ONION OF INDIA s O CHAKRADHAR

AIR 20o2 Sc N9

FACT.S
Re Railway Reeuilment Boaral angalar ssneo

unies ilnk auum ist. n yunaubnu

a
delertsn klat, the
eajanolent wss inles Aa
Qumas Clakte 1996, deie tnene tirmiuatid
r o l olaleal 18.08.1999 sming to
th teasiuct
umagulor
he
deletioa. Respanslnt oneosheol
ie entira! dolmunutratiine ibnal
Ake
(cAT) ageuins!
als e4 nninala among alHera
an e ne
ind f nngularnty anel
lhoat he tannat a lelod
neapen
naible jor
penaibe lapse
th a leernilent Goard, do
dninnatng li
ke
aeleeionwd basl, ulke t e l e , gneina

dmes/ oLh cooaliolate lo

enall kium a
dulmt a
ollegotieu ndsl
CB Lnguineghats e
matter ano
l e duliua dmek a mala jiale ana
nbna

tilain d e e a t a
Me fraal e s l t
 e CAT Rlot ARat mrnly s a n hat sasu
ngilenites neie tommuttsl ntsnoleustrg dhe
electan unas n t Relel, duek gueal olegadasa

hoae
anol piuniunci, tanslelalie, h e
ANolen e
TminaliaA tansl, tiateel anolalae
oeeealings ceulol he intiates le s u e 4
neuk uhow eaune ustcrs

TssUES
1 kAhe imegulatus in deleetie jeciss L a
Jusijy he tennninabisn.af all -canoliolates
l e t i o noles eueh yocess
2 th pincynle. s f naliralyatice kaus Aaen

ialati
RELATED LAWS
nolia denaibitian
tiele 311e lle
2 oineiles a natinalutice
3 Kushna Yasla vs a aoyana
aki MatlDkahtin vslnis nola
BRIEF ARGUMENTS
dllate
seluance lbe
Ke le6rneal cauniul placeol
an

oliesion n Kialra oolar Vs tat layer

 cammitto in he ynaeLas

suleetisn da all ymauue witiobng t h dwhale dleoia

h o a l t n n t it waalol nat he ugainned h a t Lael
eleete e alsmLol uith ndirrstiual lew couas
Aee, n aueh cneumnalancer nill b r p e r l o

Cancl t h uAale aeletien. t uvas fulh sbwm

alialua! saue af innssense hane Ae reliuares

Reayanolnt
Rewanuul yer he myandt
angpuol that it

Rat it
sould he yasails h i m lo aue
o e s t i utan nlreh ha athemmas
aslenurby
manation i woltune Aiule 31lsn te drane
Raw dause nslir.
ul a alaling a
AdA dof puniahiner lnuny
n e reusal, e
Ke Amgulonntbes henejierema a
vcaulot he uolntyieal
ounnt unhopm auek astier anal AR d
hon heer dahei in l
B ant, do caneullotio
hat aueoliol nkale ailesbon
ke uuneaio i tha
snly a e who benfitd
he ngulontes by
ammitrss by tke amdmat Bsonl
dhoulo Kaue Aren uuumd nousss
onol asuan
daulol he
Takes aganst them. Al aliva k e uee alhsths

enene n a t liahle lo he lenrinale

Thei svn meut
n Kaski Math Likahitha v. UOl,wnkers aArable

mUt nnnaliol.

nslu i lo he det asisl

JUDGEMENT
he
ilagndity anel dinngolari ane

inkro i t t h uhele prieea aj i e dileetian ZRat

it leeamis imyasuible sart aut mght frsn l
e a u l t af dneh a auleetien cannat Ae

uei useanaliat s a ZRe j o r t a a consbsdate

d be olelueal dnto aRse bnhere tidse ahie

nouelid K aoleeban l a s enserrd ut
ukatyy
talle. A e t ane 4 Llese caaes tuhere it
m a heesn aisibl ta eane an inoliueolual
uaeanaliuct to e a h deleetee ansl deek Ku
aoien negonas tothe lange aeole ivoliyia
n d all enersine
illenobties ttis hese
ahe canoluelia the alectian uuhish
may f
ly le fa ti lensit a ieLe uhs Kaue Keea
dteta but e may be a few tinh may hane
 elvemed seleelicn aliAmniue but it ie alfiult Ja
do he eases dsme e warolidalo ho
Kere may ha d n he olevisi
oLe
y ishna Maslaw byus aprsint casi
Zkeeja l e o a d olceiiar
ns hefonlteal with, dle onual unas diins
allaueal.
ANALSIS
nagulatis an lle ynat a
leerunbnert losnol
Ono dDMe candislae. unhe
nere eleanby daleutf
y i e CBI, eel to sancllatisn the
nine

ie cael selcetis sanodiolali. as ae faul

e@ale
nks aMunall, lesemies.
pesthan ane a l e e

eleutLes thaLe Jrspaaablo far lu

olalng Line
dnglary
IhLe uKe ane lnnaiLnt iejaniilte
l
eeihmate tnpeeatia e dahue af degdama
npecidaan e eanslialat to de reatis
it

haloling a voletiles CB ingjiny he sdot dcaA

Kone heen rtenoleol
eegctig di Ln
Canalalatu afpan Key enere Cenbnialia. tik Zhe
Ranndmnt Boounland innsent castslatr
ady anplieatid ou le t dneihirgreas o go t a i g

aknw souue nate vaah canslialate ie negnrod

A esnly iatnpuinlall lorsea a sunslielol

oginall, barhued u h s tai wialatu

alunal uuttie e a l i alLlinssn
ouler has aa been Jablevreed Aiaretginnaa
h lemnatra ansleetaki a uesasable
anunly being head a ayloi ZRen
Case, hey
uislolho juulrss, aguuly

itgre.
nolonsl guathi hare natbee llauntal
tRe mallt URis citugue uu menely Bascal
.
2

oasie uuralerolansing aolminiaiatine lar

unLas Klnk in Zhs ailwanzd, duuckralangeal

Etgetue tinuth Onensmenl AeuOwALs delma Autile
VKe daynemme dant may kaue deinenal alK m@ne
A i g dsuiea t s tinas lo. dnch heina

olninisidd ahoulaA enght i Doslia as

danekl. duek anoll ADR ancl TDR echasnan

dl
hkely Aelliene t k uurolen af Ze dannre Leut

olitNA