Guidelines For The Feasibility Study of Solar Mini Grid Projects 1654685783
Guidelines For The Feasibility Study of Solar Mini Grid Projects 1654685783
June 2022
Published by:
The following people have provided valuable contribution to prepare this guideline
Jiwan Kumar Mallik, Dipesh Shrestha, Dr. Madhusudhan Adhikari, Khem Raj Bhandari, Dr. Anusuya Joshi, Dr. Narayan
Prasad Adhikari, Nagesh Singh, Nawaraj Dhakal, Santosh Rai, Dr. Laxman Prasad Ghimire, Chaitanya Prakash Chaudhary,
Satish Gautam, Shiva Hari Budhathoki, Sunita Khatiwada, Muhan Maskey, Srijana Shrestha
Recommended Citation:
The use of this document must be acknowledged using a citation which would include: - Alternative Energy Promotion
Centre (AEPC) Nepal, Guidelines for The Feasibility Study of Solar Mini Grid Projects 2022.
List of Figures
Figure 1: Solar radiation components resulting from interactions with the atmosphere 10
(Source: NREL)
Figure 6: DC Coupled 22
Figure 10: Temperature dependence of solar cell, Credit Canadian solar (source: Canadian solar) 28
Figure 12: Small fixed modular system with four layers with concrete foundation (Source: Italy 31
Grid System)
Figure 14: Solar tracking system in a field in La Calahorra, Granada, Spain (Source: Encyclopedia) 34
Figure 19: Battery and Battery Inverter Connection in an AC coupled system (credit SMA) 43
Figure 21: Earthing and Lighting Protection System of Mini Grid Systems 47
Table 7: Sizes and designations of ACSR conductors used in mini grid schemes 56
Table 10: Minimum Clearances between live wires and structures or trees. 57
Table 19: Environmental Impacts of large scale solar PV and Wind project 77
REFERENCES 85
ANNEX 1- DEMAND ASSESSMENT SURVEY FORM 87
ANNEX 2- BILL OF QUANTITY- SAMPLE 93
ANNEX 3 - GLOSSARY 96
ANNEX 4 - WIND GLOSSARY 104
Executive Summary
In the context of Nepal, solar and solar-wind This Guideline also identifies the key planning and
hybrid mini grids are one of the most innovative strategic aspects of solar energy development
technologies deployed to provide energy access in Nepal. It provides guidelines for site selection,
to rural and isolated communities, and meet their demand assessment, renewable resource
development needs. In 2011, the first solar-wind assessment, design considerations, uses of
hybrid mini grid of 12 kW installed capacity (10 simulation software, environment and social impact
kW wind + 2 kW solar PV) was implemented in assessment, cost estimation, and financial analysis
Dhaubadi village of Nawalparasi district. By 2021, used by the Alternative Energy Promotion Centre
65 solar and solar-wind hybrid mini grids with a (AEPC) while designing solar mini grid systems.
cumulative installed capacity of 2697 kW were in Nonetheless, the document is not intended to
operation serving more than 8,600 rural households address every circumstance and consideration such
and powering around 6050 rural enterprises. that it may not be relevant to every project. Rather,
Subsequently, to further maximize the positive this Guideline endeavors to be a blueprint document
socio-economic impact of installed solar mini grids, for development of solar mini grid projects in Nepal
the Government of Nepal has launched the “Mini with consideration of the major design principles and
Grid Special Programme” in 2019 with ambitious the country context.
targets that will ultimately contribute to the
Government’s target of Electricity for All by 2023.
4 Control-Power House
4.1 Lights 5 5 25 6 1.00 150
Total for Control-Power House 25 150
Coincidence load factor is usability or availability the power, energy and safety requirements of not
of devices. For example, S.N. 1.1 in the table above only the households but also productive energy
has a coincidence load factor of 85% for main uses (PEUs) and community energy uses (CEUs).
room lights, which means only 85% of installed The daily load curves of these three types of energy
main room lights for 50 households shall be used usage shall be graphed and the “Combined Load
on an average on any particular day. Similarly, S.N. Curve” will help accurately determine the peak power
1.4 has a coincidence load factor of 5% for radio, sizing (kWp), storage (kWh) and energy demand and
which means 5% of total households shall be using generation matching (kWh) for a 24-hour cycle.
radio in the community at an instant. Such demand
analysis tools should be used to accurately estimate
3.1. SOLAR RESOURCE Note: To convert MJ/m² to kWh/m² (or PSH), divide
ASSESSMENT the number of MJ/m² by 3.6
Absorbed
Direct
For all solar mini grid projects to be implemented Satellite-derived data can offer a wide geographical
through AEPC should have a GHI value more than coverage and can often be obtained retrospectively
4kWh/m² per day. for historical periods in which no ground-based
measurements were taken. This is especially useful
3.3.4. Global Tilted Irradiation (GTI) for assessing long term averages. A combination
of analytical, numerical and empirical methods
GTI is the total energy received on a unit are of can offer 15 minutes data with a nominal spatial
surface with defined tilt and azimuth, fixed or sun- resolution down to 250m, depending on the location
tracking. Unlike the horizontal surface, the tilted and field of view of the satellite.
surface also receives a small amount of ground
reflected radiation. This is the sum of the scattered For locations that have a low density of
radiation, direct and reflected. GTI is derived from meteorological stations and rely on satellite data,
GHI and DNI. on-site resource monitoring may be considered
during the feasibility stage of the project. On-site
solar radiation data collected from solar resource
monitoring stations may be used to calibrate
satellite-derived estimates, thereby reducing
Solar Energy Europe, 1991-today 1-hourly 2.5Km x hourly GHI, DNI Commercial https://wdc.dlr.de/
Mining Africa, (Europe), 2.5Km data_products/SERVICES/
(SOLEMI) Asia 1999-2006 SOLARENERGY/description.php
(Asia)
3Tier Europe, 48°N and 1999-present 1-hourly 3Km x 3Km hourly GHI, DNI Commercial https://www.3tier.com/
Africa, 60°S
Asia
Surface Globally 1983-2005 3-hourly 100Km x monthly GHI, DNI Free https://eosweb.larc.nasa.gov/
meteorology 100Km sse/
and Solar
Energy (SSE)-
NASA
Pre-feasibility study is an early stage analysis of a Solar mini grid feasibility study is the most
potential project. The study is conducted by a group fundamental engineering effort required for
of small teams and is designed in order to decide assessing and planning any type of solar mini grid
whether or not the project will be worth proceeding design. Feasibility study is the cornerstone of solar
with or not and commitment of additional financial mini grid design because it provides an in-depth,
resources. The following are fundamental tasks meaningful assessment of the energy potential and
involved in conducting Pre-Feasibility Study. the relationship to consumers and productive end
• Site Assessment use.
• Roof-top and ground mount planning; Solar feasibility study is also of paramount
• Solar Resource Assessment importance in securing investment in solar mini
• Demand Assessment grids, since it provides detailed assessments of
• Cost estimate solar energy production potential as well as sets up
• Estimation of Energy Yield a bankable engineering platform for future project
• Financial and Economic Analysis execution.
• Environmental and Social Safeguards Screening The following are fundamental tasks involved in
• Preliminary Risk assessment conducting Feasibility Study:
• Site assessment
• Roof-top and ground mount planning;
• Solar resource assessment
• Demand assessment and projection
• Shading analysis
• System design
• Design layout
GESI Analysis
GESI Analysis Tool
Risk Assessment
Sustainability
Assessment
Pre-feasibility
Survey Tool
Report
• BoQ and Cost Estimate long term success and sustainability of a project as
• Estimation of Energy Yield well as securing investment and investor confidence
• Financial and Economic Analysis in the viability of a project. Therefore the design
• Environmental and Social Safeguards guidance focuses primarily on socioeconomic and
• Risk assessment financial assessment in pre-feasibility planning, as
these are the key drivers for the mini grid project.
The engineer or designer will need the following
documentation in order to provide a comprehensive
analysis. Solar system feasibility studies usually
involve several site visits and a close collaborative
effort with the organization or community at that
location.
1kW/m²
Solar Rodiation
Solar Rodiation
Time of Day Time of Day
Mini grids vary considerably in terms of scale, The designer will have the choice to organize
complexity and loads. They can incorporate solar mini grids into four basic configurations or
many different types and combinations of power architectures: ac coupled, dc coupled and DC and
generation and energy storage technologies, AC Coupled and DC-AC coupled with distributed
including fossil fuel generators, micro-turbines, generation systems. There are pros and cons
photovoltaics, batteries and energy management associated with each design approach.
systems.
Field Components
Distribution Network
Power House
AC Bus
Grid Tie
PV Array
Inverter
Bidirectional DC Bus
Inverter/Charger Battery
(Battery Inverter)
Energy
Meter
T&D
Network
PEU Load
HH Load
AC Bus
DC Bus
Battery
MPPT PV Array
Inverter
Energy
Meter
Distribution
Network
PEU Load
HH Load
Figure 6: DC Coupled
The advantages and disadvantages of a DC coupled day-load” efficiency (assuming that load<PV
system are listed as below. production):
• “PV to day-load” efficiency = MPPT SCC
Advantages: efficiency (95%) x battery inverter mean
• Charge battery with relative high “PV to battery” efficiency (87.5%)= 83%
efficiency: • High system cost for relatively large off-grid
• “PV to battery” efficiency = MPPT SCC systems, as multiple solar charge controllers
efficiency = 95% (and potentially inverters) are required as well as
• Supply nighttime load with relative high “PV to the associated balance of system components
night-load” efficiency: (cable, combiner boxes, etc.).
• “PV to night-load” efficiency = MPPT SCC
efficiency (95%) x battery efficiency (80%) 5.2.3. DC and AC coupled system
x battery inverter mean efficiency (87.5%)=
67%, A hybrid system configuration integrates additional
• More compact in terms of physical space; generator(s) into the dc- or ac-coupled mini grid.
• Low system cost for relatively small off-grid PV This architecture is mainly beneficial where there
systems. are chances of full drainage of battery caused by
faulty low voltage discharge protection of battery
Disadvantages: or improper O&M. This architecture overcomes the
• Supply day time load with relative low “PV to shortcomings of AC coupled systems.
AC Bus
DC Bus
Grid Tie
PV Array
Inverter Battery
MPPT PV Array
Bidirectional
Inverter/Charger
Energy
Meter
Distribution
Network
PEU Load
HH Load
5.2.4. DC-AC coupled with distributed in the T&D line at the far end from the power house.
generation The biggest advantage of this architecture is I2R loss
minimization. Further, the quality and reliability of
This system shall be adopted where there is a long electricity is also enhanced.
transmission line (say >5km) and availability of land
at one place is not possible. In that case, the portion
of PV array and grid tie inverter can be synchronized
Power House
AC Bus
DC Bus
Grid Tie
PV Array
Inverter Battery
MPPT PV Array
Bidirectional
Inverter/Charger
Energy
Meter
Distribution
Network PEU Load
HH Load
Distributed Generation
CS6K-265M/I-V CURVES
Maximum Power Point (MPP)
A
Short Circuit (Isc)
10 10
9 9
8 8
7 7
6 6
5 5
4 4
3 3
2 2
Open Circuit (Voc)
1 1
0 V 0 V
5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
MPPT Range
Voltage
Solution
Temp adjustment factor = -0.35% *(5-25)*44 =
3.08V [formula used is ‘ɣV * (TCELL - TSTC)’ ]
(Temp coef. is given in percentage thus have to
multiply it by Voc)
Voc cell eff = 44+3.08 = 47.08 V
Maximum no. of modules in series = inverter max
input voltage/ Voc cell eff
= 1250/47.08 = 26.56
= 26
(always round down for maximum no. of modules)
Figure 12: Small fixed modular system with four layers with concrete
foundation (Source: Italy Grid System)
f) Battery charge and discharge rate (C rate) many inverter and battery manufacturers will
A C-rate is a measure of the rate at which a recommend no more than a maximum of 3-5
battery is discharged relative to its maximum strings. This guideline recommends a maximum
capacity. In the US battery capacity is typically of 3 strings.
specified as C20 however in Asia the capacity
is given as C10. In Nepal it is typically C10 or It is always optimum to use less physical
C/10 however it could be different depending batteries, the installation site may prohibit the
on where the batteries came from. For a battery use of such large and heavy batteries, and for
with a capacity of 100 Amp-hrs, this equates to a remote sites with difficult or limited access
discharge current of 10 Amps at C10 rate. (helicopter) it might be necessary to use smaller
batteries to ease logistics. For example if the
g) Battery Configuration requirement is 2000AH at 48V, it would be
Batteries, like solar modules, need to be optimal to deploy a single string of twenty four
configured in strings and connected in series 2v 2000AH industrial deep-cycle batteries
and parallel to establish the desired voltage and instead of forty eight 2v 1000AH deep-cycle
AH capacity. As a general rule of thumb, it is industrial batteries configured as 2 strings. If the
optimum to keep the whole battery bank design requirement is for 6000AH at 48v, two strings of
to the minimum number of cells, strings and 3000AH batteries could be used rather than 3
minimum connections. In large battery banks strings of 2000AH or 4 strings of 1500AH.
over 500AH, it is recommended to always use
industrial deep cycle 2v, 4v or 6 volt batteries.
+ -
+ - + - + -
12V
+ + + - + - + - + - + - + -
6V 6V 2V 2V 2V 2V 2V 2V
+ - - -
12V SERIES
SERIES
2 PARALLEL
+ -
+ -
+ - + +
+ - + - + - + - + - + -
2V 2V 2V 2V 2V 2V
+ - 6V
-
6V
-
12V + - + - + - + - + - + -
+ + 2V 2V 2V 2V 2V 2V
+ - 6V
-
6V
- SERIES / PARALLEL
12V
SERIES/PARALLEL
+ -
12V 12 Volt Battery Wiring
2 PARALLEL
+ -
+ -
+ + + +
+ + 6V 6V 6V 6V
- - - -
12V 12V
SERIES
+ -
+ + + +
+ - 6V 6V 6V 6V
- - - -
+ - + -
+ + + +
12V 12V 6V 6V 6V 6V
- - - -
+ - + -
SERIES / PARALLEL
12V 12V
- +
+ - + -
12V 12V + - + - + - + - + - + -
2V 2V 2V 2V 2V 2V
2V 2V 2V 2V 2V 2V
SERIES/ PARALLEL - + - + - + - + - + - +
+ -
- +
+ - + - + - + - +
6V
+
6V
+
6V
+
6V
12V 12V 12V 12V - - - -
- - - -
Series 6V 6V 6V 6V
+ + + +
+ -
SERIES
+ - + - + - + -
12V 12V 12V 12V
+ - + - + - + -
12V 12V 12V 12V
When the sulfuric acid is mixed with the water requirements as shown in the table below and
the mixture can be calibrated by measuring the the chemical requirements as given in Table 2,
density, this is known as specific gravity. The in most cases the battery manufacturer would
battery manufacturer will provide the necessary provide this information, this is provided here as
values for first filling, and this should be strictly a reference. Purified water in compliance with the
adhered to and test certifications from calibrated requirements can be prepared from tap water by
equipment should demonstrate this. Specific distillation or by ion exchange.
gravity is relational to the ambient temperature
of the conditions, therefore it is necessary to
TABLE 6: PHYSICAL REQUIREMENTS OF
apply a correction factor to the specific gravity
PURIFIED WATER FOR ELECTROLYTE
measurements according to the temperature at
the time of filling. This is given here as reference. Appearance
pH value 5 -7
Water and refilling water. Water (H2O) is an Electric conductivity at 20°c < 10 μS/cm
ingredient of the electrolyte for accumulators.
Purified water is used for the preparation of
electrolyte for accumulators and for refilling
of water loss caused by overcharging and
evaporation in the operating electrolyte.
MPPT is mostly inbuilt in the PV inverter. The PV Battery Inverter efficiency ranges between 0.85 to
array side voltage can go upto 250V whereas the 0.95
output side voltage depends upon the DC input
voltage (12V or 24V or 48V) of PV inverter. Power factor can be taken as 0.8 (lag)
A solar charge controller is usually used in DC When designing any multi-inverter systems such
coupling systems, also sometimes refered to as as stacked, multi-cluster and multi-phase system,
MPPT charge controller. It also gathers energy from the designer must be careful to understand the
solar arrays, and stores it in batteries. Along with the manufacturer’s requirements for connection of the
MPPT function, all the battery protection systems battery storage
are in-built features of the Solar Charge Controller.
For example, a single inverter system from any
Usually, the voltage at PV array side and Battery manufacturer will have the inverter connected to a
connection side are the same. The Solar Charge type of fuse box which connects to all of the battery
Controller can be rated in Watt or Ampere. strings in the system. A stacked or 3 phase system
will have all the inverters connecting to the fuse box
Solar Charge PV array capacity (Watt-peak)
= and all of the battery strings, the inverters all sharing
Controller (Watt) FSM*FCTD the fuse box and the battery strings.
Sunny Boy
PV-Distribution
(not included in delivery)
Sunny Island
5048U
Battery
Figure 19: Battery and Battery Inverter Connection in an AC coupled system (credit SMA)
PV Inverter Size Array Capacity (Watt-peak) In the morning and post afternoon, the solar
=
(Watt) PDC to PAC ratio irradiance is relatively lower resulting in lower
power level which. If the DC to AC ratio is higher, the
Pdc to Pac ratio can be taken from 1.2 to 1.4 because inverter can operate in higher loading conditions
theoretical peak power of the modules is often owing to higher efficiency. For lower DC to AC
not achieved in reality. Higher the ratio, better the ratio, the DC power level would be lower resulting
advantage of inverter clipping. in lower efficiency due to lower loading of inverter.
Consequently, there are some losses during the
b) Optimizing Array-to-Inverter Power Ratio afternoon due to higher power generation and
Solar arrays to PV inverters have been designed with insufficiency of inverter size. Therefore, the total gain
much higher dc-to-ac ratios, up to and exceeding in the morning and post afternoon is higher than the
1.4. The energy yield can be optimized with inverter loss in the afternoon. A typical inverter clipping is
clipping. The ratio 1 or less will make inverter size shown in figure below.
higher than the PV Array and inverters are typically
less efficient at low power levels. In cold, sunny
weather, the dc system is capable of generating
more power than both the inverters and the ac
system designed to handle. In this case the inverter
restricts dc power output by simply moving the array
off its maximum power point. Inverter power limiting
results in a clipped, flat-topped power curve rather
than the traditional bell curve, a phenomenon often
referred to as clipping. What results is the inverter
3000
Inverter active power curve for 1.2 DC/AC ration 800
2500
Solar Irradiance
2000 600
1500
400
1000
Gain
200
500
0 0
21:36 00:00 02:24 04:48 07:12 09:36 12:00 14:24 16:48 19:12 21:36
Equipotential Equipotential
bonding 1 bonding 2
Figure 21: Earthing and Lighting Protection System of Mini Grid Systems
16.50
16.50
0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.60 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30
0.60
3.00 4.00 4.00 4.00 3.00 4.00 4.00 4.00
0.30 0.30
0.60
1.47 0.35
1.25 B1 B1 B1 B1
2.95 Toilet 2.95
7.00 B1
0.25 0.25
0.60 1.60
125mm Thick M20
(1:1, 5:3) RCC Slab SOAK PIT
0.25
250 mm Brick
R0.60
0.22 0.22
FRONT VIEW 0.51 250 mm thick
1.30 0.25
1.30 Stone Soiling
0.80
SECTION AT WALL SEPTIC TANK PLAN
1.05
GRAVEL PACKING
BACK VIEW
1.50
OPENING SCHEDULE
SYMBOL NO. SIZE
Do 1 1.5m x 2.3m
D1 2 1m x 2.3m SEPTIC TANK SECTION
W1 5 1.5m x 1.5m
Note:
V1 3 0.5m x 0.75m All dimensions are in meters.
LEFT SIDE VIEW RIGHT SIDE VIEW
5.6.12. Fencing
A fence is required to prevent unauthorized people The set-back (free space between fence and front of
from accessing the array, powerhouse and its PV array) should be provided in the east, south and
surrounds, which can also be used for the system’s west side of the fence to avoid the shading in the
security. As a ground mounted array is highly visible; solar array due to the fencing structure. Usually, the
it makes accessibility to thieves easier. A metallic set-back length is equal to the height of the fence.
entrance door and lock shall be included in the Generally, two types of fencing can be used in solar
fencing premises. mini grid; barbed wire fencing and chain mesh link.
650
550
700
5.7.5. Analysis of the wind data 5.7.6. Wind Generator Architectures and
Integration Considerations
In the early days, the anemometer data should be
collected regularly and analyzed to see if the site is Wind generators are available in multiple capacities,
producing worthwhile wind energy within the range configurations and electrical topologies (single
that you need for your wind turbine. At this early phase, 3 phase, AC or DC). Selection of topology
stage you will be looking out for issues such as, will be driven by the role of the wind turbine and the
overall poor wind energy metrics, wind energy out preferred technology vendor.
of range for the wind turbine, or problems with the
anemometer or data logging. AC coupled Wind turbines can be easier to integrate
into the mini grid, supplying direct AC power to
If poor wind energy measurements are being loads, however it is essential that the wind system
recorded it is possible the tower is poorly sighted or be controlled by the mini grid battery inverters, for
the location itself is not suitable. It is often the case example through phase shift power control mode.
that a site that seemingly has good wind energy Wind turbines on the AC bus typically act in the
suffers from turbulent wind which lowers the actual same way as solar PV inverters do, therefore the
usable wind energy. In this case, alternative tower requirements for control and integration are identical
locations should be tried. to that of a PV inverter. Collaboration between the
wind technology vendor and the inverter vendor
Any issues with the anemometers should be rectified should be pursued with diligence to understand how
as soon as possible, smooth consistent data coming the integration will work in reality.
in from the anemometers is the goal and will
provide the best possible information in which to DC coupled wind turbines require some additional
make decisions with. Do not rely on these devices planning, typically DC coupled turbines connect
to operate on their own for months at a time. They directly to the storage via a dedicated battery
may not be recording the data, if you are new to charger. In this case, the wind turbine charges the
the anemometer you are using it is best to become batteries directly whilst the energy management of
familiar with their idiosyncrasies and operational the mini grid is performed by the battery inverters.
behavior. Most inverter manufacturers will require some type
of interface between the wind turbine charger and
Talking to the wind turbine manufacturer as you go the batteries, typically this will be in the form of a
will provide you with some confidence regarding current sensor and shunt combination to provide
what wind metrics are going to work well with their measurements of battery energy flows external to
particular product. They will be able to indicate the inverters BMS. These “external” energy flows
6. The clearances of overhead conductors with ground, trees and other structures should maintained in
accordance with the values presented in tables below
1. 230/400 to 11 kV 1.25
2. above 11 kV and upto 33 kV 2
Note: Maximum deflection of wire due to wind pressure should be considered while fixing the minimum
clearances.
Span (m) 20 30 40 50 60 80
Minimum sag ( mm) 13 30 54 84 121 210
The value of sag should be included when determining the ground clearance of a transmission line.
9. Shackle insulators of appropriate voltage should be used in overall lines with voltages up to 1000 V.
Stay insulators shall be provided on all stays sets along overhead lines of more than 1000 V. Insulator
dimensions and appropriate conductors are listed in the table below.
12. A stay set should be provided at the first pole, at all poles set at an angle and at line ends. For safety and
protection from storms, every fifth pole is generally stayed on both sides even if the poles are in a straight
line.
13. Distribution lines and branches with more than 100 households or 10 kW should have a back-up breaker in
a distribution box in order to be able to identify faults.
14. For easy maintenance and fault finding, the distribution system should be divided into different areas
separated by switches and fuses.
15. Drop-out fuses and gang-operated switches of suitable ratings shall be provided at high voltage points.
16. Distribution transformers should be oil-immersed, natural-cooled single and/or three-phase, suitable for
outdoors installation on 11 kV and 33 kV, 50 Hz distribution systems. The design of transformers should
conform to the latest edition of the appropriate IEC specifications and/or other recognised international
standards.
b) Electrical Properties
Additional phase conductors for street light may be i. 95 sq. mm., 4-core ABC
required for centralized switching on/off. ii. 50 sq. mm., 4-core ABC
iii. 25 sq. mm., 4-core ABC
e) Anchor Clamps
The anchor clamps shall be bolted type. The wedge h) Insulated Insulation Piercing Connectors
of clamp shall be made of age and weather resistant The insulated insulation piercing connectors shall be
insulating material with high mechanical strength. suitable for using with aluminum ABC and concentric
The tightening straps shall be made of hot dip cables. It shall be made of high quality, weather,
galvanized steel. The clamp shall be loaded with the heat and age resistant insulating material having
spring. The clamp shall have at least two bolts for wet flashover voltage not less than 6 kV. It shall be
tightening. The hooking end of the clamp shall be watertight and suitable for making connections to
provided with a hot dip galvanized nuts and bolts the live lines. The piercing of the main line and the
with a safety lock. tapping shall be done simultaneously. The design
of the connectors shall be such that its removal
• The clamp shall be suitable for following ABC. is possible even after breaking of the shear head.
The connector shall be provided with an end cap
ABC size/type Min. Breaking load (kN) for tapping end. The connector shall be suitable for
95 sq. mm, 4-core ABC 43
50 sq. mm, 4-core ABC 37 following cables.
25 sq.mm, 4-core ABC 37
hook shall be suitable for mounting in steel tubular Type A 25-95 sq. mm, ABC 25-95 sq. mm, ABC
Type B 25-95 sq. mm, ABC 6-25 sq. mm, Concentric Cable
(ST)poles. Support hooks suitable for Steel Tubular
Poles: The support hooks shall be mounted on
circular two-way clamps. The hook (pig tail) shall be
mounted on one of the ways of the clamp. The clamp
shall be suitable for following sizes of poles.
• Type TC6: Two-way clamp suitable for pole
diameter ranging between 190 mm to 230 mm.
• Type TC8: Two-way clamp suitable for pole
diameter ranging between 140 mm to 180 mm.
The costing of the project shall be carried out based costs shall be calculated based on the similar
on the project component quantities and unit rates projects carried out or current ongoing projects
derived from the corresponding district rates for the within AEPC or outside AEPC.
fiscal year. Wherever possible, the current costs of
equipment and material also need to be obtained
from manufacturers. Where these are not available,
6.2.2. Contingencies
6.2. GENERAL METHODOLOGY
The estimated costs should include physical
The project shall be divided into a number of major
contingencies which allow for unforeseen cost
components for the estimating process as follows:
increases that may become necessary as more
• Pre-operating cost
information is obtained and evaluated. In view of
- Institutional set-up
the extent of investigations and study, the following
- Community mobilization
contingencies shall be considered:
• Main Generation System
• Solar equipment 5%
- Solar PV Array
• Civil Works - Surface & Infrastructure & General
- Mounting structure
Items 10%
- Solar Charge Controller/MPPT Controller
- Battery and Battery Management System
6.2.3. Annual operation and Maintenance
- Battery Inverter and PV Inverter
Cost
- Protection System
- Monitoring System
The annual operation and maintenance (O & M)
- Powerhouse
cost of a mini grid project is generally 1.5% to 3% of
• Transmission Line system(including
the total capital cost. It is less for larger plants and
transformers, LT lines, service cable etc)
high for smaller plants. Alternatively this cost can
• Land and support: The cost components include
be calculated with the breakdown of cost items. The
land acquisition and lease, compensation to
cost items are:
Forest Users’ Committee, camp and other
• salary and benefits to the operators/managers
physical facilities, local development, access
• cost of spare parts
roads, if any, and environmental mitigation. This
• regular repair and maintenance cost
cost also shall include the cost of relocation of
• insurance cost (if any)
existing infrastructure facilities that lie in the
• other costs
project construction site.
• Annual operation and maintenance (for financial
analyses)
Module This represents the losses due to rise in cell temperature of the module 7% 0.93
Temperature above the standard temperature conditions of 25oC. For every degree rise
in temperature above the standard value, the efficiency can be reduced by
around 0.5%.
Module Soiling This represents the losses due to dust, bird droppings and other foreign 3% 0.97
matter on the surfaces of PV modules that reduces the amount of solar
radiation received. It is usually less than 4% but PV arrays located in arid,
dusty areas with infrequent rain and regular covering of snow areas can
experience soiling losses of 20 percent a year or higher.
Mismatch This represents the losses due to “mismatch” related to the fact that 1% 0.99
modules connected in series do not rigorously present the same I-V
(Current-Voltage) curve characteristics. A de-rating factor of 0.99
represents a loss of 1 percent due to mismatch and is a reasonable
assumption.
Module Module quality losses refers to the deviation between actual module power 0% 0.00
Quality and nominal power specified in the manufacturer specification. In case of
positive tolerance on peak power, module quality loss can be considered
as zero.
Near Shading Near shading losses affect only a part of the PV array. This partial shading 1% 0.99
could be caused by closer row to row alignment, external shading objects
in the surroundings such as trees, buildings, poles, overhead cabling etc.
Light and This represents the losses occurring at module temperature above 50oC 1% 0.99
Temperature under illumination. LeTID may occur regularly during summer and at peak
Induced times in hot climates.
Degradation
(LeTID)
Low Irradiance This represents the losses due to irradiance level (to consider the lower 2% 0.98
performance behavior of PV modules at low light).
Reflection This represents the losses due to the reflection of the sun rays on the PV 1% 0.99
module surface.
DC Cable This represents the losses between PV modules and inverter input and 3% 0.97
should be less than 3%. It includes voltage drops in wiring, connections,
fuses, switches, or any other components, as applicable. These losses can
be determined in the field by measurements of the current and voltage
drops through the entire DC circuit. Total DC wiring and connection losses
usually will be on the order of 3 percent for most PV systems, resulting in a
derating factor of 0.97.
Inverter This represents the losses due to efficiency of the inverter. Almost all the 5% 0.95
good inverter manufacturers claim the maximum efficiency greater than
95%.
AC Cable This represents the losses from inverter to first pole. It includes voltage 1% 0.99
drops in wiring, fuses, and disconnects and usually is on the order of 1
percent or less for most PV systems, resulting in a derating factor of 0.99.
These losses are smaller than DC cable losses.
Transformer & This represents the losses in terms of iron and resistive/inductive losses. 2% 0.98
Others
Transmission This represents the losses in the transmission and distribution line, mainly 5% 0.95
& Distribution the power loss.
Total De-rating Factor (Multiplying all the De-rating Factors) 0.714
The PV system performance can be determined by Specific Yield refers to how much energy (kWh) is
the following parameters. produced for every kWp over the period of a year.
• Performance Ratio It is measured in kWh/kWp. The produced energy
• Specific Yield in MWh or GWh is simply the specific yield times
• Capacity Utilization Factor (CUF) the installed nominal power of the solar PV system
and accounts for the annual production delivered at
the site. Range from 1,000 kWh/kWp to over 2,000
7.3.1. Performance Ratio (PR) kWh/kWp
Performance Ratio (PR) is the ratio between actual The specific yield of a PV system depends on
energy yield and theoretical yield. The quality of a PV • Amount of solar irradiation falling on the module
power plant is described by its Performance Ratio plane
(PR). The PR, usually expressed as a percentage, can • Total System Losses or Total De-rating Factor
be used to compare PV systems independent of size
and solar resource. 7.3.3. Capacity Utilization Factor (CUF)
AC Yield (kWhr) x 1 (1kW/m²)
(PR) = x 100% The capacity utilization factor, usually expressed as a
DC Installed Capacity (kWp) x Plane of
Array of Irradiance(kWhr/m²) percentage, is defined as the ratio of total AC energy
over a period of a year to the theoretically available
PR is usually between 75% to 85% AC nominal power operated for the entire year.
The CUF is defined as:
97.5%
Guaranteed Performance
91.2%
80.7%
0%
0 5 10 15 20 25
Years
Figure 26: Example of PV Module Degradation
The solar mini grid project must be technically The amount of applicable subsidies for implementing
feasible as well as financially viable. Apart from new solar mini grid projects are as per Renewable
the technical, environmental and socio-economic Energy Subsidy Policy, 2078.
aspects of the project, the financial analysis provides
the most important indicators for the acceptability of
the project for investment. The financial evaluation 8.2. GENERAL ASSUMPTIONS
is aimed at giving potential investors an overview
of the risks and benefits associated with financing Analysis Period:
the project. The analysis is based on the use of The analysis period starts with cash flow investment
real time monetary values of the cost and benefit for project construction works which is distributed
and makes use of market prices and, therefore, for each year of construction period generally 6
includes any taxes which will be levied on the month to 1 year. Then the cost and revenue are
factors of production and any subsidies, capital or spread over the economic life of the plant from the
operating costs, which may be received as part of the date of commercial generation. Generally, 15 years
development. All costs are charged and all revenues can be adopted as the economic life of a solar mini
credited to the analysis in the actual amounts grid. One time of battery replacement has to be
expended or received at the time of expenditure. considered in the cash flow.
For this analysis the financial rate of return and
cash flow is assessed from the perspective of a mini Reference Date:
grid owner/operator. Financial analysis should be A reference date for costs, exchange rate and
carried out in such a way to develop a mini grid into a discounting is established on the date of project
business model. evaluation.
Financial Assessment
Financial Financial
Assessment Assessment Tool
Report
Applicable tariff (for connected load and for energy) The NPV is one of the most comprehensive
for different categories of consumers forms the approaches for the financial evaluation of a
basis for revenue analysis. Factors like time value of project. The NPV method evaluates the future cash
money, inflation etc. shall be considered to define a flows of the system in a real value basis. This is
mechanism for tariff adjustment/escalation. done by discounting the cash flows at a specific
interest rate. In addition, the recurrent costs of the
8.3.2. Life Cycle Cost Analysis project can be assumed to inflate or deflate at a
fixed inflation rate.
The LCC considers the investment cost, O&M and
the replacement costs. The investment cost of this 8.3.5. Internal Rate of Return (IRR)
project comprises the costs of the PV array, the
battery bank, inverter/battery charges, and wiring/ The internal rate of return is a discount rate that
BOS components. The costs of the wiring/BOS makes the net present value (NPV) of all cash
components may be assumed to be 10% of the flows equal to zero in a discounted cash flow
cost of other components (PV array, battery bank, analysis. IRR calculations rely on the same formula
inverter/battery charger). The investment cost as NPV does. The formula and calculation used to
generally includes the cost of the equipment plus the determine this figure is as follows.
installation cost and any modification required in the
S
T
equipment. The cost of the system installation and Ct
0 = NPV = - C0
other modifications required may also be assumed (1 + IRR)t
to be 10% of the sum of the main components. The t=1
annual cost of an energy system includes operational Where:
costs (including salary and benefits of the staff), Ct = Net Cash Inflow during the period t
mortgage payments, and maintenance and parasitic C0 = Total initial investment costs
energy costs etc. IRR = the internal rate of return
t = the number of time periods
8.3.3. Sensitivity analysis
To calculate IRR using the formula, one would
Sensitivity Analysis is the process of recalculating set NPV equal to zero and solve for the discount
outcomes under alternative assumptions to rate, which is the IRR. However, because of
determine the impact of variable parameters. the nature of the formula, IRR cannot be easily
Sensitivity analysis is one such method that is calculated analytically and therefore must instead
implemented to analyze the various risks to the be calculated either through trial-and-error or
project on uncertain conditions. Sensitivity analysis by using software programmed to calculate IRR.
involves changing the inputs in the financial model to This can be done in Excel easily with inbuilt IRR
analyze how the cash flow of the project is impacted. function.
Sensitivity analysis gives lenders and investors a
greater understanding of the effects of changes in 8.3.6. Payback Period.
inputs on the project’s profitability and bankability.
It helps lenders and investors understand the key The payback period refers to the amount of time
risks associated with the project. Consultant has it takes to recover the cost of an investment or
to provide outcome of below mentioned financial how long it takes for a developer to reach break-
parameter for following scenarios; even. The desirability of an investment is directly
a) Without any financial incentive i.e. no subsidy related to its payback period. Shorter paybacks
b) Subsidy with 60% of total project cost, 20% loan mean more attractive projects. This is a non –
and 20% equity discounted cash flow method of capital budgeting
c) Subsidy with 90% of total project cost, 10% which is its limitation.
equity
9.1. ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL Solar mini grid systems are mainly for community
ASSESSMENT electrification powering lighting in the households,
school, hospital, office building etc. The adverse
Environmental and Social Safeguard requirements environmental impacts of these systems is generally
of the projects shall be governed by the Environment not very significant. Mini grid systems could be
Protection Act (EPA) 2076 and Environment located in a remote rural community, a group of
Protection Rule (EPR) 2077 of the Government of villages or districts interconnected by transmission
Nepal and Environmental and Social Safeguard lines. The aggregate effects of several such projects
(ESS) Policy 2018 of AEPC. According to the EPA could be of magnitude to cause adverse impact
2076, an environmental study report shall be to the environment. Therefore, environmental
prepared for any proposal as prescribed in the EPR and social impact due to implementation of such
2077. A brief environmental study shall be carried projects shall be considered in the detailed feasibility
out for solar and wind projects which will use up study. Environmental and Social Study for a mini
to 1 hectare forest land (Schedule-1, Ka.6). Initial grid project should identify key impact, predict
Environmental Examination (IEE) shall be carried magnitude, extent and duration of impact as well as
out for solar and wind projects with generation suggest strategies for minimization/mitigation of
capacity of 1 to 10 MW (Schedule-2, Cha.7) and impacts.
projects which will use 1 to 5 hectares of forest land
(Schedule -2, Ka.12). However, Environmental Impact
Assessment (EIA) shall be carried out for solar and
wind projects with generation capacity more than
10 MW (Schedule-3, Cha.6), projects which will use
more than 5 hectares forest land (Shedule-3, Ka.9)
and projects in national parks, hunting reserve and
wildlife reserve (Schedule -3, Ka.10). In terms of
projects supported by Development Agencies such
as the World Bank and Asian Development Bank,
Environmental and Social Safeguard requirements
as per the safeguard policy of respective agencies
shall be fulfilled.
Physical Biological
Socio-Economic
Environment Environment
Study
Study Study
Environment Impact
Assessment Tool
Environment Impact
Assessment Report
9.2.1. Environmental and Social Baseline data collection is a record of the situation
Screening and Categorization and status of the project site before project
implementation. It is a description of existing
Screening will determine whether the projects are conditions against which subsequent change can be
likely to have potential adverse environmental and examined, predicted and confirmed.
social impacts, establish the level of environmental/
social assessment required, help proponents Baseline study refers to the collection of existing
to understand environmental and social issues physical, biological, socio-economic and cultural
related to the projects before they are considered information of the proposed project area including
for implementation, and assist in the decision- changes that are expected in future.
making process. Screening will be conducted based
on criteria mentioned in Schedule 1, 2 and 3 of For environmental assessment of the proposed
Environment Protection Rules 2077 (EPR, 2077) and project, the baseline conditions for the physical,
Environmental and Social Safeguard (ESS) Policy of biological, socio-economic, and cultural environment
AEPC 2018. of the project area should be found out and
documented for future records. The major categories
Based on the environmental and social screening, of the environment likely to be included in the
projects will be categorized as High, Medium Low environmental report of Large Scale Solar PV and
risk. AEPC will be responsible for the categorization Wind are detailed below.
decision of the project.
Activities Impact
Construction Phase Physical environment
• Soil erosion and chances of landslide due to removal of tree, shadow obstacles
Solar PV mounting concrete and cutting existing slope and filling of loose excavated materials
pillars, wind turbine support • Surface erosion from excavated material filling site
foundation structure, • Change in land use pattern
Armor cable ground layout, • Deterioration of surface water due to surface runoff from excavated site
powerhouse, earthing or • Air pollution
grounding, project accessories, • Noise level
access road • Water quality
• Solid waste and muck disposal
• Stockpiling of construction materials
• Visual impact
Biological Environment
• Loss of forest and vegetation
• Exploitation of none timber forest product
• Hunting and Poaching
• Stress on natural resources
Socioeconomic Environment
• Land Acquisition: Acquisition of private as well as governmental land
• Visual intrusion caused by construction activities
• Production of sound and noise due to wind turbine rotation
• Shadow and shadow motion due to wind turbine rotation
• Local birds strike on the wind turbine
• Destruction and destroyed recreational spot and activities
• Labor influx and management: Raised social issues from the migrated work force
• Change in demographic profile
• Impact on livelihood of Project Affectd Peoples (PAPs)
• Occupational health and safety
• Community health and safety
• Health, hygiene and sanitation
• Gender and vulnerable group
• Employment opportunity
• Impact on sites of cultural importance
• Stress on infrastructure
Biological Environment
• Barrier on wildlife movement
• Birds and bats mortality
• Forest and vegetation
•
Socio-economic and cultural environment
• Issue on electrical and electronic waste
• Battery Management: Issue on lead acid disposal and battery recycling
• Issue on mercury due to florescent bulb disposal
• Issue on public health
• Impact on livelihood of Project Affectd Peoples (PAPs)
• Occupational health and safety
• Community health and safety: Issue on public health
• Stress on infrastructure
• Employment opportunity
There could be various types of risk profiles 10.1. UNCERTAINTY IN METEO DATA
associated with any new project and in general
such risk profiles vary from project to project. The solar irradiance could have yearly variability.
Risk profiles that need careful scrutiny in case of The climate evolution made solar irradiance more
solar mini grid projects. The foremost risk may be unpredictable. However, the uncertainty can be
associated with proper resource assessment as minimized by quality of the data recording, care of
incorrect assessment will lead to premature failure of the operators, positioning, calibration and drift of the
the project. Some of the risks may have tremendous sensors, perturbations like shadings, dirt or snow
negative effects whereas some others may be on the sensors, etc. The quality of data depends
alleviated with proper back up planning. Similarly upon the location difference (distance of measuring
the risk of error in existing demand assessment and station) for terrestrial measurements.
future demand projection needs to be minimized.
Other risks may include geological risk, seismic risk, The quality of the models used for interpreting the
risk of large migration, technological risk, risk of satellite data, which is in continuous improvement
alternative options (e.g. of grid electricity). since 20 years. Usually the probability index p(xx)
represents yield levels, for which the probability that
Some of the risks are site specific and they should the production of a particular year is over this value
be assessed during the field investigation and design is xx%. The energy yield are derived at p(90), p(70)
period. The feasibility study shall collect and analyze and p(50) data whenever possible/ required. For the
adequate data/information associated with the bankable project P(70) is required.
risks as stated above. This will prevent harming
the project implementation as well as operation.
Appropriate measures should be suggested
in descriptive form by the consultant on risk
management.
P (70)
P (90) P (10)
The financial risks include change in interest, Social risks are associated with acquisition of land
change in item rates, change in project cost, change for the project and the implementation of the
in legislation, change in exchange rate, change project without proper consultation and consent
in construction period, etc. These risks shall be of the people residing in the project areas. Timely
analyzed during negotiations with lenders and stakeholders engagement is recommended for
community. minimizing such a risk. Social risk may arise
due to excessive use of local resources (water,
land, forest, construction materials, etc.) by
10.3. OTHER RISKS the developer, intervention in the living style or
tradition of the locals, etc. These risks shall be
Other risks in mini grid development can be: identified and adequate mitigation measures shall
be recommended during the socio- economic and
environmental studies of a solar mini grid project.
10.3.1. Environmental risk
Contents
List of Acronyms
List of Drawings
List of Figures
List of Tables
Executive Summary (Summary of the Detailed
Feasibility Study Report)
Salient Features
Renewable Energy Subsidy Delivery Mechanism, SMA, Technical and Product Documentation, 2020
Alternative Energy Promotion Centre, 2022
Tracking SDG 7: The Energy Progress Report,
Electricity Storage Valuation Framework, International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA),
International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA), 2020.
2020.
Quality Assurance Framework for Mini Grids,
Policies and regulations for renewable energy mini National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) of
grids, International Renewable Energy Agency the U.S. Department of Energy, 2016
(IRENA), 2018.
Key Steps in Mini Grid Technical Design, USAID, 2020
Guidelines for Detailed Feasibility Studies of Mini
Karnamadakala Rahul Sharma, Approach for
Hydropower Projects, Alternative Energy Promotion
Designing Solar Photovoltaic-Based Mini Grid
Center (AEPC), 2014
Projects: A Case Study from India, 2014
Guidelines for Developing Utility-Scale Solar PV
Project in Nepal, Alternative Energy Promotion
Center (AEPC), 2019
Questionnaire
Individual
District
Rural/Municipality
Ward no/Tole
Respondent Name
Age
Social NOTE
Family Size
Income Source
Service Please Tick
Agriculture Please Tick
Business (mention type)
Monthly Income Total Income in Cash in NPR
Education
Highest Education Level Separate with comma for different classes. Eg: Input as
Number Classes Enrolled 1,2&3 for 3 Male Students in class 1, 2 & 3
Male Students
Female Students
Name of Nearest School
Proximity to Nearest School meters
Present Source of Lighting and monthly associated Cost
Candle Yes/No & NPR
Kerosene Yes/No & NPR
Dry Cell Yes/No & NPR
Solar Home System Yes/No & NPR
Diesel Generator Yes/No & NPR
Others Please mention
Present Method of Cooking and monthly associate cost
Fuelwood Yes/No, kG/Lit & NPR
Biogas Yes/No, kG/Lit & NPR
Others Yes/No, kG/Lit & NPR
Average Monthly spending for Energy application in NPR
Solar Home System (if any)
Size of Solar Home System in Wp
Year of Installation
Financial Support Self / AEPC / Other Donors
Cost of installed Solar Home System
Drinking Water
Questionnaire 2
Focus Group Discussion
Need Assessment Note
Level of electricity need for the community High/Medium/Low or No
Existing number of Solar Home System (SHS) users
Current issue with existing SHS Please specify issue
Current demand for additional electricity High/Medium/Low or No
Community contribution
Likelihood for community contribution High/Medium/Low or No
Cash Please specify the average expected cash contribution
KIND Please specify the average expected kind contribution
such as transportation from nearest road head to
project site, unskilled labor and fencing.
Unskilled Human Resource High/Medium/Low or No
Local Resource Availability High/Medium/Low or No
Sand
Water
Stone
Wood
Aggregates
Others
Proposed site for Solar Mini Grid System or accessories Please take photo and coordinate for GPS
Name of Location Pros Cons
Location 1
Location 2
Location 3
Location 4
Existing source of electricity (except NEA Grid) Mention Yes/No and Approximate Number of Installed
Capacity & Units
Micro Hydro
Institutional Solar
Solar Home System
Bio Mass
Biogas
Wind
Expected time of use of electricity Mention total hours
Day
Night
Expected demand of electricity for Mention expected demand in kW & units demanded
Industrial application
Agricultural application
Service/Commercial
13-19
20-24
Education Level
Skill Level
Employment Status