Implementation Challenges of Condominium Housing
Implementation Challenges of Condominium Housing
BY:
(Ph.D. Candidate)
February 2022
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Foremost, deserving of all our thanks and praise is God, the Almighty, for providing us with
health and unconditional love to complete this task.
We would like to express our sincere and deepest gratitude to our Instructor Mss. Bosena Y.
(Ph.D. Candidate), for the intellectual support and invaluable motherly guidance we received
throughout the course.
We would also like to acknowledge the Bole Gerji condominium site Corporation Manager, all
committee members, and residents of the site for their generous contribution and support to
conducting this study.
i
Challenges of condominium Housing
CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT.............................................................................................................................i
LIST OF FIGURES.....................................................................................................................................iii
LIST OF TABLES.......................................................................................................................................iii
ABBREVIATIONS.....................................................................................................................................iv
CHAPTER ONE...........................................................................................................................................1
1. INTRODUCTION................................................................................................................................1
1.1. Background of the study...............................................................................................................1
CHAPTER TWO..........................................................................................................................................2
2. REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE...........................................................................................2
2.1. Definition and Concept.................................................................................................................2
2.2. The Importance of Condominium.................................................................................................2
2.3. Challenges of Condominium housing...........................................................................................3
CHAPTER THREE.......................................................................................................................................4
3. PROBLEM STATEMENT AND OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY.....................................................4
3.1. Problem statement.........................................................................................................................4
3.2. Objectives......................................................................................................................................4
3.2.1. General objective..................................................................................................................4
3.2.2. Specific Objective.................................................................................................................4
3.3. Research Questions.......................................................................................................................4
CHAPTER FOUR.........................................................................................................................................5
4. STUDY AREA DESCRIPTION AND RESEARCH METHODOLOGY..........................................5
4.1. Study area and Scope of the Study................................................................................................5
4.1.1. Study Area.............................................................................................................................5
4.1.2. Scope of the study.................................................................................................................5
4.2. Source of data................................................................................................................................5
4.3. Sampling technique and Size........................................................................................................6
4.3.1. Sampling technique...............................................................................................................6
4.3.2. Sampling Size.......................................................................................................................6
4.3.3. Data instruments...................................................................................................................6
4.4. Methods of data analysis...............................................................................................................6
CHAPTER FIVE...........................................................................................................................................7
5. RESULT & DISCUSSION..................................................................................................................7
5.1. Results and Discussion..................................................................................................................7
5.2. Major Findings............................................................................................................................14
CHAPTER SIX...........................................................................................................................................15
6. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS...............................................................................15
6.1. Conclusion..................................................................................................................................15
6.2. Recommendations.......................................................................................................................15
REFERENCES............................................................................................................................................16
ii
Challenges of condominium Housing
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1 Map of the study area (source, ArcGIS and Google Earth pro: modified by group
members..........................................................................................................................................5
Figure 2 current building condition of Gerji condominium site.....................................................8
Figure 3 current environmental condition of Gerjy condominium site..........................................9
Figure 4 current playground and electrical installation condition of Gerji condominium site.....11
Figure 5 administrative office of Gerjy condominium site...........................................................12
Figure 6 current security gate condition of Gerjy condominium site...........................................13
Figure 7 current sanitary condition of Gerjy condominium site...................................................14
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1 Gerji condominium housing affordability.........................................................................7
Table 2 Quality of the houses.........................................................................................................8
Table 3 Environment.......................................................................................................................9
Table 4 Social and cultural interaction.........................................................................................10
Table 5 Infrastructure and facilities..............................................................................................11
Table 6 Administration.................................................................................................................11
Table 7 Security............................................................................................................................12
Table 8 Security............................................................................................................................13
iii
Challenges of condominium Housing
ABBREVIATIONS
CBE: Commercial Bank of Addis Ababa
ETB: Ethiopian Birr
FDRE: Federal democratic republic of Ethiopia
GTZ: German Technical Cooperation
IHDP: Integrated housing development program
MWUD: Ministry of Works and Urban Development
UN-HABITANT - United Human Settlement Program
iv
Challenges of condominium Housing
CHAPTER ONE
1. INTRODUCTION
Housing is a basic necessity for human beings. In the world, there are different housing
typologies, of which condominium is one of them. Condominiums represent one type of
common interest legal tenure, combining detached and individually-owned property with
undivided fractional ownership of common areas and infrastructure (Stefan R. Treffers and
Randy K. Lippert, 2019). The condominium is a dominant and popular form of home ownership
in metropolitan areas, with an escalating popularity of owner-occupied homes in the last couple
of decades (Yip, N. Chang, C. and Hung, 2007). Its development has helped land-use policies to
encourage urban intensification, and displaced other forms of residential tenure (Stefan R.
Treffers and Randy K. Lippert, 2019). Yet, managing and up-keeping such homes poses a
challenge to most condominium owners, with larger condominiums equipped with sophisticated
facilities becoming increasingly popular (Yip, N. Chang, C. and Hung, 2007)
This has been accomplished through the collaboration of a variety of stakeholders, including
financial institutions, government agencies, and brokers. Proclamation No. 370/2003 provides
the legal framework for the program. Since 2004, a nationwide condominium construction
program has been in place, with numerous houses constructed. (Workineh, 2022)
Bole Gerji in Addis Ababa was the first condominium project to be constructed in Ethiopia. It
was initiated by GTZ and the Addis Ababa City Administration in 2002, following a request
from the Mayor. The first master plan for the design of the project was drawn by renowned
architect Fasil Giorgis and accommodated 750 housing units, composed of studios, 1 and 2-
bedroom typologies; an office building and several commercial units. (UN-HABITAT, (2011)
The study aimed at seeking to identify, investigate, analyze, and answer the major questions
about the challenges of condominium housing specially in the case of Bole Gerji condominium
site. Then forward the possible recommendations and measurement that should be taken to
handle those challenges.
CHAPTER TWO
Housing is one of the basic needs/rights of human beings. When we say “housing” it is beyond
the physical framework of the building (floor, roof and walls), and includes giving permanent
and reliable security to residents, ensuring the resident’s land use and permanent property
ownership rights and having sufficient moving and working space. In addition to these, there
should be access to infrastructure, social and economic services, which are among basic needs
and important for a healthy life, inside and nearby the house at affordable prices (FDRE, 2013)
The above definitions are important for this research paper because they have indicated what an
adequate housing should include. These things can be seen as a factor which leads residents to
be satisfied or not on their housing and the environment.
Condominium housing is a name given to the form of housing tenure where each resident
household owns their individual unit, but equally shares ownership and responsibility for the
communal areas and facilities of the building, such as hallways, heating systems, and
elevators. There is no individual ownership over plots of land. All of the land on a
condominium site is owned by all home owners. Usually, the external maintenance of the roof
and walls are undertaken by a Condominium association that jointly represents ownership of
the whole complex, employing strict management to ensure funding from each homeowner
(UN-HABITAT, (2011)
Today, the prevailing wisdom emphasizes that condominiums are more valuable than
cooperatives and any other privately or real estate housing supply means in many ways. As
stated (Lesner, 2012) home clubs (original owners-occupied building) morphed into
cooperatives, in which the building is legally structured as a corporation, with the residents
owning shares based on the size of their apartments. They became somewhat popular in New
York and elsewhere, though their appeal was limited because financing and reselling the 24
units was legally complex. Umberger also underlined the Lesner’s emphasis as, despite the
agonies of some condo boards and homeowner associations whose clashes over property rights
have generated headlines, that condos are here to stay and probably will grow13 as an aging
population eschews the maintenance of single-family homes.
The challenges in condominium housing development stem from poorly designed open spaces,
lack of strong administration, facility, infrastructure, awareness and houses with limited
greenery and indoor air (Weldeyesus, 2019). The other challenges identified were well-suited
funding mechanisms, finance, affordability and maintenance issues. (Duffhues, 2019). To some
extent, condominium development influences the urban form and lives of local residents and
thus implicates various aspects of social sustainability to some extent (Qing, 2018). On the other
hand, in condominium house development, sustainability from the economic perspective is
given more emphasis than social well-being and environmental protection (Arku, 2020). The
researcher's arguments focused on the challenges of condominium housing that existed in the
country. In addition, communal condominium space management was addressed by many
researchers.
While the IHDP has the laudable aim of targeting the low-income sector of the population,
unfortunately experience has shown that the low-income groups are not benefiting from the
IHDP due to inability to afford the service related costs and monthly service payments. (UN-
HABITAT, (2011)
The housing administration function is wide-ranging, covering aspects of estate and tenancy
management at both a strategic level and day-to-day contact with individual tenants (Blomé,
2019)In condominium houses, there are common resources that are different from natural
resources. Design principles, the communal resource boundary should be clearly designed and
the use and provision of the resources should be adaptable to the local community (Foster &
Iaione, 2019).
Economics and Sociology of Housing 3
Challenges of condominium Housing
CHAPTER THREE
Like most housing projects in Ethiopia, condominium housing was challenged by different
factors from the start of the project to that of the occupancy stage, some of the major challenges
are affordability, quality of the houses, environmental quality, social and cultural interaction,
accessibility to infrastructure and facilities and that of maintenance. So, this paper assessed the
case of Gerji condominium housing in relation to the major challenges of condominium housing
indicated above.
3.2. Objectives
The principal objective of this research was to Asses and investigate the implementation
challenges of the condominium housing in the case of Bole Gerji condominium.
CHAPTER FOUR
Figure 1 Map of the study area (source, ArcGIS and Google Earth pro: modified by group members)
4.1.2. Scope of the study
Geographically: The study conducted on Addis Ababa, Bole Gerji condominium which is
geographically located at 9° 0'1.47" North latitude and 38°48'4.19" East longitude.
Thematically: the study focusses on challenges of condominium housing. It includes
affordability, quality of housing, infrastructure and other challenges.
4.2. Source of data
In this research both primary and secondary data sources are used. The primary data sources are
an interview questionnaire filled by the residents of condominium housing units and
interviews/discussions with key informants and experts on the issues. The secondary data
sources are published or unpublished documents.
Sample size for qualitative research varies with different scholars. While some experts in
qualitative research avoid the topic of “how many” interviews “are enough,” there is indeed
variability in what is suggested as a minimum. An extremely large number of articles, book
chapters, and books recommend guidance and suggest anywhere from 5 to 50 participants as
adequate (Shari 2012).
Among the residents in Gerji condominium the sample taken was Eleven households, four
committee managers. three environmental protection and green area development office team
leaders and the rest four focus group of resident members who have better knowledge. And also,
three experts and professionals were interviewed about the challenges of condominium housing.
For this specific research we have used in-depth interview for the experts and professionals,
structured questionnaires for the residents of Gerji condominium and also detail site observation
and random discussions used as instruments of data.
The data was analyzed using both qualitative and quantitative methods. The data collected via a
questionnaire was analyzed quantitatively. The information gathered through interviews,
observations, and document reviews was analyzed qualitatively or quantitatively.
CHAPTER FIVE
This part of the research deals with the findings from the survey, observations, and documents,
and the result of the analysis of the gathered data have been presented below as follows:
Currently, 90% of the households from 374 dueling units in Gerji condominium are rented to
people who work at the airport and other bigger institutions due to their high rental value most
of the owners prefer to rent their units and rent cheaper houses in another location. The smallest
rental price for a 24m2 studio on this site is around 8000 ETB per month which is higher than
the average monthly income of most of the Addis Ababa people.
Quality of the houses
In relation to most of the houses in Addis Ababa which is characterized by one-room houses
with no access to the sanitary system and poor construction materials which as mud and wood
(Matsumoto & Crook, 2021) the condominium housing is much better since has durable
construction material, access to infrastructure and sanitary system.
Since Gerji condominium housing is the first IHDP in the country its main quality problem
arises from that the design of the building, space provision, workmanship, and integration of
different stockholders
From the site observation it is clearly seen that there was a great problem in the integration of
different stakeholders during the design and construction of these houses which is mainly
manifested by the improper electrical and sanitary installation and very small space provision
which forces the occupants to use the corridors as a storage space other than this the building is
found in good physical quality when its compared to most of the houses in Addis Ababa due to
seasonal maintenance and good care
No 6 54.55
Enhanced mutual respect Yes 10 90.9
No 1 9.1
Helped with sharing and immediate problem Yes 9 81.8
solving No 2 19.2
Source: Field Survey
As indicated in table 4, most of the respondents agreed that there is good mutual respect between
the occupants and there is also a better and fast way of solving problems using the guidance of
the resident welfare association of the condominium but most believed that their social
Economics and Sociology of Housing 10
Challenges of condominium Housing
interaction is not that much strong this is due to lack of assurance of stability for rental
homeowners.
Infrastructure and facilities
The presence of adequate infrastructure and services serves as the backbone for growth and is
essential for community health, safety, and quality of life. in the case of the Gerji condominium
site, there are different communal service facilities like parking area, traditional kitchen, beauty
salons, small shops, groceries, supermarket, barber shop and so on which greatly reduce the
distance for the occupants to reach this place in their day to day life since they are located within
a 110-minute walking radius.
Table 5 Infrastructure and facilities
Challenges Response Frequency Percentage
Distance from social services Low 4 36.4
High 7 63.6
Nearer to workplace Yes 8 72.7
No 3 27.3
Infrastructure’s integration Low 6 54.55
High 5 45.45
Trait and problem to pay the service cost Low 7 63.6
High 4 36.4
Source: Field Survey
As indicated in table 5, most of the respondents found this site more accessible to different
social services and to that their workplaces, the major challenge was the lack of enough parking
space for all the households, playground, and poor integration between the building and that of
the electrical sanitary and other communication networks.
Figure 4 current playground and electrical installation condition of Gerji condominium site
Administration
The presence of communal spaces and facilities, parking areas, green areas, shared walls and
corridors forces every condominium to form a certain type of administrative system that can
manage these sorts of facilities for the common good of the occupant on behalf of them. In the
case of Gerji, they have formed a residential welfare association which is called Adwa park
condominium site public association to manage this common facility, perform maintenance
when needed, and resolve conflicts that may arise between the occupants.
This association is currently working on keeping the security of the compound, cleaning the
environment, and conflict-solving areas
Table 6 Administration
Challenges Response Frequency Percentage
Administration system Good 7 63.6
Poor 4 36.4
Community participation in the management High 8 72.7
Low 3 27.3
Condominium management Good 8 72.7
Poor 3 27.3
Source: Field Survey
As indicated in table 6, most of the respondents found that the administration system of the
resident welfare association is well organized, participatory, and effective in the provision of
maintenance and conflict management when needed
Table 7 Security
Challenges Response Frequency Percentage
Did you feel safe inside the Yes 9 81.8
compound No 2 19.2
Is the conflict-solving mechanism Yes 8 72.7
effective and quick? No 3 27.3
As indicated in table 7, most of the respondents found the security and conflict management
system which is led by the residential welfare association of Gerji condominium more effective,
and for this reason, they don’t have any major incidents up to now. There is also some degree of
violation of regulations by the occupants especially on dry waste management, corridor usage
and service payment which mainly arises from negligence, shortage of space and the working
hour of the residential welfare association which is from 2:30-10:30 respectively.
As indicated in table 7, most of the respondents agreed that the structural component of this
condominium site is in good condition and doesn’t need that much maintenance except the stair
which needs maintenance every five years. The finishing is also renewed in a regular interval by
the resident welfare association after conducting a discussion with the occupants so it is now in
good condition generally the main challenge of maintenance in this site is that of sewerage line
maintenance which almost requires multiple maintenance in every weak due to improper design
and installation of the sewerage lines and due to that of improper usage by the occupants.
Since Gerji condominium was the first in its kind its focus was mainly of providing
affordable housing for the poor and it neglect the design quality and space standards.
Due to high priorities given and the small scale of the project enables its construction to be
finished in eight months which is unlikely in current other condominium housings
Gerjy condominium is not affordable to the majority of Addis Ababa peoples to rent or own
since the minimum rental price in this site is 8000 ETB which is more than the average
monthly income of the Addis Ababa people
Affordability of this hoses is highly affected by location, land value, shortage of housing and
increasing demand of housing in this area
the poor quality of condominium houses in this site arises from the lack of integrated design
which leads to poor electrical, sanitary and other communication network lines installations,
in addition lack of enough interior space provision and the absence of cloth washing and
drying space are the major challenges which affect the quality of the houses
Absence of children’s playground forces children to play on corridors and streets
The environment of this site is kept green and clean but almost all the green spaces provided
are not physically accessible to the occupants
The social and cultural interaction of the peoples in this site is greatly affected by the tenure
type of the occupant since around 90% of the occupants are rented and doesn’t have strong
assurance on their stability they don’t participate in the major social structure like Edir.
This site has a good accessibility to different facilities and services but it is seen that there is
a great problem of with water availability and placement of electrical facilities
The major administrative challenges are that of violation of the regulations especially on
corridor usage, working hour of the association which is the same as the working hour of the
occupants and that of delayed payment of service payment to the resident welfare
association.
CHAPTER SIX
6.1. Conclusion
Generally Gerji site condominium found in good condition physically and with a well-organized
management system to solve any conflict and to manage and protect the safety, security and
webbings of the neighborhood. The cleanness of the compound the secured environment, the
presence of different services and facilities in the compound like small shops, supermarkets,
barber shops, beauty salon and many mores, the availability of green areas, a well-organized
maintenance and conflict solving makes the life of the occupants more healthier and easier. But
this site is highly challenged by the lack of enough space inside the housing, improper usage of
corridor spaces, lack of washing and drying spaces for cloths, lack of playground for children’s,
violation of minor regulation, increasing cost of the rent and lack of enough parking area that
can accommodate the existing 374 households of the neighborhood.
6.2. Recommendations
The installation of electrical and other communication lie is better be provided under ground
To overcome the shortage of water there should be a water tanker provision for all blocks
It’s better to find a best way to place satellite dishes to minimize their negative visual impact
on the buildings
The green areas should be better accessible to the occupants
The working hour of the residential welfare association should be extended so that the
occupants could contact the after-work hour
Parking area should be increased to accommodate 374 households of the neighborhood since
their current capacity is around 30 cars
To overcome the increasing high cost of rent there should be an alternative housing
accessibility in this area to accommodate the high housing demand
REFERENCES