Paper 2 Chapters' Analysis
Paper 2 Chapters' Analysis
• the soldier’s solitude and feeling of imprisonment are emphasised by the children in the
park, and the voices of the boys in the park show how they experience the freedom of
youth: ‘Voices of play and pleasures after day’, but their voices have a negative effect on
the soldier, who feels they ‘rang saddening like a hymn’
• the poet shows the warmth and tenderness of past relationships the soldier had through
the description of how the ‘girls glanced lovelier’ and how he has felt ‘how slim/Girls’
waists are, or how warm their subtle hands’
• this is contrasted with the reactions of women to him now: ‘All of them touch him like
some queer disease’. The changes in women’s reactions to him show that the soldier feels
he is no longer attractive: ‘he noticed how the women's eyes/Passed from him’
• there is emphasis on how the soldier was once young and attractive to contrast with how
he feels about himself and how others treat him in the present: an artist is described as
‘silly for his face’, and ‘Someone had said he'd look a god in kilts’
• the people who signed the soldier up to join the army are described only as ‘they’,
suggesting some nameless group who had no interest in what was best for him: ‘He didn’t
have to beg’, ‘Smiling they wrote his lie’
• after his injuries the only visitor the soldier had was ‘a solemn man’, whose behaviour
suggested he felt sorry for him as he ‘brought him fruits/Thanked him; and then inquired
about his soul’
• the end stanza shows how the treatment of the soldier is like being imprisoned, although
he has done nothing wrong: ‘a few sick years in Institutes’, ‘do what things the rules
consider wise’.
• the immediate description of the saw creates a threat of menace, which the reader will
feel foreshadows the accident: ‘The buzz saw snarled and rattled in the yard’
• the poet describes the power of the saw as if it is solely in control: ‘And made dust and
dropped stove-length sticks of wood’; it is the subject of the active verbs
• the description of the setting before the accident creates a sense of ‘calm before the
storm’ for the reader: ‘Five mountain ranges one behind the other/Under the sunset far
into Vermont’; feelings of calm and peacefulness are created, only pierced by the sound of
the saw
• the details of the accident are recounted with sadness and shock but also some
detachment, as the narrator is either witnessing them or finding out about them after they
have happened: ‘I wish they might have said’, ‘But the hand!’
• the cutting of the hand by the saw is presented as the saw taking control and the boy
losing control, creating strong feelings of confusion and disbelief for the reader: ‘Neither
refused the meeting’
• the description of life ‘spilling’ shows the speed at which the events after the accident
occur, creating feelings of a lack of control
• the reader will feel a strong sense of sympathy from the boy’s plea to keep his hand, even
though it is already lost
• the reader will feel a strong sense of sympathy from the boy’s plea to keep his hand, even
though it is already lost
• the poet creates strong feelings as death is described as coming quickly: ‘No one
believed’
• the way the poet explains the reactions of ‘them’ carrying on with their lives is shocking
to the reader.
how the boy in the poem is described:
• the boy is described as less powerful than the saw as this is foregrounded in the poem,
creating feelings of strong sympathy for him
• language to demonstrate social context also creates a sense of sympathy for him as he is
a ‘boy’ looking to be ‘saved from work’ and ‘Doing a man’s work’
• it seems as if the boy is being treated badly by having to work late: ‘Call it a day, I wish
they might have said’
• he is referred to only as ‘the boy’, showing him to be a typical boy - the reader is
interested as he could be anyone
• the boy is stereotyped as he is doing manual labour, suggesting to the reader that this is
a traditional household
• the boy seems to be attacked by the saw as it ‘Leaped out at the boy’s hand’, even though
the narrator, almost in disbelief, suggests that the boy could have had some control by
saying ‘He must have given the hand’
• he is described as possibly accepting the accident: ‘He must have given the hand’,
‘Neither refused the meeting’
• the boy’s shock at the accident is shown by his immediate reaction: ‘a rueful laugh’
• the boy desperately pleads for help and support from his family, which creates a sense of
pathos: ‘holding up the hand,/Half in appeal, but half as if to keep/The life from spilling’
• his knowledge of what is to come and the plea to his sister are shocking: ‘“Don't let him
cut my hand off—/The doctor, when he comes. Don't let him, sister!”’
• the boy loses control of his life as the doctor ‘put him in the dark of ether’ and he ‘lay and
puffed his lips out with his breath’
• the unexpected and sudden death of the boy is greeted with disbelief from his family:
‘No one believed. They listened at his heart’
how the writer feels about the experience with the girl:
• the writer begins the poem with the setting of the ‘evening bazaar/studded with neon’,
which helps to show the reader how well she remembers the experience
• the idea that the girl is ‘unknown’ creates a feeling of mystery about the experience
• even though people working in shops/services would usually be unknown to customers,
the writer attaches significance to the fact the girl is unknown by repeating this,
emphasising the sense of mystery about the cultural experience she is having
• the writer repeatedly emphasises the actions of the girl, showing interest in what she
contributes to the experience: ‘is hennaing my hand’
• verbs are used to detail the actions of the unknown girl and the active memory the
writer has of the experience: ‘squeezes’, ‘icing’, ‘steadies’
• the way the writer describes the girl shows a certain fascination about her youth and
softness: she is described as a ‘girl’ rather than a woman, ‘satin- peach knee’
• the writer shows that she is impressed by the creativity and beauty of the work in her
description of the process: ‘She squeezes a wet brown line/from a nozzle’, ‘icing my hand’,
‘a peacock spreads its lines/across my palm’, ‘I have new brown veins’, ‘soft as a snail
trail/the amber bird beneath’
• the writer also shows admiration for the skill and knowledge the girl demonstrates:
‘which she steadies with hers’, ‘very deftly’
• the writer presents the experience with the girl as sensual and exciting, through
references to what she is able to see, feel and hear: ‘the evening bazaar/studded with
neon’, ‘a little air catches/my shadow-stitched kameez’, ‘Colours leave the street’, ‘the
furious streets/are hushed’
• the way that the writer repeats what the girl is doing creates a sense of purpose and
peaceful feeling, leading to an almost dream-like state during the experience: ‘float up in
balloons’, ‘Now the furious streets/are hushed’
• the feelings she has about the experience are so strong that she feels nostalgic about it
afterwards: ‘longing for the unknown girl/in the neon bazaar’.
• the writer’s sensual description of the experience and traditional setting demonstrates
her excitement about the culture of India: ‘studded with neon’, ‘wet brown line’,
‘satin-peach knee’, ‘Colours leave the street’, ‘Now the furious streets/are hushed’
• the writer’s descriptions emphasise the Indian context of the experience: ‘evening
bazaar’, ‘for a few rupees’, ‘My shadow-stitched kameez’
• there is an underlying sense of how Indian culture approaches work and wealth in the
implication that the unknown girl is young (in the description of her being a ‘girl’ rather
than a woman), working late (in an ‘evening bazaar’) and has little money, as she is
described as working for ‘a few rupees’
• the description of the henna pattern demonstrates a connection to Indian culture since
the peacock has legendary and religious significance in Indian traditions: ‘a peacock
spreads its lines/across my palm’, ‘soft as a snail trail/the amber bird beneath’
• the writer feels that the henna pattern is symbolic of traditional India, which is creative
and should be protected: ‘very deftly/an unknown girl/is hennaing my hand’, ‘I am
clinging/to these firm peacock lines’
• this is contrasted with the way she describes her experience of a more ‘westernized’
India, which is implicitly negative: ‘Dummies in shop-fronts/tilt and stare/with their
Western perms’
• the writer feels a sense of loss after the experience is over, suggesting this sense of
cultural tradition is being lost: ‘It will fade in a week’
• the ending of the poem suggests that the writer yearns for the more traditional India: ‘I’ll
lean across a country/with my hands outstretched/longing for the unknown girl’
• the writer’s feelings about the mysterious ‘unknown girl’ are contrasted with the feelings
of identity linked to the place and the cultural experience of India: ‘I’ll lean across a
country/with my hands outstretched/longing for the unknown girl’.
the use of language and structure:
• the writer uses vocabulary to position the experience in the tradition of India, creating
texture and depth: ‘bazaar’, ‘hennaing’, ‘rupees’, ‘kameez’
• the way that the writer uses repetition of how the experience is described shows how
significant it is to the writer and emphasises the importance of tradition: ‘an unknown
girl/is hennaing my hand’
• the writer uses onomatopoeia in order to create a sensual, exciting experience:
‘squeezes’, ‘hushed’, ‘scrape’
• the contrast in sentence structures highlights different elements of the experience for
the reader; longer sentences are used which focus on the details of the experience: ‘In the
evening bazaar/for a few rupees/an unknown girl/is hennaing my hand’ while short
sentences are used to create emphasis and show contrast: ‘Colours leave the street/float
up in balloons’, ‘I have new brown veins’, ‘Now the furious streets/are hushed’
• the writer’s use of simple statements beginning with ‘she’ demonstrates the importance
of what the girl is doing: ‘She squeezes...’, ‘She is icing...’, ‘she steadies...’
• descriptions of colour and light create a sensual experience: ‘studded with neon’, ‘wet
brown line’, ‘satin-peach knee’, ‘Colours leave the street’, ‘new brown veins’
• metaphor is used to demonstrate the creativity of the unknown girl’s work: ‘She is icing
my hand’, ‘a peacock spreads its lines/across my palm’
• the writer’s use of alliteration or repetition of ‘c’ sounds emphasises ideas linked to
creativity and activity: ‘catches’, ‘kameez’, ‘Colours’, ‘curtain cloth/and sofa cloth/canopy
me’, ‘clinging’
• the contrast between westernised and traditional India is emphasised through the use of
personification: ‘Dummies in shop-fronts/tilt and stare’, ‘Now the furious streets/are
hushed’, ‘When India appears and reappears’
• the writer uses simile to place emphasis on the importance of Indian traditions: ‘like
people who cling/to the sides of a train’, ‘soft as a snail trail’
• the use of present tense through the poem until the end, when the poet thinks about the
future, creates a feeling of a present, immediate experience.
Still I rise
• the narrator shows that she is proud of how she overcomes the oppression of others by
opening the poem with ‘You may write me down in history/With your bitter, twisted lies’,
and then saying ‘still, like dust, I’ll rise’
• the narrator shows pride in qualities she has by referring to them as belonging to her:
‘my sassiness’, ‘my haughtiness’, ‘my sexiness’
• her questions to others repeat and foreground her views of her own strengths, showing
pride in showing them off: ‘Does my sassiness upset you?’, ‘Does my haughtiness offend
you?’, ‘Does my sexiness upset you?’
• the writer’s strength and pride are shown in the way she describes the others as
unhappy, while she is strong and positive: ‘bitter, twisted’, ‘upset’, ‘beset with gloom’, ‘take
it awful hard’
• the narrator’s description of how she walks, laughs and dances shows her pride in how
she does things, as she links these actions to symbols of wealth and power: ‘oil wells’, ‘gold
mines’, ‘diamonds’
• the narrator’s pride in her strength is seen in the way she aligns herself with the planets
and elements: ‘like moons and like suns’, ‘certainty of tides’, ‘like air’
• she is proud of being a woman, seen in her reference to ‘my sexiness’ and ‘diamonds/At
the meeting of my thighs?’
• the narrator’s description of how others expect her to be shows she is proud that she
does not behave in that way: ‘Bowed head and lowered eyes?/Shoulders falling down like
teardrops,/Weakened by my soulful cries?’
• the narrator shows pride in her determination to rise above the actions of others by
repeating: ‘I’ll rise’
• the way the narrator moves from the hopeful ‘I’ll rise’ to the definitive ‘I rise’ at the end of
the poem shows power and control that come from strength and pride.
how pride in the narrator’s background is presented:
• the narrator’s pride in her background is shown in the way she can affirm that her people
have been misrepresented: ‘write me down in history’
• the narrator shows that she challenges the views of others about her background: ‘your
bitter, twisted lies’, ‘You may shoot me with your words’
• the narrator’s reactions to the treatment by others show her sense of pride in herself and
her background: ‘trod me in the very dirt’, ‘You may cut me with your eyes,/You may kill
me with your hatefulness’
• the repeated descriptions of the behaviour of others to the narrator, from verbal abuse to
being metaphorically physically abusive, indirectly show how proud she is of her
background: ‘trod me in the very dirt’, ‘You may shoot me ... You may cut me ... You may kill
me’
• the narrator feels proud of her background and is unapologetic when presenting it as
difficult: ‘huts of history’s shame’, ‘a past that’s rooted in pain’
• the narrator is proud of her background as an African-American woman: ‘I’m a black
ocean, leaping and wide,/Welling and swelling I bear in the tide’
• the narrator sees her background as a source of pride rather than as a disadvantage, as
her ancestors gave her ‘gifts’: ‘Bringing the gifts that my ancestors gave’
• towards the end of the poem she is proud to be the figurehead for more than just her
own feelings: ‘I am the dream and the hope of the slave.’
Mrs. Mallard’s thoughts and feelings about her husband and marriage:
• Mrs. Mallard’s sister and Richards view her as likely to respond as any other wife would
to the ‘news of her husband’s death’, and because she has a heart condition they break it to
her ‘as gently as possible’
• however, Mrs. Mallard’s reactions on hearing the news are not like other wives: ‘She did
not hear the story as many women have heard the same’
• the writer uses the description of a usual reaction to the death of a loved one in order to
show the contrast with hers: ‘with a paralyzed inability to accept its significance’
• her reaction to the news shows that she does what she feels is expected of her as a
‘loving wife’ as she weeps in her sister’s arms
• the writer describes her response to the news as over-dramatic and exaggerated: ‘She
wept at once, with sudden, wild abandonment’
• there is a sense that Mrs. Mallard feels exhausted and empty after the news, as any wife
would: ‘pressed down by a physical exhaustion’
• she has intelligent recognition that the feelings she has are not ones she should have as a
wife. She feels she should be grieving but is fearful that she is going to feel ‘“free, free,
free!”’
• Mrs. Mallard is aware that it may be a ‘monstrous joy that held her’, as she is joyful for the
‘death’ of her husband, but she dismisses this as ‘trivial’
• the writer shows that Mrs. Mallard knows that she will grieve again for her husband
when she sees his body: ‘she would weep again when she saw the kind, tender hands
folded in death’
• Mr. Mallard is described in positive terms and as always being a loving husband: ‘kind,
tender hands’, ‘the face that had never looked save with love upon her’
• Mrs. Mallard is shown as conflicted about her feelings for her husband: ‘And yet she had
loved him--sometimes. Often she had not. What did it matter!’
• Mrs. Mallard is shown to have a feeling of dread and fear of a lack of meaning or direction
in life: ‘It was only yesterday she had thought with a shudder that life might be long’.
Mrs. Mallard’s thoughts and feelings about her future:
• Mrs. Mallard’s wish to be solitary and alone after the news appears to be a reaction to
death, but it is her need to reflect on the future: ‘she went away to her room alone’ and
‘would have no one follow her’
• Mrs. Mallard is alone with her thoughts and has a heightened awareness of her senses,
making her focus on the present as she starts to think of the future: ‘She could see’, ‘The
delicious breath of rain’, ‘singing reached her faintly’
• once her grief is spent she moves quickly into a pore and there through the clouds’
st-crying sob like a child: ‘as a child who has cried itself to sleep continues to sob in its
dreams’
• her physical appearance contrasts with her actions as she is ‘young, with a fair, calm face’
but has a gaze that ‘rather indicated a suspension of intelligent thought’, showing youthful
capability
• Mrs. Mallard feels the future coming but because of her past ‘repression’ she is unsure
and fearful of it: ‘There was something coming to her and she was waiting for it, fearfully’
• once she feels the freedom in the future the repetition of the words ‘“free, free, free!”’
helps her to accept her feelings: ‘The vacant stare and the look of terror that had followed
it went from her eyes’
• her ‘clear and exalted perception’ shows a sharp sense of positivity about her
independence: ‘she saw beyond that bitter moment a long procession of years to come
that would belong to her absolutely’. she thinks about her new-found freedom: ‘she would
live for herself’, ‘‘‘Free! Body and soul free!’’ she kept whispering’
• she is hopeful about a long and happy future: ‘She breathed a quick prayer that life might
be long’
• Mrs. Mallard’s response to her new freedom is seen in her reaction to her sister’s
knocking: ‘There was a feverish triumph in her eyes, and she carried herself unwittingly
like a goddess of Victory’
• she exerts control in the relationship by the way she ‘clasped at her sister’s waist’
• it is ironic that she does not die ‘of the joy that kills’ but from the loss of the idea of a new
life without her husband: the shock and disappointment kill her.
the use of language and structure:
• the writer uses language to suggest that the event of the death of a spouse needs to be
broken gently, with some euphemism: ‘as gently as possible’, ‘in broken sentences’, ‘veiled
hints’, ‘assure himself of its truth’
• language is used to suggest Mrs. Mallard’s fragility given her ‘heart trouble’: ‘afflicted’,
‘great care’, ‘as gently as possible’
• the description of her reactions when hearing the news shows a violent response:
‘sudden, wild abandonment’
• the use of metaphor shows Mrs. Mallard’s extreme reaction to ‘her husband’s death’:
‘storm of grief’, ‘pressed down by a physical exhaustion that haunted her body and seemed
to reach into her soul’
• positive language is used to show (new) life and this reflects the character’s thoughts on
her future: ‘aquiver with the new spring life’, ‘delicious breath of rain’, ‘sparrows twittering
in the eaves’
• the writer creates a sense of peace and tranquillity in the description of the setting,
showing her calm attitude to facing the future
• the use of prepositional phrases creates a sense of relationships between people and
feelings: ‘moment of illumination’, ‘possession of self-assertion’, ‘strongest impulse of her
being!’
• range of sentence types shows extreme emotion and a range of feelings: ‘What was it?’,
‘What did it matter!’, “‘Body and soul free!’”
• the use of adverbs demonstrates the range of feelings that she is experiencing: ‘fearfully’,
‘tumultuously’, ‘absolutely’, ‘unwittingly’
• the use of coordinated sentences creates a feeling of events moving at a fast pace: ‘Fixed
and gray and dead’, ‘Spring days, and summer days, and all sorts of days’
• short sentences create a sense of building tension which reflects her married life and her
sense of urgency to start a new one: ‘Often she had not’, ‘What did it matter!’, ‘Go away’
• the writer repeats the phrase ‘life might be long’ to show the contrast in her feelings
towards life from before and after the ‘death’
Night
how the narrator of the story is presented:
• the narrator begins the story with ‘When I was young’, showing that it will be looking
back on her childhood, creating interest in this memoir-style reflection
• the narrator’s illness is described as painful but exciting: it is a ‘pain’ that ‘struck’ ‘at
about eleven o'clock at night’, which is late for a child, and leads to ‘A trip of no more than a
mile and a half but an adventure all the same’
• the narrator’s reactions to her operation present her as a ‘typical’ child that the reader
can relate to. She shows boredom in the aftermath of the operation (‘So I lay, minus my
appendix, for some days looking out a hospital window’) and enjoyment in being excused
from some school activities (‘enjoyed being excused from physical training for longer than
necessary’)
• the narrator realises that as a child she did not have any idea of the financial impact her
illness had on her family, which builds the reader’s awareness of family circumstances: ‘I
don’t suppose it ever crossed my head to wonder how my father was going to pay for this
distinction’
• the narrator’s description of how she thinks her father paid for the operation
demonstrates contrast with the child’s view because as an adult she feels the need to take
into account such responsibilities: ‘I think he sold a woodlot that he had kept when he
disposed of his father’s farm’
• the narrator shows that following the operation she is treated differently, creating some
apprehension in the reader: ‘It seems that the mysterious turkey egg must have given me
some invalid status, so that I could spend part of the time wandering about like a visitor’
• in contrast, by the summer, the narrator’s actions and behaviour lead her family to have
no concerns about her, which is reassuring: ‘nobody knew there was a thing the matter
with me’
• although the actions the narrator describes suggest ‘typical’ sibling rivalry and the sense
of her being a ‘superior’ older sister (‘tormenting her, teasing her’, ‘I would take on the role
of sophisticated counsellor or hair-raising storyteller’), the fact that she describes her
relationship with her younger sister as ‘always unsettled’ builds tension
• the description of how her physical illness causes the narrator to feel some emotional
ill-health creates unease in the reader: ‘this uselessness and strangeness I felt’, ‘I had
begun to have trouble getting to sleep’
• the narrator’s concern about her emotional health creates foreboding in the reader: ‘I
was not myself’, ‘Something was taking hold of me and it was my business, my hope, to
fight it off’, ‘The more I chased the thought away, the more it came back’
• the description of her feelings is threatening and worrying, showing that her physical
illness has caused, or has led to, mental health issues: ‘The thought that I could strangle
my little sister’, ‘I might do it for no reason I or anybody could understand, except that I
could not help it’, ‘it eased me to look towards town, maybe just to inhale the sanity of it’
• the way the narrator tries to take control of her symptoms and her insomnia
independently shows her determination and intelligence: ‘The thing to do was to get up, to
get myself out of that room and out of the house’
• the isolation the narrator feels because of her insomnia and subsequent mental health
issues is shown in the way her family are unaffected: ‘My brother and sister had gone off
to their classes in the public school’, ‘When my sister got home from school we would
swing in the hammock’, ‘I did not speak of my night difficulties’
• the adult narrator’s reflection that the insomnia might have been caused by something
simple reassures her in adulthood and, in turn, the reader: ‘It was in that hammock that I
spent much of the days, which possibly accounted for my not getting to sleep at night’, ‘the
simple information that I’d be better off getting more action during the day’
• the narrator feels that she has ‘special status’ due to her operation, as her family give her
freedom to lie awake: ‘Nobody would have called out to me earlier, telling me to put out my
light and get to sleep’, ‘I was left to make up my own mind about such a thing’
• the narrator’s relationship with her father is complex, as he is shown to be violent in his
punishment of his children: ‘with his use on me of the razor strap or his belt’. The narrator
also acknowledges that he helps to reassure her, and the reader, that all is well and after
his intervention she is able to sleep: ‘on that breaking morning he gave me just what I
needed to hear and what I was even to forget about soon enough’, ‘From then on I could
sleep’.