during transport.
Barriers (e.g., temporary fence) shall be Throughout project Part of Contractor DDIS, PMU3/SEO
installed at construction areas to deter sites, contractor’s
pedestrian access to these areas except where appropriate bid cost
at designated crossing points.
Operation
Increased Elevated noise levels Along schools, hospitals, etc., provide All project roads Part of DPWT, Local MPWT/PMU3
number traffic signs prohibiting blowing of horns project cost traffic authority
of and impose speed limits
vehicles Road safety risks Implementation of a community-based All project roads Part of DPWT MPWT/PMU3
road safety program under the Project to project cost
increase safety awareness. The
program includes education program for
schools, drivers, road users, and the
community.
Proper maintenance of traffic signs, All project roads Part of DPWT, Local MPWT/PMU3
markings and other devices used to project cost traffic authority
regulate traffic at appropriate places.
Potential damage to the Under the Project, each project province All project roads project cost DPWT MCFA
Conservation areas shall be provided with portable weigh
scales to control overloading of trucks.
This measure will help ensure that
overloaded trucks shall not be allowed
to pass through PSP and other Project
roads.
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 18
B. Monitoring
d. siting of various project facilities All project roads Check contractor’s facilities Prior to DDIS,
(workers/construction camps, crushing location plans, site visit establishment of MPWT/PMU3
plants, asphalt plants, etc.) consistent with contractor’s
EMP facilities
e. relocation of community facilities (e.g., water All project roads Site visit, confirm with local Prior to start of DDIS,
supply pipelines, irrigation canal, etc.) officials site works MPWT/PMU3
3. Ambient surface water quality (fecal coliform, All project roads --- on Field sampling Once, prior to DDIS
dissolved oxygen,pH, oil and grease, suspended rivers or streams close to establishment of
solids, biological oxygen demand – 5 days or proposed sites for workers /
BOD5) to be compared to standards specified in construction/workers construction
Subdecree on Water Pollution Control, 1999 (No. camps camps
27 ANK.BK)
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 19
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan 20
4. The estimated costs for implementing the EMP are provided in Table 3 as follows:
C. Implementation Arrangements
5. The table below shows the institutional responsibilities for implementation of the EMP.
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan
21
Detailed Design and • Incorporate into the project design the environmental protection and
Implemenation mitigation measures identified in the EMP for the design/pre-
Supervision construction stage;
Consultant (DDIS) • Assist PMU3/SEO to ensure that all environmental requirements
and mitigation measures from the IEE and EMP are incorporated in
the bidding documents and contracts
• Prior to start of site works, assist MPWT in establishing a
grievance redress mechanism as described in the IEE,
• Implement all mitigation and monitoring measures for various project
phases specified as DDIS’s tasks in the EMP
• Undertake environmental management capacity building activities for
SEO as required in the EMP
• Undertake regular monitoring of the contractor’s environmental
performance as scheduled in the EMP
• Conduct field measurements for surface water quality, dust and noise
as required in the EMP
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
Environmental Management Plan
22
Bidding Document for Improvement of NR13, PR314D and Prey Vor CBF Procurement of Works
PART III
-i-
Initial Environmental Examination
September 2011
Prepared by Ministry of Public Works and Transport, Cambodia for the Asian Development
Bank.
CURRENCY EQUIVALENTS
(As of 1 September 2011)
ABBREVIATIONS
This initial environmental examination is a document of the borrower. The views expressed
herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff,
and may be preliminary in nature.
In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any
designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the
Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status
of any territory or area.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1
II. POLICY, LEGAL, AND ADMINISTRATIVE FRAMEWORK 2
A. Policy Framework 2
B. Legal Framework 3
C. Administrative Framework 5
III. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT 9
A. The Project Overview 9
B. Road Design and Realignments 14
C. Project Environmental Classification 15
D. Current Conditions of Project Roads 15
IV. WATER CAPTURE PROJECTS 17
A. Rainwater Capture 17
B. Dams, Spillways and Canals, Chiprong and Svay Chek,Tuek Phos District,
Kampong Chhnang Province 17
C. Water Capture and Distribution, PAWS, Tuek Phos, and Khset Lake, Kampong
Chhnang Province 21
V. DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT 25
A. Physical Resources 25
B. Ecological Resources 27
C. Economics 32
D. Socio-economic Profile 33
E. Poverty 34
F. Gender 35
VI. POTENTIAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS AND MITIGATION 35
A. Impacts of Roads on Protected Areas due to Location 35
B. Potential Impacts Pre-construction Phase 43
C. Potential Impacts Due to Construction Works 44
D. Potential Impacts Due to Workers Camps 46
E. Potential Impacts Due to Operation 47
F. Mitigation of Impacts Due to Location 49
G. Mitigation of Impacts Due to Construction Works 50
H. Mitigation of Impacts Due to Workers Camps 56
I. Mitigation of Impacts Due to Operation 58
J. Climate Change 67
K. Land Acquisition and Resettlement 69
L. Social and Labor Impacts 72
M. Poverty Impacts 73
N. Gender Issues 73
O. Indigenous Peoples 73
VII. ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES 74
VIII. INFORMATION DISCLOSURE, CONSULTATION, AND PARTICIPATION 74
A. General Public Consultation on Environmental Issues 74
B. Perception towards the Project NR13, 314D and CBF 74
C. Perception about the Project PR150B, NR53, andPR151B 74
IX. GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISM 77
A. Grievance Redress 77
X. ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN (EMP) 78
A. General Environmental Management Plan 78
B. Contractors Environmental Management Plan (CEMP) 78
C. Guidance on Environmental Issues 78
D. Social and Environment Office (SEO) 78
E. EMMP 80
XI. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION 97
ANNEXES:
Annex 1: Condition Surveys 99
Annex 2: Check Lists for EMP 105
Annex 3: Baseline Community Level Survey Abstracted from Socio-economic Study (July 2011) 121
Annex 4: Public Consultation on Water Capture (September 2011) 139
FIGURES
Figure III-1 Map of Project Roads NR13 and road 314D and CBF (marked in green) 12
Figure III-2 Map of Project Roads 150B, NR53 and 151B (marked in green) 13
Figure III-3 Road 150B, Realignment at Alngkae Village 15
Figure 0-1 Location of Dam, Spillway and Primary Canal 18
Figure 0-2 Old Wooden Dam 18
Figure 0-3 Concrete Dam 18
Figure 0-4 Bomb Damage to Dam 18
Figure 0-5 Primary Canal 18
Figure 0-6 Location of Svay Check Dam and Primary Canal 19
Figure 0-7 Svay Check Dam 19
Figure 0-8 Dam built by MOWRAM 20
Figure 0-9 Water Capture in PAWS 22
Figure 0-10 Water Delivery to houses in PAWS 22
Figure 0-11 Water Tower in Tuek Phos 23
Figure 0-12 Khset Lake, embankment and spillways 23
Figure 0-13 Location of Water Tank in Railway Yards 24
Figure 0-14 Location of Khset Lake Proposed Works 24
Figure V-1 PAWS Zones 30
Figure V-2 PAWS Types of Forest Cover 31
Figure VI-1 Road 150B in relation to Outer Zone of TLSBR 36
Figure VI-2 Road 150B, NR53 and 151B in relation to All Zones of TLSBR 36
Figure VI-3 Road NR53 in relation to Outer Zone of PAWS 38
Figure VI-4 The 80 Perimeter Marking Points of PAWS as marked by FFI and MoE 39
Figure VI-5 Concrete Marker Post showing Boundary of PAWS 40
Figure VI-6 Concrete Marker Post 45, 46, 47, 48, 49 and 50 and UTM coordinates showing
Boundary of PAWS contiguous with NR53 41
Figure VI-7 PAWS Zones in Vicinity of NR53 42
Figure VI-8 Road 151B in relation to Kirirom National Park 43
Figure VI-9 Spill Protection for Fuel Oil Storage / Rain Proofing for Waste Oil Storage 54
6
TABLES
Table II-1 List of Projects that require an Initial Environmental Impact Assessment 7
Table III-1 Project Road Lengths 11
Table IV-1 Summary of Evaluation Results (US$ mill) 33
Table IV-2 PAWS Internal Demarcation Zones 41
Table IV-3 Distance of NR53 from PAWS Internal Zones 42
Table IV-4 Policy on Crops and Trees Removal 59
Table IV-5 Quantities of Affected Perennials PR314D 59
Table IV-6 Quantities of Affected Timber Trees PR314D 60
Table IV-7 Quantities of Affected Fruit and Timber Trees CBF 60
Table IV-8 Quantities of Affected Perennials NR13 60
Table IV-9 Quantities of Affected Timber Trees NR13 61
Table IV-10 Compensation for Perennials PR314D 61
Table IV-11 Compensation for Timber Trees PR314D 61
Table IV-12 Compensation for Assorted Trees CBF 62
Table IV-13 Compensation for Perennials NR13 62
Table IV-14 Compensation for Timber Trees NR13 62
Table IV-15 Summary of Impacts PR 314D and NR13 62
Table IV-16 Quantities of Affected Perennials PR150B 63
Table IV-17 Quantities of Affected Timber Trees PR150B 63
Table IV-18 Quantities of Affected Perennials NR53 64
Table IV-19 Quantities of Affected Timber Trees NR53 64
Table IV-20 Quantities of Affected Perennials PR151B 64
Table IV-21 Quantities of Affected Timber Trees PR151B 64
Table IV-22 Compensation for Perennials PR150B 65
Table IV-23 Compensation for Timber TreesPR150B 65
Table IV-24 Compensation for Perennials NR53 65
Table IV-25 Compensation for Timber Trees NR53 65
Table IV-26 Compensation for Perennials PR151B 66
Table IV-27 Compensation for Timber Trees PR151B 66
Table IV-28 Summary of Tree Removal 66
Table IV-29 Treatment of Adaptation to Climate Change and Notional Budget 68
Table IV-30 Summary of Resettlement Costs (PR314D, CBF, NR13) 71
Table IV-31 Summary of Resettlement Costs (PR150B, NR53, andPR151B) 72
Table V-1 Measurement of Environmental Parameters 82
I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1. The terms of reference require the Consultants to prepare the Initial Environmental
Examination (IEE) for the project roads and the cross border facility (CBF) in accordance with
both the Asian Development Bank’s (ADB) Social Safeguards Policy (SPS, 2009) and the
Government guidelines, and to confirm if the project should be categorized as B or re-
categorized, and recommend on mitigation measures for the Environmental Management Plan
(EMP) including its implementation and monitoring.
2. Consultations were conducted with all stakeholders, including the Ministry of Public
Works and Transport (MPWT) and its Social and Environment Unit (SEU), Ministry of the
Environment (MOE), Ministry of Agriculture, Forests, and Fisheries (MOAFF), the Ministry of
Culture and Fine Arts, their Provincial Departments in the project area, and relevant non-
government organizations (NGOs).
3. Detailed maps were obtained and field studies undertaken to identify the proximity of
places of religious, cultural, and traditional value, and Sites of Special Ecological Interest such
as protected areas, natural reserves, and national parks.
4. Only minor environmental impacts are anticipated. Such impacts will be experienced
during site works mainly due to dust and noise emissions as well as potential occupational,
community health, and safety risks, but can be mitigated. Some minor mitigation measures will
be specified but no major impacts have been identified.
5. Some slopes on National Road (NR) 13 will be eased from 1:2 to 1:3 to improve slope
stability. Road 314D will be improved by filling in of old roadside narrow rectangular borrow pits
which are a source of vector breeding.
6. Provision of a concrete road on 150B at the approach to Ta Ches market will reduce
airborne dust and improve muddy conditions during rain and flooding.
7. A short section of NR 53 will have its alignment adjusted slightly on the opposite side to
Phnom Aural Wildlife Sanctuary (PAWS) to avoid a concrete marker post of PAWS which has
been placed actually outside the PAWS boundary close to the shoulder of the road.
8. None of the eastern project roads (NR13, 314D and the CBF) are in close proximity to
any protected areas of ecological significance.
9. For the western roads, none traverses the transition, buffer or core zones of ecologically
protected areas.
10. Road 150B has an eastern section of 5.5 kilometers (km) which connects NR 5 to Tonle
Sap River. It terminates at the village of Ta Ches at the ferry crossing point of the river. This
point is the nearest that any project road approaches to the boundaries of Tonle Sap Biosphere
Reserve. Road 150B is approximately 4.5 km from the boundary of the outer zone, known as
the Transition zone. There will be no impacts from the road on the Tonle Sap Biosphere
Reserve.
11. NR 53 runs alongside part of the eastern boundary of PAWS for a distance of
approximately 6.5 km. The boundary is defined in Royal Decree 1993 and is indicated by concrete
marker posts. Site surveys have been conducted to confirm the exact location of the boundary
2
markers, and these have agreed by local villagers and the Provincial Department of Environment
(PDE) officers. The PDE officers confirmed that NR 53 does not intrude into the PAWS.
12. Road 151B marks the most southern point of the western project roads. This road is
further away from PAWS than NR 53 and more than 50 km from Kirirom National Park. No
adverse environmental impacts are anticipated from this section of the project road on protected
areas.
13. The Sub-decree No. 72 ANRK.BK dated 11 August 1999 contains an annex “List of the
projects that require an Initial Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA)”. This stipulates that an
IEE is required for “National Road Construction ≥ 100 km and bridges ≥ 30 tons”. As this project
is rehabilitation of existing roads, and the only major bridge will be 25 tons capacity, according
to MOE Legislation, an IEE will not be required by MOE.
14. To avoid or mitigate negative impacts arising from the project, an EMP detailing
mitigation measures and monitoring activities has been prepared as part of the IEE.
15. Public consultations involving affected people and local officials have been conducted
during the preparation of the IEE in compliance with ADB information disclosure and
consultation requirements through focus group discussions and individual interviews in all
project affected provinces. Environment was not seen as a major issue by those persons
interviewed.
16. Climate change adaptation was included in the project. The residents’ knowledge of
climate change induced effects and adaptation strategies was limited. However, they were
strongly in favor of water capture projects.
17. Temporary environmental impacts caused by the civil works have been identified and
mitigation measures are given in the EMP. The EMP (and EMMP) will be included in the IEE
and will form part of the tender documents which becomes legally binding on the selected
contractor.
18. To ensure that the project is carried out in accordance with the EMP requirements,
MPWT will specify details of the implementation of the EMP in the tender documents and civil
works contracts.
19. Social and Environment Office (SEO), previously SEU, is operational but needs capacity
building. The detailed design and implementation supervision (DDIS) consultant will provide on-
the-job training to the field personnel of the SEO of MPWT to build their capacity in
environmental management and monitoring.
20. All potential environmental impacts have been identified. The project is confirmed as
Category B according to ADB guidelines. No environmental impacts were identified that would
warrant the conduct of an environmental due diligence study.
A. Policy Framework
21. In 1993, the Royal Government of Cambodia confirmed a new Constitution in which
environmental considerations were included for the first time. Specifically Article 59 states: The
3
State shall protect the environment and balance of abundant natural resources and establish a
precise plan of management of land, water, air, wind, geology, ecological system, mines,
energy, petrol and gas, rock and sand, gems, forests and forestry products, wildlife, fish and
aquatic resources and it was within this constitutional context that the MOE was established.
23. The major legislation in Cambodia is the Royal Decree which ratifies laws passed by
parliament. These can be supplemented by “prakas” or ministerial decisions. These laws allow
sub-decrees and regulations to be passed which can stipulate procedures and standards to be
met in order to ensure compliance with the law. Many of these sub-decrees and standards have
been drafted but have not yet been ratified by parliament. However, contractors are still
expected to make sure their operations comply with the draft regulations.
B. Legal Framework
1. Laws on Environment
24. In 1996, the Law on Environmental Protection and Natural Resource Management
(NS/RKM/1296/36) came into force and it requires the government to prepare national and
regional environmental plans and sub-decrees concerning a wide range of environmental
issues, including EIAs, pollution prevention and control, public participation and access to
information.
25. Other ministries explicitly mentioned at the time were Ministry of Water Resources,
Hydrology, and Meteorology (MOWRAM), and the Ministry of Land Use Management,
Urbanization, and Construction. The list was later expanded to include MPWT, MOAFF, the
Ministry of Rural Development (MRD), the Ministry of Health, and the Ministry of Tourism.
26. There is a general law in Cambodia which covers all national monuments. This is the
"Law on Protection of Cultural and National Heritage" (1996). This is supplemented by the
"Decision on the Definition of 3 Zones to Protect Temple Surrounding Areas in All Provinces and
Municipalities Except Angkor Wat", 1996. These laws protect small temples or ancient
structures.
27. Royal Decree "Protected Natural Areas" issued in November 1993 gives protection to
environment, land, forests, wetlands, and coastal zones. This decree covers 23 locations
representing 18% of Cambodia's total area and is under the jurisdiction of MOE.
4. Laws on Wildlife
28. The “Joint Prakas of MOE and MOAFF on Prohibition of Hunting and Catching of Wildlife
4
Animals” (1996) specifically bans hunting of animals and birds for food. A contractor’s workers
must observe this law.
29. The “Law on Environmental Protection and Natural Resource Management” (1996) is
“enabling legislation”, in that it enables MOE to pass sub-decrees and regulations to protect the
environment. This subsidiary legislation lays down quantitative standards which must be met by
contractors in their operation.
30. Several sub-decrees are already laws. Others have been drafted and are expected to
become law in the near future. These standards give parameters and values which must be
measured to check compliance with the regulations. Even if the regulations are in draft form, the
contractors are expected to comply with them.
31. The air pollution regulations are contained in Draft Sub-Decree on Air and Noise
Pollution. For dust control, there should no visible emissions from stockpiles of materials,
crushers or batching plants. At sensitive receptors, a standard of total suspended particulates
(TSP) < 0.33 milligrams/cubic meter at 24-hour average should be met. All vehicles should be
well maintained and comply with the air quality regulations.
32. The noise regulations are contained in Draft Sub-Decree on Air and Noise Pollution. The
regulations do not stipulate a level for noise from construction sites but refer to mixed
commercial and/or industrial and residential property. Neither do they give the measurement
method. Therefore the following standards are recommended. Noise levels at the perimeter of
any site should not exceed:
iii. Vibration
34. There is no standard for vibration in Cambodia, therefore the following standard is
recommended: the vibration levels at any vibration sensitive property or location should be less
than 1 millimeter/second (mm/s) peak particle velocity (PPV). The level of 1 mm/s PPV is a
good “standard” and is derived from the United States Bureau of Mines publications for
5
avoidance of damage and the United Kingdom Greater London Council standard for avoidance
of nuisance.
35. As a minimum, all discharges of liquid wastes from construction camps, work sites or
operations, to streams or water courses should be: biological oxygen demand < 50 milligrams
(mg)/liter (l); turbidity < 5 NTU; suspended solids < 50 mg/l; temperature < 45oC; pH = 6–9; oil
and grease < 5 mg/l and dissolved oxygen > 4mg/l.
36. There is no legal standard for performance of septic tanks but they should be checked
for correct operation: that is absence of smell; no overflowing; and no surface water logging.
37. Under the Draft Sub-Decree on Solid Waste Management (No. 36 ANRK.BK 1999),
Article 7 “the disposal of waste in public sites or anywhere that is not allowed by authorities shall
be strictly prohibited”. There are no quantitative parameters given but good sensible practice is
expected. Such practices would include:
(i) All general waste and food waste should be removed to a government approved
landfill.
(ii) All demolition waste must be removed to a government approved location.
(iii) All waste oils and greases should be removed by a registered subcontractor. The
final destination should be established.
38. Failure to employ sensible precautions may cause sanitation problems to workers living
in camps and also may result in prosecution.
e. Hazardous Substances
39. There is no specific regulation for hazardous substances in Cambodia. This aspect is
covered in the Sub-Decree on Water Pollution Control Annex 1 and Sub-Decree on Solid Waste
Management, which give details of classifications of what are defined as hazardous substances.
Any hazardous substances must be stored correctly and only disposed in a manner approved
by the MOE.
C. Administrative Framework
40. There are two particular types of areas of special ecological interest in relation to this
project. These are:
1. Protected Areas
41. Cambodia has a network of 23 natural protected areas managed through the MOE.
These areas cover 2.2 million hectares (ha) or 18% of Cambodia’s land area and include most
of its important habitats. The Forest Administration has also designated protected forests (from
cancelled logging concessions) bringing the total area under protection to around 25% which is
more than twice the global average. Protected Areas are sites which are protected by Royal
6
Decrees, Laws and Regulations. Such mandatory stipulations are promulgated in Khmer
language. These have been obtained and if necessary, translated. The Khmer version takes
precedence over the translated version.
42. In 2008 Cambodia introduced the Protected Area Law (No. NS/RKM/0208/007), which
defines:
Details are:
National Parks (International Union for Conservation of Nature [IUCN] category
II) – Natural and scenic area of significance for their scientific, educational and
recreational values.
Wildlife Sanctuaries (IUCN category IV) – Natural area where nationally
significant species of flora or fauna, natural communities, or physical features
require specific intervention for their perpetuation.
Protected Landscapes (IUCN category V) – Nationally significant natural and
semi-natural landscapes that must be maintained to provide opportunities for
recreation.
Multiple-Use Areas (IUCN category VIII) – Areas that provide for the sustainable
use of water resources, timber, wildlife, fish, pasture, and recreation with the
conservation of nature primarily oriented to support these economic activities.
The Tonle Sap Multiple-Use Area was nominated as Cambodia’s first Biosphere
Reserve in 1997. The Boeung Chmar portion of Tonle Sap Multiple-Use Area
(28,000 ha) is designated as a Ramsar site.
Ramsar Sites – There are two sites in the IUCN categories IV and VIII above
and one site in the middle stretches of the Mekong River between Stung Treng
and the border with Laos.
43. The Law on Forestry Management prohibits the hunting of wildlife within such protected
areas. As well as maintaining checkpoints and providing rangers, MOE has an active
community education program to promote environmental awareness especially within the rural
communities.
44. This law is recent (2008) and many of the protected areas predate this by many years.
Both the original legislation and the most current have been reviewed during this project.
Several protected areas, of differing designations, are located in proximity to several of the road
segments, and these are discussed.
45. An Important Bird Area (IBA) is an area recognized as being a globally important habitat
for the conservation of bird populations. Currently there are about 10,000 IBAs worldwide. The
7
program was developed and sites are identified by Bird Life International. These sites are small
enough to be entirely conserved and differ in their character, habitat or ornithological importance
from the surrounding habitat.
46. Bird Life International is an international organization working to protect the world’s birds
and their habitats. It is a global conservation federation with a worldwide network of over 100
partner organizations. Bird Life International was founded in 1922 and was originally known as
the International Council for Bird Preservation, acting as a lobbying group. It changed its name
in 1993 to Bird Life International and is the official IUCN Authority for the Red List for birds.
47. Often IBAs form part of a country's existing protected area network, and so are protected
under national legislation. Both the Cambodia’s PAWS and the Phnom Samkos Wildlife
Sanctuary contain designated IBAs.
48. On 11 August 1999, a Sub-decree (72 ANRK.BK) on EIA processes was promulgated
requiring an initial EIA or EIA for selected projects listed in the sub-decree annex to be
submitted by public or private project owners to the MOE for review.
Table II-1: List of Projects that require an Initial Environmental Impact Assessment
No. Type and activities of the projects Size / Capacity
A. Industrial
a) Foods, Drinks, Tobacco
1 Food processing and caned ≥ 500 tons/year
2 All fruit drinks manufacturing ≥ 1,500 liters / day
3 Fruit manufacturing ≥ 500 ones/year
4 Orange Juice manufacturing All sizes
5 Wine manufacturing All sizes
6 Alcohol and Beer brewery All sizes
7 Water supply ≥ 10,000 users
8 Tobacco manufacturing ≥ 10,000 boxes/day
9 Tobacco leave processing ≥ 350 tons/ year
10 Sugar refinery ≥ 3,000 tons / year
11 Rice mill and cereal grains ≥ 3,000 tons / year
12 Fish, soy bean, chili, tomato sources ≥500,000 liters/ year
b) Leather tanning, Garment and Textile
13 Textile and dyeing factory All sizes
14 Garments, washing, printing, dyeing All sizes
15 Leather tanning, and glue All sizes
16 Sponge- rubber factory All sizes
c) Wooden production
3
17 Plywood ≥100,000m /year(log)
3
18 Artificial wood ≥ 1,000 m /year (log)
3
19 Saw mill ≥ 50,000m /year (log)
d) Paper
20 Paper factory All sizes
21 Pulp and paper processing All sizes
e) Plastic, Rubber and Chemical
22 Plastic factory All sizes
23 Tire factory ≥ 500 tons /year
24 Rubber factory ≥ 1,000 tons /year
25 Battery industry All sizes
26 Chemical production industries All sizes
8
49. The Sub-decree No. 72 ANRK.BK dated 11 August 1999 Annex “List of the projects that
require an Initial Environmental Impact Assessment” refers to “National Road Construction ≥
100 km and bridges ≥ 30 tons”. As this project is rehabilitation of existing roads, and bridges are
25-ton capacity, an IEE will not be required. This has been confirmed in discussions with MOE.
50. The Government of Cambodia has requested ADB for project preparatory technical
assistance (TA) to prepare the Provincial Roads Improvement Project. This project is a priority
project in the Government’s key infrastructure development agenda as it provides all-year
access to provincial and rural agricultural communities of Prey Veng and Svay Rieng provinces
of southeastern Cambodia. The project aims to rehabilitate 87 km of provincial roads in Prey
Veng and Svay Rieng provinces to paved condition to provide a safer, cost-effective provincial
road network with all-year access to markets and other social services for provincial centers of
southeastern Cambodia. A new CBF will be constructed at Prey Var-Mocva to facilitate efficient
cross border transport and trade between Cambodia and Vietnam. The project will support a
sustainable road maintenance regime in MPWT, HIV/AIDS and human trafficking prevention
program, and climate change adaptation measures.
51. Roads are the principal mode of transportation in Cambodia. The road network of
approximately 39,600 km includes: (i) national roads (primary national highways) with a total
length of about 2,100 km; (ii) provincial roads (secondary national highways) with a total length
of about 9,500 km; and (iii) about 28,000 km of rural roads. Management of national and
provincial roads is the responsibility of MPWT, whereas management of rural roads is the
responsibility of MRD.
52. The TA is included in the ADB Cambodia Country Operation and Business Plan 2009–
2012. The business plan aims to provide pro-poor and socially inclusive growth by enhancing
environmentally sustainable agriculture and rural development by diversifying rural growth and
bolstering poverty reduction efforts.
53. The remote rural economy is becoming increasingly dependent on the improved national
road network, yet the provincial road network, with a paved ratio of 11%, continues to
deteriorate because of the rapid growth in traffic, combined with a lack of maintenance
financing, and poor road maintenance standards.
54. NR 13 that links NR 1 and NR 8 in north-south direction and NR 314D linking NR 1 with
CBF at Prey Var-Mocva are two provincial roads that are vital for transport within Prey Veng and
Svay Rieng provinces and for cross-border transport and trade. These roads do not provide all-
year accessibility. During the inception phase, the improvement of continuous sections of Road
150B, NR 53 and Road 151B which traverse Kampong Chhnang and Kampong Speu provinces
10
were included in the project scope. The output for these roads is civil works. This output has
associated DDIS consulting services, and land acquisition and resettlement studies required for
the project roads.
55. The impact of the project is improved access to markets, jobs, social services, and cross
border transport and trade in Prey Veng and Svay Rieng provinces.
56. The outcome of the project is the safe, cost effective, all-year access provided in the
road network of provincial agricultural areas of Kampong Chhnang, Kampong Speu, Prey Veng,
and Svay Rieng provinces.
Civil works to: (i) improve, to paved condition, NR 13 connecting NR 8 and NR1,
between Komchay Mear and Prosot, 65 km; and NR 314D from Prosot town to
the border of Vietnam at Prey Var-Mocva, 25 km; and construct a new CBF at
Prey Var-Mocva, and (i) Civil works to improve roads 150B, NR53 and a short
length of road 151B, Total length 69 km approximately. This output has
associated DDIS consulting services, and land acquisition and resettlement
required for roads and the CBF.
Improved road asset management through axle load control at strategic locations
of national and provincial roads, to expand the ongoing axle load control
programs of MPWT.
Increased road safety and safeguards by implementing: (i) a community-based
road safety awareness program in line with the national program; (ii) an
HIV/AIDS and human trafficking prevention program; and (iii) a sex-
disaggregated baseline socioeconomic survey of beneficiaries.
Climate change adaptation to assess vulnerability to climate change in NRs and
vulnerability mapping for NRs to improve planning for climate changes by
introducing ecosystem-based adaptation strategies. The output will also develop
emergency management planning for NRs and planning water capture and
storage systems.
Efficient project management support to MPWT. As well as the support in the
design, approach and methodology for the improvement of the project roads from
the engineering perspective, there are many innovative features. These include
road asset management through axle load control, road safety, social
safeguards, effective gender mainstreaming, and climate change adaptation.
With the CBF at Prey Var-Mocva, the project has regional cooperation features
as well.
58. A symposium on axle load control for the executing agency’s staff and a two day training
course on Fédération Internationale des Ingénieurs-Conseil also for executing agency staff was
held.
59. The project roads are given below (Table III-1) and their locations shown in Figure III-1
and Figure III-2.
11
CBF
Figure III-1: Map of Project Roads NR13 and road 314D and CBF (marked in green)
13
Figure III-2: Map of Project Roads 150B, NR53 and 151B (marked in green)
14
60. The road design is intended to be within the existing construction limits, with no widening
or realignment. However it will be seen below that one realignment is recommended.
61. Road 150B west will be realigned to the east to bypass the village of Alangkae. Within
Ta Ches market the road length maybe adjusted slightly (0.5 km) to provide paving within the
town, without widening. Road 150B will be realigned just east of the village of Alangkae to pass
directly to Tuek Phos. This will protect the village community. The length on the realigned route
is 1.4 km shorter than the existing route through the village.
62. The existing alignment of road 150B through the village will be paved to ensure the
community is not isolated. Minor road pavement works will be carried out and it will be surfaced,
all within the existing width with no resettlement.
63. For NR 53 the project begins where the ongoing Department of Works and Public
Transport improvements end. This is approximately 8.6 km southwest of Tuek Phos. The project
roads terminate at Thnal Bambaek in Amleang. The MPWT is planning other road
improvements that will connect the end of the project roads to the important centre at Oudong,
to the west on NR 5 and to Aoral town to the east. Both connections are along continuations of
road 151B.
64. As mentioned above road 150B will be realigned at Alangkae village. The existing route
(blue line) and the realigned route (red line) are shown in Figure III-3. The existing route has 3
curves will very low radii, the first immediately in front of a school and the others as the road
traverses the edge of the village. The approaches to the existing bridge donated by Japan in
2009 are extremely poor, suitable for a community road but unsuitable for an MPWT road where
heavy traffic will pass in the future.
65. As well as providing a more direct route to Tuek Phos the realignment reduces the
number of railway crossings from three to one. The railway is shown as a black line in the figure.
The realignment is along existing local roads and near parallel and slightly (30 m) to the east of
the existing railway line.
66. Where it crosses the river a new bridge will be provided. The new bridge will be
approximately parallel to the existing railway bridge. On the northern bank of the river the land is
open and largely unused. This area may provide a suitable civil engineering construction camp.
It is 0.6 km into Tuek Phos along an existing local road.
67. A minor realignment is under consideration within at the town of Kampong Rou on road
314D. This will be a minor improvement to provide curvature at two right angled bends and
protect access to a school. The realignment may take part of the land of a Government office.
15
68. The Project is classified as environment category B and an lEE has been conducted as
part of project preparation in accordance with ADB SPS.
1. NR 13
2. Road 314D
70. Road 314D is a gravel road with two very short sections of sealed surface. The whole
length is in flat terrain. There is residential property and roadside activity along much of the
length of the road, with one major settlement at Kampong Rou. There has clearly been recent
establishment of commercial activity in the border area.
3. CBF
71. Freight traffic on road 314D is believed to be seasonal, with heavier traffic during the rice
harvesting period. The road ends at a border crossing into Vietnam. There is some international
traffic but it is not yet significant. Some goods are transferred from road to barge at this location
16
and carried into Vietnam by water transport. A CBF will be constructed at Prey Var-Mocva to
facilitate efficient cross border transport and trade between Cambodia and Vietnam.
4. Road 150B
72. Road 150B must be considered as two roads; the short section of approximately 5.5 km
to the east of NR 5 and the longer section of about 28 km to the west of NR 5.
73. The eastern section is a gravel road to the village of Ta Ches, which is a major local
market centre and from where there is a ferry taking vehicles across the Tonle Sap River. A
road continues south from Ta Ches along the western bank of the Tonle Sap River.
74. The section of 150B to the west of NR 5 is also a gravel road, which terminates at a
junction with NR 53 at Tuek Phos. It passes through flat terrain used for rice production, and
connects with numerous local access roads. The road alignment changes direction sharply
when passing south of Tuel Phos and a new section of approximately 1.5 km is being
considered. This will be a straighter section following the railway line. A new river crossing will
be necessary.
75. NR 53 connects the village of Tuek Phos northwards to Kampong Chhnang, and in the
opposite direction westwards before turning in a southerly loop to give a connection to Udong. It
is already being upgraded to a sealed standard (6 m carriageway plus shoulders) to a point 8.7
km to the west of Tuek Phos. The proposed project would continue this road westward for about
31 km to the junction with road 151B just north of Amleang. This is a gravel road about 6 m wide
in generally good to fair condition. The first 17 km to Kbal Tuek passes through flat terrain used
for rice cultivation that is densely populated. Where rice paddies are prevalent on both sides of
the road they tend to be inundated with water and consequently the road is on embankment.
Beyond Kbal Tuek the land is undulating and much less intensively farmed. There are five
single-lane bridges on this section of NR 53.
76. It was proposed that the works to improve NR 53 would be continued southwards along
road 151B for 3.5 km to Amleang, and then westwards via an unclassified road to Aural, a total
distance of 40 km. This road is currently a gravel road in mostly poor condition. The existing
road traverses undulating country and in part passes through PAWS. However, this section of
road is no longer included in this ADB-funded Project, and will not be considered further in this
assessment.
6. Condition Survey
77. A condition survey was carried out to identify visually environmentally sensitive locations
on the ground. These included: (i) pedestrian crossing points, (ii) watercourses, lakes, ponds,
rivers, and streams, (iii) schools, kindergartens, hospitals, clinics, and medical centres, (iv)
pagodas, temples, churches, mosques; cemeteries, and individual graves, (v) high and low
tension power lines and mobile phone towers, and (vi) trees, orchards, and vegetation. Details
are given in Annex 1.
17
A. Rainwater Capture
78. Most rural communities rely on wells, ponds, and canals. The project area experiences
both very wet and very dry periods throughout the year. Very little infrastructure has been built
to capture water and store it during the rainy season so that it can be available during extended
dry periods. Where water storage exists in some areas, water appears to run out before the next
rains.
79. Currently, when roads are being constructed, materials are being extracted from the
roadside lands to be used for embankment construction. Local people ask for these ditches to
remain so that rainwater can collect in them. However, these are not rehabilitated and some are
eroding close to the road. In addition, they can pose a road safety problem if cars fall off the
road in places where ditches are dug deep and close to the road.
80. Rainwater harvesting to improve water supply for safe drinking water has been identified
as an adaptation priority for the country (NAPA, 2006) and this project will contribute to the
supply of water sources primarily for agriculture and livestock along the project road.
B. Dams, Spillways and Canals, Chiprong and Svay Chek,Tuek Phos District,
Kampong Chhnang Province
1. Background
81. Project Road NR53 exits Tuek Phos Village and runs west towards PAWS. It crosses
the river west of Tuek Phos Village on a Japan International Cooperation Agency-funded
concrete bridge. Just upstream of this crossing point there is the remains of a wooden dam
constructed in earlier regime and now destroyed. MPWT have been approached by local
villagers and asked to assist in rehabilitation of the dam. The dam originally was intended to
obstruct water flow and divert it to a concrete dam and spillway. The spillway then controlled the
flow of the river into a primary canal which irrigated downstream fields. The dam has suffered
extensive bomb damage. MOWRAM have been asked to repair it. The primary canal also needs
rehabilitation.
82. At a point 1 km west of Tuek Phos and 3 km south of NR 53, there is a dam constructed
in an earlier regime which is still operating but requires some repair and maintenance. MPWT
have been approached and asked to assist in rehabilitation of the dam. The dam originally was
intended to control water flow and divert it to a primary canal which irrigated downstream fields.
The primary canal also needs rehabilitation and further works in order to provide irrigation to
farmers.
83. The location of the Chiprong old wooden dam, the damaged concrete spillway and the
primary canal are shown below (Road 142 is actually NR 53). Tuek Phos is to the east (right of
picture) and PAWS is to the West (left of picture).
18
84. The location of the existing dam and primary canal are shown below.
19
85. The Kampong Chhnang Provincial Department of Water Resources act as a design
consultant to Life with Dignity NGO on water resources projects. They charge $1,000 to $2,000
for such services plus field expenses. Meetings have taken place with Mr. Eng Daravuth,
Deputy Director MOWRAM (Mob 0975521000). He and his department have previous links with
ADB. He was Project Manager on Emergency Food Assistance Project funded by ADB.
20
86. He has already prepared design drawings, bill of quantities and engineers estimated
costs for similar projects, but not for these dams. The photo below shows a concrete dam which
MOWRAM built for a cost of $60,000.
5. Proposed Works
88. For Svay Chek dam, MOWRAM have already examined the dam for structural integrity
and have confirmed that the foundations of the dam are structurally sound. The superstructure
and railings require some repairs. The gates are in good condition but are jammed with
branches and debris.
89. The dam is still working and the gates are operated by two local farmers. The main issue
is not the dam but the offtake primary canal. The primary canal is intended to deliver water to
secondary and tertiary canals when the dam gates are closed. However, the primary canal has
no water gates so the water flows directly to the downstream users. This is a source of
complaint from the upstream users.
6. Budget
91. The cost for the earth dam has not yet been estimated. The concrete spillways would
cost approximately $60,000 each. The upgrading of the primary canals has not yet been costed.
21
7. Objectives
92. The objectives of this project are: (i) to provide water catchment facilities to farmers
besides NR 53; (ii) to enable the farmers to grow 2 rice crops per year, possibly 3; (iii) to
increase use of NR 53 as the farmers will make more use of NR 53 to take their rice crops to
market in Teuk Phos and Kampong Chhnang; (iv) to show cooperation between MPWT,
MOWRAM, and ADB; and (v) to show that MPWT’s activities go far beyond building
infrastructure and support sustainable development.
C. Water Capture and Distribution, PAWS, Tuek Phos, and Khset Lake, Kampong
Chhnang Province
1. Background
93. Project Road NR 53 runs alongside PAWS for about 6 km in Kampong Chhnang
Province. There is no intrusion of the road into PAWS and MOE has no objection to the road
project. However, the project does offer an opportunity to support the activities to preserve the
park.
94. An existing NGO, Life with Dignity, is actively implementing a Climate Change
Adaptation program in PAWS. They have been invited to the Cambodia Resident Mission
recently to discuss aspects of climate change in this area with ADB officers from Manila.
95. Under the Climate Adaptation program they are running a pilot project to capture water
from a stream in the mountains. This stream flows during the dry season. The project is located
in PAWS, in the outer Community Zone where development is encouraged. It is a simple
system. There is a stream or small waterfall at the top of the nearby mountain where they have
created a small dam. This feeds a concrete box type reservoir of 20 m3 capacity. This then
feeds down the mountain in 150 mm diameter PVC pipes to the village, about 2 km away and
80 m lower in altitude. Individual houses then have 25mm PVC pipe connectors. The villagers
must pay for their own connections out of their own pocket. Due to the altitude difference all
flows are gravity driven. Simple PVC taps and valves are used to control flow. There are no
moving parts, and no pumping. Materials were supplied by Life with Dignity. Labor was supplied
by the villagers.
22
96. They currently are installing supplies to 4 villages and are keen to extend to more. The
mountain stream flows in all seasons, even in the dry season, and the intention is to supply
water to the villagers during the dry season to improve household sanitation and permit small
scale irrigation of household vegetable gardens, with a view to improving food intake and
general nutritional health.
23
97. The railway sidings in Tuek Phos village have an abandoned water tank. Villagers are
short of water, particularly in the dry season. By rehabilitating the tank, drilling a well,
disinfecting the water and providing a controlled access point, free drinking water of potable
quality could be provided to the local residents. This would improve the health of local people,
especially infants who are most vulnerable to gastro-enteric diseases.
98. The East Meets West Foundation, and NGO, began working in Cambodia in early 2009
and has successfully completed one clean water project using a similar storage tank in April
2011. This project provides safe drinking water for students and teachers in Soramarith school,
by installation of filters and ultraviolet system run by solar panels.
99. East Meets West Foundation plans to select Sre Tachey village, Aphiwat Commune,
Teuk Phos District in Kampong Chhnang Province for its second Clean Water and Sanitation
Project in Cambodia. They intend to install a small water treatment system that will connect all
households in Aphiwat Commune, Teuk Phos District.
100. To the south of Tuek Phos is Khset Lake. This was created artificially by the villagers
who constructed an embankment across a natural drainage basin into which a stream runs. A
local road runs on top of the embankment. Two spillways allow the captured water to overflow
and be directed to the nearby rice fields. The villagers wish to deepen the lake by excavating
and use the dredged material to widen the approach road on the embankment. This will
increase the capacity of the lake and give water supplies during the dry season.
2. Locations
101. The water collection system is located alongside NR53. The water tower is located in
Tuek Phos as shown below.
103. The major items of equipment for the PAWS water distribution would be:
PVC pipes
Concrete
Taps and connectors
104. The major items of equipment for the water tank would be:
Down the hole pump
Solar panels, voltage regulator and batteries
Water filters
UV disinfection lamps
Piping and taps
Epoxy sealant
25
3. Budget
106. For the water supply project the concrete water tank cost US$6,000. It costs about
US$5,000 to install supply to 1 village.
107. For the water tower the full budget is not yet calculated but previous experience suggest
US$40,000
4. Objectives
A. Physical Resources
1. Geography
110. Cambodia lies in the southwestern part of the Southeast Asian peninsula and has a land
area of 181,035 km2. International borders are shared with Thailand to the west, the Lao
People's Democratic Republic to the north, and the Socialist Republic of Vietnam on the east
and southeast. The country is bounded on the southwest by the Gulf of Thailand and has a
coastline of 440 km.
2. Climate
111. Cambodia's climate is dominated by the monsoon which causes distinct wet and dry
seasons. The southwest monsoon typically brings the rainy season from May to October.
The northeast monsoon brings drier and cooler air from early November to March, then
hotter air prevails in April and early May. The southern part of the country typically has a two-
month dry season whereas the northern areas have a four-month dry season although weather
patterns have been changing and what is typical is now increasingly problematic.
3. Rainfall
112. The annual mean rainfall is 1,400 mm in the central lowland regions and can reach
26
5,000 mm in coastal areas. However, there are really no reliable rainfall databases for the
Project zones and rainfall can vary from a low of less than 1,000 mm to a high of 2,000 mm. The
relative humidity is high throughout the year, usually exceeding 90%, and even in the dry
season rarely falls below 50%.
4. Temperatures
113. Temperatures are fairly uniform throughout the country, with only small variations from
the average annual temperature of around 28°C. January is the coldest month where
temperatures as low as 12°C have been recorded and April is the warmest where temperatures
reach 42°C. Most of Cambodia’s regions have an average wind velocity of less than 3 m/s.
Maximum wind speeds can reach in excess of 20 m/s during the wet season. During the dry
season the maximum wind velocities are lower and are commonly in the range of 6 - 8 m/s.
5. Topography.
114. Cambodia is divided into three distinct topographic regions: the central plains, the
flat coastal areas, and the mountain ranges with high plateaus. The central plains form 75% of
the country and consist of the alluvial plains of the Mekong River and the Tonle Sap basin
where the project roads are located. These are Cambodia's two dominant topographical
features and this is where over 90% of the population resides. The road sections are generally
in flat terrain.
115. The Project roads traverse primarily agricultural areas and villages/residential areas in
rural settings with no industrial development. Currently, main sources of air pollution are
dust emission due to passage of vehicles along the unpaved project roads. Sources of noise
are community activities (especially near markets) and the existing traffic largely composed
of motorcycles.
7. Surface Water
116. The Project roads cross a number of rivers, streams and irrigation canals. Road
371 in Kampong Cham is located on the southern bank of the Mekong River. Within the
Project area, surface run-off on exposed soil and erosion of river embankments cause
turbidity in some of the watercourses. Surface water pollution from domestic sewage along
sections where densely populated villages are found as well as run-off from surrounding
agricultural fields may also be expected.
8. Flooding
117. Generally the southeast roads are not expected to flood. There is a greater risk over
future years for midwest roads. The main issues for flooding are NR13 along Lake Viaco where
it is planned to raise the road by up to 1m along a 1 km length and provide slope protection. The
lake is not subject to high energy wave action, but might need some toe protection. The water
level does vary seasonally, on occasion reaching up to the top of the shoulder, and at the
moment clay dumping is taking place on the side slopes to try to prevent erosion.
118. PR150B east in Ta Ches market on Tonle Sap is intended to have a cement concrete
road as a one way traffic system. Locals report the existing road is flooded by 300mm almost
27
every other year. In the year 2000 floods the water marks on the walls are about 1.7m above
the road level. This is very localized and as one exits the market the road is about 3m above the
level of the usual flooding with locals saying it has never flooded.
9. Soil T ypes
119. Cambodia has 27 different soil types but the main ones are either soils developed on
the old alluvial terraces of the colluvial-alluvial plains. Four types – Prey Khmer, Prateah
Lang, Bakan and Tuol Samroung – are where most of the agricultural production occurs
although just one, the Toul Samroung, which occupies just 10% of the rice area is really suited
to high yielding rice production. Soils developed on the active flood plains – Kabal Po and
Krakor – are also highly suited for rice production and occupy approximately 30% of soils
where rice production takes place. Such soils respond well to improved ditch and drainage
irrigation and judicious application of fertilizers. Yields have increased over the past two
decades with wet season yields averaging 2.4 tons per ha and dry season yields (only 15% of
rice produced) averaging almost 3.7 tons per ha. These are below regional averages but the
labor intensive system is currently recording average yields of 3.6 tons per ha in the wet
season. In 2008, Cambodia produced a surplus of 3 million tons although there are still food
security problems for rice deficit households.
10. Minerals
120. Cambodia’s natural mineral resources include gem stones such as sapphires, ruby and
zircon; coal, offshore gas and oil; basalt, granite, limestone, dolomite, quartzite; and phosphate
deposits. There are no major mineral resources in the vicinity of the project roads, although
there are white clay deposits in Kampong Chhnang
B. Ecological Resources
1. Flora
121. Forests make up a major part of the country's natural resources. Hill evergreen,
tropical rain and dry land evergreen forests are found in the humid coastal ranges, humid
northeastern uplands, and the very humid to sub-humid low altitude areas. Freshwater
inundated forests are found in the Tonle Sap Lake and in areas of the Mekong River. Mangrove
forests are found along the coasts of Kaput and Kohl Kong provinces. In 1960 Cambodia's
forests covered 73% of the total land area of the country. By 1998 the forest cover had
decreased to 58% and at least until the mid-2000s it was estimated that Cambodia was losing
forest cover at the rate of 2% per annum. The reduction has been attributed mainly to
commercial logging, illegal logging (both large and small scale), large scale agricultural
concessions, fuel wood collection, non-traditional shifting cultivation and the settlement of new
villages. Secondary measures include forest fires and infrastructure development. Nevertheless,
Cambodia still has substantial forest cover in comparison with other GMS countries with the
exception of the Lao PDR.
122. Forests are divided into concession forests and protected forests. In the Project
provinces, there are some protected forest areas and indigenous tree species (e.g. the
Diptherocarpus species) that are protected by Cambodia’s Forestry Law of 1995. However, as
the primary land use along the Project roads is agricultural and residential, these forests are not
located in the vicinity of the roads proposed for upgrading. Community forests are
managed by local residents who must abide by a management plan that is supervised
28
by the Forestry Department. The community has access to the forest and may remove forest
products and cut trees for their own use but they are prohibited from selling the trees. Timber
harvesting for sale is only allowed from forest concessions. There are also non- timber forest
products (NTFPs) that poorer households rely on such as bamboo, resins, wild fruits and
vegetables, honey bees and other insects, and larger wildlife, although the collection of some
NTFPs for commercial purposes are prohibited by Cambodian laws.
123. Vegetation cover along the project roads largely consists of agricultural crops such as
rice, while some sections traverse areas covered with shrubs, grasses and sparse trees.
Lowland rice cropping is the main activity but other crops grown include soybean, cassava,
and cashew. Fruit and vegetables crop are also cultivated although primarily for domestic
consumption.
2. Fauna
124. Cambodia has a rich biodiversity. The forests, wetlands and other habitats support
many species of flora and fauna, including 212 species of mammals, 536 species of birds, 240
reptile species, 850 freshwater and 436 marine fish species and more than 2,300 plants (800
of these plants are used in for the local manufacture of traditional Khmer medicine).
125. Along the Project roads, fauna is mainly made up of the large and small livestock raised
by some households. There are indigenous endangered species such as the Siamese
Crocodile and a variety of monkeys (e.g. silvered leaf monkey) and birds (e.g. white-
shouldered Ibis) within p r o t e c t e d a r e a s b u t a s n o project roads are located in
protected areas adverse impacts to endangered species are not anticipated.
3. Fishery
126. Fish is the most important source of animal protein in the diet of all Cambodians,
constituting upwards of 75% of total animal protein input. Fish are also an important source of
calcium and Vitamin A, especially for the rural poor. On average the countrywide consumption
rate is 65.5 kg/capita/year. Each year, Cambodia’s combination of subsistence, middle-scale
and large- scale commercial fishing harvests produce 300,000 to 430,000 tons of freshwater
fish. This production ranks fourth in the world and is worth approximately US$300 million.
However, there have been incremental declines in fish catches and it is now estimated that
less than 250,000 tons of fish is being caught, consisting of approximately 105,000 tons of
household fisheries, 75,000 tons of rice field fisheries and 68,000 tons of middle and large-
scale fisheries (marine fisheries production account for an additional estimated 55,000 tons).
127. The Tonle Sap Biosphere Reserve is protected by national legislation and is recognized
by UNESCO under the MAB program. The Tonle Sap is the largest freshwater lake in the
Greater Mekong Sub-Region with an area of 2,500-3,000 km2 in the dry season and 10,000 –
15,000 km2 in the wet season. The water depth ranges from 1 meter in the dry season to 10
meters in the wet season and it is home to nearly one-third of Cambodia’s population. In 1997 it
was nominated as a Biosphere Reserve under the Man and the Biosphere Reserve Program of
United Nations Education and Scientific Cooperation Organization (UNESCO). Biosphere
29
reserves are nominated by governments and remain under their jurisdiction. Reserves are
intended to fulfil three complementary functions: (i) a conservation function; (ii) a development
function; and (iii) a logistic function.
128. The Tonle Sap Biosphere Reserve (TSBR) has the following zones: (i) Core areas are
securely protected sites for conserving biodiversity, monitoring minimally disturbed ecosystems,
and undertaking research and other low-impact uses such as education. The TSBR core areas
cover a total of about 43,000 ha which are characterized by a flooded forest, streams and water
bodies, and rich biodiversity. Nearly 100 water bird species are found there, a dozen of which
are of global significance. The areas are also known for their fish, mammals, and reptiles.
There are three core areas in TSBR.
(ii) The buffer zone covers about 541,482 ha and is used for cooperative activities compatible
with sound ecological practices, including environmental education, recreation, ecotourism, and
research. Its boundary corresponds to the outer boundary of the Tonle Sap Multiple-Use Area.
The TSBR buffer zone surrounds the core areas up to the outer limit of the flooded forest.
(iii) The transition area is the outer zone which covers 899,600 ha. It is intended to be flexible
and allows development in keeping with the needs of the local population. The transition area
forms the interface between the TSBR and common land. The southern edge of TSBR transition
zone forms a boundary with national road NR5. The flexible transition area is the integrated
economic zone, which is managed for sustainable agriculture, human settlement and land uses,
without having adverse effects on the flooded forest, water quality and soils of the region around
the Tonle Sap Lake.
129. None of the project roads are located within the core, buffer zones and transition zones
of TSBR.
130. The Phnom Aural wildlife sanctuary is located in western Cambodia and lies within the
Cardamom Mountain range, covering parts of the three 3 provinces of Kampong Chhnang,
Kampong Speu and Pursat. It was created by Royal Decree in 1993 and is one of the oldest
protected areas in Cambodia. It covers a large area of 2,500 km2 (1,000 square miles) or
250,000 ha.
131. The Phnom Aural wildlife sanctuary has been subject to a zoning process. Following
consultation with local stakeholders and a series of ecological and socioeconomic surveys of
the areas, a set of four zones was demarcated :
132. No consumptive use of resources is permitted in more than 60% of the land area.
134. The topography is dominated by Mount Aural which at around 1,813m ASL is
Cambodia's highest mountain. At elevations below 1,200m ASL the vegetation is dominated by
lowland evergreen forest. Elevations between 1,200 and 1,500m ASL support lower montane
evergreen forest, while elevations above 1,500m ASL support upper montane evergreen forest.
The forest types are shown below. (ha = hectare, PAWS = Phnom Aural Wildlife Sanctuary.
Source: Calculations by Ministry of Environment, Cambodia.
Table IV-1: Forest Types in Phnom Aural Wildlife Sanctuary (PAWS) in 2003
Total in Core zone Conservation Sustainable Community
Type PAWS (ha) (ha) zone (ha) use zone (ha) zone (ha)
Agriculture and bare soil. 5,493.24 41.13 206.17 653.74 4,592.20
Evergreen hill forest on dacite 17,509.36 17,390.28 119.07 0.01
and rhyolite.
Evergreen hill forest on 49,886.64 49,163.27 723.34 0.03
granite.
Evergreen hill forest on 13,220.91 12,457.99 732.58 29.17 1.17
sandstone.
High elevation woodland and 295.24 295.24 ─ ─ ─
grassland often with pine.
Highly disturbed forest with 1,519.85 774.54 570.07 154.31 20.93
abundant bamboo.
Low elevation of woodland 126,953.25 46,711.81 51,573.18 19,835.31 8,832.95
and grassland.
31
135. PAWS contains an IBA which comprises all areas of evergreen and semi-evergreen
forest above 400 m ASL, which is thought to be the lower altitudinal limit of the Chestnut-
headed Partridge Arborophila cambodiana.
136. The IBA supports both restricted-range species found in the Cambodia-Thailand-
Mountains Endemic Bird Area: Chestnut-headed Partridge and Cambodian Laughing thrush
Garrulax ferrarius.
137. Within the IBA, hunting pressure on bird populations appears to be relatively low, and
largely restricted to the snaring of ground birds for domestic consumption. Such snaring is
mainly conducted by wood collectors. Another potential threat to biodiversity is selective
logging, which can lead to habitat degradation and loss. This threat is, however, currently low,
since no large-scale, commercial logging is taking place within the IBA, and small-scale, illegal
logging is on the decline.
138. The Phnom Samkos Wildlife Sanctuary was established in 1994 and is located in the
Cardamom Mountains in western Cambodia, adjacent to the border with Thailand. It is a
mountainous area containing three peaks: Mount Samkos which is Cambodia's second highest
mountain (1,717 m), Mount Khmaoch (1,496 m) and Mount Tumpor (1,250 m). The area
includes an IBA.
139. The Cardamom mountain range extends along a southeast-northwest axis from Koh
Kong Province to Pursat Province. The highest elevation of the Cardamom Mountains is Phnom
Aural. Dense tropical rain forest prevails on the wet western slopes, which annually receive from
3,800–5,000 mm of rainfall. By contrast only 1,000 to 1,500 mm fall in Kirirom National Park on
the wooded eastern slopes in the rain shadow facing the interior Cambodian plain.
140. Threats to the biological diversity of the Cardamom Mountain Range include habitat loss
due to illegal logging, wildlife poaching, and forest fires caused by slash-and-burn agriculture.
The government has been increasing support for protected area management but still relies
extensively on donor and NGO assistance for implementing effective management. Many
international conservation organizations are working in the area including Wildlife Alliance,
Conservation International, Fauna and Flora International, and World-Wide Fund for Nature.
Sections of the area have been designated as protected areas, including Phnom Samkos
Wildlife Sanctuary and PAWS. The level of active protection in all parks in the mountains has
been criticized as being too low.
32
141. The Cardamom Mountains are an emerging tourist destination, with the opening of
Wildlife Alliance's Chi-Phat eco-tourism area in the southern Cardamoms in 2008 followed by
their second Cardamon Mountains eco-tourism site in Trapeang Roung.
142. The Phnom Aural and Phnom Samkos wildlife sanctuaries were established in 1993
under the Royal Decree on the Creation and Defining of Natural Protected Areas. They are
located at the south-eastern end and north-western end, respectively, of the Cardamom
Mountains. The two sanctuaries combined cover nearly 600,000 ha. Surveys carried out since
2001 have shown the special importance of the two sanctuaries for biodiversity conservation
and environmental services. They have diverse geography, extensive forests, and many
endemic and globally threatened species. Evergreen hill forest covers most of the two
sanctuaries and the area is listed among the World Wildlife Funds Global 2000 Ecoregions as a
priority for biodiversity conservation
143. The two wildlife sanctuaries are home to about 30,000 people who rely on subsistence
agriculture, cattle raising, and collection of non-timber forest products for their livelihoods. These
communities are among the poorest in Cambodia. Under the Cardamom Mountains Wildlife
Sanctuaries Project, a joint project of the Cambodian MOE and Fauna and Flora International,
zoning plans have been developed for both sanctuaries through participatory consultation with
local stakeholders but the sanctuaries face threats from clearance of land by in-migrating
settlers and the granting of economic concessions as in 2009 a decree was issued permitting
limited economic development in PAWS.
144. Kirirom National Park is located mostly in Phnom Sruoch District, Kampong Speu
Province, while a smaller section is in neighboring Koh Kong Province. It was established in
1993 and covers 350 km2. The park extends over the eastern part of the Cardamom Mountains.
It is located 112 km from Phnom Penh off National Highway 4 on the road to Sihanoukville. It is
located at an altitude of 675 m (2,215 ft) above sea level and was Cambodia's first officially
designated national park. Among the animals in the park are Asian elephant, deer, gaur,
banteng, leopard, spotted linsang, pileated gibbon and tiger.
C. Economics
145. The economic appraisal has been carried out for six road sections. NR 13 was
analyzed as three sections, but the results have been combined for the whole road; all three
sections are individually economically viable. The results for Road 314D are shown for two
cases; one with only the cost of the road upgrading and one with the capital cost of the
development of the CBF at Prey Vor included. No additional benefit for the CBF has been
calculated. Road 150B has been analyzed as two sections, east and west of NR 5, and the
results are shown on this basis, as the two sections are distinct in terms of the road network.
The sealing of the 3.1km of the western section of Road 150B in the village of Alnkae that will
be bypassed by the proposed realignment has not been included. The analysis of the western
section of Road 150B includes the new alignment and the distance saving obtained applied to
all traffic. NR 53 and Road 151B were both analyzed as single sections. The results are shown
in Table V-1 where they are summarized for the six road sections and for the project as a whole,
with the total based on Road 314D including the CBF. In this table, the values of the main
components of project costs and benefits are shown as discounted present values. The Net
Present Value (NPV) shown is the sum of all savings minus the capital costs, discounted to
33
base year values at 12%. The Economic Internal Rate of Return (EIRR) is shown in the final
column.
146. All of the road sections are shown to be viable, with positive NPVs and EIRRs above the
target rate of 12%. Overall the project has an EIRR of 15.5%. The EIRRs are similar for all
sections. The higher traffic levels on NR 13 and Road 314D produce higher benefits but the
higher design standard results in much higher costs per km for the upgrading.
147. By far the largest source of benefits is VOC savings, being on average five times those
of passenger time savings. Benefits to non-motorized traffic, almost entirely bicycles, are
insignificant despite the large numbers on some road sections. There is a small net saving from
routine road maintenance costs.
D. Socio-economic Profile
148. During the baseline survey conducted in June 2011, 99.4% of respondents were in favor
of the project while less than 1% are not in favor due to fear that their houses and shops might
be affected during the construction. Overall, the key stakeholders are in favor of the project due
to the following positive impacts: (i) greater access to basic facilities and services, specially for
women/girls, children, elderly and disabled persons; (ii) improved roads will increase
household’s income; (iii) prices of commodities and transportation costs will be reduced due to
improved roads; (iv) greater job opportunities for both unskilled women and men who would like
to work during the road construction and maintenance; (v) children will be motivated to go to
schools, and will increase enrollment and completion rates; (vi) faster and more convenient
travel; (vii) the mothers will no longer be tired doing laundry for the uniform of their children daily
(which is costly and time consuming), especially during rainy season; (viii) easy to transport
agricultural products (although there is a need to improve further roads in their
communes/villages); and (ix) there will be more jobs that will be created in the future as more
business investors will put up factories and other business establishments. Negative impacts
raised by the key stakeholders include: (i) increase in road accidents; (ii) increase in number of
individuals with HIV/AIDs/sexually-transmitted diseases (STDs), and human trafficking cases;
(iii) possible increase in school drop-outs and child labor during the construction period; (iv)
economic and physical displacement of some households (permanent and temporary); and (v)
dust and noise during the construction, but this is only temporary.
149. During the baseline survey conducted in June 2011, less than 30% of the key informants
mentioned that the project will result to spread of HIV/AIDS/STDs and will increase human
34
trafficking cases. However, the community leaders have expressed that public awareness
campaign on HIV/AIDS and human trafficking prevention program (HHTPP) will be of great
help. There are NGOs that conduct HHTPP and road safety awareness in the communities. The
teachers and the MoWA also mentioned the possibility for children who are enrolled in school
(especially the girls) to work during the construction of the project. This could mitigated by
implementing the labor and gender action plan (LGAP) where the “no child labor policy” will be
strictly enforced.
E. Poverty
150. Cambodia is one of the least developed countries in Southeast Asia, and in the Asia-
Pacific region, it ranks 131 of the 179 countries included in the UNDP’s Human Development
Index (HDI). It has a total population of 14.3 million as of 2010 with an annual population growth
rate of 1.6%. The country’s population in 2009 was 13.9 million and of this number, 51.23% are
women. There were 2.9 million households with an average of 5 people and over 82% are in the
rural areas. ADB mentioned in the Country Poverty Assessment for 2011 that based on the
2008 census, a quarter of Cambodian households (25.6%) are headed by women. The
population is young, with more than half (56.1%) under the age of 25. The fertility rate has
declined slightly but remains high. Rapid population growth from 1998–2008 at 1.54% per year
is higher than the 1.3% average for Southeast Asia as a whole. Around 72% of the workforce is
engaged in agriculture, forestry, and fishing. Urbanization is low, with just 19.5% of the
population living in cities in 2008 and only a 1.3 percentage point increase over the previous
decade (18.2% in 1998). While the annual growth rate of the rural population was 1.4% from
1998 to 2008, the urban population grew at 2.2% per year.
151. The country’s national poverty incidence in 2008 was 30.1% but rural areas have higher
poverty rate of 34.7%. Cambodia ranked 33 in the “alarming” countries with high level of hunger
and under nutrition, where 12% of the households were classified as food insecure due to
increase in food prices (UNDP Poverty Reduction Report, 21 March 2011). The UN-WFP
Cambodia reported that although the poverty rate in the country fell by 4.7% from 2004 to 2007,
the 30.1% poverty level among the country’s total population was still high. The unemployment
rate in Cambodia is projected to reach 20% by end of 2011. The poverty rate in Svay Rieng
province was 24% and 35% in Kampong Chhnang province (2008 Census).
152. The total population in the project areas covering 10 districts in 4 provinces (Svay Rieng,
Prey Veng, Kampong Chhnang and Kampong Speu) was 705,738 with 140,818 households in
2008. Of this number, 25,755 or 18% were female-headed households (2008 Census).
Agriculture is the primary source of income and food for the households. In Svay Rieng province
(with 5 out of 10 districts included in the project areas), only 5% of the farmers have access to
irrigation and 33% owned less than 1 ha of land, and 4% do not own land for rice cultivation. In
Kampong Chhnang province (with 3 districts included in the project areas), 54% of the
households owned less than 1 ha of land and 8% do not own land for rice cultivation. Around
30%of the households in Kampong Chhnang have access to irrigation. Based on the baseline
survey conducted in June 2011, 26% of farmers who have land do not have legal land title.
Absence of proof of land ownership makes the farmers vulnerable to losing land and inhibits
them from investing long-term in agricultural production. Landless farmers and those with less
than 1 ha are included among the poor households in Cambodia. Based on the international
poverty line (in 2006 purchasing parity terms), 40% of the population in Cambodia lived on less
than $1.25 a day, and 68% on less than $2 a day (A. Bauer et. al. 2008, World Bank’s New
Poverty Data: Implications for ADB, Sustainable Working Development Working Paper Series
No. 2. Manila).
35
F. Gender
153. Women account for 52% of the population in the project areas. Female-headed
households comprise 13% of the total households who were interviewed during the baseline
survey conducted in June 2011. Of this number, 3% have children less than 5 years old. The
country’s child mortality rate in 2010 was 350 per 100,000 live births. Of the 4 provinces
covered by the project, Kampong Chhnang has the highest maternal mortality rates with more
than 500 mothers who died within 1 month after giving birth in 2008, followed by Kamchay Chay
Mear district in Prey Veng with 305 and Svay Rieng with 350. Neonatal mortality rate per 1,000
live births in the country was 60 in 2010. Kamchay Mear district (Prey Veng province) has the
highest neonatal mortality rate of 42 cases, followed by Svay Rieng with an average of 25 cases
per 1,000 live births in 2008.
1. National road NR 13
154. NR 13 will not pass in close proximity to any legally designated protected areas or sites
of special ecological, cultural or religious interest. The only localized environmental concern at
this time is the large water body through which the road passes on embankment which may be
subject to periodic inundation in the short term, or extreme weather events in the long term.
155. Road 314D will not pass in close proximity to any legally designated protected areas or
sites of special ecological, cultural or religious interest.
156. The CBF site is already developed and in use by cross border traffic. No adverse
environmental impacts are anticipated by further development and upgrading of this facility.
3. Road 150B
157. Road 150B has an eastern section of 5.5 km which connects NR5 to Tonle Sap river. It
terminates at the village of Ta Ches at the ferry crossing point of the river. This point is the
nearest that any project road approaches to the boundaries of Tonle Sap Biosphere Reserve. It
is approximately 4.5 km from the boundary of the outer zone, known as the Transition zone.
There will be no impacts from the road on TSBR.
36
Figure VI-2: Road 150B, NR53 and 151B in relation to All Zones of TSBR
37
4. Road NR53
159. NR 53 runs alongside part of the eastern boundary of Phnom Aural Wildlife Sanctuary
for a distance of approximately 6.5 km.
160. The figure below depicts the location of PAWS based on public domain information with
the project road superimposed. he road does not intrude into the PAWS but runs contiguous
with the boundary (Figure VI-3).
161. This has been confirmed by detailed investigations and “ground truthing” as described
below.
162. Under the Royal Decree on the Protection of Natural Areas 1993 Article 3: Amendments
“The protected natural areas may be modified or expanded in the future on the basis of scientific
information involved in the conservation of ecology and the maintenance of the existing
landscape in the Kingdom of Cambodia.” It is possible that the boundary may have been
modified and yet still be completely in accordance with the law. However, site visits have
established this has not occurred.
38
163. The boundary of PAWS was given in the Royal Decree of 1993 which showed a
boundary line drawn on a map. The consultants obtained a copy of the original decree to
confirm this. Flora and Fauna International, an NGO, have recently been very active in PAWS
with regards to the boundaries. They took coordinates off the original map and transformed
these into cartographic coordinates using the UTM system. (The consultants have obtained
these coordinates, called “Waypoints”.) The waypoints were then used by Flora and Fauna
International on a global positioning system (GPS) system to identify locations on the ground
where concrete posts could be erected to mark the boundary of the PAWS. In some cases the
intended location was inaccessible and could not be used to locate a concrete marker. In this
case, discussions were held between Flora and Fauna International, MOE, Provincial officers
and local villagers to agree on a location for the marker post (Figure VI-4).
39
Figure VI-4: The 80 Perimeter Marking Points of PAWS as marked by FFI and MoE
164. The boundary shown in the Royal Decree 1993, the estimated waypoints and the
concrete marker posts could possibly be different. Site surveys were conducted to “ground truth”
the data and confirm in reality exactly where the boundaries are, as indicated by the marker
posts and agreed by local villagers.
165. Site surveys were carried out together with the PAWS Rangers from the Provincial
Department of Environment (DOE), and the District Village Heads. A series of concrete posts
were identified which mark the boundary of PAWS. Each post is numbered, states the Royal
Decree and has the UTM Coordinates written on it. Some of these have been moved slightly at
the request of the villagers to avoid natural features such as a drainage ditch (Figure VI-5).
40
166. The locations were checked with a GPS unit and the findings crossed checked with the
UTM coordinates written on the post. All were found to be correct. Six posts mark the boundary
of PAWS where it runs contiguous to NR 53 (Figure VI-6).
41
Figure VI-6: Concrete Marker Post 45, 46, 47, 48, 49 and 50 and UTM coordinates showing
Boundary of PAWS contiguous with NR 53
167. Having established the boundary of PAWS in relation to NR 53, it is possible to show the
distance of the project road from the various zones of PAWS. PAWS is divided into 4 zones
which are not concentric (unlike TSBR). The characteristics of the zones are described below
(Table IV-2) and the location of them with respect to NR53 given in Figure VI-7. It can be seen
that NR53 has no adverse impact on the activities designated by the zones of PAWS.
NR 53 runs contiguous to the outer boundary of PAWS for about 6.5 km.
The distances of NR 53 to the nearest point of each zone are :
Distance to Community Zone (Red) 10 m (for approximately 3.5 km)
Distance to Sustainable Use Zone (Blue) 10 m (for approximately 3 km)
Distance to Conservation Zone (Yellow) 2 km (at nearest point)
Distance to Core Area (Green) 5 km (at nearest point)
km = kilometer, m = meter, NR = national road, PAWS = Phnom Aural Wildlife Sanctuary.
168. It is intended to support activities to the villagers in PAWS to enhance their activities in
line with sustainable development in locations adjacent to project roads. Discussions have been
initiated with the stakeholders in PAWS to develop collaborative assistance in the future and
these are reported in the public consultations sections.
5. Road 151B
169. Road 151B marks the most southern point of the project roads. This road is further away
from PAWS than NR 53 and more than 50 kms from Kirirom National Park. No adverse
environmental impacts are anticipated from this section of the project road on these two
protected areas.
43
1. Unexploded Ordnance
170. A land mine or unexploded ordnance (UXO) risk is widespread in Cambodia including
the provinces in which the proposed project will be conducted. The works are to upgrade
existing roads without widening. Nevertheless, a risk remains since there may be deep seated
mines that could be exploded by heavy construction equipment and shallow ordnance may be
uncovered during the works. The detailed design and implementation supervision consultant
(DDIS) shall engage a UXO specialist to determine the level of risk of all project roads and
advise on the need for clearance. Any clearance that is required will be undertaken through the
civil works contracts, by the engagement of qualified local UXO clearance firms. The contractor
shall only commence site works after the UXO clearance firm has certified that areas are
already cleared.
171. Existing climate change projections supported by field observations highlight two major
concerns related to current and future climate changes. Specifically, there appears to be an
overall increase in average total annual rainfall and, this increase is poorly distributed over
seasons, resulting in increased floods during the rainy season and increased drought during the
dry season. Droughts are significant especially for unpaved roads as dust levels increase and
reduce visibility and create poor local air quality. Flooding and soil moisture content is a primary
concern for protecting investments in roadworks and will be addressed as a priority in the climate
change adaptation strategy to be implemented under the Project. The strategy will seek to
strengthen the overall objective of the Project to improve rural road mobility. It will do so by:
44
(i) Protecting the road infrastructure from the impacts of climate change and,
(ii) Ensuring that the road infrastructure does not increase the vulnerability of the
surrounding area to climate change.
172. The adaptation activities fall under two outcomes: Outcome 1: improved planning for
rural road infrastructure development to accommodate climate changes and, Outcome 2:
increased resilience of road infrastructure to climate changes. In particular, Outcome 2 will
involve design and implementation of ecosystem-based adaptation strategies focusing on
environmental/green planning for project roads to improve flood and drought management, i.e.
increasing ground cover and infiltration of floods and water retention during droughts, which has
the added co-benefits of improving rural livelihoods by improving the soil structure for
agriculture.
173. In selecting species of trees and other vegetation for the ecosystem-based adaptation,
the consultants for the climate change adaptation component of the Project shall ensure new
species (i.e., species not currently established in the country or region of the project) shall not
be intentionally introduced unless carried out in accordance with the existing regulatory
framework for such introduction, if such framework is present, or unless the introduction is
subject to a risk assessment. Under no circumstances must species known to be invasive be
introduced into new environments.
174. To address hydrological impacts, the project shall provide for appropriate design of
roadside and cross drainage systems, where necessary, to avoid flooding on project roads as
well as in areas surrounding the road embankment. The road embankment, bridges and
drainage facilities shall be designed based on the historical flood data and flood forecasting.
Erosion control and slope stabilization measures shall be included in the design, as appropriate,
such as side ditches and berms, rock lining and slope walls along the road, shrub buffer strips
sites in areas of high erosion risk, cross drainage to accommodate floodwater/run-off in case
road sections are on elevated fills that will obstruct natural drainage.
2. Borrow Areas
176. Widening and raising of embankments will use a variety of earth, laterite and rock
materials. Soil will be obtained from borrow pits or excavated material taken from trenches
running lateral to the road. Temporary roads may be needed to access borrow pits. After work is
completed borrow areas (borrow pits and borrow roads) must be reinstated to their original
condition.
3. Rock Extraction
45
177. Where rock extraction is by explosives, blasting noise and vibration impacts may occur.
The blasting method statement must be submitted to the resident engineer in advance for his
approval.
4. Fabrication Sites
178. Construction of bridges and culverts will be by the use of pre-cast concrete structures,
which will be transported to site and installed. The location of fabrication sites and their
operation may have impacts on surrounding areas.
179. Construction materials such as earth, gravel and rock will be hauled by trucks to the
project sites. Concrete beams will be pre-cast in a fabrication yard and then transported to site
and erected. If contractors' haulage trucks exceed weight limits there may be damage to
bridges.
180. Vehicles will require fuel and lubrication oils which may leak into watercourses. Vehicle
wash down water may cause contamination.
181. Bitumen for asphalt and batching plants will be stored on site. Storage areas must be
strictly controlled and not located near watercourses. Bitumen will need a fuel source for
heating. Wood should not be used as an alternative fuel. Asphalt applied during rain can be
washed into watercourses.
182. During construction, noise and vibration may be generated by construction equipment,
vehicles, pile driving, demolition and blasting.
9. Dust
183. Dust from unpaved roads is a major nuisance for roadside residents, especially those in
built-up areas. During construction, fabrication sites and access roads, material stockpiles,
crushers and batching plants may generate dust.
184. Demolition of old structures may give rise to waste construction materials. These may
comprise waste concrete rubble, wood, nails and old steel re-bars. These can be sharp and
pose a threat to grazing animals.
185. Borrow pits, quarries, road embankments, culverts and bridge abutments and road
diversions will expose bare soils where material can be eroded. Work within channels and
dumping of excavated material into flowing channels can cause blockage of drainage channels.
46
186. Services within the right-of-way (ROW) may include electrical cable, fibre optic
telephone cables, mobile telephone transmission towers and underground water pipelines.
Damage to such utilities must be avoided.
187. It may be necessary to divert traffic around certain areas. Drivers must be forewarned of
changed road conditions. Old signage may be misleading if not removed.
188. In order to allow widening large numbers of roadside trees will be removed. These must
be disposed of adequately. These are discussed in detail under “Mitigation”.
189. No ancient monuments have been located along the project roads, but contractors must
exercise care as historic artifacts may be discovered during excavation.
190. The Contractor must have a stated policy and clear program for Occupational Health
and Labor Safety. Trained first aid personnel and emergency response facilities are required.
191. The conceptual layout of the construction camps, workers quarters and quarries has not
yet been proposed. In addition to permanent camps there may be temporary camps for teams
of workers who move around the project roads. Their exact locations are not yet specified.
More details will become available as the works progress.
192. Workers living in camps will need adequate facilities for food preparation and cooking
facilities, laundry, personal hygiene and waste removal. Contractors must provide these to
avoid unsanitary impacts on nearby residents.
193. If teams move around the route as works progress contractors may try to use temporary
camps with containers for sleeping and temporary latrines on rented land. This is considered
too disruptive to local villagers and renting houses as temporary quarters is preferred.
194. Stagnant water can gather in borrow pits, discarded solid waste such as plastics, old
47
tires and metal containers and provide temporary breeding habitats for mosquitoes. Malaria
and dengue fever are prevalent. Contractors should provide preventive control measures.
195. Risks may arise during the construction stage from (i) inadequate sanitation facilities in
work camps (ii) lack of preparation for accidents and injuries (iii) introduction of contagious
diseases by immigrant workers (iv) outbreaks of malaria in the labor force. Contractors must
take steps to avoid these.
197. When construction is completed, the contractors must clean up the construction sites by
removing all equipment and buildings and carrying out site remediation work, unless the site
and buildings are to be left intact and handed over to the local authorities.
1. Road Accidents
198. As a result of the improved road and with long straight stretches and relatively long
distances between the villages, it will be possible for vehicle speeds to increase. This may
increase road accidents. Traffic safety is an issue and a road safety program will be
implemented.
199. Cambodia experiences an extremely high accident rate that is three times that of other
countries in the ASEAN region, and accidents, casualties and fatalities have all increased
proportionally faster than the growth in road traffic and the population. Consequently the
government has committed to a national target of reducing road crash fatalities by 30% in 2010.
This project will improve selected provincial roads and the rural communities are aware that
paving the roads is likely to lead to an increase in traffic speeds, and have expressed concern
over road safety. The project includes a component to address the Road Safety problem
through the provision of road safety experts who will, in concert with existing programs in
Cambodia, support the NRSAP and deliver practical solutions including public awareness of the
road law, road user competence and education and vulnerability awareness.
200. The National Road Safety Committee supports and coordinates road safety action plans
throughout Cambodia such as the Cambodia Road Safety Week before Khmer New Year. The
2011-2020 National Road Safety Action Plan (NRSAP) is aligned to the UN Global Decade of
Action for Road Safety and consists of 7 pillars : Pillar 1 Road Safety Management; Pillar 2
Infrastructure; Pillar 3 Safe Vehicles; Pillar 4 Safe Road User Behaviour; Pillar 5 Post Crash
Care; Pillar 6 Legislation and Enforcement; Pillar 7 Driver Licensing. Under the ADB funded
Provincial Roads improvement Project TA 7665-CAM baseline studies have been carried out in
August 2011 on selected roads. These included helmet surveys, road user surveys, school
48
surveys, hospital surveys and road safety consciousness surveys. Drawing on these results the
7 pillars of NRSAP are to be applied to Community Based Road Safety (CBRS) through a
Technical Assistance Project.
202. The CBRS project will focus on districts, communes and villages adjacent to project
roads. It will be coordinated by the CBRS Management Team at MPWT; District Level
facilitators of whom 30% will be female; Commune level facilitators (30% female); and Village
level volunteers of whom 40% will be female and the majority youth. A fundamental aim is to
ensure long term sustainability at grass roots level.
204. These will comprise annual and weekly events, school events, exhibitions and ground
breaking events. Consultants will be hired who will be responsible for facilitating all of these
actions and for monitoring and evaluation of progress.
3. Noise
205. Noise from road traffic is a nuisance for roadside residents. As traffic grows, with more
heavy goods vehicles, noise levels will increase. However smoother road surfaces can reduce
road / wheel interaction noise.
4. Air Pollution
206. Air pollution from vehicle operation, especially heavy diesel powered vehicles will
increase. However, higher speeds give more engine efficiency which reduces air pollution.
49
5. Toxic Spills
207. Currently transport operators face a poor road system with the attendant risks of a high
proportion of accidents attributable to these poorly maintained roads. With the new road and
better road conditions transport accidents attributable to poor road conditions will decrease but
accidents attributable to speed are likely to be several times greater. Thus as traffic densities
and speeds increase there is increased likelihood of accidents and toxic materials being
released into the air, ground and aquatic systems. To date there do not appear to have been
any major accidental spills.
6. Illegal Settlement
208. Illegal dwellings should be discouraged as encroachments and squatters can effectively
reduce the road width and contribute to accidents.
7. Loss of Forests
209. Improved access to an area can sometimes result in accelerated loss of forests due to
illegal logging. Illegal logging is controlled by MoE Rangers and they reported that is not a major
activity in PAWS, the main protected area near to any project roads.
8. Loss of Wildlife
210. A concern with increased access is the possibility of an increase in illegal wildlife hunting
and threats to endangered species. As stated above MoE Rangers patrol to control such illegal
activities.
211. Not all impacts are adverse. The project will have several positive benefits which
include:
212. These will enhance the quality of life and living standards of the local population.
214. There are no ancient bridges or old temples adjacent to the project roads.
3. Religious Edifices
215. There are no religious edifices in the immediate vicinity of the project roads. There are
several pagodas and graves located near some of the roads. Contractors must employ normal
care when working near these. Details are given in the Conditions Surveys. (Annex1)
216. All of the construction activities, including structural work and laydown yards, quarries,
borrow pits, fabrication yards and workers camps must be located outside any protected areas.
2. Borrow Areas
217. The borrow areas are still to be identified and finalized. Details of location, excavation
and rehabilitation are still to be decided. Many villagers stated during consultations that they
wished borrow pits to be left open so that they could be used for water reservoirs, duck ponds or
fish ponds. As borrow areas will be subject to a private contract between the villagers and the
contractor, the decision as to rehabilitation will be made on a case by case basis. However,
should the villagers specify rehabilitation, the contractor must comply with this request.
Otherwise all borrow pits must be filled in after project completion, and resurfaced with topsoil
and revegetation, as indicated in the borrow pit excavation plan, to such a condition that they do
not pose a hazard to local residents. Temporary roads will be needed to access borrow pits.
After work is completed these must be removed. This includes breaking up compaction and
reinstating the original ground surface.
218. The following measures should be implemented at quarry and borrow sites to
minimize impacts on water quality, reduce dust emission during transport, minimize erosion
and siltation of nearby water courses and avoid damage to productive land and ecologically
sensitive areas:
(i) Sourcing of quarry and borrow materials from existing sites shall be preferred
over establishment of new sites, as much as possible.
(ii) Quarries and borrow pits shall not be established in national, provincial, district
and village conservation forests and other ecologically sensitive and protected
areas.
(iii) Borrow/quarry sites shall not be located in productive land.
(iv) In case the Project will involve new quarry/borrow sites, necessary approvals
from environmental authorities shall be obtained prior to operation of such
sites. Such sites shall be located over 300 m away from residential, school,
hospital and other sensitive receptors.
(v) Prior to extraction, topsoil (about 15 cm) shall be stockpiled, preserved and
then refilled after completion of quarry/borrow pit operation for rehabilitation
purposes after excavation is over.
51
(vi) Dust control during excavation and transport e.g. water spraying on access roads
and covering of truck loads with tarpaulins shall be undertaken in areas where
there are sensitive receptors such as residential areas, school, hospital, etc.
(vii) Long-term material stockpiles shall be covered to prevent wind erosion.
(viii) During quarry and borrow site operation, provide adequate drainage to
avoid accumulation of stagnant water.
(ix) The use of river bed sources shall be avoided, as much as possible, however if
this is unavoidable the contractor shall minimize use of river bed for
construction materials and sources of fill and quarry materials lying on small rivers
and streams shall be avoided. Alluvial terraces or alluvial deposits which lie on the
river beds but are not covered by water in normal hydrological conditions shall be
preferred.
(x) It is possible that villagers may request borrow pits to be left excavated so that
they may be used as water reservoirs or fishponds. If this were to be agreed
between the contractors and the villagers, all full safety measures must be
observed to prevent drowning. Such agreements would be formalized in writing
between the contractors and the villagers after full discussion with all concerned
parties.
4. Rock Extraction
219. Where rock extraction is to be by explosives blasting, normal industry standards and
safety practices must be followed to minimize noise and vibration impacts. The blasting
method statement must be submitted to the resident engineer in advance for his approval.
220. The contractor, or his appointed blasting subcontractor, must advise on location of drilled
holes, depth of drilling, diameter of hole and charge per hole. The total number of holes and the
total maximum quantity of explosive to be used must be given. If pattern blasting is to be
utilized, then 10-20 millisecond delays between holes must be used to minimize vibrations.
Stemming to holes must be used to minimize noise and projection of “flyrock.”
221. If explosives are to be stored on site, a licensed magazine must be used. This must
have strict security and restricted access. An inventory of explosives transported in, used and
stored must be kept and reported monthly to the R.E.
222. Details of the type of explosive must be given, whether it proprietary or prepared on site
(e.g. ANFO). The type of initiation must be stated, whether electrical, cortex, etc. Local
residents must be made aware of blasting taking place and warned in advance. If possible
blasting must take place at some regular prearranged time so that residents become
accustomed to it and are not alarmed. Audible (siren) and visual (red flag) signals must be used
to warn passersby of an imminent blast.
223. Charges and hole spacing must be selected to minimise any subsequent “bouldering”
blasting. All intended blasting of quarries or for demolition of structures must be notified to the
UXO officer to ensure that any related areas have been cleared, in order to avoid secondary
detonations. Blasting for demolition of structures must be notified to local residents at least 7
days in advance. Written notices (in Khmer) must be distributed or attached to notice boards,
trees and the like in the area. Audible and visual warnings must be given in advance of the
blast.
52
5. Fabrication Sites
224. Concrete beams and culverts will be pre-cast in a fabrication yard and then transported
to site and erected. Cement and aggregate must be kept on the yard and not transported to site.
225. Materials such as earth, gravel and rock will be required for the road construction.
Borrow pits may be located along the roads. Gravel and crushed stone will be hauled by trucks
to the project sites. If contractors' haulage trucks exceed weight limits there may be damage to
bridges and road surfaces. Weight restrictions must be imposed on contractor’s vehicles to
prevent damage to structures. Wheel washing facilities must be provided at roadside camps to
prevent mud being carried over onto roads.
226. It is expected that vehicles will be stored at construction sites. Fuel stored on site must
follow good industry practice. Fuel suppliers must provide skid mounted tanks with a metered
off take and pump, mounted on a concrete hard standing. The concrete base must have a
perimeter kerb to catch and retain any minor leaks or spills from the main tank manifold. Some
vehicle maintenance may take place at commercial garages. This will have no impact on the
project area. If maintenance takes place on site, measures must be implemented to control oily
water runoff.
8. Waste Oil
227. Waste oil can be sold to local waste contractors. This process is endorsed. The project
contractor is at liberty to subcontract with any one he chooses. This approach has several
advantages:
228. Any waste oil must be stored in drums which are clearly marked “waste material”. The
drums must be of sound structural integrity and not leak, or be covered on the outside with dirty
oil.
229. Drums must be stored on a concrete hard standing with a perimeter kerb to catch and
retain any minor leaks or spills from the drums. The base must be covered with a lightweight
rain proof shelter. Simple inclined corrugated lightweight material is sufficient. This must stop
rain falling on the drums. (See figure below)
53
230. Bitumen will be heated by kerosene or gas. Fuel wood must not be used or as an
alternative cold mix bitumen can be employed. Asphalt must not be applied during rain so as to
avoid it being washed into watercourses.
231. Pile driving, improper silencing of vehicles and equipment used on the road construction
site may impact on communities. The Contractor must ensure that machinery is adequately
silenced and operations are restricted to normal daylight hours. Blasting noise must also be
controlled as described above.
232. The Contractor must maintain dust abatement procedures where roads, construction
sites and access areas pass through villages and at sites where workers are employed. In rock
quarries which are privately owned dust abatement will be owner's responsibility, unless the
crusher, screens and storage are owned by the contractor. Abatement measures can include
covering piles of raw material with tarpaulins to prevent dust being blown away, and water
spraying of roads and construction areas.
54
Fuel
Oil Rain Water Drain
"Normally Closed"
Concrete Base
Supports
Figure VI-9: Spill Protection for Fuel Oil Storage / Rain Proofing for Waste Oil Storage
233. Demolition of old structures may give rise to waste construction materials. These may
comprise waste concrete rubble, wood, nails and old steel re-bars. These can be sharp and
pose a threat to grazing animals. They must be disposed of at an agreed location approved by
the local authorities. This must be reported to the resident engineer.
234. Borrow pits, quarries, road embankments, culverts and bridge abutments and road
diversions will expose bare soils where material can be eroded. Areas must be re-vegetated as
soon as possible after disturbance. Depending on the season this may require watering to
55
ensure establishment of vegetation until the wet season arrives. Re-vegetation work may be
carried out by project affected people within the Resettlement Plan as a form of income
generation. Re-vegetation specifications will be included in the Detailed Design. The contractor
must take care to avoid unnecessary work within channels and avoid dumping of excavated
material into flowing channels. If possible, work which could affect water channels must take
place during the dry season, before heavy rainfall flows occur.
235. The Contractor must liaise with the relevant utility companies to check location of
services and avoid damage.
236. It may be required to divert traffic around certain areas. Warning signs and flagging
must displayed at the commencement of any road construction or diversion so as to forewarn
drivers of changed road conditions. Old signage must be removed by the Contractor.
237. Trees to be cut down are on 314D are 2,234 and NR13 it is 9,906. On NR53 there are
3,010 and 2,612 on the other western roads. For road 150B the trees on the shoulders are
15m high and along NR 13 planting on the shoulder/ sideslope must be removed as will the
short section in Prey Veng province where they are 10m high. Where they are under the new
road it will be necessary to remove the roots where widening from 4m to 8m as the tap root is
thought to be about 5m long. Replacement of trees is discussed under Resettlement.
238. If during excavation relics are discovered, under the Law on Cultural Heritage, 1996, the
discovery must be reported to the responsible agency.
239. The Contractor shall have a Safety Officer trained in first aid and the contractor must
check the response time of emergency facilities such as fire and ambulance. All workers must
be issued with PPE – Personal Protective Equipment – such as safety boots, helmets, goggles
and gloves. Workers must be trained in their use and reminded daily at morning “Toolbox
Briefings” when the day’s tasks are assigned. Records must be kept of accidents, lost time due
to fatalities, injury or medical attention. Workers should be offered incentives to report “near
misses” and correct carelessness. Extra efforts must be made to prevent children injuring
themselves on site after working hours. Emergency telephone numbers must be displayed
prominently on site.
240. The road is being built within an established ROW but minor dislocations such as
temporary bypasses around structures must be agreed by the contractor and local people.
56
241. Potable water must be supplied for cooking and washing but it is not intended for
drinking. If wells are drilled on sites the supply must be 100 L / man / day. It must be stored in
overhead storage tanks for gravity distribution. If no wells are planned water for personal
washing, laundry, cooking and toilets must be supplied to the camp by road tanker. The supply
must be 100 L / man / day.
2. Drinking Water
242. Adequate drinking water must be supplied. Between 1-4 litres per day bottled water
must be supplied per worker.
3. Sanitation
243. Toilets must be flushed by water which connects to septic tanks. Prefabricated septic
tanks must be used which have internal baffles and connect to underground soakaways. These
are readily available in the local market. It is recommended that local subcontractors / builders
be used to install them as they have local knowledge of soil conditions, water table depth and
are low cost.
Septic tanks must be covered with concrete slabs to control odour and must have vent pipes.
They must be accessible by manhole covers with grease seals to allow emptying when needed.
Soakaways must be constructed below the ground surface to allow dissipation of liquid effluents
and be subsurface.
4. Food Preparation
244. Food must be prepared by offsite local contractors to provide 3 meals per day. Food
waste must be collected daily and removed regularly to discourage vermin.
245. If the labor force is not supplied with adequate rations they may exert demands on local
supplies of fuelwood, fruit and wildlife. The Contractor must provide gas, kerosene or similar for
cooking and heating, and regular meals three times a day.
57
6. Washwater
246. Potable water must be used for personal hygiene washing, laundry and washing cooking
utensils. Such wash waters must be kept in a separate waste stream and not mixed with
sanitary waste. If discharged to water courses the waste water must first pass through a grease
trap to retain detergents and oil / grease. This must be cleaned regularly and the grease waste
buried.
247. Biodegradable waste must be buried in pits and covered with soil on a daily basis. Non
biodegradable wastes such as paper, plastics, cans bottles and the like must be collected and
removed from the site by a subcontractor.
8. Mobile Teams
248. If mobile teams are used they may move around the route as the works progress. The
contractors must rent houses as temporary quarters, with full water supply, sanitation and
cooking facilities for each team of workers. These locations must be determined through the
approval of the Engineer.
249. Contractors must check borrow pits, discarded plastic sacks, old tires and metal
containers for stagnant water to avoid temporary breeding habitats for mosquitoes. This must
be at least every 7 days to interrupt the breeding cycle of the mosquito which is 12 days.
Contractors must implement regular pesticide sprays and provide mosquito nets for workers
during sleeping.
250. The contractors must implement a pre-employment health screening, employ a safety
officer skilled in first aid, and carry out regular sanitary checks. They must also liaise with the
local emergency services (fire, police, ambulance) to check the response time of emergency
facilities.
251. Workers from outside the community must be given pre-employment HIV screening.
Work camps should be sited away from local communities. An HIV/AIDS awareness program
has been developed and should be implemented by a specialist subcontractor.
252. When construction is completed, the contractors must clean up the construction sites by
removing all equipment and buildings and carrying out site remediation work.
58
1. Alignments
253. A short section of NR53 will have its alignment adjusted slightly on the opposite side to
PAWS to avoid a concrete marker post of PAWS which has been placed actually outside the
PAWS boundary close to the shoulder of the road.
2. Embankments
The raising of the embankment to a flood free height will avoid flooding of the road. It may
cause runoff to be held behind the embankment and so additional cross drainage has been
included. Some slopes on NR13 will be eased from 1:2 to 1:3 to improve slope stability.
3. Noise
254. Noise from road traffic can be a nuisance for roadside residents. The project will have
positive impacts on the quality of life of roadside residents as paved roads will be less noisy, but
as traffic grows with more heavy goods vehicles noise levels will increase. The paved road will
assist in reducing noise. Other controls include; prohibition on the use of air horns at night and
fining drivers who operate vehicles without adequate silencers.
4. Air Pollution
255. Air pollution from vehicle operation, especially heavy diesel powered vehicles will
increase. The project will pave roads reducing dust which will have a major immediate beneficial
impact on those people living alongside the road. Road 314D will be improved by filling in of old
roadside narrow rectangular borrow pits which are a source of vector breeding. Provision of a
concrete road on 150B at the approach to Taches market will reduce airborne dust and improve
muddy conditions during rain and flooding.
5. Religious Edifices
256. There are no religious artefacts located near the roads. Graves will be avoided.
6. Road Accidents
257. Control of speeding and overloaded vehicles is the responsibility of the police. A
community based road safety program will be implemented.
7. Toxic Spills
258. Control of vehicles carrying hazardous materials is the responsibility of the police.
Vehicles in Cambodia do carry HAZCHEM warning signs. To date there do not appear to have
been any major accidental spills.
8. Illegal Settlement
259. MPWT will discourage illegal dwellings, encroachments and squatters within the RoW.
59
9. Loss of Forests
260. While the Project will improve access to PAWS protected area it is not expected to
increase any forest loss beyond that taking place at the moment. The Departments of
Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries are active in controlling illegal logging and impound vehicles
if caught involved in such activities.
a. Policy
261. All standing annual crops will be allowed to be harvested before the start of civil works in
a particular section of the Project roads. This can be achieved with the synchronization of the
start of civil works and the cropping schedule of DPs cultivating plots of land in the ROW. This is
shown below.
Crops and Loss of, or Owners DPs to be notified at least 3 months in advance of
trees damage to, regardless of the start of civil works in the locality.
assets tenure status To the extent possible, DPs will be allowed to
harvest their annual and perennial crops prior to
construction.
Perennial and timber trees will be compensated in
cash as per replacement cost study.
262. All standing annual crops will be allowed to be harvested before the start of civil works
in a particular section of the Project road. This can be achieved with the synchronization of the
start of civil works and the cropping schedule of DPs cultivating plots of land in the ROW.
263. PR314D: A total of 584 perennials of various species and age will be cleared from the
COI in PR314D. These trees are not commercially grown but sporadically planted inside the
ROW. Of this number, 82 are not yet bearing fruits. In addition, some 1,650 of timber trees of
commercial value will also be cleared from the COI.
264. CBF: A total of 583 timber trees and 15 fruit trees on private and government land will be
acquire in the expansion and development of the CBF.
265. NR13: A total of 966 perennials of various species and age will be cleared from the COI
in NR13. These trees are not commercially grown but sporadically planted inside the ROW. Of
this number, 195 are not yet bearing fruits. In addition, some 8,940 of timber trees of
commercial value will also be cleared from the COI.
267. The replacement cost of 584 perennials in PR314D is estimated to be $23,825.71, while
the 1,650 timber trees in said section are estimated to be $10,055.28. At the CBF, the
replacement cost of 598 perennials and timbers trees thereat is estimated to be $4,599.20. In
63
NR13, the replacement cost of 966 perennials is estimated to be $39,345.08, while the 8,940
timber trees in said section are estimated to be $44,435.99.
268. The estimated cost of resettlement for the rehabilitation of PR314D, CBF, NR13 is
US$1,676,977.00. Table VI-29 provides a breakdown of these costs. As can be seen from the
summary of resettlement costs replacement costs for trees along PR314D, CBF, NR13
represents 7.3% of total resettlement costs.
269. PR150B: A total of 2,278perennials of various species and age will be cleared from the
COI in PR150B. These trees are not commercially grown but sporadically planted inside the
ROW. Of this number, 224 are not yet bearing fruits. In addition, some 1,912 timber trees of
commercial value will also be cleared from the COI.
270. NR53: A total of 637 perennials of various species and age will be cleared from the COI
in NR53. These trees are not commercially grown but sporadically planted inside the ROW. Of
this number, 28 are not yet bearing fruits. In addition, some 687 timber trees of commercial
value will also be cleared from the COI.
64
271. PR151B: A total of 95 perennials of various species and age will be cleared from the
COI in PR151B. These trees are not commercially grown but sporadically planted inside the
ROW. Of this number, 44 are not yet bearing fruits. In addition, 13 timber trees of commercial
value will also be cleared from the COI.
274. There are no wildlife-protected areas within the immediate project area and there are
considerable numbers of rangers deployed to protect wildlife.
275. The project will have several positive benefits which will enhance the quality of life and
living standards of the local population. No mitigation is required but efforts must be made to
maximize these benefits.
276. The contractors must maintain contact on a working level with the local authorities :
Provincial DoE
Provincial DoCF
Provincial DoAFF
277. In addition liaison with community heads, local village representatives, individual
landowners and utility companies must be maintained.
J. Climate Change
1. Adaptation Strategy
278. In Cambodia, there appears to be an overall increase in average total annual rainfall
and, this increase is poorly distributed over seasons, resulting in increased floods during the
rainy season as well as increased drought incidence during the dry season.
279. Some of the ways in which climate change can impact on road infrastructure is damage
due to land-slides and mud-slides, increased moisture in the subsurface causing failure to the
structure, increased erosion to unpaved shoulders from rapid water runoff, increased winds
erosion of unpaved roads, and penetration of rainwater through poor surface treatment.
Increased wind and reduced moisture on unpaved roads can increase dust levels and reduce
visibility. These issues are of concern to the infrastructure itself as well as pose a safety issues
for drivers and other road and roadside users.
280. Flooding and soil moisture content is a primary concern for protecting investments in
road works and will be addressed as a priority in the adaptation strategy of this project. There is
no evidence of major landslides damaging the road in what is a relatively flat topography.
However, ditches alongside the road, created when materials are extracted for construction of
the embankments, are increasingly eroded and cause safety problems to people, livestock and
infrastructure.
281. The proposed project roads experience regular flooding both from surface runoff during
the rainy season and stream overflows each year in the rainy season. The most recent high
intensity event were the 2000/2001 floods. Experts recollect this to have been the only major
flood in the last 60 years in the project area (other parts of the country were affected by typhoon
Ketsana in 2009). With high likelihood of increasing intensity of rainfalls causing stronger floods
68
than usual, the roads need to be strengthened structurally to withstand intensified climate
events.
282. The proposed adaptation strategy therefore includes a combination of engineering, non-
engineering and planning activities to manage the changes observed and predicted in the
project area. The engineering changes have been mainstreamed in the project design itself for
mainstreaming adaptation into core development planning activities. These include elevation of
the road in areas where major flooding is becoming increasingly common and changing the
selection of sub-grade materials to withstand higher moisture contents.
283. All the water capture projects are rehabilitation and repair of existing structures. The
planned works will simply return them to their original state or improve them. No additional
impacts on the environment will be generated by these works.
284. The Cambodian legislation requires IEEs for irrigation projects greater than 5,000 ha. All
these projects are below this figure and so no IEE needs to be submitted to MoE.
285. In view of the absence of impacts no major mitigation measures are required.
286. The major impacts caused by the project in the rehabilitation of PR314D and NR13
include demolition of structures used for residence and business, and acquisition of occupied
land in the road ROW. According to the inventory of losses (IOL) conducted on 20 May 2011 –
2 June 2011, around 697 households (215 in PR 314D and 482 in NR13) in 20 communes (7
PR314D and 11 in NR13) are affected by the loss of fixed assets and sources of incomes or
livelihoods.1 45 households in PR314D and 108 households in NR13 are affected by impacts on
their homes and house-and-shops, of which 20 households in PR314D and 26 households in
NR13 will lose entirely their homes and house-and-shops and will need to reconstruct behind
the construction corridor.
287. Moreover, 62 households in PR314D and 114 households in NR13 are affected by
impacts on their independent shops (i.e., detached from other buildings), of which 45
households in PR314D and 57 households will have to relocate their business behind the
construction corridor. In PR314D, some 27,936 m2 of land in the ROW are used or occupied by
private households (12,004 m2 for agriculture and 15,932 m2 for residence and business), while
in NR13, around 47,398.3 m2 of land in the ROW are used or occupied by private households
(44,681 m2 for agriculture and 2,717 m2 for residence and business).
1
This number excludes the 14 houses and shops in PR314D and the 44 houses and shops in NR13 whose owners
could not be determined at the time of the IOL because said structures were unattended or locked.
70
288. Other fixed structures affected include fences, concrete pavements, extended eaves,
pipe culverts and sign boards. In addition, 96 electric and telecommunication posts (75 in
PR314D and 21 in NR13) need to be relocated behind the COI. Around 12,140 perennials and
timber trees (2,234 in PR314D and 9,906 in NR13) need to be removed from the COI.
289. In the expansion of the CBF at Prey Var, an aggregate of 24,945.12 m2 of private land
will be acquired, in addition to 2 houses and 1 store with a combined floor area of 90 m 2. Some
15 perennial and 583 timber trees owned by these private individuals will likewise be acquired.
Two absentee (i.e., living abroad or in Phnom Penh) and one landed local farmer own the
affected plots of land. Two other households have built structures on the land of two of the
landowners to oversee the properties. The existing CBF facilities are standing on a 10,982 m 2
government land.
290. The major impacts caused by the Project in the rehabilitation of PR150B, NR53, and
PR151B include demolition of structures used for residence and business, and acquisition of
occupied land in the road ROW. According to the inventory of losses (IOL) conducted on 6 – 21
June 2011, a total of 39 houses, 34 house-and-stores, and 89 shops in PR150B; 17 houses,
and 43 shops in NR53; and 2 houses and 10 shops in PR151B are adversely affected by the
rehabilitation of the Project roads; 38 houses and house-and-stores in PR150B; 12 houses in
NR 53; and 1 house in PR151B are entirely affected and must shift behind the corridor of
impact.
291. Moreover, 67 independent shops in PR150B, 29 shops in NR53, and 3 shops in PR151B
are entirely affected. Some150,290.5 m2 of ROW land in PR150B are used or occupied by
private households for farming, for residence and business; while 18,228.5 m2of ROW land is
occupied by private persons in NR53; and 2,485 m2in PR151B.
292. Other fixed structures affected include fences, concrete pavements, extended eaves,
pipe culverts and sign boards. In addition, 41electric and telecommunication posts (39in
PR150B and 2 in PR151B) need to be relocated behind the COI. Around 3,010 of perennials
and 2,612 timber trees need to be removed from the COI of the Project roads.
293. In order to avoid or minimize displacement of people from assets and livelihoods, the
existing road alignment will be followed and construction works will be confined within a corridor
of impact (COI) of 10 meters measured either way from the road centerline. In addition, as part
of the Project’s resettlement strategy, project displaced persons (DPs) will be provided sufficient
time to rebuild their homes and shops prior to the commencement of civil works and that they
are able to continue with their present livelihood activities even during Project implementation.
Also, all standing annual crops, including privately-owned trees, will be allowed to be harvested
before the start of civil works in a particular section of the Project roads. The MPWT, through its
Project Management Unit 3 (PMU3) and the Inter-ministerial Resettlement Committee (IRC),
through the Resettlement Department at the Ministry of Finance (RD-MEF), will ensure that this
resettlement strategy is followed diligently.
294. The project will acquire approximately 24.4ha of land within the existing ROW of various
roads and 2.5ha of privately owned land at the site of the Prey Vor cross border facility (CBF).
Land acquisition will cause temporary and permanent displacement of an estimated 936
households. Of the 566 households experiencing impacts on structures (houses and/or shops)
most will be partially affected and will be able to remain on remaining unaffected land. There
will 4 households that are expected to require relocation in Akphi Vot commune in Tuek Phos
district. The other affected households are expected to lose use of productive land within the
right of way only and/or secondary structures or trees/crops.
295. The total costs of resettlement for provincial roads 314D and 13 is US$1,676,977. The
total costs of resettlement for PR150B, NR 53, and PR151B is estimated at US$773,779.12.
Sub-Total 1 821,597.62
ALLOWANCES AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS
Moving allowance for relocating house and shops no. 151 $50 7,550.0
Moving allowance for 6 relocating house/shop renters no. 6 $50 300.0
Living allowance for relocating house no. 48 5,400.0
Living allowance for relocating independent shops no. 103 3,862.5
Income loss allowance for relocating shop, house/shop no. 106 $50 5,300.0
Rental allowance for relocating renters of house/store 2 mo 6 $25 300.0
Living allowance for vulnerable AHs 3 mo 385 100 kg 43,312.
Income restoration program (IRP) block fund lump sum 322,800
Hiring of IRP specialists/consultants 322,800 20% 64,560.0
Sub-Total 2 453,385.0
External Monitoring/Evaluation Lump sum 15,000.00
TOTAL DIRECT COSTS 1,289,982.62
Administrative Cost (15%) 193,497.39
Costs contingencies (15% 193,497.39
GRAND TOTAL (rounded) 1,676,977.0
72
Sub-Total 1 355,139.70
ALLOWANCES AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS
Moving allowance for relocating houses and shops no. 150 $50 7,500
Moving allowance for 1relocating shop renter no. 1 $50 50
Living allowance for relocating house and house-and-
no. 51 $112.5 5,737.5
store
Living allowance for relocating independent shops no. 99 $37.5 3,712.5
Income loss allowance for relocating shop, house/shop no. 115 $50 5,750
Rental allowance for relocating renters of shop 2 mo 1 $25 50
Living allowance for vulnerable AHs no 134 $112.5 15,075
Income restoration program (IRP) block fund 260 $600 156,000
Hiring of IRP specialists/consultants 156,000 20% 31,200
Sub-Total 2 225,075
External Monitoring/Evaluation Lump sum 15,000.00
TOTAL DIRECT COSTS 595,214.70
Administrative Cost (15%) 89,282.21
Costs contingencies (15% 89,282.21
GRAND TOTAL (rounded) 773,779.12
296. Bidding documents and civil works contracts will require implementation of appropriate
labor standards and basic occupational/health and safety measures. Civil works contracts will
also require unskilled men and women to be given priority for employment using LBES, and that
no child labor nor trafficked individuals be hired for the construction or maintenance works.
297. Monitoring tools with sex-disaggregated data will be developed and used for monitoring
project impacts (social benefits, employment and other economic opportunities, cases of
HIV/AIDS/STDs, human trafficking, etc.). These indicators will be included in the baseline
survey with sex-disaggregated and will be used for project impact monitoring. Actual inspection
and meeting/consultation with the laborers will be done at the project sites during road
construction and maintenance. Other monitoring tools will be designed. Monthly and quarterly
progress reports will also be prepared, in addition to the mid-term and final reports. The local
communities (CC/VDC) and the commune/district women and children’s consultative
committee) will be trained and encouraged them to participate in monitoring and evaluation
activities during and after project implementation.
73
M. Poverty Impacts
298. The project has 5 outputs: (1) civil works/road rehabilitation and construction of a cross
border facility at Prey Vor –Mocva; (2) improved road asset management; (3) increased road
safety (RS) and safeguards by implementing: a) a community-based RS awareness program in
line with the national program; b) an HIV-AIDS and human trafficking prevention program; and
c) a sex-disaggregated baseline socio-economic survey of beneficiaries; (4) climate change
adaptation to assess vulnerability to climate; develop emergency management planning; and (5)
efficient project management support to MPWT. During the road construction, unskilled men
and women will be given job opportunities using labor-based equipment support (LBES).
Around 30% of women will be hired during the construction and 30% during road maintenance
and in climate change adaptation and other community-based climate change activities. A labor
and gender action plan (LGAP) was prepared to serve as guide to ensure gender
mainstreaming before and during project implementation.
N. Gender Issues
299. The project will have significant positive impacts to women particularly female-headed
households. Majority of the houses are located more than 3km away from urban centers, where
hospitals, markets, banks and agencies are located. Lack of access to basic health facilities
affects women and children’s health as oftentimes they will just resort to self-medication instead
of going to the health center/hospitals for medical check-up. The schools are also located far
with 53% of households located 2-3 km from schools and 27% located more than 3km from
schools. Around 56% of the children go to school using bicycles while 37% go to school by foot.
300. The mothers also mentioned that their children’s health is at risk due to dust which they
inhale everyday when they go to school. There is a high rate of school drop-outs, especially
among girls in lower secondary levels due to the distance of schools from their houses and poor
economic conditions of households. Livelihood opportunities for women are even less than for
men. Agricultural production is low due to farmers’ limited access to irrigation facilities with the
majority being limited to planting rice only once a year. There are also few job opportunities in
rural areas, and low educational levels among girls would limit their capacity to compete with
others with higher educational attainment for waged employment. Lack of job opportunities in
the area push men and women to migrate to other areas. Migration rate in the project areas is
high (7.2%) and female migrants comprised 6% (2008 census). There are risks involved in
working in areas away from their families, e.g. engaging in risky behavior such as unprotected
sex with casual partners and sex workers, and drug use.
O. Indigenous Peoples
301. There will be improved access to markets, education, health, banks, and government
agencies. One hundred percent of the Cham and Vietnamese in Kampong Tralach and Tuek
Phos districts are highly in favor of the road project. For the Cham, they could go to mosques
faster, and the Vietnamese in Ta Ches market expressed that better roads will improve their
profit. There are over 10,000 IPs in the projects areas with more than 3,000 households.
adversely affected other than the generalized potential risks of HIV/AIDS, human trafficking and
road safety.
303. This project was originally classified as Category B and this has been confirmed by this
IEE. No Analysis of Alternatives is required.
304. A total of 40 public information meetings/ consultations with various stakeholders were
conducted in 25 communes from May-July 2011. A total of 319 people attended (50%) were
women. The meetings provided information on the project, anticipated impacts (environmental,
involuntary resettlement and social risks) and mitigation measures. Participants were provided
opportunities to raise questions, clarify information and express their opinions. There were also
7 separate consultations with the IPs/ethnic groups (i.e. Cham and the Vietnamese) conducted
in the districts of Kampong Tralach and Tuek Phos in Kampong Chhnang province from June-
July 2011. In addition to stakeholder consultations, a total of 700 households also participated
in the socio-economic baseline survey conducted in June 2011 and 437 (62%) of the
respondents were women.
306. Majority (69% or 42 respondents) of the male-headed and all 4 of the women-headed
AHs in PR150B are supportive of the Project. Similarly, most (82.76% or 24 respondents) and
all 8 of the women-headed AHs in NR53 are supportive of the Project. Also, most (77% or 10
respondents) of the male-headed and the 2 women-headed AHs in PR151B are supportive of
the Project. Among the reasons cited for their support of the Project are (a) good road will
facilitate the development of the villages, communes, and districts; (b) better access to health
care; (c) cheaper transport cost; and (c) cleaner environment. Reasons for the negative view
about the Project are (a) income loss due to disruption in business operation during
construction; (b) damage to or loss of houses and other structures; and (c) the need to rebuild
public structures, such as Pagoda gates, wells, and drainage system.
Full details are given in Annex 3.
307. Under the Climate Change Mitigation Measures component of TA 7665 Project, a series
of five water capture projects have been identified in Kampong Chhnang Province. Each of
75
these projects must be described in the IEE and an essential component of this evaluation is
Public Consultation. Public Consultation Meetings were conducted on 7-8 September 2011 in
Tuek Phos District, Kampong Chhnang Province
308. The public consultations were organized with the assistance of the Commune Chiefs in
each locality. Potentially Affected Persons from the villages were invited verbally, relevant
provincial government officers invited in writing by MPWT, and suitable locations organized in
pagodas. The venues were :
309. There were 3 venues for 4 meetings covering 5 communes, all in Tuek Phos District,
Kampong Chhnang Province. The 4 meetings took 2 days in total.
310. In order to demonstrate Gender Equity in the meetings and ensure a correct record of
comments from villagers the services of a female rapporteur were retained. A “break out group”
to hold discussions among females only was offered but proved not necessary.
311. It was estimated that 150 people might attend the 4 meetings over 2 days and
refreshments were offered to attendees. No other incentives were offered to any persons. The
budget was US$550. In the event 109 villagers attended plus provincial government staff and
consultants.
312. No disputes or conflicts were raised. Competing needs were described but in general all
the villagers were very supportive of the plan to provide more irrigation water for generating two
rice crops a year instead of one. Some pertinent points were :
A dam across the river was needed but it would raise the water level upstream
where people currently wade across the river because the water level is low.
Could a crossing be provided on top of the dam ?
One lady was concerned that she was so poor she could not afford the money for
a connection to a piped water supply and asked if she could offer her labor in
exchange for a connection?
The use of the ex-railway water tank to provide water was enthusiastically
supported. Local residents asked for drinking water not general garden irrigation
water. They were willing to pay for the water if it was cheaper than commercially
available bottled water. They were concerned over who would manage the water
supply, would it be taken over by private operators, and would the raise the price
of the water.
A villager offered use of his land for free to show his support for the projects
76
313. Government officers from MOE, MRD and MOWRAM also concurred with the proposals
and endorsed inter ministry cooperation.
A. Grievance Redress
315. During site preparation and construction phases, there may be complaints related to the
environmental performance of the project. To ensure that there will be a mechanism to resolve
such complaints, MPWT shall undertake the following prior to start of site works:
316. Through a Grievance Redress Committee (GRC), MPWT shall promptly address
affected people’s concerns, complaints, and grievances about the Project’s environmental
performance at no costs to the complainant and without retribution. The GRC, which shall
be established before commencement of site works, shall be chaired by PMU to be assisted
by the SEU. The GRC shall have members from the Provincial Department of Rural
Development (PDRD), commune councils, local NGO, and women’s organization. Grievances
can be filed in writing or verbally with any member of the GRC. The committee will have 15
days to respond with a resolution. If unsatisfied with the decision, the existence of the GRC
shall not impede the complainant’s access to the Government’s judicial or administrative
remedies.
317. PMU, through the PDRDs, shall make public the existence of this grievance redress
mechanism through public awareness campaigns. PMU shall also set-up a hotline for
complaints and the hotline shall be publicized through the media and numbers placed on the
notice boards outside the construction site and at local government offices (e.g., provincial,
district, commune levels). Locally affected people will still be able to express grievances through
the commune councils and these would be referred to PMU through the usual channels in those
committees.
318. The GRC, through the SEU, will receive, follow-up and prepare monthly reports
regarding all complaints, disputes or questions received about the Project and corresponding
actions taken to resolve the issues. The SEU will develop and maintain a database of
complaints received related to the Project. The GRC will also use the punitive clauses of the
1996 Law on Environmental Protection and Natural Resources Management in conjunction with
MOE to prosecute offending parties.
78
319. The General Environmental Management Plan (EMP) gives guidance on how to mitigate
the environmental concerns identified in connection with this project The EMP deals with
mitigation and management measures to be taken during Project implementation to avoid,
reduce, and mitigate adverse environmental impacts.
320. MPWT will ensure that the EMP is included in the tender documents for civil works. It
will form part of the contract between MPWT and the selected contractor and the requirements
of the EMP will be contractually binding on the contractor. The conformity of contractors with
environmental contract procedures and specifications shall be regularly monitored by the
project management unit (PMU) through the Social and Environmental Unit (SEU) during
Project implementation. PMU/SEU shall be assisted by the detailed design and implementation
supervision consultant (DDIS) to undertake EMP monitoring and to prepare corresponding
semi-annual reports for submission to ADB.
321. After appointment and mobilization the contractor must prepare his own version of the
EMP known as the Contractors EMP (CEMP). This must give specific details of locations of
borrow areas, borrow roads, workers camps and other facilities. This must be submitted to the
Supervising Consultant for their approval before works commence.
322. A document has been produced jointly by MRD and MPWT entitled “Guidance on the
Implementation of Environmental Safeguards”. This was produced under the “Provincial and
Rural Infrastructure Project (PRIP) PHRD Grant No. TF056974.(May 2010) It is a guidance
document and has no regulatory authority but the contractor should obtain a copy and follow its
recommendations.
324. SEU staff with environmental knowledge will respond to complaints during the
construction phase, and support the environmental inspectors in the field.
79
325. On 20th October 2005 MPWT engaged the services of an Independent Consultant under
the Cambodia Road Improvement Project, ADB Loan 1945. His duties were to assist in the
reorganizing of MPWT. The reorganized structure was to be submitted to the Council of
Ministers within 24 months of loan effectiveness.
327. In December 2006 the consultant recommended the staff needed for Social and
Environmental Impact Evaluation were :
Chief of Division
Social specialist
Environmental specialist
Land / property surveying supervisor
328. Job descriptions were provided. In February 2007 the SED was reviewed again and the
need for further training noted. This review was repeated in October 2007. The SED staff were
involved in the resettlement and land acquisition issues associated with NR5, NR6 and NR56.
329. Currently the SED is located in the MWPT under the Department of Planning and
Investment (DPI). The Director of DPI has the additional duties of being Head of SED. He
reports to the General Directorate of Planning and Administration who in turn reports to the
Undersecretary of State, Secretary of State and Minister. He has three staff who have a
background in legal studies and the social sciences. There is a strong need for more technical
skills. There mandate is oversight, monitoring and evaluation.
330. SEU Environmental Staff must coordinate the site assessment procedures undertaken
by the consultants site inspectors. They will be involved in the finalization of the EMP, the
familiarization of the inspectors with the check lists and reporting procedures and the interaction
of the inspectors with the contractors. (see Table Annex 1)
331. They must review the monthly reports of the inspectors and comment on them before
submitting to the Project Manager for discussion at the monthly progress meetings. Where
issues are identified and remedial measures proposed by the contractors, the SEU must check
before the next monthly meeting if these measures have in fact been implemented, and if they
proved effective. If not, the issues must be raised at the next progress meeting.
332. If the DoE or MoE are needed for environmental monitoring, or analysis, using
equipment that is not available to consultants’ inspectors, the SEU must coordinate with MoE in
Phnom Penh to arrange the necessary support. SEU will be responsible for receiving any
analytical data from the MoE and interpreting it in terms of the legislation, and the obligations it
places on the contractors of MPWT. The duties and responsibilities of SEU must include
ensuring that the contractors comply with the relevant legislation.
80
E. EMMP
1. Environmental Monitoring
334. The essence of monitoring is to ensure Compliance with Environmental Legislation. The
contractors have a duty to comply with the relevant legislation. The supervising consultant must
check their activities and report to MPWT. In the event of noncompliance MPWT can exert
pressure on the contractor to comply.
2. Measurements
335. It will be necessary to carry out measurements to establish if the regulations are being
met. In fact, simple compliance with the standards is not necessarily the final objective. There is
no harm in the contractor “going beyond compliance” and running an operation better than that
required by the standard. The measurements to be made and standards to be met are given
below. There will be a “hierarchy” of monitoring and measurements. This would be based on :
Contractors
Consultants inspectors
SEU environmental staff
Ministry of Environment
336. Initially, contractors should check daily that all operations are being conducted correctly.
In general “good housekeeping” must be employed. Overflowing of septic tanks must be
checked by visual inspection. Dust must be controlled by covering of stockpiles and water
sprays. Solid waste, engine oil and grease, must be taken away by waste removal contractors
and records kept.
337. Construction supervision inspectors must make daily spot checks and weekly formal
checks on site operations. They must cross check all of the above and view records for waste
disposal. They must also investigate any pollution incidents or complaints. They must use the
checklists for record purposes and make sure that the complaint or incident is brought to the
notice of the contractor immediately, verbally and with a follow up written notice.
338. SEU staff will have access to noise and water quality monitoring equipment. This will be
kept at a central location and made available as necessary. SEU staff will be responsible for
care and maintenance of the equipment and regular calibration. When requested by inspectors
SEU staff must visit the site and make measurements. The equipment for noise and water will
give direct results so data will be available immediately. In the event that more detailed
information is required on water quality SEU staff must take samples of water and deliver them
to a commercial laboratory for analysis. This may be MOE or other labs which are available. In
addition SEU staff should make monthly visits to site to check the veracity of reporting. They
should also review the reports submitted by the consultants to the MPWT and report to the
MPWT project manager.
81
340. If dust measurements are needed than a two stage process must be adopted. A high
volume sampler (HVS) will be deployed by MOE. After a suitable period, usually 24 hours, the
filter in the HVS will be retrieved by MOE staff and transported to the laboratory for the second
stage which is analysis. This requires highly specialized equipment which MOE possess in
Phnom Penh. The MOE will charge for this service. These charges must be covered by the
contractor.
341. The results must be submitted to SEU who will interpret them with respect to the
relevant regulations. Discussions must then be held with SEU, the consultants’ inspectors and
the contractor to determine how to resolve any problems.
342. After extraction from borrow areas is finished, revegetation and reinstatement must be
carried out. Warning signs must be erected to avoid drowning if deep ponds are left. Inspectors
and SEU staff must make regular checks by visual inspection.
3. Timing of Monitoring
343. The timing of the monitoring is important. The following list is for guidance and is
indicative only.
Liquid emissions from sites must be checked every three months or after heavy
rain if overflowing is reported. Measurements in streams and water courses
must be made.
Dust emissions on site must be checked weekly by visual inspection and monthly
by examining records of water spraying. Ambient air quality must be checked
over a 24 hour continuous period at sensitive receptors in the event of
complaints.
Noise levels must be checked every three months at site perimeters, or in the
event of a complaint, at night as well as during the daytime.
Correct removal and disposal of food waste and waste engine oil and grease
must be checked weekly by visual inspection of the camps and checking of
records from the waste disposal contractors.
Noise and vibration must be checked at sensitive receptors when blasting first
occurs or in the event of complaint. Before blasting commences warning notices
must be posted to local residents.
Reinstatement of borrow pits and quarries must be checked after closure of the
facility.
344. In addition to regular monitoring, unannounced spot checks must be made by SEU on
contractors operations. All of the above procedures should be carried out by the site inspectors,
in conjunction with SEU, and where appropriate MOE/ DOE. The results should be formally
recorded every week and compiled into a monthly report. This should be submitted to the
Engineer, the Chief Resident Engineer and discussed with SEU and the contractors as
necessary but at a minimum on a monthly basis. Monthly reports should be compiled into
quarterly and annual reports to be submitted to ADB.
82
4. Review Procedures
345. Successful implementation of the EMP will require combined efforts from contractors,
consultants, MPWT and local authorities. The EMP is a dynamic document and may be subject
to change as the project progresses. Periodic reviews may be necessary and these should in
fact be encouraged. These changes should be driven by the SEU in MPWT.
346. The contractors should have an environmental specialist on their staff who will advise on
implementing the EMP. MPWT will retain supervision consultants. They will maintain a
Resident Engineer on site and a team of inspectors. The inspector’s responsibilities will include
environmental issues and they must check activities and progress against environmental
checklists. (See Annex 2) The inspectors must report to the resident engineer who in turn
submits reports to the Consultants. Environmental results must be reported to the social and
environment division (SEU) which has been established in the Department of Planning, MPWT.
The results must also be incorporated in the progress reports submitted to ADB.
6. Response to Complaints
347. Villagers and APs are encouraged to voice complaints and these are to be duly
investigated and reported through the contractor to SEU and so to MPWT. As a
complaints procedure exists it is recommended that this procedure be maintained and
extended to include environmental issues.
349. Review of progress must be checked on a daily basis by the inspectors. Any urgent
issues must be drawn to the contractors’ attention immediately. Failure by the contractor to
respond in a timely or adequate manner must be raised with them at the monthly progress
meetings. The procedure is shown below.
84
350. The estimated costs for implementing the EMP are provided in Table VII.3 as follows:
Table VII.3: SUMMARISED POTENTIAL NEGATIVE IMPACTS, MITIGATION MEASURES AND RESPONSIBILITIES
Activities Potential Negative Impacts Mitigation Measures Implementing Supervising
Organisation Organisation
(a) Road alignment Damage to marker posts showing Road alignment was changed slightly widen Consultant MoCF, MPWT
boundary of PAWS. road on opposite side to PAWS.
(b) Raising Road Increase erosion, possible road All bridges stream flow area increased, extra Consultant MPWT
Affecting Hydrology or failure due to impoundment of cross drainage provided. Included in detailed
Drainage. flood waters. design.
(c) Road Widening Loss of infrastructure Minimal Impacts, alignment changed to Consultant N/A
change number of railway crossings from 3 to
1. No mitigation required.
(d)Need for fill material Loss of livehood, Loss of Develop alternative uses for borrow pit areas Contractor SEU, MPWT
Agricultural Land for Borrow Pits. with agreement of farmers and villagers. Some
villagers request borrow pits to be left as water
ponds for use by village.
(e) Cutting of roadside Loss of roadside trees, loss of Compensation to be paid under Resettlement IMRC MPWT
trees shade and utility. Plan. No replanting is required by contractor.
(f) Cut faces and borrow Erosion and instability of cut Design cut slope to minimize instability. Consultant MPWT
pits faces and borrow pits Use structural stabilization measures such as
retaining walls and gabions, if necessary.
Use adequate design, siting, and sizes of
drainage structures.
All included in detailed design.
(g) Outflow from drainage Erosion of Lands below the Position drainage structures to avoid a Consultant MPWT
structures roadbed receiving concentrated cascade effect and to ensure that runoff is
outflow carried by drainage conveyed into natural drainage lines at
structures– in contravention of controlled velocities.
Draft Sub-Decree on Water Line receiving areas with stones or concrete to
Quality. protect soils at outflow areas
Incorporate sufficient number of drainage
outlets such that flow from any individual outlet
is not excessive.
Included in detailed design.
(h) Road alignment Loss of riverside vegetation, Minimise areas of bridge abutments Consultant MPWT
across river disturbance river flow. Minimise area of bridge pillars.
(i) Road widening for Loss of vegetation and habitat Shoulders will be approx 1 metre. No mitigation Contractor Consultant
hard shoulders through road widening, and hard necessary.
shoulders
(j) Road alignment Impacts on wildlife through No impacts. Consultant Consultant,
interruption of migratory routes MPWT, DoE
87
(xxxii) Construction Destruction of agricultural land Do not dispose cut spoil and construction Contractor SEU, MAFF
activities near prime through spoil and construction waste at agricultural land.
agricultural lands waste disposal– in contravention
of Draft Sub-Decree on Waste
Management
(xxxiii) Construction Solid waste– in contravention of Provide garbage bins & sanitary facilities for Contractor SEU
Camps Operation Draft Sub-Decree on Waste workers. Waste in the bins should be cleared
Management periodically.
Special attention should be paid to the
sanitary condition of camps.
(xxxiv) Residual Effects Depletion of natural resources Do not harvest wood resources within the Contractor SEU
from Construction Camps through demand for building PAWS
materials, fuel and food for Do not allow construction camps to become
workers– in contravention of Law permanent settlements. Remove camps prior
on Environmental Protection and to project completion.
Natural Resource Management Use non-wood fuels such as Liquid Propane
(1996) Gas or kerosene for cooking food and heating
bitumen.
Where local materials must be used, make
agreements with local communities about the
95
(c) Poor control of Accidental Risk of Toxic Spills – Enforcement of transport regulations and Police DoE, Police
increased traffic volume in contravention of Draft Sub- HAZCHEM procedures
with more vehicles Decree on Hazardous
carrying hazardous Substances
96
352. All potential environmental impacts have been identified. The project is confirmed as
being Category B according to ADB guidelines.
353. Only minor environmental impacts are anticipated. Such impacts will be experienced
during site works mainly due to dust and noise emissions as well as potential occupational and
community health and safety risks, but can be mitigated. Some minor mitigation measures will
be specified but no major impacts have been identified.
354. Some slopes on NR13 will be eased from 1:2 to 1:3 to improve slope stability. Road
314D will be improved by filling in of old roadside narrow rectangular borrow pits which are a
source of vector breeding.
355. Provision of a concrete road on 150B at the approach to Taches market will reduce
airborne dust and improve muddy conditions during rain and flooding.
356. A short section of NR53 will have its alignment adjusted slightly on the opposite side to
PAWS to avoid a concrete marker post of PAWS which has been placed actually outside the
PAWS boundary close to the shoulder of the road.
357. None of the eastern project roads (NR13, 314D and the CBF) are in close proximity to
any protected areas of ecological significance.
358. For the western roads, none traverses the transition, buffer or core zones of ecologically
protected areas.
359. Road 150B has an eastern section of 5.5 kms which connects NR5 to Tonle Sap river. It
terminates at the village of Ta Ches at the ferry crossing point of the river. This point is the
nearest that any project road approaches to the boundaries of Tonle Sap Biosphere Reserve.
Road 150B is approximately 4.5 kms from the boundary of the outer zone, known as the
Transition zone. There will be no impacts from the road on TLSBR.
360. NR 53 runs alongside part of the eastern boundary of Phnom Aural Wildlife Sanctuary
for a distance of approximately 6.5 kms. The boundary is defined in the Royal Decree 1993 and
is indicated by concrete marker posts. Site surveys have been conducted to confirm the exact
location of the boundary markers, and these have agreed by local villagers and the PDE
officers. The PDE officers confirmed that NR53 does not intrude into the PAWS.
361. Road 151B marks the most southern point of the western project roads. This road is
further away from PAWS than NR53 and more than 50 kms from Kirirom National Park. No
adverse environmental impacts are anticipated from this section of the project road on protected
areas.
362. The Sub-decree No 72 ANRK.BK. Date 11, August 1999 contains an annex “List of the
projects that require an Initial Environmental Impact Assessment”. This stipulates that an IEE is
required for “National Road Construction ≥ 100 Kilometers and bridges ≥ 30 tonnes”. As this
project is rehabilitation of existing roads, and the only bridge will be 25 tonnes capacity, then
according to MOE Legislation an IEE will not be required.
98 Annex 1
363. To avoid or mitigate negative impacts arising from the project, an environmental
management plan (EMP) detailing mitigation measures and monitoring activities has been
prepared as part of the IEE.
364. Public consultations involving affected people and local officials have been conducted
during the preparation of the IEE in compliance with ADB information disclosure and
consultation requirements through focus group discussions and individual interviews in all
project affected provinces. Environment was not seen as a major issue by those persons
interviewed.
365. Climate change adaptation was included in the project. The residents knowledge of
climate change induced affects, and adaptation strategies, was limited. However, they were
strongly in favor of water capture projects.
366. Temporary environmental impacts caused by the civil works have been identified and
mitigation measures are given in the EMP. The EMP (and EMMP) will be included in the IEE
and will form part of the tender documents which becomes legally binding on the selected
contractor.
367. To ensure that the project is carried out in accordance with the EMP requirements,
MPWT will specify details of the implementation of the EMP in the tender documents and civil
works contracts.
368. ESO (previously SEU) is operational but needs capacity building. The detailed design
and implementation supervision consultant will provide on-the-job training to the field personnel
of the ESO of MPWT to build their capacity in environmental management and monitoring.
369. No environmental impacts were identified that would warrant the conduct of an
environmental due diligence study.
Annex 1 99
ROAD Date of
SECTION FROM TO Survey
BEGINNING
POINT
KRABAU 122
kms from
NR13 PHNOM PENH NR1 17.3.2011
Measured Marked Start
# distance Chainage LHS / RHS Feature /End Reference
1 0 0 LHS Electricity post; Low Tension 0954
2 0 RHS Electricity post; Low Tension
3 0.4 LHS / RHS Electricity post; Low Tension
crossing, culvert
4 1.0 RHS Mature trees
5 1.4 LHS / RHS Trees
6 1.5 LHS Electricity post; Low Tension,
lateral borrow areas both sides
7 2.3 LHS/ RHS Close trees
8 2.9 LHS Electricity post; Low Tension, no
trees, road very dusty
9 3.9 LHS Electricity post; Low Tension,
cross drainage
10 4.6 LHS Andong Trabek school
11 4.8 Both Open Padi
12 6.5 LHS/RHS Excavations, Electricity post; Low
Tension, LHS
13 7.4 LHS Low shrubs
14 9.6 LHS Andong Trabek Police Station
15 10.2 LHS Temple
16 13.1 LHS/RHS Open Padi
17 14.4 RHS School
18 14.5 LHS Commune Building
19 15.3 LHS Pagoda
20 16.8 Both Bushes
RHS Mobile Tour
21 17.6 RHS EU FAO Food Program
22 17.7 RHS Svay Rien province boundary,
road dusty
23 19.7 Both Crossroads, Commune office,
police station, EU/FAO signs.
Roads dusty
24 22.3 LHS Electricity post; Low Tension
25 23.5 Both Tarmac surface begins
26 23.7 Both 15Tonne bridge over river. Built
2001, needs replacing
27 23.8 LHS Electricity post; Low Tension
28 24.0 Both High school. Small town, market,
Kampong Trach
29 24.7 LHS Kampong Trach health centre
30 24.8 Both Romeashek Referral Hospital
(LHS); District office (LHS); School
(LHS); Pagoda (RHS)
100 Annex 1
ROAD Date of
SECTION FROM TO Survey
BEGINNING
POINT
KRABAU 122
kms from
NR13 PHNOM PENH NR1 17.3.2011
Measured Marked Start
# distance Chainage LHS / RHS Feature /End Reference
31 25.9 LHS High school
32 28.0 Both 16T bridge, Culvert
33 31.1 LHS Pagoda entrance; primary school
34 32.9 LHS Electricity post; Low Tension
35 36.2 LHS / RHS Mobile phone towers; Hospital,
pagoda (RHS)
36 38.2 38+200 Both Bridge Built 2003 no weight limit
37 38.9 LHS / RHS Pagoda (RHS), High school (LHS)
ROAD Date of
SECTION FROM TO Survey
BEGINNING
POINT
KRABAU 122
kms from
NR13 PHNOM PENH NR1 17.3.2011
Measured Marked Start
# distance Chainage LHS / RHS Feature /End Reference
62 60.0 LHS Pagoda
63 60.8 Both Box culvert
64 61.1 Both Primary schools
65 61.3 Both Highway 1 1135
ROAD Date of
SECTION FROM TO Survey
BEGINNING
POINT
NR13 Highway 1 CBF 17.3.2011
Measured Marked Start
# distance Chainage LHS / RHS Feature /End Reference
1 0 0 Rasot, T-junction Highway 1. 1200
Height restriction Max 16T axle 2,
20T axle 3
2 0.5 RHS Hospital
3 1.0 RHS Electricity post; Low Tension,
gravel road
4 2.3 Both Electricity lines crossing
5 2.4 RHS Electricity from Vietnam
6 2.9 LHS Pagoda
7 3.4 LHS Primary school
8 5.3 RHS Electricity posts High Tension
9 6.0 LHS Pagoda
10 6.4 LHS Christian church
11 6.7 RHS Pagoda
12 7.3 LHS Mobile Phone tower
13 7.4 LHS/RHS Electricity post High Tension
14 10.1 LHS Electricity post; Low Tension
15 11.4 RHS Pagoda; electric poles crossing
16 13.6 RHS Pagoda
17 14.7 Both Road very dusty
18 15.0 Both Road changes from gravel to
blacktop
19 15.2 LHS Kampomg Gro high school
20 15.5 Both Roundabout, dual carriageway
21 15.6 Both Blacktop ends, gravel resumes
22 15.8 LHS Market
23 16.3 LHS Mobile phone tower, high tension
electricity poles
24 17.8 RHS Primary school
25 19.3 Both Water gate and water channel
102 Annex 1
ROAD Date of
SECTION FROM TO Survey
BEGINNING
POINT
NR13 Highway 1 CBF 17.3.2011
Measured Marked Start
# distance Chainage LHS / RHS Feature /End Reference
crossing road
26 21.1 LHS Pagoda
27 21.4 LHS Mobile phone tower
28 22.9 Both Bridge 16T. Viet Nam border
markers
29 24.5 LHS Boats loading rice to Viet Nam
30 25.0 Both Viet Nam border crossing 1400
ROAD Date of
SECTION FROM TO Survey
Crossing
BEGINNING NR5 to
150B and POINT Tonle Tuek Phos
NR53 Sap River Village 16.6.2011
Measured Marked Start
# distance Chainage LHS / RHS Feature /End Reference
1 0 0 LHS Tak Ches Village Market; very 0900
narrow road
2 1.1 RHS Pagoda, school
3 1.3 LHS Rice padi
4 1.7 LHS Rice padi
5 2.6 LHS Mosque
6 3.5 LHS School
7 4.7 LHS/ RHS School; Health centre
8 5.1 RHS Mobile phone tower
9 5.3 Both NR5 intersection
10 5.7 RHS School setback 200m
11 6.2 LHS Commune office
12 6.7 Both Rice paddies
13 7.5 LHS Mobile phone tower
14 8.4 Both Road on embankment, rice padis
15 9.0 LHS Sharp left hand bend
16 9.6 LHS/RHS Mobile phone tower/School
17 12.7 Both Embankments
18 13.3 RHS School
19 13.5 LHS Mosque
20 15.7 Both Rice padis
21 17.5 LHS Old sign Primary school
22 19.1 LHS Road to school
23 19.6 RHS Mobile phone tower
24 20.2 LHS Grave setback 100m
25 21.7 Both HT Electric poles crossing
26 22.9 RHS Sharp right hand bend, rice padis
both sides
27 23.5 LHS Left hand bend
Annex 1 103
ROAD Date of
SECTION FROM TO Survey
Crossing
BEGINNING NR5 to
150B and POINT Tonle Tuek Phos
NR53 Sap River Village 16.6.2011
Measured Marked Start
# distance Chainage LHS / RHS Feature /End Reference
28 23.8-24.2 LHS Grave, school, many mature trees
29 25.1-25.3 LHS Dense stands of trees
30 26.9 Both Rice padis
ROAD Date of
SECTION FROM TO Survey
BEGINNING
POINT
Tuek Phos
NR13 Village End 151B 17.3.2011
Measured Marked Start /
# distance Chainage LHS / RHS Feature End Reference
1 0 0 Culvert #7 0954
2 2.5 LHS LT Electric poles
3 3.6 LHS School
4 3.7 RHS Pagoda
5 3.8 LHS Mobile phone tower
6 5.2 Both sides Mobile phone towers
ROAD Date of
SECTION FROM TO Survey
BEGINNING
POINT
Tuek Phos
NR13 Village End 151B 17.3.2011
Measured Marked Start /
# distance Chainage LHS / RHS Feature End Reference
20 22.2 LHS LT Electric poles
21 23.8 RHS School
22 26.7 LHS LT Electric poles
23 28.9 LHS Fishponds
24 29.3 LHS Watergate
25 30.3 RHS Y-junction
26 306 Both River
27 31.2 Both Y-junction 151B 1500
ROAD Date of
SECTION FROM TO Survey
BEGINNING Chinese
151B POINT NR53 Road 09.07.2011
Measured Marked Start
# distance Chainage LHS / RHS Feature / End Reference
1 0 0 LHS LT Electric poles 1330
2 0.4 LHS Borrow pits full of water
3 1.7 LHS Private school
4 1.8 LHS Pagoda
5 3.3 RHS Mobile phone tower
6 3.7 LHS Oblique junction; end of 151B 1400
section; junction with “Chinese
road”.
Annex 2 105
Project Site:
Observer:
Frequency: Check weekly during preparation of camp, at opening of camp, then weekly or in response to
complaint.
Date: Time:
Weather Condition:
If no, comment on how it is being disposed and what are the impacts:
If no, comment on how it is being disposed and the impacts of such disposal:
If yes, are appropriate precaution taken to avoid water and land contamination?
8. Is the fuel storage area properly surfaced and has a containment kerb
around it?
10. Does the community have any issues with the camp?
Project Site:
Observer:
Frequency: Check weekly during preparation of borrow pit, at opening, then weekly or in response to complaint.
Date: Time:
Weather Condition:
If no, comment:
17. Are the cut faces stabilized with appropriate materials and methods?
19. Are the borrow pit / quarry operations creating excessive dust / noise?
If yes, are any measures being taken to minimize dust and noise?
20. Do the communities have any concerns / issues with borrow pit /
quarry during operation or after closure?
Project Site:
Observer:
Date: Time:
Weather Condition:
b. Improper drainage
e. Are the slopes properly stabilized before the start of the rainy
season?
If yes, comment:
4. Did the contractor take appropriate mitigatory measures, pre and post
erosion / instability / landslides, to avoid / counter the problem?
If no, why did the contractor not consider it necessary to take appropriate mitigatory measures?
(N.B. The contractor must carry out his activities to ensure compliance with
the regulations stated in draft Sub Decree on Air and Noise Pollution Control)
Project Site:
Observer:
Date: Time:
Weather Condition:
Checklist Question
If yes, did the contractor take appropriate measure to mitigate the problem?
(N.B. The contractor must carry out his activities to ensure compliance with
the regulations stated in Sub Decree on Water Pollution Control, No. 27 ANRK.BK, April 06, 1999)
Project Site:
Observer:
Weather Condition:
Checklist Question
a. disposal of cut spoil into water body or on slope leading to water body
b. discharge of wastewater from camp into fresh water body
c. road run-off into water body
d. discharge of used oil, fuel, grease, etc. into water body
1.2 Groundwater
e. leakage of oil, fuel, wells, etc. on land resulting in
contamination of ground water and wells
f. any other reason
If yes, comment:
Additional comments:
112 Annex 2
CHECKLIST 6 Agriculture
(N.B. The contractor must carry out his activities to ensure compliance with
the regulations stated in draft Law on Agriculture made by MAFF)
Project Site:
Observer:
Date: Time:
Weather Condition:
Checklist Question
If yes, how?
If yes, comment:
Project Site:
Observer:
Date: Time:
Weather Condition:
Checklist Question
13. Is the local administration satisfied with the measures taken by the
contractor to protect agricultural activities?
14. Did the community allow the use of their land for borrow pit or any
other purpose?
If no, did the contractor take permission from the land owner and local administration for the specific use?
(N.B. The contractor must carry out his activities to ensure compliance with the regulations stated
in "Law on Protection of Cultural and National Heritage", (1996)
Project Site:
Observer:
Date: Time:
Weather Condition:
If yes, how?
3. Did the concerned authorities and the contractor take any appropriate
measures to protect the site?
(N.B. The contractor must carry out his activities to ensure compliance with
the regulations stated in draft Sub Decree on Air and Noise Pollution Control)
Project Site:
Observer:
Date: Time:
Weather Condition:
Checklist Question
a. vehicles on road
b. Generators, construction plant
c. Construction vehicles
d. vibration from equipment
e. vibration from road vehicles
f. vibration from explosive blasting
Checklist Question Yes No Additional
Data needs
30. Is the problem significant enough to warrant attention?
If yes, did the contractor / consultant take appropriate measure to mitigate the problem?
Project Site:
Observer:
Frequency: As required
Date: Time:
Weather Condition:
34. Are cross drainage structures "as built" same as in "detailed design"?
Project Site:
Observer:
Date: Time:
Weather Condition:
37. Has the camp / yard been properly cleared of all debris and
revegetated?
If no, comment on how it was being disposed and what were the impacts:
If no, comment on how it was being disposed and the impacts of such disposal:
If yes, have all appropriate precautions been taken to avoid water and land contamination?
43. Has the scrap metal from vehicle maintenance being disposed of
properly?
44. Has all fuel storage been removed from the site?
45. Have all general offices and staff dwellings been removed?
If no, comment on if they are to be handed over to new owner or other plans:
46. Does the community have any issues with the camp closure?
Table 9. Data on Wet Season Rice Irrigation and Farmers’ Access to Irrigation
Province Description 2007 2008
Svay Total area of wet season rain fed rice land 98% 597,452 ha
Rieng Percentage of wet season rice land that is 2% 3,001 ha (1%)
Province irrigated & are in hectares (2008):
(i) Area irrigated from canal/dam 75% 2,364 ha (78%)
(ii) Area irrigated from river, stream, etc. 7% 11 ha (0%)
(iii) Area irrigated from drilled well 11% 370 ha (12%)
(iv) Area irrigated from dug pond 8% 266 ha (9%)
Families who have access to irrigation 5% 5,826 families (5%)
water
Families who have irrigation wells 1% 1,532 families (1%)
Number of irrigation wells in the province 1,029 wells 1,272 wells
Percentage of families per district (with
access to (supplemental) irrigation for wet No Data in 2008
season cultivation 2007
Project (i) Kampong Rou District - 11.0% (access to irrigation); 4.8%
Areas (access to supplemental irrigation);
(Svay 478 families owned irrigation; wells-
Rieng) 429 number of irrigation wells.
(ii) Rumduol District - 0.0% (access to irrigation); 0.1%
(access to supplemental irrigation);
53 families owned irrigation; wells -
47 number of irrigation wells .
(iii) Romeas Haek District - 0.9% (access to irrigation); 0.2%
(access to supplemental irrigation);
493 families owned irrigation; wells
378 number of irrigation wells.
(iv) S vay Teab District - 0.7% (access to irrigation); 0.0
(access to supplemental irrigation);
26 families owned irrigation; wells 25
number irrigation wells .
Prey Total area of wet season rain fed rice land 88% 180,744 ha (87%)
Veng Percentage of wet season rice land that is 12% 25,928 ha (13%)
Province irrigated & are in hectares (2008):
(i) Area irrigated from canal/dam 56% 15,847 ha (61%)
(ii) Area irrigated from river, stream, etc. 26% 5,451 ha (21%)
(iii) Area irrigated from drilled well 17% 4,455 ha (17%)
(iv) Area irrigated from dug pond 0% 175 ha (1%)
Families with access to irrigation 22% 47,278 families (21%)
Families who have irrigation wells 7% 15,554 families (7%)
Number of irrigation wells in the province 14,649 wells 14,467 wells
Percentage of families per district with
access to irrigation for wet season No Data 2007 2008
cultivation
Project (i) Kamchay Mear District - 8.7% (access to irrigation); 3.6%
Area (access to supplemental irrigation);
892 families owned irrigation; wells-
681 number of irrigation wells (dist.)
Kampong Total area of wet season rainfed rice land 78% 84,905 ha (83%)
Chhnang Percentage of wet season rice land that is 22% 16,988 ha (17%)
Province irrigated & are in hectares (2008):
(i) Area irrigated from canal/dam 22% 16,988 ha (17%)
(ii) Area irrigated from river, stream, etc. 70% 10,435 ha (22%)
122 Annex 3
Total area of wet season rain fed rice land 87% 267,089 ha (87%)
Kampong Percentage of wet season rice land that is 13% 13,037 ha (5%)
Speu irrigated & are in hectares (2008):
Province (i) Area irrigated from canal/dam 80% 11,253 ha (86%)
(ii) Area irrigated from river, stream, etc. 19% 1,760 ha (14%)
(iii) Area irrigated from drilled well 0% 0 ha (0%)
(iv) Area irrigated from dug pond 0% 24 ha (0%)
Families who have access to irrigation 17% 21,632 families (16%)
water
Families who have irrigation wells 0% 0 families (0%)
Number of irrigation wells in the province 68 wells 0 wells
Percentage of families per district with
access to irrigation for wet season No Data 2008
cultivation
Project (i) Thpong District - 4.4% (access to irrigation); 18.6%
Area (access to supplemental irrigation); 0
irrigation wells
Table 28. Over-all assessment on the impacts of road project by Sex and Province
In Favor of the Road Project Not in Favor of the Road Project
Province
F (N) M (N) F (N) M (N)
Svay Rieng 233 152 0 2
Prey Veng 30 20 0 0
Kampong Chhnang 152 77 1 0
Kampong Speu 21 12 0 0
Total 436 (62%) 261 (37%) 1 (1%) 2 (3%)
Grand Total 697 (99.6%) 3 (0.4%)
Source: HSES, June 2010.
Annex 3 123
Table 30. Perceptions on the Negative and Level of Impacts of the Project
Negative Impacts Svay Prey Kg Kg Total & Rank Level of Impacts
Rieng Veng Chhnang Speu (All provinces)
N N N N N High Med. Low
Dust during construction 134 100
49 20 62 3 rd 12 22
(4 )
Noise during construction 109 18
50 5 51 3 th 12 79
(5 )
Some houses/lot will be
affected (families will be 349
183 18 130 18 nd 24 80 245
displaced), loss of jobs (2 )
and source of income
Increase number of
74
migrants/ increase of 72 0 2 0 th 52 14 8
(7 )
human trafficking cases
Increase in number of
women/girls who will
82
work in casinos/hotels 82 0 0 0 th 39 12 31
(6 )
and other business
centers
Increase in 12
10 0 2 0 th 1 6 5
HIV/AIDS/STDs cases (9 )
Increase in number of 13
13 0 0 0 th 0 1
child labor cases (8 )
Increase road accidents;
over-speeding vehicles 400
250 15 130 5 st 196 170 34
dangerous to children (1 )
and old people
No negative Impacts
316
what’s important is to 190 35 76 15 rd - - -
(3 )
have improved roads)
Total 790 93 453 44 1,380* 196 383 442
*Multiple responses
Source: HSES, June 2011
124 Annex 3
Table 84. Respondent’s Answer to the Question, Have you experience flood or drought?
Province and District Yes No Total Number and Percentage
(per province)
N % N %
Svey Rieng Province
(i) Kampong Rou 42 59 101 14%
(ii) Svey Teab 40 46 86 12%
(iii) Romeas Haek 34 72 106 15%
(iv) Rumduol 32 42 74 11%
(v) Svey Rieng City 10 10 20 3%
Prey Veng Province:
(i) Kamchay Mear 12 38 50 7%
Kampong Chhnang Province:
(i)Kampong Tralach 56 70 126 18%
(ii) Tuek Phos 21 49 70 10%
(iii) Sameakki Mean
10 24 34 5%
Chey
Kampong Speu Province:
(i) Thpong 8 25 33 5%
Total 265 37.86%) 435 (62.14%) 700 100%
Province and Heard from Others Need to Protect No information Total Number and
District that a big flood is Environment to received, no training Percentage
coming Protect Flood yet on climate per province/district
change or disaster
preparedness
N N N N %
Kampong Speu
Province:
(i) Thpong 0 0 33 33 5%
Total Per
56 (8%) 40 (6%) 604 (86%) 700 100%
Response
Province and Evacuate or Open spillway Always watch Just stay at No Idea / Total Number
District leave house in areas with TV, listen to home (it is Not and Percentage
and go to big rivers / radio and still safer at experience per
higher irrigation information from home) d flood yet
province/district
grounds; don’t structures the commune /
stay close to village chief
rivers
N N N N N N %
Prey Veng
Province:
(i) Kamchay
1 1 5 22 21 50 7%
Mear
Kampong
Chhnang
Province:
(i)Kampong
9 7 5 10 95 126 18%
Tralach
(ii) Tuek Phos 1 1 0 0 68 70 10%
(iii) Sameakki
0 1 0 0 33 34 5%
Mean Chey
Kampong Speu
Province:
(i) Thpong 0 0 0 0 33 33 5%
Total Per
23 (3%) 27 (4%) 38 (4%) 138 (20%) 474 (68%) 700 100%
Response
Table 89. Respondents’ Answers to the Question, “Have you attended any training
on climate change/disaster preparedness?”
Province and District Attended Not Yet Attended Total Number and Percentage
per province/district
N F N %
Svey Rieng Province
(i) Kampong Rou 16 85 101 14%
(ii) Svey Teab 18 68 86 12%
(iii) Romeas Haek 16 90 106 15%
(iv) Rumduol 8 66 74 11%
(v) Svey Rieng City 7 13 20 3%
Prey Veng Province:
(i) Kamchay Mear 10 40 50 7%
Kampong Chhnang
Province:
(i)KampongTralach 5 121 126 18%
(ii) Tuek Phos 14 56 70 10%
(iii) Sameakki Mean Chey 1 33 34 5%
Kampong Speu Province:
(i) Thpong 1 32 33 5%
Total Per Response 96 (14%) 604 (86%) 700 100%
132 Annex 3
Table 90. Early Warning Systems Known by the Respondents (all provinces)
Province and Use Information Making noise Personal No Total Number and
District bells in from the by knocking experience, just Idea / No Percentage
school Commune/ on some observe the Response per
and Village Chiefs ; objects made weather; and province/district
pagoda neighbors and of wood, and watch TV/listen
during other local other to radio; just do
emergen people indigenous whatever is safe
cy materials for the family
during typhoon
N N N N N N %
Svey Rieng
Province
(i) Kampong
2 1 2 72 24 101 14%
Rou
(ii) Svey Teab 2 1 3 44 36 86 12%
(iii) Romeas
4 1 1 54 46 106 15%
Haek
(iv) Rumduol 2 4 3 45 20 74 11%
(v) Svey Rieng
1 2 10 5 20 3%
City 2
Prey Veng
Province:
(i) Kamchay Mear 1 1 1 35 12 50 7%
Kampong
Chhnang
Province:
(i)Kampong
3 14 4 26 79 126 18%
Tralach
(ii) Tuek Phos 0 9 0 2 59 70 10%
(iii) Sameakki
0 3 0 1 30 34 5%
Mean Chey
Kampong Speu
Province:
(i) Thpong 0 0 0 0 33 33 5%
Total Per
16 35 16 289 344 700 100%
Response
Table 93. Place Where Households Bring their Livestock During Floods by Province
Province and Near the Near the Road Have not experienced Pagoda Total Number and
District House (Higher Grounds) any flood yet (just leave Percentage
animals where they will per province/district
be safe)
N N N N N %
Svey Rieng Province
(i) Kampong Rou 8 6 85 2 101 14%
(ii) Svey Teab 11 5 69 1 86 12%
(iii) Romeas Haek 12 4 88 2 106 15%
(iv) Rumduol 13 10 50 1 74 11%
(v) Svey Rieng City 3 5 11 1 20 3%
Prey Veng Province:
(i) Kamchay Mear 6 5 36 3 50 7%
Kampong Chhnang
Province:
(i)Kampong Tralach 4 13 109 0 126 18%
(ii) Tuek Phos 8 2 60 0 70 10%
(iii) Sameakki Mean
6 1 27 0 34 5%
Chey
Kampong Speu
Province:
134 Annex 3
Province and Near the Near the Road Have not experienced Pagoda Total Number and
District House (Higher Grounds) any flood yet (just leave Percentage
animals where they will per province/district
be safe)
N N N N N %
(i) Thpong 1 0 32 0 33 5%
Total Per Response 10
72 (10%) 51 (7%) 567 (82%) 700 100%
(1%)
Table 94. Suggestions on what else is needed by the commune/village to best respond during disasters
Province and Conduct Organize disaster The govt. should Construct Improve Total Number and
District public preparedness team raise funds, have irrigation roads Percentage
awareness / (with medical team, money/resources facilities – it can and per province/district
training on trained volunteers, (relief goods/foods, provide water canals
disaster etc. who will help medicines and for rice fields
prepared the people during other supplies any season
ness with disasters ready always) for
drills distribution to the
people or could be
used anytime
N N N N N N %
Svey Rieng
Province
(i) Kampong
14 22 16 20 29 101 14%
Rou
(ii) Svey Teab 26 13 12 3 32 86 12%
(iii) Romeas
37 23 20 6 20 106 15%
Haek
(iv)Rumduol 15 15 14 4 26 74 11%
(v) Svey Rieng
3 4 3 1 9 20 3%
City
Prey Veng
Province:
(i) Kamchay Mear 14 9 5 4 18 50 7%
Kampong
Chhnang
Province:
(i)Kampong
21 27 28 27 23 126 18%
Tralach
(ii) Tuek Phos 10 17 12 9 22 70 10%
(iii)Sameakki
9 9 7 0 9 34 5%
Mean Chey
Kampong Speu
Province:
(i) Thpong 7 11 3 0 12 33 5%
Total Per 156 (22%) 150 (21%) 120 (17%) 74 (11%) 20(29 700
100%
Response %)
Table 95. Respondents’ Answer to the Question, “Do you run out of Water During Dry Season?” (per
province)
Province and District Yes No Total Number and Percentage (Per
province)
N N N %
Svey Rieng Province
(i) Kampong Rou 29 72 101 14%
(ii) Svey Teab 26 60 86 12%
(iii) Romeas Haek 23 83 106 15%
(iv) Rumduol 24 50 74 11%
(v) Svey Rieng City 3 17 20 3%
Prey Veng Province:
(i) Kamchay Mear 14 36 50 7%
Kampong Chhnang Province:
Annex 3 135
Table 96. Respondents’ answer to the question, “Do you Need the Borrow Pits?” (by province)
Province and District Yes No Total Number and Percentage (Per
province)
N N N %
Svey Rieng Province
(i) Kampong Rou 38 63 101 14%
(ii) Svey Teab 27 59 86 12%
(iii) Romeas Haek 22 84 106 15%
(iv) Rumduol 27 47 74 11%
(v) Svey Rieng City 8 12 20 3%
Prey Veng Province:
(i) Kamchay Mear 12 38 50 7%
Kampong Chhnang Province:
(i)Kampong Tralach 42 84 126 18%
(ii) Tuek Phos 15 55 70 10%
(iii) Sameakki Mean 10 24 34 5%
Chey
Kampong Speu
(i) Thpong 14 19 33 5%
Total: 215 485 700 100%
Table 97. Purpose of borrow pits as perceived by the respondents (per province)
Province and District Source of Source of Serve as No Benefits Total Number and
Water for Irrigation Fish Percentage
Livestock During Dry Ponds per province/district
Season
N N N N N %
Svey Rieng Province
(i) Kampong Rou 15 8 12 66 101 14%
(ii) Svey Teab 11 5 8 62 86 12%
(iii) Romeas Haek 8 8 10 80 106 15%
(iv) Rumduol 12 5 9 48 74 11%
(v) Svey Rieng City 5 3 1 11 20 3%
Prey Veng Province:
(i) Kamchay Mear 21 5 14 10 50 7%
Kampong Chhnang
Province:
(i)Kampong Tralach 5 29 8 84 126 18%
(ii) Tuek Phos 2 9 4 55 70 10%
(iii) Sameakki Mean
2 7 1 24 34 5%
Chey
Kampong Speu Province:
(i) Thpong 0 12 2 19 33 5%
Total Per Response 81 (11%) 91 (13%) 69 (10%) 459(66%) 700 100%
136 Annex 3
Table 98. Respondents’ reasons why they do not like borrow pits (per Province)
Province and District Possible Risky to Land No Idea / Total Number and
Negative Children used for Answer Percentage
Effects on (might get Borrow per province/district
People’s drowned) Pits
Health could
still be
Used as
Farm
Land
N N N N N %
Svey Rieng Province
(i) Kampong Rou 24 10 4 63 101 14%
(ii) Svey Teab 15 8 5 58 84 12%
(iii) Romeas Haek 14 7 2 83 106 15%
(iv) Rumduol 14 9 1 50 74 11%
(v) Svey Rieng City 12 6 1 1 20 3%
Prey Veng Province:
(i) Kamchay Mear 32 8 3 7 50 7%
Kampong Chhnang
Province:
(i)Kampong Tralach 26 8 28 64 126 18%
(ii) Tuek Phos 4 1 8 57 70 10%
(iii) Sameakki Mean
1 1 2 30 34 5%
Chey
Kampong Speu Province:
(i) Thpong 8 1 17 7 33 5%
Total Per Response 150 (21%) 59 (9%) 71 (10%) 420 (60%) 700 100%
Table 99. Respondents’ Answer to the Question, “Do you Need More Water Capture?”
(per Sex and Province/District)
Yes No No Answer/No Idea Total (both sexes)
Province
F (N) M (N) F (N) M (N) F (N) M (N) N %
Svey Rieng 44 51 26 34 143 89 387 55%
(i) Kampong Rou 10 10 8 6 50 17 101 14%
(ii) Svey Teab 10 11 5 11 36 13 86 12%
(iii) Romeas Haek 13 15 4 7 33 34 106 15%
(iv) Rumdoul 9 10 5 6 22 22 74 11%
(v) Svey Rieng City 2 5 4 4 2 3 20 3%
Prey Veng 8 1 15 17 7 2 50 7%
(i) Kamchay Mear
Kampong Chhnang 18 24 44 21 91 32 230 33%
(i) Kampong Tralach 12 17 19 10 54 14 126 18%
(ii) Tuek Phos 5 7 17 7 26 8 70 10%
(iii) Sameakki Mean Chey 1 0 8 4 11 10 34 5%
Kampong Speu 0 1 16 7 5 4 33 5%
(i) Thpong
Table 101. Respondents’ Answer to the Question, “Do you Need More Planting to Reduce
Damage to Erosion?” (all provinces)
Respondents’ Answer N %
Yes 593 85%
No 56 8%
No idea 51 7%
Total 700 100%
Table 102. Respondents’ Perceptions on the Usage/Purpose of Planting Trees (all provinces)
Usage/Purpose of Planting Trees N Rank
th
Livestock Fodder 37 5 rank
nd
Source of food (fruits) 408 2 rank
th
Fuel wood/firewood and fiber 73 4 rank
st
Shade from the un 534 1 rank
rd
Stabilize soil 84 3 rank
Note: * Multiple Responses
Table 103. Respondents’ Perception on Who are Usually Involved in Planting Trees in the Communes
Province and District Commune / Father (Men) Mothers Youth (both
Village leaders (Women) Sexes)
N N N N
Svey Rieng Province
(i) Kampong Rou 11 50 13 27
(ii) Svey Teab 7 40 20 19
(iii) Romeas Haek 9 33 33 31
(iv) Rumduol 6 41 11 16
(v) Svey Rieng City 5 27 18 20
Prey Veng Province:
(i) Kamchay Mear 5 27 15 15
Kampong Chhnang Province:
(i)Kampong Tralach 24 56 50 42
(ii) Tuek Phos 27 45 29 20
(iii) Sameakki Mean 6 24 18 1
138 Annex 3
1. Under the Climate Change Mitigation Measures component of TA 7665 Project, a series
of five water capture projects have been identified in Kampong Chhnang Province. Each of
these projects must be described in the IEE and an essential component of this evaluation is
Public Consultation. Public Consultation Meetings were conducted on 7-8 September 2011 in
Tuek Phos District, Kampong Chhnang Province. The public consultations were organized with
the assistance of the Commune Chiefs in each locality. Potentially Affected Persons from the
villages were invited verbally, relevant provincial government officers invited in writing by
MPWT, and suitable locations organized in pagodas. The venues were :
(i) Roleang Ke Pagoda, Chaong Maong Commune, Tuek Phos District, Kampong
Chhnang Province
(ii) Keo Buthearam Pagoda, Akphivodth Commune, Tuek Phos District, Kampong
Chhnang Province
(iii) Vihear Beth Meas Pagoda, Kbal Tuek Commune, Tuek Phos District, Kampong
Chhnang Province
(iv) There were 3 venues for 4 meetings covering 5 communes, all in Tuek Phos
District, Kampong Chhnang Province. The 4 meetings took 2 days in total.
2. In order to demonstrate Gender Equity in the meetings and ensure a correct record of
comments from villagers the services of a female rapporteur were retained. A “break out group”
to hold discussions among females only was offered but proved not necessary.
3. It was estimated that 150 people might attend the 4 meetings over 2 days and
refreshments were offered to attendees. No other incentives were offered to any persons. The
budget was US$550. In the event 109 villagers attended plus provincial government staff and
consultants.
4. No disputes or conflicts were raised. Competing needs were described but in general all
the villagers were very supportive of the plan to provide more irrigation water for generating two
rice crops a year instead of one. Some pertinent points were :
5. A dam across the river was needed but it would raise the water level upstream where
people currently wade across the river because the water level is low. Could a crossing be
provided on top of the dam ?
6. One lady was concerned that she was so poor she could not afford the money for a
connection to a piped water supply and asked if she could offer her labor in exchange for a
connection?
7. The use of the ex-railway water tank to provide water was enthusiastically supported.
Local residents asked for drinking water not general garden irrigation water. They were willing to
pay for the water if it was cheaper than commercially available bottled water. They were
concerned over who would manage the water supply, would it be taken over by private
operators, and would the raise the price of the water.
A villager offered use of his land for free to show his support for the projects
8. Government officers from MOE, MRD and MOWRAM also concurred with the proposals
and endorsed inter ministry cooperation.
140 Annex 4
All in all, I am to show my sincere thank for your actively participation. After the
examination, if it responds to the development of people, ADB will start doing
it.
The topic raised on dams are:
Review the pass: Boeung Khset
Svay Chek dam: since 1989, eight open streams were demolished by the
thieves and its location was full of sand caused soil eroded into the marsh.
Mr. Dork Bunthun, Direcotr of Review the pass: He has been working and development of irrigation system
PDWRAM, Kampong Chhnang for Akphivodth commune, Teuk Phos district since 2006. This project was
Province spend $USD8 million (including buy the land and pay for affected area,
construct).
Svay Chek dam: nearby Svay Chek dam, there was shallow and need to drain
it deeper up, which will be used for irrigating 1800 ha rice field. It was built in
1980 in which supported by AFFC. Up to now, there had been guarded by Mr
Chan Sim, for more than 24 years. Additionally, he has added that this
irrigation system study has been conducted for years including examining the
geographical area and our budget to see how much water it could store. At the
end he concluded that Provincial Department of Water Resource and
Meteorology will try to develop the irrigation system for the villagers and
Annex 4 141
Svay Chek village Perception: All villagers who are living within project areas very happy and
welcome to have a big bridge in Svay Chek village.
Mr. Mao Key, village chief, The government always develops new irrigation system; the quality of water
Trapaing Chum village, gate must be good and reliable unlike the previous one has been damage
Chaong Maong commune some part already.
Mr. Som Kim, Village Very happy and welcome to have Svay Chek dam and rehabilitation the canal
development, Trapaing Raing that will make his life even better.
village
Mr. Bun Phan, Villager, Need to have bridge with box culvert because it is too weak to support heavy
Ralaing Ker village weight trucks etc., and the old one has been damaged
Mrs. Phoeuk Vy, Villager, Srae Want to have the automatic water gate in order easily to control the in-let and
Prich, Akphivodth commune out-let of water for irrigating into the rice field. It should be better to clearly
study the canal location before construct.
Mrs. Phong Yeit, Villager, Want to have canal and small dike to irrigate water into the rice field.
Trapaing Chum village,
Chaong Maong commune
Mr. Lay Phal, village chief, Pea On behalf of the villager, he very happy and welcome to have these projects
Raing, Chaong Maong because his villagers will be gotten benefit from the dam and there is no
commune problem of construct.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
-i-
Resettlement Plan
November 2011
Prepared by Ministry of Public Works and Transportfor the Asian Development Bank.
ABBREVIATIONS
NOTE
Cut-off date – This refers to the date prior to which the occupation or use of the project area
makes residents/users of the same eligible to be categorised as affectedpeople.
Persons not covered in the census are not eligible for compensation and other
entitlements, unless they can show proof that (i) they have been inadvertently
missed out during the census and the inventory of losses (IOL); or (ii) they have
lawfully acquired the affected assets following completion of the census and the
IOL and prior to the conduct of the detailed measurement survey (DMS).
Affected – In the context of involuntary resettlement, affectedpeople are those who are
Household/ physically displaced (relocation, loss of residential land, or loss of shelter)
AffectedPeople and/or economically affected (loss of land, assets, access to assets, income
sources, or means of livelihood) as a result of (i) involuntary expropriation of
land, or (ii) involuntary restrictions on land use or on access to legally
designated parks and protected areas.
In the case of affected household, it includes all members residing under one
roof and operating as a single economic unit, who are adversely affected by a
project or any of its components.
Detailed – This activity involves the finalization and/or validation of the results of the IOL,
Measurement severity of impacts, and list of affected people earlier done during resettlement
Survey plan preparation. The final cost of resettlement can be determined following
completion of the DMS.
Entitlement – Refers to a range of measures comprising compensation, income restoration
support, transfer assistance, income substitution, relocation support, etc. which
are due to the affected people, depending on the type and severity of their
losses, to restore their economic and social base.
Income – This is the re-establishment of sources of income and livelihood of the affected
restoration households.
Inventory of – This is the process where all fixed assets (i.e. lands used for residence,
Losses commerce, agriculture, including ponds; dwelling units; stalls and shops;
secondary structures, such as fences, tombs, wells; trees with commercial
value; etc.) and sources of income and livelihood inside the Project right-of-way
are identified, measured, their owners identified, their exact location pinpointed,
and their replacement costs calculated. Additionally, the severity of impact to the
affected assets and the severity of impact to the livelihood and productive
capacity of affected people will be determined.
Land acquisition – Refers to the process whereby an individual, household, firm or private
institution is compelled by a public agency to alienate all or part of the land it
owns or possesses to the ownership and possession of that agency for public
purposes in return for compensation at replacement costs.
Relocation – This is the physical relocation of a displaced people from her/his pre-project
place of residence and/or business.
Replacement Means the amount in cash or in kind needed to replace an asset in its existing
Cost condition, without deduction of transaction costs or for any material salvaged, at
prevailing market value, or its nearest equivalent, at the time of compensation
payment. The replacement rates of affected assets as determined during the
conduct of the replacement cost study (RCS) will be updated to reflect prevailing
market values at the time of payment of compensation.
Replacement – This refers to the process involved in determining replacement costs of affected
Cost Study assets based on empirical data.
Resettlement - This is a time-bound action plan with budget, setting out the resettlement
Plan objectives and strategies, entitlements, activities and responsibilities,
resettlement monitoring, and resettlement evaluation.
Severely – This refers to affected households who will (i) lose 10% or more of their total
affected productive land and/or assets, (ii) have to relocate; and/or (iii) lose 10% or more
households of their total income sources due to the Project.
Vulnerable – These are distinct groups of people who might suffer disproportionately or face
groups the risk of being further marginalized by the effects of resettlement and
specifically include: (i) households headed by women with dependents, (ii)
disabled household heads, (iii) households falling under the generally accepted
indicator for poverty, (iv) children and the elderly households who are landless
and with no other means of support, and (v) landless households,.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
List of Tables
Table I.1 Indicative Resettlement Schedule 3
Table II.1 Districts and Communes Traversed by 314D 4
Table II.2 Districts and Communes Traversed by NR13 5
Table III.1 Occupied Right-of-Way Land According to Use (m2) 10
Table III.2 Land Losses (in m²) According to Gender of AH Heads 11
Table III.3. Location of Concentrated Commercial Areas in 314D 12
Table III.4. Location of Concentrated Commercial Areas in NR13 13
Table III.5 Number of Affected Main Structures According to Use 13
Table III.6 Affected Households with Affected House by Severity of Loss 14
Table III.7 Affected Households Losing House-Store by Severity 14
Table III.8 Affected Households with Affected Shops by Severity of Loss 15
Table III.9 Floor Area of Affected Houses by Construction Grade 314D 15
Table III.10 Floor Area of Affected Houses by Construction Grade NR13 16
Table III.11 Floor Area of House-stores by Construction Grade 314D 16
Table III.12 Floor Area of House-stores by Construction Grade NR13 16
Table III.13 Floor Area of Shops by Construction Grade 314D 17
Table III.14 Floor Area of Shops by Construction Grade NR13 17
Table III.15 Quantities of Affected Extended Eaves 18
Table III.16 Quantities of Fence 18
Table III.17 Assorted Secondary Structures 19
Table III.18 Affected Wells and Waiting Sheds NR13 19
Table III.19 Affected Electric and Communication Posts 20
Table III.20 Quantities of Affected Perennials 314D 20
Table III.21 Quantities of Affected Timber Trees 314D 21
Table III.22 Quantities of Affected Fruit and Timber Trees CBF 21
Table III.23 Quantities of Affected Perennials NR13 21
Table III.24 Quantities of Affected Timber Trees NR13 22
vii
Table III.25 Range of Net Monthly Income of Partially Affected Shops 314D 22
Table III.26 Range of Net Monthly Income of Entirely Affected Shops PR 314D 23
Table III.27 Range of Net Monthly Income of Partially Affected Shops NR13 23
Table III.28 Range of Net Monthly Income of Entirely Affected Shops NR13 24
Table IV.1 Affected Assets of Sample AHs 314D 25
Table IV.2 Affected Assets of Sample AHs NR13 26
Table IV.3 Years in Possession of Affected Main Structures 26
Table IV.4 Civil Status of Head of Sample AHs 314D 27
Table IV.5 Civil Status of Head of Sample AHs NR13 27
Table IV.6 Head of Sample AHs by Physical Condition and Age 314D 28
Table IV.7 Head of Sample AHs by Physical Condition and Age NR13 29
Table IV.8 Educational Attainment of Head of Sample AHs 314D 29
Table IV.9 Educational Attainment of Head of Sample AHs NR13 30
Table IV.10 Number of Persons in the Sample AHs 314D 31
Table IV.11 Number of Persons in the Sample AHs NR13 31
Table IV.12 Primary Sources of Income of Sample AH Heads 314D 31
Table IV.13 Combined Monthly Income of Sample AHs 314D 32
Table IV.14 Monthly Expenses of Sample AHs 314D 33
Table IV.15 Primary Sources of Income of Sample AHs NR13 33
Table IV.16 Combined Monthly Income of Sample AHs IR13 34
Table IV.17 Monthly Expenses of Sample AHs IR13 34
Table IV.18 Main Source of Potable Water of the AHs 314D 35
Table IV.19 Main Source of Water for Washing of the AHs 314D 35
Table IV.20 Toilet Facilities Used by the AHs 314D 36
Table IV.21 Bathing Facilities Used by the AHs 314D 36
Table IV.22 Garbage Disposal Used by the AHs 314D 36
Table IV.23 Main Source of Power for Lighting 314D 36
Table IV.24 Main Source of Fuel for Cooking 314D 37
Table IV.25 Household Appliances 314D 37
Table IV.26 Ownership of Transportation 314D 37
Table IV.27 Main Source of Potable Water of the AHs NR13 38
Table IV.28 Main Source of Water for Washing of the AHs NR13 38
Table IV.29 Toilet Facilities Used by the AHs NR13 38
Table IV.30 Bathing Facilities Used by the AHs NR13 39
Table IV.31 Garbage Disposal Used by the AHs NR13 39
Table IV.32 Main Source of Power for Lighting NR13 39
Table IV.33 Main Source of Fuel for Cooking NR13 40
Table IV.34 Household Appliances NR13 40
Table IV.35 Ownership of Transportation NR13 40
Table V.1 Roles and Responsibilities of Key Stakeholders in the RP 41
Table G-V.2 Dates of Pre-IOL Consultations 44
Table V.3 Dates of Post-IOL Consultations 44
Table VII.1 Resettlement Policy and Its Application in Cambodia 52
Table VIII.1 Entitlement Matrix 55
Table X.1 Loss of Land Use within Road Right of Way 61
Table X.2 Acquired Private Land at CBF 61
Table X.3 Income Loss Allowance 62
Table XI.1 Summary of Resettlement Costs (314D, CBF, NR13) 62
Table XIII.1 Indicative Schedule of Resettlement Activities 67
ix
I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
A. Introduction
1. The Government of Cambodia, through the Ministry of Public Works and Transport
(MPWT), has requested the Asian Development Bank (ADB) for a project preparatory technical
assistance (TA) to prepare the Provincial Roads Improvement Project. The project aims to
rehabilitate an aggregate of approximately 176 km of provincial road 314D, national road (NR) 13,
150B, NR53, and 151B, located in Prey Veng, Svay Rieng, Kampong Chhnang, and Kampong
Speu provinces, to paved condition to provide a safer, cost-effective provincial road network with
all-year access to markets and other social services for provincial centers of southeastern and
mid-western Cambodia. The existing cross border facility (CBF) at Prey Var-Mocva will be
expanded and developed to facilitate efficient cross border transport and trade between
Cambodia and Vietnam. This resettlement plan is for 314D, the CBF, and NR13. (See Figure 1
for the project location map).
2. The major impacts caused by the project in the rehabilitation of 314D and NR13 include
demolition of structures used for residence and business, and acquisition of occupied land in the
road right-of-way (ROW). According to the inventory of losses (IOL) conducted in 20 May 2011 –
2 June 2011, around 697 households (215 in 314D and 482 in NR13) in 19 communes (7 in
314D and 12 in NR13) are affected by the loss of fixed assets and sources of incomes or
livelihoods.1Forty-fivehouseholds in 314D and 108 households in NR13 are affected by impacts
on their homes and house-and-shops, of which 20 households in 314D and 26 households in
NR13 will lose entirely their homes and house-and-shops and will need to reconstruct behind the
construction corridor. Moreover, 62 households in 314D and 114 households in NR13 are
affected by impacts on their independent shops (i.e., detached from other buildings), of which 45
households in 314D and 57 households will have to relocate their business behind the
construction corridor. In 314D, some 27,936 square meter (m2) of land in the ROW are used or
occupied by private households (12,004 m2 for agriculture and 15,932 m2 for residence and
business), while in NR13, around 47,398.3 m2 of land in the ROW are used or occupied by
private households (44,681 m2 for agriculture and 2,717 m2 for residence and business). Other
fixed structures affected include fences, concrete pavements, extended eaves, pipe culverts and
sign boards. In addition, 96 electric and telecommunication posts (75 in 314D and 21 in NR13)
need to be relocated behind the COI. Around 12,140 perennials and timber trees (2,234 in 314D
and 9,906 in NR13) need to be removed from the COI.
3. In the expansion of the CBF at Prey Var, an aggregate of 24,945.12 m2 of private land will
be acquired, in addition to twohouses and onestore with a combined floor area of 90 m2.
Fifteenperennial and 583 timber trees owned by these private individuals will likewise be
acquired. Twoabsentees (i.e., living abroad or in Phnom Penh) and onelanded local farmer own
the affected plots of land. Twoother households have built structures on the land of twoof the
landowners to oversee the properties. The existing CBF facilities are standing on a 10,982 m 2
government land.
1
This number excludes the 14 houses and shops in 314D and the 44 houses and shops in NR13 whose owners
could not be determined at the time of the IOL because said structures were unattended or locked.
2
4. In order to avoid or minimize displacement of people from assets and livelihoods, the
existing road alignment will be followed and construction works will be confined within a COI of
10 meters (m) measured either way from the road centerline. In addition, as part of the Project’s
resettlement strategy, affected peoplewill be provided sufficient time to rebuild their homes and
shops prior to the commencement of civil works and that they are able to continue with their
present livelihood activities even during Project implementation. Also, all standing annual crops,
including privately-owned trees, will be allowed to be harvested before the start of civil works in a
particular section of the Project road. The MPWT, through its Project Management Unit (PMU) 3
and the Inter-ministerial Resettlement Committee (IRC), through the Resettlement Department at
the Ministry of Economy and Finance (RD-MEF), will ensure that this resettlement strategy is
carried through diligently.
5. This resettlement planhas been prepared to address land acquisition and resettlement in
the rehabilitation of 314D and NR13, consistent with ADB’s Safeguard Policy Statement (June
2009) and relevant laws and regulations of the Royal Government of Cambodia, notably the
1993 Constitution, the 2001 Land Law, 2010 Expropriation Law, and Prakas (Government Order)
No. 6, dated 27 September 1999. The resettlement plan includes the resettlement policy and
specific time-bound and budgeted measures for mitigating the adverse social impacts of the
Project, and for rehabilitating all physically and economically displaced persons.
6. The basic compensation and rehabilitation principles adopted in this resettlement plan
are: (i) land acquisition is minimized if avoidance is not possible; (ii) compensation and cash and
no-cash assistance will be provided to help ensure that affected persons are able to maintain, if
not improve, their pre-Project living standards; (iii) affected persons are fully informed and
consulted on compensation and relocation options; (iv) existing socio-cultural institutions of
affected persons are supported and used; (v) the project resettlement policy will equally apply to
women and men; (vi) lack of formal title will not be a bar to compensation and rehabilitation; (vii)
particular attention will be extended to vulnerable groups, such as households headed by women
and the elderly with no other social support; (viii) resettlement is planned and implemented as an
integral part of the project and that the budget for resettlement is part of Project costs; and (ix)
affected persons are not displaced from assets until they are fully compensated for the same.
7. Key information on the draft resettlement plan has been disclosed to the affected persons
through the holding in June 2011 of public meetings to: (i) present the results of the IOL; (ii)
discuss the salient points of the Project resettlement policy in general term; and (iii) find out from
the affected persons their suggestions and preferences regarding compensation, allowances
and assistance, relocation of structures, grievance redress and participation. A project
information leaflet in Khmer will be distributed to the affected persons in the first half of
September 2011. Likewise, during the first half of September 2011, the draft resettlement plan
will be posted in provincial, district, and commune offices and on the ADB website. Following
concurrence by ADB of the resettlement plan, the summary of the agreed resettlement plan will
again be disclosed to the affected peoplewith its posting at local government offices, while the full
text of the approved resettlement plan will be uploaded on the ADB website (www.adb.org).
Social monitoring reports will be made available to the affected peopleand will be submitted to
ADB for web posting.
2
3
8. In case of grievances, the affected persons will first lodge their complaint with the
commune office. If within 15 days settlement could not be reached, the grievance would be
elevated to the district office. If the same could still not be settled at the district level, the
complaint would be lodged at the provincial office. A court of law is the final arbiter of complaints
that are not settled at the local government levels.
G. Implementation Arrangements
10. The MPWT, through PMU3 and the Social and Environmental Office (SEO), and the
Inter-ministerial Resettlement Committee (IRC), through the Resettlement Department of the
Ministry of Economy and Finance (RD-MEF), are overall responsible for preparing, updating,
implementing and financing the resettlement plan. At the local government level, the MPWT and
IRC are assisted by Resettlement Subcommittee in the provinces and districts through the
Resettlement Sub-committee Working Groups (RSWG).
H. Monitoring
11. The SEO is the Project’s internal monitor, while an external monitoring organization will
be hired by IRC to do external monitoring and evaluation (M&E). During resettlement plan
implementation, which is reckoned to begin at the time of the detailed measurement survey
(DMS), quarterly progress report of internal monitoring and semi-annual external M&E report will
be submitted to ADB. Within one year after the completion of resettlement plan implementation, a
resettlement completion report will be submitted to ADB that includes lessons learned to improve
resettlement work in future projects.
12. The total costs of resettlement for provincial roads 314D and NR 13 and construction of
the CBF is $1,380,966.58. Below is an indicated schedule of resettlement plan preparation and
implementation.
A. Project Background
13. In response to the Government of Cambodia’s request for TA to prepare the Provincial
Roads Improvement Project, the ADB mobilized a group of international and national consultants
in March 2011. The TA was for a period of 14 months with most of the outputs of the consultants
being completed in the first 6 months. Among others, the TA consultants were tasked to do the
following:
a. Prepare the engineering design for the upgrading of NR13 and 314D. The overall
length of these roads is 91 kilometer (km).
b. Prepare the engineering design for the upgrading of 150B, NR53 and 151B. The
overall length of these roads is approximately 85 km.
c. Prepare the engineering design for a CBF at Prey Var-Mocva that will provide
efficient cross border transport and trade between Cambodia and Vietnam.
B. Description of 314D, CBF, and NR13
14. Provincial Road 314D is gravel road and it starts from NR1 in Prasout Village, Kandieng
Reay commune, Svay Teab in Svay Rieng Province. It runs for 26.6 km to the south and ends at
the Cambodia-Vietnam Border in Prey Var village, Thmei commune, Kampong Rou district. The
ROW of 314D is 40 m, measured 20 m each way from the road centerline.2 With the exception
of several locations where the road crosses a bustling business center (such as Rou village in
Kampong Rou), the existing ROW is basically clear of structures, interspersed occasionally by
huts used for selling goods. Shops within 8 m either way from the centerline of the road are found
in Ro Village. Table below lists the districts and communes traversed by 314D.
Table II.1 Districts and Communes Traversed by 314D
Province District Km Point Communes Village
Svay Teab Kandieng Reay Prasout Ti Muoy
Prasout Ti Pi
Prasout Angk Ta Mouk
Prey Rumduol
Pou Vong
Kampong Rou Preah Ponlea Pring Chrum
Trapeang Run
Tradaet
Prey Thum Prey Sakum
Nhor Trapeang Chhlonh
Rou
Svay Anat
Trapeang Trav
Ksetr Ruessei Am
Thmei Ou
Prey Var
km = kilometer.
15. The CBF at Prey Var will be expanded and developed under the proposed project. The
present CBF is located on a 10.9 hectare (ha) land and an additional 2.49 ha of land adjacent to
2
Government decree Prakas 6, “Measures to Crack Down on Anarchic Land Grabbing and Encroachment” (dated 27
September 1999), set the ROW for 2-digit national roads at 25 m from the road centerline, and for provincial roads
at20 m from the road centerline.
4
5
the present facilities will be acquired. The CBF is located on the right hand side of 314D towards
the Vietnam border.
16. NR13 starts from NR1 at Thmey village, Sangkhor commune, Svay Rieng town in Svay
Rieng province. It runs northward for about 65 km before joining NR8 in Veal Smach village,
Krabau commune, Kamchay Mear district in the province of Prey Neng. For the first 43 km, the
road, with a carriageway of typically 6 m, is paved with double surface treatment (DBST). The
remaining 22 km of the road is earth and gravel. There is visibly more traffic on NR13 than on
314D. However, there are more densely populated areas traversed where houses and shops are
built close to the carriageway, such as in Chak village (Kompong Chak commune), Kampong
Trach village (Kampong Trach commune), and Samruong village (Angk Prasrae commune). Also,
there are more perimeter fences put up by the residents close to the carriageway.
Table II.2 Districts and Communes Traversed by NR13
Province District Communes Km Point Village
Svay Rieng Sangkhor Thmey
Bak Ronorse
Thlork
Preah Tonle
Po Phlear
Akna Kot
Rom Duol Kampong Chak Chak
Prey Keav
Sangkae Kouk Srama
Ta Naeng
Poun
Ta Chou
Chrung Popel Trapeang Kruos
Trapeang Kraet
Preah Angk Kaev
Krouch
Kampong Ampil Trasak
Trapeang Damrei
Romeas Haek Angk Prasrae Samraong
Trapeang Rumdenh
Thnal Peam
Andoung Pou Bos Kokir
Trapeang Tbal
Trapeang Choar
Trapeang Banteay
Areaks Svay
Kampong Trach Chong Ou
Ta Trav
Kampong Trach
Amkpil Tuek Vil
Trapeang Prei
Ta Mau
Trapeang Popel
Ampil
Traok
Tras Muni Proeksa
Voat
Andoung Trabaek Trapeang Smach
Andoung Trabaek
Kamchay Krabau Tboung Voat
6
17. NR13 and 314D will be paved with single bituminous treatment (SBST) and will have a
standard carriageway of 7 m (i.e. 3.5 m either way from the centerline) and a paved shoulder of 1
m on each side of the carriageway. Existing bridges will be replaced and will have the same width
as the road. Culverts will be extended or replaced as necessary. Ditches through major
commune centers will be lined and covered, and the road will be raised on embankments in
flood-prone areas.
18. The existing CBF facilities at Prey Var are very basic. Land to the east of the road is being
developed by private owners and land to the east has government buildings offering greater
scope for the CBF location. The design of the improvement of the CBF at Prey Var will be
patterned, albeit smaller, after that of the Bavet-Moc Bai CBF located at the end of NR1
bordering Vietnam.
19. The following measures have been adopted in order to minimize adverse social impacts:
a. There will be no re-alignment of any segment of the road sections.
b. A corridor of only 10 m from either side of the road centerline will be cleared of
obstructions. 314D has a ROW of 40 m (i.e., 20 m from either side of the road
centerline) while NR13 has a ROW of 50 m (i.e., 25 m from either side of the road
centerline).
20. The construction of concrete and covered side drains in major commune centers will also
reduce the COI in said locations. The carriageway and paved shoulder will only be 4.5 m from
the centerline and additional 2 m would be needed for the construction of a side drain on each
side of the road. The covered side drain can double as sidewalk. Following completion of
detailed engineering design, the data on affected assets and people will be updated to reflect any
reduction in the COI in commune centers.
21. Owners of entirely affected shops will be allowed to construct replacement structures
before demolishing the existing ones in order to minimize, if not avoid, income loss arising from
the disruption of business operation. Prior to and after the conduct of the IOL, local officials and
residents have been advised to refrain from building new fixed structures along the COI.
6
7
CBF
8
22. The potential impacts of the Project have been determined with the conduct of the IOL
where all fixed assets (i.e., lands used for residence, commerce, agriculture, including ponds;
dwelling units; stalls and shops; miscellaneous structures, such as fences, tombs, wells; trees
with commercial value; etc.) located inside the COI were identified, tagged, measured, their
owners identified, their exact location pinpointed, and their replacement values calculated.
Likewise, the severity of impact on the affected assets and the severity of impact to the livelihood
and productive capacity of persons affected by such losses were determined. Photographs of the
affected assets with a placard indicating their location and owners had been taken. Also,
information on the households of the affected persons, such as sources of livelihood, income
level, and ownership of productive assets were gathered. The IOL and census of affected
peoplein 314D were conducted 20–25 May 2011 and in NR13 on 26 May to 2 June 2011. The
IOL and census affected peoplein the proposed expanded CBF were conducted on 5–7 August
2011 based on preliminary information of the boundaries of the expanded area of the CBF.
23. The basic tool used in the IOL and census of affected peoplewas a survey questionnaire.
Detailed socioeconomic information on the household of affected peoplewhose main structures
(i.e., houses and shops but excluding government buildings) stand to be partially or entirely
affected was obtained with the use of a survey questionnaire written in Khmer. The questionnaire
is divided into 3 sections. The first section seeks basic socioeconomic information on the
displacd people, while the second section deals on the affected assets and livelihoods. The third
section seeks information on other landholdings of the affected people’s households, including
relocation options for those who lose entire houses and shops. (See Appendix 1 for a copy of the
IOL questionnaire).
24. The survey of affected land in 314D and NR13 was limited to measuring the areas of land
within the COI on each side of the roadway that were visibly occupied, and determining their use
(i.e., for agriculture, residence, commerce, both for residence and commerce). With the
exception of ROW land with houses and shops that were attended to when the survey team
conducted the IOL and census of displacd people, it was impossible for the team to determine
the identities of the occupants or users of land in the COI. It was likewise impossible for the
survey team to determine the boundaries, and therefore the areas, of cultivated or built-on plots
of ROW land in open swathes of land adjacent to the roadway because said occupied lands are
not demarcated and there are no cadastral plans available. Also, even for plots of ROW land that
had structures on them, the names and gender of the users or occupants of said plots of ROW
land could not be determined if said houses and shops were locked or unattended to during the
survey.
25. In view thereof, the survey team could only estimate the area of cultivated land (i.e.,
farmland) and woodlands (i.e., degraded public forest with naturally growing tree species) within
the COI. Relatedly, the survey team could only estimate the area of ROW land used for
residence and commerce that had structures on them (i.e., footprint of the structures) and those
that are fenced in. These estimates will be validated and corrected as necessary during the
updating of the resettlement plan, with the assistance of commune officials who will also sit as
members of the Provincial RSWG, the main resettlement body that is tasked to carry out the
8
9
DMS.
26. Plots of land to be acquired in the expansion and development of the CBF are private.
The identities of the owners of these plots of land, including residents who serve as caretakers of
the properties, have been determined. Fixed assets found on the properties have also been
surveyed.
28. The survey team met with district and commune officials, including the local population,
prior to the commencement of the IOL and census of affected people. Among others, the
purpose of said public meetings was to discuss the need for the IOL and socioeconomic survey
(SES) and to explain the Project policy on cut-off date for eligibility to resettlement entitlements.
For the purpose of the preparation of the resettlement plan, local official and residents were
informed that the cut-off date coincides with the announcement about the Project and the
completion of the IOL and census of the affected peoplein the districts, which was 25 May 2011
for 314D and 2 June 2011 for NR13. The list of affected peoplewill be updated and/or validated
during the DMS following approval by project authorities of the project feasibility study. The IRC,
the government body that is tasked to spearhead the conduct of the DMS and the
implementation of the resettlement plan, will confirm the final date of the cut-off-date.
29. In parallel with the conduct of the IOL and census of AHs, an RCS was carried out by a
professional appraiser. The objective of the RCS was to establish compensation rates for land,
structures, trees and crops that are sufficient for AHs to acquire or purchase a replacement for
assets lost to the Project without deductions for taxes, and/or costs of transaction. The IOL
survey team members and the RCS specialist spent some time visiting the project sites and
agreed on the classifications to use in categorizing the various affected structures.
1. Land
30. A total of [number] ha of land will be acquired for the Project in 314D, NR13 and for the
CBF. All affected lands in 314D and NR13 are within the ROW and as such are State public
land. However, affected plots of land in the expanded CBF are private.
31. 314D. A total of 27,936.2 m² of ROW land in 314D that are occupied or used by local
residents will be cleared for the Project. Of these, 51.19% (14,300 m²) are used for residence,
while 42.97% (12,004 m²) are cultivated, and 5.84% (1,632.2 m²) are used for commercial
activities. All affected plots of land in 314D are inside the ROW and not covered with title or with
legally recognized proof of ownership.
10
32. NR13. Some 47,398.3m² of ROW land in NR13 will be cleared for the Project. Of this,
94.27% (44,681.3m²) is cultivated, while 3.57% (1,690.1 m²) is used for residence, and 2.17%
(1,026.9 m²) is used for commercial activities. There is no private land (i.e., covered by title or
with legally recognized proof of ownership) affected in the rehabilitation of NR13.
33. CBF. In connection with the expansion and development of the CBF at Prey Var, a total of
24,945.72m² of private plots of land belonging to 3 individuals will be acquired. Of the private
land to be acquired, 48.65% (12,135.12 m2) is rain-fed farmland belonging to a landed farming
household. Grazing land makes up 42.33% (10,560 m2) of the total private land to be acquired,
and this belongs to a Cambodian national presently living abroad. The rest of the private land to
be acquired (2,250.6 m2) is residential land belonging to the owner of an adjacent property that is
being developed into a hotel. Government land in the present CBF area is 10,982m².
34. In settlement areas and business centers, the identities of occupants of affected ROW
lands had been determined. However, occupants or users of swathes of cultivated ROW land
between settlement areas could not be determined, including plots of land in settlement areas
with no houses or shops or when said houses or shops were unattended to during the IOL and
census of AHs. Their identities will be determined with the active involvement of local cadastral
officials during the DMS. Table below gives a breakdown of the affected ROW land in 314D and
NR13 according to the gender of the head of the affected households (AHs).
10
11
2. Main Structures
35. 314D: A total of 107 main structures 3 in 314D are adversely affected by the road
improvement. Of this number, 57.94% (62 structures) are independent shops; while 33.64% (36
structures) are houses, and 8.41% (9 structures) are house-and-shops (see Table C-8).
36. Houses. Of the 36 affected houses in 314D, 6 were locked and unattended at the time of
the survey. Therefore, the identities of the owners of these structures could not be obtained. All of
these 6 unattended houses are entirely affected. Of the remaining 30 affected houses in 314D,
21 belong to male-headed households, of which 9 are entirely affected. Moreover, 4 of the
affected houses belonging to male-headed households are being rented out for about $25 per
month per house. There are 9 affected houses owned by women-headed households, of which 3
are entirely affected. (see Table III.6).
37. The 18 partially affected houses in 314D have an aggregate floor area of 397.8 m 2. Five
partially affected houses of construction grade of 2J (i.e., single floor with plastered brick walls,
concrete columns, and concrete floor) account for 48.14% (or 191.5 m2) of the floor area of
partially affected houses. The 18 entirely affected houses in 314D (comprising 9 of male-headed
households, 3 of women-headed households and 6 of unidentied owners) have an aggregate
floor area of 594.0 m2. Of this area, houses of 2J construction grade account for 29.46% (or 175
m2), followed by houses of 2C construction grade (i.e., single floor with earthen wall combined
with temporary material, such as metal sheet, wood, thatch, or plastic; wooden posts; and
earthen floor) that account for 26.94% (or 160 m2) of the aggregate floor area of entirely affected
houses (see Table III.9).
39. The 7 partially affected house-and-stores in 314D have an aggregate floor area of 103.5
m , while the 2 entirely affected house-and-stores have an aggregate floor area of 26.0 m2 only.
2
All of the affected house-and-stores in 314D are of construction grades 2 (see Table C-14).
40. Independent shops. Of the 62 affected shops in 314D, 8 were locked and unattended at
the time of the survey. 7 of these unattended shops are entirely affected. Of the remaining 54
affected shops in 314D, 36 belong to male-headed households, of which 28 are entirely affected.
On the other hand, of the 18 affected shops owned by women-headed households, 10 are
entirely affected (see Table C-11).
41. The 17 partially affected independent shops in 314D have an aggregate floor area of
167.0 m2. 4 shops of construction grade 2F (i.e., single floor with metal sheet walls, low quality
wooden posts, and earthen floor) account for 27.54% (46.0 m2) of the combined floor area of the
partially affected shops. The aggregate floor area of entirely affected shops in 314D is 1,003.2 m2.
16 shops of 2C construction grade account for 27.26% (273.5 m2) of the combined floor area of
entirely affected shops (see Table C-16).
42. CBF: 3 concrete single floor buildings4 with a combined floor area of 332.0 m2 and a 32
2
m thatched hut (construction grade 2C) all belonging to the custom and immigration offices at
the CBF are entirely affected. The household taking care of the affected grazing land has a 35 m2
house (construction grade 1C) and a 35 m2 shop (construction grade 1B), while the household
taking care of the affected private residential has a 20 m2 house-and-shop of construction grade
1A. These caretaker households are male-headed and their houses and shops are affected
entirely.
43. NR13. A total of 222 main structures in NR13 are adversely affected by the road
improvement. Of this number, 51.35% (114 structures) are independent shops, while 47.30%
(105 structures) are houses, and 1.35% are (3 structures) house-and-shops.
44. Houses. 24 of the 105 affected houses in NR13 were locked and unattended at the time
of the survey. 6 of these unattended houses are entirely affected. 57 of the remaining 81 affected
houses in NR13 belong to male-headed households, of which 12 are entirely affected. Moreover,
1 of the affected houses belonging to a male-headed household is being rented out for about $25
per month. Of the 24 affected houses owned by women-headed households, 8 are entirely
affected (see Table C-9).
45. The 79 partially affected houses in NR13 have an aggregate floor area of 910.3 m 2. 18
partially affected houses of construction grade of 2F account for 27.50% (or 250.30 m 2) of the
4 2
By construction grade, 2 buildings are of construction grade 3D with a combined floor area of 236 m ,
2
and 1 building of construction grade 2J with a floor area of 96 m .
12
13
floor area of partially affected houses. 14 other partially affected houses of 2J construction grade
account for 25.82% (235.0 m2) of the combined floor area of partially affected houses. The 26
entirely affected houses in NR13 have an aggregate floor area of 717.5 m2. Of this area, 7
houses of 2FJ construction grade account for 32.47% (or 233.0 m 2), followed by 7 other houses
of 2C construction grade that account for 26.90% (or 193.0 m2) of the aggregate floor area of
entirely affected houses (see Table C-13).
47. The 3 partially affected house-and-stores in NR13 have an aggregate floor area of 35.0
m2 only. 2 of these house-and-stores are of construction grade 2J and have an aggregate area of
23.0 m2. There are no entirely affected house-and-stores in NR13 (see Table C-15).
48. Independent shops. 20 of the 114 affected shops in NR13 were locked and unattended at
the time of the survey. 6 of these unattended shops are entirely affected. 73 of the remaining 94
affected shops in NR13 belong to male-headed households, of which 45 are entirely affected. 1
of the affected shops belonging to a male-headed household is being rented out for about $25
per month. Of the 21 affected shops owned by women-headed households, 6 are entirely
affected (see Table C-11).
49. The 57 partially affected independent shops in NR13 have an aggregate floor area of
549.3 m2. 23 shops of construction grade 2F account for 40.92% (224.8 m2) of the combined
floor area of the partially affected shops. The aggregate floor area of the 57 entirely affected
shops in NR13 is 1,416.1 m2. 16 shops of 2F construction grade account for 25.07% (355.0 m2)
of the combined floor area of entirely affected shops (see Table C-17).
House-and-
Commune House store Store/shops Total
Total 1 1 1 3
NR13
Sangkhor 15 1 23 39
Kampong Chak 28 0 14 42
Sangkae 10 0 16 26
Chrung Popel 13 0 7 20
Kampong Ampil 2 0 9 11
Angk Prasrae 9 1 6 16
Andoung Pou 5 0 7 12
Kampong Trach 22 1 19 42
Amkpil 1 0 8 9
Andoung Trabaek 0 0 1 1
Krabau 0 0 4 4
Total 105 3 114 222
CBF = cross-border facility, NR = national road.
Excluding the 3 concrete offices and 1 thatched hut of the customs and immigration offices.
14
15
16
17
51. CBF: The customs and immigration offices at the CBF will also lose a thatched shed and
18
a stupa (small altar for venerating spirits of deceased relatives). Additionally, a concrete fence of
construction grade F6 and measuring 206 meters long will be acquired.
52. NR13: Affected secondary structures of various construction grades in NR13 include
126 pieces of fence with an aggregate length of 22,269.6 linear meters; 399 extended eaves with
an aggregate area of 7,496.5 m2 (normally used as shops); 284 pieces of concrete pavement
with an aggregate area of 7,455m2; 13 pieces of tiled pavement with an aggregate area of 218
m2; 3 deep wells and 4 dug wells; 11 pieces of concrete pipe culverts; 10 waiting sheds with an
aggregate area of 224 m2; 9 pieces of metal signboards, and 3 concrete pagoda gates. In
addition, 21 electric and telecommunication posts will need to be relocated behind the COI.
18
19
54. 314D: A total of 584 perennials of various species and age will be cleared from the COI in
314D. These trees are not commercially grown but sporadically planted inside the ROW. Of this
number, 82 are not yet bearing fruits. In addition, some 1,650 of timber trees of commercial value
will also be cleared from the COI.
20
21
Categories
Type of Perennial 1* 2 3 Total
Others 32 36 38 106
Total 82 376 126 584
*Not yet bearing fruits
55. CBF: A total of 583 timber trees and 15 fruit trees on private and government land will be
acquire in the expansion and development of the CBF.
56. NR13: A total of 966 perennials of various species and age will be cleared from the COI
in NR13. These trees are not commercially grown but sporadically planted inside the ROW. Of
this number, 195 are not yet bearing fruits. In addition, some 8,940 of timber trees of commercial
value will also be cleared from the COI.
Categories
Type of Perennial 1* 2 3 Total
Total 195 662 109 966
*Not yet bearing fruits
58. 314D: Among the 10 households in 314D whose shops are partially affected and who
responded to the query on net income, 6 claimed to be earning a net income of less than $100 a
month, while 2 claimed to earn a net income of between $101 and $200 a month. 2 others
claimed to earn a net income of more than $200 a month from their shops. Similarly, among the
26 households losing entire shops who responded to the query on net income, 15 households
(57.69% of the respondents) claimed to be earning a net income of less than $100 a month,
while 6 households (23.08%) claimed to earn a net income of between $101 and $200 a month.
5 others claimed to earn a net income of more than $200 a month from their shops.
59. NR13: Among the 39 households in NR13 whose shops are partially affected and who
responded to the query on net income, 30 (76.92% of the respondents) claimed to be earning a
net income of less than $100 a month, while 7 claimed to earn a net income of between $101
and $200 a month. 2 others claimed to earn a net income of more than $200 a month from their
shops. Similarly, among the 43 households losing entire shops would responded to the query
on net income, 29 (67.44% of the respondents) claimed to be earning a net income of less than
$100 a month, while 10 households (23.26%) claimed to earn a net income of between $101 and
$200 a month. 4 others claimed to earn a net income of more than $200 a month from their
shops.
Table III.25 Range of Net Monthly Income of Partially Affected Shops 314D
Net Monthly Income
Total
Head of AH Commune $100 or $101 -
> $200 N/A*
Less $200
Male Kandeang Reay 0 0 1 0 1
Prasout 1 0 0 0 1
Nhor 1 0 1 1 3
22
23
Table III.26 Range of Net Monthly Income of Entirely Affected Shops PR 314D
Net Monthly Income
Head of AH Commune $100 or $101 - Total
> $200 N/A*
Less $200
Kandeang Reay 1 0 3 2 6
Prasout 2 0 1 2 5
Preah Ponlea 0 1 1 0 2
Male Nhor 4 2 0 2 8
Ksetr 1 0 0 3 4
Thmei 0 2 0 1 3
Total 8 5 5 10 28
Prasout 0 0 0 1 1
Preah Ponlea 0 1 0 0 1
Nhor 4 0 0 1 5
Female
Ksetr 1 0 0 0 1
Thmei 2 0 0 0 2
Total 7 1 0 2 10
Prasout 1 1
Preah Ponlea 1 1
Owners not known Nhor 4 4
Thmei 1 1
Total 7 7
*No answer
Table III.27 Range of Net Monthly Income of Partially Affected Shops NR13
Net Monthly Income
Gender Commune $100 or $101 - Total
>$200 N/A
Less $200
Male Sangkhor 1 1 1 0 3
Kampong Chak 3 0 1 1 5
Sangkae 0 1 0 1 2
Chrung Popel 2 0 0 0 2
Kampong Ampil 2 0 0 0 2
Angk Prasrae 3 0 0 0 3
Andoung Pou 3 0 0 1 4
Kampong Trach 3 1 0 1 5
Amkpil 0 1 0 0 1
Krabau 1 0 0 0 1
24
Table III.28 Range of Net Monthly Income of Entirely Affected Shops NR13
Net Monthly Income
Gender Commune $100 or $101 - Total
>$200 N/A
Less $200
Male Sangkhor 7 1 0 0 8
Kampong Chak 2 2 0 1 5
Sangkae 1 0 2 5 8
Chrung Popel 3 0 1 0 4
Kampong Ampil 3 1 0 1 5
Angk Prasrae 3 0 0 0 3
Andoung Pou 1 1 0 1 3
Kampong Trach 4 2 0 0 6
Krabau 1 1 1 0 3
Total 25 8 4 8 45
Female Sangkhor 3 1 0 0 4
Kampong Chak 1 0 0 0 1
Kampong Trach 0 1 0 0 1
Total 4 2 0 0 6
Owners not known Chrung Popel 1 1
Kampong Ampil 1 1
Amkpil 2 2
Total 4 4
24
25
A. Introduction
60. A socioeconomic survey (SES) of the affected households (AHs) was conducted in
parallel with the IOL. A sample of at least 20% of AHs losing entire houses and shops and
sources of income, and a sample of at least 10% of AHs are affected by the partial loss of their
houses and shops, were randomly selected from the list of affected households generated
immediately following the IOL in each road section. In road sections where there were less than
50 severely affected households, the SES covered 100% of the severely affected while
maintaining the 10% sample size of the partially affected AHs. Not covered in the SES were AHs
affected only by the loss of secondary structures, such as fences, gates, driveways, in addition
to randomly grown trees (i.e., not in a commercial plantation or orchard) inside the COI.
61. The SES gathered information on the AHs’ living standards and living conditions as well
as their perceptions towards the project. Information gathered has guided the preparation of an
appropriate resettlement strategy for the Project. The SES data set also serves as a baseline of
AH living conditions to form part of the monitoring and evaluation data that will assess the extent
to which the measures of this resettlement plan are effective in mitigating land acquisition and
resettlement impacts.
62. 314D: 26 of the 51 male-headed AHs and 9 of the 26 women-headed AHs surveyed in
314D are affected by the partial or entire loss of their houses. In addition, 17 male-headed AHs
and 11 women-headed AHs are affected by the partial or entire loss of their house-and-stores.
Another 8 male-headed AHs and 56 women-headed AHs are affected by the partial or entire loss
of their independent shops. The affected structures of the sample AHs are mostly located in the
communes of Kandien Reay, Prasout, Nhor, and Ksetr.
63. NR13: In NR13, thirty-four of the 72 male-headed AHs and 6 of the women-headed
AHs surveyed are affected by the partial or entire loss of their houses. In addition, 26
male-headed AHs and 4 women-headed AHs are affected by the partial or entire loss of their
26
house-and-stores. Another 12 male-headed AHs and 4 women-headed AHs are affected by the
partial or entire loss of their independent shops. The affected structures of the sample AHs are
mostly located in the communes of Kampong Chak and Kampong Trach.
64. In 314D, 36 of the 51 male-headed AHs (or 70.59%) and 20 of the 26 women-headed
AHs (or 76.92%) have been living or in occupation of their affected houses and shops for 5 to 9
years already. In NR13, while 31 of the 72 male-headed AHs (or 43.06%) have been living or in
occupation of their affected houses and shops for 5 to 9 years already, 22 other AHs (30.56%)
have been living or in occupation of their affected houses and shops for 1 to 2 years only.
Women-headed AHs in NR13 seem to have settled to live and conduct business inside the road
right-of-way more recently than male-headed AHs.
26
27
66. In NR13, most (97.22% or 70 persons) of the 72 sample male household heads are
married. In contrast, all of the while 23 other male household heads are still single. On the other
hand, widowed and married women have an equal number of 9 each (34.6% each of the sample
26 AH heads). Also, single women AH heads account for 26.92% the sample women-headed
AHs.
Table IV.6 Head of Sample AHs by Physical Condition and Age 314D
Gender of AH Physical Age grouping
Commune Total
Head condition < 60 Years > 60 Years
Male Normal Kandieng Reay 13 2 15
Prasout 9 0 9
Preah Ponlea 1 0 1
Nhor 4 6 10
Ksetr 12 2 14
Thmei 1 1 2
Total 40 11 51
Female Normal Kandieng Reay 1 1 2
Prasout 3 0 3
Preah Ponlea 3 0 3
Nhor 4 3 7
Ksetr 4 0 4
Thmei 4 1 5
Total 19 5 24
Handicapped Ksetr 2 0 2
Total 2 0 2
68. In NR13, nine (12.50%) of the 72 male respondents are aged 60 years or older, 2 of
whom also have disabilities. None of the women respondents has disabilities, although 3 fall
within the elderly age bracket.
28
29
Table IV.7 Head of Sample AHs by Physical Condition and Age NR13
Age AH Grouping
Gender of AH Physical
Commune < 60 Total
Head condition > 60 Years
Years
Male Normal Sangkhor 8 0 8
Kampong Chak 6 5 11
Sangkae 3 0 3
Chrung Popel 6 0 6
Kampong Ampil 6 0 6
Angk Prasrae 6 0 6
Andoung Pou 6 1 7
Kampong Trach 16 1 17
Amkpil 2 0 2
Andoung Trabaek 1 0 1
Krabau 3 0 3
Total 63 7 70
Handicapped Chrung Popel 0 1 1
Kampong Trach 0 1 1
Total 0 2 2
Female Normal Kampong Chak 1 2 3
Sangkae 3 1 4
Chrung Popel 1 0 1
Angk Prasrae 1 0 1
Kampong Trach 3 0 3
Amkpil 2 0 2
Total 11 3 14
Educational attainment
Not
Gender of Finished
Commune Finished finished Total
AH Head None Primary high
Elementary high
school
school
Female Kandieng Reay 0 1 0 1 0 2
Prasout 1 0 1 1 0 3
Preah Ponlea 0 0 1 1 1 3
Nhor 0 4 2 0 1 7
Ksetr 0 1 1 4 0 6
Thmei 0 2 1 2 0 5
Total 1 8 6 9 2 26
71. In NR13, majority (48.61% or 35 persons) of the 72 male respondents attended high
school but did not graduate, while 20 (27.78%) of the male respondents only reached primary
school. Five(6.94%) did not attend school. None of the 14 women AH heads attended school,
however.
30
31
1. 314D
73. Almost half (43.14% or 22 AHs) of the 51 sample male AH heads derive their main source
of income from farming. Another 13 male-headed AHs (25.49%) are primarily involved in selling
food and non-food items. While a significant percentage (34.62% or 9 persons) of the 26 sample
women AH heads are earning through selling goods, an equally significant percentage (30.77%
or 8 persons) are not involved in productive activities.
74. More than half (53.0% or 27 AHs) of the 51 male-headed sample AHs reportedly have a
monthly household income of less than $65/month for a family of 5 people in rural areas. Nine
(17.65%) other male-headed AHs have monthly household income of $65 ~ $100. Similarly, half
(50.0% or 13 AHs) of the 26 sample women-headed AH have a monthly household income
below $65. Another 7 (26.92%) women-headed AHs live on the borderline of poverty.
75. It can be seen from table below that the sample AHs could only spend for their needs
within the limits of their incomes. A number of them, however, are apparently spending beyond
what they earn in a month and are probably in debt.
32
33
2. NR13
76. The 3 most common primary livelihood of the 72 sample male AH heads are running
repair shops/barber shops (33.33%), farming (30.56%), and selling food and non-food items
(18.06%). While majority (42.86%) of the 14 sample women AH heads are earning through
selling goods, an equally significant percentage (35.71%) are not involved in productive
activities.
77. More than half (52.78% or 38 AHs) of the 72 male-headed sample AHs reportedly have a
monthly household income of less than $65/month. 12 (16.67%) other male-headed AHs have a
monthly household income of $65 ~ $100. In contrast, only 4 (28.57%) of the 14 sample
women-headed AH have a monthly household income below $65. Five(35.71%) women-headed
AHs reportedly earn a monthly income of $101 ~ $200. The amount of poor people will be
confirmed during Detailed Measurement Survey and updating the RP based on appropriate
poverty line.
78. It can be seen from table below that a number of the sample AHs spend beyond what
they earn in a month. It can only be surmised that they are in constant debt.
34
35
1. 314D
79. Health and sanitation. Most of the 77 sample AHs in 314D have their own well for
drinking (86.0%) and washing (83.0%). However, 40.0% (31 AHs) do not have a toilet in their
homes. Relatedly, 64.0% of the AHs have no bathrooms. Moreover, most (88.0%) of the AHs
burn or bury their refuse.
Table IV.18 Main Source of Potable Water of the AHs314D
Source of potable water
Commune Total
Own well Public well Neighbor wells
Kandieng Reay 16 0 1 17
Prasout 8 1 3 12
Preah Ponlea 3 0 1 4
Nhor 16 0 1 17
Ksetr 16 0 4 20
Thmei 7 0 0 7
Total 66 1 10 77
Table IV.19 Main Source of Water for Washing of the AHs 314D
Water for washing/bathing
Commune Total
Own well Public well Neighbor wells
Kandieng Reay 15 0 2 17
Prasout 8 1 3 12
Preah Ponlea 2 0 2 4
Nhor 16 0 1 17
Ksetr 16 0 4 20
Thmei 7 0 0 7
Total 64 1 12 77
36
80. Power for lighting and fuel for cooking. Except for 1, the rest of the 77 sample AHs in
314D get electricity for lighting the public service provider. Wood is the most commonly used fuel
for cooking among the AHs.
36
37
81. Household appliances and transportation. Television set is the most common
household appliance, with 65 (84.0%) of the AHs owning one. Next is electric fan (75%), followed
by hand phone (74%). Majority of the 77 sample AHs own a bicycle (84.0%) and a motorbike
(81.0%).
2. NR13
82. Health and sanitation. Majority of the 86 sample AHs in NR13 have their own well for
drinking (58.0%) and washing (56.0%). However, 57.0% (49 AHs) do not have a toilet in their
homes. Relatedly, 65.0% of the AHs have no bathrooms. Moreover, most (95.0%) of the AHs
burn or bury their refuse.
38
Table IV.28 Main Source of Water for Washing of the AHs NR13
Water for washing/bathing
Commune Buy from Neighbor's Total
Own well Public well
retailers Well
Sangkhor 5 0 0 3 8
Kampong Chak 10 0 0 4 14
Sangkae 6 0 0 1 7
Chrung Popel 4 0 0 4 8
Kampong Ampil 3 2 0 1 6
Angk Prasrae 2 2 1 2 7
Andoung Pou 2 0 1 4 7
Kampong Trach 11 1 0 9 21
Amkpil 3 1 0 0 4
Andoung Trabaek 1 0 0 0 1
Krabau 1 1 0 1 3
Total 48 7 2 29 86
38
39
83. Power for lighting and fuel for cooking. While majority (56.0%) of the 86 sample AHs
get electricity from the public service provider, the rest of the sample AHs still use rechargeable
car batteries for lighting and running electric appliances. All 86 sample AHs use wood for cooking,
although some of them also use gas and electricity.
Table IV.32 Main Source of Power for Lighting NR13
Main source of power for lighting
Commune Total
Rechargeable battery Public electricity
Sangkhor 0 8 8
Kampong Chak 3 11 14
Sangkae 3 4 7
Chrung Popel 7 1 8
Kampong Ampil 6 0 6
Angk Prasrae 4 3 7
Andoung Pou 7 0 7
Kampong Trach 6 15 21
Amkpil 2 2 4
Andoung Trabaek 0 1 1
40
84. Household appliances and transportation. The hand phone is the most common
household appliance, with 79.0% of the AHs owning one. Next is a television set (78.0%),
followed by electric fan (43.0%). Majority of the 86 sample AHs own a bicycle (77.0%) and a
motorbike (71.0%).
40
41
Means of Transportations
Commune
Bicycle Motorbike None Car Truck
Angk Prasrae 4 5 3 1 0
Andoung Pou 5 2 2 0 0
Kampong Trach 15 12 6 3 2
Amkpil 2 2 2 0 0
Andoung Trabaek 1 1 0 0 0
Krabau 1 3 2 0 0
Total 66 61 20 4 2
85. Participation provides for the occasion and the process by which stakeholders influence
and become co-responsible for development initiatives and decisions that affect them. Through
participation, the needs and priorities of the local population are ventilated; the adverse social
impacts of the Project, including the corresponding mitigating measures, are collectively
identified; and the commitment and feeling of ownership over the Project is engendered among
the APs.
86. The public, especially the AHs, the local governments and road users will be consulted
and their opinions solicited, and will in fact participate in the preparation, updating, and
implementation of the resettlement plan. Table below summarizes the roles and responsibilities
of the Executing Agency, the local governments, and the AHs in the preparation, updating, and
implementation of the resettlement plan.
Pre-feasibility/ Briefing of the provincial, district, commune, and PMU3 and Consultants
Feasibility village officials; PDWT; and stakeholders about the
Project TA, the resettlement policy, and the
activities of the consultants
87. The resettlement survey team conducted consultations in the affected districts prior to the
IOL and SES activities. The agenda of the consultations included (a) explaining to local officials
and residents what the TA was all about; (b) introducing the members of the survey team, the
reasons for the survey and the schedule for the conduct of the same, including the policy on
5
The Project information leaflet, written in Khmer, contains the following brief information: (i) Project background,
specifically about the civil works to be done; (ii) results of the IOL; (iii) entitlements due to the AHs; (iv) bases for
computing compensation for affected assets; (v) schedule of delivery of entitlements and displacement; (vi) grievance
redress mechanism; and (vii) contact persons at PMU3. (See Appendix 5 for the draft leaflet).
42
43
cut-off date for eligibility to Project entitlements; and, (c) identifying the major project
stakeholders in the districts and getting their views regarding the road improvement project,
including their suggestions on how to avoid and minimize adverse impacts. A total of 199 local
officials and residents participated in the consultations, 60 of whom were women. (See
Appendix 4 for the highlights and list of participants to the pre-IOL consultations).
44
88. Following the conclusion of the IOL and SES, the resettlement survey team returned to
the affected districts to hold a second round of consultations, specifically with the AHs. The
agenda of said consultations included (a) highlights of the results of IOL, such as information on
the types and magnitude of impacts; (b) discussion of basic resettlement principles to be used in
the project, such as compensation at replacement cost, public participation, and grievance
redress; and, (c) finding out from the AHs what their views and suggestions are regarding
compensation, allowances and assistance, relocation of structures, grievance redress, and
participation. A total of 525 persons participated in the post-IOL consultations, 234 of whom were
women. See Appendix 4 for the highlights and list of participants to the post-IOL consultations).
89. The resettlement plan has been disclosed to affected households by way of public
information meetings and dissemination of the public information brochure (attached as an
annex to the resettlement plan). Translated copies of the resettlement plan (key isssues) have
also been disseminated to each district and commune office within the project areas and are to
be AHs accessible. The resettlement plan is also uploaded on the project website of the
Ministry of Public Works and Transport as well as ADB’s website.
90. Consultation with AHs will continue during resettlement plan updating up to
implementation or resettlement. Particular attention will be given to the poor and other vulnerable
AHs. All consultation and disclosure activities will be properly documented; minutes of
44
45
91. Disclosure of the updated RP to AHs will be undertaken through each Commune Office in
the project areas (where it will be made available for AH reading). MPWT (through the PMU3 and
ESO) will disclose the final updated resettlement plan approved by the Government and the ADB
and any revisions to the updated resettlement plan as a result of changes in scope or design
layout. Key information in the updated resettlement plan to be disclosed to the commune office
include (a) relocation and rehabilitation options, (b) entitlements, (c) grievance procedures, (d)
schedule of delivery of assistance, and (e) displacement schedule. The information will be made
publicly available at MPWT, district, and commune offices and will be provided to the AHs in the
form of a project information leaflet (see Appendix 5 for the Project information leaflet). Social
monitoring reports will also be made available to the AHs and will be uploaded on the ADB
website.
92. The objective the grievance redress provisions are to resolve complaints as quickly as
possible and at the local level through a process of conciliation; and, if that is not possible, to
provide clear and transparent procedures for appeal. AHs are entitled to lodge complaints
regarding any aspect of the preparation and implementation of the RP. A well-defined grievance
redress and resolution mechanism will be established to resolveAH grievances and complaints in
a timely and satisfactory manner. All AHs will be made fully aware of their rights, and the detailed
grievance redress procedures will be publicized through an effective public information
campaign. The grievance redress process includes four stages:
a. First stage: AHs will present their complaints and grievances verbally or in writing to the
village chief, commune chief or IRC and PRS working groups. The receiving agent will
be obliged to provide immediate written confirmation of receiving the complaint. If after
15 days the aggrieved AH does not hear from the village and commune chiefs or the
working groups, or if he/she is not satisfied with the decision taken in the first stage, the
complaint may be brought to the District Office.
b. Second stage: The District Office has 15 days within which to resolve the complaint to
the satisfaction of all concerned. If the complaint cannot be solved at this stage, the
District Office will bring the case to the Provincial Grievance Redress Committee.
c. Third stage: The Provincial Grievance Redress Committee meets with the aggrieved
party and tries to resolve the situation. The Committee may ask for a review of the DMS
by the external monitor (IMO). Within 30 days of the submission of the grievance, the
Committee must make a written decision and submit copies to the MOWRAM,
PDOWRAM, PDRD, EMA, PRS/IRC and the AH.
Final stage: If the aggrieved AH does not hear from the Provincial Grievance Redress Committee
or is not satisfied, he/she will bring the case to Provincial Court. This is the final stage for
adjudicating complaints. The Court will make a written decision and submit copies to the
MOWRAM, PDOWRAM, EMA, PRS/IRC and the AH. If any party is still unsatisfied with the
Provincial Court judgment, he/she can bring the case to a higher-level court.
46
92. The legal and policy framework for addressing the adverse social impacts of the Project is
provided by relevant policies and laws of the Royal Government of Cambodia and of the ADB.
A. Relevant Laws
1. 1993 Constitution
93. The 1993 Constitution of Cambodia sets two basic principles for land acquisition. The
first is Article 44 which states that the “right to confiscate properties from any person shall be
exercised only in the public interest as provided by law and shall require fair and just
compensation in advance” (Article 44). The second principle is Article 20 which stipulates that
“nobody shall be forced to transfer his or her ownership, if forcing is not necessary in the public
interest and (if) no proper and just indemnity has been paid to the owner”. These two
principles are also adhered to in almost all countries.
94. Articles 73 and 74 of the Constitution provide for special consideration and support to
vulnerable people including mothers and children, the disabled and families of combatants who
sacrificed their lives for the nation. Indigenous minorities however are not explicitly included in
these two articles but included in the Land Law.
96. The rights and responsibilities of the Government with respect to eminent domain are
specified in the Land Law. The Government can acquire private land for public purposes but has
to pay a fair and just compensation in advance of the land acquisition. The Land Law, Article 5,
states that “No person may be deprived of his ownership, unless it is in the public interest. An
ownership deprivation shall be carried out in accordance with the forms and procedures provided
by law and regulations and after the payment of fair and just compensation in advance.”
97. Other provisions of the Land Law that are relevant to land acquisition, compensation and
resettlement include:
a. Legal possession as defined by the Law is the sole basis for ownership, and all
transfers or changes of rights of ownership shall be carried out in accordance with the
required general rules for sale, succession, exchange and gift or by court decision.
(Article 6)
b. Any regime of ownership of immovable property prior to 1979 shall not be recognized.
(Article 7)
c. Only persons or legal entities of Khmer nationality are entitled to own land in
Cambodia; or to buy or sell land. (Articles 8, 66)
d. State public land includes, among other categories, any property a) that has a natural
origin, such as forests, courses and banks of navigable and floatable rivers or natural
lakes; b) that is made available for public use such as roads, tracks, oxcart ways,
46
47
pathways, gardens, public parks and reserved land; or, c) that is allocated to render a
public service, such as public schools, public hospitals or administrative buildings.
(Article 15)
e. Persons that illegally occupy, possess or claim title to State public land cannot claim
any compensation. This includes land established by the Government as public
rights-of-way for roads and railways. Moreover, failure to vacate illegally occupied
land in a timely manner is subject to fines and/or imprisonment. (Article 19)
g. No authority outside the community may acquire any rights to immovable properties
belonging to an indigenous community. (Article 28)
h. Persons with legally valid possession of land for five years (at the time the law came
into effect) are allowed to be registered as the owner of the land (Article 30). Persons
who (at the time the law came into effect) held legal possession but had not yet
completed the five years were allowed to remain in possession until they were eligible
to be registered as the owner. (Article 31)
i. However, temporary possession claims made by persons after the law comes into
effect will not be recognized, rescinding a previous right under the 1992 Land Law for
acquiring land by taking possession. (Articles 29, 34)
j. Landless people may apply for land for residential and subsistence farming purposes
at no cost, as part of a social land concessions scheme. The concessionaire may
obtain ownership of this land after fulfilling conditions set out in a separate
Sub-Decree on Social Land Concessions. (Articles 50, 51)
k. Acquisition of land through gifts is permitted with the following conditions: (i) the gift of
immovable property is only effective if it is made in writing and registered with the
Cadastral Registry Unit; (ii) once accepted, gifts of immovable property are
irrevocable; and, (iii) the donor may retain the right of usufruct in the property, and the
right of use and habitation of an immovable property. (Articles 80-84)
6
As per Article 23 of the Land Law, “An indigenous community is a group of people that resides in
Cambodia whose members manifest ethnic, social, cultural and economic unity and who practice a
traditional lifestyle, and who cultivate the lands in their possession according to the customary rules of
collective use”
48
99. The private ownership of land was re-established in 1989, and confirmed in the 2001
Land Law (Article4). Cambodians are able to register the land they occupy with the local
Cadastral Administration Office, whereupon a certificate of land title is granted. Issuing land titles
is a lengthy process and most offices have a major backlog of applications. People are given a
receipt and until the official title deed is issued, this receipt is accepted as title for land purpose or
sale.
100. The present legal status of land use in Cambodia can be classified as follows:
a. Privately owned land with title: The owner has official title to land, and both owner and
the Cadastral Administration Office have a copy of the deed.
b. Privately owned land without title: The owner has make application for title to land, and is
waiting for the issuance of a title deed. The Cadastral Administration Office recognizes
the owner.
c. Land use rights certified by the Government: In this case, a receipt for long-term land
use has been issued. This land use right is recognized by the Cadastral
Administration Office.
d. Lease land: The Government or private owners lease the land, usually for a short
period. There is provision for the owner to reclaim land if it is needed for development.
e. Non-legal occupation: The user has no land use rights to State land that he occupies
or uses. The Cadastral Administration Office does not recognize the use of this land.
100. Prakas No. 6, entitled “Measures to Crack Down on Anarchic Land Grabbing and
Encroachments”, sets a ROW of 50 m for NR 2, 3, 6, and 7, and a ROW of 60 m for NR 1, 4, 5,
11, 22, 64, and 78. Exceptions are made for urban areas traversed by these national roads,
where the ROW can be reduced, subject to the decision of the Government. In support of this
Prakas, the Ministry of Economy and Finance (MEF) on 6 April 2000 issued Decree No. 961
prohibiting compensation for structures and other assets located in the road ROW.
101. Prakas No. 6 must have been prompted by the influx of people inside the road ROW
following the ouster from power of the Khmer Rouge in 1979 after a reign of four years. During
that short period, private property was abolished and all land records destroyed. The years that
followed after 1979 until the restoration of private property in 1989 were very disorderly, often
chaotic, exacerbated by more armed conflicts. Returning people who were forced to do manual
farm labor during the Khmer Regime occupied any vacant or empty property they could find
along the road and in town centers. To make the re-occupation of abandoned properties and
the distribution of land more systematic, the post-1979 government introduced usufruct rights,
organizing families in rural areas into groups that collectively owned land and assets. Each group
of families had a head, and land was distributed to individual families according to fertility.
4. Expropriation Law
101. The Expropriation Law, passed by the National Assembly on 29 December 2009 and
promulgated by the King on 04 February 2010, contains 8 Chapters with 39 Articles. It provides
48
49
clear procedures on acquiring private properties for national and public interests. Key Articles of
the Law are listed below.
a. Article 2: the law has the following purposes: (i) ensure reasonable and just
deprivation of a legal right to ownership of private property; (ii) ensure payment of
reasonable and just prior compensation; (iii) serve the public and national interests;
and (iv) development of public physical infrastructure. Article 7:
b. Only the State may carry out an expropriation for use in the public and national
interests.
c. Article 8: the State shall accept the purchase of part of the real property left over
from an expropriation at a reasonable and just price at the request of the owner of
and/or the holder of right in the expropriated real property who is unable to live near
the expropriated scheme or to build a residence or conduct any business.
d. Article 12: an expropriation committee shall be established and headed by a
representative from the Ministry of Economy and Finance and composed of
representatives from relevant ministries and institutions. The organization and
functioning of the expropriation committee shall be determined by a sub-decree.
e. Article 22: an amount of compensation to be paid to the owner of and/or holder of
rights in the real property shall be based on the market value of the real property or
the alternative value as of the date of the issuance of the Prakas on the expropriation
scheme. The market value or the alternative value shall be determined by an
independent commission or agent appointed by the expropriation committee.
B. ADB Policies
102. The objectives of the ADB Safeguard Policy Statement (2009) are (a) to avoid impacts on
people and the environment, where possible; (b) where avoidance is not possible, minimize,
mitigate, or compensate for adverse project impacts on the environment and the affected people;
and (c) help the executing agency strengthen its safeguard system. Towards this end, ADB
resettlement policy includes the following principles:
a. Screen the project early on to identify past, present, and future involuntary
resettlement impacts and risks. Determine the scope of resettlement planning through
a survey and/or census of affected persons, including a gender analysis, specifically
related to resettlement impacts and risks.
b. Improve, or at least restore, the livelihoods of all affected persons through (i)
land-based resettlement strategies when affected livelihoods are land based where
possible or cash compensation at replacement value for land when the loss of land
does not undermine livelihoods, (ii) prompt replacement of assets with access to
assets of equal or higher value, (iii) prompt compensation at full replacement cost for
assets that cannot be restored, and (iv) additional revenues and services through
benefit sharing schemes where possible.
d. Improve the standards of living of the affected poor and other vulnerable groups,
including women, to at least national minimum standards. In rural areas provide them
with legal and affordable access to land and resources, and in urban areas provide
them with appropriate income sources and legal and affordable access to adequate
housing.
f. Ensure that affected persons without titles to land or any recognizable legal rights to
land are eligible for resettlement assistance and compensation for loss of non-land
assets.
l. Monitor and assess resettlement outcomes, their impacts on the standards of living of
affected persons, and whether the objectives of the resettlement plan have been
achieved by taking into account the baseline conditions and the results of
resettlement monitoring. Disclose monitoring reports.
103. The objective of ADB Policy on Indigenous Peoplesas set out in the Safeguard Policy
Statement (2009) is to design and implement projects in a way that fosters full respect for
Indigenous Peoples’ identity, dignity, human rights, livelihood systems, and cultural uniqueness
as defined by the Indigenous Peoples themselves so that they (i) receive culturally appropriate
50
51
social and economic benefits, (ii) do not suffer adverse impacts as a result of projects, and (iii)
can participate actively in projects that affect them.
104. The ADB Policy on Gender and Development (2006) adopts gender mainstreaming as
a key strategy for promoting gender equity, and for ensuring that women participate in and
that their needs are explicitly addressed in the decision-making process for development
activities. For projects that have the potential to have substantial gender impacts, a gender plan is
prepared to identify strategies to address gender concerns and the involvement of women in the
design, implementation and monitoring of the project.
105. In dealing with ODA funded projects, the Government has adapted on a
project-by-project basis to the resettlement policies of donor agencies. Thus, starting in 1999
with the ADB-assisted Phnom Penh to Ho Chi Minh City Highway Improvement Project (Loan
1659-CAM), projects supported by such funding agencies are governed by the resettlement
policies of these agencies and relevant laws and government regulations not consistent with the
same are waived.
106. Table below summarizes how the resettlement policy ADB is applied in Cambodia.
52
7
Land use assistance is provided for productive land in the ROW.
52
53
107. The Project resettlement policy has been developed taking into account the types,
characteristics, and severity of Project impacts on assets and living conditions of the affected
population, guided by the Constitution of the Royal Government of Cambodia, prevailing legal
and government procedures and policies, not to mention resettlement policies adopted by the
government for specific development projects funded by the ADB.
A. Objectives
108. The paramount objective of the Project Resettlement Policy is to ensure that AHs are not
worse off because of the Project. The Project should provide an opportunity for the local
population to derive benefits from it, and it should likewise serve as an occasion for the local
population to participate in its planning and implementation, thereby engendering a sense of
ownership over the same.
B. Key Principles
109. Cognizant of the aforementioned, the Royal Government of Cambodia commits itself to
the following principles in the implementation of the Project road:
a. Acquisition of land and other assets, and resettlement of people will be avoided or
minimized as much as possible by identifying possible alternative project designs and
appropriate social, economic, operational and engineering solutions that have the
least impact on the population.
b. No land acquisition or site clearing will be done inside the ROW in anticipation or
ahead of it being considered for implementation under the Project. Relatedly, no land
acquisition or site clearing will be done inside the ROW until and after the RP has
been updated and approved both by Royal Government of Cambodia and the ADB,
and until and after all entitlements due to the AHs as provided for in this resettlement
policy have been delivered.
c. AHs will be eligible for compensation and rehabilitation assistance, irrespective of
tenure status, social or economic standing and any such factors that may discriminate
against achievement of the Project resettlement objective. Lack of legal rights to lost
assets or adversely affected tenure status and social or economic status will not bar
the AHs from entitlements to such compensation for non-land assets and
rehabilitation measures or resettlement objectives.
d. AHs residing, working, doing business and/or cultivating land within the Project
impacted areas during the conduct of the IOL, to be validated or updated during the
detailed measurement survey (DMS), are entitled to be compensated for their lost
assets, incomes and businesses at replacement cost prevailing at the time of
compensation, and, depending on the severity of impact on their livelihood and
income capacity, will be provided with rehabilitation measures to improve or restore
their pre-Project living standards, income-earning capacity and production levels.
e. There will be no deductions in compensation payments for land, structures or other
affected assets for salvage value, depreciation, taxes, stamp duties, fees or other
payments.
54
f. If ownership over any affected asset is under dispute, the compensation for the same
will be held in a court designated bank until its lawful owner is decided by competent
legal authorities.
g. AHs that lose only part of their physical assets will not be left with a portion that will be
inadequate to sustain their current standard of living. The minimum size of remaining
land and structures will be agreed between the MPWT, the Inter-Ministerial
Resettlement Committee (IRC), and ADB during the updating of the RP and prior to
the conduct of the detailed measurement survey (DMS).
h. Shop owners will be assisted in gradually dismantling and setting up their shops in a
new location to be agreed with the Provincial Resettlement Sub-committee-Working
Group (PRSC-WG) in the residual area of the ROW and in a way that will allow them
to gradually phase out their operation in their present location place and gradually
begin their operation in their new place. Under this arrangement, disruption in the
operation of shop owners will be minimized, thereby averting severe impact on the
AHs’ livelihood.
i. People presently cultivating plots inside the ROW will be allowed to continue
cultivating the residual area of their cultivated plots in the ROW, if there is any. If
during RP updating it is determined that the loss of these farmers is equivalent to 10%
or more of their total livelihood or income from various sources, the PRSC-WG will
assist in finding an affordable replacement land with similar productive attributes for
the farmers to lease.
j. Temporarily affected land and communal infrastructure will be restored to pre-project
conditions.
k. Project stakeholders, especially AHs, will be consulted and given the opportunity to
participate in matters that will have adverse impacts on their lives during the design,
implementation and operation of the Project.
l. Any acquisition of, or restriction on access to, resources owned or managed by the
AHs as a common property, e.g., communal forest, communal farm, will be mitigated
by arrangements that will ensure access of those AHs to equivalent resources on a
continuing basis. Similarly, temporarily affected land and communal infrastructure will
be restored to pre-Project conditions.
m. Plans for the acquisition of land and other assets will be carried out in consultation
with the AHs who will receive prior information of the compensation, relocation and
other assistance available to them.
n. There shall be an effective mechanism for hearing and resolving grievances during
the planning, updating and implementation of the RP.
o. Existing cultural and religious practices shall be respected and, to the extent possible,
preserved.
p. Special measures will be incorporated in the RP to protect socially and economically
vulnerable groups who face greater risk of further hardship. These vulnerable groups
include women-headed households, households headed by persons with disabilities,
landless households, children and elderly people without support structures, and
people living below poverty line. Appropriate assistance will be provided to help AHs
belonging to any of these vulnerable groups improve their socio-economic status.
q. Adequate resources will be identified and committed during the preparation of the RP.
This includes sufficient budgetary support that is fully committed and made available
54
55
to cover resettlement costs within the agreed implementation period; and, adequate
human resources for supervision, liaison and monitoring of land acquisition,
resettlement and rehabilitation activities.
r. Appropriate reporting, monitoring and evaluation mechanisms will be identified and
set in place as part of the resettlement management system.
s. The RP or its summary will be translated in Khmer and placed in district and
commune offices for the information of the AHs as well as other interested groups.
t. Civil works contractors will not be issued notice of possession or notice to proceed
(NTP) for any section or segment of the Project roads until (i) compensation has been
satisfactorily completed for that area; (ii) agreed rehabilitation measures are in place;
and (iii) the area is free from all encumbrances. The schedule of the start of civil
works in any section or segment of the Project road will be coordinated and planned
with the PRSC-WG whose members include male and women representatives of the
AHs.
C. Entitlements
110. For purposes of this resettlement plan (RP), the cut-off date coincides with the date the
IOL was held which was preceded by a public meeting in the districts during which MPWT
representatives and TA consultants briefed local officials and residents about the project, the
compensation policy and the need to conduct the IOL, including the policy regarding cut-off date.
The IOL in PR 314D and NR13 was carried out in on 20 May 2011 – 2 June 2011. The list of AHs
will be updated and/or validated during the DMS following approval by project authorities of the
project feasibility study. The Inter-ministerial Resettlement Committee (IRC), the government
body that is tasked to spearhead the conduct of the DMS and the implementation of the RP, will
confirm the final date of the cut-off-date.
111. Based on the impacts identified during the IOL, the corresponding entitlements to be
provided to the AHs are presented in the entitlement matrix below. It should be noted that these
entitlements may be enhanced, as necessary, following the conduct of the DMS during RP in
consultation with the AHs to ensure that their livelihoods are restored, if not improved
56
57
Higher risks of Loss of house Vulnerable One time assistance allowance of $100 per
hardship due to and shops, Groups: AHs household.
project impacts paddy land belonging to Participate in income restoration program
within the ROW one or more of
the following
vulnerable
groups: (i)
living below the
poverty line; (ii)
AHs headed by
women and
AHs headed by
the elderly with
no social
support; and
(iii) households
that are
headed by
persons with
disabilities;
Impacts during Contractors will be responsible for paying rental in
Construction cash for land outside the ROW which will be not less
than the net income that would have been derived
from the affected property during disruption.
Restoration of land within 3 months after use.
Non-land assets within the residual area of the ROW
and/or outside of the ROW that are adversely
impacted by construction activities will be
compensated at replacement cost by the civil works
contractor.
58
59
112. The Project includes the following specific actions to address gender issues in the Project:
113. As discusses in the preceding sections, on top of the compensation and applicable
allowance that vulnerable AHs will receive for their losses as provided in the entitlement matrix,
vulnerable AH, AHs are entitled to participate in the income restoration that will be designed with
their active involvement.
114. The project will foster full participation of vulnerable households in meaningful
consultations so that they are able to participate in decisions which affect them.
F. Unforeseen Impacts
115. If during the DMS, additional adverse social impacts are identified and/or additional AHs
are found, these persons and households are entitled to receive Project entitlements as the
others on condition that it can be ascertained that they have actually been in the Project ROW
even before 20-15 May 2011 in 314D and on 26 May to 2 June 2011 in NR13, the cut-off date for
eligibility8. New AHs that will emerge due to changes in Project design or alignment prior to or
even during construction works are likewise entitled to the same entitlements as those of the
other AHs.
A. Relocation Strategy
116. The PRSC-WG will endeavor to ensure minimal disruption in the livelihood activities of
the owners of the 103 entirely affected independent shops (i.e., 45 in 314D, 1 in the CBF, and 57
in NR13); the 74 partially affected independent shops (i.e., 17 in 314D and 57 in NR13); the 3
entirely affected house-and-stores (i.e., 2 in 314D and 1 at the CBF); and 10 partially-affected
8
To be confirmed by the IRC.
60
house-and-stores (i.e., 7 in 314D and 3 in NR13). Through the PRSC-WG the shop owners
will be informed regarding the schedule of civil works in a specific section of 314D and NR13 at
least 3 months in advance.
117. All AHs affected by the entire loss of their houses and shops can move behind the
residual area of the ROW. If it is not possible for the AH to rebuild behind where their affected
structures presently stand, the PRSC-WG, in consultation and with the active participation of the
AHs, will look for a place elsewhere in the ROW outside of the COI. The shifting of entirely
affected shops will be done in a way that will allow the AHs to gradually phase out their operation
in their present location and gradually begin their operation in their new place. Under this
arrangement, the shop owners, whose business caters greatly to road users, will not experience
total disruption in their operation.
B. Temporary Impacts
118. To ensure that temporary impacts during construction will be avoided, if not minimized,
the contract for civil works will include the following provisions: (a) contractor to pay rent for any
land required for construction work space outside the ROW; (b) to the extent possible, only idle
land will be used as construction work space to avoid disruption to households and business
establishments; and (c) temporary use of land will be restored or improved to its pre-Project
condition. The PMU3, assisted by the PRSC, will review any written agreement with the AHs,
payment records, and disbursement of payment to ensure proper monitoring and compliance
with the Project resettlement policy. Said monitoring will be included in the quarterly progress
reports of the PMU3 to be submitted to MPWT and the ADB.
A. General Provisions
119. An income restoration program (IRP) will be planned and developed with the assistance
of community development specialists to be hired by IRC for the purpose. While those who are
entitled to participate in program include AHs affected by the loss of entire shops, it is not
expected that the Project will severely disrupt the business operation of shop owners. Therefore,
the focus of the IRP is more on helping the poor and other vulnerable AHs improve their
situation. For this purpose, the IRP will be designed during the updating of the RP and will be
implemented in parallel with the implementation of the RP with the active involvement of the
participating AHs.
120. The IRP will be geared towards helping the participating AHs produce for their basic
needs within one years. This will be accomplished by helping them find ways to (a) maximize the
use of their remaining lands for food production (rice and vegetables), (b) engage in fast-return
and short-cycle backyard livestock production, and (c) find work in urban areas. The IRP strategy
puts emphasis on food production, aware of the fact that the AHs are mostly, if not all, farmers
and that production in the project area is basically for home consumption. Farm production will
be augmented by small-scale, short-cycle livestock production on the remaining lands of the
AHs. This activity is intended to provide both food and cash to the AHs. It is also intended to
provide livelihood to members of the AHs who are no longer able to seek employment in
factories and shops in urban areas, such as the elderly. In addition to the two activities, members
of the AHs that are within the working age (15 to 60 years old) will be provided training, as
needed, and referred to establishments in need of workers. This component of the strategy is
also intended to bring in cash for the other basic needs of the AHs.
60
61
121. For purposes of budgeting, and assuming that there is not double counting9, a total of 536
AHs are entitled to participate in the IRP. A provisional sum is allocated in the resettlement
budget to finance the various components of the IRP, notably, training in food production, seed
capital for home-based livestock and food production, and training for job placement. The
allocated amount for each AH will not be given to the household but will be used as a block fund
to support the various components of the program. The specific implementation mechanism for
the use of the IRP funds will be spelled out in the planning of the program. Therefore, the block
fund that will be put up for the 536 AHs is $160,800.
124. Owners of unregistered independent shops and house-and-stores that are entirely
affected are each entitled to receive one-time cash assistance (allowance) of $50 for loss of
income. None of the owners of entirely affected shops claimed to be registered.10 In all, $2,350
is allocated for 314D for income loss allowance, while $100 is allocated for the CBF, and $2,850
for NR13.
9
Some of the AHs in the vulnerable groups could also be among those losing entire houses and shops.
10
If during the DMS, registered entirely affected shops are found, owners of the same will be provided
income loss allowance equivalent to the daily net income (as reflected in tax receipts) multiplied by the
days of business disruption.
62
125. Funds for the implementation of the RP are part of the Project budget. Costs have been
estimated based on results of the IOL and the RCS as of July 2011.
126. The IRC will request the MEF for the funds to implement the RP. The funds will be
forwarded to the Provincial Department of Finance. Payment vouchers will be prepared at the
RD-MEF for submission to and approval by the IRC. Funds for compensation and other
entitlements will be forwarded by the Provincial Department of Finance to the PRSC for
disbursement. Payment of compensation and other entitlements, except for land-for-land
arrangements, will be in cash and will be given in commune offices. The AHs will be notified
through the village chiefs of the schedule of payment of compensation and other entitlements.
127. Implementation costs cover payment of allowances and per diem of concerned personnel
involved in the updating and implementation of the RP, including members of the provincial and
district resettlement working groups. Administrative costs and contingencies amounting to 15%
each have been added on top of the cost of resettlement. MPWT and IRC will ensure that
adequate funds are made available as and when necessary for the efficient and timely
implementation of resettlement.
128. The estimated cost of resettlement is US$1,380,966.58, inclusive of the cost for hiring an
external monitoring agency. Table XI.1 provides a breakdown of these costs.
62
63
Rate AMOUNT
Items Unit Quantity
($/Unit) (US$)
Fence LM 35,152.80 varied 59,754.95
Shed m² 240.0 varied 3,996.20
Assorted other structures - - varied 71,071.79
Sub-Total 1 806,926.29
ALLOWANCES AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS
@
Transportation allowance for relocating house and shops AH 151 $50 7,550.00
Transportation allowance for 6 relocating house/shop
AH 6 $50 300.00
renters
One time assistance allowance for relocating house * AH 48 200 9,600.00
One time assistance allowance for relocating independent
AH 103 100 10,300.00
shops *
Income loss allowance for relocating shop, house/shop AH 106 $50 5,300.00
Rental allowance for relocating renters of house/store AH 6 $33 198.00
&
One time assistance allowance for vulnerable AHs AH 90 100 9,000.00
Income restoration program (IRP) block fund 536 $300 160,800.00
Sub-Total 2 203,048.00
External Monitoring/Evaluation Lump sum 68,000.00
TOTAL DIRECT COSTS 1,009,974.29
Administrative Cost (15%) 151,496.14
Costs contingencies (15%) 151,496.14
GRAND TOTAL (rounded) 1,380,966.58
* Based on the assumption that all those entitled will relocated outside ROW. The number of AHs relocating in or
outside the ROW will be determined during DMS
&
The precise number of vulnerable AHs will be determined during updating of the resettlement plan
@
The unit rate for transportation allowance used above is an estimated average. The precise entitlements per
household will be determined during updating of the resettlement plan depending on type of impact and where they
relocate to.
129. Additional resources will also be provided by the Project to prepare and implement the
updated resettlement plan which are costed elsewhere in the overall Project budget. These
include:
a. Dedicated officers within the Social and Environment Unit of the PMU including
resettlement, gender and social specialists.
131. The owner of the project is MPWT, the Executing Agency; therefore, it has over-all
responsibility for the successful implementation of the RP. MPWT will be assisted by a number
of offices within and outside the Ministry, starting with the Project Management Unit 3 (PMU3)
that is tasked with undertaking the Project. With assistance from the ESO of MPWT, the PMU3
will work closely with the Resettlement Department of the Inter-ministerial Resettlement
Committee (RD-IRC) relative to the preparation, updating, and implementation of the RP.
132. The Environmental and Social Office (ESO)11, under the Department of Planning of
MPWT is the lead arm of the PMU3 in the preparation and implementation of the RP. The ESO
presently has 9 staff, with plans to get 3 additional persons from other units of the Ministry. The
staff members of the ESO work for both resettlement and environmental tasks. However, while
all of them claim to be familiar with the conduct of socioeconomic survey, only 3 claim to know
how to do the inventor of losses. None of the staff has the capacity to write an RP. For this reason,
the project supervision consultants should prepare a training program for the staff of ESO in
connection with the preparation, implementation, and monitoring of the RP.
133. The ESO will work closely with the IRC and Resettlement Department at the Ministry of
Economy and Finance (RD-MEF). Its tasks include the following:
a. Secure the approval of the RP by the IRC;
b. Secure prior approval by IRC and the ADB for any variations in the approved RP;
c. Secure the data base of affected persons and assets that will be gathered during
the preparation and updating of the RP;
d. Prepare progress reports on RP implementation for submission to the MPWT and
PMU3.
134. The IRC is a collegial body composed of representatives from concerned line ministries,
such as the Council of Ministers (COM); the MPWT; and the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and
Fisheries (MAFF), including representatives of the Municipality of Phnom Penh, the Governor
and Deputy Governor of provinces traversed by the Project road. Created by the Prime Minister
through Decision No. 13, dated 18 March 1997, in connection with the resettlement of APs in the
Highway 1 Project (Loan 1659-CAM), it has since been involved in other foreign-assisted
government infrastructure projects with involuntary resettlement.
135. The IRC will assume the function of a quasi-regulatory body, ensuring that funds for
resettlement are spent properly and that the RP is carried out as intended. The technical arm of
the IRC is RD-MEF. The RD-MEF will assist IRC in the following tasks:
11
Formerly the Social and Environmental Unit (SEU)
64
65
a. Reviewing and approving the RP, ensuring that the RP is consistent with ADB’s
2009 Safeguard Policy Statement (SPS) and, later, the loan agreement;
b. Endorsing the approved RP to ADB;
c. Establishing or convening the Provincial Resettlement Committee (PRSC) and its
Working Group (WG);
d. Orienting, as needed, the PRSC and its working group (PRSC-WG) on their tasks
relative to RP updating and implementation;
e. Securing from the national treasury the budget for carrying out the RP, ensuring
that funds are available in a timely manner and in sufficient amounts;
f. Approving all disbursements connected with the implementation of the RP, such
as payment of compensation and other entitlements, acquisition and preparation
of replacement plots, operational expenses of personnel, etc.;
g. Ensuring that funds for resettlement are spent judiciously; and
h. With assistance from an independent organization, monitoring the implementation
of the RP, ensuring that this is carried out in compliance with the Project
resettlement policy and with the loan agreement.
C. Provincial Resettlement Sub-committee
136. The Provincial Resettlement Sub-Committee (PRSC) is a collegial body at the provincial
level. Headed by the Provincial Deputy Governor, the members of the PRSC are provincial
department directors of line ministries represented in the IRC, and also the chiefs of the districts
and communes traversed by the Project road.
137. The technical arm of the PRSC is the Working Group (PRSC-WG). The PRSC-WG is
headed by the Director (or a representative) of the Provincial Department of Public Works and
Transport (PDPWT). The regular members of the PRSC-WG come from the Provincial
Government, Provincial Department of Economy and Finance (MDEF), and the Ministry of
Interior. The PRSC-WG has a counterpart at the district level composed of personnel from
various line agencies.
138. In an effort to make the whole process of resettlement effective, participatory and
transparent, the chiefs of the affected communes and villages, and a male and female
representative each of the APs in affected communes will seat in the district RSC-WG in matters
concerning their respective areas of jurisdiction.
139. The PRSC, through the provincial and district working groups, will have the following
functions:
a. Facilitate a sustained public information campaign, ensuring that the public,
especially the AHs, are updated on any developments regarding the Project and
resettlement activities;
b. Spearhead the DMS and updated census of APs, including the updating of the
rates used in calculating compensation and other entitlements to reflect prevailing
market rates at the time of compensation;
c. Spearhead the selection, acquisition, and preparation of replacement plots,
including the preparation of a coordinated schedule of delivery of compensation
66
and other entitlements, the relocation of people, harvesting of standing crops, and
the start of civil works in a particular section of the Project road sections;
d. Spearhead the delivery of compensation and other entitlements to the AHs;
e. Receive and act on the complaints and grievances of AHs in accordance with the
Project resettlement policy; and
f. Maintain a record of all public meetings, grievances, and actions taken to address
complaints and grievances.
D. Project Supervision Consultants
140. The Project Supervision Consultants (PSC), together with the ESO and the PRSC-WG,
will spearhead the updating of the RP through the conduct of the DMS in a participatory and
transparent way and consistent with the Project resettlement policy. Once approved by the IRC
and MPWT and concurred in by ADB, the PSC will provide technical advice in the
implementation of the approved RP. The PSC will likewise provide capacity-building orientation
and skills training, as needed, to concerned personnel of the PMU3, the ESO, and the Provincial
and District Working Groups.
141. Together with the PMU3 and ESO, the PSC will supervise civil works activities to ensure
that the contractors adhere with the terms of their contract relative to avoiding and/or minimizing
resettlement impacts, in addition to ensuring that contractors provide the necessary
compensation and/or assistance to the AHs prior to and/or during construction activities.
142. The PSC will have one international resettlement specialist (6 months, intermittent), a
local resettlement specialist (12 months, intermittent), a local livelihood specialist (6 months,
intermittent), and a local gender specialist (3 months, intermittent).
66
67
146. A new socio-economic survey will be carried out if RP updating does not commence
within two years as demographic and socio-economic factors may change significantly within
that period. It will cover at least 20% of severely affected AHs and at least 10% of other AHs
losing main structures and productive assets.
147. The table below summarizes the various inter-related activities connected with the
updating and implementation of the RP.
148. The ESO of MPWT and the IRC, through the Resettlement Department at the Ministry of
Economy and Finance (RD-MEF), will conduct regular monitoring and evaluation of the updating
and implementation of the RP. Said monitoring and evaluation is intended to help ensure that
the RP is prepared according to the resettlement policy and that it is implemented as planned.
The ESO is Government’s in-house monitoring body, while the RD-MEF, which will hire an
independent organization, will be the Project’s external monitor.
150. The IRC will hire an independent organization to carry out external monitoring and
post-implementation evaluation. The IRC will prepare the terms of reference (TOR) for this
purpose. The TOR of the external monitoring organization (EMO) and the selection of the monitor
will require the prior consent of ADB. The EMO will provide RD-MEF and ADB a copy of its
semi-annual monitoring reports. The EMO will likewise conduct a Post-RP Implementation
Evaluation Study one (1) year following the completion of resettlement.
68
Appendix 1
INVENTORY OF LOSSES
INSTRUCTION: To be accomplished for all persons/households with affected assets (i.e., structures,
crops, trees, and land located within 10 meters from the centerline of the roadway or carriageway).
A.2 If renting or occupying the affected land with permission from owner:
With Lease Agreement (Renting) With permission (not
Amount of rental Address/Location of Land Owner paying rent)Check the
Name of Land Owner box below
fee (Indicate in US$)
1.
2.
B. Relocation options for AHs losing entire (totally) house or building: (Check the appropriate box)
Construct on remaining land in Relocate to other landholdings Landless (Relocate to
Relocation options the ROW of the AH government relocation site)
__________________________
____________________
Name and Signature of AH or Representative Relationship with the
AH
____________________________
Name and Signature of Enumerator Date accomplished:________________
70
Appendix 1
IV. Sketch of affected land and relative location of other assets found thereat:
10 m COI
10 m COI
Appendix 2
1. Introduction
1. This report is to present the survey results of the Study of Replacement Cost for provincial
roads improvement project, Southeast NR314D, NR 13 and Midwest NR150B, NR53 and
NR151B, funded by ADB TA 7665-CAM.
2. Data collection for this study was conducted from 21 May 2011 to 01 July 2011 for
Southeast section and from 06 July to 13 July 2011 for section Midwest.
3. The study is to establish compensation rates for structures, trees, and other non-land
based income (e.g., businesses, fishponds, etc.). The aim is to ensure full restoration value of
the affected/expropriated assets by the Project.
3. Survey Methodology
4. In order to achieve the above research objectives, the study required detailed
preparations. First, it was necessary be become familiar with legal framework and associated
resettlement and compensation issues in Cambodia. This was done during the first days of
research planning.
5. Next, all available literature related to replacement cost study, and more particularly,
resettlement and replacement cost study of road improvement projects.
6. The information gathering at the field for the calculation of replacement cost in the project
area are as follows:
7. Field data survey including measurement of affected stall and houses along the project
road. Categories of houses are classified based on the roofing material and its sub-categories
also were classified for those houses with similar material and price in average.
72
Appendix 2
8. Throughout Cambodia it is very common to see people lives on and uses the land within
the right of way (ROW) of a highway or road. Since we have full peace in Cambodia, 1993, the
government never publicly claimed the land located within the later announced ROW, average
Cambodians moved into the ROW zone, cultivating, operating business, building stores and
houses.
9. The 1993 Constitution of Cambodia states that the “right to confiscate properties from any
person shall be exercised only in the public interest as provided by law and shall require fair and
just compensation in advance” (Article 44).
10. The Land Law of 2001 (NS/RKM/0801/14, 20 July 2001) governs land and property rights
in Cambodia. Based on the provisions of the 1993 Constitution, it determines the regime of
ownership of immovable properties that are defined as including land, trees and immovable
structures.
11. The rights and responsibilities of the Royal Government of Cambodia (RGC) with respect
to eminent domain are specified in the Land Law. The RGC can acquire private land (i) for public
purposes under condition of (ii) fair and just compensation, (iii) paid in advance. The Land Law,
Article 5, states:
“No person may be deprived of his ownership, unless it is in the public interest. An
ownership deprivation shall be carried out in accordance with the forms and
procedures provided by law and regulations and after the payment of fair and just
compensation in advance.”
12. There are other provisions of the Land Law that are relevant to land acquisition,
compensation and resettlement. The key provisions are indicated below:
(i) Legal possession as defined by the Law is the sole basis for ownership, and all
transfers or changes of rights of ownership shall be carried out in accordance with
the required general rules for sale, succession, exchange and gift or by court
decision. (Article 6)
(ii) Any regime of ownership of immovable property prior to 1979 shall not be
recognized. (Article 7)
(iii) State public land includes, among other categories, any property that is made
available for public use such as roads. (Article 15)
(iv) Persons that illegally occupy, possess or claim title to state public land cannot
claim any compensation. This includes land established by the RGC as public
rights-of-way (ROW) for roads and railways. Moreover, failure to vacate illegally
occupied land in a timely manner is subject to expel. (Article 19)
73
Appendix 2
(v) Persons with legally valid possession of land for five years (at the time the law
came into effect) are allowed to register as the owner of the land (Article 30).
Persons who (at the time the law came into effect) held legal possession but had
not yet completed the five years were allowed to remain in possession until they
were eligible to be registered as the owner. (Article 31)
(vi) However, temporary possession claims made by persons after the law comes into
effect will not be recognized, rescinding a previous right under the 1992 Land Law
for acquiring land by taking possession. (Articles 29, 34)
(vii) Landless people may apply for land for residential and subsistence farming
purposes at no cost, as part of a social land concessions scheme. The
concessionaire may obtain ownership of this land after fulfilling conditions set out
in a separate Sub-Decree on Social Land Concessions. (Articles 50, 51)
13. The RGC Prakas No. 6, “Measures to Crack Down on Anarchic Land Grabbing and
Encroachment” (No. 06 BRK, 27 September 1999) prohibits private ownership of State lands,
including land adjacent to roads and railways. The Prakas establishes rights-of-way (ROW) for
2-digit national roads such as NR33 of 25 metres from the centerline. Ministry of Economy and
Finance (MEF) Decree No. 961 (2000) declares that, in order to implement Prakas No. 6, the
RGC will not pay compensation to people who occupy the ROW, for any structures or assets
located on the land.
5 ADB Policy
14. The objectives of the ADB Policy on Involuntary Resettlement (1995) and as refined in
the New Safeguard Policy Statement (June 2009) are (i) to avoid impacts on people and the
environment, where possible; (ii) where avoidance is not possible, minimize, mitigate, or
compensate for adverse project impacts on the environment and the affected people; and (iii) help
the executing agency strengthen its safeguard system. Towards this end, ADB resettlement
policy includes the following principles:
m. Screen the project early on to identify past, present, and future involuntary
resettlement impacts and risks. Determine the scope of resettlement planning
through a survey and/or census of affected persons, including a gender analysis,
specifically related to resettlement impacts and risks.
n. Improve, or at least restore, the livelihoods of all affected persons through (i)
land-based resettlement strategies when affected livelihoods are land based
74
Appendix 2
where possible or cash compensation at replacement value for land when the loss
of land does not undermine livelihoods, (ii) prompt replacement of assets with
access to assets of equal or higher value, (iii) prompt compensation at full
replacement cost for assets that cannot be restored, and (iv) additional revenues
and services through benefit sharing schemes where possible.
p. Improve the standards of living of the affected poor and other vulnerable groups,
including women, to at least national minimum standards. In rural areas provide
them with legal and affordable access to land and resources, and in urban areas
provide them with appropriate income sources and legal and affordable access to
adequate housing.
r. Ensure that affected persons without titles to land or any recognizable legal rights
to land are eligible for resettlement assistance and compensation for loss of
non-land assets.
75
Appendix 2
15. The objective of ADB Policy on Indigenous Peoples (1998) and as refined in the New
Safeguard Policy Statement (June 2009) is to design and implement projects in a way that fosters
full respect for Indigenous Peoples’ identity, dignity, human rights, livelihood systems, and
cultural uniqueness as defined by the Indigenous Peoples themselves so that they (i) receive
culturally appropriate social and economic benefits, (ii) do not suffer adverse impacts as a result
of projects, and (iii) can participate actively in projects that affect them.
16. The ADB Policy on Gender and Development (ADB, 2006; ADB, 1998) adopts gender
mainstreaming as a key strategy for promoting gender equity, and for ensuring that women
participate in and that their needs are explicitly addressed in the decision-making process for
development activities. For projects that have the potential to have substantial gender impacts, a
gender plan is prepared to identify strategies to address gender concerns and the involvement of
women in the design, implementation and monitoring of the project.
17. However, since this project has minor negative impact on vendors at the above project area
and the demolishment was done before the project study, the report of losses assessment has been
required for the project based on the ADB safeguard policy rather than a resettlement plan.
6.1 Material Used for Shop Construction, Stall, House and Fence
18. To assess the loss of structures of both in this study, consultant will use the market rate
from construction shop seller in the area as basis to estimate the impact. Hence compensation to
affected people will reflect market rate.
19. In order to produce the table of materials for structures, the consultant interview
construction shops along the project road that supply to people living in the area. An average of
construction material was produced provided the assumption that people may buy construction
material from different sources.
20. This study will produce two separate replacement cost tables for different geographic area
and distance of transportation of construction materials. First table will be for Southeast section
and second table is for Midwest section.
Table 6.1: Price of Construction Material along the Project Road- SOUTHEAST
Average for RCS
Item Description Qty Unit 2011 from Survey
A CEMENT
1 Elephant cement (Big) 1 ton
2 Elephant cement (Small) 1 ton
3 Diamond cement 1 ton 99.76
4 Camel cement 1 ton
5 Mountain cement 1 ton
76
Appendix 2
77
Appendix 2
Table 6.2: Price of Construction Material along the Project Road (Midwest)
Average for RCS
Item Description Qty Unit 2011 from Survey
A CEMENT
1 Elephant cement (Big) 1 ton
2 Elephant cement (Small) 1 ton
3 Diamond cement 1 ton
95.58
4 Camel cement 1 ton
5 Mountain cement 1 ton
6 Dragon Cement 1 ton
B STEEL
1 Vietnam brand name Ø6,8 1 kg 0.89
2 Vietnam brand name Ø10 1 d 5.69
3 Vietnam Ø12, 14, 16 or 18mm 1 d 8.13
4 Steel Net 1 kg 1.30
C PLYWOOD FOR HOUSE PARTITION 1
1 Paper plywood 1 piece 5.75
2 3mm plywood 1 piece 6.63
3 5mm plywood 1 piece 8.13
D FLOORING
1 Chinese floor tile with low quality 1 m2 3.75
2 Chinese tile for wall 200x300 1 m2 3.63
3 Chinese tile for wall 250x400 1 m2 4.50
4 Chinese floor tile for bathroom 1 m2 4.88
78
Appendix 2
79
Appendix 2
21. The affected structures in the project area can be physically identified and classified into
stall, shop, fence, house and other structures.
22. Below is the summary list of cost calculation for stall and shop with above market survey
rate. The shops, stall and house of type 1 cannot compensate for setback labor since the moving
of structure may damage to material and some of them cannot re-use. It is suggested that these
type 1 structures shall be compensated at full market price.
Unit
Type Wall Column Floor No. of Floor Cost
($/m2)
STALL, SHOP AND HOUSE
1A No wall Small pole for Use soil as floor Single 3.90
supporting roof
structure
1B No wall Small pole or used Used wood or Single: 0.3m-0.6m 5.84
wood bamboo with small higher than natural
wood or bamboo soil
structure, higher
1. Thatch/Leave Roof
1D Used metal with Pole or used wood Used wood or Single: 0.3m-1.2m 9.29
used wood or bamboo with small higher than natural
mixed temporary wood or bamboo soil
materials structure, higher
from soil about
0.3m-1.2m
1E Earth wall Pole or used wood Use soil as floor Single 6.28
80
Appendix 2
Unit
Type Wall Column Floor No. of Floor Cost
($/m2)
1F Thatch/ Leaves/ Pole or used wood Lean Concrete Single 13.78
plastic, or mixed
temporary materials
2D Earth wall with Pole or used wood or Used wood or Single: 0.3m-1.2m 10.11
some temporary low quality wood bamboo with small higher than natural
wall material such wood or bamboo soil
as metal sheet, structure, higher
wood, thatch, from soil about
plastic. 0.3m-1.2m
2E Wood wall with Pole or used wood or Used wood or Single: 0.3m-1.2m 18.48
temporary material low quality wood bamboo with small higher than natural
less than 10% wood or bamboo soil
structure, higher
from soil about
0.3m-1.2m
2F Metal wall Pole or used wood or Use soil as floor Single 10.04
low quality wood
2G Thatch wall Pole or used wood or Used wood or Single: 0.3m-1.2m 10.08
low quality wood bamboo with small higher than natural
wood or bamboo soil
structure, higher
from soil about
0.3m-1.2m
2H Thatch wall Pole or used wood or Used wood or Single: 1.2m-2.5m 10.90
low quality wood bamboo with small higher than natural
wood or bamboo soil
structure, higher
from soil about
1.2m-2.5m
2I Wood wall at first Wood column with Wood floor (house Single: 1.2m-2.5m 42.45
floor and only concrete support on still), ground higher than natural
column at ground 0.60m floor can be used soil
floor for other purpose,
not higher than
2.5m
2J Brick wall with Concrete column Concrete floor Single 33.66
plastering 20cm x 20cm
81
Appendix 2
Unit
Type Wall Column Floor No. of Floor Cost
($/m2)
2K Brick wall for Hardwood columns Tile at ground floor Two stories: Ground 66.64
ground floor and and wooden floor floor with tile and first
wood wall for first with wood structure floor with wood plank
floor at first floor
3B Wood wall at first Wood column with Wood floor (house Single: 1.2m-2.5m 59.89
floor and only concrete support on still), ground higher than natural
3. Tile Roof
4A Brick wall Concrete column Ground floor and One story plus half 102.45
with foundation mezzanine (half floor with concrete
floor) slab (compensation
4. Concrete
23. In order to establish market price of fence and gate, construction material from above
table and local contractor were interviewed and use as basis for the calculation.
F1 Loose Fence (palm leave, bamboo, small 1 LM 0.95 Some of the materials used not
wooden bar or mix of available local available in the market. In this
material) case labor cost will be estimated
for the calculation
F2 Wooden post with bamboo rebar or wire 1 LM 1.43
F3 Concrete column with its foundation, ground 1 LM 14.36 In case there is no foundation, it is
beam of 20cmx20cm; 2meters interval; no suggested to compensate per
82
Appendix 2
25. The methodology to calculate the cost of other structure and non structure also based on
the interview with local people for their knowledge, labor cost together with price list from
construction material shops.
83
Appendix 2
26. Since the world economic downturn in late 2008, land price market in Cambodia is stable
and has little sign of going up. From interview with local people, village chief and other property
owner, the real estate sector in Cambodia is being recovered back especially in the area where
development activities are planned i.e border between Cambodia-Vietnam (NR314D). Up to now
there is no transaction in the study area, according to commune chief in Svay Rieng.
27. According to the data collection the price of land can be summarized as below table.
Definition of land category are as following:
a. Commercial Land: Land near National Road Number 1 (near junction of NR1 and
NR314D) and land near border with Vietnam.
b. Resident-cum-commercial land: refer to land or house serves as living and also
doing business i.e near market or build-up area in rural, mostly at district level.
c. Residential land: land along the study road where village is located or vacant land
within the village area.
d. Agriculture land: land for doing agriculture purpose along road project.
e. Forest land: land that is far from village and is chiefly covered with small trees and
undergrowth.
84
Appendix 2
28. Crop and tree were calculated based on harvesting yield and maturity time of different tree
species interviewed with local people in the area. According to compensation experience of IRC
in previous project tree below 3 years get 1/3 of full mature cost, 3 to 5 year compensate 2/3 of full
mature cost and 5 years over compensate with full yield cost.
85
Appendix 2
29. The Midwest section of this study combines three road sections, NR150B, NR53 and
NR151B. Type of structures along these sections is not very much different. They can be
classified into types and category12 as in below table. All structures are classified into four
categories in which each category has different types.
12
The structure’s category and type in this study is not equivalence to same category in other study (in
Southeast Section).
86
Appendix 2
Unit
Type Wall Column Floor No. of Floor Cost
($/m2)
1d Used wood/ wood Pole or used wood Concrete floor Single 12.06
with thatch (10-15%
of total wall area)
2a No (selling stall on Pole No: use soil as floor Single 6.68
ROW)
2b Thatch/ thatch and Pole/ wood - Bamboo/ used Single 12.10
used wood wood:
(15-20%) 0.3m-0.6m high
from ground
- Concrete floor:
on compacted
ground
2c Metal Pole/ wood Concrete floor on Single 14.77
compacted land/
raised land of less
than 20cm high
2d Wood/ Brick with no Pole/ wood Concrete floor on Single 15.06
2. Metal/ Fiber Cement Roof
87
Appendix 2
Unit
Type Wall Column Floor No. of Floor Cost
($/m2)
3b Wood plank with - Concrete from Wood with wooden Single: 49.85
wooden structure ground structure House-on-still;
- Wood on first floor Ground floor is soil;
more than 2.0 -2.5
meters high
4a Brick wall Concrete column Ground floor and One story plus half 99.75
with foundation mezzanine (half floor with concrete
floor) slab (compensation
rate for this type is
4. Concrete
based on every
affected floor area)
4b Brick wall Concrete column Ground floor, Multiple stories 140.96
with foundation mezzanine, first house (compensation
floor and possibility rate for this type is
of additional floor based on every
house affected floor area)
30. The road project will need to remove some property fences of different classification.
Material chosen will alter the cost of building a fence and gate. Below costing the summary table
of fence and gate based on market rate of construction material available in the project area.
f1 Loose Fence (palm leave, bamboo, small 1 LM 0.83 Some of the materials used not
wooden bar or mix of available local available in the market. In this
material) case labor cost will be estimated
for the calculation
f2 Wooden post with bamboo rebar or wood 1 LM 1.78
rebar
f3 Concrete post 1.5meter interval, 1.5 meter 1 LM 4.52
high with 8 horizontal wire
f4 Concrete post 2meter interval; brick wall at 1 LM 12.20
lower part with plastering both sides of
about 60-80cm; 2 meters high (from
ground) with wire or wire mesh; brick wall
at lower part 0.3m-0.6m high
f5 Concrete Post with plastering brick wall; 1 LM 34.20 Ventilation brick in some as part of
1.6m-2.0m high; 3.5m-4.0m interval brick wall also classified in same
type
f6 Concrete column with plastering brick wall 1 LM 61.15
of 20cm; 1.8m-2.2m high; 3.5m-4.0m
interval; decorative concrete baluster and
decoration capital
B GATE
88
Appendix 2
31. To get the cost of this structure it is also based on the interview with local people for their
knowledge, labor cost together with price list from construction material shops.
32. The land market in Cambodia has very little sign of going up in urban area. From interview
with local people, village chief and other property owner the land in rural area has no activity at all
since the down turn of world economic. Up to now there is no transaction in the study area,
according to commune chief along the project influence area.
89
Appendix 2
33. According to the data collection (from group discussion and interview with commune chief)
the price of land was calculated based on its category. Definition of land category are as following:
a. Commercial Land: Land near National Road Number 5 (near junction of NR5 and
NR150B; NR150B and NR53).
b. Resident-cum-commercial land: refer to land or house serves as living and also
doing business i.e near market or build-up area in rural, mostly at district level.
c. Residential land: land along the study road where village is located or vacant land
within the village area.
d. Agriculture land: land for doing agriculture purpose along road project.
e. Forest land: land that is far from village and is chiefly covered with small trees and
undergrowth.
34. Except from junction of NR5 and NR150B to riverside, the rest of national roads are pass
through similar category of land i.e. residential, agriculture and forestland. The average cost of
land can be summarized in below table.
35. In order to simplify the study, trees have been classified in three types as following:
a. Sapling- below one year: will not get compensation as it can be re-planted,
b. Small tree- one to three year: 1/3 of full price,
c. Young tree- bearing some fruit: 2/3 of full price,
d. Mature- full bearing tree: compensate full price.
36. From the survey, full compensation cost of trees is calculated and summary in below
table:
90
Appendix 2
37. The compensation of the affected structure will be calculated based on the affected floor
area at market price for every development projects in Cambodia. During IOL survey it is found
that:
91
Appendix 2
92
Appendix 3
93
Appendix 3
94
Appendix 3
95
Appendix 3
96
Appendix 3
97
Appendix 3
98
Appendix 3
99
Appendix 3
100
Appendix 3
101
Appendix 3
102
Appendix 3
103
Appendix 3
104
Appendix 3
105
Appendix 3
106
Appendix 3
107
Appendix 3
108
Appendix 3
109
Appendix 3
110
Appendix 3
111
Appendix 3
112
Appendix 3
113
Appendix 3
114
Appendix 3
115
Appendix 3
116
Appendix 4
Agenda:
Introduce purpose of the project and road section and what TA is all about
Introduce survey team and date for conduct IOL and SES
Why conducted IOL and ESE?
Cut off date
Minimize impact of the project
Location of
Road Date of Meeting Number of
No Section Meeting (District) Participants Concerns Raised by the People
When this road will started
construction?
They proposed to construct this
road as soon as possible,
Proposed to build drainage along
NR - 20 May
1 Svay Tep 13 road side,
314D 2011
Proposed to compensation for fruit
trees and other threes
make clear between compensation
price for rural and urban land area,
117
Appendix 4
Location of
Road Date of Meeting Number of
No Section Meeting (District) Participants Concerns Raised by the People
construction?
He affected his house 100%, he
proposed to project to pay for
relocated his house is possible.
During the first construction nearly
two year ago, the authorities
proposed to contributed his land for
road construction, during this time,
24 May Kamchay he propose suitable price for
5 NR - 13 76
2011 Mear compensation.
When this road will started
construction?
How many meters of ROW for our
road NR-13
When this road will started
construction?
25 May Don’t excavated land in ROW to
6 NR - 13 Svay Rieng 26
2011 used for road construction, should
get from borrow pit far from the
road ROW.
118
Appendix 4
Participants
AGENDA
1- Provides the Purpose of project and Project Location along NR 314D and NR13
2- Resettlement Introduction
3- Conduct IOL
3- Conduct SES
5- Time table for field work
6- Cutoff Date
7- Entitlements of Affected people
8- Post-IOL consultation
The Government of Cambodia has requested the Asian Development Bank (ADB)
project preparatory technical assistance (TA) to prepare the Provincial Roads
Improvement Project. Among others, the project aims to rehabilitate NR 314D
from Prosot to the border of Vietnam at Prey Var-Mocva, 25 km; construct a new
cross border facility (CBF) at Prey Var-Mocva; NR 13 connecting NR 8 and NR1,
between Komchay Mear 65 km;
NR53, which traverse Kampong Chhnang and Kampong Speu provinces, we
need time to study more after submit to Government and ADB for approved
119
Appendix 4
Income and Expense for their each household and find out Vulnerable group like Elderly,
Widow, handicap and income under poverty line etc.
4. Cutoff date: We would like to inform to authorities during IOL is the cutoff date by tell to all
people by no need to build new houses, Shops stalls in COI.
5. Middle of June 2011 International Resettlement Consultant will come here again to public
consultation again
C- Deputy of District
Referring to ideas for MPWT’s officer and Resettlement Consultant provided all of the
information, he would like to inform to all of authorities related to the project site to
participate strongly with this actions to get successfully, and he provide this to commune
head to repot some of structures and fences etc,
Attendants List
Province: Svay Rieng, District: Svay Tep, Commune: Kandeang Reay, Village:
/ Sign or Thumb
No. Name Sex Position Organization/Village Print
1 Romeo Clito M Inter- Consultant KCI
2 Sao Primarak M MPWT
3 Seang Bora M Local Consultant KCI
4 Phenh Pha M Deputy of District Svay Teap
5 Koung Sary M District officer Chief of office
6 Men Saran M District officer Chief of Admin
7 Hay Chan M District officer Deputy Chief of Admin
Nak
8 Gnoun Sat F Commune head Kandeang Reay
9 Ouk Pak M Commune head Prasot village
10 Sek Saline M Village head Prey Rumdol village
120
Appendix 4
121
Appendix 4
AGENDA
1- Provides the Purpose of project and Project Location along NR 314D and
NR13
2- Resettlement Introduction
3- Conduct IOL
3- Conduct SES
5- Time table for field work
6- Cutoff Date
7- Entitlements of Affected people
8- Vulnerable grou
A- Chief of District
Report name of District, Communes and village along NR-314 and Participants
during this meeting and transfer purpose of meeting to Mr. Seang Bora (Local
Resettlement Consultant) and Mr. Romeo B. Clito (International Resettlement
Consultant)
Thank the participants for coming and the local officials for facilitating the holding of the meeting
today.
6. Explain what the TA is all about:
The Government of Cambodia has requested the Asian Development Bank (ADB)
project preparatory technical assistance (TA) to prepare the Provincial Roads
Improvement Project. Among others, the project aims to rehabilitate NR 314D
from Prosot to the border of Vietnam at Prey Var-Mocva, 25 km; construct a new
cross border facility (CBF) at Prey Var-Mocva; NR 13 connecting NR 8 and NR1,
between Komchay Mear 65 km;
NR53, which traverse Kampong Chhnang and Kampong Speu provinces, we
need time to study more after submit to Government and ADB.
2. The members of the survey team will conducting measurement from Svay Teap to Kampong
Ro District, So I would like to inform you all of authorities to help and provide this
information to all affect people along the road site to participate with our team to conduct
122
Appendix 4
IOL and SES to measure size of impact before road construction. As you know the project
successful when have participated from authorities and people and all APs must be clear
what assets, others assets or lands that affected with the project after thumb print or sign
agreement with the team survey. The project needed 10m from road existing centerline for
each site, total is 20 m.
3. Why Conduct IOL and SES? because, we want to get legible and eligible people and living
life of the people along the project site like, Income and Expense for their each household
and find out Vulnerable group like Elderly, Widow, handicap and income under poverty line
etc. especially, find out that their own assets for each affected household that affected by
road construction project.
4. Cutoff date: We would like to inform to authorities during IOL is the cutoff date by tell to all
people no need to build new houses, Shops stalls in COI.
7. Middle of June 2011 International Resettlement Consultant will come here again to public
consultation again with affected people and authorities along the project site.
C- Chief of District
Referring to Resettlement Consultant provided all of the information, he would like to
inform to all of authorities related to the project site to participate strongly with this actions
to get successfully, and he provide to commune head to report some of structures and
fences and to find out how many people that affected inside the COI and that assts that
all people lose.
Attendants List
123
Appendix 4
124
Appendix 4
AGENDA
1- Provides the Purpose of project and Project Location along NR 314D and
NR13
2- Resettlement Introduction
3- Conduct IOL
3- Conduct SES
5- Time table for field work
6- Cutoff Date
7- Entitlements of Affected people
8- Vulnerable group
A- Dputy of District
Report name of District, Communes and village along NR-13 in Rum Duol District area and
Participants during this meeting and transfer purpose of meeting to Mr. Seang Bora
(Local Resettlement Consultant) and Mr. Romeo B. Clito (International Resettlement
Consultant)
Thanks you very much for Mr. Romeo B. Clito (International Resettlement Consultant) that has
present, Deputy of district, Chief of Communes, Village head and all of the people that
participated for this meeting today.
8. Explain what the TA is all about:
The Government of Cambodia has requested the Asian Development Bank (ADB)
project preparatory technical assistance (TA) to prepare the Provincial Roads
Improvement Project. Among others, the project aims to rehabilitate NR 314D
from Prosot to the border of Vietnam at Prey Var-Mocva, 25 km; construct a new
cross border facility (CBF) at Prey Var-Mocva; NR 13 connecting NR 8 and NR1,
between Komchay Mear 65 km;
NR53, which traverse Kampong Chhnang and Kampong Speu provinces, we
need time to study more after submit to Government and ADB for approved after
construction.
125
Appendix 4
2. The members of the survey team will conducting measurement road number 314Dfrom Svay
Tep to Kampong Ro District and, will to conducted Rum Duol district around between next
week, So I would like to inform you all of authorities to help and provide this information to
all affect people along the road site to participate with our team to conduct IOL and SES to
measure size of impact before road construction. As you know the project successful
when have participated from authorities and people and all APs must be clear what assets,
others assets or lands that affected with the project after thumb print or sign agreement
with the team survey. The project needed 10m from road existing centerline for each site,
total is 20 m.
3. Why Conduct IOL and SES? because, we want to get legible and eligible people and living
life of the people along the project site like, Income and Expense for their each household
and find out Vulnerable group like Elderly, Widow, handicap and income under poverty line
etc. especially, find out that their own assets for each affected household that affected by
road construction project.
4. Cutoff date: We would like to inform to authorities during IOL is the cutoff date by tell to all
people no need to build new houses, Shops stalls in COI.
5. Middle of June 2011 International Resettlement Consultant will come here again to public
consultation again with affected people and authorities along the project site.
C- Deputy of District
Referring to Resettlement Consultant provided all of the information, he would like to
inform to all of authorities related to the project site to participate strongly with this actions
to get successfully, and he provide to commune head to report some of structures and
fences and to find out how many people that affected inside the COI and that assts that
all people lose.
126
Appendix 4
Attendants List
127
Appendix 4
128
Appendix 4
AGENDA
1- Provides the Purpose of project and Project Location along NR 314D and
NR13
2- Resettlement Introduction
3- Conduct IOL
3- Conduct SES
5- Time table for field work
6- Cutoff Date
7- Entitlements of Affected people
8- Vulnerable group
Thanks you very much for Mr. Romeo B. Clito (International Resettlement Consultant) that has
present, Deputy of district, Chief of Communes, Village head and all of the people that
participated for this meeting today. And, I would like inform the purpose of the meeting
and project introduction as following:
9. Explain what the TA is all about:
The Government of Cambodia has requested the Asian Development Bank (ADB)
project preparatory technical assistance (TA) to prepare the Provincial Roads
Improvement Project. Among others, the project aims to rehabilitate NR 314D
from Prosot to the border of Vietnam at Prey Var-Mocva, 25 km; construct a new
cross border facility (CBF) at Prey Var-Mocva; NR 13 connecting NR 8 and NR1,
between Komchay Mear 65 km;
NR53, which traverse Kampong Chhnang and Kampong Speu provinces, we
129
Appendix 4
need time to study more after submit to Government and ADB for approved after
construction.
2. The members of the survey team will conducting measurement road number 314Dfrom Svay
Tep to Kampong Ro District and, will to conducted Rum Duol district and after conducted
at Romeas Haek district around between next week and also Kamchay Mear district at
NR-8, So I would like to inform you all of authorities to help and provide this information to
all affect people along the road site to participate with our team to conduct IOL and SES to
measure size of impact before road construction. As you know the project successful
when have participated from authorities and people and all APs must be clear what assets,
others assets or lands that affected with the project after thumb print or sign agreement
with the team survey. The project needed 10m from road existing centerline for each site,
total is 20 m.
3. Why Conduct IOL and SES? because, we want to get legible and eligible people and living
life of the people along the project site like, Income and Expense for their each household
and find out Vulnerable group like Elderly, Widow, handicap and income under poverty line
etc. especially, find out that their own assets for each affected household that affected by
road construction project.
4. Cutoff date: We would like to inform to authorities during IOL is the cutoff date by tell to all
people no need to build new houses, Shops stalls in COI.
5. Middle of June 2011 International Resettlement Consultant will come here again to public
consultation again with affected people and authorities along the project site.
C- Deputy of District
Referring to Resettlement Consultant provided all of the information, he would like to
inform to all of authorities related to the project site to participate strongly with this actions
to get successfully, and he provide to commune head to report some of structures and
fences and to find out how many people that affected inside the COI and that assts that
all people lose.
130
Appendix 4
Attendants List
Province: Svay Rieng, District Romeas_Haek, Commune: , Village:
/
No. Name Sex Position Organization/Village
1 Hen Sokun M Deputy Chief of District Romeas Haek
2 Romeo Clito M Inter- Consultant KCI
3 Seang Bora M Local Consultant KCI
4 Pov Savonng M Commune head Trorse
5 Pov Seap M Village head Andong Po
6 Koung Vaet M Commune Council 2 Andong Trabaek
7 Koung Sok M Commune Council 2 Ampil
8 Soeng Sarorn F Commune Council Ampil
9 Prach Yim M Village head Trorse
10 Mom Sorn M Commune head Andong Po
11 Ros Phan M Village head Arak Svay
12 Keo Rim M Village head Trapeang Rum Denh
13 Ouk Van M Commune head Ang Prasre
14 Tep Chan Savuth M Village head Ang Prasre
15 Chan Samoeurn M Village head Ang Prasre
16 Chan Saban M Village head Ang Prasre
17 Moek Moung M Village head Vat
18 Pen Oeurn M Village head Trapeang Smach
19 Korng Bunthoeurn M Village head Andong Trabaek
20 Pen Savorn M District Officer Romeas Haek
21 Men Samoeurn M District Officer Romeas Haek
22
131
Appendix 4
AGENDA
1- Provides the Purpose of project and Project Location along NR 314D and
NR13
2- Resettlement Introduction
3- Conduct IOL
3- Conduct SES
5- Time table for field work
6- Cutoff Date
7- Entitlements of Affected people
8- Vulnerable group
First, I would like to say thanks you very much for Chief of district Public Work and
Transport , Commune head that has present that had arrange meeting today, thanks for
all village head Village head and all of the people that participated for this meeting
today.
The Government of Cambodia has requested the Asian Development Bank (ADB)
project preparatory technical assistance (TA) to prepare the Provincial Roads
Improvement Project. Among others, the project aims to rehabilitate NR 314D
from Prosot to the border of Vietnam at Prey Var-Mocva, 25 km; construct a new
cross border facility (CBF) at Prey Var-Mocva; NR 13 connecting NR 8 and NR1,
between Komchay Mear 65 km;
NR53, which traverse Kampong Chhnang and Kampong Speu provinces, we
132
Appendix 4
need time to study more after submit to Government and ADB for approved after
construction.
2. The members of the survey team will conducting measurement road number 314Dfrom
Svay Tep to Kampong Ro District and, will to conducted Rum Duol district , Romeas Haek
and will arrived Kamchay Mear District around next week, So I would like to inform you all
of authorities and people along the road side to help and provide this information to all
others affect people to participate with our team to conduct IOL and SES to measure size
of impact after road construction. As you know the project successful when have
participated from authorities and people and all APs should be understand the purpose of
the project. The project needed 10m from centerline of existing road for each site, total is
20 m. so, all of properties/ assets/lands/ trees and other assets will collected during team
survey conduct OL and SES
3. Why Conduct IOL and SES? because, we want to find out legible and eligible people and
living life of the people along the project site like, Income and Expense for their each
household and find out Vulnerable group like Elderly, Widow, handicap and income under
poverty line etc. especially, find out that their own assets for each affected household
that affected by road construction project.
4. Cutoff date:
We would like to inform to authorities and participants and others affected people along
the road side during IOL and SES is the days for cutoff date by tell to all people no need to
build new houses, Shops stalls and others structures in COI.
5. Middle of June 2011 International Resettlement Consultant will come here again to
conduct the public consultation meeting again with affected people and authorities along
the project site.
C- Chief of commune
Referring to Resettlement Consultant provided all of the information, he would like to
inform to all of authorities related to the project site especially, Village head to participate
strongly with this actions to get successfully, and he provide to village head to report
some of structures and fences and to find out how many people that affected inside the
COI and assts that all people loss.
133
Appendix 4
Attendants List
/
No. Name Sex Position Organization/Village
1 Romeo Clito M Inter- Consultant KCI
3 Seang Bora M Local Consultant KCI
4 Yat Yorn M Public Work of District Kamchay Mear
5 Yaeng Cham M Commune Council Kra Bao
6 Sao Sonay M Commune Council Kra Bao
7 Teap Run M Village head Veal Smach
8 Heng SamOn F Village head Thbong Vat
9
134
Appendix 4
AGENDA
1- Provides the Purpose of project and Project Location along NR 314D and
NR13
2- Resettlement Introduction
3- Conduct IOL
3- Conduct SES
5- Time table for field work
6- Cutoff Date
7- Entitlements of Affected people
8- Vulnerable group
First, I would like to say thanks you very much for Deputy Mulniciple of Svay Rieng
Town, Public Work and Transport , Commune head that has present and arranged
meeting today, thanks for all village head Village head and all of lady and gentlemen
that have participated for this meeting today. I would like to introduce purpose of meeting
as follow:
The Government of Cambodia has requested the Asian Development Bank (ADB)
project preparatory technical assistance (TA) to prepare the Provincial Roads
Improvement Project. Among others, the project aims to rehabilitate NR 314D
from Prosot to the border of Vietnam at Prey Var-Mocva, 25 km; construct a new
cross border facility (CBF) at Prey Var-Mocva; NR 13 connecting NR 8 and NR1,
135
Appendix 4
3. Cutoff date:
We would like to inform to authorities and participants and others affected people along
the road side during IOL and SES is the days for cutoff date by tell to all people no need to
build new houses, Shops stalls and others structures in COI.
4. The members of the survey team will conducting measurement road number 314Dfrom
Svay Tep to Kampong Ro District and, will to conducted Rum Duol district , Romeas Haek
and will arrived Kamchay Mear District around next week, So I would like to inform you all
of authorities and people along the road side to help and provide this information to all
others affect people to participate with our team to conduct IOL and SES to measure size
of impact after road construction. As you know the project successful when have
participated from authorities and people and all APs should be understand the purpose of
the project. The project needed 10m from centerline of existing road for each site, total is
20 m. so, all of properties, assets, lands, trees and other assets will collected during team
survey conduct IOL and SES
5. Middle of June 2011 International Resettlement Consultant will come here again to
conduct the public consultation meeting again with affected people and authorities along
the project site.
136
Appendix 4
7- Attendants List
/
Organization/Villag
No. Name Sex Position
e
1 Chhiv Sarorn M Deputy Municipal of Svay Rieng Svay Rieng Town
2 Romeo Clito M Inter- Consultant KCI
3 Seang Bora M Local Consultant KCI
4 Souce Sear M Village head Bak Ronorse
5 Pal Saban M Village head Po Phlear
6 Sam Samet M Thlork
7 Ros Hun M Staff of village Bak Ronorse
8 Tith Salei F Deputy of village Po Phlear
9 Nem Savoeurn F Staff of village Po Phlear
10 Kim Sina F Staff of village Aknakot
11 Em Kroch M Deputy of village Aknakot
12 Pen Malida F Deputy of village Thlork
13 Sao Han M Village head Aknakot
14 Phouk Cheat M Village head Preah Tonle
15 Meas Horn M Commune Council Sang Khor
16 Torn Samon M Deputy of village Bak Ronorse
17 Sin Yong M Chief of Commune Sang Khor
18 Sok Norn M Deputy Chief of Commune Sang Khor
19 Sorn Sam At M Village head Thmey
20 Choup Chanrithy M Community Development Town Svay Rieng
21 M
22
137
Appendix 5
Discuss the result of IOL( how many losing entire houses, entire shops and public facilities
such as electric and communication poles need to be relocated
Discuss Resettlement policy in general terms (affected houses and other structures will be
compensated at replacement cost
find out from the affected people their suggestions and preferences regarding compensation,
allowances and assistance, relocation of structures
Re-inform the cutoff date
Location of
Road Date of Number of
No Meeting Main Points Raised by the People
Section Meeting Participants
(District)
He has two place of Residential
land along road NR-314D but, he
participated to measured only one
place, how should he do?
Proposed to constructed drainage
Mon, 20 June
1 NR 314D Svay Tep along the during road
2011
construction.
When will project stared
compensation?
For example: If landless where
people should live?
Proposed to constructed drainage
along the during road construction
Project construct road in district
50% people to proposed to
Mon, 20 June Kampong constructed 50% more road to
2 NR 314D
2011 Ro improve the town in district if
possible.
Compensation rate, how much
per quare meter?
138
Appendix 5
Location of
Road Date of Number of
No Meeting Main Points Raised by the People
Section Meeting Participants
(District)
10m each side total 20m, do the
project need some more land or
not?
Proposed to minimize COI around
7 to 8m each side for urban area?
139
Appendix 5
Location of
Road Date of Number of
No Meeting Main Points Raised by the People
Section Meeting Participants
(District)
all properties that affected by
project base on currently market
value?
If affected fences or stalls, will the
project pay for compensation or
not?
140
Appendix 5
AGENDA
Report name of District, Communes and village along NR-314D in Kampong Ro District
from Svay Tep district to Prey Vao Vietname border and Participants during this meeting
(see attach files ), and transfer purpose of meeting to Mr. Try Yorn (Resettlement Unit
from MPWT) and Local Resettlement Consultant.
Thanks you very much for Deputy of district, Commune Chiefs, Village headman
and all of affected people that has present here today. Referring to population and
Transportation were increased from day to day, The Government of Cambodia
has requested the Asian Development Bank (ADB) project preparatory technical
assistance (TA) to prepare the Provincial Roads Improvement Project. Among
others, the project aims to rehabilitate NR 314D from Prosot to the border of
Vietnam at Prey Var-Mocva, 26,5 km; construct a new cross border facility (CBF)
at Prey Var-Mocva; NR 13 connecting NR 8 and NR1, between Komchay Mear 65
km; NR150B, 53 and 151B which traverse Kampong Chhnang and Kampong
Speu provinces, we need time to study more after submit to Government and
ADB for approved after construction. The Pre IOL was conducted, Now, Post IOL
are inform the meeting to understanding the result of Inventory loss, But the result
141
Appendix 5
Thanks you again for Deputy Chief of district, Commune Chiefs, Village headman and all
of affected people that has present here today.
We was first meeting with authorities, not participated with APs in May 2011 for proposed
authorities to inform to all APs know information about survey team to measured,
interview APs along the NR 314D.
Now, this is second meeting that have authorities and affected people to participate to
understand the first result during conducted IOL.
As you know Survey team was conducted measured, Interviewed IOL and SES with
affected people
that affected in the COI ten meters each side, the total length around 26,5 Km, the total
affected people are 288households, Interview with men are 159 households, interview
with women are 56 households and did not meet owners are 73 households. In 288
households affected residential land 14300m2, Commercial land is 1632.2m2;
agricultural land is 12004m2, Widow 23 households, poor 40 household, disable 01.
Affected Electric and communication post 135(Concrete 57 Steel 03 and Wood 75),
affected 36 houses, Partial houses 18 and entire houses 18, Divorced 01 household,
Widow 23, Poor 40 and Disable 01.
Affected people total 288 household are legible APs that project affected people for NR
314D, So all of properties affected by project will compensate base on replacement cost
result at currently market value after replacement cost study completed and send to
IRC/MEF, when IRC/ MEF approved and for vulnerable group like Widow, Elderly,
handicap, displace people and people income under national poverty line will
haveassistance out of properties affected by project.
Cutoff date: The project was limited the date of IOL is cutoff date that mead by no more
structures builds in the COI.
The projects still have option to minimize impact, should be keep the same COI or
decrease COI for urban area depending on detail design of road engineering.
(i) First stage: APs will present their complaints andgrievances verbally or in writing
to the CLAC. The CLAC will be obliged to provide immediate written confirmation
of receiving the complaint. If after 15 days the aggrieved AP does not hear from
the CLAC, or if the AP is not satisfied with the decision taken in the first stage, the
complaint may be brought to the District Office.
(ii) Second stage: The District Office has 15days within which to resolve the
complaint to the satisfaction of all concerned. If the complaint cannot be solved at
this stage, the District Office will bring the case to the Provincial Grievance
Redress Committee.
(iii) Third stage: The Provincial GrievanceRedress Committee meets with the
aggrieved party and tries to resolve the situation. The Committee may ask for a
142
Appendix 5
review of the DMS by the external monitor (EMO). Within 30 days of the
submission of the grievance, the Committee must make a written decision and
submit copies to the MPWT, PRS/IRC and the AP.
(iv) Final stage: If the aggrievedAP does not hear from the Provincial Grievance
Redress Committee or is not satisfied, he/she will bring the case to Provincial
Court. This is the final stage for adjudicating complaints. Within 30 days of the
submission of the grievance, the Court must make a written decision and submit
copies to the MPWT, PRS/IRC and the AP. If any party is still unsatisfied with the
Provincial Court judgment, he/she can bring the case to a higher-level court.
Attendants List
143
Appendix 5
144
Appendix 5
145
Appendix 5
AGENDA
Report name of District, Communes and village along NR-314D in Svay Tep District from
NR-1 to Kampong Ro district’s border and Participants during this meeting (see attach
files ), and transfer purpose of meeting to Mr. Try Yorn (Resettlement Unit from MPWT)
and Local Resettlement Consultant to presentation the primary result of IOL and SES,
Thanks you very much for Deputy of district, Commune Chiefs, Village headman
and all of affected people that has present here today. Referring to population and
Transportation were increased from day to day, The Government of Cambodia
has requested the Asian Development Bank (ADB) project preparatory technical
assistance (TA) to prepare the Provincial Roads Improvement Project. Among
others, the project aims to rehabilitate NR 314D from Prosot to the border of
Vietnam at Prey Var-Mocva, 26,5 km; construct a new cross border facility (CBF)
at Prey Var-Mocva; NR 13 connecting NR 8 and NR1, between Komchay Mear 65
km; NR150B, 53 and 151B which traverse Kampong Chhnang and Kampong
Speu provinces, we need time to study more after submit to Government and
146
Appendix 5
ADB for approved after construction. The Pre IOL was conducted, Now, Post IOL
are inform the meeting to understanding the result of Inventory loss, But the result
will introduce by Local Resettlement Consultant.
Thanks you again for Deputy Chief of district, Commune Chiefs, Village headman and all
of affected people that has present here today.
First, I would like to inform the meeting that, We had first meeting with authorities, not
participated with APs in May 2011 for proposed authorities to inform to all APs know
information about survey team to measured, interview APs along the NR 314D.
Now, this is second meeting that have authorities and affected people to participate to
understand the first result during conducted IOL.
As you know Survey team was conducted measured, Interviewed IOL and SES with
affected people
that affected in the COI ten meters each side, the total affected people along road
number 314D that have distance around 26,5 Km are affected 288households, Interview
with men are 159 households, interview with women are 56 households and did not meet
owners are 73 households. In 288 households affected residential land 14300m2,
Commercial land is 1632.2m2; agricultural land is 12004m2, Widow 23 households, poor
40 household, disable 01. Affected Electric and communication post 135(Concrete 57
Steel 03 and Wood 75), affected 36 houses, Partial houses 18 and entire houses 18.
Affected people total 288 household are legible APs that project affected people for NR
314D, So all of properties affected by project will compensate base on replacement cost
result at currently market value after replacement cost study completed and send to
IRC/MEF, when IRC/ MEF approved and for vulnerable group like Widow, Elderly,
handicap, displace people and people income under national poverty line will
haveassistance out of properties affected by project.
Cutoff date: The project was limited the date of IOL is cutoff date that mead by no more
structures builds in the COI.
The projects still have option to minimize impact, should be keep the same COI or
decrease COI for urban area depending on detail design of road engineering.
(v) First stage: APs will present their complaints andgrievances verbally or in writing
to the CLAC. The CLAC will be obliged to provide immediate written confirmation
of receiving the complaint. If after 15 days the aggrieved AP does not hear from
the CLAC, or if the AP is not satisfied with the decision taken in the first stage, the
complaint may be brought to the District Office.
(vi) Second stage: The District Office has 15days within which to resolve the
complaint to the satisfaction of all concerned. If the complaint cannot be solved at
this stage, the District Office will bring the case to the Provincial Grievance
Redress Committee.
147
Appendix 5
(vii) Third stage: The Provincial GrievanceRedress Committee meets with the
aggrieved party and tries to resolve the situation. The Committee may ask for a
review of the DMS by the external monitor (EMO). Within 30 days of the
submission of the grievance, the Committee must make a written decision and
submit copies to the MPWT, PRS/IRC and the AP.
(viii) Final stage: If the aggrievedAP does not hear from the Provincial Grievance
Redress Committee or is not satisfied, he/she will bring the case to Provincial
Court. This is the final stage for adjudicating complaints. Within 30 days of the
submission of the grievance, the Court must make a written decision and submit
copies to the MOWRAM, PDWRAM, PDRD, EMO, PRS/IRC and the AP. If any
party is still unsatisfied with the Provincial Court judgment, he/she can bring the
case to a higher-level court.
Attendants List
No. Name Sex Position Organization/Village
1 Souce Samreth M Deputy of District Kampong Ro
2 Try Yorn M Resettlement Unit MPWT
3 Seang Bora M Local Consultant KCI
4 Sam Sorn M Village headman Trapeang Trave
5 Chin Em M People Trapeang Trave
6 Seth Koeng M People Trapeang Trave
7 Chhuon Sakoun M People Trapeang Trave
8 Bive Sinath F People Trapeang Trave
9 Loeng Sitha F People Trapeang Trave
10 Boek Saroeurn F People Trapeang Trave
11 Kok Him F People Trapeang Trave
12 Hemh Sam Phorse F People Trapeang Trave
13 Kiv Many F People Trapeang Trave
14 Heng Sam On F People Trapeang Trave
15 Chuon Vanna M People Trapeang Trave
16 Gnuoy Chanda M People Trapeang Trave
17 Long Vuthy M People Trapeang Trave
18 Put Eng M People Trapeang Trave
19 Khmao Sareth M People Trapeang Trave
20 Keo Phearum M People Trapeang Trave
21 Chhan Thim M People Trapeang Trave
22 Ngin Khemra M People Trapeang Trave
23 Ouk Kory M People Trapeang Trave
24 Pol Rorn M People Svay Anath
25 Duch Try M People Svay Anath
26 Sok Ouk M People Svay Anath
27 Sar Tith M People Svay Anath
28 Suo Phorse M People Ro
148
Appendix 5
29 Pin Ty F People Ro
30 Seang Sina F People Ro
31 Khat Pheach F People Svay Anath
32 Chab Hean M People Svay Anath
33 Neang Peak M People Svay Anath
34 Sao Samen M Deputy ofvillage Svay Anath
35 Sek Nhim M Deputy ofvillage Ro
36 Sar Phal M People Svay Anath
37 Chan Sokha F People Trapeang Trave
38 Pok Chanda F People Ro
39 Chea Mavany F People Svay Anath
40 Ke Samon F People Svay Anath
41 Sam Sporn M Village head Trapeang Trav
149
Appendix 5
AGENDA
Report name of District, Communes and village along NR-13 from National road 1 to
border of Rumduol district have 6 villages. and Participants during this meeting (see
attach files ), and after that Municipal transfer purpose of meeting to Mr. Try Yorn
(Resettlement Unit from MPWT) and Local Resettlement Consultant to explain the
result as following:
Thanks you very much for present of Deputy Municipal of Svay Rieng Town,
Commune Chiefs, Village headman and all of affected people that has present
here today. Referring to population and Transportation were increased from day
to day, The Government of Cambodia has requested the Asian Development
Bank (ADB) project preparatory technical assistance (TA) to prepare the
Provincial Roads Improvement Project. Among others, the project aims to
rehabilitate NR 13 from NR-1 to NR-8, 65 km; construct a new cross border
facility (CBF) at Prey Var-Mocva; NR 13 connecting NR 8 and NR1, between
150
Appendix 5
Komchay Mear NR150B, 53 and 151B which traverse Kampong Chhnang and
Kampong Speu provinces, we need time to study more after submit to
Government and ADB for approved after construction. The Pre-IOL was
conducted in May 2011, Now, Post-IOL are inform the meeting to understanding
the result of Inventory loss, But the result will introduce by Local Resettlement
Consultant
Again, I would like to say thanks you very much for Deputy of Municipal of Svay Rieng
Town, Commune Chiefs, Village headman and all of affected people that has present
here today.
We was first meeting with authorities in May 2011, by not participated with for proposed
authorities to inform to all APs know information about survey team to measured,
interview APs along the NR 13 for conducted Inventory of Loss.
Now, this is second meeting that have authorities and affected people participate to
understand the Primary data result during conducted IOL. During conducted pre-IOL, the
team were study along NR-13 there are 4 districts, 11 communes and 39 villages and
Survey team was conducted measured, Interviewed IOL and SES with affected people
that affected in the COI ten meters each side fro centerline, the total affected people
around 65Km is 676 households, Interview with men are 381 households, interview with
women are 101 households and did not meet owners are 472households. In 676
households affected residential land 1690.1m2, Commercial land is 1026.9m2;
agricultural land is 44681.3m2, electric post 42 and telephone post and affected 45
houses, Partial houses 25 and entire houses 20. Shops/Stalls 62, Partial 17 and entire
45.
Affected people total 676 household are legible APs that project affected people for NR
13, So all of properties affected by project will compensate base on replacement cost
result at currently market value after approved rate from IRC at MEF and for vulnerable
group like Widow, Elderly, handicap, displace people and people income under national
poverty line will haveassistance out of properties affected by project. Except Sangkhor
commune were conducted with 85 households, Male 41 households, Female 16
households and did not meet owner 28 households that affected Farm land12420m2,
Residential land 429m2 and commercial land is 48m2, the total is 12594m2.
Cutoff date: The project was limited the date of IOL is cutoff date that mead by no more
structures builds in the COI.
The projects still have option to minimize impact, should be keep the same COI or
decrease COI for urban area depending on detail design of road engineering.
(ix) First stage: APs will present their complaints andgrievances verbally or in writing
to the CLAC. The CLAC will be obliged to provide immediate written confirmation
of receiving the complaint. If after 15 days the aggrieved AP does not hear from
151
Appendix 5
the CLAC, or if the AP is not satisfied with the decision taken in the first stage, the
complaint may be brought to the District Office.
(x) Second stage: The District Office has 15days within which to resolve the
complaint to the satisfaction of all concerned. If the complaint cannot be solved at
this stage, the District Office will bring the case to the Provincial Grievance
Redress Committee.
(xi) Third stage: The Provincial GrievanceRedress Committee meets with the
aggrieved party and tries to resolve the situation. The Committee may ask for a
review of the DMS by the external monitor (EMO). Within 30 days of the
submission of the grievance, the Committee must make a written decision and
submit copies to the MPWT, PRS/IRC and the AP.
(xii) Final stage: If the aggrievedAP does not hear from the Provincial Grievance
Redress Committee or is not satisfied, he/she will bring the case to Provincial
Court. This is the final stage for adjudicating complaints. Within 30 days of the
submission of the grievance, the Court must make a written decision and submit
copies to the MPWT, PRS/IRC and the AP. If any party is still unsatisfied with the
Provincial Court judgment, he/she can bring the case to a higher-level court.
Attendants List
Province: Svay Rieng Town
152
Appendix 5
153
Appendix 5
154
Appendix 5
155
Appendix 5
156
Appendix 5
157
Appendix 5
AGENDA
Thanks you very much for present of Chief of district, Commune Chiefs, Village
headman and all of affected people that has present here today. Referring to
population and Transportation were increased from day to day, The Government
of Cambodia has requested the Asian Development Bank (ADB) project
preparatory technical assistance (TA) to prepare the Provincial Roads
Improvement Project. Among others, the project aims to rehabilitate NR 13 from
NR-1 to NR-8, 65 km; construct a new cross border facility (CBF) at Prey
Var-Mocva; NR 13 connecting NR 8 and NR1, between Komchay Mear NR150B,
158
Appendix 5
53 and 151B which traverse Kampong Chhnang and Kampong Speu provinces,
we need time to study more after submit to Government and ADB for approved
after construction. The Pre-IOL was conducted in May 2011, Now, Post-IOL are
inform the meeting to understanding the result of Inventory loss, But the result will
introduce by Local Resettlement Consultant.
Again, I would like to say thanks you very much for Chief of district, Commune Chiefs,
Village headman and all of affected people that has present meeting here today.
We was first meeting with authorities in May 2011, by not participated with for proposed
authorities to inform to all APs know information about survey team to measured,
interview APs along the NR 13 for conducted Inventory of Loss in area of Rumduol
district.
Now, this is second meeting that have authorities and affected people participate to
understand the Primary data result during conducted IOL. During conducted pre-IOL, the
team were study along NR-13 there are 4 districts, 11 communes and 39 villages and
Survey team was conducted measured, Interviewed IOL and SES with affected people
that affected in the COI ten meters each side from centerline, the total affected people
around 65Km is 676 households, Interview with men are 381 households, interview with
women are 101 households and did not meet owners are 472households. In 676
households affected residential land 1690.1m2, Commercial land is 1026.9m2;
agricultural land is 44681.3m2, electric post 42 and telephone post and affected 105
houses, House/Store 03, Store/ Shops/ Restaurant 114. Divorced 8 households, Widow
30 households, Disable 5 households, Poor 96 households.
Affected people total 676 household are legible APs that project affected people for NR
13, So all of properties affected by project will compensate base on replacement cost
study result at currently market value after approved rate from IRC at MEF and for
vulnerable group like Widow, Elderly, handicap, displace people and people income
under national poverty line will haveassistance out of properties affected by project.
Rumduol district were conducted with 4 communes, 12 villages that affected with Project.
Cutoff date: The project was limited the date of IOL is cutoff date that mead by no more
structures will build in the COI.
The projects still have option to minimize impact, should be keep the same COI or
decrease COI for urban area depending on detail design of road engineering.
(xiii) First stage: APs will present their complaints andgrievances verbally or in writing
to the CLAC. The CLAC will be obliged to provide immediate written confirmation
of receiving the complaint. If after 15 days the aggrieved AP does not hear from
the CLAC, or if the AP is not satisfied with the decision taken in the first stage, the
complaint may be brought to the District Office.
159
Appendix 5
(xiv) Second stage: The District Office has 15days within which to resolve the
complaint to the satisfaction of all concerned. If the complaint cannot be solved at
this stage, the District Office will bring the case to the Provincial Grievance
Redress Committee.
(xv) Third stage: The Provincial GrievanceRedress Committee meets with the
aggrieved party and tries to resolve the situation. The Committee may ask for a
review of the DMS by the external monitor (EMO). Within 30 days of the
submission of the grievance, the Committee must make a written decision and
submit copies to the MPWT, PRS/IRC and the AP.
(xvi) Final stage: If the aggrievedAP does not hear from the Provincial Grievance
Redress Committee or is not satisfied, he/she will bring the case to Provincial
Court. This is the final stage for adjudicating complaints. Within 30 days of the
submission of the grievance, the Court must make a written decision and submit
copies to the MPWT, PRS/IRC and the AP. If any party is still unsatisfied with the
Provincial Court judgment, he/she can bring the case to a higher-level court.
Attendants List
Province: Rumduol District
160
Appendix 5
30 Em Da F People Chork
31 Chea Thida F People Chork
32 Phal Sitha F People Chork
33 Hun Vanny F People Prey Keav
34 Naiy Sar M Admin Rumduol district
35 Kao Boren F People Prey Keav
36 Mey Navy F People Chork
37 Kung Piseth F People Chork
38 Pich Srey Naeng F People Chork
39 Toch Sinath M People Chork
40 Me Sophon F People Chork
41 Uk Kunthea F People Chork
42 Sorn Vanthorn F People Chork
43 Nuon Saron M People Chork
44 Ros Mara M Director of High school Chork
45 Long Saron M Teacher Chork
46 Seng Heang M People Chork
47 Loek sary F People Prey Keav
48 Kim Sakhorn M People Chork
49 Roth Sam Oeurn M People Chork
50 Em Sothea M People Chork
51 Mao Chanra M People Chork
52 Chap Sok F People Chork
53 Orn Saphat F People Prey Keav
54 Hing Vanna M People Prey Keav
55 Pov Khanpanharith M People Chork
56 Prum Savan M People Chork
57 Bo Kosal M People Chork
58 Meas Kala M People Chork
59 Kuy Ang M People Chork
60 Pen Sam M People Chork
61 Um Sopha F People Chork
62 Yim Heang F People Chork
63 Tang Sokhorn F People Chork
64 Pe OL M People Chork
65
Total participants are 64 persons, Female 27 persons
161
Appendix 5
II- AGENDA
Thanks you very much for present of Deputy district of Romeas Haek, Commune
Chiefs, Village headman and all of affected people that has present here today.
Referring to population and Transportation were increased from day to day, The
Government of Cambodia has requested the Asian Development Bank (ADB)
project preparatory technical assistance (TA) to prepare the Provincial Roads
Improvement Project. Among others, the project aims to rehabilitate NR 13 from
NR-1 to NR-8, 65 km; construct a new cross border facility (CBF) at Prey
Var-Mocva; NR 13 connecting NR 8 and NR1, between Komchay Mear NR150B,
53 and 151B which traverse Kampong Chhnang and Kampong Speu provinces,
162
Appendix 5
we need time to study more after submit to Government and ADB for approved
after construction. The Pre-IOL was conducted in May 2011, Now, Post-IOL are
inform the meeting to understanding the result of Inventory loss, But the result will
introduce by Local Resettlement Consultant.
Again, I would like to say thanks you very much for Chief of district, Commune Chiefs,
Village headman and all of affected people that has present meeting here today.
We was first meeting with authorities in May 2011, by not participated with for proposed
authorities to inform to all APs know information about survey team to measured,
interview APs along the NR 13 for conducted Inventory of Loss in area of Romeas Haek
district.
Now, this is second meeting that have authorities and affected people participate to
understand the Primary data result during conducted IOL. During conducted pre-IOL, the
team were study along NR-13 there are 4 districts, 11 communes and 39 villages and
Survey team was conducted measured, Interviewed IOL and SES with affected people
that affected in the COI ten meters each side from centerline, the total affected people
around 65Km is 676 households, Interview with men are 381 households, interview with
women are 101 households and did not meet owners are 472households. In 676
households affected residential land 1690.1m2, Commercial land is 1026.9m2;
agricultural land is 44681.3m2, and affected 105 houses, House/Store 03, Store/ Shops/
Restaurant 114. Divorced 8 households, Widow 30 households, Disable 5 households,
Poor is 96 households.
Affected people total 676 household are legible APs that project affected people for NR
13, So all of properties affected by project will compensate base on replacement cost
study result at currently market value after approved rate from IRC at MEF and for
vulnerable group like Widow, Elderly, handicap, displace people and people income
under national poverty line will haveassistance out of properties affected by project.
Rumduol district were conducted with5 communes, 19 villages that affected with Project.
Cutoff date: The project was limited the date of IOL is cutoff date that mead by no more
structures will build in the COI.
The projects still have option to minimize impact, should be keep the same COI or
decrease COI for urban area depending on detail design of road engineering.
(xvii) First stage: APs will present their complaints andgrievances verbally or in writing
to the CLAC. The CLAC will be obliged to provide immediate written confirmation
of receiving the complaint. If after 15 days the aggrieved AP does not hear from
the CLAC, or if the AP is not satisfied with the decision taken in the first stage, the
complaint may be brought to the District Office.
(xviii) Second stage: The District Office has 15days within which to resolve the
complaint to the satisfaction of all concerned. If the complaint cannot be solved at
163
Appendix 5
this stage, the District Office will bring the case to the Provincial Grievance
Redress Committee.
(xix) Third stage: The Provincial GrievanceRedress Committee meets with the
aggrieved party and tries to resolve the situation. The Committee may ask for a
review of the DMS by the external monitor (EMO). Within 30 days of the
submission of the grievance, the Committee must make a written decision and
submit copies to the MPWT,PRS/IRC and the AP.
(xx) Final stage: If the aggrievedAP does not hear from the Provincial Grievance
Redress Committee or is not satisfied, he/she will bring the case to Provincial
Court. This is the final stage for adjudicating complaints. Within 30 days of the
submission of the grievance, the Court must make a written decision and submit
copies to the IMPWT, PRS/IRC and the AP. If any party is still unsatisfied with the
Provincial Court judgment, he/she can bring the case to a higher-level court.
Attendants List
Province: Romeas Haek District
164
Appendix 5
65
Total participants are 60 persons, Female 24 persons
165
Appendix 5
II- AGENDA
Thanks you very much for present of Deputy of district, Chief of Commune,
Village headman and all of affected people that has present here today. Referring
to population and Transportation were increased from day to day, The
Government of Cambodia has requested the Asian Development Bank (ADB)
project preparatory technical assistance (TA) to prepare the Provincial Roads
Improvement Project. Among others, the project aims to rehabilitate NR 13 from
NR-1 to NR-8, 65 km; construct a new cross border facility (CBF) at Prey
Var-Mocva; NR 13 connecting NR 8 and NR1, between Komchay Mear NR150B,
53 and 151B which traverse Kampong Chhnang and Kampong Speu provinces,
we need time to study more after submit to Government and ADB for approved
166
Appendix 5
after construction. The Pre-IOL was conducted in May 2011, Now, Post-IOL are
inform the meeting to understanding the result of Inventory loss, But the result will
introduce by Local Resettlement Consultant.
Again, I would like to say thanks you very much for Chief of district, Commune Chiefs,
Village headman and all of affected people that has present meeting here today.
We was first meeting with authorities in May 2011, by not participated with for proposed
authorities to inform to all APs know information about survey team to measured,
interview APs along the NR 13 for conducted Inventory of Loss in area of Kamchay Mear
district.
Now, this is second meeting that have authorities and affected people participate to
understand the Primary data result during conducted IOL. During conducted pre-IOL, the
team were study along NR-13 there are 4 districts, 11 communes and 39 villages and
Survey team was conducted measured, Interviewed IOL and SES with affected people
that affected in the COI ten meters each side from centerline, the total affected people
around 65Km is 676 households, Interview with men are 381 households, interview with
women are 101 households and did not meet owners are 472households. In 676
households affected residential land 1690.1m2, Commercial land is 1026.9m2;
agricultural land is 44681.3m2, and affected 105 houses, House/Store 03, Store/ Shops/
Restaurant 114. Divorced 8 households, Widow 30 households, Disable 5 households,
Poor is 96 households.
Affected people total 676 household are legible APs that project affected people for NR
13, So all of properties affected by project will compensate base on replacement cost
study result at currently market value after approved rate from IRC at MEF and for
vulnerable group like Widow, Elderly, handicap, displace people and people income
under national poverty line will haveassistance out of properties affected by project.
Rumduol district were conducted with5 communes, 19 villages that affected with Project.
Cutoff date: The project was limited the date of IOL is cutoff date that mead by no more
structures will build in the COI.
The projects still have option to minimize impact, should be keep the same COI or
decrease COI for urban area depending on detail design of road engineering.
(i) First stage: APs will present their complaints andgrievances verbally or in writing
to the CLAC. The CLAC will be obliged to provide immediate written confirmation
of receiving the complaint. If after 15 days the aggrieved AP does not hear from
the CLAC, or if the AP is not satisfied with the decision taken in the first stage, the
complaint may be brought to the District Office.
(ii) Second stage: The District Office has 15days within which to resolve the
complaint to the satisfaction of all concerned. If the complaint cannot be solved at
this stage, the District Office will bring the case to the Provincial Grievance
Redress Committee.
167
Appendix 5
(iii) Third stage: The Provincial GrievanceRedress Committee meets with the
aggrieved party and tries to resolve the situation. The Committee may ask for a
review of the DMS by the external monitor (EMO). Within 30 days of the
submission of the grievance, the Committee must make a written decision and
submit copies to the MPWT, PRS/IRC and the AP.
(iv) Final stage: If the aggrievedAP does not hear from the Provincial Grievance
Redress Committee or is not satisfied, he/she will bring the case to Provincial
Court. This is the final stage for adjudicating complaints. Within 30 days of the
submission of the grievance, the Court must make a written decision and submit
copies to the, MPWT, PRS/IRC and the AP. If any party is still unsatisfied with the
Provincial Court judgment, he/she can bring the case to a higher-level court.
Attendants List
Province: Kamchay Mear District
168
Appendix 5
169
Appendix 5
170
Appendix 6
PUBLIC INFORMATION BROCHURE (IRC) will supervise the implementation of existing road. The COI is narrower than the
the Resettlement Plan (RP). The Ministry of road right-of-way (ROW) that has been
Cambodia Provincial Roads Public Works and Transport (MPWT) has established along road section. The COI
Improvement Project established a Social and Environmental has a width of maximum 20 m (10 m either
Office (SEO) to implement and monitor the side of the road centerline). MPWT will
PUBLIC INFORMATION BOOKLET implementation of the RP for affected land, place demarcation markers on the ground
1. QUESTION: What is the Asian structures, crops and trees along the road. before a detailed measurement survey
Development Bank (ADB) Cambodia (DMS) starts. Its purpose is to define an
3. QUESTION: Are the improvements of
Provincial Roads Improvement Project? area reserved for the road improvements,
the roads and cross-border facility
and to establish who is affected by the
ANSWER: The Royal Government of intended to benefit us?
Project.
Cambodia (RGC) proposes to use funds ANSWER: Yes. The roads will be improved
from the Asian Development Bank (ADB) to Everyone that is occupying or using land in
to paved condition to provide a safer,
improve Provincial Road Improvement the COI must move out of the COI. All
cost-effective provincial road network with
Project No. 314D, 13 at Svay Rieng and people must also remove from land
all-year access to markets and other social
Prey Veng province and road numbers, acquired to expand the border facilities or
services for provincial centers in the project
150B, 53 and 151B at Kampong Chhnang for the road realignment. During detailed
areas Improved roads will enable the
and Kampong Speu province, and to design, every effort will be made to
transportation of goods and people to be
upgrade and expand the border facilities at minimize the impacts.
quicker, more efficient and cheaper. The
Prey Var in Kampong Rou district (Svay new and improved roads will improve A preliminary census and inventory of
Rieng province). The TA is part of a regional inter-provincial connectivity as well as losses (IOL) was conducted in May-June
project to improve road links between cross-border trade and movement at the 2011 to determine the potentially affected
Cambodia and Viet Nam on road No. 314D Prey Var-Moc Va border crossing point. persons and the severity of impacts on their
from NR-1 at Svay Teab to Kampong Rou properties. Based on the IOL, a preliminary
district and NR-13 from National road No. 1 4. QUESTION: If there are road
list of eligible persons and their losses has
to National Road No.8 at Prey Veng construction activities in our locality,
been prepared, and is available in your
province, NR-150B,53 and 151B from will we be affected?
commune office. After the detailed design
Taches to Amleang commune in Tphong ANSWER: There will be three main types of for road improvements is finalized and the
district (Kampong Speu province). land acquisition impacts: (i) expansion of COI demarcated, DMS will be conducted
The project will also support a sustainable the existing roads within the existing road and a final list of eligible persons prepared.
road maintenance regime in the Ministry rights of way; (ii) creation of a 1.2km new
5. QUESTION: What if my land will be
ofPublic Works and Transport (MPWT), alignment on PR150B at Chaung Moung
affected by the Project?
HIV/AIDS and human trafficking prevention commune requiring privately owned farming
program, road safety and climate change land; and (iii) expansion of the Cross Border ANSWER: Acquired privately owned land
adaptation measures. Facility at Prey Var requiring approximately will be compensated at replacement cost
5ha of land, of which 2.5ha is privately which is market value plus reasonable
2. QUESTION: Who is responsible for owned. transaction costs. Land within the existing
the Project? road right of way will not be compensated.
As part of the Provincial Road Improvement
ANSWER: The RGC represented by the However, those losing use of productive
Project, MPWT will establish a Corridor of
Inter-Ministerial Resettlement Committee (farming) land within the road right of way
Impact (COI) on 10m each side of the
171
Appendix 6
will be entitled to assistance for loss of land will be used by the Project and that they resettlement plan. Those relocating
use of productive land. must harvest their crops in time. If standing outside the road right of way altogether
crops are ripening and cannot be under this project will be entitled to higher
6. QUESTION: What are the entitlements
harvested, eligible affected persons can be levels of support compared to those
that we have in order to be
compensated for the loss of the relocating within the road right of way.
compensated?
unharvested crops at the current market
Affected persons will receive compensation
ANSWER: Cut off dates for entitlement to value. For perennial crops, affected
at replacement cost for affected structures
compensation and assistance have been persons will be compensated for the loss of
plus transitional allowances to assist in the
established for each project section fruit and timber trees at replacement value,
process of relocating. Transitional
corresponding to the date of completion of which value will take account of lost
assistance will consist of: (i) Transportation
the inventory of losses. The respective cut potential income and time required to
allowance; (ii) One time assistance
off dates are 20 May 2011 for PR314D; 2 re-establish the perennial trees. This will
allowance of $100 if movingback within the
June 2011 for NR13 and CBF; 12 June compensate for lost income until the newly
road right of way or $200 if moving outside
2011 for PR150B; 17 June 2011 for NR13; planted seedlings bear fruit. Affected
the road right of way; (iii) income loss
and 19 June 2011 for PR151B. Those persons will be awarded the full value of any
allowance for disrupted businesses; and (iv)
persons who have occupied and used the lost crops/fruit where the plants are near or
additional assistance for vulnerable
land prior to this cut off date are entitled to ready to harvest.
households. Renters will be eligible for
compensation if the project construction
9. QUESTION: What about public three months rental assistance.
affects their land and/or structures. Anyone
property resources?
who encroaches and occupies the land The specific amounts for compensation
after the cut off date will not be eligible for ANSWER: Affected buildings and rates as well as allowances and assistance
compensation or assistance. structures will be restored to original or will be advised at the time the resettlement
better condition. plan is updated.
7. QUESTION: Does compensation apply
to my affected houses or structures? 10. QUESTION: If in case there will be 11. QUESTION: If in case our livelihoods
relocation of houses or businesses are affected, how can the Project help
ANSWER: Yes. Houses and structures that
involved, how can the Project help me me restore my livelihood and living
will be affected by the Project shall be
rebuild my house during relocation? standards?
compensated at replacement cost without
deduction for depreciation or salvageable ANSWER: Affected persons will have the ANSWER: The census and detailed
materials. Partially affected houses will be option of moving back outside the corridor measurement survey (DMS) will take note
compensated for the lost affected portion as of impact but within the road right of way, or of the livelihoods of affected persons and
well as repair costs. Other structures (e.g. moving outside the right of way altogether. any impacts the Project may have. The
fences, wells, pavement) will also be Those relocating within the road right of way Project will provide various forms of
compensated at replacement cost. will be permitted to remain there until assistance to enable affected people to
theland is needed by the Government for restore their livelihoods and living
8. QUESTION: What about my crops and
any future public works but will not be conditions to at least pre-project levels. For
trees?
permitted to build permanent structures. If vulnerable households (e.g. those classed
ANSWER: For annual crops, affected such future displacement is required those as poor, disabled, etc.), the Project will
persons will be given advance notice that required to relocate will be entitled to similar seek to improve living standards to at least
the land on which their crops are planted forms of assistance as provided under this minimum national standards. Such forms of
172
Appendix 6
assistance will include: (i) one time will only be carried out in the presence of providing a translated version to each local
assistance allowance to households losing the affected persons. The affected persons district and commune office for public
more than 10% of the productive assets or and the local authorities will be informed access and by uploading it on ADB’s
being required to relocate their houses or prior to the activity. website.
shops outside the corridor of impact
13. QUESTION: How will the Project 14. QUESTION: If I disagree or problems
depending of the type and severity of
consult with me and provide arise during project implementation
impact; (ii) for those losing loss of use of
information? such as compensation, technical, and
productive land within the road right of way,
other project-related issues, do I have
cash assistance for loss of land use; (iii) ANSWER: The Project has prepared a
the right to voice my complaint?
cash assistance to cover transportation communication and consultation plan. The
costs; (iv) cash grant for temporary Project will keep local communities
ANSWER: Yes. If the affected person is not
disruption to business income for affected informed of significant activities. Regular
clear about or not satisfied with the
shops/stalls; (v) potentially other forms of information will be provided to the
compensation package offered or, if for any
income restoration measures to be commune offices, village chiefs and local
reason, the compensation does not
determined during updating of the community-based organizations as well as
resettlement plan in consultation with those materialize according to the agreed
other culturally recognized community
affected; and (vi) additional special schedule, the affected person has the right
leaders. The local commune offices will
to lodge a complaint. The grievance
assistance to vulnerable households. maintain a public notice board where
redress mechanism consists of a four stage
significant information and schedules will
In addition the Project will seek to maximize process as follows:
be posted. In addition to this affected
project work opportunities to adults in the
households will be consulted directly First Stage, Commune Level: An aggrieved
affected local communities (both men and
through public consultation meetings on person may bring his/her complaint to the
women) during the implementation phases.
significant matters affecting them. Such commune leader. The commune leader
Such opportunities will be announced in the
public consultation meetings will take place together with the representative/s of the
local areas.
(i) prior to the conduct of the DMS (to Provincial Resettlement Sub-Committee
12. QUESTION: What is the detailed advise survey schedules and procedures), Working Group (PRSC-WG) coming from
measurement survey and when will it be (ii) following the DMS (to advise of DMS the district offices will call for a meeting of
conducted? results and proposed mitigation measures), the Group to decide on a course of action
(iii) during preparation of the updated to resolve the complaint within 15 days
ANSWER: The DMS is a detailed survey of
resettlement plan (to identify appropriate following the lodging of the complaint by
100% of affected persons to document all
livelihood restoration measures, advise of the aggrieved person. The commune
affected assets including land, houses,
compensation rates and details of leader is responsible for documenting and
shops, other structures, crops and trees. It
allowances and assistance measures as keeping file of all complaints that are
establishes the official list of affected
well as details of resettlement coursed through it.
persons who are eligible for compensation
arrangements); and (iv) on-going through Second Stage, Provincial Resettlement
and other assistance. It will be conducted
implementation of the resettlement plan. In Sub-committee Working Group: If after 15
after detailed engineering for the road and
addition the Project will publically disclose days the aggrieved person does not hear
border facilities is completed, and the COI
the approved updated resettlement plan from the commune leader, or if the person
has been marked on the ground. The
through a public information brochure is not satisfied with the decision taken by
activity will be carried out early in the project
(distributed to all affected households), by the commune and district officials, the
implementation stage in 2012. The activity
173
Appendix 6
complaint can be brought to the office of expected to commence in the 4th quarter of 16. If you have further queries and
the PRSC-WG (provincial level), either in 2012. Affected communities will be kept suggestions, please contact us at:
writing or verbally. It is incumbent upon said informed of updated activity schedules from
(i) Provincial Department of Public Works
member of the PRSC-WG to notify the May 2012.
(PDPW) Resettlement Sub-Committee in the
other members of the Group. The Team
14. QUESTION: How will you know if following provinces: Svay Rieng, Kampong
Leader of the PRSC-WG will call for a
these undertakings are kept and the Chhnang. Prey Veng and Kampong Speu
meeting of the Group to decide on a course
objectives of this Project are met? Ministry of Public Works and Transport
of action to resolve the complaint within 15
(Phnom Penh) .
days following the lodging of the complaint ANSWER: All project activities will be
by the aggrieved person. The PRSC-WG is monitored by: The Social and Environment (ii) Project Management Unit 3, Provincial
responsible for documenting and keeping Office of the Project Management Unit-3 of Roads Improvement Project
file of all complaints that are coursed the Ministry of Public Works and Transport
Attention: Social and Environment Office
through it. and by an External Monitoring Agency
th
Third Stage, Inter-ministerial Resettlement (EMA). Address: 4 Floor, Eastern Building,
Committee: If after 15 days the aggrieved Corner Norodom Blvd. & Street 106, Phnom
person does not hear from the PRSC-WG, Monthly Report and Quarterly Reports will
Penh
or if the person is not satisfied with the be prepared and submitted to ADB. A
post-resettlement impact evaluation will Phone: [add]
decision taken by the PRSC-WG, the
also be undertaken to assess whether
complaint may be brought to the office of Email: [add]
impacts of the Project have been mitigated
the IRC, through the IRC-RD, either in
adequately and the pre-project standard of (iii) Inter-Ministerial Resettlement
writing or verbally. The IRC has 15 days
within which to resolve the complaint to the living of affected persons have been Committee, Resettlement Department,
satisfaction of all concerned. The IRC is restored as a result of the resettlement and Ministry of Economy and Finance (Phnom
responsible for documenting and keeping
project. ADB will also monitor these Penh) – Tel/Fax: 023 42 66 82
activities in its regular supervision missions
file of all complaints that reaches it. (iv) Asian Development Bank Resident
during project implementation. Semi-annual
Final Stage, Court of Law: If after 15 days Mission - Phnom Penh. Tel: (023) 215 805,
following the lodging of the complaint the reports of the EMA will be disclosed to
aggrieved person is not satisfied with the affected communities. Fax: 023 215 807
decision taken by the IRC, or if the person 15. QUESTION: Are there any other
does not hear from the IRC, the complaint documents available to know more
may be brought to a court of law for about the Project and resettlement
adjudication. The rules of court will be issues?
followed in the resolution of the complaint.
ANSWER: The draft RP prepared during
13. QUESTION: When is the project the feasibility studies for the Project can be
expect to start? obtained from the commune, district and
provincial offices. Following detailed
ANSWER: The project is expected to engineering design and the DMS, the RP
commence in April 2012. The updated will be updated and the final version will be
resettlement plan will require at least 4 available in these offices.
months to prepare and site clearance is
174
PART V
-i-
PART V
1 Introduction
Recognizing the potential risk that the road construction may exacerbate the spread of
HIV and the risk of human trafficking in the project areas, an integrated prevention and
mitigation package is included as part of the road project design. The HHTPP aims to
strengthen and scale-up previous and ongoing initiatives in the national umbrella
programs.
2 Background
National HIV Situation. Cambodia has made good progress in containing the HIV
epidemic with HIV prevalence falling from 1.2% in 2003 to an estimated 0.9% in 2006. The
decline has been attributed to the 100% Condom Use Programme and safe-sex campaigns
that have targeted brothel-based sex workers and their clients. However, a second wave of
HIV infections is being seen among most-at-risk populations, including indirect female sex
workers, clients of sex workers and their partners, men who have sex with men, and
injecting drug users (IDUs). The confluence of unprotected paid sex and sharing of
contaminated needles during female sex workers have decreased from 21.4% in 2003 to
12.7% in 2006. According to 2006 data, HIV prevalence among IDUs tested was at 14.3%.
As male clients of sex workers also have sex with their wives and girlfriends, more
traditionally low-risk women are increasingly getting infected. In 2006, among the total
number of people living with HIV, 52% were estimated to be women compared to 37% in
1998. In 2005m married women accounted for almost half of new infections.
Under the de-concentration and decentralization (D&D) policy of the Government, local
governments at district and commune levels are being strengthened to plan, implement and
manage their community development plans. In 2002, commune councils were established
in all of the 1,621 communes in the country, each on receiving a discretionary budget
of %15,000 per year as their community Sangkat fund. Selected communes are also
receiving additional funds from development partners (mainly from United Nations
Development Programme, United National Population Fund and United Nations Children’s
Fund) to create and pilot different committees on social sector issues, e.g. Commune
Committee on Women and Children. In line with the D&D policy, National Aids Authority
(NAA) mandated the creation of District AIDS Committees and Commune AIDS Committees
in 2006. Roll-out of this NAA sub-decree commenced in 2009, but it has been slow due to
limited funding.
Impact and Outcome. The impact of the proposed intervention if to have contributed to
achieving the Millennium Development Goal 6, Target 7: to have halted and begun to
reverse the spread of HIV/AIDS by 2015 in the Greater Mekong Sub-region. The outcome is
reduced HIV transmission and prevalence of sexually transmitted infections among workers
and communities associated with the Project and prevention of human trafficking. The
project will focus on four outputs: (i) community-based risk mitigation package for HIV and
human trafficking; (ii) focused HIV initiatives in the work setting/construction sites; (iii)
strengthened sexual and reproductive health services at district-level; and (iv) a rigorous
monitoring and evaluation system.
Methodology Outputs and Key Activities. The program will focus on four outputs:
Output 2: Focused HIV Initiatives in Work Settings. The output will be effective and
gender-responsive HIV and STI prevention services for the construction workforce,
entertainment and casino workers, and border police and officials. In collaboration with
the local AIDS authorities, NGO and other relevant government agencies, HIV prevention
activities and services should include the activities below.
4 Implementation Arrangements
MPWT will select a program-implementing consultant, which maybe a consulting firm, joint
venture, or consortium of consulting firms or an NGO, following the quality and cost-based
selection and simplified technical proposal in accordance with ADB’s Guideline on Use of
Consultants. The consultant team should consist of one national team leader(15 pm), one
national deputy team leader(15 pm), two national program officers( a total of 20 pm), and a
national M&E officer(4 pm). The civil works contractors and subcontractors need to be
involved in the HIV prevention program, as does the DDIS team representative.
The cost of the consulting services is estimated US$320,000. The details are shown in the
following table.
Cost Estimate($’000)
Item Cost ($)
1. National Consultants
a. Remuneration and Per Diem 160
b. Local Travel (air and land) 10
2. IEC Materials, Office and Communication Costs
• Print and audio-visual materials and equipment 10
• STI diagnostic kits, medicines and condoms 15
• Communication 5
3. IEC/BCC Activities, Trainings and Workshops 70
4. Facilitators and Outreach Workers 30
5. Contingencies 20
Total 320
BCC= Behavior Change Communication, IEC=Information, Education
and Communication, STI= sexually-transmitted infections