armature

the Switchgear
Protection
and
Element
set 6.2.2
drivesMeasuring transducer
applying
maybefore as Element
6.2.1
nput 6.2electronic
manipulated comparison
us Thus produces designedrelays.
whenever Introduction
6.1
rectifier The study solid
value This also The 1S
the Fig.BIock static
is relaying Relayin9
quantity the The seen
be components
tripping and the is or 6.2.1
a a using state in
required basic relayresponse andquantity ofcircuits their that
required it Diagram
decidesheart electronicelectronic
electrical
it quantity shows
to may Rectifierelement elementsresponse given control the
circuit. of Input
as a be without such
the the as the but under
an
measuring Flg. to converntional
binationbmocan can of componentsdetectors,
components circuitry.
as
Thussigralstatic input 6.2.1 block s
of ittripping aquantities.
input be atripping acircuit considerationany comparators,
Static static
measuring relay.
to element. the Block diagram
element.
element output ComparatorMeasuring
element moving The
be of relay. does circuit The electromagnetic relays
It Relay circuit are
applied
compares various
diagram suchrelays
of 6-2
element not parts exceeds
static used level
Some to of a as
get C.T. static may which which
to of element
Feed have such relay indiodes,
signals. the
isthe the mixing the Transistor
or amplifier as be may
static a anamplifier
element relay a
a
output input Output electronic o
P.T. AU moving particular as static is
ecidingoutput be
armature. transistors not
circuits Thus indicating : designed Static
signal or relay electronic
of supply Dec.-08, relays zero use use
element an an it powerD.C. parts Relays
signal such in may or level, crossing moVng movng
input electronic
circuitsu This in fo r
electromagnetic.
its 10, etc and
be Tripping 13,17, and or
as a circuit basic response measurement
thesuch Numernical
nerator. which the electromagneti: are
opaT
Convenient made partsparts
element May-13,22 static detectors a called
output elements.
way Protec
is
circut
such
an
for stak.
ultimate.) with
ad er of up then
 are
6.2.3.Fig. Jne The Droduce
Such time higherrepresented energi
higher
much
zed classified
device
then nput 3. 2. I. The nargi nal As urtahMulti-input
er as, device.
The 3. 2 1.
onlyhas It inputThus Ihis b. Noncritical
the Two Single
(ks1). R device
intertripping
critical Critical Toetc. To Tomaindevices less than input
very completely name
single Measuring Pateton 8nd.
mustwhen produce
act produce than
Rcondition
as
input input Switchgear
input as th e
R functions have fast input element
can be in level
Measuring is 20 is
shown
one intermediate marginal suggests,Repeat device
be less a final multiple ms. eitherresponse. device
decided sort signals unenergized devices, can
connectedoutput than R tripping of The in
ALNs is on-offof the Function
these be
Fig.instantaneous Function such operating zero required,
kP critica! to output
switching It than classified
and greater 6.2.3 by switching Fi g . depending
to devices
signal or can devices
the perform
switching than
antaneous controller. : contacts. level. too6.2.2. be to the or (All
Instantaneous protection
stages to in power or as,
some Input 6-3
the the Such R Nothing on
gain lt
supplementary
critical in circuit
protection gain Fig. the
- activates
scheme. when a devices
noncritical
an need critlcal associated 6.2.2 Relay)protection
thrust
complex breaker.
value Instantaneous Instantaneous
not noncritical Such are, are
Noncritical noncritical Static
to
function :
for be P, protectionfunctions instantaneous
with and Relays
ledge obtain
high. it athe
operates. deviceinput them and
repeat control
multiple The scheme. such Numerical
is
reaches
signal is
output While shown as generally withfunction schemes
outputs. (contracts) Protection
alarming, response outputsMany
of for
in
such reset, the 10. are
to
haracteristics. Practically orshown removalinputbetweern mayelement. Switchgear
Protection
and
devices
while are time
The
inverse As The The This d. too The This accuracy.
C. 3. High 1.Ine
is Input be Definite Fast
multiple twOinversely n function common function high input in and various
is the of
provided its It is and
definite Dependent charging input
activation
input negative, inputnothing
produces
t than is Fig. or
reliable
Input
R requirements
input and =
form noncritical
depends Fixed
proportional the
6.2.4. andbetween and
devicesminimum its f(R") time
CAL
S as of resetting of butoperation.
function
time characteristics Time marginal the a Time
the Fig. dependent input on of
Input type output
are input 6.2.5 and where
the a output.
the define Function of
are time to dependent Function: capacitor function
delay
very i.e. applicationof critical
extension some Input input requirement.
increases
lag Negative = n R= either output. or The time
common are between
overcurrentpower dependent characteristics
Input is : 4.function 2.
shown time controlled zero delay delay High Long 6-4
It
of the is of
two such of function
n controllable termdevices
Operating the in
input and time the
asinput. and to Fig. InputR consistency.
comparators, earth function Fig, characteristics obtain are,
decides 6.2.4
devices Static
time 6.2.5. reset
fault The fixedDefinite Relays
examples delay timeFixed
to decreases. the T ratio.
relays. time
and
extendlevel is, time time
R
delay. Numerical
ofSo according!y function
the
detectors such Signal
Output
range Protecin

ot e relavs
operatin;
 6.3 Questions
Review provides theoutput Element 2.4 Output
No. The 6.Feed
3 2
signalelsemerntnot Element
10. 9 6. 4 St. The 2.
7
62.3 tion and
5 1. tripping The SwiProtcschgear
Write Draw
Table
Comparison element
measuring
4top lying
transients.
Wiring robust.
Less
and components.
electronic temperature.on
The PowerResponseMoving the
Susceptible Additional LowTesting
a and
delay signaltos
6.3.1 note
d.c.
circuit them
onlythe the
shortcharacteristics explain obtained
errors and consumption voltage uses hem.tripping
parts on element
tamplifies
time is gives
to d.c. servicing very relays
Static static require
transistor
are the are of the
IONS
AL the required from
less. Supploverload
y quick.absent. block
voltage of Static relays. uses circuit.
is comparison d.c.
is small. the
is components
easy. diagram as signalsbut
capacity. electronic
supply
fluctuations required and by an Thus
measuring
of the
amplifier.
for depend of
Electromagnetic static
various for output
circuits 6-5
static AU multiplies element
relay.
:
the
anfluctuations
transients.
and Not More relays. Moving
The PowerResponse and Dec.-08,10,13,17, All element
Possibility temperature.
dependernton
Testing
AdditionalHigher elements.
proper
p-thrust consisting
these
susceptible robust characteristics
electromagnetic are
short
time and consumption Electromagnetic
parts relays is Static
for of d.c.
is components,
functioning. required
in servicing sBower or an
wledge wiring are Relays transistors, Relays
nature.
to supply amplifier.
combines
the capacity.
overload of present. May-13,15,22,
compared
is AU AU to
errors. components
is and
voltage is more. relays. :
notcomnplicated. May-18, : Dec.-14, The
circuits be Numerical
diodes them
amplified
required. to feed Sometimes
are static Marks5 Marks
Dec.-18 alongwith with
not elernent etc. Protection
6 The other thisbefore
 Question
Review Sathgea
Protection
and
9. 6
6.4
13. 12. 11. 10.
8 7.
5. 4 3 2 1. The 13 12
1.
aircraftsetc.Srmaller Therequirements. tripping The
No and The operating possible.
idealelectronic
rangecircuits
of As The The ofThefriction AsThe The used.can beThe various
Advantages ComepTe
gravity testing compact low
mechanical moving
sensitivity moving Resetting
huntionsSngiereduei
use resetting responsepower burden
and or circuit stta
energy of
advantages nelav
contact and time
effect
compact and in printed parts
consumption on parts relays
LICA
IONs
CAL inertia time is and carn
servicingmeasuring
size.levels is very curent and can and
on
high troubles
can are not are of uth perfomn
be
in characteristics circuits
wiring overshts
operation required
circuits can be as and beabsent,quick. transformers absent. in Limitations
static electromagnetic pngraable
size. is signal
thermal
reduced exist. is the vartous
simplified. eliminates
errors very
the control The relays arr
make in to
usedamplification low Table
6.3.1
of storage. andminimum
static
theobtained,can be moving are,
as getscircuit. ofreays. 6-6
- the overshoots
an perform most Static
hrust relays. considerably functions.
single
relay
maintenance parts Programming due
Resetting
can of mechanical
inertiato
for number the RelaysAU
Hence
be can are AU
time
edge achieved circuits : Static
be Dec.-06, perfom
several
cannot
almost
approach
which reduced present May-18, : and
facility the of Relays
can of and reduced is
required. are overshoots
be 17, is and
the functions, mass very electronic. thus only May-12, Dec.-18, not
due Numercal
easily. availabie
mot are
used relavs No smaller in
parts
in the
productr to the Marks
a bear 13. Pree
sh sae a
 operation. are twooutput The Question
Review Dy Switchgear
relays Comparators6.5 3. 2. 1. The 14. Protectioand
6.The5.1 Many 1. careful Now 6. 3. 4. The notsingle A
cOmpared.Thus quantities,
Comparator
the based These temperature
Components
LessAdditionalrelays.
Susceptable Theageing. limitations
single
Fig. Mention a possible
relays design days robust characteristics
phase relaysreliability phasing
on the relay
advantages
effect
of
compared tod.c. of in
shows ise
anglenteesring the operat the he have and dependent. static
electromagnetic
that tsupply is protection can
the of their
the circuits.
voltage low of
betwcompar
een aindson partbased temperature unpredictable relays perform
phase and to is electrical electronic
short Hlence
classification leaving of on
limitations electromagnetic required are, by
and the fluctuations time
relofay, the
the incorporating
relays. several
on connections. relay
ascomponents
for overload 6-7
de ng atworesulwhichtawnt
Comparators amplofitusendi of the functions
static avarious
nd it
characteristics
depends
protecteidnputs. semiconductorrelays.
comparators end receives of relays.
AU transients. such respective
comparatquant
ors ities zone In the : transistor capacity like
Dec.-06, on Static
some two
comparison as
used are vary overcurrent,
devices compared atransistors, functional Relays
inputs 17, circuits. large
are and relays
in compared. with and
ybrid the receiving
quantitiesend May-12,13,22,
necessary the and of can be tonumber Numerical
relays. the temperature diodes blocks.under
amplitudes
While ittwo electromagnetic
for produces compensated of etc. voltage,
This Protection
Marks
the inquantities. small and are is
6
relay some theofthe
 equivalent the
hecircuit. pass TeceSsary level
Componernts. umbers
itgital
facility The Thus 1he The A
filters. Voltage Current relay
6.19 QuestRevi1 eiownSwiProtce hgear
tion and
from
P.T. C.T. from Fig.relay, Discuss
With the ng
USivoltage andC.P.T.. Analog
signals
sgignal
from removeto from
signals representng
ommodateto removes
This 6.19.1 using Block
digital Signals This C.I. microprocessor
systemPower the
and antialiasing
filters digital
Diagramsynthesis
is and conditioning shows
form help Includesconditioning
circuit circuit
Signal Signal
from called current
of of high P.T. Fig. nstantaneous
the device of
analanalog C.T.
aog unwanted aliasing 6.19.1 blockbased ofsimple
large frequency These
signals
and like
Numerical
Block circuit holdSample
and
impedance
condiinputtioning diagram relay
numbermultiplexerfrequency P.T. which signals in microprocessor
values
are the
diagram
signal component or 6-35
distorts of relay.
s can
of circuits given power computer
a of Relay
signals.
input is and /multiplexerAnalog
an component s. not of converter
digital numerical the
to the Analog to
st achieved.analog are the which system numerical
be loggerData o for
signals
sampled required
antialiasing
based decision
Static
for to convert
may ed are relay.
The
digital relay request Data
Microprocessor
ADC relay. is Relays
ge
analog using signal.appear brought Converter called
making AU
to analog
Digital to
filters and
converter breakeCircuit May-17,18, :
sample digital
as down numericalbased Numerical
multiplexer low DAC
which Tripping
signal
Line
form. to on
(ADC), and frequency Display Dec,-22 Protection
are suitable digital
relay.
gives the hold low It
is
 reliability.its and display
requestconverteralgorithmstored Protection
and
6.19.2 6.19.1 theinSwitchgear
2) 1) 13) 12) 11) 10) 9) The The
8) 7) 6) 5) 4) 3) 2) 1)
produces The digitalThe
environment.
interferences
Proper and The Useful Very One It
ItTripping Numerical
time ItNumerical
(like bettercomponent
Relay software
It The It
can has has uses numerical iffrom data trip
Limitations uses Advantages
numerical required, (DAC). and
microprocessor economical unit provide least high fibrematching
care for characteristics electronic logger signal
can or an the
centrally relayoptical fewer accordingly output
of resetting pick relay failures. with alarmrelay This memory.
earthing perform data of microprocessor. bycaptures is
NICAL
IONS of up
imposes of relayy
for 1/2
communication). can components slight circuits of signal taking is trippingdigital of
Numerical
unitcO-ordinated large history time. cycle ratio protection FHence
relaying be are canNumericalprogrammable trip The ADC
mustbe modification information the signal
needs power and less easily stored be for if signal is
for or it there dataanalog decision
greater
less burdencharacteristics. is functioning
made where
given i
to future
of interfaced resulting The
taken, Relav back
systems.several inmore is and signalhence is
be can Relay is to
sensitivity. memory multifunctional in mismatch information
and from feeds processed
shielded
Properlyas up reference. be
on reliable. made. 6-
36
hardware. converted is
microprocessor
an protection. systems. achieved CTs in and periodically
with the itgiven
hrust and of less hence in
microprocessor. to
digital
microprocessor. the can the to with
PTs. inter to
for with with is the
normalmicroprocessor
it the Static
edge compact be analog or
the communication performs trip
connections numerical
relayzhelp
gets suitable displayed Relays
use routine.
microcontroller
coilusing
affected
extermalby of in of
Hence of and
modifications size. self a
numerical digital
with when relay. Nunerical
and This
diagnostic
equipe it
provie reduce improye athere to
relay Prtesr
pr a
 etc.
the
ftnplemented., Temoving The Questions
Review
lt The processed
Thealgorithm.
filteringThe 5 This The The 6.20 3) ) 3) SwiPtacochgear
tion 8nd
signal 3. 2 1.
relay. The It If
erical digital current Fig. limitations.Discuss State Draw has it
. Numerical relay is
hultiplexer Signal high Current 6.20.1 the and risk
multifunctional,
signal about
ucroprocespithecnumerical
skor volbytage condiistioningsignal advantages explain can of
The f requency shows the hacking.
and systemPower be
g. circuit Signal Overcurrent block the faster
the and
rid.thc.m up signalconverADC ted from Ficonditioning block
circuit the 6.20.1 block diagram
limitations then
ofoffset valuestores is in .
component tos but
diagram
of of failure
Sample diagram
alnt culaistes ofthe tcascade. henequivalent convertspower
Numerical círcuit hold and no
Protection numerical of of
This a a use of 37
6-
iltered the currentset,tings applied
is system numerical
numnerical
isthis of one
if
pared using r.m.s time such todigital is
overcurrentmultiple Analog
xer numerical relay circuit element
the possiblesignal breakerCircuit with relay. relay.
Fourier value setting as
form brought breaker
with of byto signal Trip neat affects Static
the mi ctr
yo
peproces or ection overcurrent
transforthme n. multiplier, the
usiprngoporusitnigonal protto ADC sketch operation Relays
Line AU AU all
fundamental
stored of AU: the
ant
samplialeiasing desired DAC :with ; and
the
Then characteristics or Microprocessor protection Dec.-22, its May-17,
is
May-18, systerms. Numerical
Microcontroller
pick ay and voltage level Dec.-16AU
:
advantages not
the delmicrocontroller.
circuit,
hold filter. Marks Marks
up
component
r.m.s. if Marks as Protection
signal using scheme. fast
value required to 13and
8
16
value as
of of be It byC.T.
 knowledge up-thrust
for an
PUBLICATIONs TECHNICAL
mho Synthesis
of 6.16.1 Fig.
relay angle
,. by
Zt3 =ARZp, AQ= Z1. =AP
=Z. phasor
AP the leads which -Z1) (ZR
represents which PB
phasor the Join
R + output.
trip bemust relay output
of the circle,
Q the within lies it As point
P. indicated by
P' Z berelay the byimpedance
seen
90°
Trip/ the Let A. point located
at relay
is The
Trip B 6.16.1, Fig. the shown
in is circle.
This this
within falls relay the by
impedance
seen
X+ the when operates relay.
It the setting
of
Trip
<0° <0 90° the isThis ZR.diameter having circle a
characteristics
with ahas relay mho The
Dec.-16,
Comparator:AU Static using Relay Mho Synthesis
of 6.16
Marks
13 May-19, AU: scheme. relay distance static basic the
Explain 1.
Question Review
lines.
connected interconnected
T
and andfeeders parallel transmission
lines,
andmedium protection
of popularly
for used are relays distance static The
6.15.2 Fig.
Mho (d) Reactance (c) Impedance (b) Directional (a)
Operating
Operating +R R
Operating ZR
X
6.15.2. Fig the in
are 6.15.1 schemes various
characteristics
of The
Table above from obtained as
6.15.1 Table
Mho
VL
arce
9sin V-ZR I 3
VumeProis rical Switchgear Protection
end
6-30
 PUBLICATIOWS
knowledge up-thirust
tor an
Synthesis
of
6.16.2 Fig.
relay mho
using
comparator phase cosine
relay PZgl-V
mho
R+ Trip like Acts
Restrain
Comparator
phase
<+ 90°< type Cosine P
Trip 90°’ Trip
Trip
Restrain
using relay mho synthesis of The 1il-V;)
comparator phase cosine
in is
6.16.2. Fig. the shown as ration
Vf. denoted
to two the Hence (ZR-Z) and 2:1,
comparator phase the inputs ZRlf = I;
and V;are product
Z the But-Z{lf. the by impedance
seen kner e
the is I; general upto relay
at
relay voltage Zf. is point P angle 8
is angle The
Multiply phasors between
OA
I,, byboth ini.e. APand multiplying
the byUSsible
-Z, RZ Z;
and general phasors
by
location relay current at converted bemust ances
If. to
them before voltages comparator
comparator. to giving accepts cosine static But
isThis signals voltage only
inputs. as
its comparator. phase OSTe
the Hence
and -
90° between isputs
hence 90° +
becan relay of
mho synthesis Comparator static cosine Ihe
using obtained which one the is
the
two between phase when operates
is
the Restrain 9>-90°’
law trip MEnce,
-’ 0° < < 90° -
Threshold -90°
’ =Trip,0
likeRpoints the all for shile
90. than- lessalways is ZR, AR'> where is ZR. :P<
Q the At90°. than
- greater always
boundary,
90 - =8 the on point shown
in Ras
negative. is then 0 6.16.1 Fig. th e
where P'like points For if
the Similarly
side other onlies
the impedance fault
positions ati.e. ZR AB = of
law trip is
the Restrain 90°’ 0> Hence,
Threshold ’90° =Trip,0 ’ 90° <<8 (°
nicated
trip. not wil relay and Bas
impedance ut
than greater
90 is=Za>Zp
then as
AR such circle thoutside
e lies
While 90".
exactly isangle Q,
point boundary
at the On towards
90°. increases 8
angle he
the towards
Q, fromn
P moves location fault the As90°. than less is B,
Protection Wumerical and Relays Static Switchgear
6-31
 Trip
=2OPA
9< -Z1 |XR
that, written becan Thusit
greater whiisch angle condition. restrain
edhis y 9O". characteristic
thanas
line theabove liby Zg
es OP impedance
leads as
such CP
phasor the thenthe When point
C
condition. threshold isThis 9.exactly iswhereboundary
B
on iNpoint
and Zp relay
is the impedance
byseen
nangle the the B,
point At90.towards
B, to from
A moves relay the byseen
impedance the As
phasorO 90. than Jess which
is angle
the leads phasor This |XR-Z represents which phasor
AP the Join
ion, trip the within point shown.
A lies
at Z1 as trips relay the impedance
Zp, For
=|Xl OPrelay
is the settingof The
relay
reactance synthesis
of forinputs Obtaining 6.17.1 Fig.
R
ZOC
Zy OB
Z1 OA 9=90
9<90
Restrain
9>90
6.17.1. Fig. the shown
in as X of
linestraight the
impedance
lies this if
trips relay The Z. be
relay impedance
the byseen The
ujXrelay
is the setting
of The X-axis. Xon distance
of diagram
aat
I K-azit
n the parallel
to linestraight characteristics
a as hasa relay
reactance The
AU
parators Statlc using Reactance
Relay Synthesis
of 6.17
MarAke May2, Dee-16, AU
phase statie using relay mho synthesis
a of thdetail
e Describe
in 1
comparator.
Question Review
Switchgear Protection
and
632
 up-thrust an -
knowledge for
6.17.2. Fig.
reactance
relay
synthesis
of The
using
comparator phase consine Xglf Q= and -Vt XRIf = P
the shown
in is
comparater to
the inputs two the Thus
are, voltage
Vi:denoted location relay at Multiplyingthe isZil,
as the I;, by both
X angle
is
product -Z{)If. (XR and I;between
between is angle The
the But phasors
OP
XR-Zi: ini.e. APand multiplying Pasble
by
XR general
and between phasors
by the
location
If. relay currentat pedances
converted
to bemust
comparator. them giving before voltages
to acceptscomparator cosine static But
isThis only
the Hence inputs. as voltage
its signals relay.reactance synthesizing
the
are and
XRR-ZA) two the (XInus
comparator type cosine to
ainputs
for
|XR
Tr>-90-
ip -Z| |XR 2 If Hence,
law Trip
XR
Restrain -90° OPC< 2 =
-Z3| |XR
|XR
Threshold E
90° OPB= 2 -Z2| XR
=
XR
Trip 90° >- OPA 2 -Z1 Xg|
=
that, written be can then
it nhasor
j)XR ofleft the toie. OPofside other the impedance
onlies fault the Similarly
if
XR
law Trip Trip ’ 90 <
XR-Zi Hence,
XR
Restrain 90° 20PC > =
Threshold
90° 2OPB= =
andRelays Static 6-33
Protection Numerical Switchgear 8nd
 amplitude The
magnitude
ZR circle
of characteristics ZRthan less actual|isZ{ trips
if relay
d amnplitude a is impedance
or. using obtained relay
ay
relisimpedance simple the
because isThis
synthesis
of The
RelImpedance
ay Synthesis
of
AU: 6.18
,Marks
16 May-17,22,
comparator. phase static using relayreactance synthesiofs the detail, Descriinbe
1.
reactance
relay Synthesis Question Review
of 6.17.2 Fig.
R+
relay
7 reactance V
X¡ly P=
Trip like Acts
X+
90° <+ <
90° comparater
Trip phase
type Cosine
Trip Restrain
ton Numerical andRelays Static 6-34 Switchgear Protection
and