Challenges, Coping Strategies, and Skills of Out-of-Field Physical Education Teachers As Mediated by Self-Efficacy
Challenges, Coping Strategies, and Skills of Out-of-Field Physical Education Teachers As Mediated by Self-Efficacy
ABSTRACT: This study aims to discern the challenges, coping strategies, and skills utilized by out-of-field teachers handling
MAPEH subjects to determine self-efficacy mediates the relationship between the Challenges, coping strategies, and skills. The
respondents rated moderate agreement on their challenges from initial to novice teachers. Moderate agreement assessment of the
respondents on their challenges regarding ongoing teaching-learning. The assessment of the respondents as to the challenges they
encountered in terms of professional development was verbally interpreted as moderately agree. The agreement from the
respondents on their coping strategies utilized as to content knowledge. The respondents agreed that they utilize the indicated
coping strategies. The respondents agreed that they utilized careful guidance as one of the strategies as out-of-field teachers. The
respondents agreed on attentive leadership as a strategy for the out-of-field teacher. The assessment of the respondents on their
human skills was verbally interpreted as agreeing. The hard skill is interpreted as agreed by the respondents.
The overall level of the respondents' performance in terms of self-efficacy is verbally interpreted as agreed. There is a significant
relationship between coping strategies and self-efficacy variables. On the one hand, a moderate to strong relationship is seen
between variables. Thus the research null hypothesis is rejected. There is a significant relationship between coping strategies and
performance variables. A moderate to strong relationship was seen between variables; hence, the research null hypothesis is
partially sustained. Findings revealed that Self-Efficacy constructs do not mediate the relationship between Challenges and
Performance. On the other hand, Self-Efficacy could explain the variations in Coping Strategies and Performance Scores. It led to
the acceptance of the research null hypothesis.
KEYWORDS: Challenges, CopingStrategies, HumanSkill, HardSkill, Self-Efficacy
I. INTRODUCTION
Quality education is at the heart of sustainable development, acting as a powerful catalyst in developing more just, humane, and
equitable societies. It has become critical in many rapidly increasing enrollments in many countries to achieve education for all.
Education systems have recently been strained, but the assumption that there is a trade-off between access and quality is flawed.
In countries with limited resources, successful efforts to increase access to primary education have frequently resulted in declining
educational quality.
Also, education is essential in peoples' lives because it allows us to better our living conditions. To do so, people will need
the help of others, specifically our teachers. The teacher's primary responsibility is to transfer knowledge and inspire students to
learn more through experience. Teaching is a time-consuming endeavor. It is a multifaceted task regarded as the noblest of all
professions because it lays the groundwork for any discipline that many people envision. As a result, their efforts are highly
valued to begin the high-quality education that students deserve. Aside from their actions, teachers' educational backgrounds are
essential in effective teaching. It is argued that a teacher is expected to demonstrate subject expertise.
To do justice to the preceding, people require the assistance of others, particularly teachers. The teacher's primary
responsibility is to transfer knowledge and inspire students to learn more through experience. Teaching is a time-consuming
endeavor. It is a multifaceted task regarded as the noblest of all professions because it lays the groundwork for any discipline that
many people envision. As a result, their efforts are highly valued to begin the high-quality education that students deserve. Aside
from their actions, teachers' educational backgrounds are important in effective teaching. It is argued that a teacher must
demonstrate expertise in their subjects.
Du Plessis (2017) asserts that public school teachers play an essential role in society, particularly for students. Quality
teachers are required for quality education. The availability of qualified teachers is critical in developing the educational system,
as education quality is directly related to classroom instruction quality. Using qualified teachers in all schools is critical in
METHOD
This research study employed the participation of out-of-field physical education teachers in the division of Lipa City. The
researcher utilized a sampling technique to include all out-of-field physical education teachers in this study. The number of
respondents was taken from the 16 public high schools in the Lipa City division.
Table 5. Assessment of the Respondents on the Challenges Encountered in Terms of Transition from Initial Teacher to
Novice
Indicators Mean SD VI
1. Participating in the courses/workshops to improve my preparation for the lesson. 3.93 .946 Moderately Agree
2. delivering a more interactive lesson to my students 3.92 1.002 Moderately Agree
3. Integrating differentiated instruction in preparing my lesson. 3.90 1.000 Moderately Agree
4. providing technical assistance on students' behavior in the class 3.76 1.006 Moderately Agree
5. utilizing media-based instruction to boost the attention of my students 3.77 1.109 Moderately Agree
Overall 3.86 .928 Moderately Agree
Individually taken, the indicator participating in the courses/workshops to improve my preparation for the lesson on got the
highest weighted mean of 3.93 and verbally interpreted as moderately agree. With the number of years invested in education,
training, and practice prior to receiving a teaching license, a teacher must always be prepared for his or her vocation. However,
whomever is assigned a task that is outside of their area of expertise may run into difficulties in completing it, just like a teacher
who is given a subject that is out of his or her line of specialization. It would always take time to be prepared so as to deliver the
lessons well in class and to be able to come up with activities where the learners can learn the subject effectively.
This result is in line with was stated by Roffey (2017) that even teachers with the best preparation need help putting what
they have learned into practice and transitioning from student teaching to their own classroom where they are now in charge. The
difficulties are made worse for the growing number of teachers who enter classrooms without solid academic and professional
Table 7. Assessment of the Respondents on the Challenges They Encountered in Terms of Ongoing Teacher Learning
Indicators Mean SD VI
1. Participating in the courses/workshops to improve my preparation for 3.93 .946 Moderately Agree
the lesson.
2. delivering a more interactive lesson to my students 3.92 1.002 Moderately Agree
3. integrating differentiated instruction in preparing my lesson. 3.90 1.000 Moderately Agree
4. providing technical assistance on students' behavior in the class 3.76 1.006 Moderately Agree
5. utilizing media-based instruction to boost the attention of my students 3.77 1.109 Moderately Agree
Overall 3.86 .928 Moderately Agree
The overall weighted mean of 3.77 (SD=.995) suggests a moderate agreement assessment of the respondents. Teachers are
expected to teach a new subject sincethis is the focus of the locus of change in the field of education. This is one of the things that
make teaching a challenging profession. According to Hobbs and Quinn (n.d.) teachers are often required to learn on the job and
often without the support structure.
In addition, the statement maximize the time allotted in teaching my lesson obtained the highest weighted mean
of 3.86 (SD=1.083) and has a verbal interpretation of moderately agree. Each subject is assigned with the so-called Budget of
Work (BOW) that guides the teacher when to start and when to end a specific lesson. In this case, teachers should always
maximize so that they can finish the lesson and that they can meet all the most essential learning competencies the learners must
acquire at the end of every quarter. According to Department of Education (2023) the budget of work covers K–12 basic
education curriculum competencies, skills, and objectives, subjects for certain skills and competencies; and teaching strategies,
activities, and time allotment grouped into columns for simple reference and notation. It is a resource document for teachers of
multi-grade classrooms teachers must use as a resource for creating daily and/or weekly lesson plans.The teachers who
participated in the survey said that, on occasion, it can be challenging to make the most of the time given for each lesson because
of unforeseen circumstances that have an impact on classroom activities and other curriculum-related activities.
Further, the statement conducts various research before planning the lesson achieved a weighted mean of 3.70
(SD=1.068) and verbally interpreted as moderately agree. Conducting research is one of the tasks that teachers usually. Research
using a variety of references and speaking with knowledgeable teachers in the field, such as in MAPEH, could really help out-of-
field teachers who know a bit about the subject deliver the lessons and prepare as well as execute the activities affectively. As
stated by Bin-Hady (2018) teachers take necessary research-like steps for preparing lesson plans, such as reading the teaching
materials for the lesson and listen to the cassette if it is connected with that lesson. Also, this finding is congruent with Morales
argument which stated that in general, teachers are also researchers who must evaluate and assess their classroom activities in
order to grow and improve their teaching as agents of knowledge and change.
As shared by the respondents, they continue to read books and visit websites where they can get ideas and information
relevant to their classes because MAPEH is a new subject as it is outside of their field of competence. They added that in order to
learn more about the lesson, they also asked their colleagues who have been teaching MAPEH for a longer time.
Table 9. Assessment of the Respondents on the Coping Strategies Utilized in Terms of Content Knowledge
Indicators Mean SD VI
As a PE Teacher, I….
1. ask the assistance from co-teachers on how to apply knowledge of content 4.42 .781 Agree
within and across the curriculum teaching areas.
2. weigh possible solutions for executing my activities in physical education 4.37 .720 Agree
3. choose to collaborate with my co-workers in creating performance tasks in PE 4.39 .751 Agree
4. acquire competence through training 4.45 .642 Agree
5. do watch fb live and video lesson 4.31 .825 Agree
Overall 4.39 .640 Agree
It can be seen from Table 9 that the overall mean for the coping strategies that the respondents utilized as to content knowledge is
4.39 (SD=.640) and has a verbal interpretation of agree. Given their status as out-of-field teachers, they must seek assistance from
others, especially mentors and more experienced co-workers like those with a MAPEH major.
Individually taken, the statement acquire competence through training received the highest weighted mean of 4.45 and
was verbally interpreted as agree. Teachers must train before entering the classroom and receive ongoing training even as they
work there. Teachers must be given the greatest chance of success and sustain veteran teachers as they meet new educational
challenges, especially those given teaching loads out of their specialization. The result is synonymous with Horizon Report (2016)
that one of the immediate recommendations was the need for teacher education programs to reconceptualize training to more
closely address the skill set needed by the 21st-century educator.
According to Srirat (2017), Facebook is one of the most popular social networking websites, which allows users to share
and exchange profiles, photos, and videos with others. It can be a useful tool in teaching various subjects. With the demand of
IJSSHMR, Volume 2 Issue 07 July 2023 www.ijsshmr.com Page 493
Challenges, Coping Strategies, and Skills of Out-of-Field Physical Education Teachers as Mediated by Self-
Efficacy
21st-century learning, where technology dominates, they are usually motivated to listen and watch when the lessons are delivered
via FB live. More so, Carag (2020) supports this finding as he found out in his study that as a provider of knowledge, teachers in
MAPEH may use technology as an innovative tool for improving the quality teaching-learning process and may participate in a
seminar-workshop for them to enhance their teaching capabilities as mentors.
Table 10. Assessment of the Respondents on the Coping Strategies Utilized in Terms of Context-Specific Pedagogical Skills
Indicators Mean SD VI
1. make a plan of action and try to carry it out 4.34 .755 Agree
2. assess students' Performance in Physical Education 4.44 .686 Agree
3. communicate well with other MAPEH teachers to get skills as to how to teach 4.46 .673 Agree
the subject
4. provide a variety of concrete learning materials in teaching Physical Education 4.39 .695 Agree
5. Design, organize and select formative and summative assessment strategies 4.41 .726 Agree
consistent with curriculum requirements
Overall 4.41 .623 Agree
As shown in Table 10, the respondents agreed to utilize the indicated coping strategies, as shown in the obtained overall mean and
standard deviation of 4.41 and .623, respectively. The result indicates that out-of-field teachers continue to adjust to give the
learning the students deserve. According to Carag (2020), it is important to note how teachers employ because doing so helps
students receive a high-quality education. It is now the responsibility of the knowledge supplier to disclose the methods used to
keep track of the types of students in the classroom.
Obtaining the highest mean of 4.46 (SD=.673) and verbal interpretation of agree is communicated well with other
MAPEH teachers to learn how to teach the subject. This means that out-of-field teachers do not disregard the significance of
communication in an academic institution. Communication and collaboration among teachers lead to school improvement and
student success because it allows teachers to delegate tasks that allow each to feel effective and fosters the development of
significant professional and personal relationships. It also allows non-major teachers to get additional information and improve
their knowledge about the lessons they will deliver in class.
Based on the Department of Education (DepEd) Memorandum Number 050 series 2020 contains the professional
development for teachers priorities for the school years 2020-2023, a variety of efficient diagnostic, formative, and summative
assessment procedures that are in line with curriculum requirements must be designed, selected, organized, and used by teachers
in collaboration with colleagues.
Table 11. Assessment of the Respondents on the Coping Strategies Utilized in Terms of Careful Guidance
Indicators Mean SD VI
Invite the school head, master, or head teacher to observe my class and provide 4.15 .833 Agree
technical assistance
1. Participate in collaborative discussions with my co-teachers in MAPEH and 4.41 .698 Agree
other learning areas
2. Discuss my strategy with my co-workers and mentors for any unfamiliar content 4.39 .665 Agree
3. Follow my mentors' advice in strengthening my MAPEH teaching strategies. 4.41 .712 Agree
4. Apply my mentor's advice to improve my personal and professional development 4.46 .642 Agree
in teaching MAPEH.
Overall 4.36 .608 Agree
Table 11 reveals that the respondents agreed that they utilized careful guidance as one of the strategies as out-of-field teachers as
it obtained an overall mean of 4.36, standard deviation of .608. This finding suggests that non-specialist teachers are consulting
those who have more experience. It is quite helpful to get technical support or guidance from mentors, school administrators, head
teachers, master teachers, and subject-matter experts. It is congruent with Mott (2015), stating that professional teachers learn
through different modes. One is learning in the inquiry mode, which is exploratory and cooperative, and produces a synthesis or
creation of new techniques or concepts.
When viewed separately, applying my mentor's advice to improve my personal and professional development in teaching MAPEH
obtained the highest weighted mean of 4.46 and verbally interpreted as agree. Technical assistance provided by the mentors
should be applied in the class, particularly in delivering the lessons. The result can be supported by Strauss et al. (2015) as he cited
that teachers as mentees should be open to feedback, be active listeners, and be respectful of their mentor's input and time.
Table 12. Assessment of the Respondents on the Coping Strategies Utilized in Terms of Attentive Leadership
Indicators Mean SD VI
1. know how to establish and maintain professional relationships with my superiors, 4.49 .643 Agre
co-workers, and students
2. tend to overcome barriers to reach my goals 4.34 .685 Agree
3. seek out additional information from the school leader, teacher, or some other source 4.48 .559 Agree
4. Welcome others to challenge my ideas and strategies constantly 4.35 .672 Agree
5. seek feedback as a way of understanding myself as a teacher 4.45 .702 Agree
Overall 4.42 .563 Agree
The attained composite mean of 4.42 (SD=.563) suggests that the respondents agreed on attentive leadership as a strategy for out-
of-field teachers. It means the respondents deeply understand their strengths and shortcomings and know how they manifest in
their interactions. It could also mean the respondents know how to manage their weaknesses properly. The result is consistent with
Walt (2018) when he stated that attentive leaders intimately know their strengths and weaknesses and how they are expressed in
their behavior towards others. He also stated that authentic leaders can thoughtfully compensate for their weaknesses and manage
them wisely.
As agreed, obtaining the highest mean of 4.49 (SD=.643) is knowing how to establish and maintain a professional
relationship with my superiors, co-workers, and students. However, if there is one job where maintaining harmonious
relationships among professionals is crucial, it is teaching. Meador (2019) supports this finding by suggesting that professionalism
is a quality every educator and school employee should possess. Also, Cassiatori (2021) cited that effective teachers form
authentic, caring relationships with their students. He further stated that a healthy relationship between the teachers and
stakeholders is important, enabling everybody to work together and positively impacting the students harmoniously.
Moreover, the item tended to overcome barriers to reach my goals and attained the lowest weighted mean of 4.33 and
standard deviation of .685. It suggests that even out-of-field teacher-respondents always find ways to overcome the challenges
they face in teaching MAPEH subjects. It is consistent with what the respondents said, who admitted that there are times when
they are unsure of whether the materials they produce for the students are accurate and would help them achieve proficiency. They
view them as teachers, and professionalism must always be upheld.
Apart from being a good indicator of teachers' effectiveness, teachers' self-efficacy is essential for an effective school and
academic program. The process of restructuring schools and establishing effective schools are believed to be determined by the
teachers' self-efficacy, which is an important variable that must be considered.
It can be gleaned from the table that the overall level of the respondents' performance in terms of self-efficacy is 4.38
(SD=.563) and verbally interpreted as agree. It indicates that despite the respondents being given subjects that are out of the area
of their expertise, they still believe that they can somehow teach their students well. The respondents confirmed during the usual
conversation with the researcher that during the first days of handling the subject, they had low self-efficacy and were not
motivated because they had to study a new set of subjects. About the findings of Hobbs and Porsch (2021), the result of out-of-
field teaching promotes learning opportunities, and the experience of educators teaching the subject multiple times caused an
increase in educators' perceived capacity. Experience leads to improved confidence among out-of-field educators. This result is
also congruent with the findings of Kini and Podolsky (2016), which showed that as educators gain experience, their students
learn more and are more likely to do better in school attendance.
The results also revealed that inspiring the learners to produce meaningful concepts and worthwhile performance got the
highest weighted mean of 4.46 and was verbally interpreted as agree. Despite the difficulty that they are also new to the subject
they are teaching, teachers are very much dedicated to ensuring quality education by doing their best to help students learn and
Table 16. Significant Relationship Between Challenges, Coping Strategies, And Self-Efficacy
Challenges Self-Efficacy
The transition from initial teacher education to novice .134
Ongoing teacher learning .098
Formal professional development .037
Coping Strategies
Content Knowledge .578**
Context-Specific Pedagogical Skills .727**
Careful Guidance .695**
Attentive Leadership .711**
It can be seen from Table 16 that there is a significant relationship between coping strategies and self-efficacy variables. On the
one hand, a moderate to strong relationship is seen between variables.
Every teacher is expected to perform certain roles in the workplace. And the performance of those expected roles
depends upon an individual" s belief about his capacity to perform those roles effectively. Nevertheless, some teachers are given
tasks that were not part of their previous training, such as the case of out-of-field teachers. The challenge for them is how they
would believe they can teach the subjects well and figure out what coping they can use to overcome the challenges. The result
shows a moderately significant relationship between the respondents' coping strategies and self-efficacy variables. Jex et al.
(2016) support the finding in which he argues that individuals with high self-efficacy confidently believe in their abilities to
respond to the environment stimulus and maintain self-control effectively. Salanova (2015) also considered self-efficacy a
dominant organizational catalyst that can help develop actions and effective strategies (active coping strategies) for defeating or
mitigating the issues caused by the educational factors that affect teachers' performances.
Rosenbaum (1990) presented a theory of learned resourcefulness that suggested that individuals who are rich in
resourcefulness can cope better with stress than those who are poor. They achieve this result by minimizing the negative
consequences of stress.
There is a significant relationship between coping strategies and performance variables. Moderate to strong relationship was seen
between the variables. As Gustems-Carnicer et al. (2019) cited, teachers should be given ample space to relieve stress through
coping strategies and improve themselves as indispensable catalysts of the academic environment. Like other professionals,
teachers experience stress and use avoidance of coping strategies, affecting their performance in the workplace.
Table 18. Mediating Effect of Self-Efficacy Between Coping Strategies and Performance
Indirect Effects Effect SE LLCI ULCI
C→SE→P .0481 .0569 -.0448 .1790
CS→SE→P .3749 .0918 .2043 .5586
Completely Standardized Indirect Effects
C→SE→P .0791 .0860 -.0812 .2501
CS→SE→P .3735 .0832 .2151 .5448
Mediation analyses were initiated using PROCESS Macro v4.1 following the procedure of Hayes (2022). Findings revealed that
Self-Efficacy constructs do not mediate the relationship between Challenges and Performance. On the other hand, Self-Efficacy
could explain the variations in Coping Strategies and Performance Scores. These indirect effects are statistically different from
zero, as revealed by a biased-corrected bootstrap confidence interval based on 5,000 samples from the lower and upper limit class
interval. The result indicates that overall Self-Efficacy can transmit the effect of being influenced by Coping Strategies, increasing
performance. It can also be noticed that overall Self-Efficacy demonstrated the highest mediating effect of Coping Strategies on
Performance (CS=.3749). This indirect effect means that respondents who differ by one unit in their reported Coping Strategies
are estimated to vary by 37.35% units on the performance. The results further explain that for those with relatively higher Coping
Strategies, realizing their Self-Efficacy later translates into greater Performance.
The result is synonymous with the definition of self-efficacy provided by Schawarzer and Hallum (2016) that it is the
perceived competence of the teacher to cope with all challenges and hassles accumulated with their career. Also, Pethe and
Chaudhari (2016) stated that an individual with higher self-efficacy believes that he can perform organizational tasks.
V. CONCLUSIONS
1. Majority of the respondents were female, 26-30 years old, attained a bachelor's Degree, Filipino major, and had been in the
teaching profession for 0-3 years.
2. The respondents assessed all the indicated challenges to a moderate degree.
3. The respondents also rated agreeing with all the indicated coping strategies.
4. The level of performance of the respondents as too hard and human skills were both rated agree by the respondents, which
means a high-level performance.
5. The respondents rated the level of self-efficacy agree, implying true of me assessment.
6. There is a significant relationship between coping strategies and self-efficacy variables. On the one hand, a moderate to strong
relationship was seen between variables. Thus, the research null hypothesis is accepted.
7. There is a significant relationship between coping strategies and performance variables. A moderate to strong relationship was
seen between variables; hence, the research null hypothesis is partially sustained.
8. Self-Efficacy does not mediate the relationship between Challenges and Performance. It led to the acceptance of the research
null hypothesis.
REFERENCES
1) Abas, Jr. R. (2019). Challenges of BSED MAPEH Program at the College of Teacher Education. Batangas State
University. Pablo Borbon, Main Campus I. Batangas City.
2) Abulon, E. L. R. (2017). Basic education teachers' concept of effective teaching: Inputs to teacher education curriculum
in the Philippies. International Journal of Research Studies in Education, 3(3): 35-48.
3) Adela Solís, Ph.D. • IDRA Newsletter • August 2009. Pedagogical Content Knowledge- What Matters Most in the
Professional Learning of Content Teachers in Classrooms with Diverse Student Populations,
https://www.idra.org/resource-center/pedagogical-content-knowledge/
4) Akareem, H.S., 2016. Determinants of education quality: What makes students" perception different? Open Review of
Educational Research, 3(1): 52-67.
5) Akhavan, N., & Tracz, S. (2016). The effects of coaching on teacher efficacy, academic optimism and student
achievement: The consideration of a continued professional development option for teachers. Journal of Education and
Human Development, 5(3), 38-53. https://doi.org/10.15640/ jehd.v5n3a5.
6) Augusto, W.S, Jumior. (2019). A phenomenological study on the lived experience of the out-of-field mentors. Cebu
Normal University. Cebu City, Philippines.
7) Bala, C. (2017). Problems encountered in K to 12 curriculum. DepEd Nueva Ecija. Retrieved from
http://depedne.net/?page=news&action=detai ls&opt=popup&REFECODE=ARPRO20170 70 002.
8) Baldoni, J. (2010). The importance of resourcefulness. Harvard Business Review. Retrieved October 28, 2016, from
https://hbr.org/2010/01/leaders-canlearn-to-make-do-a/.
9) Bayani, R., & Guhao Jr., E. (2017). Out-of-Field Teaching: Experiences of Non-Filipino Majors. International Journal of
Education, Development, Society and Technology, 5(11), 91–127. https://zenodo.org/record/1423235#.YAr10OgzbIU.
10) Bryant, J. (2016). Teachers are increasingly frustrated, and that's bad for students. Retrieved October 20, 2016 from
http://www.alternet.org/education/teachers-areincreasingly-frustrated-and-thats-bad-students
11) Caylao, F. R. (2015). My thoughts on out-of-field teaching. Sun.Star Pampanga. Retrieved November 5, 2016 from
https://www.pressreader.com/.
12) Cinkir, S. and Kurum, G. (2015). Discrepancy in teacher employment: the problem of out-of-field teacher employment.
Ankara University.
13) Craig, C. J. (2016). Structure of Teacher Education." In International Handbook of Teacher Education, edited
by J. Loughran and M. Hamilton, 69–135. Singapore: Springer.
doi:https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-0366-0_3. [Crossref], [Google Scholar].
14) Deci, E. L., & Ryan, R. M. (2015). Self-determination theory: A macrotheory of human motivation, development, and
health. Canadian Psychology, 49(3), 182-185. doi: 10.1037/a0012801.
15) Du Plessis, A. E. 2017. Out-of-Field Teaching Practices: What Educational Leaders Need to Know. Sense Publishers.
doi:https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-6300-953-9. [Crossref], [Google Scholar].
16) Faulkner, F., J. Kenny, C. Campbell, and C. Crisan. (2019). Teacher learning and continuous professional development.
in examining the phenomenon of "teaching out-of-field": international perspectives on teaching as a non-specialist, edited
by L. Hobbs and G. Törner, 269–308. Singapore: Springer.
doi:https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-3366-8_11. [Crossref], [Google Scholar].
17) Geoffrey Phelps, Stephen Schilling.(2004). Developing Measur eloping Measures of Content K es of Content Knowledge
for T nowledge for Teaching eaching Reading.
18) Gielnik, M. M., Bledow, R., and Stark, M. S. (2020). A dynamic account of self-efficacy in entrepreneurship. J. Appl.
Psychol. 105, 487–496. doi: 10.1037/ apl0000451.