Experimental and Numerical Thermal Analy
Experimental and Numerical Thermal Analy
Research Article
JOURNAL OF
Engineering Science and
Technology Review
www.jestr.org
Experimental and Numerical Thermal Analysis of Formula Student Racing Car Disc
Brake Design
Manthan Vidiya1,* and Balbir Singh2
1
Department of Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering Manipal Institute of Technology, Manipal University, Manipal, 576104
INDIA.
2
Department of Aeronautical and Automobile Engineering, Manipal institute of Technology, Manipal University, Manipal, 576104 INDIA.
Abstract
Formula racing car brakes undergo massive loading not only mechanical, but thermal as well. There are various
problems that occur due to brake assembly components reaching very high temperatures such as brake fade, induction of
thermal stresses and chances of thermo-mechanical fatigue of components taking the braking loads. Hence analyzing the
brake components for thermal loads becomes very important. This paper deals with the theory behind thermal analysis of
the brake, the method used to calculate the conversion of the car’s kinetic energy to the brake’s heat energy, to find the
convection coefficient available due to the air flow on the car and to determine the overall temperature rise on the brake
disc. This paper shows simulations conducted in various software and the data as well as the graphs obtained from these
simulations. Similar type of data and graphs are obtained from the actual testing with the use of various sensors mounted
on the car. In the end there is a comparison made between the simulation and the data obtained from the car’s testing to
verify the method used for its accuracy and reliability.
Keywords: Formula Student Car; Operating Temperature; Brake Performance; ANSYS; Brake Fade; Convection Coefficient.
__________________________________________________________________________________________
• It should provide a surface having well anti wear The brake disc used on the car was made from stainless
qualities. steel 410 and had a diameter of 170 mm and a PCD of 90
• It should allow the optimum rate of heat transfer. mm for mounting on the wheel hub. Stainless steel was used
• Heat is generated at every cycle of brake as disc material due to advantages described in [12].The
application and must be dissipated to the Disc weighed 360 grams and was of a drilled type to ensure
atmosphere. maximum heat dissipation by the air. It is completely
• Sufficient strength and minimum weight. designed and manufactured by the vehicle dynamics team of
• It must be accommodate within the minimum MIT, Manipal. Fig. 2 shows the 2D draft and 3D render of
space available. the designed brake disc. The brake disc has teeth on its
circumference to be used to measure the wheel RPM using
the Hall Effect sensor.
2. Background Theory described an equation to calculate the heat input on the brake
disc. It states that heat flux on the rotor is equal to the
The equations used in this paper along with their relative friction force due to braking times the change in velocity of
theories are given below. For calculating the working the disc produced due to braking.
temperature of the brake, it is important to understand that the
basic function of brakes is to convert the kinetic energy of the 𝐻 = 𝐹! ×∆𝑣 (2)
car into heat energy through friction [5]. This kinetic energy
is not entirely sent to the brakes but also lost due to friction The friction force generated can be calculated using the
between parts, wear and tear of parts, drag etc. Since it is equation given by Saeed Abu Alyazeed Albatlan [12] and
difficult to calculate the kinetic energy loss in the vehicle and Swapnil R. Abhang, D.P.Bhaskar [13].
the actual energy being transmitted to the brakes, we can find
the heat generated at the brakes with another equation. Since 𝐹! = 𝜇! ×𝐴! ×𝑝𝑟×𝑛 (3)
we know
The heat is generated on the brake pad and disc contact.
𝑃𝑜𝑤𝑒𝑟 = 𝐹𝑜𝑟𝑐𝑒× 𝑐ℎ𝑎𝑛𝑔𝑒 𝑖𝑛 𝑣𝑒𝑙𝑜𝑐𝑖𝑡𝑦 (1) Faramarz Talati, Salman Jalalifar [8] have shown how the
heat is distributed on the pad surface.The heat distribution
We can use this principle on the rotor and pad contact between the brake pad and disc depends upon the surface
patch. L. Kowal, K. Turewicz and T. Kruczek [7] have area as well as the material properties of both the
139
Manthan Vidiya and Balbir Singh/Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 10 (1) (2017) 138 - 147
components. When the contact is taken into account the heat Temperature rise of the components depends directly on
partition coefficient is given by: the heat absorbed by the component. For brake disc, hence
the temperature rise (ΔT) is given by
!! !! !! ×!!
𝑝= (4) !! !!!"#$%!&'"# ! !!"#$"%$&'
!! !! !! ×!! ! !! !! !! ×!!
(𝛥𝑇)! = (9)
!! ×!!
140
Manthan Vidiya and Balbir Singh/Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 10 (1) (2017) 138 - 147
141
Manthan Vidiya and Balbir Singh/Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 10 (1) (2017) 138 - 147
142
Manthan Vidiya and Balbir Singh/Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 10 (1) (2017) 138 - 147
The brake assembly was fitted with three sensors namely Myrio data logger mounted on the car with motec ECU. Hall
Texense infrared temperature sensor on the disc to measure Effect sensors uses the teeth on the brake disc which creates
the brake disc temperature, Honeywell hall effect sensor to spikes in the output signal of the sensors. This is processed
measure wheel RPM and brake pressure sensors to log the by measuring the amount of spikes per unit time and the
changes in brake pressures. Fig. 10 shows the mounting of RPM is found out.
these sensors on the car. These sensors were logged using
143
Manthan Vidiya and Balbir Singh/Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 10 (1) (2017) 138 - 147
4. Results convection coefficient vs. velocity of the car was plotted for
the car running on the test track. Sofia Finnved and
4.1 Convection coefficient on the rotor Sebastian Nöbbelin [20] has shown that the convection
The flow around the wheels was simulated with the coeffiecient varies linearly with the car velocity.We
boundary conditions given in sub heading 3.3. The calculated the convection coefficient when the car is
convection coefficient is determined as a wall function. The standing still to be 5.15 W/m2K. Hence we could plot a
maximum convection coefficient of 243.5 W/m2K was straight line showing the variation of convection coefficient
observed on the disk at vehicle speed of 13.89 m/s. This was with velocity. Fig. 11 shows the airflow on the car and the
obtained from a plot on the rotor and will be used to disc and Fig. 12 shows the variation of convection
calculate the heat dissipated by the rotor. The plot of coefficient with car velocity.
144
Manthan Vidiya and Balbir Singh/Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 10 (1) (2017) 138 - 147
4.3 Temperature obtained from Testing The car specification such as weight, power, torque, height
The temperature obtained from the testing with the sensors of center of gravity etc., are given as input in a lap time
on the car was carefully analyzed. The data was plotted as a simulation software called as Optimum Lap. This software
graph to see the variation of temperature during the test and simulates the car on the endurance race track and gives car
compare with the temperature graph obtained from velocity and deceleration as output in the required time
simulation in ANSYS. The maximum temperature reached steps. Fig. 17 shows the endurance track used in Formula
by the brake disc was 62.3 degree. The temperature went to student Germany event.
increase with every braking application. The variation was
bit rough as the brake disc was of drilled type and the sensor This data can be used to calculate the heat input on the
read the holes as drop in temperature. Fig. 15 shows the rotor using the method mentioned above in this paper and
variation of temperature during the testing of the car. the temperature variation can be obtained for 8 laps of the
endurance race track. The variation of temperature observed
from this simulation is given in Fig. 18. Hence it can be
deduced from Fig. 18 that the working temperature of the
brakes is 300 to 500 degree Celsius for the endurance race
track.
145
Manthan Vidiya and Balbir Singh/Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 10 (1) (2017) 138 - 147
Acknowledgement
Fig. 18. Variation of temperature for 8 laps of endurance track I would like to acknowledge Manipal Institute of
Technology for their constant support during this research. I
would also like to thank Formula Manipal for the
7. Conclusion and Application knowledge, motivation, prototype car and instruments they
have provided for this research. This research wouldn’t have
We have used the velocity of the car to determine the heat been complete without the help of my college and team
generated due to braking and taken into account various mates.
factors that affect the net heat generation and dissipation
from the brake disc. Thus we have determined the This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the
temperature rise in the brake disc and have found a working Creative Commons Attribution Licence
temperature range of the brakes. This method of finding the
operating temperature of the brakes can be used for many
purposes. As by knowing the operating temperature of the
brakes in advance one can decide on the material used to
_____________________________
References
1. Gowtham.S, Manas M Bhat, “Elimination of Brake Fade in 11. Mr. Pengkam kenglang lungchan, Mr. Parag deshattiwar, Mr.
Vehicles by Altering the Brake Disc Size (A Kahani menjo, Mr. Toshif ruikar, Mr. Sanjeet kumar, “A
Concept)”,International Journal of Innovative Research in Science, PROJECT ON ‘THERMAL ANALYSIS OF BRAKE DISC”,
Engineering and Technology,Vol. 4, Issue 11, November 2015, Btech Project Department of Mechanical Engineering Government
DOI:10.15680/IJIRSET.2015.0411093 College of Engineering, Aurangabad (2014-2015).
2. Rakesh Jaiswal, Anupam Raj Jha, Anush Karki, Debayan Das, 12. Saeed Abu Alyazeed Albatlan, “Study Effect of Pads shapes on
Pawan Jaiswal, Saurav Rajgadia and Ankit Basnet, Temperature Distribution for Disc Brake Contact
“STRUCTURAL AND THERMAL ANALYSIS OF DISC Surface”,International Journal of Engineering Research and
BRAKE USING SOLIDWORKS and ANSYS”, International Development e-ISSN: 2278-067X, p-ISSN: 2278-800X,
Journal of Mechanical Engineering and Technology (IJMET) www.ijerd.com Volume 8, Issue 9 (September 2013), PP. 62-67-
Volume 7, Issue 1, Jan-Feb 2016, pp. 67-77, Article ID: 62
IJMET_07_01_008. 13. Swapnil R. Abhang, D.P.Bhaskar, “Design and Analysis of Disc
3. Pradnya Kosbe, Chittaranjan More, “Characterization of Fade and Brake”, International Journal of Engineering Trends and
Recovery Behavior of Brake Friction Technology (IJETT) – Volume 8 Number 4- Feb 2014
Material”,INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON CURRENT 14. Ali Belhocine, Mostefa Bouchetara, “Investigation of temperature
TRENDS IN TECHNOLOGY, ‘NUiCONE – 2011’ and thermal stress in ventilated disc brake based on 3D
4. Mr. Sachin Subhashrao Pujari Prof. Mr. K. M. Narkar,Mr. Kishor thermomechanical coupling mode”, Ain Shams Engineering
T. Phalke, “Structural Analysis and Thermal Analysis of Journal, Volume 4, Issue 3, September 2013
Automotive Ventilated Brake Disc”, IJSRD - International Journal 15. Arthur Stephens,”Aerodynamic Cooling of Automotive Disc
for Scientific Research & Development| Vol. 2, Issue 03, 2014 | Brakes”,Msc Thesis, School of Aerospace, Mechanical &
ISSN (online): 2321-0613. Manufacturing Engineering RMIT University,March 2006.
5. Shah E Alam, Yuvraj Vidhyadhar, Prashant Sharma, Abhishek Jain, 16. Adam Adamowicz, Piotr Grzes, “Analysis of disc brake
“Thermal Analysis of disc Brakes Rotor: A comparative Report”, temperature distribution during single braking under non-
Journal of Information Sciences and Computing Technologies axisymmetric load”, Applied Thermal Engineering, Elsevier,
(JISCT) ISSN: 2394-9066, Volume 3, Issue 2, April 20, 2015. 2011, 31 (6-7), pp.1003.
6. Manjunath T V, Dr Suresh P M, “Structural and Thermal Analysis 17. A. belhocine, C.D.Cho, M.Nouby, Y.B.Yi, A. R. Abu Bakar,
of Rotor Disc of Disc Brake”, International Journal of Innovative “Thermal analysis of both ventilated and full disc brake rotors
Research in Science, Engineering and Technology,Vol. 2, Issue with frictional heat generation”, Applied and Computational
12, December 2013,ISSN: 2319-8753. Mechanics 8 (2014) 5-24.
7. L. Kowal, K. Turewicz and T. Kruczek, “Measurements of 18. Guru Murthy Nathi, T N Charyulu, K.Gowtham, P Satish Reddy,
temperature of brake disks in hoisting machines of mine shaft “COUPLED STRUCTUAL / THERMAL ANALYSIS OF DISC
hoists”, 11th International Conference on Quantitative Infrared BRAKE”, IJRET: International Journal of Research in
Thermography, 11-14 June 2012, Naples Italy. Engineering and Technology,ISSN: 2319-1163,Volume: 01 Issue:
8. Faramarz Talati, Salman Jalalifar, “Analysis of heat conduction in a 04 | Dec-2012
disk brake system”, Heat Mass Transfer (2009) 45:1047–1059 19. Ishwar Gupta, Gaurav Saxena, Vikas Modi, “Thermal Analysis Of
DOI 10.1007/s00231-009-0476-y Rotor Disc Of Disc Brake Of Baja Sae 2013 Car Through Finite
9. Er.N.B.Shinde, Prof.B.R.Borkar, “C.A.D &F.E.M analysis of disc Element Analysis”, International Journal of Engineering Research
brake system”, International Journal of Engineering and Computer and Applications (IJERA) ISSN: 2248-9622.
Science ISSN: 2319-7242. 20. Sofia finnved, Sebastian Nöbbelin, “Temperature Estimation in
10. Subhasis Sarkar, Prof. (Dr.) Pravin P. Rathod, “Review Paper on Trailer Disc Brake”, MSc Thesis ISRN LUTFD2/TFRT--5966--
Thermal Analysis of Ventilated Disc Brake by Varying Design SE ISSN 0280-5316, Department of Automatic Control Lund
Parameters”, International Journal of Engineering Research & University
Technology (IJERT) ISSN: 2278-0181, Vol. 2 Issue 12, December
– 2013
146
Manthan Vidiya and Balbir Singh/Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 10 (1) (2017) 138 - 147
Nomenclature
𝐻 Heat input to the brakes.
𝑝 Heat partition coefficient between the brake Disc and brake pad.
𝐻! Heat input to the pad.
𝑘! Thermal conductivity of the pad.
𝜌! Density of the disc.
𝜌! Density of the pad.
𝑐! Specific heat of the disc.
𝑐! Specific heat of the pad.
𝑆! Frictional contact area of the disc.
𝑆! Frictional contact area of the pad.
𝐻! Heat input to the disc.
𝐻!"#$%!&'"# Heat loss due to convection.
𝐻!"#$"%$&' Heat loss due to radiation.
𝐴 Surface area of the disc.
∆𝑇 Difference in temperature of the disc and surrounding air.
𝑚! Mass of the brake pad.
𝑚! Mass of the brake disc.
𝜎 Stefan Boltzmann constant.
∆𝑣 Change in tangential velocity of Disc
𝐹! Friction force on the Disc.
ℎ Convection Coefficient due to airflow
𝜇! Coefficient of friction between brake pad and disc
𝐴! Area of caliper piston
𝑝𝑟 Pressure developed in the brake line
𝑛 Number of pistons in brake caliper
147