IELTS with Fiona

Task and possible response

Mobile phones have brought many benefits, but they have also had negative effects. Do the
disadvantages of having mobile phones outweigh the advantages?

Mobile phones have had an enormous impact on many aspects of our lives. They have
significantly changed the way we communicate with each other in both our personal and our
professional lives and they clearly have many advantages. However, there are several
drawbacks to being constantly available and connected to the internet, which I will outline
below.

By far the most common criticism of mobile phones is the fact that we are now expected to be
available 24/7. Before mobile phones were invented, the time spent away from work was our
own, but now it seems that the separation between work and free time has disappeared. In
addition, mobile phones pose certain health risks and can be dangerous if drivers use them at
the wheel or if people cross busy roads while texting. There have been several mobile-phone
related accidents and fatalities. A final negative effect is that in public places such as on the
train or at the cinema, there is no escape from the noise of annoying ringtones and loud, one-
sided conversations.

On the other hand, there are several obvious benefits. The most powerful argument in favour
of mobile phones is that they can be used to call for help in the most inaccessible places, for
example when a car breaks down in a remote area, and emergency services can be called to the
scene of an accident without delay. Moreover, being easily contactable every minute of the day
has real advantages for business people and for working parents.

To sum up, I feel that although there are some clear drawbacks to mobile phones, their
efficiency, portability and multi-functional abilities have greatly enhanced most aspects of our
lives and the plus points certainly offset the downsides.

(289 words)

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

IELTS CDT
Click here

Overall 7/0
● Task Achievement: 8.5
● Lexical Resource: 6.5
● Cohesion and Coherence: 6.0
● Grammatical Range and Accuracy: 7.0

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

IELTS podcast
Click here

Overall Band 6

● Task Achievement: 7.0

● Lexical Resource: 6.0
● Cohesion and Coherence: 5.5
● Grammatical Range and Accuracy: 6.5

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

Essay checker
Click here

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

Chat GPT

Please evaluate my essay according to the IELTS Writing Band Criteria. The question is:

Mobile phones have brought many benefits, but they have also had negative effects. Do the
disadvantages of having mobile phones outweigh the advantages?

Mobile phones have had an enormous impact on many aspects of our lives. They have
significantly changed the way we communicate with each other in both our personal and our
professional lives and they clearly have many advantages. However, there are several
drawbacks to being constantly available and connected to the internet, which I will outline
below.

By far the most common criticism of mobile phones is the fact that we are now expected to be
available 24/7. Before mobile phones were invented, the time spent away from work was our
own, but now it seems that the separation between work and free time has disappeared. In
addition, mobile phones pose certain health risks and can be dangerous if drivers use them at
the wheel or if people cross busy roads while texting. There have been several mobile-phone
related accidents and fatalities. A final negative effect is that in public places such as on the
train or at the cinema, there is no escape from the noise of annoying ringtones and loud, one-
sided conversations.

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

On the other hand, there are several obvious benefits. The most powerful argument in favour
of mobile phones is that they can be used to call for help in the most inaccessible places, for
example when a car breaks down in a remote area, and emergency services can be called to the
scene of an accident without delay. Moreover, being easily contactable every minute of the day
has real advantages for business people and for working parents.

To sum up, I feel that although there are some clear drawbacks to mobile phones, their
efficiency, portability and multi-functional abilities have greatly enhanced most aspects of our
lives and the plus points certainly offset the downsides.

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

Overall, your essay presents a clear and coherent argument in response to the question. You
have provided relevant examples and points to support your position, and have also
acknowledged and addressed counterarguments.

Based on the IELTS Writing Band Criteria, I would evaluate your essay as follows:

Task Response: 8

Your essay addresses the prompt and presents a clear position. You have provided relevant
examples and points to support your argument.

Coherence and Cohesion: 8

Your essay is well-organized, with a clear introduction, body, and conclusion. You have used
appropriate transitional devices to connect your ideas and maintain coherence.

Lexical Resource: 7

You have used a range of vocabulary effectively, including both general and specific words.
However, there is some repetition of words and phrases throughout the essay.

Grammatical Range and Accuracy: 7

Your grammar is generally accurate, and you have demonstrated some range in your sentence
structures. However, there are a few errors and awkward phrasings throughout the essay.

Overall, I would give your essay a band score of 7.5.

Please tell me more about the errors and awkward phrasings throughout the essay.
Overall, your essay is well-written with clear arguments and ideas. However, there are a few
errors and awkward phrasings that could be improved. Here are some examples:

● In the introduction, the first sentence is a bit awkwardly phrased. You could simplify it to
say "Mobile phones have had a significant impact on our personal and professional lives,
bringing many advantages but also some negative effects."
● In the second paragraph, the phrase "By far the most common criticism of mobile
phones is the fact that" could be simplified to "The most common criticism of mobile
phones is that."

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

● In the same paragraph, the phrase "Before mobile phones were invented, the time
spent away from work was our own" could be rephrased to "Before the invention of
mobile phones, we had more control over our free time."
● In the third paragraph, the sentence "Moreover, being easily contactable every minute
of the day has real advantages for business people and for working parents" could be
improved by using a different word than "real," as it sounds a bit vague. You could
replace it with "significant" or "meaningful."
● In the conclusion, the phrase "multi-functional abilities" could be simplified to
"versatility" or "range of functions."

Please tell me more about the repetition of words and phrases.

There is a noticeable repetition of words and phrases throughout the essay. For example, the
phrase "mobile phones" is used multiple times, especially at the beginning of sentences, which
can make the essay sound repetitive and monotonous.

Additionally, the phrase "drawbacks to mobile phones" is used twice in the second paragraph
and the phrase "most powerful argument in favour of mobile phones" is used twice in the third
paragraph. These repetitions can be avoided by using synonyms or rephrasing the sentence to
avoid repeating the same phrase or word.

Furthermore, the word "advantages" is repeated three times in the first paragraph and the
word "negative" is repeated twice in the same paragraph. These repetitions can be avoided by
using alternative words such as "benefits" or "positives" instead of "advantages" and
"disadvantages" or "downsides" instead of "negative".

Overall, varying the vocabulary and avoiding the repetition of words and phrases can improve
the flow and coherence of the essay.

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

Band 9 (Chat GPT)

Mobile phones have brought about numerous benefits to society, revolutionizing the way
people communicate and work. However, they have also brought about several negative effects
that must be considered. In this essay, I will discuss the advantages and disadvantages of
mobile phones and argue that while there are certainly drawbacks, the benefits outweigh them.

One of the most notable benefits of mobile phones is that they have greatly improved
communication, enabling people to easily connect with friends and family, regardless of
location. Additionally, mobile phones have expanded access to information and services,
allowing people to quickly and easily access the internet, make online purchases, and even
manage their finances. Another advantage is that mobile phones have improved safety,
allowing people to call for help in emergencies, and in some cases, even preventing accidents
through the use of GPS technology.

Despite these benefits, there are several drawbacks to mobile phones that must be considered.
One disadvantage is that they have contributed to the blurring of boundaries between work
and personal life, with many people feeling pressured to be available 24/7. Moreover, the
constant connectivity that mobile phones provide can lead to stress and anxiety, as people feel
the need to constantly check their devices. Additionally, mobile phone use has been linked to
certain health risks, such as increased exposure to electromagnetic radiation and the potential
for distracted driving accidents.

Despite these disadvantages, I believe that the benefits of mobile phones outweigh the
drawbacks. Mobile phones have undoubtedly improved people's lives in countless ways,
allowing them to communicate and access information and services more easily and quickly
than ever before. Moreover, mobile phones have become an essential tool in emergency
situations, potentially saving lives. While there are certainly valid concerns about the negative
effects of mobile phone use, these drawbacks can be mitigated through responsible use and
increased awareness of the potential risks.

In conclusion, while mobile phones have brought about several negative effects, including the
blurring of work-life boundaries and health risks, their advantages far outweigh their
disadvantages. Mobile phones have revolutionized communication, expanded access to
information and services, and improved safety in emergency situations. With responsible use
and increased awareness of the potential risks, mobile phones can continue to be an essential
tool in modern society.

377 words

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

My question: Please evaluate this Band 9 essay

Chat GPT response:

Overall, this essay presents a clear and well-organized argument regarding the advantages and
disadvantages of mobile phones. The writer effectively addresses the prompt, and the essay is
cohesive and easy to follow.

In terms of Task Response, the essay addresses the prompt in a clear and organized manner.
The writer provides a balanced assessment of the advantages and disadvantages of mobile
phones, and ultimately argues that the benefits outweigh the drawbacks. The essay stays on
topic and provides relevant examples to support the writer's claims.

In terms of Coherence and Cohesion, the essay is well-structured with clear topic sentences and
effective use of transition words and phrases. The writer effectively develops each paragraph,
and the ideas flow smoothly from one to the next. The essay is easy to read and understand.

In terms of Lexical Resource, the writer demonstrates a good range of vocabulary and uses
appropriate terminology throughout the essay. There is some repetition of words and phrases,
but this does not significantly detract from the quality of the essay. The writer effectively uses
collocations and idiomatic expressions to convey meaning.

In terms of Grammatical Range and Accuracy, the essay demonstrates a good command of
grammar and sentence structure. The writer effectively uses complex sentences to convey
meaning, and there are few grammatical errors. However, there are a few minor errors in
punctuation and sentence structure that could be improved.

Overall, this essay would likely score a Band 7 or 8 on the IELTS Writing Task 2, due to its
effective organization, clear and concise writing, and strong arguments. With a few minor
improvements, particularly in terms of grammatical accuracy, the essay could potentially score
higher.

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

Claude.ai

Mobile phones have become an integral part of modern life, providing numerous benefits to
users worldwide. However, their rapid proliferation has also led to some negative
consequences that cannot be ignored.

On the positive side, mobile phones allow us to stay connected with friends and family at all
times, no matter where we are. They provide easy access to information, entertainment, and
public services through the internet. Phones have also enabled innovative technologies like
ride-hailing and food delivery apps, remote working capabilities, and digital payments. For
many, a smartphone is the primary way to take photos, navigate unfamiliar places, and stay
safe in emergencies. On a societal level, mobile technology is helping bridge communication
gaps, promote financial inclusion for the unbanked, and disseminate education in remote
regions.

Despite such advantages, excessive mobile phone use has been linked to risks like increased
distracted driving, cyberbullying, and tech-addiction. The prevalence of smartphones has
reduced face-to-face interaction and diminished attention spans. Mobile devices have also
enabled the spread of misinformation and breaches of privacy on an unprecedented scale.
There are also concerns about potential health impacts like digital eye strain and cellular
radiation exposure from frequent use. The ease of access smartphones provide to potentially
harmful content like explicit material or violent images is another issue, especially for children.

While mobile phones provide connectivity and convenience, it is clear that proper usage habits
need to be encouraged among users. With mindful use and regulation, mobile phones can
continue providing immense value. But if misused, their disadvantages like distraction,
misinformation and tech-dependence may begin to outweigh their benefits to society.
Ultimately, awareness and balance are key to maximizing their advantages while minimizing
their risks.

280 words

I asked Claude to grade my original essay but it is not able to do this:

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

‘Unfortunately I do not have the capability to provide IELTS essay scores. IELTS essay scoring
requires human evaluators to assess qualities like task response, coherence, lexical resource,
grammatical range and accuracy based on the IELTS essay band descriptors. As an AI system
without deep understanding of language qualities or scoring criteria, I can only generate essays
in response to prompts, not evaluate them against the IELTS rubric. Providing accurate IELTS
scores would require more advanced NLP techniques and training on a dataset of scored essay
samples which I currently lack. While I cannot score essays myself, I can assist humans in
practicing and improving their essay writing skills to aim for better IELTS scores. But for formal
scoring, human raters are still necessary to judge essays against the IELTS standards. My role is
limited to providing essay content rather than evaluating quality or assigning scores. I apologize
that I cannot provide an IELTS band score for the sample essay I generated.’

I asked IELTSpodcast.com to rate Claude’s essay and I was totally shocked by the result: Band 6
(TA 6, CC 5.5 LR 6 GRA 6.5) This score is completely wrong.

Also, the explanations for each Band Criteria were completely wrong:

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

I asked Claude to correct this student’s essay:

Employers sometimes ask people applying for jobs for personal information,such as their
hobbies and interests, and whether they are single or married. Some people say that this
information may be relevant and useful. Others disagree. Discuss both views

Nowadays, when applying for a job people are requested to share their interests and leisure
time activities and also their marital status. Mojarity of the people think that this type of
personal information is good while the other oppose it. In my opinion giving such sort of
information is very helpful for the employers for finding for you the suitable position. This essay
will duscuss the both views with reasons.
First of all according to one school of thought asking such personal queries reveals your
personality traits, your areas of interest and what kind of things you are looking for in free time.
The employeer understands you and find out in what sort of activity you can additionally, what
are you capalble for and what are your intentions. Certain companies dont want married
employees as according to them married people could not pay attention tp their assigned job
properly due to their domestic and marital issues, but not in all cases.

Hovever, the other group of people see this viewpoint negatively. They think that such
questions are personal attack on a person. A person has no right over the personal life and
matters of other.

To sum up, giving clues about your habits and abilities or marital status at the interview is not
such a bad thing, unless not be misused or missinterpreted.

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

Claude rewrote it (NOT a good model)

Nowadays, when applying for a job people are requested to share their interests and leisure
time activities and also their marital status. The majority of people think that this type of
personal information is good while the others oppose it. In my opinion, giving such sort of
information is very helpful for the employers. This essay will discuss both views with reasons.

First of all, according to one school of thought, asking such personal queries reveals your
personality traits, your areas of interest and what kind of things you are looking for in free time.
The employer understands you and finds out in what sort of activity you can excel, what are
you capable of and what are your intentions. Certain companies don't want married employees
as according to them married people could not pay attention to their assigned job properly due
to their domestic and marital issues, but not in all cases.

However, the other group of people see this viewpoint negatively. They think that such
questions are a personal attack on a person. A person has no right over the personal life and
matters of others.

To sum up, giving clues about your habits and abilities or marital status at the interview is not
such a bad thing, unless not misused or misinterpreted.

I asked for specific information about the corrections and it gave me this list:

Grammatical Errors:
● Subject-verb agreement issues ("Mojarity of the people think" should be "Majority of
people thinks")
● Wrong word forms ("find out in what sort of activity you can additionally" should be
"find out what sort of activities you can excel in additionally")
● Missing words ("In my opinion giving such sort of information..." should have "the"
before information)
● Wrong prepositions ("good while the other oppose it" should be "good while others
oppose it")
● Missing articles ("According to them married people..." should have "the" before
married people)

Spelling Errors:
● "Mojarity" should be "Majority"

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved

 IELTS with Fiona

● "Duscuss" should be "Discuss"

● "Hovever" should be "However"
● "Capalble" should be "Capable"

Formatting/Structure Issues:
● Paragraphing needs improvement for visual clarity
● Introduction and conclusion are underdeveloped
● Ideas not organized coherently (views are mixed within paragraphs)

Vocabulary Issues:
● Word choice is informal in places (finding "for you" the position, "such sort of"
information)
● Repetition of words like "people"

Punctuation Errors:
● Missing commas after intro clauses ("Nowadays," "In my opinion," "First of all")
● Run-on sentences need dividing

Copyright IELTS with Fiona All rights reserved