Foster Shawn
Foster Shawn
ThesisAMK
SHAWN FOSTER
Degree programme
Physiotherapy
Abstract
The aim for this thesis is to create an educational information packeage for
physiotherapy students in Satakunta University of Applied Sciences about
physiotherapy in wound care management of diabetic foot ulcers. This was ac-
complished by doing an in-depth literature review from trusted sources about
the topic and to create an understanding of this information with its readers.
This topic was chosen to illuminate the role physiotherapist can and should
play in wound care, specifically when it comes to the management of diabetic
foot ulcers. Research supports the use of various modalities as well as thera-
peutic exercise when it comes to wound care. However more research is need-
ed evaluating the effectiveness of modalities specifically on diabetic foot ul-
cers.
Diabetes, wound care, diabetic foot ulcers, physiotherapy, modalities, off loading
CONTENTS
1 INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................................... 3
2 AIM AND OBJECTIVES .............................................................................................. 3
3 DIABETES .................................................................................................................... 4
3.1 Diabetes Mellitus Type I ........................................................................................ 4
3.2 Diabetes Mellitus Type II ....................................................................................... 5
3.3 How Diabetes Affects Wound Healing .................................................................. 8
4 DIABETIC FOOT ULCERS ....................................................................................... 10
4.1 Causes of Diabetic Foot Ulcers ............................................................................ 10
4.2 Consequences of Diabetic Foot Ulcers................................................................. 11
4.3 Diabetic Foot Clinical Examination ..................................................................... 11
4.4 Abnormal Wound Healing and Chronic Wounds ................................................ 12
5 PHYSIOTHERAPY IN DIABETIC FOOT ULCER .................................................. 13
5.1 What is a Physiotherapist’s Role in Wound Care ................................................ 14
5.2 Modalities ............................................................................................................. 15
5.2.1 Heating agents .......................................................................................... 15
5.2.2 Electrotherapy methods ........................................................................... 16
5.3 Exercise ................................................................................................................ 19
5.4 Offloading ............................................................................................................ 20
5.5 Shoe Modification ................................................................................................ 21
5.6 Standard Course of Wound Care Physiotherapy for Diabetic Foot Ulcers .......... 21
6 THESIS PROCESS AND METHODS ........................................................................ 22
7 DISCUSSION .............................................................................................................. 23
REFERENCES ................................................................................................................ 24
APPENDIX 1 .................................................................................................................. 30
1 INTRODUCTION
In this thesis diabetic foot ulcers (DFU’s) and what a physiotherapist can do in order
to treat and prevent them will be discussed thoroughly. Diabetic foot ulcers affect
approximately 15% of all diabetics, with almost 25% of these ulcers requiring ampu-
tations (Turan et al, 2015). Research shows that after the first amputation in diabetic
patients, 50% of the patients don’t live past 5 years. Approximately 73,000 non
traumatic diabetic amputations are performed every year in the USA. (Azura Vascu-
lar Care, 2017.) Diabetes is an ongoing and developing epidemic in the world, result-
ing in more deaths annually than breast cancer and AIDS combined yearly (South-
western Academic Limb Salvage Alliance, 2017). The Finnish Diabetes Association
reports that out of Finland’s 5.5 million people, there is a combined total of more
than 500 000 diabetics in the country. More specifically roughly 400 000 of those
diabetics have diabetes mellitus type 2. (Finnish Diabetes Association, 2016.) The
best way Physiotherapist can prevent diabetic foot ulcers in our patients is try and
prevent them from getting diabetes in the first place (Turan et al, 2015). Which we
can accomplish by promoting a healthy and active lifestyle that can be maintained for
the remainder of their life. Further on in this thesis how wounds heal, what diabetes
is, how diabetes affects wound healing and the complications it can create for the pa-
tient, what a diabetic foot ulcer is, how to manage them from the physiotherapy point
of view will be discussed.
3 DIABETES
Diabetes mellitus type I (DM1) is a chronic condition in which the pancreas fails to
produce enough insulin or any at all. Insulin is a vital hormone that enables us to
produce energy by allowing glucose to enter our cells. The exact cause of DM1 is
unknown, however there are various different reasons and risk factors believed to aid
in developing this condition. Physically the body may turn on itself and destroy the
insulin-producing cells found in the pancreas (islet cells), but why this happens ex-
perts aren’t sure. (Mayo Clinic, 2020.) According to Physiopedia (2021) DM1 is a
“autoimmune disease that leads to the destruction of insulin-producing pancreatic
beta cells”.
There are fewer signs and symptoms to Diabetes Mellitus Type 1 than there is in Di-
abetes Mellitus Type 2, and these ones are often objectively less severe. The com-
mon symptoms of Type 1 are as follows: extreme hunger, fatigue, increased thirst,
mood changes, unintended weight loss, irritability, weakness, blurred vision, fre-
quent urination, and bed-wetting in children who didn’t do so previously. These
symptoms often appear suddenly. (Mayo Clinic, 2020.) DM1 may be rapidly diag-
nosed which is believed to be because it presents similarly to the flu (JDRF, 2021).
Risk factors for developing DM1 are as follows: age, family history, genetics, and
geography (Mayo Clinic, 2020). Physiopedia identifies that the following are associ-
ated co-morbidities: retinopathy, cardiomyopathy, hypoglycemia, diabetic foot dis-
ease, amputation, neuropathy, nephropathy, diabetic ketoacidosis (Physiopedia,
2021). Type one diabetes can occur/develop at any age, however there are two age
groups where it seems to occur the most. Four years old to seven years old are the
first age group, followed by ten years old to fourteen years old in the second age
group. Having anyone in your immediate family with DM1 increases your risk of
developing it yourself. (Mayo Clinic, 2020.) According to the ADA if the father has
DM1, the odds of the child getting it are 1 in 17. If the mother has DM1 and the child
was born before her turning 25 the risk is 1 in 25, but if the child was born after her
turning 25 the risks is 1 in 100. However there are always exceptions; 1 in 7 people
with DM1 has Type 2 Polyglandular Autoimmune Syndrome. If a parent has this
condition then the odds of the child having DM1 is 1 in 2. (American Diabetes Asso-
ciation, 2018.) Statistics tend to show that the prevalence of diabetes type one tends
to increase the farther away you are from the equator (Mayo Clinic, 2020). The pos-
session of specific genes increase your risk of developing DM1, and these genes can
vary from ethnicity to ethnicity (American Diabetes Association, 2018).
Overtime DM1 can cause various different complications to occur within the body.
However maintaining a healthy blood sugar level can reduce the risk or severity of
those complications. (Mayo Clinic, 2020.) Diabetes mainly affects your cardiovascu-
lar system, nerves, kidneys and eyes, as is relevant from the associated co-
morbidities listed above from Physiopedia (2021). These complications occur be-
cause the sugar levels in the blood stream get too high and damage the interior walls
of the big and small arteries. The body responds to this by creating a layer of plaque
(to protect from further damage), which reduces the blood flow to the legs, feet, kid-
neys and eyes. This is known as atherosclerosis, when it is prevalent in the legs and
feet and it is then known as Peripheral Arterial Disease (PAD). Diabetes makes PAD
much more difficult to manage, and it can lead to amputation if not treated properly.
(Society for Vascular Surgery, 2019.) Diabetes mellitus type 1 also damages the
nerves because high blood sugar weakens the small blood vessels (as mentioned
above) and they are responsible for supplying the nerves with blood (Mayo Clinic,
2020).
Diabetes mellitus type II (DM2) is different from DM1 in a few different ways.
Where as type one occurs from the pancreas not producing enough insulin or any at
all, type two occurs from the pancreas not producing enough insulin or the cells not
responding effectively to the insulin released. Type two usually occurs in adults, but
can also occur in children. In recent years there have been more and more cases of
type two diabetes in adolescents, and this can be attributed to the increased in child-
hood obesity throughout the world. The exact cause for why the body does not re-
spond to insulin correctly or doesn’t produce enough is also unknown for type 2 dia-
betes. There is no cure for DM2 either, but eating healthy, regular exercise, and
weight loss have proven to help manage diabetes. (Mayo Clinic, 2020.) Physiopedia
(2021) summarizes DM2 well by stating “your fat, liver, and muscle cells do not re-
spond correctly to insulin, known as insulin resistance.” This incorrect response to
insulin unfortunately results in blood sugar reaching excessive levels in the blood
stream, which is known as hyperglycemia (Physiopedia, 2021).
Diabetes Type 2 has more symptoms than DM1 and they are generally more severe.
However, these symptoms are usually slow to develop, which often leads to people
having this type of diabetes for years without knowing it. So early diagnosis is diffi-
cult, but very important to reduce irreparable damage that diabetes could to do the
body. The most common symptoms of DM2 are as follows: increased thirst and hun-
ger, frequent urination, areas of darkened skin (typically in the neck and armpits),
frequent infections, fatigue, unintended weight loss, blurred vision, numbness or tin-
gling in the hands and feet, and slow healing sores. (Mayo Clinic, 2020.)
There are many more known risk factors for DM2 than DM1. These risk factors are
as follows: weight, inactivity, blood lipid levels, fat distribution, family history, age,
race and ethnicity, polycystic ovary syndrome, pregnancy related health issues, and
prediabetes. Being obese or even just overweight increases your chance of develop-
ing DM2. Physical inactivity also increases your risk because physical activity in-
creases your body’s response to insulin, uses stored glucose, and helps control your
weight. Low levels of the good cholesterol HDL (high-density lipoprotein) and high
levels of triglycerides are associated with a higher risk for developing DM2 (affects
insulin production and sensitivity). If your fat storage occurs mainly in your abdo-
men instead of your thighs and hips you are more likely to develop DM2 (affects liv-
er function). You can measure waist circumference, and for a male with more than
101.6cm or a female with more than 88.9cm circumference you fall into this in-
creased risk category. Having a parent or sibling with DM2 increases your risk. Your
age is a risk factor because studies show that you are at an increased risk of develop-
ing DM2 the older you get, especially after aging past 45 years old. Experts are still
unsure why, but some specific ethnicities (Native American, Asian, Pacific Islanders,
and African Americans) are at an increased risk of developing DM2. (Mayo Clinic,
2020.) Physiopedia also notes the following associated co-morbidities: obesity, car-
diovascular disease, neuropathies, retinopathy, skin wounds or infections, stroke, hy-
perglycemia, reduced pulmonary functions, hypertension, nonalcoholic fatty liver
disease (NAFLD), and dyslipidemia. They also go on to break down DM2 affects on
the body based on organs. It is briefly discussed but DM2 can result in damaged ocu-
lar blood vessels that could lead to glaucoma, cataracts, retinopathy and even blind-
ness. The nervous system can become damaged by high blood sugar (hyperglycemia)
weaking the walls of small blood vessels. Resulting in not enough nutrients being
delivered to the nerves. Hyperglycemia forces the kidneys to work harder when fil-
tering your blood, eventually resulting in your kidneys being overworked, potentially
resulting in kidney failure. Extended periods of time with badly managed blood sugar
can result in various cardiac illnesses/conditions. Some of which are: atherosclerosis,
stroke and heart attacks. (Physiopedia, 2021.) Polycystic ovary syndrome is a risk
factor because most of the women with this condition are insulin resistant, which we
know is part of diabetes (CDC, 2020). If you develop gestational diabetes while
pregnant or birth a baby heavier than 4kg’s you are at an increased risk of developing
DM2 (Mayo Clinic, 2020). Gestational diabetes results in insulin resistance during
pregnancy, and increases your likelihood of developing DM2 after giving birth due
to the insulin resistance. Birthing a baby heavier than 4kg can point to DM2 because
the mother has insulin resistance (which is case with gestational diabetes) the babies
pancreas will produce more insulin. This extra insulin in the baby results in excess
fat to form on it, making it larger that it should be. (Freeborn, et al.)
Diabetes Mellitus Type 2 has some similar complications as Diabetes Mellitus Type
1, but in general has more complications that are typically more severe. Similarly to
DM1, DM2 also damages your major organs such as your nerves, kidneys, cardio-
vascular system, and eyes. However, it also can lead to slow healing, skin conditions,
sleep apnea, hearing impairment, and dementia. Like DM1, DM2 causes nerve dam-
age (neuropathy) in the limbs, especially the lower limbs. This occurs because over-
time high blood sugar can destroy or damage nerves, producing numbness, pain,
burning, tingling, or loss of feeling at the distal ends of the extremities and slowly
works up the extremities. However, DM2 can also affect the nerves in the heart, di-
gestive system and male reproductive organs. If it affects the heart, it can cause ir-
regular heart rhythms. In the digestive system in can cause diarrhea, nausea, consti-
pation, or vomiting. In the male reproductive organs it may cause erectile dysfunc-
tion. DM2 also damages your kidneys, and may lead to chronic kidney disease or
even a kidney transplant. If it affects your heart it could lead to a stroke, atheroscle-
rosis, high blood pressure and various heart diseases. DM2 can also lead to blind-
ness, glaucoma, cataracts, and retina blood vessel damage. Diabetes can lead to slow
wound healing, resulting in small cuts or injuries turning into infections that cause
severe damage and may require amputation (which will be discussed more later).
DM2 has been proved to increase your risk of bacterial or fungal infections of the
skin. Sleep apnea is still a bit of a mystery when it comes to diabetes. Obesity has
been proven to be a key factor in sleep apnea, but it is unclear as to whether or not
controlled blood sugar helps in the management and treatment of this condition.
(Mayo Clinic, 2020.) Diabetes can also lead to hearing problems or loss, and this is
believed to be because of damage to the nerves and blood vessels in the inner ear due
to high blood sugar (diabetes.co.uk, 2019). According to the Mayo Clinic (2020)
“Type 2 diabetes seems to increase the risk of Alzheimer’s disease and other disor-
ders that cause dementia. Poor control of blood sugar levels is linked to more-rapid
decline in memory and other thinking skills”
The hyperglycemic conditions that result due to diabetes complicates wound healing
for a variety of reasons. This phenomenon is increasing around the world due to in-
adequate control or prevention measures. (Patel et al, 2019.) Vijayakumar et al states
“Approximately 50-70% of all the limb amputations are because of diabetic wounds
and it was reported that in every 30s, once leg is amputated due to diabetic wounds in
worldwide.” Diabetes inhibits all phases of wound healing which results in a nega-
tive long-term effect of reduced life quality with increased morbidity and morality.
Diabetic wounds are associated with delayed acute wound and chronic wounds re-
sulting in inhibited healing due to a incomplete, uncoordinated, or postponed healing
process. Diabetic wounds are associated with a consistent inflammatory phase that
reduces the formulation of mature granulation tissue and reduced wound tensile
strength. This is believed to occur due to the vascular damage that occurs in diabetes,
which results in ischemia. It is widely known that diabetes is associated with poor
wound healing, however the direct link between diabetic pathophysiology and poor
wound healing is unknown. For proper healing it is known that there is a need for
inflammatory cells to collaborate with biochemical mediators, however the alteration
of those mediators has been shown to cause failure in wound healing in diabetics.
Diabetes can be one cause for biochemical mediator alteration. (Patel et al, 2019.)
There are various factors that can lead to delayed or poor wound healing in diabetics.
However, when it comes to diabetic specific conditions the most common reasons for
poor or delayed wound healing is due to hypoxia, ischemia, metabolic deficiencies
(such as hypoxia due to glycation of hemoglobin), alteration of red blood cell mem-
branes, and blood vessel narrowing (Brem & Tomic-Canic, 2007) Hypoxia is the
term used for decreased oxygen delivery to wounds due to the narrow blood vessels.
Glycation of hemoglobin results in hypoxia because it creates a inadequate supply of
oxygen and nutrients to tissues. Glucose deficiency, hypoxia, and deformed proteins
create a stress response to cell by gradual growth of unfolded proteins that are
housed within the ER (endoplasmic reticulum). (Schürmann et al, 2014.)
Ischemia is another common reason for poor wound healing in diabetics. As dis-
cussed earlier, the blood vessel coat their inner layers with plaque to protect the
blood vessels. This plaque build up results in decreased blood flow, which is exactly
what ischemia is. (Schürmann et al, 2014.) Hypoxic conditions can be a result of is-
chemia, if this occurs then a specific micro RNA (MiR-210) is induced and reduces
proliferation of keratinocytes (Biswas et al, 2010). There are also other micro RNA’s
that can have various effects in diabetic wound healing, specifically on inflammation
delay, keratinocyte and fibroblast migration, epithelialization, angiogenesis and re-
epithelialization (Patel et al, 2019).
4 DIABETIC FOOT ULCERS
Diabetic foot ulcers occur in approximately 15% of patients with diabetes, and ap-
proximately 14-24% of patients that develop these ulcers, require amputations. Ac-
cording to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2012) diabetic foot ulcers
are the leading cause of non-traumatic lower extremity amputations in the United
States. The result of these amputations are associated with a major decrease in quali-
ty of life, morbidity, and a heavy financial burden; but perhaps most important of all,
the post-amputation patient survival is only 50% for 5 years after surgery (Turan et
al, 2015).
Often time’s foot ulcers can become quite large or severe in diabetic patients before
they even realize they have them. This can occur because of peripheral neuropathy
that develops as diabetes progresses. These ulcers can occur from something as sim-
ple as walking a lot in a new pair of shoes. But since diabetics with the peripheral
neuropathy cannot fully feel their hands and feet, they may accidentally wear im-
proper fitting shoes, which can lead to these ulcers. In most healthy people, this sce-
nario would only cause a small blister, but since diabetics typically have poor blood
flow paired with dull sensations, it can progress quiet quickly to a muscle or bone
infection that may inevitably lead to amputation in an attempt to save the patients
life. (Boike et al, 2010.)
Diabetes Type 1 and Type 2 can develop these ulcers, although they are much more
likely to occur in Diabetes Type 2. Studies have also shown that males are more like-
ly to develop Diabetic Foot Ulcers (DFU’s) than females. One Turkish study reports
that of the 142 participants they studied, 65% of them were males. The occurrence of
these ulcers are more closely linked to the length of time that diabetes has been pre-
sent, rather than the patients age at diabetes onset. Meaning that the longer the pa-
tient has had diabetes, the more likely they are to develop a DFU. More often then
not, DFU’s occur due to peripheral neuropathy (damage to the peripheral nervous
system) or peripheral artery disease (PAD – narrowing of the peripheral arteries).
(Turan et al, 2015.)
Diabetic Foot Ulcers can be divided into primary and secondary pathologies, even
though multiple factors are involved in the development of them. Primary patholo-
gies are limited to vasculopathy (any condition that affects the blood vessels) and
peripheral neuropathy (damage to the peripheral nerves). Meanwhile secondary pa-
thologies are isolated to hyperglycemic complications. DFU’s may be ischemic
(15%), neuroischemic (50%), or neuropathic (35%). Poorly controlled blood sugar
levels often cause damage to the neural cells. Damage to the neural cells can result in
sensory, autonomic, and motor neuropathy. Which would result in decreased sensory
perception, altered or adapted foot anatomy and skin cracks. The decreased blood
flow to the feet can be a result of various vascular conditions, whether that is macro-
vascular or microvascular. Typically ulcers tend to develop in the feet following
thermal, chemical, or physical trauma. Foot deformities often result in diabetic pa-
tients, and can easily lead to DFU’s if the patient does not take proper care of their
feet and inspect them regularly. With foot deformities comes partnered with a de-
creased ability for the foot to absorb forces while walking or during other weight
bearing activities. This often results in increased pressure in the metatarsophalangeal
and subtalar joints, which can lead to the development of diabetic foot ulcers if left
untreated. (Turan et al, 2015.)
When assessing a diabetic foot wound, it is imperative to assess the neurologic, vas-
cular, musculoskeletal and dermatologic findings. In order to do that you must assess
for any swelling, pain, redness, warmth, numbness or neuropathy type sensations,
peeling, callus, nail deformities, skin breaks, and blisters. The examiner should check
all surfaces of the foot in addition to the nails and compare them to the hands. In or-
der to determine what type of DFU the ulcer is, there are a variety of different tests
that can be preformed. (Turan et al, 2015.)
In order to determine what type of DFU that patient has, it is important to perform
accepted diagnostic tests. In order to assess if the ulcer is neuropathic, you need to
evaluation the patient’s protective sensations that should be present in the foot. The
most common ways to do this are: testing for a vibration sensation using a tuning
fork, using a two point discrimination tool for superficial sensation, and using a
monofilament to check for pressure sensations. (Turan et al, 2015.) To evaluate if the
ulcer is ischemic you need to check for proper blood flow into and out of the foot.
This can be done a few different ways, with the most common being Ankle Brachial
Index (ABI) testing. In ABI testing a Doppler is used to assess the blood pressure in
the ankle and upper arm. They should be approximately equal, if the ankle is lower it
indicates PAD, which essentially means reduced blood flow thus categorizing the
ulcer as ischemic. When checking to see if the ulcer is neuroischemic, you will need
to test for neuropathic and ischemic type ulcers using the methods mentioned previ-
ously. If there are positive findings in both categories, then the ulcer is deemed neu-
roischemic. (Myers, 2012.)
When a wound does not complete the inflammatory process or is not progressing as
it should, it is suspected to be healing abnormally or that it has become a chronic
wound. Abnormal wound healing is examined clinically if the healing process is
slower than expected by noticing periwound (typically used to refer to the 4cm area
surrounding the wound) or the wound itself for a significant decrease in the nor-
mal/expected markers of sufficient wound healing for each phase. Unfortunately,
chronic wound pathophysiology is not completely understood. (Myers, 2012, p.20.)
There are currently three known common causes for chronic inflammation. They are:
the existence of a foreign body in the area, cytotoxic agents, and finally repetitive
mechanical trauma. Foreign bodies increase the inflammation process in an attempt
to cleanse the wound. Repeated mechanical trauma constantly restarts the inflamma-
tion phase, because you are constantly introducing another trauma to the injury. Cy-
totoxic agents prolong the inflammation process because the kill or incapacitate hu-
man cells. (Myers, 2012, Chapter 2.)
Physiotherapists often receive a basic amount of education in this field, with most of
the education, training, and practice occurring in post-graduate areas. These areas are
often self-study, mentorships, continuing education courses, or on the job training in
wound care facilities or teams and are more plentiful in the United States of America.
Getting specialized in this field takes lots of time and dedication, but allows for phys-
iotherapist to better treat their patients in a wound care setting. (Academy of Clinical
Electrophysiology and Wound Management, 2017.)
Outcomes have steadily been better when DFU patients are cared for by a interdisci-
plinary team. There are several different professions that would be beneficial to this
interdisciplinary team. However the most beneficial ones may be a physiotherapist,
podiatric or vascular surgeon, diabetologist, and a wound care specialist or nurse.
(Turan et al, 2015.)
5.2 Modalities
There are two main forms of modalities that will be discussed in this thesis, heating
agents and electrotherapy methods. The heating agents discussed will be ultrasound,
global heat treatment, local heat treatment, and infrared treatment. The electrotherapy
methods discussed will be laser treatment, shock wave therapy (ESWT), electrical
stimulation, galvanic current treatment, and magnetic field treatment.
Heating agents have been proven to have a positive effect on healing when there are
no contraindications affecting it. Heating agents have this effect by promot-
ing/increasing vasodilation. (Turan et al, 2015.) As discussed previously, it is im-
perative for wounds of any kind and size to have adequate blood flow for it to heal
completely and timely. Heat helps to promote vasodilation by sending signals to
thermoreceptors. These receptors initiate the blood vessels to relax - or dilate - allow-
ing for greater blood flow to occur closer to the skin. This happens as an effort to
dissipate the heat and causes heat loss across the skin. (Gillam, 2015.)
In a study conducted in 2007, it was proven that exposing the patient to global heat
prior to electrical stimulation increased healing rates. Global heat was accomplished
by keeping the patient in a room that was 32 degrees Celsius for 20 minutes. The
study demonstrated a 20% higher healing rate for global heat treatment than with lo-
cal heat or no heat treatments. Local heat also increased blood flow and resulted in a
higher healing rate, but paled in comparison to the results of global heat. Laser Dop-
pler ultrasound measured blood flow during these tests. However, it must be said that
local heat is much more attainable for clinicians to provide for their clients that glob-
al heat. Local heat was provided by using a heat lamp at 37 degrees Celsius that was
targeting the wound for 20 minutes. This study lasted for 4 weeks, and the electrical
stimulation (e-stim) used was biphasic e-stim (20 mA) 3 times a week for the full 4
weeks. (Turan et al, 2015.)
Ultrasound is also a form of deep heat, but starts out as sound waves. In ultrasound,
the sound waves turn into heat energy once the pass through a homogenous environ-
ment. Ultrasound’s use in chronic wound healing has been studied very extensively
when compared to the use of other modalities. So much so that there are multiple dif-
ferent forms and techniques to doing it. A systemic review published in 2011 took on
the daunting challenge of sifting through several studies and have discov-
ered/observed that low-intensity, low-frequency, noncontact ultrasound is the most
beneficial when it comes to diabetic foot ulcer healing. This systemic review looked
at studies with low frequency’s being between 20-30 kHz. It is important to note that
Ultrasound does have various contraindications. Those contraindications are typical-
ly considered to consist of pregnancy, plastic or metal implant, malignant lesion, car-
diac pacemaker, hemorrhagic diathesis, cardiac failure, and acute infection when di-
recting acoustic energy over the area. (Turan et al, 2015.)
Several studies have been conducted evaluating various types of ultrasound, and it
appears that the most common and recommended is the MIST Therapy System
(MIST) or a device similar in function. MIST is a device that is essentially a water
gun that sprays a mist of saline solution. The MIST device (and other noncontact
low-frequency ultrasound device) should be held 0.5 – 1.5cm from the wound, the
saline mist being sprayed onto the wound bed stimulates cellular activity. This
should typically be done three times a week, with each session being 2-13 minutes.
Not only does this type of device promote cellular activity, but also is a form of
maintenance debridement and cleans wounds. However, it is important to note that
this modality is only a part/supplement to wound care. (Aetna, 2021.)
Several studies have shown the efficacy of electrical stimulation (e-stim) when being
used to strengthen muscles; however it can also be used to aid in wound healing. E-
stim accomplishes this by creating a short pulse of electrical stimulus that is intended
to copy the body’s natural electrical system and to stimulate wound healing. E-stim
accomplishes this by affecting the cellular calcium channels, which promotes greater
nitric oxide production. This is desirable because nitric oxide is a strong vasodilator,
it may also change forms and take on the role of a strong bactericidal. Nitric oxide is
also known to increase epithelization rates and collagen storage by promoting glu-
cose transfer into cells. (Thakral, 2013.) E-stim also has been proven to stimulate
several wound healing cells, such as macrophages, keratinocytes, neutrophils, and
fibroblasts by interacting with several signaling mechanisms. (Petrofsky et al, 2010).
There have been various studies to evaluate the effectiveness of specific waveforms
and intensities. There has not been a widely accepted/agreed best option, just that the
studies have showed e-stim can make a significant statistical difference in wound
healing rates. It is also important to note that a cardiac pacemaker is a contraindica-
tion to e-stim. (Thakral, 2013.)
Extracorporeal shock wave therapy (ESWT) is a way of addressing specific soft tis-
sue injuries. ESWT is similar to ultrasound in the sense that it uses sound waves.
However, ESWT delivers stronger amounts of energy compared to ultrasound. So
strong, that even though it is non-invasive, the waves can pass through the soft tis-
sues and reach the bones. ESWT is classified as low, middle, or high energy based
off of the mJ/mm2 delivered. For DFU’s it is recommended to use 0.03mJ/mm2 (low
energy is classified as 0.1 mJ/mm2 or lower) two times a week. (Thakral, 2013.) The
objective when administering one of these treatments is to achieve 100 pulses/cm2,
which may take up to 30 minutes per area (Moretti et al, 2009).There have only been
2 studies done that tests ESWT’s effectiveness on DFU’s, but the results are promis-
ing. However, the contraindications that go along with this type of treatment are:
cardiac bypass operation, major cancer, coagulation disorder, and active pregnancy.
(Thakral, 2013.)
In physiotherapy low-level lasers (also known as cold lasers) are mainly utilized.
These lasers are believed to work by increasing blood flow to the area. (Thakral,
2013.) Physiopedia (2020) states it “is used for pain relief, accelerated tissue regen-
eration and reduction of inflammation”. Cold lasers work by emitting 1 wavelength
of light. That light is believed to work by providing the needed stimuli for the cells to
kick it up a notch (so to speak) in the healing process. However, there has not been
much research with this modalities efficacy for DFU’s specifically, and calls for fur-
ther investigation. But the results we currently have available are promising. (Physi-
opedia, 2020.)
5.3 Exercise
It is also important to remember that all though modalities are highly recommended
to use, so is therapeutic exercise. Within therapeutic exercise we have 4 goals: im-
prove/promote circulation/healing, proper gait training, maintain/improve range of
motion, maintain/improve sensation in the extremities. Studies prove that exercise is
effective for patients with DFU’s and in preventing them from occurring in the first
place. Specifically exercises aimed at improving range of motion, Buerger-Allen ex-
ercises, stretching, balance, and proprioception. (Turan et al, 2015.)
Other recommended exercises involve ROM and stretching to help increase blood
flow to the area, which again, promotes healing. The specific exercises that have
been studied and resulted in improved ulcer healing are as follows active dorsiflex-
ion, inversion, plantar flexion, and eversion of the ankles on the effected leg. Exer-
cises studied to prevent/reduce improper plantar pressure while walking and ROM
are as follows: active and passive dorsiflexion of the metatarsophalangeal and ankle
joints, active ankle supination and pronation, plantar flexion, and stretching the so-
leus and gastrocnemius muscles. (Turan et al, 2015.)
5.4 Offloading
The International Working Group on the Diabetic Foot (IWGDF) has published of-
floading guidelines in an effort to make a more uniformed approach to this area of
treatment (Bus et al, 2020). Several studies over the years have tried to accomplish a
similar goal. In a literature review from 2010 they discuss how there is a lack of uni-
form intervention when it comes to offloading. There are different types of offload-
ing available, and even more ways to implement them. For example, total contact
casting (TCC) has been thought of as the “gold standard” for offloading. However,
clinicians can apply a TCC in a variety of ways, shapes and sizes. (Cavangah & Bus,
2010.) The IWGDF guidelines state that the ideal TCC for plantar forefoot or mid-
foot ulcer (most common areas for ulcers) is to use a knee-high non-removable cast
(Bus et al, 2020).
The Rosalind Franklin University of Medicine and Science released a video in 2012
aimed at creating a easily understandable video for patient education for DFU’s.
However, this video is also a incredible resource for professionals looking to increase
their own knowledge for DFU’s and offloading specifically. This explains how im-
portant offloading is and its necessity for a DFU to properly heal. In the video they
site several studies that address various healing mechanisms and TCC’s have the
highest healing rate by more than 20%. The purpose of a offloading device is to help
evenly distribute your weight among your foot to give the ulcer the rest/ability to
heal properly. A big reason that TCC’s are more effective than other offloading
methods is it is more difficult for patients to be noncompliant. It has often been ob-
served that if a patient is given a diabetic walking boot (DWB) to wear that they will
not wear it as directed, versus in a TCC (or a DWB that has been modified for harder
removal) the patient has extreme difficulty removing the device themselves making it
that much harder for them to be non-compliant. A DFU heals at approximately 1mm
a day. It is common that patients’ will not wear their offloading devices in their own
homes or if they are only taking a few steps. However this is one of the worst deci-
sions they can make. For each step they take without a offloading device, they are
losing one day of healing. (Rosalind Franklin University of Medicine and Science,
2012.)
It is also worth mentioning that another form of off-loading is shoe modification. Di-
abetics may be recommended by their physicians to purchase some diabetic shoes.
These shoes are often custom made, with the intent to prevent DFU’s before they
form. However, the TCC’s and other forms of off-loading are to treat DFU’s that
have already formed. It is known that repetitive trauma is a factor in developing a
DFU. The most common trauma that results in DFU’s stem from improper fitting
shoes, which is another reason why modified shoes are so important to prevent these
from forming. These may also be recommended on the notice of a foot deformity be-
ginning to develop and may need to be adjusted/modified further as time progresses.
(Turan et al, 2015.)
5.6 Standard Course of Wound Care Physiotherapy for Diabetic Foot Ulcers
Total contact casting (TCC) has become the gold standard of treatment when it
comes to DFU’s. TCC is a form of pressure offloading done by molding and placing
a cast around the injured extremity. These casts are very similar to the casts that we
tend to think of when we think of a broken leg or ankle. The key differences with
TCC are that the cast covers the toes and it is a tighter fit. There are five main rea-
sons this is believed to work so well. The first reason is that with the cast being
molded correctly it allows for weight bearing forces to be evenly distributed all
around the foot while being rerouted from the area of injury. The cast also provides
protection and benefits without immobilizing the patient, which is thought to en-
hance patient adherence. With this cast being a snug fit, it prevents shearing forces
from occurring by immobilizing the foot and ankle. This snug fit also helps with
edema and improves local circulation; those being the third and fourth reason. The
last reason being it also covers the toes, assisting to protect them from damage and
bacteria. (Myers, 2012, Chapter 13.)
The research conducted in this thesis was obtained via several literature reviews tar-
geting wound care, modalities, exercises, and diabetes, and webinars from various
wound care specialists. Various search engines were used to obtain this information,
including PubMed, Pedro and Google Scholar. Information was found using various
search terms such as: Diabetes, wound care, diabetic foot ulcers, physiotherapy, mo-
dalities, off loading, exercises, electrical stimulation, ultrasound, therapeutic heat,
galvanic current, magnetotherapy. An educational package for the physiotherapy stu-
dents in NPH19SP was created so they could pilot it within their Cardiopulmonary
Physiotherapy course taught by Mari Törne in Spring 2021. Based off of the partici-
pants feedback no changes to the educational package was recommended and thus
none were made. The educational package was aimed to condense the material in this
thesis into a more user-friendly platform, allowing videos, pictures, quizzes, and in-
formation regarding the material showing the highlights and most important infor-
mation from this thesis. After completing the educational package the participants
completed a feedback form and an informed consent form, which can be found at the
end of this thesis.
7 DISCUSSION
The initial topic for this thesis was chosen due the authors previous work experience
in an acute care and critical care settings in the United States of America. In these
settings Physical Therapists performed wound care regularly for a variety of condi-
tions, most prominently infected ulcers or amputations. With the previous work ex-
perience and knowledge gained during the physiotherapy studies I believed this topic
would not only suit my interests, but also push my research and critical thinking
skills due to the lack of research about this topic. There is some research evaluating
physiotherapies effectiveness for treating diabetic foot ulcers that have been pub-
lished within the last 10 years. However there were not many modality studies evalu-
ating their effectiveness for diabetic foot ulcers. Those studies rather evaluated the
modalities effectiveness on treating wounds in general. Those studies were still used
and deemed credible for this thesis because they are used in wound care today, and
the research has not been disproven or questioned. Much is known about DFU’s
however more research would be beneficial to the healthcare systems and could re-
duce the amount of diabetic amputations performed each year. This thesis allowed
me to explore and learn about more modalities than prior to starting this. However I
would have liked to include more information regarding the anatomical and physio-
logical changes in regards to the wound healing process, but that itself could be an
entirely different thesis.
REFERENCES
wound-management-team-reinforced-in-new-white-paper
Aetna (2021, January 10). Ultrasound Therapy for Wound Healing - Medical Clini-
http://www.aetna.com/cpb/medical/data/700_799/0746.html
https://www.diabetes.org/diabetes/genetics-diabetes
Azura Vascular Care. (2018, August 27). 25 MUST Know Statistics About Amputa-
foot-amputation-stats/
Biswas, S., Roy, S., Banerjee, J., Hussain, S. A., Khanna, S., Meenakshisundaram,
G., Kuppusamy, P., Friedman, A., & Sen, C. K. (2010, March 22). Hypoxia
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2872456/
Boike, A., Maier, M., & Logan, D. (2010, August). Prevention and Treatment of Leg
and Foot Ulcers in Diabetes Mellitus. Cleveland Clinic Center for Continuing
Education.
https://www.clevelandclinicmeded.com/medicalpubs/diseasemanagement/end
ocrinology/prevention-treatment-diabetic-leg-and-foot-ulcers/
Brem, H., & Tomic-Canic, M. (2007, May 1). Cellular and Molecular Basis of
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1857239/
Bus, S. A., Armstrong, D. G., Gooday, C., Jarl, G., Caravaggi, C., Viswanathan, V.,
Cavanagh, P. R., & Bus, S. A. (2010, September). Off-loading the diabetic foot for
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0741521410013285
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2012, January 24). CDC Online News-
https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2012/p0124_lower_limb.html
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2020, March 24). PCOS (Polycystic
https://www.cdc.gov/diabetes/basics/pcos.html
https://www.diabetes.fi/en/finnish_diabetes_association/diabetes_in_finland
Dr Sunil Ramaway, Foot & Ankle Surgeon, Blacktown NSW. (n.d.). Shockwave
foot-ankle-surgeon-westmead-blacktown-nsw.html
Freeborn, D., Burd, I., & Turley, R. K. (n.d.). Gestational Diabetes - Health Ency-
Medical Center.
https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/encyclopedia/content.aspx?contenttypeid=85
&contentid=P00337
https://pmgbiology.com/tag/thermoregulation/
Henry, S., Concannon, M., & Yee, G. (2008, July 25). The Effect of Magnetic Fields
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2490801/
Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation. (2021, May 31). The Complexity of Diag-
re-
sources/about/diagnosis/#:%7E:text=A%20type%201%20diabetes%20(T1D,l
ong%2C%20full%2C%20happy%20lives.
Mallik, S. B., Jayashree, B. S., & Shenoy, R. R. (2018, May). Epigenetic modulation
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S105687271731468X?
via%3Dihub
Maruyama, K., Asai, J., Ii, M., Throne, T., Losordo, D. W., & D’Amore, P. A. (2007,
https://ajp.amjpathol.org/article/S0002-9440(10)61333-8/fulltext
Mayo Clinic Staff. (2020, March 3). Diabetic neuropathy - symptoms and causes.
neuropathy/symptoms-causes/syc-
20371580#:%7E:text=Researchers%20think%20that%20over%20time,nerves
%20with%20oxygen%20and%20nutrients
Miller, J., & Armstrong, D. (2014, March). Offloading the diabetic and ischemic
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/274257309
Moretti, B., Notarnicola, A., Maggio, G., Moretti, L., Pascone, M., Tafuri, S., & Pa-
tella, V. (2009, May 27). The Management of Neuropathic Ulcers of the Foot
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2693140/
Myers, B. (2012). Wound management: Principles and practice (3rd ed.). Pearson.
Patel, S., Srivastava, S., Singh, M. R., & Singh, D. (2019, April 1). Mechanistic in-
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0753332218374031?via%
3Dihub
Petrofsky, J. S., Lawson, D., Berk, L., & Suh, H. (2010, February 21). Enhanced
healing of diabetic foot ulcers using local heat and electrical stimulation for
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1753-0407.2009.00058.x
Physiopedia contributors. (2020, August 23). Low level laser therapy. Physiopedia.
https://www.physio-pedia.com/Low_Level_Laser_Therapy
pedia. https://www.physio-pedia.com/Diabetes_Mellitus_Type_1
Physipedia contributors. (2021, July 14). Diabetes Mellitus Type 2. Physiopedia.
https://www.physio-pedia.com/Diabetes_Mellitus_Type_2
YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRolebcoL2g
Schürmann, C., Goren, I., Linke, A., Pfeilschifter, J., & Frank, S. (2014, March 28).
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0006291X14003568?
via%3Dihub
Society for Vascular Surgery. (2019, November 25). Why diabetes can damage your
blood vessels, and how to know if you’re at risk | Society for Vascular Sur-
gery. https://vascular.org/news-advocacy/why-diabetes-can-damage-your-
blood-vessels-and-how-know-if-you%E2%80%99re-risk
Southwestern Academic Limb Salvage Alliance. (2019, February 5). Diabetic Foot:
facts-and-figures/
Thakral, G., LaFontaine, J., Najafi, B., Talal, T. K., Kim, P., & Lavery, L. A. (2013).
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3776323/
Turan, Y., Ertugrul, B. M., Lipsky, B. A., & Bayraktar, K. (2015, May 20). Does
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4436937/
Vijayakumar, V., Samal, S. K., Mohanty, S., & Nayak, S. K. (2019, February 1). Re-
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0141813018338923?v
ia%3Dihub
APPENDIX 1
Signature:
Name (printed):
Date:
APPENDIX 2
Feedback Questionnaire
Please answer each question with a rating of 1-5 (excluding number 6).
1 = I completely disagree
2 = I partially disagree
3 = I don’t know
4 = I partially agree
5 = I completely agree
Please describe your experience with the learning material more in depth below
while answering the questions listed/ What did you like about the material and
why? What did you not like about the material and why? Do you think more in-
formation should be included it in, if so what would you like to be included? Do
you have any suggestions or recommend any changes to the structure of the
learning material? Etc.