2 Utility of Positron Emission Tomography in The Mediastinum Moving Beyond Lung and Esophageal Cancer Staging
2 Utility of Positron Emission Tomography in The Mediastinum Moving Beyond Lung and Esophageal Cancer Staging
Emission Tomography
in the Mediastinum:
Moving Beyond Lung
and Esophageal Cancer
Staging
Varun Puri, MD, Bryan F. Meyers, MD, MPH*
KEYWORDS
PET Mediastinum Lymphoma Thymoma
Germ cell tumor
Broadly, all imaging can be divided into functional/ used most commonly because of its convenient
molecular and anatomic. Functional imaging may half-life (110 minutes) and easy availability.
be defined as the ‘‘in vivo characterization and Lack of detailed resolution and inability to accu-
measurement of biologic processes at the cellular rately localize anatomy on PET images have been
and molecular level.’’1 Positron emission tomogra- the inherent drawbacks of PET technology. These
phy (PET) is the most widely employed functional weaknesses have led scientists to investigate the
imaging technique, while the modern-day proto- possibility of combining PET with the precise ana-
type of anatomic imaging is the CT scan. tomic imaging offered by CT. Two dichotomous
The last decade has seen a rapid increase in the approaches have been pursued: software fusion
use of PET technology in clinical medicine, and the and hardware fusion. Attempts to align or register
trend is expected to continue (Fig. 1). CT and PET data sets by using fusion software
Much of this has been in the field of oncology, have proven successful imaging the brain. In the
with PET being used to diagnose and stage tumors remainder of the body, however, differences in
and to assess response to therapy, usually in scanner bed profiles, external patient positioning,
conjunction with other imaging modalities. and internal organ movement present challenges
to the pure software approaches.2 Hardware fu-
TECHNICAL ASPECTS sion has largely resolved these issues with the in-
troduction of the combined PET/CT scanner. This
PET is based upon a chemical process termed technology has been commercially available since
‘‘annihilation,’’ which involves the collision of an 2001 and most PET scanners in the United States
electron with a positron that is emitted by a radio- are now combined CT/PET scanners. One must
isotope. The process results in the production of understand, however, that the CT scan performed
two photons that simultaneously move in diametri- as part of the CT/PET is usually a noncontrast
cally opposite directions and are detected by study using a lower radiation dose and provides
a PET scanner that encircles the body. Several less anatomic detail than a contrast-enhanced
positron-emitting isotopes have been developed standard CT scan, especially in the mediastinum.
(Table 1), but 18F fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) is Other attempts at combining functional and
thoracic.theclinics.com
Division of Cardiothoracic Surgery, Washington University School of Medicine, Barnes- Jewish Hospital,
Queeny Tower, 3108, One Barnes-Jewish Hospital Plaza, St. Louis, MO 63110, USA
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: [email protected] (B.F. Meyers).
Oncology imaging
1.5 Cardiology imaging diology and oncology from 1999 to 2009.
(Data from Podoloff DA, Advani RJ, Allred
1.0 C, et al. NCCN Task Force report: positron
emission tomography (PET)/computed to-
0.5 mography (CT) scanning in cancer. J Natl
Compr Canc Netw 2007;5(2):S1–22.)
0
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
anatomic imaging are ongoing and simultaneous nonsmall cell lung cancer and esophageal cancer.
PET-MRI scanning was reported recently.3 For lung cancer, PET provides a significant advan-
tage when combined with conventional anatomic
INTERPRETATION OF POSITRON EMISSION imaging, in diagnosing and staging.4 In a meta-
TOMOGRAPHY analysis, PET was 95% sensitive and 77% specific
FDG is the most commonly used tracer, and it de- in providing a diagnosis.5 Similarly, for esophageal
lineates the uptake of glucose in various tissues of cancer, PET has been used in the diagnostic set-
the body. Substitution of fluoride for a hydroxyl ting6 and in monitoring response to treatment.4
group allows cellular uptake but prevents metabo- The discussion about PET in the thorax has been
lism of the tracer; thus tracer accumulation and ac- dominated by lung and esophageal malignancies
tivity are proportional to glycolysis in the anatomic because of the sheer number of papers and vol-
area. Most tumors are obligate consumers of glu- ume of information. For the purpose of this article,
cose and avidly accumulate FDG. Such uptake is the authors will exclude the extensive and volumi-
also increased in various benign pathologies, nous literature surrounding lung and esophageal
such as inflammatory conditions, regenerating tis- cancer.
sue in trauma, infection, persistent muscular activ-
ity, and granulomatous diseases. Familiarity with THE MEDIASTINUM
normal background activity in various tissues is
essential in detecting abnormalities. The mediastinum is populated by structures
PET results are often reported with an SUV derived from all three germ lines with various basal
(standardized uptake value): a semi-quantitative metabolic rates. This unique anatomic and func-
measure of FDG uptake and activity in tissue that tional arrangement makes the mediastinum partic-
frequently has been criticized but also widely ularly suited to accurate evaluation with CT-PET.
accepted because of its relative simplicity. The Myocardial and background mediastinal activity
general formula for calculating SUV is activity per must be understood to accurately interpret PET
unit volume/injected activity/body weight. Maxi- imaging in this area. Mediastinal anatomy can be
mum SUV is a better indicator than average SUV categorized along conventional lines7 (Fig. 2),
and provides more clinical information when the and this helps in classification of mediastinal pa-
there is a large difference between the area of thology (Box 1).
interest and background activity.
The Anterior Mediastinum
POSITRON EMISSION TOMOGRAPHY
FOR THORACIC MALIGNANCIES Information about the use of PET in the anterior
mediastinum is dominated by the application of
In the last decade, PET has been employed widely PET to assessment of the thymus gland. FDG up-
in the thorax in the diagnosis and follow-up of take is commonly seen in the thymus and can be
Table 1
Positron-emitting isotopes in clinical use
Box 1 Lymphoma
Mass lesions of the mediastinum Soft tissue tumor
Anterior mediastinum Infectious/inflammatory
Neoplastic Fungal adenopathy
Substernal goiter Sarcoidosis
Thymoma Mycobacterial disease
Thymic hyperplasia Fibrosing mediastinitis
Thymic cyst Mediastinal abscess
Ectopic parathyroid mass Cystic lesions
Lymphoma Bronchogenic
Teratoma Esophageal
Germ cell tumor (GCT) Others
Seminoma Extramedullary hematopoiesis
Nonnseminomatous GCT
Fig. 3. A 33-year-old woman with stage IIa thymoma (case 9). (A) Axial CT shows solid homogenous mass in the
anterior mediastinum. (B) 18F fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG)—positron emission tomography shows intense FDG up-
take in the anterior mediastinum and contiguous pleura suggesting thymoma. (From El-Bawab H, Al-Sugair AA,
Rafay M, et al. Role of flourine-18 fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography in thymic pathology. Euro
J Cardiothorac Surg 2007;31(4):734; with permission.)
lymphomas routinely are FDG-avid. Pretherapy confound the interpretation of PET scans, the Inter-
PET, however, may be valuable, because it can national Harmonization Project recommends that
facilitate the interpretation of post-therapy PET. scans should not be performed sooner than
PET has had the highest impact in management 3 weeks after chemotherapy and should preferably
of lymphoma in the assessment of response to occur 8 to 12 weeks after completion of radiother-
therapy and guiding decisions about further treat- apy. Response assessment at the conclusion of
ment (Fig. 4). Juweid and colleagues17 assessed therapy is recommended; however, no specific
response to therapy in 54 patients who had guidelines about midtherapy assessment are avail-
aggressive non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma using the able. Visual assessment alone appears to be ade-
established criteria in conjunction with PET scan quate for determining whether PET is positive or
results and compared response with progres- negative at the conclusion of therapy, and quantita-
sion-free survival. Using the CT-based criteria tive or semiquantitative approaches (eg, using the
alone, 17 patients experienced a complete re- SUV) do not seem necessary.16
sponse, and seven experienced a less than com- The true incidence of false-positive scans in fol-
plete response. In contrast, when PET results low-up, however, remains unresolved. Zinzani
were incorporated, 35 patients experienced and colleagues19 followed 151 patients who had
a complete response, and no patients experi- mediastinal lymphoma (57 with Hodgkin’s disease
enced less-than-complete response. Therefore, and 94 with aggressive non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma
a negative PET scan even in the presence of a re- after the end of front-line treatment. Patients who
sidual mass was interpreted correctly as a com- had a positive PET scan of the mediastinum under-
plete response. Subsequently, the International went CT scanning and surgical biopsy. In 30 cases,
Harmonization Project has published revised a suspicion of lymphoma relapse was raised based
response criteria for treating lymphoma incorpo- on positive mediastinal PET scanning. Histology
rating PET.18 confirmed this suspicion in 17 out of 30 patients,
Post-therapy inflammatory changes can be seen whereas either benign (nine fibrosis, three sar-
after chemotherapy and radiation. To minimize the coid-like granulomatosis) or unrelated neoplastic
frequency of these changes, which potentially conditions (one thymoma) were demonstrated in
12 Puri & Meyers
Fig. 4. Positron emission tomography (PET)-positive residual mass in a patient with initial diagnosis of stage IIA
nodular sclerosis Hodgkin’s disease. This patient underwent a restaging PET/ CT scan 2 months after treatment
with six cycles of doxorubicin, bleomycin, vinblastine, and dacarbazine. (Top panel) Fused PET/CT images show
increased uptake clearly greater than that of mediastinal blood pool structures within the residual anterior me-
diastinal mass, consistent with persistent disease. (Middle panel) A follow-up PET/CT scan performed 2 months
later shows substantially more intense uptake in the same area, again suggesting persistent disease. (Lower
panel) A third follow-up scan performed 4 months thereafter also demonstrates intense uptake in the same
area but now with additional new sites of disease in the right paratracheal, right hilar, and subcarinal regions,
indicating frank disease progression. The patient then underwent high-dose chemotherapy and autologous
stem cell transplantation. (Courtesy of M. Juweid, MD, Iowa City, IA.)
the remaining 13 patients (43%). SUVmax was sig- mediastinum and frequently present as a very
nificantly higher among the 17 patients who had large mass with local compression. The mediasti-
signs of relapse (median 5.95, range 3.5 to 26.9) num can also be involved by metastatic germ cell
than among the 13 patients who stayed in remis- tumor from the gonads. Chest CT and evaluation
sion (median 2.90, range 1.4 to 3.3). They recom- of serum tumor markers provide the critical
mended routine biopsy before further therapy in workup before tissue diagnosis is obtained. PET
this setting. has found a niche in the evaluation of these meta-
In addition, PET is useful for directing biopsy of bolically active tumors.
the most suspicious areas based on SUV.1 Seminomas are extremely sensitive to chemo-
therapy and radiation and primarily are treated
Germ Cell Tumors
nonsurgically. The dilemma lies in managing post-
Mediastinal germ cell tumors are uncommon tu- chemotherapy residual masses. Traditionally,
mors that occur predominantly within the anterior masses larger than 3 cm on CT have been
Utility of PET in the Mediastinum 13
considered to potentially harbor residual disease selective venous sampling, and FDG PET and
and thus offered further therapy, usually resection. 11C methionine PET. Beggs and colleagues26 ret-
This approach was re-evaluated with addition of rospectively evaluated 51 patients presenting with
FDG PET studies in patients with metastatic pure hyperparathyroidism, in whom other imaging tech-
seminoma who had radiographically defined post- niques had failed to definitely identify the site of
chemotherapy residual masses.20 The PET studies suspected parathyroid adenoma. All patients had
were correlated with either the histology of the re- undergone 11C methionine PET scanning.
sected lesion or the clinical outcome documented Patients were followed up by surgical histology,
by CT, tumor markers, or physical examination or clinically if surgery was not performed. 11C
during follow-up. All 19 cases with residual lesions methionine PET scanning was found to have a sen-
greater than 3 cm and 35 (95%) of 37 with residual sitivity of 83%, a specificity of 100%, and an accu-
lesions less than or equal to 3 cm were predicted racy of 88% in successfully locating parathyroid
correctly by FDG PET. FDG-PET was superior to adenomas. Most false negatives were caused by
CT scan in detecting residual disease (specificity adenomas in the lower mediastinum that were
100% versus 74%, sensitivity 80% versus 70%, outside the area of scanning.
positive predictive value 100% versus 37%, and
negative predictive value 96% versus 92%,
Middle Mediastinum
respectively).
In another report, FDG PET was shown to be ac- Lymphoma, once again, is a prominent differential
curate in the initial staging of germ cell tumors and diagnosis in middle mediastinal neoplasia. Inflam-
in detecting unsuspected metastatic disease.21 matory involvement of mediastinal lymph nodes
Residual masses in nonseminomatous germ cell (LNs) may be acute, subacute, or chronic. Acute
tumors (NSGCT) may contain necrotic tissue, lymphadenopathy, often related to pneumonia, is
viable NSGCT, or teratoma. Kollmannsberger FDG-avid, but the activity diminishes with follow-
and colleagues22 studied patients who had up studies. Subacute or chronic LN involvement
NSGCT; independent reviewers who were blinded may be fungal or mycobacterial. Mediastinal histo-
to each other’s results evaluated the PET results plasmosis is a frequently seen entity in the mid-
and corresponding CT scan and tumor marker re- western United States and can masquerade as
sults in 85 residual lesions from 45 patients. a malignant mediastinal process in patients who
Resulting sensitivities and specificities for the pre- have known malignancy elsewhere.27 The pres-
diction of residual mass viability were as follows: ence of calcification in LNs on CT and concomitant
PET, 59% sensitivity and 92% specificity; granulomas in the lungs may provide a clue to di-
radiologic monitoring, 55% sensitivity and 86% agnosis, but tissue diagnosis frequently is
specificity; and tumor markers (TUM), 42% sensi- required.
tivity and 100% specificity. The positive and nega- The assessment of mediastinal LNs with PET is
tive predictive values for PET were 91% and 62%, even more problematic in tuberculosis-endemic
respectively. This study shows that a positive PET countries. In a study from Korea involving 674 pa-
image after treatment was a strong predictor for tients who had lung cancer,28 nodes with greater
the presence of viable carcinoma/teratoma. Con- FDG uptake than the mediastinum at PET without
versely, a negative PET after the end of treatment benign pattern calcification or high attenuation
does not allow one to avoid surgery, because 37% (greater than 70 Hounsfield units) on unenhanced
of all negative PET masses either progressed dur- CT scans were regarded as being positive for ma-
ing 6 months of follow-up, or led to a histologic ex- lignancy. The overall sensitivity, specificity, and
amination showing mature teratoma. accuracy of PET/CT for mediastinal nodal staging
Only anecdotal reports show the usefulness of were 61%, 96%, and 86%, respectively. The high
PET in mediastinal germ cell tumors,23,24 but the specificity was achieved at the expense of sensi-
identical biologic nature of disease in the medias- tivity by interpreting calcified nodes or nodes
tinum and elsewhere makes extrapolation from with high attenuation at CT, even with high FDG
previous reports meaningful. uptake at PET, as benign.
One scientist’s false positive is another’s true
PARATHYROID ADENOMA positive. Although sarcoidosis and other granulo-
matous lesions of the mediastinum can create a di-
The incidence of mediastinal parathyroid glands lemma on PET imaging in patients who have
requiring surgery was 3% in a large database.25 known malignancy, scientists have found a unique
Strategies to localize parathyroid tissue before application for PET in assessment of sarcoidosis.
parathyroid surgery encompass CT, MRI, 99Tc FDG uptake in sarcoidosis is nonspecific in both
Sestamibi scan, ultrasound, arteriography, intensity and pattern, and it is not useful in making
14 Puri & Meyers
15. Kubota K, Yamada S, Kondo T, et al. PET imaging of teratoma syndrome or cancer recurrence? J Clin
primary mediastinal tumours. Br J Cancer 1996; Oncol 2007;25(28):4494–6.
73(7):882–6. 25. Nilubol N, Beyer T, Prinz RA, et al. Mediastinal
16. Juweid ME, Stroobnts S, Hoekstra OS, et al. Use of hyperfunctioning parathyroids: incidence, evolving
positron emission tomography for response assess- treatment, and outcome. Am J Surg 2007;194(1):
ment of lymphoma: consensus of the imaging sub- 53–6.
committee of international harmonization project in 26. Beggs AD, Hain SF. Localization of parathyroid
lymphoma. J Clin Oncol 2007;25(5):571–8. adenomas using 11C-methionine positron emission
17. Juweid ME, Wiseman ME, Vose JM, et al. Response tomography. Nucl Med Commun 2005;26(2):
assessment of aggressive non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma 133–6.
by integrated International Workshop Criteria and 27. Mackie GC, Pohlen JM. Mediastinal histoplasmosis:
fluorine-18-fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission to- F-18 FDG PET and CT findings simulating malignant
mography. J Clin Oncol 2005;23(21):4652–61. disease. Clin Nucl Med 2005;30(9):633–5.
18. Cheson BD, Pfistner B, Juweid ME, et al. Revised 28. Kim YK, Lee KS, Kim BT, et al. Mediastinal nodal
response criteria for malignant lymphoma. J Clin staging of nonsmall cell lung cancer using inte-
Oncol 2007;25(5):579–86. grated 18F-FDG PET/CT in a tuberculosis-endemic
19. Zinzani PL, Tani M, Trisolini R, et al. Histological ver- country: diagnostic efficacy in 674 patients. Cancer
ification of positive positron emission tomography 2007;109(6):1068–77.
findings in the follow-up of patients with mediastinal 29. Nishiyama Y, Yamamoto Y, Fukunaga K, et al. Com-
lymphoma. Haematologica 2007;92(6):771–7. parative evaluation of 18F–FDG PET and 67Ga scin-
20. deSantis M, Becherer A, Bokemeyer C, et al. 18fluoro- tigraphy in patients with sarcoidosis. J Nucl Med
deoxy-D-glucose positron emission tomography is 2006;47(10):1571–6.
a reliable predictor for viable tumor in postchemother- 30. Truong MT, Erasmus JJ, Munden RF, et al. Focal
apy seminoma: an update of the prospective multi- FDG uptake in mediastinal brown fat mimicking
centric SEMPET trial. J Clin Oncol 2004;22(6):1034–9. malignancy: a potential pitfall resolved on PET/CT.
21. Hain S, O’Doherty M, Timothy A, et al. Fluorodeoxy- Am J Roentgenol 2004;183(4):1127–32.
glucose PET in the initial staging of germ cell 31. Gelfand MJ, O’hara SM, Curtwright LA, et al. Pre-
tumours. Eur J Nucl Med 2000;27(5):590–4. medication to block [(18)F]FDG uptake in the brown
22. Kollmannsberger C, Oeschle K, Dohmen B, et al. adipose tissue of pediatric and adolescent patients.
Prospective comparison of [18F]fluorodeoxyglucose Pediatr Radiol 2005;35(10):984–90.
positron emission tomography with conventional 32. Watanabe H, Shinozaki T, Aoki J, et al. Glucose met-
assessment by computed tomography scans and abolic analysis of musculoskeletal tumors using fluo-
serum tumor markers for the evaluation of residual rine-18-FDG PET as an aid in preoperative planning.
masses in patients with nonseminomatous germ J Bone Joint Surg Br 2000;82(5):760–7.
cell carcinoma. Cancer 2002;94(9):2353–62. 33. Ahmed AR, Watanabe H, Aoki J, et al. Schwannoma
23. Bachman J, Ernestus K, Werner T, et al. Detection of of the extremities: the role of PET in preoperative
primary choriocarcinoma in the mediastinum by planning. Eur J Nucl Med 2001;28(10):1541–51.
F-18 FDG positron emission tomography. Clin Nucl 34. Beaulieu S, Rubin B, Djang D, et al. Positron emis-
Med 2007;32(8):663–5. sion tomography of schwannomas: emphasizing its
24. Aide N. Enlarging residual mass after treatment of potential in preoperative planning. Am J Roentgenol
a nonseminomatous germ cell tumor: growing 2004;182(4):971–4.