SIF SPC 2022 Biography Scientist Acharya P C Ray New
SIF SPC 2022 Biography Scientist Acharya P C Ray New
Biography-Indian Scientist
Group Syllabus
Note: - This study material is only indicative of the range of topics that will be covered in the
test. This material covers 40% of the SPC syllabus while 40% syllabus is from school
curriculum of the respective grade and the general knowledge will cover the balance 20%
syllabus. Therefore, the organizers appeal to all the students to explore further reading
materials to prepare well for the test.
Shastra Pratibha Contest (SPC) is a science talent search contest for students studying in
UAE organized by Science India Forum, UAE guided by VIBHA (Vijnana Bharti) in
collaboration with NCERT – Ministry of Human Resources and Development and Vigyan
Prasar, an autonomous organization under the Department of Science and Technology,
Government of India.
SPC is a national contest for popularizing Science among school students of grades V to XII
studying at CBSE, ICSE & Indian curriculum.
SPC aims to identify and nurture the bright minds among the student community who are
willing to pursue science related subjects at higher studies.
To acquaint school children about India’s contributions to the world of Science and
Technology in traditional & modern format.
To conduct an annual talent search exam at the national level to identify students
who have a scientific fervour of mind.
To organize excursion visit for the winners to the various R & D institutions in the
country.
To identify successful students at the national levels and felicitate them with prizes
and certificates.
SCIENCE INDIA FORUM-UAE gratefully acknowledges the contribution of the individuals and
organizations involved in the development of this book -Legendary Indian Scientists.
This in fact solely is the initiative of Vijnana Bharati to introduce literature prepared with
material from ancient to modern period specially highlighting the contribution of India in
the field of Science & Technology as a reading material for SHASTRA PRATIBHA CONTEST.
SIF UAE is grateful to CBSE- Ex Advisors- Shri Vineet Joshi (Ex-Chairman), Dr. Sadhana
Parashar, Ex Director (Academics & Training), Convener Prof. Jagbir Singh, all the members
of Material Production Team of K.T.P.I., supporting members (CBSE) and editors Prof. Kapil
Kapoor and Prof. Michel Damino.
SIF UAE sincerely acknowledges the contributions of the Academic Committee members of
SIF-UAE & Vijnana Bharathi who participated in the review of the manuscript.
The efforts of the publication Department- VIBHA in bringing out this publication are also
appreciable.
=======================================================
The use of this book is limited to viewing, downloading, temporary storing & printing for
individual, non-commercial, educational purposes only.
========================================================
THE LEGENDARY ACHARYA PRAFULLA CHANDRA RAY
Author
Dr. Rajeev Singh
Editors
Dr. Arvind C. Ranade
National Convenor, VVM
Ms. Sangeeta Abhyankar
Content Coordinator, VVM
Published by:
Vijnana Bharati
A4, First Floor, Gulmohar Park,
August Kranti Marg,
New Delhi- 110049
e-mail: [email protected]
Author
Dr. Rajeev Singh
Editorial Team
Dr. Arvind C. Ranade
National Convenor, VVM
Ms. Sangeeta Abhyankar
Content Coordinator, VVM
Design
Mr. Jitesh Gandhi
All rights reserved. No part of the publication may be reproduced in whole or in part, or
stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic,
mechanical photocopying, recording, or otherwise without the written permission of the
publisher. For information regarding permission, write to Vijnana Bharati at:
[email protected] or call us at +91-11- 49032436
From the desk of Editors
It is indeed a great coincidence that this book on Legendary Indian Scientist and
revolutionary Acharya Prafulla Chandra Ray is getting released on his 160th birth
anniversary!
The life and work of Acharya P. C. Ray has an immense potential to inspire
generations of Indian students and people in general to walk on the path of making
Atmanirbhar Bharat – the Self-reliant India of 21st century!
Acharya P. C. Ray was the first Indian scientist who was deeply involved in studying,
analysing, reviewing and connecting the past, the present and the future of SCIENCE IN
INDIA! He fathomed the treasure of scientific knowledge created in ancient India, realised
how the British were using modern science as a tool to govern and loot the resources and
wealth in India and focussed on the future of scientific and industrial development
Independent India. His pioneering research in chemistry, revolt against discriminatory
attitude of British towards Indian scientists, efforts to impart science education for Indian
students and setting up Indian industries in British India were path-breaking actions! He was
the torch bearer who paved the path for scientists with nationalist spirit to mobilise the
independence movement in their own ways and to voice against the injustice and
discrimination to Indian scientists by British.
Vijnana Bharati will continue to strive to bring the lesser known but important facts in
the field of science and technology to the forefront; so that every Indian feels proud of the
Indian scientific heritage. As the members of the core team of VVM, we wish that this book
does not remain mere study material for the students, but gets a larger readership across India.
We are happy to mention that this book is being translated and published
simultaneously by Vijnana Bharati in eleven official languages of the country, in addition to
English, ensuring a greater outreach to the nooks and corners of India.
1. Introduction
2. Early Life
3. Education
4. Contribution to chemical research
5. Passionate and Innovative Teacher
6. Establishment of Indian Chemical Society
7. Revolutionary Scientist of Independence Movement
8. Visionary Startup Industrialist
9. Humble Philanthropist
10. The Book that taught Ancient Indian Chemistry to World, “The History of Hindu
Chemistry”
11. What others said about P. C. Ray
12. Timeline of Life Events
1. Introduction
There are occasions that demanded that I should leave the test tube to attend to the call of the
country…”. - P. C. Ray (Rowlatt Act, 1919)
The book will tell you the story of a Scientist who was a Revolutionary, an Acharya
who was an Industrialist, a Philanthropist who loved his people. These words are too
less to define the life of Acharya Prafull Chandra Ray, a towering genius of
Chemistry. The British feared his revolutionary thoughts but the world respected his
scientific discoveries. His modern Chemistry discoveries gave him the title of “Master
of Nitrites” and his path breaking book, “The History of Hindu Chemistry”, attracted
the whole world towards the scientific works and experiments of ancient Indian Sage-
Scientists. He was a patriot who finds mention in government records as
“Revolutionary under the garb of a Scientist”.
We had the privilege and pleasure of listening to-night to that eminent Indian chemist whose
name is already familiar to us for his most interesting researches on nitrites, and who
unaided has kept the torch burning for years in that ancient land of civilization and
learning.” - Nobel Laureate Sir William Ramsay
Acharya Prafulla Chandra Ray, a character defined by respect, indomitable courage and
patriotism is known as the Father of Modern Chemistry in India, who reached a high level of
perfection in his times. His commitment to scientific integrity by using the best available
local resources is of utmost significance. Ray can easily be regarded as the first Indian who
started the integration process of ancient Indian Chemistry with modern sciences, a
researcher who led Indians towards modern Chemistry, founder of Indian Chemical Society
and a Startup entrepreneur.
Acharya Prafulla Chandra Ray, a nationalist, worked hard to retrieve and strengthen
the ancient scientific knowledge of India and amalgamated it with the then emerging modern
sciences. Ray writes in his biography (preface): “While a student at Edinburgh I found to my
great regret that every civilized country including Japan was adding to the world’s stock of
knowledge but unhappy India was lagging behind. I dreamt a dream that, God willing, a time
would come when she too would contribute her quota.”
Acharya Ray was unique in his style of working as he dealt with three different fields at the
same time which included research in pure chemistry, establishment of industries and
interpretation of the ancient scientific manuscripts of chemistry.
2. Early Life
Prafulla Chandra was born on August 02, 1861, in the village of Raruli-Katipara, Jessore
district, now in present day Bangladesh. His father Harish Chandra Ray was a zamindar who
appreciated education, supported learning, had liberal views, and had set up an extensive
library at home. He was a regular subscriber to Tatwabodhini Patrika, Vividhartha Sangraha,
Hindu Patrika, Amrita Bazar Patrika and Soma Pariksha. His library was stocked with books
like Krishna Mohan Banerjee’s Encyclopedia Bengalensis, Young’s Night Thoughts,
Lawson’s Paswavali (Tale of Animals), Bacon’s Novum Organum, Carey’s Holy Bible,
Mrityunjaya Vidyalankar’s Probodh-chandrika and Rajabali. He strongly believed and
supported women education and established the first girls’ school in Raruli and a Middle
English School. Many times, his father was called ‘Mlechha’ (foreign heretic) by the fellow
villagers. His mother, Bhubanmohini Devi was very well educated with supporting views.
This academic atmosphere at home made a lasting impact on Ray and he was captivated
towards literature and history. They were six siblings, four brothers; Jnanendra Chandra,
Purnachandra, Buddhadev and two sisters Indumati and Belamati. Prafulla Chandra was the
third child of his parents and was nicknamed Fulu.
3. Education
Prafulla Chandra had his early education in the school founded by his father. In 1870, Ray’s
family shifted to Calcutta and Prafulla was admitted to Hare School. When he was in IV class
(1874), he got a bad attack of dysentery, which took a long period of treatment and forced
him to discontinue his studies for some years. This long period impaired his digestive organs
and made him a permanent valetudinarian. In 1876, he resumed his regular studies at Albert
School, Calcutta, established by Keshab Chandra Sen, the founder of Brahmo Samaj.
After clearing the entrance examination in 1879, Prafulla Chandra took admission at
Metropolitan Institution (now Vidyasagar College) founded by Pandit Iswarchandra
Vidyasagar. Ray mentions in his autobiography “…This was the first bold experiment in
India of making higher education as cheap as secondary education….. In the first place the
Metropolitan Institution was a national institution and something we could look upon as our
own''. Metropolitan College had great teachers like Surendranath Banerjee and
Prasannakumar Lahiri, who strongly influenced the nationalist feelings of Prafulla Chandra
and inspired him to work for the development and upliftment of the society.
As an external student, his Physics and Chemistry classes were held at Presidency
College, Calcutta. Chemistry soon became his dearest subject which was being taught by
Prof. Alexender Pedler, whose teaching of the subject influenced Ray to take up the study of
Chemistry. Being inquisitive in nature since childhood, he was not merely satisfied by
watching classroom experiments. Prafulla Chandra along with one of his close friends, set-up
a mini laboratory at home and reconducted the experiments taught to them in the college.
Halfway through his BA studies, he won the Gilchrist scholarship of Edinburgh University
(1882). Only two students were selected from India, Prafulla Chandra Ray and a Parsee
student Bahadurji. Ray completed his B. Sc. in 1885 and at the age of 26, was awarded a D.
Sc. in Inorganic Chemistry (1887) for his thesis, ‘Conjugated Sulphates of Copper
Magnesium Group: A study of Isomorphous Mixtures and Molecular Combination.’ His
thesis was judged the best thesis and got ‘Hope Prize’ which allowed him to carry on
research for one more year. He was elected the Vice-President of the Edinburgh University
Chemical Society in 1887, as his colleagues and teachers held him in high esteem because of
his disciplined life, work ethics and simplicity.
Before returning to India, Ray was given testimonials and recommendations which
mentioned highly of his attainments in the field of Chemistry. Professor Cum Brown, Sir
William Muir and Prof. C. H. Tawney (Principal, Presidency College) wrote impressive
letters of introduction, mentioning him to be an invaluable asset to any institution. He
returned to India in 1888, and applied for a job at Indian Educational Services (IES) and
despite his impressive letters of recommendations and introductions, he had to remain jobless
for a year. At that time, letters of recommendations were mandatory to get a job under the
education system implemented by British. There were two classes in the education services:
Imperial and Provincial. The Imperial service was mostly reserved for Europeans and had
more pay and privileges. Such was the extent of racial discrimination of British, that P. C.
Ray was appointed as a temporary Assistant Professor in Chemistry under the Provincial
Services, with an absurdly low salary of Rs. 250 per month, for a person with such high
qualifications. He went to Darjeeling to talk to British Officer Sir Alfred Croft, the Director
of Public Instruction to discuss the injustice being meted out to him. As Ray mentions in his
autobiography, “Croft almost got into a temper and exclaimed: There are other walks of life
open to you. Nobody compels you to take this appointment.” Ray protested against this
humiliation but accepted the job due to his passion for research and teaching in July 1889.
In 1916, the then Vice-Chancellor of Calcutta University, Ashutosh Mukherjee invited P. C.
Ray and C. V. Raman as Palit* Professor of Chemistry and Physics respectively, to join the
newly opened University College of Sciences, Rajabazar, Calcutta. Here, he was able to carry
out his research work along with his students in a much better manner. P. C. Ray is credited
for shaping the Science College into a centre of excellence. It was during this time that his
students started calling him by the title of ‘Acharya’.
* The Palit Chair of Chemistry is a Chemistry professorship in the University of Calcutta, India. The post was
named after Sir Taraknath Palit who donated Rs. 1.5 million to the university in 1912.
4. Contribution to chemical research
P. C. Ray mentions in the second sentence of his autobiography that he was born (1861) in a
very historical year for the field of Chemistry, the year when Crookes discovered the element
Thallium. From 1894, in the course of the next 40 years, he produced wonderful research
results. A highly enthusiastic researcher himself, Ray’s mission was to kindle the flame of
eagerness, inquisitiveness and hunger for research among his students. Many of his research
productions have been carried out along with his research students.
Praful Chandra Ray began his research in India in the field of detection of adulteration of
edible fats and food items. He was very worried about the regular deterioration in quality of
food items available in Bengal. He conducted chemical examinations of adulterants in fats,
oils and ghees available in the market and published his findings in the Journal of Asiatic
Society of Bengal in 1894. His aim was to create standards for food items and put the
identified adulterants being used in Bengal in public domain.
P. C. Ray began analysis of certain rare Indian minerals in his quest to discover some new
elements to fill the gaps in Mendeleev’s Periodic table. He travelled far and wide all through
India collecting samples of compounds and mineral ores. By 1894, he had built up an
extensive library of samples with the aid of his friend Thomas Holland of Geological Survey
of India. He soon reported the first ever synthesis of the previously unknown compound of
Mercurous Nitrite Hg2(NO2)2. He narrates in his autobiography, "the discovery of mercurous
nitrite opened a new chapter in my life". This compound of mercury was a fascinating
example of two relatively unstable ions combining to form a stable substance. He received
congratulatory messages from eminent chemists like Victor Meyer, Volhard, Berthelot and
his teachers. On his discovery, Alexander Pedler, his former teacher said, “Dr. P. C. Ray, by
his discovery of the method of preparation of this compound, has filled up a blank in our
knowledge of the mercury series”.
P. C.
Ray’s
Laboratory,
University
College of
Science and
Prafulla Chandra was a synthetic inorganic chemist with active interest in organic
molecules and reactions; especially into the chemistry of thio-organic compounds. His initial
work which made him famous was based on the chemistry of inorganic and organic nitrites.
He was regarded as ‘Master of Nitrites’. British Chemist, Henry H. Armstrong stated: ‘The
way in which you have gradually made yourself ‘master of nitrites’, is very interesting and
the fact that you have established that as a class they are far from being the unstable bodies,
chemists had supposed, is an important addition to our knowledge.’ He continued his work
on related compounds and thereon shifted to organic thio-compounds and their metal
complexes. The metal which particularly fascinated him was mercury, maybe because it has
an extensively important role in Indian medicine system of Ayurveda.
The formation of mercurous nitrite, Hg2(NO2)2 was an accidental discovery, while he was
trying to react excess mercury with cold dilute nitric acid to synthesize mercurous and mercuric
nitrates, Hg2(NO3)2 and Hg(NO3)2. During the course of reaction, he noticed the appearance of a
yellow crystalline solid on the sides which on analysis revealed to be the unknown mercurous nitrite.
The nitrite ion probably was the result of initial reduction of nitric acid by mercury. The pertinent
point to be noted here is that stable mercury(I) complexes are very few in existence, even today, owing
to the instability of mercury(I) towards disproportionation to mercury(II) and metallic mercury in
solution.
This discovery was first published in the Journal of Asiatic Society of Bengal (1896),
and immediately noticed by Nature magazine, which mentioned the work in its issue of
May28, 1896, “A paper by Dr. P. C. Ray….. on mercurous nitrite, that is worthy of note…”.
Eminent chemists of the time like Volhard, Victor Meyer, Berthelot sent him congratulatory
letters on the discovery.
Subsequent series of work by Ray and his students, led to establishing the foundation
of the first research school of modern Chemistry in India. He published numerous significant
research papers on nitrites and its related derivatives. Now with advances in analysis
techniques, the compound has now been structurally analyzed using X-ray crystallography
techniques (1985, 1986, 2011).
As can be seen from the figure, the molecule is planar and centrosymmetric. The Hg atom is
unsymmetrically bonded to nitrite ion through the two oxygen atoms, thereby forming a four
membered chelate ring. The Hg-Hg bond length is 2.54 Å and the shorter and longer Hg-O distances
are 2.20 Å and 2.61 Å respectively .
He also reported that on careful heating to 70 oC in moderate vacuum, a part of the ammonium
nitrite goes through the process of sublimation via vaporization.
He further worked upon it to determine the vapour density of ammonium nitrite and observed
that his experimental density value agreed very well with the calculated figure, thereby showing that
the salt existed in ion-pair form. In those times, only ammonium chloride salt was known to exhibit
this property.
As a teacher, Acharya Ray was an ideal person who was loved by his students. He
believed in the philosophy of Sanskrit shloka, which he usually quoted: “Wish for victory
everywhere except from your son and from your disciple.” He writes in his autobiography,
“Although as yet scientists in posse, there was something indescribable in their character,
which drew me to them. The bonds existing between them and me were as subtle as those of
chemical affinity. I used to visit them often in their hostel rooms and they were my constant
companions in my maidan walk in the evenings.” The maidan (ground) referred to here is the
famous Garer Maath’, the vast maidan adjoining Fort William. He used to take a walk daily
evening along with his students discussing studies, social problems, swadeshi movement and
other issues.
Some of the luminaries who learned the art of scientific investigation and undertook
research with him and spread across the country in different universities were: Jnan Chandra
Ghosh (Director of IISc, Bangalore and founding Director of IIT, Kharagpur), Panchana
Niyogi (founding Principal of Raja Monindra Chandra College in Calcutta), Nil Ratan Dhar
(Allahabad University), Priyada Ranjan Ray (Calcutta University), Biresh Chandra Guha
(founder of Biochemistry Research in India), prominent scientist Shanti Swarup Bhatnagar
was a student of Prof. Atul Chandra Ghosh, who was in turn a student of P. C. Ray. Eminent
Indian scientists like Satyendra Nath Bose (Bose–Einstein statistics) and Meghnad Saha,
(Saha equation) were also part of his extended group.
P. C. Ray, S. N. Bose, Meghnad Saha and other prominent scientists of India
P. C. Ray took the initiative to create Indian Chemical Society (1924). He along with
Shanti Swarup Bhatnagar (student), J. N. Mukherjee and J. C. Ghosh had always felt the
strong need of a chemistry society of India and the Indian Chemical Society was founded and
registered on 9 May, 1924. P. C. Ray consented to be the Founder-President for the first two
terms. The establishment of the new chemical society and its journal was well received in
academic circles in India and abroad. The London Chemical Society sent this message,
"Hearty congratulations and warm wishes to the newly formed Indian Chemical Society".
In the initial days, the society didn’t have its own office and functioned from the
office of Dr. J N Mukherjee (Secretary). Prafulla Chandra Ray felt that proper
accommodation was needed and so he gifted ten thousand Rupees to Calcutta University
requesting space for the society. Thus, in 1933, the construction of three large rooms started
on the second floor of the Sir Taraknath Palit Building of the University College of Science
and Technology, Calcutta. The address 92, Acharya Prafulla Chandra Road, Kolkata- 700009
remains its registered office still.
This society published the first research journal of India, The Journal of Indian
Chemical Society, under his leadership in November, 1924. Nature magazine welcomed it
with a congratulatory note, "The great work in chemistry which has occurred in the Indian
Empire during the past ten years, had led to the establishment of an Indian Chemical Society,
the first number of the quarterly journal of the Society has now appeared. There are thirteen
papers, and only one of these is published under the English names. The remaining papers
are published by Indians and come from all parts of the Indian Empire. Four of these
emanate from the College of Science, Calcutta, and this is as it should be, because for many
years past, this Institution has been the back-bone of chemical research in India."
He believed that problems being faced by a common Indian can best be understood by
an Indian and there was a need for national regeneration using science. To achieve this, he,
along with Meghnad Saha, established Indian Science News Association (ISNA), with the
purpose of spreading and informing achievements in the scientific domain and initiating the
young scientists to devise solutions for the problems present in the society. P. C. Ray was the
founder President of ISNA and he guided in starting the journal – Science and Culture in
1935.
7. Revolutionary Scientist of Independence Movement
P. C. Ray was a nationalist scientist with a fire raging inside him since his childhood
to see India in its former glory. He mentions many times in his autobiography that India was
glorious but the present Indians need to adapt and compete with the changing times.
During the late 19th century, nations had started looking up towards establishing
scientific institutions of research and technology, it was viewed that the wealth of a nation
was dependent upon how it promotes and develops scientific thoughts in its society. The
patriot Surendra Nath Banerjee (father of Indian nationalism), who taught English to Ray in
College, instilled in him a sense of nationalism.
In 1885, he took part in the essay competition announced by Sir Stafford Northcote, Lord
Rector of the University of Edinburgh, on the subject “India Before and After the Mutiny” He
did not get a prize in this competition. In his biography, he wrote- “The prize was awarded to
a rival competitor, but my essay as well as another's was bracketed together as proxime
accesserunt (nearest approach to the best).” He described with a lot of courage and
conviction how the British are perpetuating colonial exploitation in India neglecting the
development and education of its people. Ray distributed copies of his printed essay among
the university students and general public with the appeal to take steps to free India from
colonial bondage. He sent one copy to Sir John Bright, an open minded and progressive
Parliamentarian for his comments. Bright wrote a letter commending the article and permitted
him to use the letter to publicize the contents of the essay. Prafulla’s letter to newspapers to
expose the nature of colonial exploitation before the general public of Britain is quite
noteworthy. Scottish Newspaper, The Scotsman remarked "It contains information in
reference to India which will not be found elsewhere, and is deserving of the utmost notice."
From the 1880 to 1925, Bengal was going through a rough transition period. On one
hand, the partition of Bengal occurred in 1905 and on the other hand, young Indians were
establishing themselves in all spheres from science to business. The basic Bengali community
was following two different paths, one was awakening to the concept of Swadeshi and the
other following the path of militant struggle to achieve independence. Swadeshi or self-
reliance was an attempt to create awareness among Indian masses to create opportunities in
every societal sector based upon indigenous enterprise. Ray was part of the Swadeshi
community who believed in self-reliance of India, modernising education, ushering in the
industrial revolution of Indian products, teaching skills to students so that they can participate
and compete with the fast changes occurring in the world.
Indian scientists were constantly feeling the requirement for a system of scientific self-
reliance to be created in India, which will be managed and run by Indians. He established the
first research laboratory at Presidency College from scratch and that became the cradle of
chemistry research for the whole country. He realized that our country needs a hand of highly
educated and capable researchers dedicated to the service of sciences.
P. C. Ray was always irked by the absence of research studies in the academics of
Calcutta University and therefore, he was fully supportive of a teaching system gaining roots
in Bengal at that time. He closely affiliated himself with National Council of Education
(NCE), a pedagogic organization based upon the swadeshi spirit with science, technology and
industrialization as its foundation. NCE was founded by Satish Chandra Mukherjee along
with Sri Aurobindo. In the year 1921, the council planned expansion in the syllabus of
engineering studies. Under the chairmanship of P. C. Ray, a syllabus revision committee was
set up to introduce new streams. The new curriculum introduced Chemical Engineering
besides Mechanical and Electrical. Later on, Ray was made the President of National
Council of Education, Bengal. He was of the opinion that Indian students should learn new
skills and techniques and mere getting degrees will not suffice the modern era dawning upon
the world. He inspired students to become self-reliant entrepreneurs and not keep running for
academic degrees to get a comfortable government job.
He believed in the principles of Gandhi and was a practising Gandhian in daily life. When
Mahatma Gandhi visited Calcutta in 1901, on the invitation of Gopal Krishna Gokhale,
Prafulla Ray actively participated in making arrangements for Gandhi’s first public
appearance in Calcutta. In the book My Experiments with Truth (Part 3, Chapter 17), Gandhiji
writes, “Of these the one who stands foremost in my memory is Dr. (now Sir) P. C. Ray. He
lived practically next door and was a very frequent visitor. This is how he introduced Dr.
Ray: ‘This is Prof. Ray, who having a monthly salary of Rs. 800, keeps just Rs. 40 for himself
and devotes the balance to public purposes. He is not, and does not want to get, married.’
During the decade of 1920’s, Ray participated in the freedom movement and was attached
with political fronts. Although he did not take part in active politics, he could not keep
himself aloof from the freedom struggle sweeping through the nation at that time.
In the 1920's, during the peak of the Non-cooperation Movement, he delivered the
famous inspiring quote, “Science can afford to wait but Swaraj cannot…” -
The anecdote below has been reproduced word to word from P C Ray’s autobiography “Life
and Experiences of a Bengali Chemist”.
“A mass meeting was held at the Town Hall- the principal speaker being C. R. Das,
who was just then coming to the fore. My friend Satyananda Bose called on me one afternoon
and suggested to me that I might go a little earlier to my usual maidan constitutional walk so
as to be present at the meeting. It was thus only by an accident that I happened to be one of
the audience. The ground floor of the Town Hall where the meeting was held was packed to
suffocation and a large crowd had also gathered on the southern flight of steps as also on the
broad street. C. R. Das in order to be audible to the vast seething mass of humanity took his
stand on the front of the steps. Naturally I was at the back of the audience and occupied a
very inconspicuous place. Somehow or other I was recognised and pushed forward by those
about me and placed alongside of Das. Everyone was anxious that I should have my say;
what then happened is thus described by a local daily:
“Mr. C. R. Das then asked Dr. Sir P. C. Ray to speak on the resolution. Dr. Ray rose
to speak and then was witnessed a scene which I shall never forget. For a few minutes Dr.
Ray could not utter a single syllable as ovation after ovation, -cheers after cheers, shouts of
“Bande Mataram” greeted the venerable Doctor. Dr. Ray began by saying that he had not
the remotest idea that he would have to address the meeting even for a single moment. He
came as a mere spectator. He was a man of the laboratory but he felt that there are occasions
– the rest of the sentence was drowned in deafening cheers. Dr. Ray repeated that he felt that
there are occasions which demanded that he should leave his test-tube to attend to the call of
the country. So grave was the danger to our national life that even Dr. P. C. Ray left his
work in the laboratory and joined the meeting to raise his voice of protest against the
obnoxious Bill". [The Amrita Bazar Patrika, February 1919]
When British rulers introduced the norm of separate election of Hindus and Muslims
(Indian Councils Act, 1909 or Minto-Morley Reforms) to the legislative forms, Congress
remained indifferent to it but Prafulla Chandra opposed nationalism on the basis of religion.
He criticized the opportunist policy of then Congress leadership which he believed could lead
to communal divide.
Being a righteous person and despite being a practising Gandhian, he severely criticized
Gandhiji for his blunder in Khilafat Movement (1919), “We must not allow our loyalty to the
mother country to be swamped by the wave of extra-territorial patriotism. India must not be a
spoke in the Khilafat gyrated from Istanbul. The Swaraj of India must be our one all-
compelling goal…”.Ray was vociferous in his support for Subhash Chandra Bose, when the
Congress was divided on the election of Netaji to the President’s post the second time in
1938.
During World War II, when Nazi Germany attacked Russia in 1941, Acharya Prafulla
Chandra Ray along with prominent Indians, issued a manifesto urging Indians to express full
“Sympathy and solidarity with USSR”. Acharya P C Ray was the first signatory to the
statement.
He was also sympathetic towards the revolutionaries and would make arrangements for
their shelter and food at his factories. After his death, many revolutionaries and his
colleagues mentioned his indirect support and help in manufacturing explosives. The
Government records of that time mention him as a “Revolutionary in the garb of a Scientist.”
Prafulla Chandra Ray, Netaji Subhas Bose at Sadhana Aushadhalaya (1924)
In later decades, Ray heavily criticised British for their failure to understand the
nationalist feelings of Indians, the progressive needs of young Indians and cautioned the
British that this would lead to inevitable anger against their administration. The political and
economical mayhem that they have created will cost them dearly. He was right in his
observation as can be seen from the fact that India gained independence within the next 10
years.
Civic Reception to Acharya Prafulla Chandra Roy December 10,
1932
P C Ray inaugurating Gujarat Vidyapeeth University established
by Mahatma Gandhi
‘In Europe, industry and scientific pursuits have gone hand in hand … one helping
the other… The gigantic progress in industry achieved in Europe and America is a history of
the triumph of research in the laboratory. These thoughts were weighing heavy on me at the
very threshold of my career at Presidency college. How to utilize the thousand and one raw
products which nature in her bounty has scattered in Bengal? How to bring bread to the
mouth of the ill fed…’ - P. C. Ray
Since childhood, Prafulla Ray had observed the frequent famines and poverty in the
country. Due to his knowledge of ancient Indian history, he was aware of the highly
developed Indian industries existing before the arrival of British, who deliberately destroyed
and crushed the native manufacturers to promote the British interest. Under an outsider and
aggressive rule, gradually Indians had lost the inspiration and endeavor to set up any new
venture.
During his stay in England, Ray had observed the social and scientific changes in the
English society. On his return from England, he had set up his plans to locally manufacture
some of the chemicals which were being imported in bulk from England and Europe. This
dependency on imports made the existing local industry slow with no growth and innovation.
With increasing unemployment levels in Bengal, he took up to himself to revive the industrial
economy using the latest scientific knowledge and putting it to industrial use. With an initial
investment of Rs. 700, in the year 1893, he set up India’s first pharmaceutical company,
Bengal Chemicals, now known as the Bengal Chemicals and Pharmaceutical Works Ltd
(BCPWL). The company is now in prominence during the Covid-19 situation, as it has been
licensed by Government of India to produce the much-needed hydroxychloroquine (HCQ).
With establishment of this industry, he was able to achieve his dream definition of
Swadeshi, self-reliance in research leading to the development of swadeshi industries.
BCPWL. was set up with an in-house research facility for development of alternate and cost-
efficient processes for production of imported chemicals like Tincture of Nux Vomica, Spirit
of Nitric Ether, Syrup Ferri Iodidi. The products manufactured at Bengal Chemicals were
displayed at the Indian Medical Congress, Calcutta held in 1898, which impressed the doctors
attending the Congress. Many of them at a later stage, started recommending these drugs as
prescriptions. Being from an inorganic and analytical background, it was a little easy for
Prafulla Ray to impart training skills to his industry workers and very soon he was able to
achieve his target. His excitement and dedication can be gaged from the fact that after his
academic work, he used to work in the Bengal Chemical factory daily from 7 to 8 PM. In his
autobiography, Ray pens this excitement as, “...the very idea of locally manufacturing
pharmaceutical preparations, which hitherto had to be imported, acted like a tonic”. Sir John
Cumming in 1903 noted, ‘BCPWL. is one of the most go-ahead young enterprises in Bengal.’
His industry also started manufacturing basic necessary reagents like sulphuric acid,
which were a necessary part of the chemical processing industry. Gradually his industry
moved towards manufacturing of various other products like soaps, paper pulp, fertilizers and
oils. P. C. Ray along with his students established many other industries like Acharya
Prafulla Chandra Cotton Mills, Bengal Salt Manufacturing Company, Bengal Potteries,
Bengal Enamel Works, Bengal Steam Navigation, Bengal Paper, Bengal Canning and
Condiment, National Tanneries, Chuckervertty, Chatterjee & Company Ltd (Publishing
House) and Bharati Scales and Engineering Company. Even today many of us are using the
products of industrial legacy established by Ray in the form of common sanitization products
like naphthalene and phenyl bottles.
Many Indians from various walks of life like Leaders, Scientist and Doctors gradually
started supporting him in his endeavours. People like Subhash Chandra Bose, Chitranjan Das,
Dr. Amulya Charan Basu, Radha Gobinda Kar, Kulbhusan Bhaduri, Chandra Bhusan
Bhaduri, Suresh Prasad Sarbadhikari stepped in to help his initiatives achieve success.
Prominent British Chemist of the time, Sir Thomas Thorpe, wrote a two-page front
article in Nature titled, ‘The life-work of a Hindu Chemist’. He said, “Sir Prafulla Chandra
Ray, professor of chemistry in the Presidency College, is well known to chemists in this
country as the author, either alone or in collaboration with his pupils, of more than a hundred
papers, chiefly on the inorganic and organic nitrites, published in the Transactions of the
Chemical Society, in Continental journals, or in the Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal.
Thorpe also mentions that Ray has contributed ‘as the founder of a successful chemical
industry’, which ‘proved of considerable service to the Government during the war, when the
supply of Western chemicals and drugs was seriously interfered with’.
Prominent British Chemist of the time, Sir Thomas Edward Thorpe, wrote a two-page front
article in Nature titled, “The life-work of a Hindu Chemist”. Thursday, March 6, 1919
9. Humble Philanthropist
Being from a humble background, Ray always had that spirit to contribute to society.
He never missed an opportunity wherein the welfare of citizens was priority. Even as owner
of the various industries, he never took any salary and distributed all his part among the
workers.
A simple incident will give you an example of the humbleness of P. C. Ray. It was a
tradition in colleges that before the Professor came to take the class, a clerk would come in
and clean the blackboard, table and put in all teaching materials. One day a clerk came in
wearing a coat and did all the chores. After some time, Professor Ray entered the room to
take the class and to everyone’s surprise, he was also wearing the same coat as was the clerk.
After the class was over, the students in their eagerness tried to get the reason and it was
revealed that Prof Ray had gone to purchase woollen clothes for himself but during the
purchase, he realized that the clerk from the college would also need it and so he bought two
sets of cloth and got two suits stitched for both of them.
In 1916, he joined as Palit Professor in Calcutta University and from 1921 onwards,
he stopped accepting salary and requested the University to spend the money on development
of the Chemistry Department. For the last 20 years of his life, he lived in a room of the
university building. He even considered ceiling fans as an element of luxury. This room now
houses the P. C. Ray Museum. Many students, mainly the poor, lived with him. In 1922, he
made an endowment of Rs. 10000 for an annual prize in Chemistry named after the great
Indian Chemist Nagarjuna. In 1936, he made another endowment named after Prof. Ashutosh
Mukherjee. He donated Rs. 1,80,000 to Calcutta University for extension and development of
chemistry at the time of his retirement.
In 1921, during the famine of Khulna, he created Khulna Relief Committee to feed
the poor people of the famine affected district for months. In 1922, P. C. Ray motivated
scientists and students to come out to help flood affected North Bengal (collected Rs.3 lakh
in one month). He along with Subhash Chandra Bose rushed to affected areas and set-up the
Bengal Relief Committee, he being the President of the committee. On his call, many of his
students and colleagues like Prof. P. C. Mitter, Meghnad Saha, Prof. Niren Chowdhury
worked twenty-four hours helping out the citizens.
[From his autobiography: The Special Correspondent of the Manchester Guardian
writes from the flooded area of Northern Bengal, Nov 11. —
“In these circumstances a professor of chemistry. Sir P. C. Ray stepped forward and
called upon his countrymen to make good the Government's omissions. His call was
answered with enthusiasm. The public of Bengal in one month contributed three lakhs of
rupees; rich women giving their silks and ornaments, and the poor giving their spare
garments. Hundreds of young men volunteered to go down and carry out the distribution of
relief to the villagers, a task which involved a considerable amount of hard work and bodily
discomfort in a malarious country.
What greatly aggravated the public’s dissatisfaction with the Government's attitude
was the fact that the disaster is generally attributed to the faulty design of the railways which
is believed to make very inadequate provision for the passage of flood water. There is much
evidence to support this view, but it was only after a month and a half that the Government
promised an inquiry into the question.”]
Again in 1923, the Bengal Relief Committee collected Rs. 2.5 million in cash for
millions of people made homeless by flood that year. In 1931, flood struck again North
Bengal, Prafulla at the age of 70, made Sankat Taran Samity to provide relief to the affected
people. This time he devised a new way and formed cooperative committees in which there
was direct participation of his students and the public in general.
Page of Daily Diary of P C Ray
10. The Book that taught Ancient Indian Chemistry to World: THE
HISTORY OF HINDU CHEMISTRY
As a student at the University of Edinburgh, Ray was impressed by the scientific knowledge
of ancients in the western world. This generated immense curiosity in him to explore the
contribution of ancient India in the field of science and technology. He was of the view that a
Nation's success and strength depends upon what its citizens achieve independently in the
fields of science, technology, pedagogy and methodology. He observed that Hindu traditions
had a strong scientific basis that formed a knowledge bank, which was followed in daily life
but taken for granted as it was their way of life. The importance of maintaining and nurturing
this tradition and past knowledge was important for the success of India. Ray says in his
autobiography,
“The Hindu nation with its glorious past and vast, latent potentialities may yet look
forward to a still more glorious future, and, if the perusal of these pages will have the effect
of stimulating my countrymen to strive to regain their old position in the intellectual
hierarchy of nations, I shall not have laboured in vain.”
Prafulla Chandra Ray was a visionary ahead of his times, who understood the
importance of amalgamation of ancient scientific experimentation and modern emerging
sciences. He had observed that the scientific knowledge was vast and highly advanced of its
time but scattered all over. Parts of it were present in Royal libraries, some in temple
libraries, European museums, some with individuals, various of them in regional languages,
many of them in Sanskrit and Pali. With the passage of time and the impact of Mughal and
British system, people had stopped reading them. Hence, the knowledge was not transferred
to the next generation. He decided to take up this herculean task of compiling this scientific
knowledge at one place.
He had always been interested in reading and exploring the history of science,
especially his own subject, Chemistry. While at Edinburgh University, he read Geschichte
der Chemie (History of Chemistry) by German Chemist Hermann Franz Moritz Kopp which
influenced his understanding about the topic. In 1894, at Presidency College, he read the
Collection des anciens alchimistes grecs by Bertholet. He was greatly impressed by the book
of Berthelot, Les Origines de l'alchimie (1885), which detailed the work of ancient Greeks in
alchemy. Prafull Ray sent letters to Berthelot on discussions about the topic and explaining
the work done by ancient Indians in Chemistry through the ages. To his utter dismay, he
found that at international level, scientists were not aware of the work of Indians, as the work
had never been translated in any international language and neither was it communicated in
the modern sense. Whatever was available at that time, had either been translated by
Europeans or kept at their museums as a rare transcript, with no understanding of the work.
For many years, he continued studying various Indian texts of Susruta, Charaka and
explored the world of Indian science developed hundreds of years ago. He learnt the
languages like Sanskrit and Pali from eminent scholars like Pandit Nabakanta Kavibhusana
and Acharya Brajendranath Sil. Pundit Nabakanta Kavibhusan worked with him in searching
ancient manuscripts in various temple libraries of Benares (present Varanasi). They collected
many volumes and texts of books in Sanskrit language which contained processes,
techniques, methodology, characteristics and other details about use of chemical knowledge
and involvement of concepts of Chemistry in ancient India. He studied ancient Indian
medical and chemical encyclopaedia like ‘Materia Medica of the Hindus’ by Udoychand
Dutt, ‘Indian Materia Medica and Indigenous Drugs of India’ by Kannai Lal Dey. He took
guidance and help from Kavirajs, the traditional scholars of Indian system. He carried out
many of the experiments to prove and verify their exactness like preparations with Kurchi
(Holarrhena antidysenterica), Kalmegh (Andrographis paniculata), Vasaka syrup (Adhatoda
vasica) etc.
Ray took it as a mission to disprove the misconception that the ancient Indian science
was based only on mythology and had no proof. He stated that experimental learning was
part of Indian system and mentioned important works of thirteenth and fourteenth century
Yasodhara’s ‘Rasaprakasa Sudhakara’ and Ramchandra’s ‘Rasendrachintamani’. Many of
the manuscripts were in pieces and one that he found complete was ‘Rasarnava’, from
Raghunath Temple Library, Kashmir and another copy of it at Oriental M. S. S. Library,
Chennai (now known as Government Oriental Manuscripts Library and Research Centre,
Chennai). The book highlighted and mentioned the existence of knowledge of chemistry
among the Hindus in the twelfth century.
Acharya Prafulla Chandra Ray’s book, The History of Hindu Chemistry is a critically
acclaimed treatise on Rasashastra and Ayurveda. The first volume of the book was published
in 1902, and the second in 1909. The book was strong enough to attract the attention of
western world towards Indian alchemy and lead to the globalization of the fundamentals of
Rasashastra.
In his book he proves and emphasizes the fact that alchemy and scientific and medical
principles based on metal mercury purely originated from India. He accepts in his book that
with the advent of outsiders in India, there was indeed influence of Arab and European
knowledge on Indian alchemy but the use of many medicinal and chemical compositions
predates the Arabic-European impact. He found that it was during the reign (700 AD) of
Khalif Harun and Khalif Mansur that the works of Charaka and Susruta were translated into
Arabic language. Ray's work on bringing up the ancient knowledge helped him in applying it
in terms of emerging modern science of that time. The book history of Hindu Chemistry
proudly presents to the world the great work done by Indian sage-scientists like Nagarjuna
and Charaka. He quotes an example to show the timeline, when he details the preparations of
various mild alkalis and caustics mentioned in the book of Susruta whereas the evidence of
this knowledge in Europe is found just around 1755 AD. Another example that he mentions
is of the process of Zinc extraction as mentioned in the ancient book, Rasarnava, the process
of which is exactly what the modern chemists follow.
The book asserted that Indian knowledge was far more superior than Europeans. P. C.
Ray mentions in his book ‘The History of Hindu Chemistry’ that Indians developed the
concepts and experimental knowledge of Chemistry much before the Europeans.
The book clearly mentions that, “In the European histories of chemistry, the credit of
being the first to press chemical knowledge into the service of medicine and introduce the use
of the internal administration of mercurial preparations, is given to Paracelsus… The
Nāgarjunas and Patānjalis of India, however, had the merit of anticipating Paracelsus and
his followers by several centuries… We have indeed reasons to suspect that Paracelsus got
his ideas from the East, and in Chapter on Arabian indebtedness to India we have pointed out
the media through which Indian sciences filtered into Europe”
As Ray said, ‘Hindu Chemistry ... waited long and patiently for an interpreter. I
thought I owed a debt to that great nation to which I am proud to belong ...’. Further, ‘I
implore you to take to its pursuit and I hope that you will justify by your work that your are
no unworthy successors of your glorious forefathers in the world of learning’
“He is also a real organiser and a real teacher. I heard a European saying, “If Mr.
Gandhi had only been able to create two more Sir P. C. Ray, he would have succeeded in
getting Swaraj within this year.” - Correspondent, Manchester Guardian
“A more remarkable career than that of P.C. Ray could not well be chronicled…” -
British Chemist H E Armstrong while reviewing P C Ray’s autobiography, Nature, 131,
672-674 (1933) (https://doi.org/10.1038/131672a0)
Famous Geographer and also his class fellow, Hugh Robert Mill remembered him as
“the most enlightened Hindu I ever met, speaking and writing English with grace and
fluency, and singularly at home in European modes of thought.”
Frederick G. Donnan, a professor of chemistry at University College, London, was
highly impressed by Indian students who joined him and were students of P C Ray. In a letter
to Ray, he says, “[Y]ou have, by your constant devotion to teaching and research, created a
school of chemistry in India which will be of the greatest importance for the prosperity of
that land. I feel certain that you have done work in India of which any man might feel proud
in any country.”
On his 70th birth anniversary in 1932, a reception was organized by the Corporation of
Calcutta in his honour. In his presidential address, Rabindranath Tagore said, “It says in the
Upanishads that the Supreme one wanted to be many. The urge of self-disposal is at the root
of creation. It was through this kind of creative urge that Prafulla Chandra became many in
the minds of pupils by diffusing and thereby reactivating himself in many younger minds. But
this would hardly be possible unless he had the capacity to give himself fully to others.”
Mahatma Gandhi said, “Great he undoubtedly is: But goodness from Indian stand
point is greater than greatness and Acharya Ray is even more good then he is great. And it is
his goodness—his childlike simplicity, his suavity of manners, his ready accessibility, his
unblemished purity, unostentatious charity, his voluntary poverty with plain living and high
thinking, his enthusiasm and optimism, his innate spirit of self-denial, his incurable habit of
always taking a back seat, his sturdy independence, his inflexible incorruptibility…in a word,
his nobility of nature made him idol of the people. Service and sacrifice were his watch-
word…”
“It is difficult to believe that the man in simple Indian dress wearing simple manners
could possibly be the great scientist and Professor.” - Mahatma Gandhi
In 1912, Ray was honored with an honorary D. Sc. degree by the University of
Durham. He was awarded with the Companion of the Order of Indian Empire (CIE) in
1912 and a title of Knight Bachelor in 1919.
“…. Prof. P.C. Ray had added to his success in preparing ammonium nitrite in a tangible
form, a further accomplishment in determining the vapour density of this very fugitive
compound.”
Nature (London), August 15, 1912
In the year 2011, which was also the International Year of Chemistry, the Royal
Society, UK, honoured his work with the Chemical Landmark Plaque - ‘To commemorate
the life and achievements of Acharya P. C. Ray, father of Indian Chemistry, philanthropist
and entrepreneur who founded modern Chemistry teaching and research in India.’ This was
the first-ever Landmark Plaque awarded outside Europe. The plaque was installed on 31
January 2012 at his alma mater, Presidency College, Kolkata.
Postage stamp honoring Prafulla Chandra Ray on the 100th anniversary of his birth,
India Post, 1961 (Wikimedia commons)
Life-Sketch : A Chronology
1861 Born on August 2, in Raruli-Katipara village, Ditrict Jessore district (Now in
Bangaldesh) to Harischandra Roychowdhuary (father) and Bhuvanmohini Devi
(mother).
1866-1870 Studied at the village school founded by his father.
1870 The family shifted to 132, Amherst Street, Calcutta
1871 Took admission in Hare School.
1872-1873 Suffered chronic dysentery and sleeplessness and returned to native village.
1874 Returned to Calcutta and took admission to Albert School (Established by Kashab
Chandra Sen.)
1875 Again returned to his village.
1876 Came back again to Calcutta and took re-admission in Albert School.
1879 After clearing the entrance examination in 1879, Prafulla Chandra took admission
at Metropolitan Institution (now Vidyasagar College) founded by Pandit
Iswarchandra Vidyasagar.
1881 Passed First Arts (FA) examination in Second Division. Admitted to B.A. Class (B-
Course) with chemistry as the main subject.
1882 Obtained Gilchrist Scholarship to Edinburgh University, moved to England.
2. P C Ray, A History of Hindu Chemistry: From the Earliest Times to the Middle
of the 16th Century AD. Volume 1. Calcutta: Chuckervertty & Co and Kegan
Paul. (1902). (http://bit.ly/12B4dNr)
3. R., T. A History of Hindu Chemistry from the Earliest Times to the Middle of
the Sixteenth Century A.D., with Sanskrit Texts, Variants, Translation and
Illustrations . Nature, 68, 51–52 (1903). (https://doi.org/10.1038/068051a0)
5. P C Ray, Essays and Discourses. Madras: G.A. Natesan & Co. (1918)
(https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.276445)
8. William Foster, Makers of Modern Chemistry (Ray, Sir Prafulla Chandra), Journal of
Chemical Education, 3 (5), 613 (1926). (https://doi.org/10.1021/ed003p613.2)
10. Prafulla Chandra Ray, “2. On the Conjugated Sulphates of the Copper-
Magnesium Group.” Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, 15, 267–83
(1889). (DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0370164600005502)
13. Acharya Prafulla Chandra Ray Birth Centenary Volume, Calcutta University
(1962).
14. P. C. Ray, On the Chemical Examination of Certain Indian Food Staffs, Part I,
Fats & Oils. Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal, 1, 59-80 (1894).
(http://www.southasiaarchive.com/Content/sarf.120250/221679/003)
15. P. C. Ray & S. C. Jana, The vapour density of Ammonium Nitrite, Benzoate and
Acetate. Journal of Chemical Society, Transactions, 103, 1565-1568 (1913).
(https://doi.org/10.1039/CT9130301565)
16. Praphulla Chandra Ray. "Chemical Knowledge of the Hindus of Old." Isis 2,
no. 2, 322-25 (1919). (http://www.jstor.org/stable/223882).
17. P C Ray. Lengthened Chain Compounds of Sulphur with Platinum, Nature, 123,
644 (1929). (https://doi.org/10.1038/123644d0)
18. P C Ray. Lengthened Chain Compounds of Sulphur, Nature, 119, 124 (1927).
(https://doi.org/10.1038/119124a0)
19. H Armstrong, Life and Experiences of a Bengali Chemist, Nature, 131, 672–674
(1933). (https://doi.org/10.1038/131672a0)
20. Wilder D. Bancroft, Life and Experiences of a Bengali Chemist (Ray, Prafulla
Chandra), Journal of Chemical Education 11 (4), 255 (1934).
(https://doi.org/10.1021/ed011p255.2)
21. P.C.Ray, ‘The Problem of Scientific Education in India’. The Calcutta Review,
CVIII, (April 1899): 347-395
(http://www.southasiaarchive.com/Content/sarf.120137/211188/010)