Scribd
Upload
12 views

Externality

An externality occurs when the actions of one economic agent directly impact another in a way not reflected by market transactions. This can lead to inefficient resource allocation. Solutions include quotas/taxes on the externality-generating activity, fostering bargaining over externalities through property rights, and creating a market for the externality to allow agents to express demand and supply. If well-defined property rights and markets for externalities exist, efficiency can be achieved.

Uploaded by

niles3053
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
12 views

Externality

An externality occurs when the actions of one economic agent directly impact another in a way not reflected by market transactions. This can lead to inefficient resource allocation. Solutions include quotas/taxes on the externality-generating activity, fostering bargaining over externalities through property rights, and creating a market for the externality to allow agents to express demand and supply. If well-defined property rights and markets for externalities exist, efficiency can be achieved.

Uploaded by

niles3053
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 20

Externalities

Externalities

• An externality
• Present whenever the well-being of a consumer or the
production possibilities of a firm are directly affected by
the actions of another agent in the economy
• Occurs whenever the activities of one economic agent
affect the activities of another economic agent in ways
that are not reflected in market transactions.
• Toxic chemical discharges
• Noise from airplanes
• Litter

2
Externalities

• Interfirm externalities
• One producing good x and the other producing good y
• The production of x will have an external effect on the
production of y
• If the output of y depends not only on the level of inputs
chosen by the firm but on the level at which x is produced

y = f(k,l;x)
Externalities

• The output of firm x could have a negative marginal


physical productivity
𝜕𝑦
<0
𝜕𝑥
• Increases in x output would cause less y to be produced.
• The relationship between the two firms can be beneficial
• Two firms, one producing honey and the other producing
apples
y
0
x
Externalities

• Externalities can also occur if the activities of an economic


agent directly affect an individual’s utility
• Externalities can decrease or increase utility
• Someone’s utility dependent on the utility of another

utility = US(x1,…,xn;UJ)
𝜕𝑈𝑆
• can be negative or positive
𝜕𝑈𝐽
Externality

• Public goods externalities


• Once they are produced, they provide benefit to the
entire group
• It is impossible to restrict these benefits to the specific
group of individuals who pay them.
Example of production externality

• Suppose we have two firms, firm 1 produces x (sell in


competitive market), which imposes a cost e(x) on firm 2.
• Suppose the technology is such that x units of output can
only be produced by generating x units of pollution.
Example of production externality

• Let p be the price of output, the profits of the two firms are
𝜋1 = max 𝑝𝑥 − 𝑐(𝑥)
𝜋2 = −𝑒(𝑥)
• Firm 1 chooses x at p = c’(x)
• c’(x) is private marginal costs
Example of production externality

• To determine the efficient output, we ask what would


happen if the two firms merged so as to internalize the
externality.
• Merged firms would maximize
𝜋 = max 𝑝𝑥 − 𝑐 𝑥 − 𝑒(𝑥)
• Firm chooses x at p = c’(xe) + e’(xe)
• c’(xe) + e’(xe) is social marginal costs
Externalities and Resource Allocations

• Externalities lead to inefficient allocations of resources


• Market prices do not accurately reflect the additional
costs or benefits to third parties
• The First Welfare Theorem does not hold in the
presence of externalities.
• Because there are things that people care about that are
not priced.
Traditional Solutions to the Externality Problem

• Quotas and taxes


• Fostering bargaining over externalities: enforceable property
rights
• Creating the market for externality
Quota and taxes

• Quota: The most direct sort of government intervention is


the direct control of the externality-generating activity it self.
• Mandate that the amount cannot exceed the optimal level.
Quota and taxes

• Taxes: Impose a tax on externality-generating activity. The


idea is that firm faces the wrong price for its action, and a
corrective tax can be imposed that will lead to efficient
resource allocation.
• Known as Pigouvian taxation.
Quota and taxes
Quota and taxes

• Suppose firm faced a tax on its output in amount t.


• 𝜋 = max 𝑝𝑥 − 𝑐 𝑥 − 𝑡𝑥
• Profit maximization: p = c’(x) + t. Therefore, can set t = e’(xe)
to achieve optimal output.
Quota and taxes

• Note that the optimality-restoring tax is exactly equal to the


marginal externality at the optimal solution.
• Optimality can be achieved either by taxing the externality
of by subsidizing its reduction.
• It is essential to tax the externality-producing activity
directly.
• Government must have a great deal of information about
the benefits and costs of the externality for the parties
involved to set the optimal levels of either the quota or the
tax.
Fostering bargaining

• Pollution rights equilibrium


• The rights are well-defined
• And tradable with zero transactions costs
• The initial assignment of rights is irrelevant
• Subsequent trading will always achieve the same, efficient
equilibrium
• This solution to the externality problem has a significant
advantage over the tax and quota schemes in terms of
the level of knowledge required of the government.
Creating the market

• Problem: firm 2 cares about pollution generated by firm


1 but has no way to influence it.
• Adding a market for firm 2 to express its demand for
pollution will provide mechanism for efficient
allocation.
• Firm x must purchase from firm y the rights to pollute the
river they share
• x’s choice to purchase these rights is identical to its
output choice
• Net revenue per unit: p – r
• Where r is the payment the firm must make to firm y for
each unit of x it produces
Creating the market

• In our example, x units of pollution are unavoidably


produced for every x units of output produced. If the market
price for pollution is r, then firm 1 can decide how much
pollution it want to sell, x1 and firm 2 can decide how much
pollution it wants to buy, x2.

𝜋1 = max 𝑝𝑥1 + 𝑟𝑥1 − 𝑐 𝑥1


𝜋2 = max −𝑟𝑥2 − 𝑒 𝑥2
Creating the market

• FOCs are
p + r = c’(x1)
-r = e’(x2)
• When supply equals demand we have x1=x2, leads to
p = c’(x) + e’(x) … socially optimum.
• If a competitive market exists for the externality, the
optimality results. Thus, externalities can be seen as being
inherently tied to the absence of certain competitive
markets.

You might also like