Final Report Annex3 PDF
Final Report Annex3 PDF
The information and views set out in this report are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the
official opinion of the Interreg CENTRAL EUROPE MANAGING AUTHORITY or the Interreg CENTRAL
EUROPE Programme. The Interreg CENTRAL EUROPE MANAGING AUTHORITY does not guarantee the
accuracy of the data included in this study. Neither the Interreg CENTRAL EUROPE MANAGING
AUTHORITY nor any person acting on the Interreg CENTRAL EUROPE MANAGING AUTHORITY’s behalf
may be held responsible for the use which may be made of the information contained therein.
2
Table of contents
1. Introduction ......................................................................................................... 3
2. Main discussion points ......................................................................................... 4
3. Rankings of POs and SOs ...................................................................................... 9
4. Annex 1 – Workshop posters .............................................................................. 13
5. Annex 2 – Workshop programme ....................................................................... 18
6. Annex 3 – Workshop Presentations .................................................................... 23
3
1. INTRODUCTION
The strategy and consensus building workshop took place on November 13th in Vienna. In total 35
representatives from the Interreg CE WG21+ plus additional experts of the nine central Europe (CE) countries,
the Managing authority and the European Commission participated. The workshop was organised jointly by
the Joint Secretariat (JS) of the Interreg CENTRAL EUROPE Programme and the Vienna Institute for
International Economic Studies (wiiw). The workshop was moderated by Roman Römisch (wiiw) and Helmut
Hiess (Rosinak&Partner), involving additional four experts from the wiiw.
The purpose of the workshop was to contribute to the Interreg CENTRAL EUROPE strategy building process
and to be one step towards getting a consensus between Member States on the priorities of the Interreg
CENTRAL EUROPE 2021-2027 Programme.
The workshop was organised as “World Café” so that all participants could discuss the five future ERDF Policy
Objectives (PO) as well as the Interreg specific objective (SO) “A better cooperation governance”. To stimulate
the discussions, in total three presentations were held. Firstly one overview presentation of the main results of
the territorial analysis of CE challenges and the stakeholder survey results by Helmut Hiess and Roman
Römisch. Secondly, two presentations on the policy needs and potentials of transnational cooperation and the
topics tackled by the current CE programme by experts from the JS and the wiiw.
The section below summarises the main results and points of this discussion in bullet point form; it also
includes the final participants’ ranking of the POs and their Specific Objectives. The produced output of the
workshop, i.e. posters collecting ideas on future transnational actions for each PO/SO (considering also
horizontal issues), the workshop programme as well as the presentations, are included in the Annex.
4
The following points that were discussed during the workshop are not exhaustive and represent a selection of
the most frequent and emphasised issues.
PO 1 - A SMARTER EUROPE
o Actions that address joint challenges and call for capacity building, knowledge transfer,
development of prototypes or pilot actions to find and promote solutions. Examples: a)
Changing travel behaviour and traffic patterns (more sustainable), b) development of
multimodal nodes and hubs for passenger and freight traffic, c) connecting peripheral
regions to regional centres and the TEN-T and d) the implementation of mobility as a
service as regards transnational traffic and transport relations, e.g. improving digital mobility
services like integrated digital ticketing, passenger information etc.
o SO should include both passenger and freight transport.
o Avoid overlapping of funding facilities rather than an overlapping of themes across
programmes.
• SO 4.4 Ensuring equal access to health care through developing infrastructure, including
primary care
o Make use of digitalization to allow equal access to quality health care services (e.g. better
information transfer)
o Establish networks to transfer/exchange managerial and organisational tools and expertise
for health care services. Higher performing regions/countries should support lower
performing regions/countries
o There is a need for a standardization and categorization of health care services in the CE
region. An overall spatial planning program across the entire CE region can contribute to
more efficient and better performing health care services.
o Short term projects or smaller projects with a more direct and or immediate impact might be
suitable to increase the visibility of projects and improve perceptions of EU legitimacy. There
was however no consensus on this and recommendations were to implement this as a
horizontal guideline if necessary.
o Discussions also centred on including other topics to be integrated in PO5, e.g. transport or
social topics. There was no unanimous view amongst participants however.
After finishing the discussions of the POs and the respective SOs the national delegations were asked to rank
the POs and SOs according to their importance. Each delegation got 3 points to distribute across the 5 POs,
so that in total 27 points were allocated for the ranking of POs. For ranking the SOs each delegation got 9
points to be distributed according to their preferences on the 21 SOs. Hence in total 81 points were allocated
to the SOs. The results are as follows:
10
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
PO 1 A smarter PO 2 A greener, PO 3 A more PO 4 A more social PO 5 A Europe
Europe low-carbon and connected Europe Europe closer to citizens
resilient Europe
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Number of points
13
The version below is the final workshop programme. It deviates from the initial programme as organisational
changes were made with respect to the inclusion of the Interreg Specific Objective A better cooperation
governance” in the discussions and the ranking procedure. The version below was distributed to the
participants at the workshop.
The workshop will contribute to the Interreg CENTRAL EUROPE strategy building process and will be an
important step towards getting a consensus between Member States on the priorities of the Interreg
CENTRAL EUROPE 2021-2027 Programme.
Guided by workshop moderators, the workshop participants will discuss the five 2021-2027 ERDF Policy
Objectives (POs) as well as the respective Specific Objectives (SOs) to identify those three that, as provided
for in the draft regulations 2021-2027, the future programme should put a thematic focus on.
Each national delegation should be composed by persons who are familiar with the topics addressed under
the five POs. In order to allow group work (see below agenda) national delegations should be composed by at
least 2 participants holding the needed expertise for entailing discussions under each of the five POs.
National delegations should be limited to maximum 5 participants.
1. A smarter Europe by promoting innovative and smart economic transformation ('PO 1') by:
i. enhancing research and innovation capacities and the uptake of advanced technologies
ii. reaping the benefits of digitisation for citizens, companies and governments
iii. enhancing growth and competitiveness of SMEs, including by productive investments
iv. developing skills for smart specialisation, industrial transition and entrepreneurship
2. A greener, low-carbon and resilient Europe by promoting clean and fair energy transition, green
and blue investment, the circular economy, climate adaptation and risk prevention and management
('PO 2') by:
i. promoting energy efficiency and reducing greenhouse gas emissions
19
The participants’ discussions will be backed up by information from the background report “Analysis of the
main territorial challenges, needs and transnational cooperation potentials in central Europe” and the results of
the “Survey of future objectives and priorities”. Both will be provided at least two weeks in advance of the
workshop.
In addition, the Interreg Specific objective SO1 “A better cooperation governance” will be dealt with during the
workshop.
Time table
As the following activities will be done in two smaller groups. Each workshop participant is asked to join one of the groups.
Each group will work on each of the 5 POs as well as on the Interreg SO1. To illustrate: In the morning Group1 will work on PO1,
PO2 and PO3, Group2 on PO4, PO5 and SO1; vice versa in the afternoon (Group1: PO4-SO1; Group2: PO1-PO3.
• Presentation to each working group of the policy needs and TNC potentials for concerned POs
(workshop moderators)
• Presentation of the experiences of the current CE 2014-2020 programme (JS)
Organisationally, there will be two rooms for the presentation of the main challenges and policy needs.
In Room 1 the presentations for PO1 (A smarter Europe), PO2 (A greener Europe) and PO3 (A more connected Europe) will be
held.
In Room 2 the presentations for PO4 (A more social Europe), PO5 (A Europe closer to citizens) and SO1 (A better cooperation
governance) will be held.
Group1 will be in Room1.
Group2 will be in Room2.
To begin, Group1 (Room1) will be split in Group1a, Group1b and Group1c. They will work in a rotation on PO1, PO2 and PO3.
Group2 (Room2) will be split in Group2a, Group2b and Group2c. They will work in a rotation on PO4, PO5 and SO1.
The time available for the first PO for each group will be generally longer than for the subsequent POs. This is because workshop
participants will:
• already be acquainted with the procedures
• build on the results of the groups that worked on the respective PO before.
The results of the previous groups will be shown on flip charts – insights from new groups will be added to those.
• Presentation to each working group of the policy needs and TNC potentials for concerned POs
(workshop moderators)
• Presentation of the experiences of the current CE 2014-2020 programme (JS)
To begin, Group1 (Room2) will be split in Group1a, Group1b and Group1c. They will work in a rotation on PO4, PO5 and SO1.
Group2 (Room1) will be split in Group2a and Group2b. They will work in a rotation on PO1, PO2 and PO3.
Activities will be the same as in the morning session (discussion, brainstorming, rating of SOs).
Each Group will build on the results of the groups that worked on the respective PO before.
The results of the previous groups will be shown on flip charts – insights from new groups will be added to those.
Time available:
In both rooms:
• 20-25 minutes for each PO.
22
• Presentation of the main results and findings of the participants work in the 5 POs and the Interreg
SO by the workshop moderators
Each national delegation will discuss the workshop findings. The aim is to derive at a consolidated view for each delegation
regarding the importance and transnational cooperation relevance of the 5 POs and the respective SOs.
The results will be processed by the workshop moderator and presented to the participants.
Results will include the findings of the POs, also showing the ranking of the respective SOs as determined in the working groups.
• Concluding remarks by the moderator on the use and processing of the workshop results
• Concluding remarks by the MA/JS on the next steps.
23