EDUC5440
EDUC5440
FOR, OF, and AS Learning. The assessments will be introduced in three phases. Each
phase will consist of at least 5 slides. You may use Google Slides, PowerPoint, Prezi, or a
presentation software of your choice. You will combine all three phases into one, final
presentation and each member of the group will submit a copy of this presentation.
Presentations are due by the end of Unit 7.
Phase 3. Read Chapter 4 of the WNPC (2006) manual Rethinking classroom assessment with
purpose in mind. Think of an imaginary school where you are teachers and pick one grade in the
school where you are planning to implement ‘assessment AS learning’ in this classroom.
Group 0013B
Team Leader: Dan Li OF
Co-Leader: Issam Ayash OF
Recordkeeper: Herbert Asiedu-Mante Assessment Learning
FOR
Progress Chaser: Marwan Nabawy
Presentation Organizer: Eva Cazaubon
FOR
AS
Instructor: Irv Glenn AS
July, 2022
Introduction
Assessment is an essential component of the teaching and learning process. It happens before, during, and after instruction.
Assessment for learning is defined as assessment prior to instruction. When assessment occurs during instruction, it is referred to as
assessment as learning. Following the completion of instruction, assessment of learning is performed. Overall,assessment "determines
whether or not the goals of education are being met. Assessment affects decisions about grades, placement, advancement, instructional
needs, curriculum, and, in some cases, funding" (Edutopia, 2008, para. 1). Student success is guaranteed when the purpose of the various
This project investigates the three types of assessments, as well as their descriptions, instruments, and benefits. These instruments
were created for use in Top Stars Community School's Grade 7-11 classes.
School overview
Top Stars Community School is a place where students enjoy going to school. This
school's vision is to develop students who are well-prepared to serve as global citizens.
Top Stars Community School has five grades (7-11) and a maximum student capacity of
300. Each grade level has three classes with a total of twenty students each. There are
Everything is done at this school to ensure that students are assessed carefully and
effectively. The mission is achieved through assessments for, as, and of learning. Source: Adapted from clipart-
library.com
Phase One
Assessment
Learning
FOR
FOR
Definition of ‘Assessment For Learning’
AFL, or assessment "FOR" learning, is an aspect of teaching and learning that is done before instruction. It generates feedback for
increasing students' performance. Assessment "FOR" learning adheres to the belief that evaluation and training ought to be combined.
The effectiveness of tests "FOR" learning comes from acknowledging the amount of knowledge that was applied to students' daily tasks
in the classroom rather than from using sophisticated technology or a specific assessment tool (McNamee et al., 2005, as cited in Learn
Alberta, n.d.). Such a function is frequently served by formative evaluations when evaluating learning. It gives pupils the precise, timely
feedback they need to modify their education. Students here become actively involved in the learning process, which may eventually help
them gain the confidence to learn and fulfill the learning objectives. On the other hand, teachers design their subsequent differentiation
methods to further enhance the teaching process using the knowledge they have gained from measuring "FOR" learning.
Key Features of ‘Assessment FOR Learning’
There are some key features of ‘Assessment FOR Learning’:
➢ "Assessment for learning occurs throughout the learning process" (Rethinking classroom assessment with purpose in mind,
2006, p. 29).
➢ Assessment for learning aims to identify students' potential and improve students' learning.
➢ Assessment for learning assesses a student's performance, progress, and development of knowledge, attitudes, values, and skills.
➢ Assessment for learning is to motivate students to learn, help them effectively regulate their learning process, and enhance self-
➢ The assessment for learning pays attention to the needs of the students, the learning process, and the student's experience in
learning.
Reasons for Implementing ‘Assessment For Learning’
1- It is an ongoing, everyday assessment that allows teachers to monitor students learning and modify their teaching based on what the students need for
being successful.
2- Involving students in peer and self-assessment. Students should actively participate in their learning to see what progress they have made in their
learning and what they need to improve their performance. Therefore, the teacher should encourage students to review their work critically and
constructively.
3- It is based on sharing learning goals with students, where if students realize the main destinations they seek, they will know their needs to achieve this.
4- Assessment for learning aims to provide students with the essential skills and strategies needed to help them take the following steps in their learning.
5- Providing feedback, which leads to students recognizing their next steps and how to take them. Feedback should be about the qualities of the work with
specific advice on what needs to be done to improve. "Feedback helps students become self-regulated as it signals to the learner areas to improve on."
understanding based on the feedback and feedback they receive from the teacher. This interaction between the teacher and the student helps
to enhance learning and build understanding. Conditions for an Assessment for Learning environment
the criteria they have to use for that. Then, the teacher can
inquiry that focuses on the development of critical thinking skills through problem-solving activities" (para. 14). Some examples of the
➢ One-minute Papers
➢ Think-Pair-Share
➢ Observation Checklists
➢ Admit/Exit Tickets
➢ Discussion
➢ Questioning
➢ Traffic Light
Source: Adapted from clipart-
➢ Quizzes library.com
Description of ‘Assessment FOR Learning’ Instrument
Instrument: Think-Pair-Share
Grade: Grade 7
Subject: Science
Description: In grade 7's classroom, students will explore how simple machines can make work more efficient. The Think-Pair-Share
method will be used to help students deepen their understanding. The following procedure will be followed:
1. Students are asked to think independently and brainstorm the application of simple machines to everyday situations.
2. Students have 5 minutes to write down any ideas that come to mind or draw a simple mind map.
3. Students work in pairs to exchange their views within 10-15 minutes, enriching their understanding of the subject matter.
5. The selected students share their thoughts, new knowledge gained from their peers, and the results of their cooperation.
6. The teacher make supplementary summaries, summarise comments, and guide students to think further.
Possible Benefits of Think-Pair-Share
giving opportunities.
Teachers who actively move around the classroom and pay attention to different
conversations obtain useful insight into students' knowledge levels, allowing them to
Research has shown, according to Crockett (n.d.), that students perform better when they
are held responsible for their education. With this style of discussion, students can answer
questions in writing before having meaningful conversations with other students. Source: Self-management model that
TPS offers (Snook,2018)
Possible Benefits of Think-Pair-Share (Cont’d)
● Increases comfort in sharing thoughts and ideas.
Research has shown, according to Crockett (n.d.), that when students are held
meaningful conversation with other students, this discussion style enables students to
As they hear from various viewpoints and experiences, students learn from one
another. By having students brainstorm in groups or pairs, this method improves their Source: students communicating in a
TPS (Syda Production, n.d.)
communication skills. As kids connect with one another, it promotes resiliency,
terms and broaden their past knowledge through peer engagement, it aids ELL and
Students gain focus and a deeper understanding of the topic's core when
their peers assist them in exploring the topic. In the class, students can more
overview document individually. The team leader created a framework for the group work via google docs. The link to the doc was shared with all group members on our
WhatsApp platform so all could access and edit remotely. Group members were assigned to work on the following aspects of the group presentation for phase 1 of the project:
· Reasons for implement “Assessment FOR Learning” - Marwan Mabawy (Progress Chaser)
· Analysis of group process - Examine your decision-making process in this group activity - Herbert Asiedu-Mante (Recordkeeper)
The group determined an imaginary school called "Top Stars Community School" and began to discuss the assessment for learning instruments that would be implemented in the
classrooms.
The group members agreed that, before identifying specific assessment for learning instruments that can be used in the classroom, it is crucial to clarify the definition,
After group discussions, we selected and focused on describing and developing the 'Think-Pair-Share' instrument. In addition, some other instruments of assessment for learning
were listed.
Phase Two
Assessment Learning
OF
OF
Definition of ‘Assessment OF Learning’
➢"Assessment of learning refers to strategies designed to confirm what students know, demonstrate whether or not they have met curriculum
outcomes or the goals of their individualized programs, or to certify proficiency and make decisions about students' future programs or
➢Assessment of learning is generally conducted at the end of a semester or academic year, course, subject, or unit. It benchmarks students'
➢The purpose of assessment of learning is to determine whether or not students have achieved their learning objectives. It is designed to
measure student learning in order to help different stakeholders make informed decisions.
➢Assessment of learning should be scored. The scores may be reflected on the student's report cards or be discussed in teacher-parent
conferences.
➢This method of assessment is summative and typically takes place at the conclusion of a unit or academic term. When learning is assessed
effectively, it "produces defensible and accurate descriptions of student competence in relation to defined outcomes" (Western and Northern
➢ Assessment of learning is not a routine activity that is part of regular learning and is only assessed when
➢ Assessment of learning not only achieves the purpose of summarizing and reporting learning but also
promotes learning.
➢ The combination of assessment of learning and assessment for learning provides students with opportunities
teaching activities
(Harlen, 2006 )
Reasons for Implementing ‘Assessment OF Learning’
1- It demonstrates if curriculum outcomes or individual goals were met and provides quantitative and qualitative
measures of achievement.
2- It can be used for monitoring the overall growth and progress of both individual students and the school as a whole
3- Provides academic records for the student – When summative assessments are completed, recordkeeping is a must.
With the implementation, the recorded scores and grades go into a student record. Scores are needed for many
different purposes, such as college admission, schools, and districts, to understand a school's results or performance
(Reddy, 2019).
4- Assessment of learning informs students and parents of their proficiency in relation to the learning outcomes
and how they can apply concepts, knowledge, and skills (Western and Northern Canadian Protocol for
Collaboration in Education, 2006)
5- Data will help plan learning goals and needs for students. Using the data from summative assessment, a teacher can
plan for the student's future learning goals and conditions (NSW, 2021).
Examples of ‘Assessment OF Learning’ Instruments
“Assessment of learning methods include not only tests and examinations, but also a rich variety of products and
demonstrations of learning” (Rethinking classroom assessment with purpose in mind, 2006, p. 57). Some examples of the
assessment of learning instruments are:
➢ Final Projects/Presentations
➢ End of term/ Midterm Examinations
➢ Standardized Tests
➢ Formal Essays
➢ Chapter tests
➢ One on one Interviews
➢ Portfolios and Journals
➢ Exhibitions
➢ Rubrics
Group presentation/project
Source: Adapted from www. learner.org
Description of ‘Assessment OF Learning’ Instrument
Instrument: Final Project
Grade: Grade 9
Description: Students in grade 9 are exploring how change happens along with time and how it affects people's lives. At the end of
the unit, students are asked to use multiple intelligences to complete a final project to demonstrate their understanding of the unit
● Identify the different changes in a person's life and the place around them.
● Prepare a categorized list of different changes that have an impact on one's life.
● Students are more interested in their final projects when they have to solve problems and think critically
● Final projects encourage innovation and creativity, two abilities that students need to acquire in the twenty-
● Final projects foster authenticity by connecting to students' outside-of-class experiences and communities,
which improves "engagement with the world around them and prepares students to be good citizens in
Based on the ideas of different group members, we synthesized and determined the definition of assessment of learning.
Group members believe that identifying the characteristics of assessment of learning helps teachers gain a deeper understanding of it.
The four stages of assessment of learning may guide and help teachers apply it effectively in the classrooms.
The identified importance is the reasons for implementing assessment of learning in the classrooms.
● Discuss the instruments of 'Assessment OF Learning' that can be used in the classroom
There are various instruments of assessment of learning, and the group members shared their familiar assessment strategies and made a list.
● Choose a specific instrument to expand and illustrate its application, and its possible benefits.
The group members agreed upon the ‘Final Project’ as an effective assessment of learning strategy that can be used in the classroom. An application
example was described in detail. The possible benefits of 'Final Project' also has been elaborated.
Phase Three
Assessment
Learning
AS
AS
Definition of ‘Assessment AS Learning’
➢ “Assessment as learning occurs when students are their own assessors” (Harapnuik, 2021, para. 5).
➢ Since it emphasizes students as the protagonists of their learning and participants in what is known as metacognition,
➢ "Assessment as learning is based in research about how learning happens, and is characterized by students reflecting on
their own learning and making adjustments so that they achieve deeper understanding" (Rethinking classroom assessment
➢ Students actively participate in developing their own understanding through assessment of learning, connecting and
applying prior knowledge to new learning, and self-reflection, which entails paying close attention to what they are
learning and using it to potentially change the way that they think.
Key Elements of ‘Assessment AS Learning’
There are three key elements of ‘Assessment as learning’:
❏ Student autonomy: The core of assessment as learning is to highlight the importance of students' self-reflection, self-
monitoring, and self-regulation of the learning process. In assessment as learning, "students are the critical connectors between
assessment and learning" (Rethinking classroom assessment with purpose in mind, n.d., p. 41).
❏ Metacognitive drive: "Assessment as learning focuses on students and emphasizes assessment as a process of metacognition
(knowledge of one's own thought processes) for students" (Rethinking classroom assessment with purpose in mind, n.d., p. 41).
Students' learning motivation and self-efficacy can be enhanced by improving their metacognition level.
❏ Integration of assessment and learning: By developing learning objectives into assessment criteria and transforming
assessment tasks into learning tasks, assessment as learning allows assessment and learning to be fully integrated. When students
become good assessors of their own learning activities, they have the potential to grow into genuinely independent and
2- Assessment as learning is often informal, self and peer assessments with feedback provided directly
from the learners providing the next step in the learning journey (Berry, 2008).
3- It fosters a growth mindset in students, and students learn that failure is part of the journey, not its end. As Stiggins
suggests, “Our students must understand that, when we try to grow, we sometimes fail at first, and that failure is all
right. The trick is to help students understand that failure holds the seeds of later success.” ( Western and Northern
4- It provides ways for students to use formal and informal feedback and self-assessment to help them understand the
6- Provides an opportunity to the teachers and students to discuss alternatives. (Western and
about, and monitor, their own learning" (Rethinking classroom assessment with purpose in mind, 2006, p. 42). Some examples of the
➢ Concept Maps
➢ Self-Assessments
➢ One-Sentence Summaries
➢ Reflection Journals
➢ Peer Teaching
➢ Three-Minute Pause
➢ Peer-Assessments
Source: Adapted from
➢ Portfolios destinysodyssey.com
Description of ‘Assessment AS Learning’ Instrument
Instrument: Portfolio Letter
Grade: Grade 11
Description: At the beginning of the new unit-Poetry, grade 11 students are asked to write a portfolio letter. Students are asked to state
their past experiences with poetry writing and their expectations/needs for the unit they will study in the portfolio letters. Specifics that
● What types of poetry do they already know or have written in the past?
● What poems are they interested in? Or what types of poetry do they want to learn?
● How have they expanded their knowledge of poetry through this unit? What poetry was written in this unit?
● Has poetry impacted their learning or their lives? If yes, how does poetry impact learning or life?
Possible Benefits of Portfolio Letters
● Benefits that could come from using a Portfolio Letter Portfolio letters can have biases and present inaccurate or
insufficient information, but they can also have some advantages. It first provides the teachers with information about the
● Additionally, it demonstrates their capacity to evaluate their own learning (Western and Northern Canadian Protocol for
● Third, it offers advice on how the teacher should continue with teaching and learning (even when the letters might not be
real). Last but not least, it promotes introspection and identifies the pupils' metacognitive stages.
Analysis of Group Process
1. The group investigated the definition of assessment as learning to further expand theoretical understanding of it.
2. When examining the definition of assessment as learning, the group found that assessment as learning has three key
elements: student autonomy, metacognitive drive, and integration of assessment and learning. These three elements are
3. Group members analyzed the rationale for implementing assessment as learning based on the three key elements of
assessment as learning.
4. Some examples of assessment as learning were listed based on the group member's agreement. These examples would help
5. The 'Portfolio Letter' instrument was selected and determined to describe and expand its application in the classroom. The
This project investigated the three reasons for assessment. They are assessments for, as, of learning. These facets benefit both
teachers and students. When used properly, there will be significant improvements in teaching and learning.
While working on this project, it was fascinating to learn about the various instruments that can be used to assess teaching and
learning. Some of these instruments we have used before, but we did not consider whether we were using them for, as, or of learning. We
The process of making the instruments was extremely beneficial. As a result of this project, group members are better informed
%20an%20integral%20part,%2C%20in%20some%20cases%2C%20funding.
Harlen, W (2006). Teaching, Learning and Assessing. Science 5-12. 4th ed. London: Sage.
Magno, C., & Lizada, G.S. (2015). Features of classroom formative assessment. Educational Measurement and Evaluation Review, 6.
https://www.slideshare.net/crlmgn/features-of-classroom-formative-assessment
References (Cont'd)
Main, P. (n.d.). Strategies for Assessment for Learning.
https://www.structural-learning.com/post/strategies-for-assessment-for-learning#:~:text=Assessment%20for%20learning
%20strategies%20involves
NSW Education Standards Authority. (n.d.). Assessment for, as, of learning.
https://syllabus.nesa.nsw.edu.au/support-materials/assessment-for-as-and-of-learning/
Reddy, K. (2019, November 27). Summative evaluation advantages and disadvantages. Wise Step.
https://content.wisestep.com/advantages-disadvantages-summative-evaluation/
Renshaw, P. & Baroutsis, A. & Kraayenoord, C. & Goos, M. & Dole, S. (2013). Teachers using classroom data well:
https://www.researchgate.net/figure/THREE-TIERED-TYPOLOGY-OF-STUDENT-ENGAGEMENT-AND-DATA-DRI
VEN-DECISION-MAKING_fig2_270592654
Rethinking classroom assessment with purpose in mind. (2006). Western and Northern Canadian Protocol for
References (Cont'd)
Snook, R. (2018, October 4). Co-opting traditional management skills for self-management [Image]. Medium.
https://medium.com/enspiral-tales/co-opting-traditional-management-skills-for-self-management-816ab6795c52
Syda Productions. (n.d.). Education, elementary school, drinks, children and people concept - group of school kids with Soda
Cans Talking in corridor [Image]. Education Elementary School Drinks Children People .
https://www.shutterstock.com/ko/image-photo/education-elementary-school-drinks-children-people-237002482
Western and Northern Canadian Protocol for Collaboration in Education. (2006). Rethinking Classroom Assessment with Purpose
in Mind. WNCP. https://www.edu.gov.mb.ca/k12/assess/wncp/full_doc.pdf
healthpsychologyconsultancy. (2017, March 24). Forming Safe and Productive Groups. Health Psychology Consultancy.
https://healthpsychologyconsultancy.wordpress.com/2017/03/24/forming-safe-and-productive-groups/
7,016 Group Task Photos - Free & Royalty-Free Stock Photos from Dreamstime. (n.d.). 7,016 Group Task Photos - Free & Royalty-Free