Correctional Administration 1-3
Correctional Administration 1-3
2. Custodial Model - this model is based on the assumption that prisoners have
been incarcerated for the protection of society and for the purpose of
incapacitation, deterrence and retribution. It emphasizes maintenance and
security and order through the subordination of the prisoner to the authority of
the warden. Discipline is strictly applied and most aspect of behavior is regulated.
7. Penitentiary model - applies two systems namely, the separate and the
congregate. The separate system used solitary confinement and manual labor in
which the prisoners were kept separate from one another as well as from the
outside world. The congregate system is one in which the prisoners slept in
solitary cells, worked together complete silence but is observed. They are united
but no moral tconnection exists among them. They see without knowing each
other. They are in a society without mental intercourse because there was no
communication and hence no interaction The penitentiary was practice as a
custodial institution. It demanded absolute obedience from criminals who have
never learned to respect limits, follow rules, or put in an honest day's work and
who, moreover, were the filthy elements of the society.
There are several possible approaches that prison administrators may take to deal
with prison management. Each of the following approach or strategy has
economic, social and political costs, and of time for amount entails a different
each implementation and impact.
1. Null Strategy - proponent of this say that nothing should be done, that prisons
should be allowed to become increasingly congested and staff should remain to
maintain them with the assumption that the problem is temporary and will
disappear in time. This, of course, may be the most politically acceptable
approach in the short run. In the long run, however, the approach may lead to
riots as prisoners take control of their situation and staff members become
demoralized. It may ultimately result in the courts declaring the facilities
unconstitutional and taking over their administration.
4. Construction Strategy - building new facilities to meet the demand for prison
space for an advantageous prison management. The approach comes to mind
when legislators and correctional officials confront the problem on prison
crowding, sanitation and prison violence to expand the size, number of facilities
and personnel. But given contemporary financial
NATURE OF PUNISHMENT
Definition of Punishment
Forms of Punishment
The forms of punishment in primitive society were the death penalty, corporal
punishment, public humiliation, shaming and banishment. Death penalty was
carried out by hanging, burning, immersing in boiling oil, feeding to wild animals
and in many other barbaric ways. Corporal punishment was inflicted the offender
by flogging, mutilation, disfiguration, and maiming. Public humiliation and
shaming were effected by the use of stocks and pillory, docking stool, branding,
shaving of the hair, etc. The more recent forms of punishment are imprisonment,
parole and probation
The earliest forms of punishment were death, torture, maiming and banishment.
The jail was introduced in Medieval Europe as a place of confinement of persons
arrested and undergoing trial, and for those convicted of minor offenses such as
vagrancy, gambling and prostitution. Death, corporal punishment and banishment
were the penalties for offenses, which today are punishable by imprisonment.
Justification of Punishment
Trends of Punishment
Exemptions of Punishment
The bases for the exemptions are usually social In Europe, Kings Kings and Rulers
in ancient and early modern society could do no wrong. Upper classmen were
often times exempted from criminal liability for long commoners the caused
which offences imprisonment or death penalty. Most countries today do not
punish offenders for absence of "mens rea" that is absence of a guilty mind or
lack of criminal intent. The right of sanctuary was practiced in the early Christian
era. The benefit of clergy was originally given to clerics who did not wear
ecclesiastical robes from being tried by lay courts but only by ecclesiastical courts.
Latter the privilege was extended to anyone who could read and write. Age of the
offender was another basis for exemption from criminal responsible. Under laws
on juvenile delinquents are not legally classified as criminals.
The mental condition of the offender is another basis for exemption from criminal
responsibility. The M'Naghtan case of England (1843) held the opinion that an
offender is to be considered sane and responsible until is proven that he was
insane at the act was committed, and therefore, could not haveknown right from
wrong. This doctrine holds true in every progressive country today. Reformist
would want the criminal insane, such as the criminal psychopaths and criminal
neurotics, handled by special laws and procedures in courts and to provide
specialized mental institutions for their care.
Theories of Punishment
The Pre-Classical Theorles
The first attempt to explain crime was made by the Athenian philosopher,
Aristotle. In his book "Nicomedean Ethics ", he discusses corrective justice, thus -
punishment is a means of restoring the balance between pleasure and pain". This
philosophy of individuai determinism which existed up to 400 B.C., was another
form of the so called "free-will theory". It implied a notion of causation in terms
of free choice to commit crime by rationai men seeking pleasure and avoiding
pain. According to Aristotle, "corrective justice is a means whereby the loss
suffered by the wronged man is compensated. Suffering by the offender restores
the balance between the injured and the transgressor.
Rise of the Canonical Courts - A ystem of trial and punishment was established in
the Century A. D. Rivalry existed between the church and state in trying offences.
Primitive justice was not so much concerned with determining of guilt as with
saying that the proper religious ritual who observed by private parties in settling
private disputes. In the early Christians era, the Church forbade its adherents to
resort to state courts and later in the Medieval Period the power of state courts
declined and the power of Canonical Courts increased. Criminal Courts distinct
from civil courts and separate from the administration of government had their
origin in the Roman Republic some two centuries before Christ and became firmly
of theory The empire established under punishment under the church court was
mainly reformatory in purpose.
Individualization of Punishment- The lawmakers and judges had the practical task
of making and administering law not only in the light of such theories of free will
and responsibility, but also face to face with the indignation of the community at
a particular offense.
The Abused of Judicial Individualization- The law gave judges wide direction to
impose additional punishment in view led to the circumstances. This theory gave
the judgcs tyrannical power which led to abuses. Class discrimination in the
administration of justice arose. The Hebrew right ofbsanctuary and the medieval
truce of God were religiously motivated by limitations on punishment. Yet
suchbpractices as expiation and penance demanded punishment as a process of
balancing account with God. The infliction of the punishmentnbecame a sort of
religious ceremony. The canonical courts introduced the modern principle of
individualization, but not on scientific grounds, and this very unscientific
individualization led to serious abuses and injustices.
4. Secret accusations.
Bentham of England, another exponent of the classical school, also holds that
socicty must rewardbthose who accept responsibility and punish those who do
not, thus bringing pleasure and pain into the service of society The philosophy of
the Classical School holds:
1. That man is a free moral agent, and that every act of man is of his free will and
accord
4. That the law, not the judge, should determine the punishment to be attached
to the criminal act, and should provide a scale of punishments to be applied
equally to all persons committing the same crime.
Influenced by the French Revolution and the Quakers of the New England states,
the third school ofbthought in criminological and penological theories, the Neo-
Classical School, was advocated at the beginning of the 19th century.bIn the
French Code of 1819, the principles of thebclassical school remained intact but
the system of defined and variable punishments was modified. The judge was
given direction in certain crimes to vary punishment between the maximum and
the maximum fixed by the law. Under the Code
2. the Classical Theory remained intact in its theory that "every person equally
free and therefore equally responsible. Since the publication of the French Code
of 1819, the struggle has been to individualize the punishment by setting up
varying degrees of responsibility. The Neo-Classical School admitted extenuating
circumstances in the criminal himself. The Neo-Classical School -
1. admits that minors are incapable of committing crime because they have not
reached the age of responsibility;
2. admits that certain adults are incapable of committing crimes because of their
conditions they are not free to choose.
4. It represented the reaction against the severity of the ' classical theory of equal
punishment irrespective of circumstances
1. The vicious soldier was distinguished from the honest soldier by the extent to
which the former was tattooed and by the decency of the designs.
2. In studying the insane, the patient, not the disease, should be the object of
attention
b) Insane criminals - Idiot, imbecils, dementia, paralysis, etc. make-up that they
display anti-social conduct persons suffering from
One advocate of the Italian school of thought was Enrico Ferri, born in Italy in
1856. Ferri advocated the "Theory of Imputability and the Denial of the Free-will"
in 1 878. Ferri contributed to the emphasis of the social factors such as
3. The social factors, including economics and political factors as well as age, sex,
education, religion. Another follower of the Italian school of thought was Rafaele
Garofalo, born in Naples in 1852, from parents of Spanish origins. Garofalo thinks
that crime can be understood only as it is studied by scientific methods. The
criminal is not a free moral agent, but isbthe product of his own traits and his
circumstances.
This theory advocates the study of the criminal rather than the crime. This school
is interested primarily in the criminal himself in order to determine the
conditioning circumstances that explain his criminality and in order to obtain light
upon the problem of how he should be handled by the social group.
3. Emphasis on Scientific Studies - The Clinical School also suggested adapting the
treatment of each individual in accordance with the diagnosis obtained by
scientific study of the criminal. This school entirely repudiates retribution,
expiation and intimidation. It gives a new content to the old terms of deterrence,
reformation and protection.
CHAPTER THREE
Historical Features
Retaliation (Personal Vengeance) was the earliest remedy for a wrong act to
anyone. The concept of personal revenge by the victim's family or tribe against
the family or tribe of the offender, hence "blood feuds" was accepted in the early
primitive societies
Fines and Punishment - customs have exerted effort and great force among
primitive societies. The acceptance of vengeance in the form of payment (cattle,
food, personal services, etc.) became accepted as dictated by tribal traditions
Death Penalty became prevalent as punishment during the 17th and 18th ce as a
form Century of GAOLS (Jails) were common. These are pre-trial detention in
England, GALLEYS were also These are long low narrow, single decked ship
facilities operated propelled by sails usually rowed by criminals a type used. of
ship used for transportation of criminals in the century. HULKS were abandoned
warships used to house prisoners were utilized, converted into prisons as a means
to relieve congestion of prisons. They were known as the "floating hells"
There are three main legal systems influentia around the world, and have been
extended to and adopted by all countries aside from those that produced them.
In their chronological order, they are;
Roman Laws
Mohammedan or Arabic Laws
Anglo-American Laws
Among the three, it was Roman law that has the lasting and most pervading
Roman private law (which include influence. especially has offered the Criminal
Law) most adequate basic concepts which sharply define, in concise and
inconsistent terminology. mature rules and a sense complete equity.
Babylonian and Sumerian Codes Code of Ur-Nammu (ca 2050 BC) - Through
archaeological diggings, scientists have acknowledged that the first law system in
the world belonged to the Mesopotamians, specifically the Sumerians. One of the
most ancient legislators, Ur-Nammu, who was the rulerbof the city of Ur had a
code detailing the punishments for witchcraft, the escapades of slaves and assault
Code of Eshunna (ca 1930 BC) - a Sumerian code which forbid accepting money or
objects "from the hands of a slave" or making loans (that is, any transactions with
a slave). Moneylenders are likewise forbidden from taking hostages, whether free
men or slaves.
Code of Lipit-Isthar (ca 1860 BC) - a more popular version the Sumerian law
which chronicles the rights of citizens, marriages, successions, property rights and
penalties
Code of Hammurabi (ca 1780 BC) - the Babylonian code that prescribes harsh
punishment Punishments were calculated according to lex talionis- law of
retaliation . Death penalties could also be imposed on crimes such as murder, and
several kinds of execution, depending on the nature of the crime.
Greek Code of Draco (621 BC) - In Greec was enforced around 621 BC, the Code
of Draco hash code that provides the same punishment for both citizens and the
slaves as it incorporates primitive concepts. The penalty for many offenses was
death; severe, that the word "draconian" comes from his name and has come to
mean, in the English language, an unreasonably harsh law. The Draco laws were
the first written laws of Greece. These laws introduced the state's exclusive role in
punishing persons accused crime, instead of relying on private justice. Thus, the
Greeks were the first society to allow any citizen to prosecute the offender in the
name of the injured party.
Solon's Law (530 BC) - This law repealed Draco's laws and allowed capital
punishment only for a limited number of serious offenses, such as murde or
military or political offenses against the state. It also gave the right of
representation, of every person to being done.
The Twelve Tables (450 BC)- earliest codification represented the on legal until
the foundation incorporated the Justinian Code.
Justinian Code - 6th C A.D., Emperor Justinian Rome wrote his match a code of
law. This was an effort to of Row desirable amount of punishment to all possible
crimes. However, the law did not survive due to the fall of the Roman Empire but
left a foundation ofWestern legal codes.
Secular Laws (4th AD) - were advocated by Christian philosophers who recognizes
the need for justice. Some of the proponents these laws were St. Augustine and
St. Thomas Aquinas. During this period, three laws were distinguished: External
Law (Lex Externa), Natural Law (Lex Naturalis), Human Law (Lex Humana). All
these laws are intended for the common good, but the Human law only becomes
valid if it does not conflict with the other two laws.
Qin Code- During the Chin or Qin Dynasty of to to defeat most 221-206 BC, of the
the King of other Qin kings (aka and Ch'in) was managed able consolidate power
over much of the modern-day territory of China. The emperor of Chin heeded Han
Fei's (Han Fei Tze 280-233 BC was a Chinese jurist) advice and consolidated his
rule with a harsh penal code for all - The Qin Code eroded the Confucian base
from which most Chinese law had benefited to date.
Han Code - In 206 BC, the Han Dynasty began and the Confucius legal policy was
reinvented with vengeance, and thereafter remained as the "dominant a force"
behind Chinese law right up 1949. The legal reform was led by the benevolent
spirit of Liu Pang (aka Liu Bang), emperor of China from 206-195 BC He stated
publicly that there were far too many laws. So he whittled it down to three;
prohibitions against murder, injury and theft.
The Tang Code (Tanlü Shuyi) - developed during the dynasty of the same name,
circa 624, and as substantially revised in a second edition which issued in 637. The
Code revised earlier existing Chinese codes and standardized procedures. For
examples, there were only two ways to perform capital punishment on a
convicted criminal: beheading or hanging.
The Ming Codes were a succession consolidations of the criminal law in China,
developed during the Ming Dynasty of 1368-1644.
Qing Code - In 1644, Chinese law was again altered by the publication of the Qing
Code, the great law codes of the Chinese dynasties. Some Confucian features of
the Qing Code included deference to the family hierarchy accidental death of an
elder.
Mamertine Prison/" Carcere Mamertino" (600 the oldest known prison can be
traced to the BC) Ancient Rome's series of dungeons. It was originally designed as
a reservoir for water.
Le Stinche Prison, built in the 1290s in Florence, Italy, housed male inmates
separately from female inmates, and also segregated inmates by agebgroup,
degree of sanity, and severity of offense.
Château d'If ( pronounced as shat-o-deef) -1524 fortress that was built on the
rocky islet of If, 2 miles off the French port of Marseilles. In 1580 it was takenbinto
use as a state prison for those convicted of serious political and religious crimes.
Bridewell Prison (1557) - the most popular workhouse in London which was built
for the employment and housing of English prisoners.
Hospice of San Michele (1704) - an old included special facilities and programs for
juvenile offenders.
Walnut Street Jail (1776)- constructed aswas originally converted into a detention
jail in Philadelphia was state prison and became the first American Penitentiary.
Devll's Island (lsle du Dlable) - 1852 most notorious prison in the world in terms
of harshness its regime and position. The island is situated in the Atlantic off the
coast of French Guiana and was in (N.E.coastline of S america).
Alcatraz (The Rock)- located on an island in San Francisco Bay. It was built for the
military in the 1850's and used by them, as a fort and a prison until 1933 when it
passed to the Department of Justice and became a civil prison unti it was closed in
1963.
Most of the prisons established between 1819 and 1870 were constructed on the
basis of a program espousing the punitive philosophy, the features which includes
mass treatment enforced silenced idleness, regimented rules and severe
punishment In Europe, several penal administrators mentioned as among those
who contributed can be progressive development of the reformratea to the
reformatory system which include the following reformers:
The period from 1870 to 1880 was called the "Golden Age of Penology" because
of the following significant events:
b. In 1872, the first International Prison Congress was held in London. It was
attended by representative of the government of the United States and European
countries. As a result of this congress, the International Penal and Penitentiary
Commission, an inter-government organization was established in 1875 with head
quarters at The Hague. The IPPC held international congresses every five years.
1950, the IPPC was dissolved in its fans. In were transferred to the Social Defense
Section functions of the United Nations.
d. The first separate institutions for women were established in Indiana and
Massachusetts.
Probation started in England with the old practice of suspending judgment and
releasing the offender on his own recognizance with the promise not to commit
any more crime. Often times, a surety was required and the guarantor was given
the authority to bring back the offender to the court if he violated the condition
of his release.
In the United States, probation was practice in Boston by John Augustus in 1841.
Although the frst probation law was passed in Massachusetts in 1878 it was not
until the passage of the first Juvenile Court law of Cook Country (Chicago) in 1899
that probation was widely used. Today, probation has won public acceptance as
part of the state correctional system by nearly all counties in the world.
In the Philippines, Act No. 4221 of the Philippine Assembly established adult
probation. but it was abolished in 1937 after two years of existence because it
was declared unconstitutional in the case.