Management Principles
Management Principles
What is Management?
Management is a universal phenomenon. Every individual or entity requires setting objectives,
making plans, handling people, coordinating and controlling activities, achieving goals and
evaluating performance directed towards organizational goals. These activities relate to the
utilization of variables or resources from the environment − human, monetary, physical, and
informational.
Human resources refer to managerial talent, labour (managerial talent, labour, and services
provided by them), monetary resources (the monetary investment the organization uses to finance
its current and long-term operations), physical resources (raw materials, physical and production
facilities and equipment) and information resources (data and other kinds of information).
Management is essentially the bringing together these resources within an organization towards
reaching objectives of an organization.
Management Defined
Management has been defined by various authors/authorities in various ways. Following are few
often-quoted definitions −
Management guru, Peter Drucker, says the basic task of management includes both marketing
and innovation. According to him, Management is a multipurpose organ that manages a business
and manages managers, and manages workers and work.
Harold Koontz defined management as the art of getting things done through and with people in
formally organized groups.
The principles of management are the means by which a manager actually manages, that is, get
things done through others − individually, in groups, or in organizations.
Formally defined, the principles of management are the activities that plan, organize, and control
the operations of the basic elements of [people], materials, machines, methods, money and markets,
providing direction and coordination, and giving leadership to human efforts, so as to achieve the
sought objectives of the enterprise.
Management as an Art
The personal ingenious and imaginative power of the manager lends management the approach of
an art. This creative power of the manager enriches his performance skill. In fact, the art of managing
involves the conception of a vision of an orderly whole, created from chaotic parts and the
communication and achievement of this vision. Managing can be called art of arts because it
organizes and uses human talent, which is the basis of every artistic activity.
Management as a Science
Management is a body of systematized knowledge accumulated and established with reference to
the practice and understanding of general truth concerning management. It is true that the science
1
underlying managing is not as accurate or comprehensive as physical sciences (such as chemistry
or biology) which deal with non-human entities.
The involvement of the human angle makes management not only complex but also controversial
as pure science. Nevertheless, the study of the scientific elements in management methodologies
can certainly improve the practice of management.
2
The Changing Roles of Management and Managers
Every organization has three primary interpersonal roles that are concerned with interpersonal
relationships. The manager in the figurehead role represents the organization in all matters of
formality. The top-level manager represents the company legally and socially to the outside world
that the organization interacts with.
In the supervisory role, the manager represents his team to the higher management. He acts as a
liaison between the higher management and his team. He also maintains contact with his peers
outside the organization.
3
Interpersonal Role
Figurehead − Has social, ceremonial and legal responsibilities.
Leader − Provides leadership and direction.
Liaison − Networks and communicates with internal and external contacts.
Informational Role
Monitor − Seeks out information related to your organization and industry, and monitors
internal teams in terms of both their productivity and well-being.
Disseminator − Communicates potentially useful information internally.
Spokesperson − Represents and speaks for the organization and transmits information
about the organization and its goals to the people outside it.
Decisional Role
Entrepreneur − Creates and controls change within the organization - solving problems,
generating new ideas, and implementing them.
Disturbance Handler − Resolves and manages unexpected roadblocks.
Resource Allocator − Allocates funds, assigning staff and other organizational resources.
Negotiator − Involved in direct important negotiations within the team, department, or
organization.
Managerial Skills
Henri Fayol, a famous management theorist also called as the Father of Modern Management,
identified three basic managerial skills - technical skill, human skill and conceptual skill.
Technical Skill
Knowledge and skills used to perform specific tasks. Accountants, engineers, surgeons all
have their specialized technical skills necessary for their respective professions. Managers,
especially at the lower and middle levels, need technical skills for effective task
performance.
Technical skills are important especially for first line managers, who spend much of their
time training subordinates and supervising their work-related problems.
Human Skill
Ability to work with, understand, and motivate other people as individuals or in groups.
According to Management theorist Mintzberg, the top (and middle) managers spend their
time: 59 percent in meetings, 6 percent on the phone, and 3 percent on tours.
Ability to work with others and get co-operation from people in the work group. For
example, knowing what to do and being able to communicate ideas and beliefs to others
and understanding what thoughts others are trying to convey to the manager.
Conceptual Skill
Ability to visualize the enterprise as a whole, to envision all the functions involved in a given
situation or circumstance, to understand how its parts depend on one another, and
anticipate how a change in any of its parts will affect the whole.
Creativity, broad knowledge and ability to conceive abstract ideas. For example, the
managing director of a telecom company visualizes the importance of better service for its
clients which ultimately helps attract a vast number of clients and an unexpected increase
in its subscriber base and profits.
Other Managerial Skills
Besides the skills discussed above, there are two other skills that a manager should possess,
namely diagnostic skill and analytical skill.
Diagnostic Skill − Diagnose a problem in the organization by studying its symptoms. For
example, a particular division may be suffering from high turnover. With the help of diagnostic skill,
the manager may find out that the division’s supervisor has poor human skill in dealing with
employees. This problem might then be solved by transferring or training the supervisor.
Analytical Skill − Ability to identify the vital or basic elements in a given situation, evaluate their
interdependence, and decide which ones should receive the most attention. This skill enables the
manager to determine possible strategies and to select the most appropriate one for the situation.
4
For example, when adding a new product to the existing product line, a manager may analyze the
advantages and risks in doing so and make a recommendation to the board of directors, who
make the final decision.
Diagnostic skill enables managers to understand a situation, whereas analytical skill helps
determine what to do in a given situation.
MIS - Introduction
To the managers, Management Information System is an implementation of the organizational
systems and procedures. To a programmer it is nothing but file structures and file processing.
However, it involves much more complexity.
6
The three components of MIS provide a more complete and focused definition,
where System suggests integration and holistic view, Information stands for processed data,
and Management is the ultimate user, the decision makers.
Management information system can thus be analyzed as follows −
Management
Management covers the planning, control, and administration of the operations of a concern. The
top management handles planning; the middle management concentrates on controlling; and the
lower management is concerned with actual administration.
Information
Information, in MIS, means the processed data that helps the management in planning, controlling
and operations. Data means all the facts arising out of the operations of the concern. Data is
processed i.e. recorded, summarized, compared and finally presented to the management in the
form of MIS report.
System
Data is processed into information with the help of a system. A system is made up of inputs,
processing, output and feedback or control.
Thus MIS means a system for processing data in order to give proper information to the
management for performing its functions.
Definition
Management Information System or 'MIS' is a planned system of collecting, storing, and
disseminating data in the form of information needed to carry out the functions of management.
Objectives of MIS
The goals of an MIS are to implement the organizational structure and dynamics of the enterprise
for the purpose of managing the organization in a better way and capturing the potential of the
information system for competitive advantage.
Following are the basic objectives of an MIS −
Capturing Data − Capturing contextual data, or operational information that will contribute
in decision making from various internal and external sources of organization.
Processing Data − The captured data is processed into information needed for planning,
organizing, coordinating, directing and controlling functionalities at strategic, tactical and
operational level. Processing data means −
o making calculations with the data
o sorting data
o classifying data and
o summarizing data
Information Storage − Information or processed data need to be stored for future use.
Information Retrieval − The system should be able to retrieve this information from the
storage as and when required by various users.
Information Propagation − Information or the finished product of the MIS should be
circulated to its users periodically using the organizational network.
Characteristics of MIS
Following are the characteristics of an MIS −
It should be based on a long-term planning.
It should provide a holistic view of the dynamics and the structure of the organization.
It should work as a complete and comprehensive system covering all interconnecting sub-
systems within the organization.
It should be planned in a top-down way, as the decision makers or the management should
actively take part and provide clear direction at the development stage of the MIS.
It should be based on need of strategic, operational and tactical information of managers of
an organization.
It should also take care of exceptional situations by reporting such situations.
7
It should be able to make forecasts and estimates, and generate advanced information,
thus providing a competitive advantage. Decision makers can take actions on the basis of
such predictions.
It should create linkage between all sub-systems within the organization, so that the
decision makers can take the right decision based on an integrated view.
It should allow easy flow of information through various sub-systems, thus avoiding
redundancy and duplicity of data. It should simplify the operations with as much
practicability as possible.
Although the MIS is an integrated, complete system, it should be made in such a flexible
way that it could be easily split into smaller sub-systems as and when required.
A central database is the backbone of a well-built MIS.
Characteristics of Computerized MIS
Following are the characteristics of a well-designed computerized MIS −
It should be able to process data accurately and with high speed, using various techniques
like operations research, simulation, heuristics, etc.
It should be able to collect, organize, manipulate, and update large amount of raw data of
both related and unrelated nature, coming from various internal and external sources at
different periods of time.
It should provide real time information on ongoing events without any delay.
It should support various output formats and follow latest rules and regulations in practice.
It should provide organized and relevant information for all levels of management: strategic,
operational, and tactical.
It should aim at extreme flexibility in data storage and retrieval.
Nature and Scope of MIS
The following diagram shows the nature and scope of MIS −
8
MIS - Enterprise Resource Planning
ERP is an integrated, real-time, cross-functional enterprise application, an enterprise-wide
transaction framework that supports all the internal business processes of a company.
It supports all core business processes such as sales order processing, inventory management
and control, production and distribution planning, and finance.
Why of ERP?
ERP is very helpful in the following areas −
Business integration and automated data update
Linkage between all core business processes and easy flow of integration
Flexibility in business operations and more agility to the company
Better analysis and planning capabilities
Critical decision-making
Competitive advantage
Use of latest technologies
Features of ERP
The following diagram illustrates the features of ERP −
9
Scope of ERP
Finance − Financial accounting, Managerial accounting, treasury management, asset
management, budget control, costing, and enterprise control.
Logistics − Production planning, material management, plant maintenance, project
management, events management, etc.
Human resource − Personnel management, training and development, etc.
Supply Chain − Inventory control, purchase and order control, supplier scheduling,
planning, etc.
Work flow − Integrate the entire organization with the flexible assignment of tasks and
responsibility to locations, position, jobs, etc.
Advantages of ERP
Reduction of lead time
Reduction of cycle time
Better customer satisfaction
Increased flexibility, quality, and efficiency
Improved information accuracy and decision making capability
Onetime shipment
Improved resource utilization
Improve supplier performance
Reduced quality costs
Quick decision-making
Forecasting and optimization
Better transparency
Disadvantage of ERP
Expense and time in implementation
Difficulty in integration with other system
Risk of implementation failure
Difficulty in implementation change
Risk in using one vendor
10
Scope of CRM
Advantages of CRM
Provides better customer service and increases customer revenues.
Discovers new customers.
Cross-sells and up-sells products more effectively.
Helps sales staff to close deals faster.
Makes call centers more efficient.
Simplifies marketing and sales processes.
Disadvantages of CRM
Some times record loss is a major problem.
Overhead costs.
Giving training to employees is an issue in small organizations.
12
Rules Oriented DSS − Procedures are adopted in rules oriented DSS. Export system is the
example.
Compound DSS − It is built by using two or more of the five structures explained above.
Types of DSS
Following are some typical DSSs −
Status Inquiry System − It helps in taking operational, management level, or middle level
management decisions, for example daily schedules of jobs to machines or machines to
operators.
Data Analysis System − It needs comparative analysis and makes use of formula or an
algorithm, for example cash flow analysis, inventory analysis etc.
Information Analysis System − In this system data is analyzed and the information report
is generated. For example, sales analysis, accounts receivable systems, market analysis
etc.
Accounting System − It keeps track of accounting and finance related information, for
example, final account, accounts receivables, accounts payables, etc. that keep track of the
major aspects of the business.
Model Based System − Simulation models or optimization models used for decision-
making are used infrequently and creates general guidelines for operation or management.
13
o Starting new lines of business
o Solving problems faster
o Developing professional skills
o Recruit and retain talent
15
Advantages of ESS
Easy for upper level executive to use
Ability to analyse trends
Augmentation of managers' leadership capabilities
Enhance personal thinking and decision-making
Contribution to strategic control flexibility
Enhance organizational competitiveness in the market place
Instruments of change
Increased executive time horizons.
Better reporting system
Improved mental model of business executive
Help improve consensus building and communication
Improve office automation
Reduce time for finding information
Early identification of company performance
Detail examination of critical success factor
Better understanding
Time management
Increased communication capacity and quality
Disadvantage of ESS
Functions are limited
Hard to quantify benefits
Executive may encounter information overload
System may become slow
Difficult to keep current data
May lead to less reliable and insecure data
Excessive cost for small company
16
Approaches of BIS
For most companies, it is not possible to implement a proactive business intelligence system at
one go. The following techniques and methodologies could be taken as approaches to BIS −
Improving reporting and analytical capabilities
Using scorecards and dashboards
Enterprise Reporting
On-line Analytical Processing (OLAP) Analysis
Advanced and Predictive Analysis
Alerts and Proactive Notification
Automated generation of reports with user subscriptions and "alerts" to problems and/or
opportunities.
Capabilities of BIS
Data Storage and Management −
o Data ware house
o Ad hoc analysis
o Data quality
o Data mining
Information Delivery
o Dashboard
o Collaboration /search
o Managed reporting
o Visualization
o Scorecard
Query, Reporting and Analysis
o Ad hoc Analysis
o Production reporting
o OLAP analysis
17
Uses application logic layers of different middleware systems as building blocks.
Keeps track of information related to the operations of the enterprise e.g. Inventory, sales
ledger and execute the core processes that create and manipulate this information.
18
Setting a recovery plan following a disruption to normal operating conditions.
Fulfilling legislative and regulatory requirements.
Traditionally a business continuity plan would just protect the data centre. With the advent of
technologies, the scope of a BCP includes all distributed operations, personnel, networks, power
and eventually all aspects of the IT environment.
Phases of BCP
The business continuity planning process involves recovery, continuation, and preservation of the
entire business operation, not just its technology component. It should include contingency plans
to protect all resources of the organization, e.g., human resource, financial resource and IT
infrastructure, against any mishap.
It has the following phases −
Project management & initiation
Business Impact Analysis (BIA)
Recovery strategies
Plan design & development
Testing, maintenance, awareness, training
Project Management and Initiation
This phase has the following sub-phases −
Establish need (risk analysis)
Get management support
Establish team (functional, technical, BCC - Business Continuity Coordinator)
Create work plan (scope, goals, methods, timeline)
Initial report to management
Obtain management approval to proceed
Business Impact Analysis
This phase is used to obtain formal agreement with senior management for each time-critical
business resource. This phase has the following sub-phases −
Deciding maximum tolerable downtime, also known as MAO (Maximum Allowable Outage)
Quantifying loss due to business outage (financial, extra cost of recovery, embarrassment),
without estimating the probability of kinds of incidents, it only quantifies the consequences
Choosing information gathering methods (surveys, interviews, software tools)
Selecting interviewees
Customizing questionnaire
Analysing information
Identifying time-critical business functions
Assigning MTDs
Ranking critical business functions by MTDs
Reporting recovery options
Obtaining management approval
Recovery Phase
This phase involves creating recovery strategies are based on MTDs, predefined and
management-approved. These strategies should address recovery of −
Business operations
Facilities & supplies
Users (workers and end-users)
Network
Data center (technical)
Data (off-site backups of data and applications)
BCP Development Phase
This phase involves creating detailed recovery plan that includes −
Business & service recovery plans
Maintenance plan
Awareness & training plan
19
Testing plan
The Sample Plan is divided into the following phases −
Initial disaster response
Resume critical business ops
Resume non-critical business ops
Restoration (return to primary site)
Interacting with external groups (customers, media, emergency responders)
Final Phase
The final phase is a continuously evolving process containing testing maintenance, and training.
The testing process generally follows procedures like structured walk-through, creating checklist,
simulation, parallel and full interruptions.
Maintenance involves −
Fixing problems found in testing
Implementing change management
Auditing and addressing audit findings
Annual review of plan
Training is an ongoing process and it should be made a part of the corporate standards and the
corporate culture.
20
Scope of SCM
SCM Processes
Customer Relationship Management
Customer Service Management
Demand Management
Customer Order Fulfilment
Manufacturing Flow Management
Procurement Management
Product Development and Commercialization
Returns Management
Advantages of SCM
SCM have multi-dimensional advantages −
To the suppliers −
o Help in giving clear-cut instruction
21
o Online data transfer reduce paper work
Inventory Economy −
o Low cost of handling inventory
o Low cost of stock outage by deciding optimum size of replenishment orders
o Achieve excellent logistical performance such as just in time
Distribution Point −
o Satisfied distributor and whole seller ensure that the right products reach the right
place at right time
o Clear business processes subject to fewer errors
o Easy accounting of stock and cost of stock
Channel Management −
o Reduce total number of transactions required to provide product assortment
o Organization is logically capable of performing customization requirements
Financial management −
o Low cost
o Realistic analysis
Operational performance −
o It involves delivery speed and consistency.
External customer −
o Conformance of product and services to their requirements
o Competitive prices
o Quality and reliability
o Delivery
o After sales services
To employees and internal customers −
o Teamwork and cooperation
o Efficient structure and system
o Quality work
o Delivery
22
Competitive Advantage, and Survival
Operational Excellence
This relates to achieving excellence in business in operations to achieve higher profitability. For
example, a consumer goods manufacturer may decide upon using a wide distribution network to
get maximum reach to the customers and exposure.
A manufacturing company may pursue a strategy of aggressive marketing and mass production.
New Products, Services, and Business Models
This is part of growth strategy of an organization. A new product or a new service introduced, with
a very fast growth potential provides a mean for steady growth business turnover.
With the help of information technology, a company might even opt for an entirely new business
model, which will allow it to establish, consolidate and maintain a leadership in the existing market
as well as provide a competitive edge in the industry.
For example, a company selling low priced detergent may opt for producing higher range
detergents for washing machines, washing soaps, and bath soaps.
It involves market strategies also that includes planning for distribution, advertisement, market
research and other related aspects.
23
The techniques used in information system planning are −
Critical Success Factor
Business System Planning
End/Mean Analysis
The requirement analysis part involves understanding the goals, processes and the constraints of
the system for which the information system is being designed.
It is basically an iterative process involving systematic investigation of the processes and
requirements. The analyst creates a blueprint of the entire system in minute details, using various
diagramming techniques like −
Data flow diagrams
Context diagrams
Requirement analysis has the following sub-processes −
Conducting preliminary investigation
Performing detailed analysis activities
Studying current system
Determining user requirements
Recommending a solution
Defining Requirements
The requirement analysis stage generally completes by creation of a 'Feasibility Report'. This
report contains −
A preamble
A goal statement
A brief description of the present system
Proposed alternatives in details
The feasibility report and the proposed alternatives help in preparing the costs and benefits study.
Based on the costs and benefits, and considering all problems that may be encountered due to
human, organizational or technological bottlenecks, the best alternative is chosen by the end-
users of the system.
Designing System Architecture
System design specifies how the system will accomplish this objective. System design consists of
both logical design and physical design activity, which produces 'system specification' satisfying
system requirements developed in the system analysis stage.
In this stage, the following documents are prepared −
Detailed specification
Hardware/software plan
Building or Developing the System
The most creative and challenging phase of the system life cycle is system design, which refers to
the technical specifications that will be applied in implementing the candidate system. It also
includes the construction of programmers and program testing.
It has the following stages −
Acquiring hardware and software, if necessary
Database design
Developing system processes
Coding and testing each module
The final report prior to implementation phase includes procedural flowcharts, record layout, report
layout and plan for implementing the candidate system. Information on personnel, money,
hardware, facility and their estimated cost must also be available. At this point projected cost must
be close to actual cost of implementation.
Testing the System
System testing requires a test plan that consists of several key activities and steps for programs,
strings, system, and user acceptance testing. The system performance criteria deals with
turnaround time, backup,file protection and the human factors.
Testing process focuses on both −
24
The internal logic of the system/software, ensuring that all statements have been tested;
The external functions, by conducting tests to find errors and ensuring that the defined input
will actually produce the required results.
In some cases, a 'parallel run' of the new system is performed, where both the current and the
proposed system are run in parallel for a specified time period and the current system is used to
validate the proposed system.
Deployment of the System
At this stage, system is put into production to be used by the end users. Sometime, we put system
into a Beta stage where users' feedback is received and based on the feedback, the system is
corrected or improved before a final release or official release of the system.
System Evaluation and Maintenance
Maintenance is necessary to eliminate the errors in the working system during its working life and
to tune the system to any variation in its working environment. Often small system deficiencies are
found, as system is brought into operation and changes are made to remove them. System
planner must always plan for resources availability to carry on these maintenance functions.
25
Once the organizational planning stage is over, the designer of the system should take the
following strategic decisions for the achievement of MIS goals and objectives −
Development Strategy − Example - an online, real-time batch.
System Development Strategy − Designer selects an approach to system development like
operational verses functional, accounting verses analysis.
Resources for the Development − Designer has to select resources. Resources can be in-
house verses external, customized or use of package.
Manpower Composition − The staffs should have analysts, and programmers.
Information system planning essentially involves −
Identification of the stage of information system in the organization.
Identification of the application of organizational IS.
Evolution of each of this application based on the established evolution criteria.
Establishing a priority ranking for these applications.
Determining the optimum architecture of IS for serving the top priority applications.
The following three methodologies can be adopted to determine the requirements in developing a
management information system for any organization −
Business Systems Planning (BSP) − this methodology is developed by IBM.
o It identifies the IS priorities of the organization and focuses on the way data is
maintained in the system.
o It uses data architecture supporting multiple applications.
o It defines data classes using different matrices to establish relationships among the
organization, its processes and data requirements.
Critical Success Factor (CSF) − this methodology is developed by John Rockart of MIT.
o It identifies the key business goals and strategies of each manager as well as that of
the business.
o Next, it looks for the critical success factors underlying these goals.
o Measure of CSF effectiveness becomes an input for defining the information system
requirements.
End/Means (E/M) analysis − this methodology is developed by Wetherbe and Davis at the
University of Minnesota.
26
o It determines the effectiveness criteria for outputs and efficiency criteria for the
processes generating the outputs.
o At first it identifies the outputs or services provided by the business processes.
o Then it describes the factors that make these outputs effective for the user.
o Finally it selects the information needed to evaluate the effectiveness of outputs
Information System Analysis and Design
System analysis and design follows the typical System/Software Design Life Cycle (SDLC) as
discussed in the previous chapter. It generally passes through the following phases −
Problem Definition
Feasibility Study
Systems Analysis
System Design
Detailed System Design
Implementation
Maintenance
In the analysis phase, the following techniques are commonly used −
Data flow diagrams (DFD)
Logic Modeling
Data Modeling
Rapid Application Development (RAD)
Object Oriented Analysis (OOA)
Technology for Information Systems
The technology requirement for an information system can be categorized as −
Devices
Data centre systems − It is the environment that provides processing, storage, networking,
management and the distribution of data within an enterprise.
Enterprise software − These are software system like ERP, SCM, Human Resource
Management, etc. that fulfil the needs and objectives of the organizations.
IT services − It refers to the implementation and management of quality IT services by IT
service providers through people, process and information technology. It often includes
various process improvement frameworks and methodologies like six sigma, TQM, and so
on.
Telecom services
System Test Planning and Execution
The system should be fully tested for errors before being fully operational.
The test plan should include for each test −
Purpose
Definition
test inputs
detailed specification of test procedure
details of expected outputs
Each sub-system and all their components should be tested using various test procedures and
data to ensure that each component is working as it is intended.
The testing must include the users of the system to identify errors as well as get the feedback.
System Operation
Before the system is in operation, the following issues should be taken care of −
Data security, backup and recovery;
Systems control;
Testing of the system to ensure that it works bug-free in all expected business situations;
The hardware and software used should be able to deliver the expected processing;
The system capacity and expected response time should be maintained;
The system should be well documented including;
o A user guide for inexperienced users,
27
o A user reference or operations manual for advanced users,
o A system reference manual describing system structures and architecture.
Once the system is fully operational, it should be maintained throughout its working life to resolve
any glitches or difficulties faced in operation and minor modifications might be made to overcome
such situations.
Factors for Success and Failure
MIS development projects are high-risk, high-return projects. Following could be stated as critical
factors for success and failure in MIS development −
It should cater to a specific, well-perceived business.
The top management should be completely convinced, able and willing to such a system.
Ideally there should be a patron or a sponsor for the system in the top management.
All users including managers and other employees should be made an integral part of the
development, implementation, and use of the system.
There should be an operational prototype of the system released as soon as possible, to
create interest among the users.
There should be good support staff with necessary technical, business, and interpersonal
skills.
The system should be simple, easy to understand without adding much complexity. It is a
best practice, not to add up an entity unless there is both a use and user for it.
It should be easy to use and navigate with high response time.
The implementation process should follow a definite goal and time.
All the users including the top management should be given proper training, so that they
have a good knowledge of the content and function of the system, and can use it fully for
various managerial activities such as reporting, budgeting, controlling, planning, monitoring,
etc.
It must produce useful outputs to be used by all managers.
The system should be well integrated into the management processes of planning,
decision-making, and monitoring.
28
Step 1 − Identification of the Purpose of the Decision
In this step, the problem is thoroughly analysed. There are a couple of questions one should ask
when it comes to identifying the purpose of the decision.
What exactly is the problem?
Why the problem should be solved?
Who are the affected parties of the problem?
Does the problem have a deadline or a specific time-line?
Step 2 − Information Gathering
A problem of an organization will have many stakeholders. In addition, there can be dozens of
factors involved and affected by the problem.
In the process of solving the problem, you will have to gather as much as information related to the
factors and stakeholders involved in the problem. For the process of information gathering, tools
such as 'Check Sheets' can be effectively used.
Step 3 − Principles for Judging the Alternatives
In this step, the baseline criteria for judging the alternatives should be set up. When it comes to
defining the criteria, organizational goals as well as the corporate culture should be taken into
consideration.
As an example, profit is one of the main concerns in every decision making process. Companies
usually do not make decisions that reduce profits, unless it is an exceptional case. Likewise,
baseline principles should be identified related to the problem in hand.
Step 4 − Brainstorm and Analyze the Choices
For this step, brainstorming to list down all the ideas is the best option. Before the idea generation
step, it is vital to understand the causes of the problem and prioritization of causes.
29
For this, you can make use of Cause-and-Effect diagrams and Pareto Chart tool. Cause-and-
Effect diagram helps you to identify all possible causes of the problem and Pareto chart helps you
to prioritize and identify the causes with the highest effect.
Then, you can move on generating all possible solutions (alternatives) for the problem in hand.
Step 5 − Evaluation of Alternatives
Use your judgment principles and decision-making criteria to evaluate each alternative. In this
step, experience and effectiveness of the judgment principles come into play. You need to
compare each alternative for their positives and negatives.
Step 6 − Select the Best Alternative
Once you go through from Step 1 to Step 5, this step is easy. In addition, the selection of the best
alternative is an informed decision since you have already followed a methodology to derive and
select the best alternative.
Step 7 − Execute the decision
Convert your decision into a plan or a sequence of activities. Execute your plan by yourself or with
the help of subordinates.
Step 8 − Evaluate the Results
Evaluate the outcome of your decision. See whether there is anything you should learn and then
correct in future decision making. This is one of the best practices that will improve your decision-
making skills.
Process and Modeling in Decision-Making
There are two basic models in decision-making −
Rational models
Normative model
The rational models are based on cognitive judgments and help in selecting the most logical and
sensible alternative. Examples of such models include - decision matrix analysis, Pugh matrix,
SWOT analysis, Pareto analysis and decision trees, selection matrix, etc.
A rational decision making model takes the following steps −
Identifying the problem,
Identifying the important criteria for the process and the result,
Considering all possible solutions,
Calculating the consequences of all solutions and comparing the probability of satisfying the
criteria,
Selecting the best option.
The normative model of decision-making considers constraints that may arise in making decisions,
such as time, complexity, uncertainty, and inadequacy of resources.
According to this model, decision-making is characterized by −
Limited information processing - A person can manage only a limited amount of information.
Judgmental heuristics - A person may use shortcuts to simplify the decision making
process.
Satisfying - A person may choose a solution that is just "good enough".
Dynamic Decision-Making
Dynamic decision-making (DDM) is synergetic decision-making involving interdependent systems,
in an environment that changes over time either due to the previous actions of the decision-maker
or due to events that are outside of the control of the decision-maker.
These decision-makings are more complex and real-time.
Dynamic decision-making involves observing how people used their experience to control the
system's dynamics and noting down the best decisions taken thereon.
Sensitivity Analysis
Sensitivity analysis is a technique used for distributing the uncertainty in the output of a
mathematical model or a system to different sources of uncertainty in its inputs.
From business decision perspective, the sensitivity analysis helps an analyst to identify cost
drivers as well as other quantities to make an informed decision. If a particular quantity has no
30
bearing on a decision or prediction, then the conditions relating to quantity could be eliminated,
thus simplifying the decision making process.
Sensitivity analysis also helps in some other situations, like −
Resource optimization
Future data collections
Identifying critical assumptions
To optimize the tolerance of manufactured parts
Static and Dynamic Models
Static models:
Show the value of various attributes in a balanced system.
Work best in static systems.
Do not take into consideration the time-based variances.
Do not work well in real-time systems however, it may work in a dynamic system being in
equilibrium
Involve less data.
Are easy to analyze.
Produce faster results.
Dynamic models −
Consider the change in data values over time.
Consider effect of system behavior over time.
Re-calculate equations as time changes.
Can be applied only in dynamic systems.
Simulation Techniques
Simulation is a technique that imitates the operation of a real-world process or system over time.
Simulation techniques can be used to assist management decision making, where analytical
methods are either not available or cannot be applied.
Some of the typical business problem areas where simulation techniques are used are −
Inventory control
Queuing problem
Production planning
Operations Research Techniques
Operational Research (OR) includes a wide range of problem-solving techniques involving various
advanced analytical models and methods applied. It helps in efficient and improved decision-
making.
It encompasses techniques such as simulation, mathematical optimization, queuing theory,
stochastic-process models, econometric methods, data envelopment analysis, neural networks,
expert systems, decision analysis, and the analytic hierarchy process.
OR techniques describe a system by constructing its mathematical models.
Heuristic Programming
Heuristic programming refers to a branch of artificial intelligence. It consists of programs that are
self-learning in nature.
However, these programs are not optimal in nature, as they are experience-based techniques for
problem solving.
Most basic heuristic programs would be based on pure 'trial-error' methods.
Heuristics take a 'guess' approach to problem solving, yielding a 'good enough' answer, rather
than finding a 'best possible' solution.
Group Decision-Making
In group decision-making, various individuals in a group take part in collaborative decision-making.
Group Decision Support System (GDSS) is a decision support system that provides support in
decision making by a group of people. It facilitates the free flow and exchange of ideas and
information among the group members. Decisions are made with a higher degree of consensus
and agreement resulting in a dramatically higher likelihood of implementation.
Following are the available types of computer based GDSSs −
31
Decision Network − This type helps the participants to communicate with each other
through a network or through a central database. Application software may use commonly
shared models to provide support.
Decision Room − Participants are located at one place, i.e. the decision room. The
purpose of this is to enhance participant's interactions and decision-making within a fixed
period of time using a facilitator.
Teleconferencing − Groups are composed of members or sub groups that are
geographically dispersed; teleconferencing provides interactive connection between two or
more decision rooms. This interaction will involve transmission of computerized and audio
visual information.
32
The IEEE Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct
IEEE code of ethics demands that every professional vouch to commit themselves to the highest
ethical and professional conduct and agree −
To accept responsibility in making decisions consistent with the safety, health and welfare
of the public, and to disclose promptly factors that might endanger the public or the
environment;
To avoid real or perceived conflicts of interest whenever possible, and to disclose them to
affected parties when they do exist;
To be honest and realistic in stating claims or estimates based on available data;
To reject bribery in all its forms;
To improve the understanding of technology, its appropriate application, and potential
consequences;
To maintain and improve our technical competence and to undertake technological tasks
for others only if qualified by training or experience, or after full disclosure of pertinent
limitations;
To seek, accept, and offer honest criticism of technical work, to acknowledge and correct
errors, and to credit properly the contributions of others;
To treat fairly all persons regardless of such factors as race, religion, gender, disability, age,
or national origin;
To avoid injuring others, their property, reputation, or employment by false or malicious
action;
To assist colleagues and co-workers in their professional development and to support them
in following this code of ethics.
33