Thesis
Thesis
B.Ed.
“I hereby declare that I have read this thesis and is my opinion this thesis is sufficient in terms of scope
and quality for the award of the degree of B.Ed.”
Signature: ______________________________
Name of Supervisor:
Date
Signature: ______________________________
Name of Supervisor:
Date
Declaration
I ___________ student of B.Ed. (1.5 Years) at University of Education, Lahore due here by solemnly
declare that the research project entitled “Effect of Teachers Stress on Attitude towards Teaching
Secondary Level” comprises of original research work. Its contents have not already been submitted in
full or partial for the requirements of any other degree and is our currently being submitted for any
other degree or qualification and to the best of my knowledge and belief, neither does this thesis
contain any material published or written previously by another person, except whom due reference is
made to the source in the text of the thesis.
Signature:
Name of Supervisor:
Date:
PLAGARISM UNDERTAKING:
I solemnly declare that research work presented in the thesis entitled “Effects of Teachers Stress on
Attitude towards Teaching at Secondary Level” is solely my research work with no significant
contribution from any other person. Small contribution wherever taken has been dully acknowledged
and that complete thesis has been written by me.
I understand the zero tolerance policy of HEC and University of Education, Lahore towards. Therefore, I
as an Author of the above titled thesis declare that no portion of my thesis has been plagiarized and any
material used as reference is properly referred. Plagiarism
I undertake that if I am found guilty of any formal plagiarism in the above titled thesis even after award
of the B.Ed. degree, the University reserves that rights to withdraw my B.Ed. degree and that HEC and
the University has the right to publish any name of the HEC/University website on which name of
students are places show submitted plagiarized thesis.
Signature:
Name of Supervisor:
Date:
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
All praise and thanks to the Gracious the Greatest Lord "Almighty ALLAH" who blessed me with courage
and made my efforts faithful, who best owed upon me with potential and ability to contribute a little
material to existing knowledge.
I pray all the tributes to the Holly Prophet Hazrat Muhammad (S.A.W) who enlightened our conscious,
who is Torch of guidance and knowledge for humanity, all and every respect is for the Holly Prophet
Hazrat Muhammad (S.A.W) who enables us to recognize our creator.
Research work is a wonderful opportunity for polishing various facts of student personality. This is a kind
of experience which incorporates professionalism & confidence in them.
I was fortunate enough that I was the part of group in which PhD Scholar created a family like
environment with her brilliant sense of humor. My heartiest greeting for my friends.
Chapter Page
1.
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background of the Study
1.2 Statement of the Problem
13 Research Objectives
1.4 Research Questions
1.5 Significance of the Study
1.6 Scope and Limitations of the Study
1-7 Delimination of Study
1.8 Research Methodology
1.8.1 Population
1.8.2 Sampling Technique
1.8.3 Sample
1.8.4 Research Instrument
1.8.5 Data Collection
1.8.6 Data Analysis
1.9 Operational Definition(s)
2. . REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
2.1 Stress
2.2 Teachers' Stress
2.3 Workplace Stress
2.4 Theories of Stress
2.5 Models of Teacher Stress
2.5.1 Demand Control Model
2.5.2 Functional Communication Model
2.5.3 Stress Coping Strain Model
2.5.4 Beehr and Newman's Facet Model Person Environment Fit Model
2.5.5 Person Environment Fit Model
2.6 Causes of Stress
2.7 Effect of Stress on Psychological and physical Health
2.8 Prevalence of Teacher Stress
2.9 Perspective on Teacher Stress
2.10 Attitude
2.11 Teacher's Attitude
2.12 Previous studies about Teacher's stress on Gender basis
3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1 Research Design
3.2 Population
3.3 Sample & Sampling Technique
3.4 Instrumentation
3.5 Validity and Reliability of Instrument
3.6 Data Collection
3.7 Data Analysis
4. DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION
5. SUMMARY, FINDINGS, CONCLUSION AND
RECOMMENDATIONS
5.1 Summary
5.2 Findings
5.2.1 Teacher's Stress
5.2.2 Attitude Towards Teaching
5.2.3 Effect of Teacher's stress on Attitude towards
Teaching at Secondary Level
5.3 Discussion
5.3.1 Teachers' Stress
5.3.2 Teacher's Attitude
5.4 Conclusions
5.6 Recommendations
Bibliography
LIST OF TABLES
Table No. Title Page No.
INTRODUCTION
There has been an increasing demand for more robust academic experiences and
effective learning at all levels of education, particularly at the secondary and higher education
levels in Pakistan (Akrum et al, 2011). The success of any educational system depends on good
and well-resourced teachers. Teachers cannot be replaced with any other kind of instructional
material. It is a reality that teachers are the best in the entire educational system. Therefore,
teachers are considered the most important and fundamental factor for the success of any
educational system. A teacher is more than what is commonly talked about as his duties of
profession have many other dimensions (Deen, 2000).
The effective and successful learning depends upon the quality of teaching which
demands academically competent individuals who care about the well-being of children and
youth. Sarital and Tomer (2004) considered teaching is one of the most influential and powerful
profession in society. Teachers are the lifeblood of any education system. School place, books,
and classrooms are ineffective and meaningless without teachers. Primary school teachers are
playing a vital and crucial role at secondary school level. If a secondary school teacher
succeeded in shaping sound base in science subjects to the students than it is right to say that
they will become able to make atomic bomb. Therefore, it is justified to say that secondary
school teachers possess the most crucial position in the entire system of education. The future
success of the students depends upon the effectiveness of the teaching performance of the
teachers at secondary level (Suleman, et al. 2011).
These factors may be monotony, change of technology, excessive work load, job
security, agronomy, management problems (Cooper and Davidson, 1987. Kyriacou (1997)
observes that, due to variation between countries and national education systems, there are
differences in the main sources of teacher stress (Ibid.: 30). He also observes that job satisfaction
is a complex issue in that 'even in the context of feeling overloaded, taking on additional duties
in a valued area of work need not create more stress, and may indeed enhance job satisfaction'
(Ibid.: 30). Stress has both beneficial and harmful impacts on individuals (Behere et al.
2011;Burnard et al. 2007). As a beneficial impact, stress is able to force us towards achievement
(Behereet al. 2011). Selye (1976) called this impact 'eustress'. As a harmful impact, literature
reveals that stress has negative effects that might be classified into three groups: physical
manifestations, such as headache and infections; psychological manifestations, such as anger,
low self-respect and anxiety; and behavioral manifestations, such as weight loss, smoking and
drinking (Arnold & Boggs 2006). Roney and Cohon, (2001) called these stresses as emotional
stresses, these stresses include; time stress, the pressure of something before a certain time,
anticipatory stress, worry and dread about in depending events, situational stress, fear of finding
one's self in a situation posing threat, loss of control or loss of status in the eyes of others.
In fact the United Nations has commented that occupational stress "The 20th
century disease" (Krohe, 2001). The value of research published in sense of teacher stress has
indicated that it is the number one health problem amongst the teachers (Fimian &Fastenau, 1990).
According to Fimian (1984) the occupational stress experienced by teachers is actually a multiple factor
construct and these factors are significantly related to one another. In both literature and common usage
of the term "work stress" it is apparent that certain things cause stress and that this stress when it does
occur, because evident in terms of any number of physiological, behavioral and other types of
"symptoms". It should probably be easy to locate one array of events that act as source of stress and
another of events that act as manifestations of stress. Moreover the teacher stress is concerned with a
number of work job and organizational variables in terms of both predicted directions and magnitudes
(Fimian, 1982).
The topic under study was "Effect of Teacher's stress on attitude towards teaching at secondary
level"
The aim of this study was to analyze the effect of teachers stress on attitude toward teaching of
Schools in Pakistan by using appropriate model".
The purpose of this study was to gain awareness about the classroom effective teaching
strategies, the teachers stress on attitude toward the teaching and compare the different teaching styles
used in secondary schools. The research will provide insight to determine the effectiveness of the
strategies used secondary schools level. This study will help the teaching in improving their classroom
management Strategies which ultimately increase the achievement level of the students.
This research was unable to bring light on some of the more hidden problems in teaching
activity methods, including factors such as environmental issues and socio- economics issue and socio-
cultural issues as well. The current study will be beneficial for teachers, head teachers and educationists.
1. The data was collected from both male and female government schools
There were different research method, tools and techniques used in research
but in this study simple quantitative research methodology was use. All research methods and
techniques that was used in this study are given below.
Research Design
1.8.1 Population
The target population can be defined as the collection of objects of elements that
comprises the same properties or features which is required by the researcher. Here the
population encompassed Secondary schools of city Samundari, District Faisalabad Pakistan.
Data were taken from the teachers to check the effect of teachers stress on attitude toward the
teaching at secondary level and its' effect on students' academic performance and achievements
at secondary level.
Due to time and cost constraint, it was hard to collect data from the whole
population. So, sampling method is important to gather data from the small set of
population. In this study the sampling frame were five male and five female public schools as
well as five private schools' city Samundari, District Faisalabad, Pakistan The data were
collected from the teachers of selected schools. Two types of probability kinds i.e. Probability
sampling and Non- Probability sampling are commonly med techniques. "In probability
sampling, there is an equal chance of random selection of respondents however in non-
probability sampling no chance of selection". This study. there was stratified random sampling
used because it was very difficult to generate complete list of all schools and teachers and of
whole District, in very short time to use probability sampling. The sample size of this study were
100 respondents in which 50 teachers were male teachers and 50 were female teachers of
secondary Schools due to the easily availability of the data.
1.8.3 Sample
Sample of the study was taken from secondary schools of Tehsil Samundri
District Faisalabad.
For the current study teachers stress Questionnaire was used to find out he
teacher's stress level at secondary school and to find out teachers attitude towards teaching
questionnaire of teachers attitude was used.
1.8.5 Data Collection
Diverse types of techniques can be used by to collect data i.e. surveys, interviews,
observation, questionnaire and proxies. In this research, the researcher was use the secondary
data to check the effect of teachers stress on attitude toward teaching at secondary schools. The
important information were collected through questionnaire. To get the opinion of the teachers of
both male and female Public schools, a questionnaire was developed. Furthermore, data was
collected from different articles, Research papers, Specialized International Journals, internet and
from previous studies.
There are different sources of data collection like scales, proxies, and questions.
In this study the researcher used appropriate research tools and software to analysis of data, like;
SPSS software analysis in which descriptive test was used to find out the frequency, percentage,
means and minimum/maximum values etc. Difference on the basis of gender was explored
through test.
2.1 Stress
Stress is a complex concept. The word stress is derived from the Latin word
"Stringere. Mosley, Megginson and Pietri, (2001) defined stress as any stimulus which causes
wear and tear externally in an individual. This means that stress is tension or worry which starts
from life events; and life events are part and parcel of stress. According to Jepson (2006)
generally stress is a term used for pressure that people exposed to in ones' life. Stress is usually
considered to be effect or response to a stimulus Jenkins & Calhoun (1991). The proper
understanding and origination of "stress" comes from the empirical study of Derogatis (1987),
who made his research work on the basis of Derogatis stress profile (DSP), a psychological
questionnaire. Lazares (1966) gave social interaction theory of stress, Lazarus and Foakman
(1984) describe it as a particular interaction between man and environment. There are many
definitions of stress in the literature and there is some controversy over the nomenclature as to
whether the term stress, stressor, or strain should be used to define various aspects of stress
(Thatcher & Miller, 2003). Buunk, Young, Ybema & Wollf (1998) identify three broad
theoretical approaches to stress which may determine the ways in which the term can be used.
Different classes of appreciation to literature review explain it as affects an individual event or
situation and potentially in other words, as it is harmful" - some ideas are basically dealing with
stress as a trigger which showed existence (Lazarus, 1984; Mc Grath, that the 1976 Cox,
1978).Stress has also been based on three types of theories i.e. stimulus, response-oriented and
distributed transactional and interactional theories (Coyne Lazarus; & Holroyed; Stotland
Sarafino, cited in 1990). The stimulus oriented theory identifies stress as driving the pressure
stimulus approach based on strain identified environment as a factor that causes a stress reaction
in one person.
These theories explain the stress as the chaotic environment see the stress aspects
which increase in their ideology and biology to a possible extent where peace and live demands
upon the provided stimulation by the environment or by imposing stress on him/her (; Lazarus &
Folkman, 1984 Cox, 1978) .We see this approach focuses on the environment. An event or
"source of distress as a set of conditions - such as having a high stress job," or see the cause of
the people. We stress that the events or circumstances referred to by creating feelings of stress, is
the news as threatening or harmful. Researchers, who studied the effects of a wide range of
stress, said that the following key events such as loss of a loved one or a job cause stress.
2.2 Teacher's Stress
Kyriacou (1997), states that national education systems due to variations, there
may be observed differences in teacher stress (30: Ibid) sees that even the main source of a
complex problem in job satisfaction, additional duties in a significant area of bar may increase in
the context of the need to create more pressure, and I feel job satisfaction "(30: Ibid.) the tensions
of individuals concerned and error both of these effects (Behere et al. 2011; Burnard et al. 2007).
As a beneficial effect, the stress is able to compel us towards success (. Behereet al 2011). Selye
(1976) found its impact as a harmful effect called 'eustress', and the literature suggests that the
negative effects that stress can be divided into three groups: physical manifestations such as
headaches and infections; psychological such as anger, little respect manifestations of self and
anxiety, and weight loss, smoking and drinking behavior manifestations, such as cited by
(Arnold & Boggs 2006). Roney and Cohon, (2001) called these stresses as emotional stresses,
these stresses include; time stress, the pressure of something before a certain time, anticipatory
stress, worry and dread about independing events, situational stress, fear of finding one's self in a
situation posing threat, loss of control or loss of status in the eyes of others. In fact the United
Nations has labeled occupational stress "The 20 century disease" (Krohe, 2001). The wealth of
research published on teacher stress has indicated that it is the number one health problem
amongst the teachers (Fimian &Fastenau, 1990). In the present study we have followed Fimian
teacher stress model (Fimian, 1984). This model explain the teacher stress in a ten factor theory,
five factors purees of work stress and five factors explain the manifestations of stress these ten
factors comprise stress in teachers. According to Fimian (1984) the occupational stress
experienced by teachers is actually a multiple factor construct and these factors are significantly
related to one another.
In both literature and common usage of the term "work stress" it is apparent that
certain things cause stress and that this stress when it does occur, because evident in terms of any
number of physiological, behavioral and other types of "symptoms". It should probably be easy
to locate one array of events that act as source of stress and another of events that act as
manifestations of stress. Moreover the teacher stress is concerned with a number of work job and
organizational variables in terms of both predicted directions and magnitudes (Fimian, 1982).
Stress has been viewed in three ways, stimulus, response and process. The first
way, stimulus refers to stress which can originate from three sources, catastrophic events such as
earth quakes, major life events.
He feels physically strenuous physical arousals, stomach tight and start to sweat
when the mouth gets dry. Psychological component of behavior, emotions and thought patterns
is a sense of panic. Third way, which is based on following a series of reactions to stress and
adjustment between man and environment i.e. their interaction and the adjustment of the
transaction. Stress effects of a stressor by the person that behavioral, cognitive and emotional
strategies (Coyne, 1990). Stress is seen as a processing agent that can influence an individual.
Usually stress the ideas of the three categories, based catalyst, is response oriented and
distributed transactional theories. Trigger-based approach focuses on aspects of the environment
caused by a reaction to a person exposed to stimuli. Based on the theory, that stress is a response
focused on reactions to stressful stimuli.
Interactional theories accentuate the organism as the main intermediary between
the atmosphere trigger mechanism features. This is a process that adds an important dimension
that involves not only the stressor as stress and strains of the human environment (Lazarus,
1984). Industry experts are the main causes of social division of labor, industrial relations and
politics in the interest of institutional power structures conflict occupational disease and stress
(Patterson, 1994).
Occupational stress is a systemic transactional must state that in which the
approach advocated organizing ideas, this situation is the personality that is damaged or rational
context unrelated to the environmental conditions of these negative other.
The event is a basic need unique solutions, ranging from the - from - it has to be
resolved with the Special Cases. The principle of the social system has been developed several
theories of occupational stress (Bacharach, 1991).
Strong force that may show signs of stress in response to a theory that the stress
exerted on a structure as dynamic equilibrium theory. Wearing Heart (1993) suggested that
dynamic equilibrium theory. According to this view, the stress of a demanding, approach or is
not defined as a process, rejection that arises occurs as the balance condition. People may
respond to positive and negative impact on the environment (Diner, 1985).
Hart and Waring's (1994) argued stable personality characteristics and dynamic
personality characteristics psychological distress and well-being often professional stress cope
with change are used interchangeably in the literature. although levels and working hard together
the interplay between experience and account. This approach has been noted that the more
psychological distress and moral dimensions as separate and independent features work life
partner. That is, positive experiences and negative moral impact on work experiences impact on
psychological distress. This suggests that it could be improved by increasing the negative
experiences of ethical work.
Demand control model (Karask, 1979) is related to the combined effects of job
demands and job control over the welfare of workers. Work load demands, job hazards, role
conflict, are divided into physical and emotional demands.
Administrative control refers to the results of control, mastery of discretion,
monitor, judge, and the complexity of the demand and control dimensions of ideological control.
Jobs, high pressure jobs, jobs, active, passive jobs are classified into four categories
(Landsbergis, 1992). General psychological distress reduce / control combinations in high
demand (Karasek, 1990). The control sense can also be connected to the control and self-
awareness (Frone, 1989) the locus of personality factors; (Kivimaki, 1995). Hall (1993), supports
component-wide model to include a co-worker and supervisor social support. Social support has
positive effects on well- being and psychological distress (Karasek, 1990) on occupational stress
buffer effect.
This model was given by Toohy in 1995. In this model Toohey (1995) stated that
safe dissatisfaction is sick behavior at work and pain is assessed as acceptable ways to
communicate can be expressed through it. How attached claims compensation for any discomfort
expressed particular both mental illness and general workers in this way in the context of a work
the social stigma either safe or as is acceptable is certainly controversial.
The deal models to cope with stress and Osipow Spokane. A key feature of this
model gives a lot of power for the first model. This model thus job stress, work with the
resources available to deal with the effects of concentrated stress and tension are three separate
but related domains. This model is observed in any occupation worker may take on a variety of
social roles, which can cause stress (Osipow, 1983).
Beehr and Newman (1978) can be broken down into a number of aspects of the
study of variable types that represent the proposed occupational stress. The first aspect refers to
the demographic characteristics and personality that stable to bring with them at work like
personal aspect employees. The second aspect is the work environment like the work and the
collaborative nature of the employment relationship. The third aspect is the process that refers to
the interaction between the characteristics of the situation. This is a point where a person
perceives stress or harm to the environment. The final aspect of the stressor in the environment
aspect is shown to the thought process.
Sely (1976) defines stressors as the agents or demands that evoke patterned
response. Feelings, love, hate, joy, anger, challenge, with the change of the stress syndrome
thinking with fear as the phone features. Researchers considers an increasing number of events
and conditions to be stressors. Most of the efforts are in still in qualitative domain. According to
Lazarus & Launir (1978) formulation and cognitive appraisal of stressors play a major role in the
transaction between the person and the potentially stressful environment. Quick (1984) the work-
related stress factors. These are the demands of the job, doing boring repetitive work, having too
little to do, having too much to do in too little time, responsibilities, feeling confused about how
everyone fits in, having responsibility for looking after other, poor relationship with others,
balancing work and home, inflexible work schedules, working condition and management
attitudes. In an organization many factors lead to stress that can be from person's external
environment apart from the organization. Some occupations have characteristics that make them
more stressful that other.
Every day we encounter with stress and most of stress comes and goes without
leaving any enduring imprints, but when stress is severe and pile up the demands then one's
psychological functioning may affected. Effects of stress can include hard concentrating,
difficulty in decision making, being short tempered, feeling tired most of the time, sleeping
badly, use of drugs, feeling that one achieved nothing at the end of the day. If stress is prolonged,
it can lead to poor mental health, heart diseases, high blood pressure, back pain, gastrointestinal
problem and various minor illness (French & Caplan, 1982).
During the last 25 years there has been increasing professional and public interest
in issues related to occupational stress and health. The suspects, especially in wellness education,
health and interest, began to focus on those employed within the service. Teachers have been
popular target for such research (Dunham's, 1984).
Over recent years, the problem of teacher stress has received increasing recognition (Borg,
1990). The wealth of research published on teacher stress over the last 20 years, has indicated
that most teachers experience some stress from time to time, and that some teachers experience a
great deal of stress fairly frequently (Boyle, 1995; Cooper, 1996). Kyriacou (1978) or it is very
stressful teachers considered their work as a result of extreme pressure derivative. The results of
these four studies showed that it was related to the tradition of biographical characteristics of the
surface tension and teachers. Winkinson (1988) study suggested that teaching is a profession
where practitioners are subjected to high incidence of potentially stressful situations. Nattrass
(1991) defines teacher stress as the number one health problem. In several surveys results have
revealed that up to one third of teachers regard teaching as highly stressful (Solman, 1989;
Spooner, 1994). Also numerous studies have been reported that have been looked at particular
subgroups of teachers: primary and secondary school teachers (Chaplain, 1995; new qualified
teachers, head teachers (Cooper, 1993; Friedman, 2000) all show higher level of stress in
teachers. One using a variety of measures (behavioral, physiological, behavioral, and medical)
high-stress professions of teaching that compare teachers with other professional occupations
indicate Sciences (Health Education Authority, 1988). All the above studies show that teacher
stress experts undoubtedly has become an area of great interest to academics and researchers.
However, it is recognized that a number of factors make the hard work of good teachers that
pressure. There is no widely accepted objective measure of stress, because the goal is made all
the shortcomings and limitations of the target, have been using a variety of measures is difficult
to evaluate teacher stress limit.
2.11 Attitude
Attitude is one of the main indicator of behavior when we checking the one's
behavior. Our social perception and behaves both are affected by amitade. Amitade forms one's
thoughts, feelings and behavior about a psychological object (Kagicbasi 1000) Attitude is a
statement either positive or negative. Amtade explains how a person feels about something
(Robbins 1994) Opinion beliefs and values are influenced on attitude. Attitude and opinion both
look similar to each other but they are different in measurement technique and generalization.
Opinion shows one's personal reaction against a certain event while attitude shows one's personal
behavior against a different events. When a person wishes to express his knowledge, he express
it by its behavior and attitudes (Eren, 2000).
Several studies of teachers' stress on the basis of gender were conducted. A study
by Jick &Mitz (1985) reveal that research under the demographic variable of gender has great
importance and interest. According to Fontana & Abouserie (1993) there is no significant
difference between male and female teachers' level of stress. Similarly some past studies carried
out in 1995, 2000, 2001 and 2005 point out a small difference of level of stress among male
teachers and their female counterparts. According to Milczarek et al., (2009) male teachers
experience a little bit more stress about (23%) than Females (20% ) . A recent study by Rubina,
Sadaf, & Mosood (2011) showed that the stress level can be better predicted with male and
female school teaches. It further conclude that teachers at male schools show more stress with
compare to female teachers, it means that there is a significant difference between male and
female teachers. The same result came out from the study by Sunbul & Sari (2002); Chaplin
(1995); Brown & Ralph (2002) further they reported that higher level stress in men were found
in teaching occupation.
Another study by Eris & Atanasoska (2011) found that female teachers has less
stress due to their flexible and soft personality than their male counterparts. Teachers' stress and
teachers' burnout was high in male teachers while the female teachers have spent all of their duty
time with easiness (Ravichandran & Rajandran, 2007; Bhadoria & Singh, 2010).
Vogale et al. (1997) reported that females show low level reaction in stressful
situations because of their nerviness while males experience high level of stress in the crucial
events. A socio-biologist Wilson (1997) argued that female teachers are lovely, caring and
faithful to every one having good interest in working place comfortably while their male
counterparts not show such characteristics. It was also said that females naturally have idea how
to survive in stressful situations on the other hand males have tough and hard idea toward life
(Goldberg, 1979). Chaplaine (1995) is of the view that it is interesting to know that on basis of
experience and qualification the females are dominated on men, so they have more satisfaction
about teaching than males. A study in Canada by macmillian (1999) reported that in secondary
schools about 2000 teachers were surveyed and result showed that female teachers are more
confident and satisfied with their important role of teaching as compared to their male
counterparts.
CHAPTER 3
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.2 Population
The target population can be defined as the collection of objects of elements that comprises the
same properties or features which is required by the researcher. Here the population
encompassed Secondary schools of city Samundari, District Faisalabad Pakistan. Data was taken
from the teachers to check the effect of teachers stress on attitude toward the teaching at
secondary level and its' effect on students' academic performance and achievements at secondary
level
3.3 Sample & Sampling Technique
All male and female secondary schools teachers of tehsil Samundri District
Faisalabad were selected as a sample of the study.
Table 3.1
Male Female
The above table shows teachers of the sample in the study. Due to time and cost
constraint, it was hard to collect data from the whole population. So, sampling method is
important to gather data from the small set of population. In this study the sampling frame were
five male and five female public secondary schools of city Samundari, District Faisalabad,
Pakistan. The data will be collected from the teachers of selected schools. Two types of
probability kinds i.e. Probability sampling and Non- Probability sampling are commonly used
techniques. "In probability sampling, there is an equal chance of random selection of respondents
however in non-probability sampling no chance of selection". This study, there we stratified
random sampling used because it was very difficult to generate complete list of all schools and
teachers and of whole District, in very short time to use probability sampling. The sample size of
this study was 100 respondents in which 50 male teachers and 50 female teachers of Public
secondary Schools of tehsil Samundari District Faisalabad due to the easily availability of the
data.
3.4 Instrumentation
It was a quantitative study, so for obtaining results two questionnaire were used
one was teachers stress and the other was teachers attitude the questionnaire
used in this study are as follows.
To find out teachers stress level, questionnaire of teachers stress was used. In this
questionnaire six subscales were also used to find out teachers stress level both in male
and female teachers. These subscales were Time Management, Work-Related Stressors,
Professional Distress, Discipline and Motivation, Professional Investment and Emotional
Manifestations. Thirty four questions were included in this questionnaire.
To find out attitude of teachers of both male and female schools,a questionnaire of
teachers attitude was developed.
Table3.2
Diverse types of techniques can be used by to collect data i.e. surveys, interviews,
observation, questionnaire and proxies. In this research, the study was use the secondary data to
check the effect of teachers stress on attitude toward teaching at secondary schools. The
important information was collected through questionnaire. To get the opinion of the teachers of
both male and female Public schools, a questionnaire was developed. Furthermore, data was
collected from different articles, Research papers, Specialized International Journals, internet and
from previous
studies.
First of all the entire data was analyzed. Then it was correctly coded. SPSS software was used
for obtaining results. By using this software researcher analyzed the two variables. The next step
was to calculate the Frequency distribution, SD and mean. In this study data was collected from
both male and female schools of tehsil Samundari, so to find out difference of male and female
teacher's results t-test was used.
CHAPTER 4
This chapter contains analysis and descriptions of the data. The intention of the
study was to find out the "effect of teachers stress on attitude towards teaching at secondary
level". The data was collected from male and female teachers of public schools of tehsil
Samundri, district Faisalabad of the province of Punjab. Data obtained through questionnaires
i.e. "Teachers Stress Questionnaire?, and "Attitude towards Teaching Scale" were analyzed by
using Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 21. The two questionnaires were
analyzed one by one and then interpreted in the light of the statistical results. Gender differences
were determined through t-test on teachers stress scale, then on Attitude towards teaching Finally
regression was used to investigate possible effect of the one variable on the other. The analysis
and interpretation of the data is given below.
Table 4.1
Demographic Characteristics of respondents
Respondents N Percentage
Male 50 50%
Female 50 50%
Gender N Mean SD df t p
P<0.05
The above table reflects that t value (-11.55) with df (98) was significant at
p<0.05. It shows that female respondents (M=48.24, SD=16.771) have higher scores on teachers
stress than the male respondents (M=46.43, SD=15.575) which indicate that males and females
had significant difference regarding teachers stress scale.
Table 4.3
Gender N Mean SD df t p
P<0.05
The above table reflects that t value (4.988) with df (98) was significant at P<0.05. It shows that
females respondents (M=49.24, SD=16.574) have higher scores on attitude towards teaching
than the male respondents (M=47.43, SD=16.771) which indicate that males and females had
significant difference regarding “attitude towards teaching”
Table 4.4
Effect of teachers stress on attitude towards teaching at secondary level Gender basis.
Respondents N R
Male 50 .348*
Female 50 .390*
The effect of teachers stress and attitude towards teaching for all the respondents
was analyzed and a correlation coefficient of r- 366 (p>0.01) was measured. It shows that a
negative and significant effect between teachers stress and attitude towards teaching exists. For
male respondents a correlation coefficient of r 348 (p>0.01) and for female respondents r-.390
(p>0.01) was measured which shows that an opposite and significant effect exists between
teachers stress and attitude towards teaching.
CHAPTER 5
This chapter presents the summary of the study, describes findings on the basis of
data analysis; states conclusions drawn from the findings and discusses its
recommendations.
5.1 Summary
The major approach adopted to conduct the study was quantitative.. It was a
survey type study. The researcher's intentions regarding this research were to investigate the
effect of teachers' stress on attitude towards teaching at secondary level. Hence, the research
design was causal comparative in nature. The population of the study consisted of all male and
female teachers of secondary schools of Tehsil Samundri.
To collect the data from such a population. So, convenient sampling technique
was applied to draw the sample of Secondary level teachers from all public secondary schools
situated in the Tehsil Samundri. Teachers were selected from secondary public schools.
The findings of the study are presented keeping in view the order of objectives of
the study in two areas which are teachers stress, attitude towards teaching.
1. The mean score for the female respondents (M-48.24) have higher scores on
"Teachers Stress Questionnaire" than the male respondents (M-46.43).
1. The mean score of total attitude towards teaching for the female respondents
(M-49.25) have higher scores on attitude towards teaching than the male respondents
(M=47.43) Analysis shows that there is found significant difference in male and female
respondents regarding "teachers attitude".
5.3 Discussion
The main aim of the study was to find out the effect of teachers' stress on students'
academic self-efficacy and motivation towards leaning. In Pakistani culture and context, this
study was believed to explore the ideal results. So finding of the current study will add new
knowledge in the field of education. The findings regarding the effect of teachers' stress on
students' academic self-efficacy and motivation towards learning are given below;
According to the data analysis, there was found no significant difference between
the stress level of male and female secondary level teachers. The conclusion was supported by
several studies. A study by Jick&Mitz (1985) revealed that research under the demographic
variable of gender has great importance and interest. According to Fontana & Abouserie (1993)
there is no significant difference between male and female teachers' level of stress. Similarly
some past studies carried out in 1995, 2000. 2001 and 2005 point out a small difference of level
of stress among male teachers and their female counterparts. According to Milczarek et al.,
(2009) male teachers experience a little bit more stress about (23%) than Females (20% ). A
recent study by Rubina, Sadaf, &Mosood (2011) showed that the stress level can be better
predicted with male and female school teaches. It further conclude that teachers at male schools
show more stress with compare to female teachers, it means that there is a significant difference
between male and female teachers. The same result came out from the study by Sunbul& Sari
(2002); Chaplin (1995); Brown & Ralph (2002) further they reported that higher level stress in
men were found in teaching occupation.
Another study by Eris & Atanasoska (2011) found that female teachers has less
stress due to their flexible and soft personality than their male counterparts. Teachers' stress and
teachers' burnout was high in male teachers while the female teachers have spent all of their duty
time with easiness (Ravichandran & Rajandran, 2007; Bhadoria
& Singh, 2010).
Vogale et al. (1997) reported that females show low level reaction in stressful
situations because of their nerviness while males experience high level of stress in the crucial
events. A socio-biologist Wilson (1997) argued that female teachers are lovely. caring and
faithful to everyone having good interest in working place comfortably while their male
counterparts not show such characteristics. It was also said that females naturally have idea how
to survive in stressful situations on the other hand males have tough and hard idea toward life
(Goldberg, 1979). Chaplainc (1995) is of the view that it is interesting to know that on basis of
experience and qualification the females are dominated on men, so they have more satisfaction
about teaching than males. A study in Canada by macmillian (1999) reported that in secondary
schools about 2000 teachers were surveyed and result showed that female teachers are more
confident and satisfied with their important role of teaching as compared to their male
counterparts.
Attitudinal outcomes are correlated with factors of teachers stress. It proves that
teachers stress has strong impact on teacher's attitude.
1. Findings support that attitude towards teaching and teachers stress has negative
correlation with each other..
5.4 Conclusions
Following conclusions were drawn on the basis of findings:
The male and female respondents reflected significant differences on teachers
stress scale..
The mean score of female respondents reveals that they take less stress than
male respondents.
It is evident from the findings that the male and female respondents showed
significant differences on attitude towards teaching.
Female respondents showed more optimistic and positive attitude towards
teaching than male respondents.
Effect of teacher's stress on attitude towards teaching at secondary level .
The concepts of teacher's attitude and stress are closely related with each
other. As suggested by Lazarus in his cognitive model of stress, It isamong
various personal beliefs that are crucial when it comes to the evaluation of
environmental demands. In evaluating the external demands, they are
observed as "threat" or a "challenge." People having stress feel these demands
as threats while those having less stress consider as a challenge (Zahra, 2010).
So it can be observed that there is a strong relationship between attitude and
stress. Different researchers have their vital point of views regarding these two
variables. (Windle & Windle, 1996). Most of the researchers have agreed on
the point of view that in stressful situations, attitude of teachers become
negative. The other aspect for this says that with the consisting increasing
levels of stress, in an individual, a healthy sense of attitude is gone with the
passing days. (Zautra & Reich, 1993). A number of researches reveal that
male teachers show less stress level as compared to female teachers (Schunk,
2002). The impact of teacher stress on attitude on the basis of gender has been
analyzed in the present study. For determining the difference between male
and female teachers with respect to teachers stress on attitude, sample t-test
was applied. The results of the study gave the clear idea regarding significant
connection between stress and attitude of teachers on the basis of gender.
5.5 Recommendations
1. Teachers' stress is a crucial issue which has great effect on their attitude. Teachers
should join professional organizations for recognition to reduce stress.
2. Teachers may also choose physical exercise to improve physical health and their
attitude as well as work related stress
3. Teachers should adjusting their time management strategies to overcome stress.
4. The school administrator should appreciate the school staff to creating a
pleasant environment favorable to teaching, learning process.
5. Government should revise the pay scales of teachers according to their
qualification.
6. Government should take measures to enhance job satisfaction for better outputs.
7. The higher authorities should less down the extra workload other than teaching
for better results.