An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024

The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

AN CHÚIRT UACHTARACH
SUPREME COURT

AN CHÚIRT UACHTARACH
[THE SUPREME COURT]

For Friday 22nd March 2024

With effect from 1st February 2023 attendance at the Supreme Court Office is by appointment and you can
make an appointment online via https://www.courts.ie/appointments. For urgent matters, where it is not
possible to book an appointment online, please email [email protected] or phone the office on +353 1
888 6395 or +353 1 888 6394.

Please note that the public opening Hours for the Supreme Court Office are from Monday to Friday: 10.00am -
4.30pm. Filings in either hard copy or electronically should be made within the public office opening hours.
Electronic filings received after 4.30pm are deemed filed on the following day. All relevant filings made on a
Friday should be made by 1.00pm to facilitate circulation of papers to members of the Court by Friday evening.

Ms. Justice O’Malley

Mr. Justice Murray
Ms. Justice Donnelly
At 10.00 o’clock
Panel meeting for consideration of applications received seeking leave to appeal under Article 34.5.3º and
Article 34.5.4º of the Constitution (In Chambers).
1. 159/23 The Director of Public Prosecutions v O'Flaherty
2. 155/2023 Redrock Developments Limited (In Voluntary Liquidation) & Belcarrig Quarries Limited v
An Bord Pleanála
3. 160/2023 The People at the suit of the Director of Public Prosecutions v M S
4. 13/2024 S O'C v The Director of Public Prosecutions
5. 82/2023 Official Assignee in Bankruptcy v Kenneth Joyce
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

AN CHÚIRT ACHOMHAIRC
THE COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL
NOTICES – (updated 20th December 2023)

The Court of Appeal Office in Áras Ui Dhalaigh is conducting business by appointment only

An appointment may be arranged via email to [email protected]. Documents will also be accepted
by post or via DX (No. 262001).

APPEALS FOR HEARING

All Appeals are heard by way of a physical hearing unless otherwise directed by the Court.

A revised version of Practice Direction CA06 came into effect on June 1st 2022 a copy of which is available on
the Courts website www.courts.ie.

LODGING OF BOOKS OF APPEAL

Parties are required to lodge complete books of appeal (in hard and soft copy) not later than 4 weeks prior to
the date of the appeal in accordance with Practice Direction CA06 or such other date as shall be fixed by the
Court. This must include the transcript of the DAR or approved note of the judgment of the High Court
where appropriate and a joint book of authorities. A party who has been authorised to file the books of
appeal may file the books in accordance with this direction notwithstanding the failure of another party to the
appeal to furnish its written submissions to such party for inclusion in the books of appeal.

In the event that the books are not lodged within the time fixed, the appeal shall be relisted in the next
directions list in the Court of Appeal for mention. If the books are not lodged by the latter date, the Court may
make an order extending the time for the late filing of the books of appeal for such short period as it deems
appropriate subject to an order that the appeal shall stand struck out for failure to comply with the directions of
the court. In the event of a failure to comply with such order the appeal shall be struck out. Where an appeal is
listed in the directions list by reason of the foregoing, the party in default may be liable for the costs arising
from attendance at the directions list.

Parties should lodge the books of appeal (including the books of authorities) in hardcopy (x 4) and also in soft
copy via the ShareFile platform.

A revised version of Practice Direction CA06 came into effect on June 1st 2022, a copy of which is available on
the Courts website, www.courts.ie.

DIRECTIONS LIST AND MOTION LISTS

From 12 January, 2024 the weekly directions and motions lists before Ms. Justice Costello will no longer be
conducted routinely by way of hybrid hearing in Court of Appeal Court 1, Old Public Records Building, The
Four Courts. This means that all parties must attend in person, save where the court directs otherwise.

In accordance with provisions of Order 86A Rule 16(1) the directions book is to be lodged in the office by close
of business on the preceding Friday. In accordance with the provisions of Order 86 Rule 12(5) (dealing with
interlocutory applications) the motion book is to be lodged in the office by close of business on the preceding
Tuesday.

FRIDAY CALLOVER OF APPEALS LISTED FOR HEARING

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
From 12 January, 2024 the weekly advance Callover of appeals listed for hearing are conducted in person
before Ms. Justice Costello unless otherwise directed by the court. The Callover lists for each respective Friday
list are published in advance in the Legal Diary. The Legal Diary list is updated on a daily basis. It is the
responsibility of the parties in listed appeals to check the Legal Diary for the date of the relevant Callover
(usually scheduled for six weeks in advance of the appeal hearing date).

Parties will be aware that the purpose of the Callover is to confirm that the submissions and books of appeals
(including books of authorities) have been lodged, and that there has been compliance with any other directions
previously given by the Court. It is vital therefore that there be an attendance at the Callover by all parties to an
appeal.

VIRTUAL MEETING ROOM (VMR) DETAILS FOR FRIDAY LISTS - IMPORTANT

Parties are asked to note that the Virtual Meeting Room (VMR) details for the Callover / Directions / Motion
list on each Friday will no longer be furnished unless directed by the court. If any party is unable to attend in
person, they may apply to the Office of the Court of Appeal for leave to appear remotely for a decision by the
judge in charge of the list, which application should be supported by a medical report which details the medical
reasons why the party concerned is unable to attend in person. Without prejudice to the foregoing, the court
may in any case for good and sufficient reason permit a party to appear remotely.

COURT OF APPEAL ORDERS

Due to the recent upgrade to the High Court case management system, it is not currently possible to view when
Court of Appeal Orders are perfected on High Court Search.
Please email [email protected] for updates on the perfection of Orders.

DELIVERY OF ELECTRONIC JUDGMENTS

Written judgments of courts may be delivered by means of a copy of the judgment being sent electronically to
the parties and a copy, subject to such redactions as would ordinarily apply, being posted as soon as possible on
the Courts Service website. The date and time of delivery to the parties will be notified in the Legal Diary.

The parties may be invited to communicate electronically with the Court on issues arising (if any) out of the
judgment such as the precise form of order which requires to be made or questions concerning costs or they
may be requested to attend physically to address the Court on these issues. If there are such issues and the
parties do not agree in this regard concise written submissions should be filed electronically with the Office of
the Court, [email protected], within 14 days of delivery subject to any other direction
given in the judgment.

CIVIL APPEALS FOR HEARING IN THE CRIMINAL COURTS OF JUSTICE

Civil appeals with a custody element i.e. Article 40 habeas corpus, extradition, bail and judicial review arising
out of criminal proceedings are now dealt with by the criminal office which is situated on the 4th Floor of the
Criminal Courts of Justice Building, Parkgate Street, Dublin 8. The civil office will continue to issue the Notice
of Appeal and identify whether the appeal comes within the category of appeal to be heard in the Criminal
Courts of Justice and allocate the next available case-management list in the Criminal Courts of Justice for a
directions hearing. The file will then be transferred to the criminal office and all subsequent documents in the
appeal process are to be lodged in the criminal office which will have responsibility for the management and
listing of the appeal. Any enquiries in relation to such appeals should be made to the criminal office by email
to [email protected] or by telephone on (01) 7988004.

Friday the 22nd March 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Mr Justice Haughton
At 10 o’clock
Callover List
1. 2023 328 The Revenue Commissioners -v- Maloney
2. 2024 1 M and J Duddy Developments Limited -v- Everyday Finance DAC & ors
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
3. 2024 2 Reidy -v- Swiss Krono Tex GmbH
4. 2023 314 Gibson -v- Kevin O’Gorman p/a Kevin O ‘Gorman & Company Solicitors
5. 2023 315 Gibson -v- Kevin O’Gorman p/a Kevin O ‘Gorman & Company Solicitors
6. 2023 316 Xerico Ltd -v- The Residential Tenancies Board (Case Stated)
7. 2014 437 Clohessy -v- Legal Aid Board & ors
8. 2014 1211 Clohessy -v- Legal Aid Board & ors
9. 2019 467 Clohessy -v- Legal Aid Board & ors
10. 2023 156, 154 and 155 Murphy -v- Law Society of Ireland & anor (adduce further evidence (2))
11. 2023 156, 154 and 155 Murphy -v- Law Society of Ireland & anor (Discovery - Law Society)
12. 2023 156, 154 and 155 Murphy -v- Law Society of Ireland & anor (Discovery – Non Party)
13. 2023 156, 154 and 155 Murphy -v- Law Society of Ireland & anor (Discovery – Non Party)
14. 2024 34 Norton (Waterford) Limited Trading as TEVA Pharmaceuticals Ireland -v- Bristol-Myers Squibb
Holdings Ireland Unlimited Company

Appeals for mention

2019 238 Grant & Anor -v- The County Registrar for the County of Laois
2023 235 O’Brien -v- BDO Simpson Xavier & anor
2023 289 In the matter of KK
2023 144 Coomey (Legal Personal Representative of John Richard Cox, deceased) -v- Cox
2024 48 B -v- B

Appeal for Directions (Commercial appeal)

2024 74 Nolan & ors -v- Dildar Limited & ors

At 10.30 o’clock
Directions List
1. 2024 22 Start Mortgages DAC -v- Smith & Anor
2. 2024 33 Start Mortgages Designated Activity Company -v- Simpson & Anor
3. 2024 36 Howley -v- Lohan
4. 2024 39 O'Brien & ors -v- The Chief Legal Costs Adjudicator
5. 2024 40 Everyday Finance DAC -v- Darcy & ors
6. 2024 41 In the matter of GTLK Europe DAC
7. 2024 42 Lundin -v- Kuhn & anor
8. 2024 43 Hall -v- Gorey Service Station Limited
9. 2024 47 Baynham -v- The Commissioner of an Garda Siochana & ors
10. 2024 50 M -v- The International Protection Appeals Tribunal & anor
11. 2024 11 G -v- The International Protection Appeals Tribunal & ors
12. 2024 20 Malone -v- Governor of Cloverhill Prison
13. 2024 32 Muldowney -v- The Governor of Mountjoy Prison & ors

At 11 o’clock
Motion List
14. 2017 549 Clohessy & Ors -v- Long
15. 2014 437 Clohessy -v- Legal Aid Board & ors
16. 2014 1211 Clohessy -v- Legal Aid Board & ors
17. 2019 467 Clohessy -v- The Legal Aid Board & Ors
18. 2024 64 Ulster Bank Ireland DAC -v- Greene
19. 2024 58 D -v- G
20. 2017 549 Clohessy & ors -v- Brian Long Trading under the Style and Title of Brian Long Solicitors

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

Ms Justice Costello
Ms Justice Pilkington
Ms Justice Butler
At 10.30 o’clock
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
For Hearing
2023 287 Byrne -v- Mars Capital Ireland DAC
2023 291 Byrne -v- Mars Capital Ireland DAC & ors
2023 296 Byrne -v- Mars Capital Ireland DAC (1 day)

For Electronic Delivery

Mr Barniville P
Mr Justice Haughton
Ms Justice Pilkington
At 11.00 o’clock
For Judgment (via electronic delivery)
2022 26 Foot Locker Retail Ireland Limited -v- Percy Nominees Limited
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

AN CHÚIRT ACHOMHAIRC
THE COURT OF APPEAL

CRIMINAL

AN CHUIRT ACHOMHAIRC (CHOIRIÚIL)

THE COURT OF APPEAL (CRIMINAL)

NOTICES – updated 3rd January 2023

The Court of Appeal Office Criminal in The Criminal Courts of Justice building is conducting business by
appointment only.
An appointment may be arranged via email to [email protected]. Documents will be accepted by
hand arrangement – please phone the court of appeal office at (01) 7988004 when you are in the CCJ building
outside Court 16, by post or via DX (No. 262001).

APPEALS FOR HEARING

All Appeals are being conducted by way of a physical hearing unless otherwise directed by the Court.

LODGING OF DOCUMENTS FOR CRIMINAL APPEAL HEARINGS

Parties are required to lodge all document pertaining to criminal appeal hearing not later than 2 weeks prior to
the hearing date.

LODGING OF BOOKS OF APPEAL (CIVIL APPEALS ONLY)

Parties are required to lodge complete books of appeal (in hard and soft copy) not later than 4 weeks prior to
the date of the appeal in accordance with Practice Direction CA06 or such other date as shall be fixed by the
Court. This must include the transcript of the DAR or approved note of the judgment of the High Court
where appropriate and a joint book of authorities. A party who has been authorised to file the books of
appeal may file the books in accordance with this direction notwithstanding the failure of another party to the
appeal to furnish its written submissions to such party for inclusion in the books of appeal.

In the event that the books are not lodged within the time fixed, the appeal shall be relisted in the next
directions list in the Court of Appeal for mention. If the books are not lodged by the latter date, the Court may
make an order extending the time for the late filing of the books of appeal for such short period as it deems
appropriate subject to an order that the appeal shall stand struck out for failure to comply with the directions of
the court. In the event of a failure to comply with such order the appeal shall be struck out. Where an appeal is
listed in the directions list by reason of the foregoing, the party in default may be liable for the costs arising
from attendance at the directions list.

Parties should lodge the books of appeal (including the books of authorities) in hardcopy (x 3) and also in soft
copy via the ShareFile platform.

A revised version of Practice Direction CA06 came into effect on the 1st day of June 2022, a copy of which is
available on the Courts website, www.courts.ie.

CASE MANANGEMENT LIST

The weekly Case Management List before The President will be conducted by way of hybrid hearing in Court
of Appeal Criminal (CCJ-Court 16).
This means that The President/Judge and the Registrar will be sitting in the Courtroom physically and that
Parties can either attend physically or attend remotely by means of the VMR platform.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

While it is intended to have a list every Friday in term practitioners are advised to check the Legal Diary on an
ongoing basis to confirm that there is a list scheduled on a Friday where a matter is required to be listed for
case-management. The court office will also be able to confirm the dates of such lists.

In relation to civil appeals listed in case management and accordance with provisions of Order 86A Rule 16(1)
the directions book is to be lodged in the office by close of business on the preceding Friday.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
VIRTUAL MEETING ROOM (VMR) DETAILS FOR FRIDAY LISTS - IMPORTANT
Parties are asked to note that the Virtual Meeting Room (VMR) details for the Case Management List on each
Friday will be furnished to them directly by e-mail from the Court of Appeal Office on the Tuesday preceding
the Friday listed. Parties are advised, in this regard, to ensure that e-mail contact details furnished to that Office
remain valid /are fully up to date. Any party may attend the Court physically.

DELIVERY OF JUDGMENTS
Judgments are delivered physically in the Courtroom and parties will be notified prior to the date.

Written judgments of courts may be delivered electronically if directed by the Court and in such cases will be
delivered by means of a copy of the judgment being sent electronically to the parties and a copy, subject to such
redactions as would ordinarily apply, being posted as soon as possible on the Courts Service website. The date
and time of delivery will be notified to parties. The parties may be invited to communicate electronically with
the Court on issues arising (if any) out of the judgment such as the precise form of order which requires to be
made or questions concerning costs or they may be requested to attend physically to address the Court on these
issues. If there are such issues and the parties do not agree in this regard concise written submissions should be
filed electronically with the Office of the Court of Appeal by emailing [email protected] within
14 days of delivery subject to any other direction given in the judgment.

CIVIL APPEALS FOR HEARING IN THE CRIMINAL COURTS OF JUSTICE

Civil appeals with a custody element i.e. Article 40 habeas corpus, extradition, bail and judicial review arising
out of criminal proceedings are now dealt with by the criminal office which is situated on the 4th Floor of the
Criminal Courts of Justice Building, Parkgate Street, Dublin 8. The civil office will continue to issue the Notice
of Appeal and identify whether the appeal comes within the category of appeal to be heard in the Criminal
Courts of Justice and allocate the next available case-management list in the Criminal Courts of Justice for a
directions hearing. The file will then be transferred to the criminal office and all subsequent documents in the
appeal process are to be lodged in the criminal office which will have responsibility for the management and
listing of the appeal. Any enquiries in relation to such appeals should be made to the criminal office by email
to [email protected] or by telephone on (01) 7988004.

Sentence appeals and undue leniency applications

See Practice Direction (CA02) for requirements as to materials (reports, testimonials etc) for the use of the
court in sentence appeals and undue leniency applications. Practitioners are urged to ensure that any such
materials are furnished to the court office at least two weeks in advance of the remote hearing date to facilitate
the transmission of the materials to the Court. Practitioners are also reminded that there is no necessity to apply
to Court for the preparation of a Governor’s Report or an Educational Report so that such Reports are available
in the event of the Court finding an error in principle in the sentence imposed by the court of trial. On receipt of
an email to the court office (in good time in advance of the hearing date) specifying the nature of the Report
required, the date of the appeal hearing and the prison where the appellant or respondent (as the case may be) is
incarcerated the office will request the required Report from the relevant prison.

Chief Prosecution Solicitor – service of documents and notification of any intended application
Practitioners are reminded of the requirement to serve on the Chief Prosecution Solicitor for the Director of
Public Prosecutions written submissions lodged in or transmitted via email to the court office. Except for the
documents referred to in Order 86C Rule 7 (1) (a notice of appeal or a notice of application pursuant to section
2 of the Criminal Procedure Act 1993) and in Order 86C Rule 15(1) (a notice of abandonment) notice of which
the Registrar is required to give to various parties including the Chief Prosecution Solicitor all other documents
lodged in or transmitted via email to the court office must be served on the Chief Prosecution Solicitor. Notice
of any intended application to the Court must be given to the Chief Prosecution Solicitor as well as to the court
office.

Friday 22nd March 2024

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10.00 o’clock (Remote hearing)
Case Management List
For Mention
1. 288CPA/23 DPP -v- Eve Doherty (KRW Law)
2. 246/21 DPP -v- Alan Harte (John M. Quinn Solicitor)
3. 247/21 DPP -v- Alan O’Brien (John M. Quinn Solicitor)
4. 5/22 DPP -v- Darren Redmond (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
5. 52/21 DPP -v- M.O. (In Person)
6. 233/23 DPP -v- Noel Long (Edmund Burke Solicitors)
7. 204/21 DPP -v- William Twomey (Mulholland Law)
8. 285/23 DPP -v- D.B. (Barry Fitzgerald Solicitor)
9. 199/22 DPP -v- T.R. (Michael Staines Solicitors)
10. 200/22 DPP -v- D.G. (Phelim O’Neill Solicitors)
11. 160/23 DPP -v- Paul Murphy (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)

Motion
12. 14/22 DPP -v- L C (KRW Law)
13. 49/24 DPP -v- Richard Walsh (David Burke & Co Solicitors)

Enlargement of Time Applications

14. 27/24 DPP -v- S.G. (Hughes Walsh Solicitors)
15. 39/24 DPP -v- Keith Brady (McGovern and Walsh Solicitors)

Civil Appeal
16. 2023 325 Jansone -v- DPP
17. 2023 322 Rogers -v- Cowen & Ors
18. 2024 46 DPP -v- The Special Criminal Court & Anor
19. 2024 67 Flynn & Anor -V- The Commissioner of an Garda Siochana & Anor (plus motion)

For Mention
20. 270/23 Edmond (Eamon) O'Neill & Ors (O'Gorman Solicitors, Hughes Murphy & Co. Solicitors, Carey
Murphy & Partners Solicitors, Sarah Ryan Solicitor)

The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Ní Raifeartaigh
At 10.30 o’clock
For Judgment
55/21 DPP -v- J.B. (Cyril and Co Solicitors)

Ms Justice Kennedy
Ms Justice Ní Raifeartaigh
Ms Justice Burns
At 10.30 o’clock
For Mention
1/22 DPP -V- John O’Donoghue (Michael B O’Donnell Solicitors)

The President
Ms Justice Kennedy
Ms Justice Burns
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
Undue Leniency Application
141CJA/23 DPP -v- John Lindsay (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)

Sentence Appeals
195/22 DPP -v- Mark Doyle (John Feaheny Solicitors)
245/22 DPP -v- J.L. (Kirwan & Kirwan Solicitors)

Civil Appeal
2023 158 McGuinness -v- A Judge of The Circuit Court & ors
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

AN PHRÍOMH-CHÚIRT CHOIRIÚIL
CENTRAL CRIMINAL COURT

Friday the 22nd day of March, 2024

Sitting at The Criminal Courts of Justice, Parkgate Street, Dublin 8.

Before The Hon. Mr. Justice Paul McDermott in Court 6 CCJ at 10:30 (Trial Continuing)
1 CCDP0175/2021 DPP v D M A:
Before The Hon. Mr. Justice Paul McDermott in Court 6 CCJ at 10:30 (Sentence)
2 CCDP0144/2021 DPP v Gearoid Coughlan:
Before The Hon. Mr. Justice Paul McDermott in Court 6 CCJ at 10:30 (For Hearing)
3 CCDP0049/2023 DPP v M C:
Before The Hon. Mr. Justice Tony Hunt in Court 9 CCJ at 11:15 (For Mention)
4 CCDP0155/2020 DPP v C O G:
5 CCDP0079/2021 DPP v M F:
6 CCDP0142/2021 DPP v J D S:
7 CCDP0194/2021 DPP v J P O:
8 CCDP0064/2022 DPP v C C:
9 CCDP0116/2022 DPP v K D:
10 CCDP0135/2022 DPP v R C:
11 CCDP0177/2022 DPP v P K:
12 CCDP0177/2022 DPP v J B:
13 CCDP0182/2022 DPP v P K:
14 CCDP0185/2022 DPP v G M:
15 CCDP0190/2022 DPP v Daniel Blanaru:
16 CCDP0201/2022 DPP v S G:
17 CCDP0042/2023 DPP v Robert Redmond:
18 CCDP0042/2023 DPP v Rachel Redmond:
19 CCDP0074/2023 DPP v Sean Egan:
20 CCDP0095/2023 DPP v D C:
21 CCDP0101/2023 DPP v O A:
22 CCDP0106/2023 DPP v W C:
23 CCDP0110/2023 DPP v George Turner:
24 CCDP0116/2023 DPP v W H:
25 CCDP0117/2023 DPP v Ruth Lawrence:
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
26 CCDP0124/2023 DPP v A L:
27 CCDP0126/2023 DPP v E M G:
28 CCDP0130/2023 DPP v Ann Phelan:
29 CCDP0134/2023 DPP v K T:
30 CCDP0141/2023 DPP v M Y:
31 CCDP0163/2023 DPP v D P:
32 CCDP0171/2023 DPP v P M:
33 CCDP0180/2023 DPP v C K:
34 CCDP0007/2024 DPP v M H:
35 CCDP0017/2024 DPP v E R:
36 CCDP0029/2024 DPP v H K:
Before The Hon. Mr. Justice Tony Hunt in Court 9 CCJ at 11:15 (Arraignment)
37 CCDP0071/2023 DPP v M M M:
Before The Hon. Mr. Justice Tony Hunt in Court 9 CCJ at 11:15 (For Mention by Video Link)
38 CCDP0087/2023 DPP v Philip Cox:
Before The Hon. Ms. Justice Melanie Greally in Court 13 CCJ at 11:00 (Sentence)
39 CCDP0054/2023 DPP v Michael McDonagh:
Before The Hon. Mr. Justice Michael MacGrath in Court 13 CCJ at 14:00 (For Mention)
40 CCDP0061/2022 DPP v Diego Costa Silva:
Before The Hon. Mr. Justice Kerida Naidoo in Court 14 CCJ at 10:30 (Trial Continuing)
41 CCDP0082/2022 DPP v W A:
Before The Hon. Ms. Justice Eileen Creedon in Court 17 CCJ at 11:00 (Trial Continuing)
42 CCDP0162/2021 DPP v H A:

Sitting at Waterford Courthouse, Catherine Street, Waterford

Before The Hon. Ms. Justice Siobhan Lankford in Waterford at 10:30 (Sentence Hearing)
CCDP0177/2021 DPP v C M:
Before The Hon. Ms. Justice Siobhan Lankford in Waterford at 11:00 (Trial Continuing)
CCDP0059/2022 DPP v J S:
Before The Hon. Ms. Justice Siobhan Lankford in Waterford at 13:00 (For Mention)
CCDP0031/2023 DPP v Dean Caffrey:

Sitting at Mullingar Courthouse, Co Westmeath

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
Before The Hon. Ms. Justice Mary Ellen Ring in Mullingar at 10:30 (Trial Continuing)
CCDP0036/2023 DPP v R W:
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

CÁSANNA AN LAE INNIU SAN ÁRD CHÚIRT

TODAYS CASES IN THE HIGH COURT

IN COURT 1
MR JUSTICE COFFEY
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
PERSONAL INJURIES LIST (HYBRID)

IN COURT 2
MR JUSTICE MCDONALD
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION
AT 10.45 O’CLOCK
CALLOVER OF CASES LISTED FOR HEARING FOR THE FOLLOWING WEEK (REMOTE)
AFTER THE CALLOVER
FOR MENTION
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FOR HEARING
AT 11.30 O’CLOCK
FOR HEARING

IN COURT 3
MR JUSTICE SANFEY
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
CHANCERY LIST 1
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION

IN COURT 4
MR JUSTICE HESLIN
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
WARDS OF COURT (HYBRID)

IN COURT 5
MR JUSTICE SIMONS
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
FOR MENTION
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION
FOR HEARING

IN COURT 5
THE PRESIDENT
AT 12.45 O’CLOCK
INHERENT JURISDICTION
AT 14.00 O’CLOCK
INHERENT JURISDICTION
AT 14.30 O’CLOCK
INHERENT JURISDICTION
AT 14.30 O’CLOCK
WARDSHIP MATTERS (HYBRID)

IN COURT 6
MS JUSTICE HYLAND
AT 10.45 O’CLOCK
ASYLUM MANDAMUS LIST (REMOTE)
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION
FOR HEARING

IN COURT 7
MR JUSTICE JORDAN
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
FAMILY LAW LIST (PHYSICAL)

IN COURT 10
MR JUSTICE MULCAHY
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION

IN COURT 11
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
MS JUSTICE BRETT
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION
PERSONAL INJURIES

IN COURT 12
MR JUSTICE HOLLAND
AT 10.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION (REMOTE)

IN COURT 12
MS JUSTICE FARRELL
AT 10.15 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION

IN COURT 12
MR JUSTICE BARRETT
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION

IN COURT 14
MR JUSTICE BRADLEY
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION

IN COURT 14
MS JUSTICE EGAN
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION
PERSONAL INJURIES

IN COURT 15
MR JUSTICE O’DONNELL
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION

IN COURT 15
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
MS JUSTICE REYNOLDS
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
PERSONAL INJURIES

IN COURT 16
MS JUSTICE JACKSON
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
AT HEARING
FAMILY LAW

IN COURT 18
MR JUSTICE KENNEDY
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
CHANCERY

IN COURT 19
MR JUSTICE CREGAN
AT 10.45 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION
AT 14.00 O’CLOCK
FOR RESERVED JUDGMENT (PHYSICAL)
AT 14.00 O’CLOCK
FOR JUDGMENT (PHYSICAL)
CHANCERY

IN COURT 24
MR JUSTICE BURNS
AT 10.00 O’CLOCK
BAIL MATTER

IN COURT 24
MR JUSTICE MACGRATH
AT 10.15 O’CLOCK
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
AT HEARING
AT 12.45 O’CLOCK
BAIL MATTER

IN COURT 25
MS JUSTICE PHELAN
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION

IN COURT 25
MR JUSTICE OWENS
AT 11.30 O’CLOCK
CAB MATTER

IN COURT 26
MS JUSTICE STACK
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
CHANCERY

IN COURT 29
MR JUSTICE DIGNAM
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
CHANCERY

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL 2

MR JUSTICE NOLAN
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION
CHANCERY

IN COURT TBC
MS JUSTICE STEWART
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
PERSONAL INJURIES
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
IN COURT TBC
MR JUSTICE O’HIGGINS
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
PERSONAL INJURIES

IN THE CRIMINAL COURTS OF JUSTICE

MR JUSTICE P MCGRATH
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
EXTRADITION LIST

IN THE CRIMINAL COURTS OF JUSTICE

MR JUSTICE HUNT
AT 10.00 O’CLOCK
BAIL MATTER

JUDGMENTS TO BE DELIVERED ELECTRONICALLY

MR JUSTICE GEARTY
MS JUSTICE PHELAN
MR JUSTICE BRADLEY
MR JUSTICE DIGNAM
MR JUSTICE SIMONS
MR JUSTICE KENNEDY

IN COURT 2
MR JUSTICE MC DONALD
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
2019 4140 P BIOMASS HEATING SOLUTIONS LTD -V- GEURTS INTERNATIONAL B V

IN COURT 3
MR JUSTICE SANFEY
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
2021 3588 P DROMADA WINDFARM [ROI] LTD -V- CREMINS

IN COURT 5
MR JUSTICE SIMONS
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
2012 1212 S PEPPER FINANCE COPORATION IRELAND DAC -V- RAINEY
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
H.MCA.2024.0000148 MHI Modern Homes Ireland Ltd v BALLYMAR DEVELOPMENTS LTD
2022 18 P- POP -V- FORESTAL & ANOR

IN COURT 5
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
THE PRESIDENT
AT 12.45 O’CLOCK
2023 299 MCA ST VINCENTS HEALTHCARE GROUP DAC T/A ST VINCENTS -V- F [APUM]
[INDENTITY PROTECTED]
AT 14.00 O’CLOCK
H.MCA.2023.0000432 MEDICAL COUNCIL v M
AT 14.30 O’CLOCK
H.MCA.2024.0000074 HSE v R[APUM]

IN COURT 6
MS JUSTICE HYLAND
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
2023 109 JR K v MJ
2023 1057 JR-N v THE INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION APPEALS TRIBUNAL

IN COURT 10
MR JUSTICE MULCAHY
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
2023 2831 P DUDDY HOSPITALITY IRELAND HOLDINGS LIMITED & ORS -V- PROPITEER
IRELAND HOLDINGS LIMITED & ORS
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
2011 3709 P COUGHLAN & ANOR -V- STOKES & ORS

IN COURT 11
MS JUSTICE D BRETT
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
2017 10397 P GRAY -V- DALATA LIMITED

IN COURT 12
MR JUSTICE HOLLAND
AT 10.00 O’CLOCK
2021 831 JR SWEETMAN & ORS -V- AQUACULTURE LICENSE APPEALS BOARD & ORS
2021 828 JR INLAND FISHERIES IRELAND -V- AQUACULTURE LICENCES APPEALS BOARD &
ANOR
2021 823 JR SALMON WATCH IRELAND CLG -V- AQUACULTURE LICENCES APPEALS BOARD &
ORS

IN COURT 12
MS JUSTICE FARRELL
AT 10.15 O’CLOCK
2022 67 JR BALBRIGGAN COMMUNITY COUNCIL -V- AN BORD PLEANALA

IN COURT 12
MR JUSTICE BARRETT
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
H.MCA.2024.0000139 COMPETITION AND CONSUMER PROTECTION COMMISSION v
PHONEWATCH LTD
H.MCA.2024.0000140 COMPETITION AND CONSUMER PROTECTION COMMISSION v
HOMESECURE LTD
2018 182 COS GORTLEE TOOL HIRE LIMITED v COMPANIES ACT 2014
2021 86 M D v U
2018 35 M B v B

IN COURT 14
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
MR JUSTICE C BRADLEY
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
2023 11 CA PROMONTORIA SCARIFF DAC -V- MC DONAGH

IN COURT 14
MS JUSTICE EGAN
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
2001 9223 P PERSONA DIGITAL TELEPHONY LTD & ANOR -V- MINISTER FOR PUBLIC
ENTERPRISE & ORS

IN COURT 15
MR JUSTICE O DONNELL
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
2023 41 CAF OM v G
H.MCA.2024.0000104 MERCY UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL CORK CLG v TWOMEY

IN COURT 16
MS JUSTICE N JACKSON
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
2014 37 M F v F

IN COURT 19
MR JUSTICE CREGAN
AT 10.45 O’CLOCK
2019 1963 P MALCOMSON LAW SERVICES LTD & ANOR -V- SMITHFIELD GATE MANAGEMENT
COMPANY LTD
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
2023 921 P MARS CAPITAL FINANCE IRELAND DAC -V- BRENNAN & ANOR
AT 14.00 O’CLOCK
2023 46 COS G V COMPANIES ACT 2014
2023 1818 P GAULTIER & ANOR V REILLY AND ORS

IN COURT 24
MR JUSTICE MAC GRATH
AT 12.45 O’CLOCK
H. SS.2024.0000350 DPP v H

IN COURT 25
MS JUSTICE PHELAN
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
2012 1866 S PEMBROKE EQUITY PARTNERS LTD -V- CORRIGAN & ANOR
2006 1814 P CITY PHARMACY LIMITED & ORS -V- ROCHE & ORS

IN COURT 25
MR JUSTICE OWENS
AT 11.30 O’CLOCK
2023 8 CAB CAB -V- FAN & ANOR

IN COURT 26
MS JUSTICE STACK
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
2019 6198 P EGAR -V- COOPERATIEVE RABOBANK U A & ORS

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL 2

MR JUSTICE D NOLAN
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
H.P.2024.0001410 PLATINUM PENSIONEER TRUSTEES LTD & ANOR v GILDEA & ORS
2023 120 MCA FINGAL COUNTY COUNCIL -V- CLOUGHWATER PLASTICS IRELAND LTD [T/A
VAN WERVEN & ORS

IN THE CRIMINAL COURTS OF JUSTICE

MR JUSTICE P MCGRATH
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
APPLICATION TO ENDORSE RELEVANT ARREST WARRANT
1. 2022 153 EXT MJ -V- AAS

ARABIC
2. 2023 140 EXT MJ -V- ZAKARIA MIMOUNE

ENGLISH
3. 2020 388 EXT MJ -V- PATRICK JOSEPH WARD
4. 2020 389 EXT MJ -V- PATRICK JOSEPH WARD

POLISH
5. 2023 235 EXT MJ -V- BARTLOMIEJ SMOLINSKI
6. 2023 169 EXT MJ -V- MARIUSZ ZAJAC
7. 2023 236 EXT MJ -V- KRZYSZTOF KARKOSA
8. 2023 78 EXT MJ -V- MICHAL JACEK KALINOWSKI

CZECH
9. 2023 197 EXT MJ -V- MILAN BUDIK

LITHUANIAN
10. 2023 211 EXT MJ -V- PRANAS GARBENIS
11. 2024 21 EXT MJ -V- PRANAS GARBENIS

ROMANIAN
12. 2024 9 EXT MJ -V- BOGDAN IONUT MARCU

HUNGARIAN
13. 2023 241 EXT MJ -V- TIBOR CSEPKE

PORTUGUESE
14. 2023 212 EXT MJ -V- FRANCLIM JOSE SOARES VITOR

IN THE CRIMINAL COURTS OF JUSTICE

MR JUSTICE HUNT
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
H.SS.2023.0001898 DPP v D

ELECTRONIC JUDGMENTS
MS JUSTICE GEARTY
2023 204 JR TIERNEY -V- GARDA SIOCHANA OMBUDSMAN COMMISSION

MS JUSTICE PHELAN
2023 19 JR L V MINISTER FOR JUSTICE AND EQUALITY
2023 640 JR E V THE INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION APPEALS TRIBUNAL
2023 104 JR M V MJ
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

MR JUSTICE BRADLEY
2020 478 JR KONISBERRY -V- AN BORD PLEANALA

MR JUSTICE DIGNAM
2023 3330 P BURKE -V- O LONGAIN & ORS

MR JUSTICE SIMONS
2021 1110 P GANLEY & ANOR -V- CABLE NEWS NETWORK INC & ORS

MR JUSTICE KENNEDY
MICHAEL GRIMES A BANKRUPT: APPLICANT
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

COIMIRCITHE CÚIRTE
WARDS OF COURT
COIMIRCITHE CÚIRTE
WARDS OF COURT
(i) Unless otherwise ordered, all wardship applications will proceed as hybrid hearings. Parties, witnesses and
other interested persons may either attend the physical courtroom or join the proceedings remotely.

(ii) Where any substantive issue needs to be determined in the course of wardship proceedings, the mode of
trial will be as determined by the trial judge.

(iii) Practitioners’ when connected to the Virtual Courtroom should remain at their logon device at all times. In
the event that the Court directs that a matter be heard in camera, practitioners’ are requested to disconnect from
the Virtual courtroom with immediate effect.

(iv) The virtual courtroom numbers and relevant instructions are available to members through the Law Society
of Ireland and the Bar of Ireland websites:

LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND - REMOTE HEARING LINK - https://www.lawsociety.ie/remotehearings

BAR OF IRELAND MEMBERS AREA -REMOTE HEARING LINK -

https://members.lawlibrary.ie/members-area/covid/it-help/

Hybrid Hearings
Court 4
Before Mr Justice Heslin
Friday 22nd March 2024

EPA: Linda Long (nee Crowe) Hanlon & Company Solicitors & Law Centre FM
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

COIMIRCITHE CÚIRTE
WARDS OF COURT
(i) Unless otherwise ordered, all wardship applications will proceed as hybrid hearings. Parties, witnesses and
other interested persons may either attend the physical courtroom or join the proceedings remotely.

(ii) Where any substantive issue needs to be determined in the course of wardship proceedings, the mode of
trial will be as determined by the trial judge.

(iii) Practitioners’ when connected to the Virtual Courtroom should remain at their logon device at all times. In
the event that the Court directs that a matter be heard in camera, practitioners’ are requested to disconnect from
the Virtual courtroom with immediate effect.

(iv) The virtual courtroom numbers and relevant instructions are available to members through the Law Society
of Ireland and the Bar of Ireland websites:

LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND - REMOTE HEARING LINK - https://www.lawsociety.ie/remotehearings

BAR OF IRELAND MEMBERS AREA -REMOTE HEARING LINK -

https://members.lawlibrary.ie/members-area/covid/it-help/

Hybrid Hearings
Court 5
Before The President
Friday 22nd March 2024

At 2.30 pm
1.In Re a Ward: Comyn Kelleher Tobin; General Solicitor (AB)
At 2.55 pm
2.In Re a Ward: JD Scanlon & Co.; General Solicitor (Oliver Balla)
At 3.20 pm
3.In Re a Ward: Comyn Kelleher Tobin Solicitors; General Solicitor (Mary Delee)
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

DÍOBHAL PHEARSANTA: BAILE ÁTHA CLIATH

PERSONAL INJURIES: DUBLIN

DUBLIN PERSONAL INJURIES LIST

The following arrangements will apply to all cases listed in the Dublin Personal Injures List until further
Notice

The default position will be that, save where otherwise ordered, all cases will be afforded a physical hearing
However, personal injuries actions may be heard fully remotely where the parties agree or by direction of the
Court.
THE DAILY CALL OVER OF THE DUBLIN PERSONAL INJURY LIST CALL OVER WILL TAKE
PLACE EACH MORNING AT 10.30AM BY WAY OF A PHYSICAL AND REMOTE FORMATS

Twenty cases will be listed each day -Tuesday to Friday (to include 2 Specially Fixed cases)
Cases not assigned to a Judge for hearing on the day on which they are listed will roll over from day to day
Any cases not reached or commenced at the end of a week will be removed from the list and will require, in
due course, an application to be made for a new hearing date in the usual manner.
All Specially Fixed cases and cases afforded priority will retain priority over other cases

The Virtual Courtroom Number and relevant instructions will be made available each day to members through
the Law Society of Ireland and the Bar of Ireland website

https://members.lawlibrary.ie/connect/
https://www.lawsociety.ie/remotehearings
______________________
Applications on Notice for Hearing Dates should be made by email each Friday during term to
[email protected] with a estimated timeframe for the hearing
Assigned dates will be emailed to the applicants each Monday with liberty to apply on any Friday
There will be no facility for physical applications for dates until further notice
Where there is an objection applications on notice may be made after the daily remote call over or in person
to the List Judge
fParties are strongly encouraged to agree hearing dates

Personal Injuries Actions arising from allegations of bullying and or harassment.

Upon application for a trial date the case must be identified as one arising from such allegations.
No case shall be listed for trial unless and until the parties have been to Mediation save for good reason

PLEASE NOTE PRACTICE DIRECTION HC 89 HAS BEEN REVOKED ACCORDINGLY ALL

APPLICATIONS FOR CONSENT ORDERS SHOULD BE MADE TO THE COURT

PRACTITIONERS AND ALL CONCERNED IN THE PROCEEDINGS MUST ABIDE BY THE

PRACTICE DIRECTIONS GOVERNING PERSONAL INJURY CLAIMS

HILARY TERM
PHYSICAL & REMOTE CALL OVER AT 10.30 AM EACH DAY
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
FRIDAY 22/03/2024

FOR MENTION
PI 8918 DB MCCORMACK [APUM] -V- HSE
PI 6320 DB HAYES -V- LODGE T/A TIM LODGE HARDWARE
ORD 99
PI 6477 DB ANDERSON CONNOLLY -V- HSE
PI 5940 DB O SULLIVAN -V- O RIORDAIN & ANOR
FOR RULING
2019 8192 P SHAFIQ [A MINOR] -V- HSE
2022 1480 P MOONEY & ORS –V- ADELAIDE AND MEATH HOSPITAL DUBLIN INCORPORATING
2022 5804 JOHNSON [A MINOR] -V- HSE
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

CÚRSAÍ NEAMHGHIÚRE
NON JURY

Court List

Before: Ms. Justice Niamh Hyland

At: Four Courts Court 6(Hybrid)

Date: 22/03/2024 10:45

List Type: NEAMHGHIÚIRÉ

NON JURY

Total: 1

Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum, Immigration and Citizenship List Notice- Lodgement of
Papers and Correspondence with Registrars
31st October 2023
Please take notice of the following directions regarding the lodgement of papers and correspondence with
registrars:
1. Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum Hearings and Callover of Hearings
Papers for hearings in Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum Lists must be lodged in the List Room no later
than the Tuesday of the week prior to the Hearing date. (Please note, this deadline does not apply to the
Monday Judicial Review ex parte list and the Monday Asylum and Immigration ex parte list- for information
on lodgement for that list, see item 3 below).
Parties in Asylum, Immigration and Citizenship List hearings should note that the Tuesday deadline
supersedes the deadline for lodgement of papers for hearings included in in Asylum Practice direction HC81.
Any application for late lodgement of papers must be made to the List Judge at the callover on the Thursday
of the week prior to the Hearing date.
The callover takes placed on a hybrid basis and begins at 10 a.m. Parties must also indicate at the callover
whether the hearing will be physical, hybrid or remote. If no preference is given, the hearing will be physical.
If there is no attendance at the callover, the hearing will be struck out.

Correspondence to the registrars/mailbox/Judicial Assistant seeking permission for the late lodgement of
papers, requests to change the mode of hearing or applications to re-instate hearings that have been struck out
will not be acknowledged. No additional/missing documents will be accepted by email. Any further
applications must be made to the Court at the end of the list any day.
Papers for hearings will not be returned and will be shredded. They must be re-lodged prior to any new
hearing date.

2. Case Management Hearings

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

Lodgement of papers in advance is no longer required for Case Management hearings. If there are papers
which the parties wish to bring to the attention of the Court, these may be handed in by the solicitor when the
matter is called.

3. Judicial Review Ex Parte and Asylum Ex Parte Lists

Papers for Judicial Review ex parte applications listed in the Monday Judicial Review Ex parte list and the
Monday Asylum Ex parte list must be lodged in the List Room no later than the Monday of the week prior to
the list (i.e.no later than 7 days before the Listing). Due to capacity issues in the List Room, papers can only
be accepted from a fortnight before the listing date up until the Monday of the week prior to the Listing.
Papers for leave applications will not be returned and will be shredded They must be re-lodged prior to any
adjourned date.
4. Judicial Review and Asylum- “Leave on Notice” Applications
If the Court directs that an application for leave to seek Judicial Review is to be made on notice, the
applicant/applicant’s solicitor must liaise with the solicitor for the respondent prior to the return date to
ascertain if the leave application will be contested.
If the leave application will not be contested, the applicant/applicant’s solicitor must hand in a copy of the
Statement of Grounds to the Judge in court.
If the leave application is contested by the respondent(s), a hearing date will be given and papers must be
lodged in the List Room prior to the hearing in accordance with Item 1 above.

5. Judicial Review and Asylum- Applications to Open and Adjourn (to stop time)
Applications to open a Judicial Review for the purposes of stopping time only can be made at the end of the
list any day, provided the case has been issued by the Central Office and a record number has been obtained.
Practitioners do not have to email the registrar to ask for permission to mention the proceedings in advance.
Booklets of papers are not required in Court for the application to open the Judicial Review for the purposes
of stopping time.

6. Matters Listed for Mention

Papers are not to be lodged in the List Room for matters listed for mention. If there are papers which the
parties wish to bring to the attention of the Court, these are to be handed in when the matter is called.
Emails to registrars/Judicial Assistants regarding papers/correspondence for the Judge will not be
acknowledged.

7. Queries to the Non-Jury/Judicial Review List mailbox

Parties should be mindful of the volume of correspondence that registrars are receiving and must consult
High Court Search, the list diaries and Today’s cases on the Legal Diary and this notice before contacting the
registrar/mailbox.
The Non Jury and Judicial Review mailbox ([email protected]) should primarily be used to
send in terms of orders or to request that certified actions are listed for mention to get a hearing date.
The most efficient way of raising queries is to mention your query to the Non-Jury and Judicial Review
registrar before the List or at the end of the list on Tuesday-Friday inclusive.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

Most other requests to list matters for mention can mentioned to the Judge at the end of the List on Tuesday
(in respect of Judicial Review proceedings), Wednesday (in respect of non-Jury proceedings) or Fridays (in
respect of Asylum applications).
If sending a query to the mailbox, please ensure the record number is quoted in the subject line of the
correspondence.

8. Consent Applications
Consent applications in the Non-Jury and Judicial Review Lists will be taken by the registrar on Tuesday,
Wednesday and Friday from 10:15. On Thursday, consent applications will be taken at the end of the
Callover of hearings.

9. Obtaining a hearing date for Non-Jury Actions

Once the Certificate of Readiness has been filed in the Central Office, please email
[email protected] along with a soft copy of the Certificate. The action will be listed for
mention on the next available Wednesday.
Once the registrar provides the date, the requesting party must then inform the other party/parties of the date.

PLEASE NOTE- MS JUSTICE HYLAND’S PEXIP INFINITY NUMBER FOR THE NON JURY/
JUDICIAL REVIEW AND ASYLUM LISTS IS-
https://confpool.remotecourts.ie/webapp/conference/[email protected]

Certain matters for hearing may proceed physically if this was indicated at the positive call over on
Thursday prior to the hearing

The virtual courtroom numbers and relevant instructions are available to members through the Law
Society of Ireland and the Bar of Ireland websites:

LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND - REMOTE HEARING LINK

- https://www.lawsociety.ie/remotehearings

BAR OF IRELAND MEMBERS AREA -REMOTE HEARING LINK

https://members.lawlibrary.ie/connect/

The registrar is unable to respond to emails from practitioners in relation to connection details

Position Case Number Public Title

FOR MENTION
1. 2021 4560 P O HIGGINS & ANOR -
V- URBAN LIVING
ARCHITECTURE &
CONSTRUCTION
LTD
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

ATHBHREITHNIÚ BHREITHÚNACH
JUDICIAL REVIEW

Court List

Before: Ms. Justice Niamh Hyland

At: Four Courts Court 6(Hybrid)

Date: 22/03/2024 10:45

List Type: ATHBHREITHNIÚ BREITHIÚNACH

JUDICIAL REVIEW

Total: 11

Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum, Immigration and Citizenship List Notice- Lodgement of
Papers and Correspondence with Registrars
31st October 2023
Please take notice of the following directions regarding the lodgement of papers and correspondence with
registrars:
1. Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum Hearings and Callover of Hearings
Papers for hearings in Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum Lists must be lodged in the List Room no later
than the Tuesday of the week prior to the Hearing date. (Please note, this deadline does not apply to the
Monday Judicial Review ex parte list and the Monday Asylum and Immigration ex parte list- for information
on lodgement for that list, see item 3 below).
Parties in Asylum, Immigration and Citizenship List hearings should note that the Tuesday deadline
supersedes the deadline for lodgement of papers for hearings included in in Asylum Practice direction HC81.
Any application for late lodgement of papers must be made to the List Judge at the callover on the Thursday
of the week prior to the Hearing date.
The callover takes placed on a hybrid basis and begins at 10 a.m. Parties must also indicate at the callover
whether the hearing will be physical, hybrid or remote. If no preference is given, the hearing will be physical.
If there is no attendance at the callover, the hearing will be struck out.

Correspondence to the registrars/mailbox/Judicial Assistant seeking permission for the late lodgement of
papers, requests to change the mode of hearing or applications to re-instate hearings that have been struck out
will not be acknowledged. No additional/missing documents will be accepted by email. Any further
applications must be made to the Court at the end of the list any day.
Papers for hearings will not be returned and will be shredded. They must be re-lodged prior to any new
hearing date.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

2. Case Management Hearings

Lodgement of papers in advance is no longer required for Case Management hearings. If there are papers
which the parties wish to bring to the attention of the Court, these may be handed in by the solicitor when the
matter is called.

3. Judicial Review Ex Parte and Asylum Ex Parte Lists

Papers for Judicial Review ex parte applications listed in the Monday Judicial Review Ex parte list and the
Monday Asylum Ex parte list must be lodged in the List Room no later than the Monday of the week prior to
the list (i.e.no later than 7 days before the Listing). Due to capacity issues in the List Room, papers can only
be accepted from a fortnight before the listing date up until the Monday of the week prior to the Listing.
Papers for leave applications will not be returned and will be shredded They must be re-lodged prior to any
adjourned date.
4. Judicial Review and Asylum- “Leave on Notice” Applications
If the Court directs that an application for leave to seek Judicial Review is to be made on notice, the
applicant/applicant’s solicitor must liaise with the solicitor for the respondent prior to the return date to
ascertain if the leave application will be contested.
If the leave application will not be contested, the applicant/applicant’s solicitor must hand in a copy of the
Statement of Grounds to the Judge in court.
If the leave application is contested by the respondent(s), a hearing date will be given and papers must be
lodged in the List Room prior to the hearing in accordance with Item 1 above.

5. Judicial Review and Asylum- Applications to Open and Adjourn (to stop time)
Applications to open a Judicial Review for the purposes of stopping time only can be made at the end of the
list any day, provided the case has been issued by the Central Office and a record number has been obtained.
Practitioners do not have to email the registrar to ask for permission to mention the proceedings in advance.
Booklets of papers are not required in Court for the application to open the Judicial Review for the purposes
of stopping time.

6. Matters Listed for Mention

Papers are not to be lodged in the List Room for matters listed for mention. If there are papers which the
parties wish to bring to the attention of the Court, these are to be handed in when the matter is called.
Emails to registrars/Judicial Assistants regarding papers/correspondence for the Judge will not be
acknowledged.

7. Queries to the Non-Jury/Judicial Review List mailbox

Parties should be mindful of the volume of correspondence that registrars are receiving and must consult
High Court Search, the list diaries and Today’s cases on the Legal Diary and this notice before contacting the
registrar/mailbox.
The Non Jury and Judicial Review mailbox ([email protected]) should primarily be used to
send in terms of orders or to request that certified actions are listed for mention to get a hearing date.
The most efficient way of raising queries is to mention your query to the Non-Jury and Judicial Review
registrar before the List or at the end of the list on Tuesday-Friday inclusive.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

Most other requests to list matters for mention can mentioned to the Judge at the end of the List on Tuesday
(in respect of Judicial Review proceedings), Wednesday (in respect of non-Jury proceedings) or Fridays (in
respect of Asylum applications).
If sending a query to the mailbox, please ensure the record number is quoted in the subject line of the
correspondence.

8. Consent Applications
Consent applications in the Non-Jury and Judicial Review Lists will be taken by the registrar on Tuesday,
Wednesday and Friday from 10:15. On Thursday, consent applications will be taken at the end of the
Callover of hearings.

9. Obtaining a hearing date for Non-Jury Actions

Once the Certificate of Readiness has been filed in the Central Office, please email
[email protected] along with a soft copy of the Certificate. The action will be listed for
mention on the next available Wednesday.
Once the registrar provides the date, the requesting party must then inform the other party/parties of the date.

PLEASE NOTE- MS JUSTICE HYLAND’S PEXIP INFINITY NUMBER FOR THE NON JURY/
JUDICIAL REVIEW AND ASYLUM LISTS IS-
https://confpool.remotecourts.ie/webapp/conference/[email protected]

Certain matters for hearing may proceed physically if this was indicated at the positive call over on
Thursday prior to the hearing

The virtual courtroom numbers and relevant instructions are available to members through the Law
Society of Ireland and the Bar of Ireland websites:

LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND - REMOTE HEARING LINK

- https://www.lawsociety.ie/remotehearings

BAR OF IRELAND MEMBERS AREA -REMOTE HEARING LINK

https://members.lawlibrary.ie/connect/

The registrar is unable to respond to emails from practitioners in relation to connection details
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

Position Case Number Public Title

EX PARTE
1 H.JR.2024.0000382 BARTRA OPCO
(NORTHWOOD NH)
LIMITED v
NATIONAL
TREAMENT
PURCHASE FUND
FOR HEARING
2 H.JR.2024.0000002 R v HSE

FOR MENTION
3 H.JR.2023.0001235 F -V- HSE & ANOR

4 2023 338 JR ULLAH -V-

MINISTER FOR
JUSTICE
5 H.JR.2024.0000220 D v HSE

6 H.JR.2024.0000219 D v HSE

7 2019 143 JR MURPHY -V- DPP

8 2023 1075 JR O v THE HEALTH

SERVICE
EXECUTIVE
9 H.JR.2024.0000176 R v HSE

10 H.JR.2024.0000097 B v HSE

11 H.JR.2024.0000098 R v HSE
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

SEANSAIREACHT
CHANCERY

SEANSAIREACHT
CHANCERY

FRIDAY THE 22ND DAY OF MARCH 2024

IN COURT 3
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
MR JUSTICE SANFEY

AT 10.30 AM
CALL OVER OF CASES FOR HEARING TODAY [PHYSICAL]
1. 2023 443 P COMBRAY LTD -V- TREACY & ORS (2 x Motions) (1D)
2. 2017 6788 P GIBB & ORS -V- ULSTER BANK DAC & ORS (0.5D)

MOTIONS [PHYSICAL]
3. H.P.2024.0001280 ALANIS UNLIMITED COMPANY v BEDFORD & ANOR
4. H.P.2024.0001407 CREGANNA UNLIMITED COMPANY v CULLEN & ANOR
5. H.P.2024.0001148 MCGAHAN v MARS CAPIAL FINANCE [IRELAND] DAC & ANOR

AT 11.00 AM
ADV LIST
FOR MENTION [PHYSICAL]
6. 2021 3588 P DROMADA WINDFARM [ROI] LTD -V- CREMINS

CHANCERY LIST
MOTIONS [PHYSICAL]
7. 2023 443 P COMBRAY LTD -V- TREACY & ORS
8. 2022 6415 P FARAAG & ORS -V- HE & ORS
9. H.P.2024.0001238 WHITE v HORSE SHUTTLE IRELAND LTD & ORS

FOR MENTION [PHYSICAL]

10. 2021 6617 P CINNEIDE & ORS -V- AN TARD AIGHNE & ORS
11. 2021 6617 P CINNEIDE & ORS -V- AN TARD AIGHNE & ORS
12. 2021 6617 P CINNEIDE & ORS -V- AN TARD AIGHNE & ORS
13. 2022 4049 P DUFFY & ANOR -V- KENNELLY TAX ADVISORS LTD
14. H.P.2024.0000708 FITZPATRICK v BOCOMM AVIATION LEASING IRELAND LTD
15. H.P.2024.0000172 LINDAT LTD v THE PW CAFE BAR LTD
16. 2022 4507 P THE BOARD OF MANAGEMENT OF WILSONS HOSPITAL -V- BURKE
17. H.P.2024.0001390 XIU LAN HOTELS LTD & ORS v KELLY & ANOR

TO FIX DATES [HYBRID]

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
18. 2023 443 P COMBRAY LTD -V- TREACY & ORS
19. H.P.2024.0000509 CRM PROPERTIES LIMITED v BUTT
20. 2020 2222 P DALY -V- PEPPER FINANCE CORPORATION [IRELAND] DAC
21. 2023 255 R ELIZABETH MURRAY LTD -V- REVENUE COMMISSIONERS
22. 2023 536 P ETHAFIL LTD [IN VOLUNTARY LIQUIDATION] -V- MULVANY
23. 2015 4737 P GRIFFITH -V- PARMA INVESTMENTS BV & ORS
24. 2022 3766 P O BRIEN -V- O BRIEN
25. 2022 3766 P O BRIEN -V- O BRIEN
26. H.P.2023.0006170 O HAGAN v HARPER & ANOR
27. 2021 6375 P O HARA -V- IRELAND & ORS
28. 2021 6375 P O HARA -V- IRELAND & ORS
29. 2023 3092 P O HARA -V- THE GOVERNMENT OF IRELAND & ORS
30. 2023 3092 P O HARA -V- THE GOVERNMENT OF IRELAND & ORS
31. 2023 3092 P O HARA -V- THE GOVERNMENT OF IRELAND & ORS
32. 2023 3092 P O HARA -V- THE GOVERNMENT OF IRELAND & ORS
33. 2023 2620 P O NEILL & ANOR -V- AUSTIN HEFFERNAN PRACTISING AS AUSTIN
HEFFERNAN & COMPANY
34. 2023 4634 P QUINN [A MINOR] -V- THE MINISTER FOR EDUCATION & ORS
35. 2023 192 P TOWNHOUSE & RESTAURANT ROSCOMMON LTD -V- PROMONTORIA
[ARAN] DAC & ORS
36. 2023 192 P TOWNHOUSE & RESTAURANT ROSCOMMON LTD -V- PROMONTORIA
[ARAN] DAC & ORS
37. 2022 6138 P TREACY & ORS -V- PROMONTORIA [ARAN] DAC & ORS
38. 2022 6138 P TREACY & ORS -V- PROMONTORIA [ARAN] DAC & ORS
39. 2021 4163 P TUCKER -V- CURRY
40. 2021 4163 P TUCKER -V- CURRY

NOT BEFORE 11.45 A.M. [HYBRID]

APPLICATIONS FOR HEARING DATES IN THE CHANCERY LIST
AND APPLICATIONS GENERALLY IN RELATION TO THE LIST
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

LIOSTA TRACHTÁLA
COMMERCIAL LIST
LIOSTA TRÁCHTÁLA
COMMERCIAL LIST

*********************************************************************

PLEASE NOTE THAT THE CALLOVER OF MATTERS LISTED IN THE COMMERCIAL LIST FOR
THE WEEK STARTING THE 8TH DAY OF APRIL 2024 WILL BE HELD ON THE 22ND DAY OF
MARCH 2024 AT 10:45AM

*********************************************************************

FOR FRIDAY 22ND MARCH 2024

BEFORE MR. JUSTICE McDONALD

FOR MENTION
AT 10.30AM
2019 4140 P BIOMASS HEATING SOLUTIONS LTD -V- GEURTS INTERNATIONAL B V (For update on
judgment)

2023 267 S MINISTER FOR THE ENVIRONMENT CLIMATE & COMMUNICATIONS V- SAN LEON
ENERGY PUBLIC LTD COMPANY
2018 5619 P CLARION QUAY MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED BY GUARANT -V- DUBLIN CITY
COUNCIL & ANOR
2018 5343 P KELLY & ORS -V- CLARION QUAY MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED BY
2018 5344 P MCCORMACK & ORS -V- CLARION QUAY MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED BY

CALLOVER OF CASES LISTED FOR HEARING IN THE COMMERCIAL LIST THE FOLLOWING
WEEK
AT 10:45 AM

FOR MENTION
AFTER THE CALLOVER
2023 2058 P PROAMPAC UK LTD -V- MOVEBLOCK LTD
2023 2058 P PROAMPAC UK LTD -V- MOVEBLOCK LTD
2023 2058 P PROAMPAC UK LTD -V- MOVEBLOCK LTD
2018 1057 S MICROSOFT IRELAND OPERATIONS LIMITED -V- ARABIC COMPUTER SYSTEMS &
ANOR NATIONAL TECHNOLOGY

FOR HEARING
AT 11:00AM
2024 15 COS HYPOPORT MORTGAGE MARKET LTD v CROSS BORDER CONVERSIONS, MERGERS
AND DIVISONS REGULATION 2023

2022 6117 P COOPERATIEVE RABOBANK UA T/A RABOBANK DUBLIN -V- AM ALPHA LUX
INVEST 130 SARL (Mn to amend D’s SoC against TPs)
2022 6116 P ZURICH INSURANCE PLC & ORS -V- AM ALPHA LUX INVEST 130 SARL (Mn to amend
D’s SoC against TPs)
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
2022 6505 P-USED CRANES & MATERIALS HOLLAND B.V. -V- O CARROLL HAULAGE & CRANE
HIRE LTD

AT 11:30AM
2022 5514 P-AVOLON AEROSPACE [HAMILTON] AOE 1 LTD & ORS -V- LLOYDS INSURANCE
COMPANY S A & ORS
2022 5538 P-BOC AVIATION [IRELAND] LTD & ORS -V- LLOYDS INSURANCE COMPANY S A &
ORS
2022 5759 P-CDB AVIATION LEASE FINANCE DAC & ORS -V- LLOYDS INSURANCE COMPANY SA
& ORS
2022 6087 P-HERMES AIRCRAFT A1264 LTD & ORS -V- ALL UNDERWRITING MEMBERS OF
SYNDICATE 1969 AT & ORS
2022 6232 P-NAC AVIATION 29 DAC & ANOR -V- LLOYDS INSURANCE COMPANY S.A. & ORS
2022 5975 P-SMBC AVIATION CAPITAL LTD & ORS -V- LLOYDS INSURANCE COMPANY S.A &
ORS
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

AN DLÍ TEAGHLAIGH
FAMILY LAW
FRIDAY THE 22ND MARCH 2024

MR. JUSTICE JORDAN

COURT 7
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
(PHYSICAL)

2022 64 M C -V- C

2023 84 M O’L -V- O’L

2021 101 M S -V- G

MS. JUSTICE JACKSON

COURT 16
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
(PHYSICAL)

2014 37 M F-V- F

MR. JUSTICE BARRETT

COURT 12
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
(PHYSICAL)

2018 35M B-V- B

FÉIMHEACHT
BANKRUPTCY
FEIMHEACHT
BANKRUPTCY

MR. JUSTICE KENNEDY

JUDGMENT TO BE DELIVERED ELECTRONICALLY
AT 11 O’CLOCK
22 MARCH 2024

For Judgment: Motion: Michael Grimes a Bankrupt: Applicant

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

TEARMANN
ASYLUM
Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum, Immigration and Citizenship List Notice- Lodgement of Papers
and Correspondence with Registrars
31st October 2023
Please take notice of the following directions regarding the lodgement of papers and correspondence with
registrars:
10. Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum Hearings and Callover of Hearings
Papers for hearings in Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum Lists must be lodged in the List Room no later
than the Tuesday of the week prior to the Hearing date. (Please note, this deadline does not apply to the
Monday Judicial Review ex parte list and the Monday Asylum and Immigration ex parte list- for information on
lodgement for that list, see item 3 below).
Parties in Asylum, Immigration and Citizenship List hearings should note that the Tuesday deadline supersedes
the deadline for lodgement of papers for hearings included in in Asylum Practice direction HC81.
Any application for late lodgement of papers must be made to the List Judge at the callover on the Thursday of
the week prior to the Hearing date.
The callover takes placed on a hybrid basis and begins at 10 a.m. Parties must also indicate at the callover
whether the hearing will be physical, hybrid or remote. If no preference is given, the hearing will be physical. If
there is no attendance at the callover, the hearing will be struck out.
Correspondence to the registrars/mailbox/Judicial Assistant seeking permission for the late lodgement of
papers, requests to change the mode of hearing or applications to re-instate hearings that have been struck out
will not be acknowledged. No additional/missing documents will be accepted by email. Any further
applications must be made to the Court at the end of the list any day.
Papers for hearings will not be returned and will be shredded. They must be re-lodged prior to any new hearing
date.

11. Case Management Hearings

Lodgement of papers in advance is no longer required for Case Management hearings. If there are papers
which the parties wish to bring to the attention of the Court, these may be handed in by the solicitor when the
matter is called.

12. Judicial Review Ex Parte and Asylum Ex Parte Lists

Papers for Judicial Review ex parte applications listed in the Monday Judicial Review Ex parte list and the
Monday Asylum Ex parte list must be lodged in the List Room no later than the Monday of the week prior to
the list (i.e.no later than 7 days before the Listing). Due to capacity issues in the List Room, papers can only be
accepted from a fortnight before the listing date up until the Monday of the week prior to the Listing.
Papers for leave applications will not be returned and will be shredded They must be re-lodged prior to any
adjourned date.
13. Judicial Review and Asylum- “Leave on Notice” Applications
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
If the Court directs that an application for leave to seek Judicial Review is to be made on notice, the
applicant/applicant’s solicitor must liaise with the solicitor for the respondent prior to the return date to
ascertain if the leave application will be contested.
If the leave application will not be contested, the applicant/applicant’s solicitor must hand in a copy of the
Statement of Grounds to the Judge in court.
If the leave application is contested by the respondent(s), a hearing date will be given and papers must be
lodged in the List Room prior to the hearing in accordance with Item 1 above.

14. Judicial Review and Asylum- Applications to Open and Adjourn (to stop time)
Applications to open a Judicial Review for the purposes of stopping time only can be made at the end of the
list any day, provided the case has been issued by the Central Office and a record number has been obtained.
Practitioners do not have to email the registrar to ask for permission to mention the proceedings in advance.
Booklets of papers are not required in Court for the application to open the Judicial Review for the purposes of
stopping time.

15. Matters Listed for Mention

Papers are not to be lodged in the List Room for matters listed for mention. If there are papers which the parties
wish to bring to the attention of the Court, these are to be handed in when the matter is called.
Emails to registrars/Judicial Assistants regarding papers/correspondence for the Judge will not be
acknowledged.

16. Queries to the Non-Jury/Judicial Review List mailbox

Parties should be mindful of the volume of correspondence that registrars are receiving and must consult High
Court Search, the list diaries and Today’s cases on the Legal Diary and this notice before contacting the
registrar/mailbox.
The Non Jury and Judicial Review mailbox ([email protected]) should primarily be used to send
in terms of orders or to request that certified actions are listed for mention to get a hearing date.
The most efficient way of raising queries is to mention your query to the Non-Jury and Judicial Review
registrar before the List or at the end of the list on Tuesday-Friday inclusive.
Most other requests to list matters for mention can mentioned to the Judge at the end of the List on Tuesday (in
respect of Judicial Review proceedings), Wednesday (in respect of non-Jury proceedings) or Fridays (in respect
of Asylum applications).
If sending a query to the mailbox, please ensure the record number is quoted in the subject line of the
correspondence.

17. Consent Applications

Consent applications in the Non-Jury and Judicial Review Lists will be taken by the registrar on Tuesday,
Wednesday and Friday from 10:15. On Thursday, consent applications will be taken at the end of the Callover
of hearings.

18. Obtaining a hearing date for Non-Jury Actions

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
Once the Certificate of Readiness has been filed in the Central Office, please email
[email protected] along with a soft copy of the Certificate. The action will be listed for mention
on the next available Wednesday.
Once the registrar provides the date, the requesting party must then inform the other party/parties of the date.

Court List (Web)

Before: Ms. Justice Niamh Hyland

At: Four Courts – Court 6

Date: 22/03/2024 1045hrs

List Type: ASYLUM POST-LEAVE

Total: 63

Position Case Number Case Title

1 H.JR.2023.0001289 S v MJ
2 2019 590 JR M v MJE
3 2020 80 JR M v MJE
4 2021 174 JR B v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
5 2019 591 JR S v MJE
6 H.JR.2023.0001087 R v MJ
7 H.JR.2023.0001205 A v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
8 2023 601 JR S -V- MJ
9 H.JR.2023.0001466 S v MJ
10 2023 545 JR A v MJ
11 2023 610 JR K v MJE
12 2023 613 JR A v MJE
13 2022 1100 JR A -V- MINISTER FOR JUSTICE & ORS
14 2023 611 JR A v MJE
15 2023 1013 JR C v MJ
16 2023 159 JR A v MJ
17 2023 1053 JR F v MJ
18 2023 1057 JR N v THE INTERNATIONAL
PORTECTION APPEALS TRIBUNAL
19 2023 1057 JR N v THE INTERNATIONAL
PORTECTION APPEALS TRIBUNAL
20 2022 1054 JR U v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
21 2023 902 JR A v CHIEF INTERNATIONAL
PROTECTION OFFICER
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

22 2023 1033 JR O v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE

23 2023 793 JR N v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
24 2023 701 JR R v INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION
APPEALS TRIBUNAL
25 H.JR.2023.0001361 D v MJ
26 H.JR.2023.0001339 H v MJ
27 H.JR.2023.0001217 F v THE MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
28 H.JR.2023.0001337 H v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
29 H.JR.2023.0001340 D v MJE
30 H.JR.2023.0001192 A v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
31 H.JR.2023.0001328 K v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE AND
EQUALITY
32 H.JR.2023.0001129 A v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
33 2023 1012 JR C v MJ
34 H.JR.2023.0001168 H v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
35 H.JR.2023.0001200 A v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
36 H.JR.2023.0001251 A v THE MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
37 H.JR.2023.0001422 Y v INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION
APPEALS TRIBUNAL
38 H.JR.2023.0001160 B v MJ
39 H.JR.2023.0001309 K v MJ
40 H.JR.2023.0001287 A v MJ
41 2023 1010 JR K v MJ
42 H.JR.2023.0001097 H v MJE
43 2023 1021 JR M v MJ
44 H.JR.2023.0001163 O v MJ
45 H.JR.2023.0001161 H v MJ
46 H.JR.2023.0001421 Y v IPAT
47 2023 1043 JR O v THE INTERNATIONAL
PROTECTION APPEALS TRIBUNAL
48 2021 728 JR K v MJE
49 2022 1021 JR M v MJ
50 H.JR.2023.0001107 K v CHIEF INTERNATIONAL
PROTECTION OFFICER & ORS
51 2023 941 JR G v MJ
52 2023 808 JR A v MJ
53 2021 728 JR K v MJE
54 H.JR.2024.0000189 I v THE INTERNATIONAL
PROTECTION APPEALS TRIBUNAL
55 H.JR.2023.0001154 S v MJ
56 H.JR.2023.0001132 K v THE INTERNATIONAL
PROTECTION APPEALS TRIBUNAL
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

57 2023 877 JR T v THE INTERNATIONAL

PROTECTION APPEALS TRIBUNAL
58 H.JR.2023.0001166 H v MJ
59 2023 338 JR U -V- MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
60 H.JR.2023.0001131 M v INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION
APPEALS TRIBUNAL
61 H.JR.2023.0001096 K v MJ
62 2023 865 JR M v MJ
63 2023 1039 JR C v THE INTERNATIONAL
PROTECTION APPEALS TRIBUNAL
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

AN LIOSTA EISEACHADTA
EXTRADITION LIST

AN LIOSTA EISEACHADTA
EXTRADITION LIST
CCJ 20

Before Court 20 CCJ (capacity 54), unless otherwise specified.

Please note that courtrooms and court times are subject to change at short notice and are at the discretion of the
Court.

The High Court has issued a Guidance Document and Core Booklet for the Extradition list. The purpose of this
document is to increase the efficiency in the Extradition list and to ensure that all practitioners are aware of the
manner in which the list is run.

The link to the booklet is here: High Court Extradition List - Guidance Document and Core Booklet

The booklet is also available in the High Court Procedures Section on the Miscellaneous High Court
Notices page.

All queries regarding the list should be addressed to [email protected]

FRIDAY THE 22ND DAY OF MARCH 2023

BEFORE MR JUSTICE MCGRATH IN CCJ TBC AT 11.00AM

ARABIC

1. 2023 140 EXT MJ -V- ZAKARIA MIMOUNE S18

ENGLISH

2. 2020 388 EXT MJ -V- PAT K JOSEPH WARD S16FH

3. 2020 389 EXT MJ -V- PAT K JOSEPH WARD S16FH

POLISH

4. 2023 235 EXT MJ -V- BARTLOMIEJ SMOLINSKI S16AH(PMcG)JT

CZECH

5. 2023 197 EXT MJ -V- MILAN BUDIK S20FM

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

BREITHNEOIRÍ COSTAS DLÍTHIÚIL

LEGAL COSTS ADJUDICATORS

High Court
Adjudication of Legal Costs For Mention
Before Chief Legal Costs Adjudicator Paul M. Behan
On Friday, 22 March 2024 At 09:00
Office of the Legal Costs Adjudicators - Adjudication Room 1
1st Floor, Merchants House, 27-30 Merchants Quay, Dublin 8

1 H:LCA:OLCA:2022:000513 Marion Dunne and Health Service Executive Quest Diagnostics

Incorporated and Coombe Women and Infants University Hospital
2 H:LCA:OLCA:2022:000515 Debbie Mason Connolly -v- Health Service Executive, Quest Diagnostics
Incorporated and Coombe Woman and Infants University Hospital
3 H:LCA:OLCA:2022:000798 Andrew Connolly -V- Health Service Executive & Quest Diagnostic
Incorporated & Coombe Women & Infant's University Hospital

High Court
Adjudication of Legal Costs Hearing
Before Chief Legal Costs Adjudicator Paul M. Behan
On Friday, 22 March 2024 At 9:30
Office of the Legal Costs Adjudicators - Adjudication Room 1
1st Floor, Merchants House, 27-30 Merchants Quay, Dublin 8

1 H:LCA:OLCA:2022:000833 Yvonne Melia v Health Service Executive

High Court
Adjudication of Legal Costs Hearing
Before Chief Legal Costs Adjudicator Paul M. Behan
On Friday, 22 March 2024 At 10:00
Office of the Legal Costs Adjudicators - Adjudication Room 1
1st Floor, Merchants House, 27-30 Merchants Quay, Dublin 8
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024
1 H:LCA:OLCA:2020:000312 Elaine Morgan and (By Order) Carlow County Council v. Slaneygio
Limited and Joseph Germaine
2 H:LCA:OLCA:2020:000314 Elaine Morgan and (By Order) Carlow County Council v. Slaneygio
Limited and Joseph Germaine

High Court
Adjudication of Legal Costs Hearing
Before Chief Legal Costs Adjudicator Paul M. Behan
On Friday, 22 March 2024 At 2:00 pm
Office of the Legal Costs Adjudicators - Adjudication Room 1
1st Floor, Merchants House, 27-30 Merchants Quay, Dublin 8

1 H:LCA:OLCA:2021:000447 Declan Campbell To McEntee & O'Doherty Solicitors

High Court
Adjudication of Legal Costs Hearing
Before Legal Costs Adjudicator Barry Magee
On Friday, 22 March 2024 At 10:00
Office of the Legal Costs Adjudicators - Adjudication Room 2
1st Floor, Merchants House, 27-30 Merchants Quay, Dublin 8

1 H:LCA:OLCA:2021:000518 O'Flahertys (Nassau Street) Limited To Eversheds Sutherland Solicitors

2 H:LCA:OLCA:2021:000520 O'Flahertys (Nassau Street) Limited To Eversheds Sutherland Solicitors

3 H:LCA:OLCA:2021:000563 O'Flahertys (Nassau Street) Limited To Eversheds Sutherland Solicitors

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé hAoine 22ú Márta 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Friday 22nd March 2024

BANNAÍ
BAIL

HIGH COURT BAIL LIST FRIDAY 22nd MARCH 2024

BEFORE MR JUSTICE HUNT IN THE CCJ AT 10AM – COURT 9.

DPP -V- DYNES DOMINIC (to be produced) CHILL 05/01/1972 2023 1898 SS
DPP -V- DOYLE MICHAEL NIC 03/01/1968 2024 0274 SS
DPP -V- WRIGHT JAMES NIC 28/06/1962 2024 0277 SS

BEFORE MR JUSTICE PAUL BURNS AT 10.30AM (REMOTELY – VIA J. BURNS PEXIP)

DPP -V- CASEY TIMMY LIMER 07/12/86 2024 0243 SS

BEFORE MR JUSTICE MICHAEL MACGRATH IN COURT 21 THE FOUR COURTS AT

12.45

DPP -V- HODGINS MICHAEL (VIA V/LINK) CHILL 18/08/70 2024 0350 SS