Fouling and Corrosion in An Aero Gas Turbine Compressor: Technicalarticle-Peer-Reviewed
Fouling and Corrosion in An Aero Gas Turbine Compressor: Technicalarticle-Peer-Reviewed
(2015) 15:837–845
DOI 10.1007/s11668-015-0023-8
TECHNICAL ARTICLE—PEER-REVIEWED
Abstract This paper deals with the study carried out on are present in dry air. In addition, there is always the
fouling and corrosion problems in an aero gas turbine presence of salts, contaminants, and humidity in the engine
engine which operates from coastal environment. Various inlet air depending on the local condition of the place
parameters responsible for such problems are presented in where the aircraft or engine is positioned [1]. Their pres-
the paper which causes deterioration in performance and ence in air deteriorates the engine performance due to
leads to failure of the components. Prevention and control foreign object damage, erosion, fouling, blockage of
procedures for fouling and corrosion are also highlighted. cooling passages, particle fusion, and cold and hot corro-
Compressor washes such as performance recovery wash sion [1, 2]. Low-pressure compressor (fan) and high-
and desalination wash are found to be very effective in pressure compressor being the front-end components of the
addressing these issues. The frequency of compressor wash engine are affected most due to these elements. Thus,
is to be judiciously worked out from the corrosion rate and compressor fouling and corrosion have become a serious
performance deterioration points of view. concern, and its control and prevention are of priority for
engine operators. Fouling is the degradation in perfor-
Keywords Corrosion failure analysis mance of a turbine engine due to the build-up of
Corrosion fatigue Environmental degradation contaminants on the various aerodynamic surfaces [3]. An
Gas turbine example of low-pressure compressor fouling is shown in
Fig. 1. It results in a drop in airflow and isentropic effi-
ciency which in turn reduces the thrust or power output of
Introduction the engine.
Fouling can also cause engine surge or flame blowout
Many military gas turbines operate from air bases in due to shifting of operating line toward surge line, flow
coastal regions or from offshore platforms even from small distortion, and aerodynamic mismatch as shown in Fig. 2
islets due to strategic reasons. Also many engines takeoff [4, 5]. Investigations have shown that majority of low
from unprepared runways and are subjected to arduous thrust, low spool speed, and high exhaust gas temperature
environment. The standard atmosphere is composed of a cases are attributed to compressor fouling. Compressor
mixture of gases. Although the major constituents are fouling accounts for about 70–85% of gas turbine engine
nitrogen and oxygen, there are many other gases such as performance deterioration. Fouling also has a damaging
argon, neon, helium, hydrogen, xenon, carbon dioxide and effect on compressor blading which deteriorates the
carbon monoxide, methane, oxides of nitrogen, sulfur etc. mechanical reliability of the compressor. Compressor
fouling also results in a higher turbine entry temperature
for a given power setting. This causes higher turbine entry
temperature leading to degradation of hot-end components
R. K. Mishra (&)
and higher emission levels.
Regional Centre for Military Airworthiness (Engines),
Bangalore, Karnataka 560093, India The parts of gas turbine engines which are operated in a
e-mail: [email protected] chemically reactive environment generally suffer from
123
838 J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2015) 15:837–845
Engine Configuration
Fig. 1 Fouling of a low-pressure compressor in an aero gas turbine The present study was carried on a low-bypass turbofan
engine engine with afterburner. It is a twin-spool engine of 40 kN
thrust class with multi-stage axial fan and compressor each
driven separately by single stage turbines. It has an annular
type combustion system incorporating airblast atomizers.
Schematic layout of the engine is shown in Fig. 3.
The low-pressure (LP) compressor rotor disks are bolted
together, each disk having peripheral flanges to which
blades are secured by retaining pins. The LP stator vane
assemblies are fabricated rings of vanes with inner and
outer platforms The high-pressure (HP) compressor com-
prises machined disks welded together to form a drum into
which rotor blades are keyed. Compressor stator assembly
consists of a series of vanes welded on the outer platform to
form a ring behind each row of rotor blades in each stage.
The low-pressure compressor blades are made of high-duty
Al–Cu 2618A alloy, and the vanes are made of 5056 alloy
(ASTM B316) which has strong corrosion resistance
Fig. 2 Drift in compressor operating point due to fouling characteristics.
The other modules of the engine are HP nozzle guide
vanes and turbine rotor, LP nozzle guide vanes, LP turbine
corrosion. In gas turbines, there occur two types of corro- rotor disk, rotor support system, afterburner system, gear
sion: cold corrosion and hot corrosion. Cold corrosion box, and accessories.
occurs in low- and high-pressure compressors which
operate relatively at low temperature due to wet deposits of
salts, acids, steam, and corrosive gases of various chlorides, Compressor Fouling
sulfides, and oxides. The corrosion causes reduction in the
cross-sectional properties of the material and also pitting of Fouling is the build-up of material in cavities and low flow-
the material. Cold corrosion can initiate cracks and met- rate locations along the air flow path as shown in Fig. 1.
allurgical abnormalities in the material. The hot corrosion Besides small particles as a cause for fouling, oil vapors,
occurs in the hot-end components of the engine which are water, salts, and other sticky substances working individ-
exposed to high-temperature combustion gases. Rapid ually or together create a mix of materials that find places
chemical reaction takes place between oxygen and the to adhere. These particles adhere to compressor blade
material at high temperatures. Degradation becomes more surfaces and turbine blade cooling passages. The effect is
severe with increasing contaminant concentration and is to change clearances, disrupt rotating balance, obstruct and
highly influenced by temperature [6, 7]. The present study plug flow paths, and reduce smoothness of rotating and
will focus on cold corrosion and fouling only. The paper stationary blade surfaces. Fouling is, however, usually
highlights various steps involved in the study for corrosion recoverable since there are methods available to remove
prevention in a gas turbine compressor. these deposits with online or offline washing or mechanical
123
J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2015) 15:837–845 839
123
840 J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2015) 15:837–845
Coarse [10 lm Leaves, insects, textile fibers, sand, flying ash, mist, rain, pollen and fog
Fine [1 lm Spore, cement dust, dust sediments, cloud, fog, accumulated carbon black, metal oxide smoke, oil smoke
EPA [0.01 lm Metal oxide smoke, carbon black, smog, mist, fumes, oil smoke, aerosol micro particles
123
J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2015) 15:837–845 841
123
842 J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2015) 15:837–845
Desalination Wash
123
J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2015) 15:837–845 843
Normal drinking quality water or demineralized water is Further, it was observed that the components of the
commonly used as the wash fluid for motoring wash pro- engines or aircrafts which are parked inside the hangar
cedure. Although the quality of water varies according to shed with intake and exhaust blanked are less prone to
location and season, it should meet the following minimum corrosion than those parked outside. The engines engaged
standards: in night flight were found to be less prone to salt deposits
and corrosion. The problem of corrosion was found to be
(a) Appearance: free of visible extraneous impurities
more serious during rainy days. Occasional operation from
(b) Total solids: 175 ppm (mg/L) max
offshore platforms showed a steep rise in salt deposits and
(c) pH value: 6.0–8.0 inclusive
corrosion spreading to larger areas in LP compressor.
(d) Chlorides: 15 ppm (mg/l) max
These observations have helped in defining the fre-
(e) Sulfates: 10 ppm (mg/L) max
quency for desalination wash without sacrificing the life
Compressor washing is most effective if it is performed and performance of the engines and at the same time
on a regular basis. The recommended wash schedule is avoiding over-maintenance. Adopting compressor wash at
presented in Table 3. However, the frequency of wash is suitable intervals using R-MC-G21 cleaning agent, the
decided based on the operational environment and the rate corrosion has been prevented to a large extent. Figures 11
of corrosion experienced at a particular location. Abrasive and 12 show almost corrosion-free low compressor pas-
compressor cleaning is accomplished by injecting an sages and blades which have been significantly improved
abrasive media into the compressor inlet during normal compared to that in Figs. 7 and 8.
operation. Walnut shells, rice, fluid catalytic cracking Compressor-turbine desalination wash is also strongly
(FCC) catalyst, glass beads, and other media have been recommended when operating in salt laden atmosphere.
utilized. The size and quantity of the cleaner are important When desalination washes are done in conjunction with
for obtaining a good flow path cleaning and not causing each other it is essential that the compressor wash is done
damage to the compressor flow path components. first.
Aggressive abrasive cleaning can readily cause erosion
damage to both the corrosion resistant coatings and the
compressor airfoils.
In the present study, 10 aero engines were monitored on
daily basis for 15 days in an air base at a coastal location.
The exercise was started from the day of after the desali-
nation wash of the compressors. Whitish-color salt deposits
and carbon deposits were noticed on LP compressor rotor
blade surfaces. Leading edge of the stage 1 blades was also
observed with minor salt deposits. Mild corrosion noticed
on some of the bolt heads. No corrosion marks noticed on
the rotor flow path area and air intake fairing. The quantity
of salt deposits found to increase up to day 3 or day 4. After
that, the progressive daily variation of salt deposits and
corrosion marks on the blades and rotor path areas were
found to be negligible. Also no additional area was affected
by corrosion in subsequent days. It was observed that the
engines which have logged less service hours or consumed
less calendar life are less prone to corrosion than the old
Fig. 11 State of air intake fairing with scheduled compressor wash
engines with less life left.
Continuously salt laden Desalination wash Daily. After last flight of day
Frequently salt laden Desalination wash Weekly. To suit engine condition
Occasionally salt laden Desalination wash Bi-weekly. To suit engine condition
All Performance recovery wash Generally at every 30 ± 5 h but based on engine
operating conditions. Motoring wash is recommended
123
844 J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2015) 15:837–845
Conclusion
123
J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2015) 15:837–845 845
2. SAE Aerospace Information Report: Environmental Control 12. M. Naeem, Impacts of low-pressure (LP) compressors’ fouling of
System Contamination, SAE International, 2007, New York a turbofan upon operational-effectiveness of a military aircraft.
3. Rainer Kurz, Klaus Brun, Degradation of gas turbine perfor- Appl. Energy 85, 243–270 (2008)
mance in natural gas service. J. Nat. Gas Sci. Eng. 1, 95–102 13. A. Hamed, W. Tabakoff, R. Wenglarz, Erosion and deposition in
(2009) turbomachinery. J. Propuls. Power 22(2), 350–360 (2006)
4. C. Meher-Homji, A. Bromley, Gas turbine axial compressor 14. D. Watson, D. Carter, C.D. Alleyne, Cleaning turbomachinery
fouling and washing, in Proceedings of the 33rd Turbomachinery without disassembly, online and offline, in Proceedings of 24th
Symposium (2004) Turbomachinery Symposium (1995)
5. M.T. Gresh, M. Sassos, A. Watson, Axial air compressor— 15. D.H. Linden, Long term operating experience with corrosion
maintaining peak efficiency, in Proceeding of the Twenty-First control in industrial axial flow compressors, in Proceedings of 14th
Turbomachinery Symposium (1992) Turbomachinery Symposium (Houston, Texas, Sep 12–15, 2011)
6. I.S. Diakunchak, Performance deterioration in industrial gas 16. D.H. Linden, Corrosion control in industrial axial flow com-
turbines. J. Gas Turbine Power 114(2), 161–168 (1992) pressors, in Proceedings of 30th Turbomachinery symposium,
7. M.G. Dunn et al., Performance deterioration of a turbofan and a Turbomachinery Laboratory, Texas A & M University, Texas,
turbojet engine upon exposure to a dust environment. J. Eng. Gas pp. 115–120
Turbine Power. 109, 336–343 (1987) 17. C.B. Meher-Homji, A.B. Focke, M.B. Wooldridge, Fouling of
8. A.P. Tarabrin et al., An Analysis of Axial Compressor Fouling Axial Flow Compressors—Causes, Effects, Detection, and Con-
and a Cleaning Method of Their Blading, 96-GT-363 (ASME trol, in Proceedings of 18th Turbomachinery Symposium,
International Gas Turbine and Aeroengine Congress, Birming- Turbomachinery Laboratory, Texas A & M University, Texas,
ham, 1996) pp. 55–76
9. A.P. Tarabrin et al., Influence of Axial Compressor Fouling on 18. G.W. Goward, Progress in coatings for gas turbine aerofoils. Surf.
Gas Turbine Unit Performance Based on Different Schemes and Coat. Technol. 108–109, 73–79 (1998)
with Different Initial Parameter, 98-GT-416 (ASME Interna- 19. W. Wang, P. Dowson, A. Baha, Development of antifouling and
tional Gas Turbine and Aeroengine Congress, Stockholm, 1998) corrosion resistant coatings for petrochemical compressors, in
10. J.-P. Stalder et al., Gas turbine compressor washing state of Proceedings of 32nd Turbomachinery Symposium, Turboma-
the art: field experience. J. Eng. Gas Turbine Power Gener. 123, chinery Laboratory, Texas A & M University, Texas, (2003)
363–370 (2001) pp. 91–97
11. D.J. Stephenson et al., The interaction between corrosion and 20. M. Hetmanczyk, L. Swadzba, B. Mendala, Advanced materials
erosion during simulated sea salt compressor shedding in marine and protective coatings in aero-engines application. J. Achiev.
gas turbines. Corros. Sci. 26, 757–767 (1986) Mater. Manuf. Eng. 4(1), 372–381 (2007)
123