Carboxylic Acids

When a carbonyl carbon also bears a hydroxyl group, then these compounds are appreciably acidic, and are called
carboxylic acids.
O
R C O-H RCO2H RCOOH

Carboxylic acids are classified according to the substituent that is bonded to the carboxyl carbon:

Aliphatic acids have an alkyl group bound to the carboxyl group.

An aromatic acid has an aryl group bound to the carboxyl group.

The simplest acid is formic acid.

A carboxylic acid donates protons by the heterolytic cleavage of the O-H bond, generating a carboxylate ion.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 1

 Nomenclature
IUPAC formulation
The root name is based on the longest continuous chain of carbon atoms bearing the carboxyl group.

The -e is replaced by -oic acid.

The chain is numbered starting with the carboxyl carbon atom.

The carboxyl group takes priority over any other functional groups previously discussed.
E.g.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 2

Unsaturated acids are named using the name of the alkene with -e replaced with -oic acid.

The chain is numbered starting with the carboxyl group, and a number designates the location of the multiple bond
(and may include Z or E).
E.g.

Cycloalkanes with carboxyl substituents are named as cycloalkanecarboxylic acids.

E.g.

(Notice that -CO2H as a substituent makes the carbon it is bound to C-1, not itself).

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 3

Typically aromatic acids of the form Ar-CO2H are named as derivatives of benzoic acids, with ortho, meta and
para indicating the location relative to the carboxyl group. (Recall that this is non-IUPAC).

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 4

Dicarboxylic Acids
Aliphatic dicarboxylic acids are named by simply adding the suffix -dioic acid to the root name.

The root name comes from the longest carbon chain containing both carboxyl groups.

Numbering starts at the end closest to a substituent.

E.g.

Structure of the Carboxyl Group

The most stable conformation of formic acid is an almost planar arrangement of the molecule.

The carbon is sp2 hybridized, and the O-H bond lies in the plane described by the sp2 carbon, eclipsing the C=O
double bond.

This unexpected geometric arrangement can be explained by resonance (or conjugation).

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 5

Three resonance forms can be written for formic acid.

The second structure requires the C-O-H bonds to be co-planar.

One of the unshared lone pairs of oxygen is delocalized into the electrophilic  system of the carbonyl group.

(One of the lone pairs on the hydroxyl oxygen is conjugated with the C=O double bond).

Acidity
Carboxylic acids can dissociate in aqueous solution into carboxylate ions and protons.

The equilibrium constant for this process is Ka, and more frequently we talk in terms of pKa.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 6

Values of pKa for common alkyl carboxylic acids are around 5 (Ka ~ 10-5).

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 7

E.g. ethanoic acid has pKa = 4.74, (alcohols have pKa ~ 16, so carboxylic acids are about 1011 times more acidic
than alcohols).

The reason why carboxylic acids are much more acidic than alcohols is because the carboxylate anion is much
more stable than the alkoxide anion.

Both alcohols and carboxylic acids are acidic since their respective O-H bonds can be broken heterolytically,
giving a proton and an oxygen anion.

The difference lies in the fact that the carboxylate anion has the negative charge spread out over two oxygen atoms,
whereas the alkoxide has the negative charge localized on a single oxygen atom.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 8

The carboxylate anion can be viewed as a resonance hybrid of the two anionic structures, or as a conjugated
system of three interacting p orbitals containing four electrons (like the allylic anion system).

The C and two oxygens are all sp2 hybridized, and the remaining p orbitals create the  MO system giving rise to
the half  bond between each C and O, and the half negative charge on the end oxygens.

Dicarboxylic Acids
These have two dissociation constants, since they can lose two protons.

Ka1 for the first dissociation, and Ka2 for the second dissociation (which generates a dianion).
Ka2 is always less than Ka1 (the second carboxyl group is less acidic) since it takes extra energy to overcome the
second negative charge being so close to the first negative charge.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 9

Substituent Effects on Acidity
Any substituent that stabilizes a negative charge is going to enhance the dissociation process, and therefore result
in a stronger acid.

Thus electronegative elements can enhance the acid strength, through inductive effects.

E.g.

The closer the substituent to the anion, the more profound the effect.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 10

Salts of carboxylic Acids
Strong bases can completely deprotonate carboxylic acids, thus salts of carboxylic acids are formed.

E.g.

The acid can be regenerated by protonation (acidification) of the salt.

E.g.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 11

 Syntheses of Carboxylic Acids

The previously seen syntheses (three) all involved oxidation:

(a) oxidation of primary alcohols and aldehydes.
(b) oxidative cleavage of alkenes and alkynes.
(c) side chain oxidation of alkyl benzenes.

Oxidation of Primary Alcohols and Aldehydes

These oxidations are best performed using chromic acid (made from Na2Cr2O7 and H2SO4).
Potassium permanganate can be used but gives lower yields.

E.g.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 12

Cleavage of Alkynes and Alkenes
Alkenes react with concentrated KmnO4 to produce intermediate glycols which react further to produce either
carboxylic acids or ketones (depending on the original alkene substituents).
E.g.

Alkynes also react with conc. KMnO4 to give carboxylic acids, and the same transformation can be achieved by the
use of ozonolysis.

E.g.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 13

Alkylbenzenes
Benzoic acid derivatives can be made by the oxidation of alkylbenzenes with either hot KMnO4 or hot chromic
acid.

The vigorous conditions means this can only be used when there are no oxidizable groups present in the molecule.

E.g.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 14

 New methods

Carboxylation of Grignard Reagents

Grignard reagents can react as nucleophiles and attack carbon dioxide.

This results in magnesium salts of carboxylic acids, and treatment with dilute acid produces a carboxylic acid.

The overall transformation is from alkyl halide to a carboxylic acid with an extra carbon atom.

E.g.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 15

Formation and Hydrolysis of Nitriles
Nitriles can be hydrolyzed by dilute acid to generate carboxylic acids.

E.g.

Nitriles are easily made by the action of cyanide ion as a nucleophile on alkyl halides (or tosylates).

Again the overall transformation is from alkyl halide to a carboxylic acid with an extra carbon atom.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 16

Reactions of Carboxylic Acids (and Derivatives)
Ketones and aldehydes have a carbonyl group and undergo nucleophilic addition, whereas carboxylic acids (and
their derivatives) undergo nucleophilic acyl substitution - this is where one nucleophile replaces a leaving group on
the acyl carbon.

E.g.

Carboxylic acid derivatives differ in the nature of the group bound to the acyl group.

-OH is an acid
-Cl is the acid chloride
-OCOR' is the anhydride
-OR' is the ester
-NR2 is the amide

Nucleophilic acyl substitution can interconvert all of these different acid derivatives.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 17

The mechanism for nucleophilic acyl substitution varies depending if it occurs under acidic or basic conditions
(similar to acid and base varieties of nucleophilic addition to aldehydes/ketones).

Under basic conditions, a strong nucleophile can attack the carbonyl carbon, thus generating a tetrahedral
intermediate.

This intermediate can then expel its leaving group.

E.g. the above ester hydrolysis to a carboxylic acid.

Under acidic conditions, the carbonyl group becomes protonated, and thus activated toward nucleophilic acyl
substitution.

Then attack by a weak nucleophile generates the tetrahedral intermediate.

The leaving group (often in its protonated form) is then expelled (often as a neutral molecule). (See next slide).

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 18

The Fischer Esterification
Recall that acid and alcohol  ester and water

The overall transformation is that the -OH of an acid is replaced by the -OR' of an alcohol.

E.g.

The Fischer esterification is an example of acid catalyzed nucleophilic acyl substitution.

The carbonyl group of a carboxylic acid is not sufficiently electrophilic to be attacked by the alcohol.

The acid catalyst protonates the carbonyl oxygen, and activates it toward nucleophilic attack.

The alcohol attacks, and after deprotonation of the alcohol oxygen, the hydrate of an ester is formed.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 19

The ester is produced via acid catalyzed dehydration of the ester hydrate.
As usual, the hydroxyl oxygen is protonated, thus creating a good leaving group.

This leaves with assistance from the neighboring hydroxyl oxygen.

The cation remaining is resonance stabilized, and deprotonation yields the desired ester.

The overall mechanism is quite long, but both steps have been seen before (acid catalyzed addition to a carbonyl;
acid catalyzed dehydration), and so should not be viewed as difficult, or as new work to learn.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 20

Esterification reactions such as this one are equilibrium reactions, and the equilibrium normally will lie to the left.

Keq = 3.4, so this would be a good case.

To drive the reaction to completion we can either use an excess of one of the reagents, or remove one of the
products.

Often it is the water produced which is removed by a dehydrating agent such as MgSO4, or molecular sieves.

A simpler (yet more expensive) way to make esters in the laboratory (not industrially) is to react an alcohol with an
acid chloride.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 21

Synthesis of Acid Chlorides
Both the carbonyl oxygen and the chlorine are electron withdrawing, and thus make the carbonyl carbon very
electrophilic.

Therefore acid chlorides are very reactive with nucleophiles, usually through the nucleophilic acyl substitution
mechanism.

The best way to make acid chlorides is the reaction of a carboxylic acid with either thionyl chloride (SOCl2) or
(COCl)2, which is called oxalyl chloride.

E.g.

Both these methods are good since they generate gaseous by-products, and thus do not contaminate the acid
chloride product.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 22

The mechanism of formation of acid chloride is similar to the reaction of alcohols with thionyl chloride.

The lone pair of the acid carbonyl oxygen attacks the electrophilic sulfur (sulfur analogue of an acid chloride), and
chloride is expelled from the tetrahedral intermediate.

Deprotonation yields a chlorosulfite anhydride.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 23

The liberated chloride ion now attacks the electrophilic carbon of the mixed anhydride.

This tetrahedral intermediate then expels the leaving group which fragments into SO2 and chloride ion.

Acid chlorides react with alcohols to give esters through a nucleophilic acyl substitution by the addition
elimination mechanism.

The overall transformation of this two step scheme is a carboxylic acid is converted into an acid chloride, then into
an ester.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 24

The acid chloride to ester transformation is standard nucleophilic acyl substitution.

Ammonia and amines react with acid chlorides to give amides, also through this addition-elimination version of
nucleophilic acyl substitution.

E.g.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 25

Esterification using Diazomethane
The addition of an ethereal solution of diazomethane smoothly converts carboxylic acids to their methyl esters.

The only by-product is nitrogen gas.

E.g.

Diazomethane is a toxic, explosive yellow gas that dissolves in ether, and requires special glassware.

The mechanism involves the deprotonation of the hydroxyl oxygen, which generates a methyldiazonium salt, which
is a potent methylating agent.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 26

The carboxylate anion becomes methylated, thus generating the methyl ester, and nitrogen gas is evolved.

Condensations of Acids with Amines ( Amides)

Although the acid chloride/amine reaction generates amides, it is also possible (and cheaper) to synthesize amides
directly from carboxylic acids.

The direct reaction of an amine and a carboxylic acid initially forms a carboxylate anion and an ammonium cation.

Normally the reaction would stop at this point since the carboxylate anion is a poor electrophile, but by heating the
reaction to over 100°C, the water can be driven off as steam, and amide products are formed.

E.g.

This is an important commercial process.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 27

Reduction of Carboxylic Acids
Lithium aluminum hydride reduces carboxylic acids back to primary alcohols.

The reaction proceeds through an aldehyde but it cannot be stopped at that stage since aldehydes are more easily
reduced than carboxylic acids.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 28

Carboxylic acids are also reduced by borane (BH3) to generate primary alcohols.

This reaction has good selectivity since the carboxyl group reacts faster than any other carbonyl derivative.

Therefore carboxylic acids can be reduced in the presence of ketone functionalities using borane.

Reduction to Aldehydes
(We have seen this before, Ch18). The carboxylic acid must first be converted into a group more easily reduced
than an aldehyde.

The reactive acid derivative is the acid chloride, and the mild reducing agent is lithium aluminum
tri(tbutoxy)hydride.

E.g.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 29

Alkylation of Carboxylic Acids ( Ketones)
(Also seen this before, Ch18). A general method to form ketones is the reaction of a carboxylic acid with two
equivalents of organolithium reagent.

E.g.

The first equivalent just deprotonates the carboxylic acid, and then the second performs a nucleophilic attack to
generate a dianion.

On acid hydrolysis a ketone hydrate is formed, which loses water (H2O) to yield the ketone.

Ch20 Carboxylic Acids (landscape).docx Page 30

 CARBOXYLIC ACIDS

Acid
Factors: (a) Resonance (e.g. RCO2¯ vs. RO¯)
Strength
(b) Electron Withdrawing Groups (Number and Location)

Carboxylic Acid AJR Summary